Day 11 Robert Kennedy will one day write that on the eleventh day of the Cuban Missile Crisis he felt that “this cup was not going to pass and that a direct military confrontation between the two great military powers was inevitable. Both ‘hawks’ and ‘doves’ sensed that our combination of limited force and diplomatic efforts had been unsuccessful. If the Russians continued to be adamant and continued to build up their missile strength, military force would be the only alternative.
” This is TimeGhost and the Cuban Missile Crisis, I’m Indy Neidell. Yesterday, US Ambassador to the UN Adlai Stevenson faced off with his USSR counterpart Valerian Zorin, and made Zorin look foolish while proving to the world that the Soviets had in fact placed nuclear arms on Cuba. Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev decided to offer the US a trade - guaranteed sovereignty over Cuba for removing his missiles.
The so-called quarantine - a US naval blockade of Cuba - was in effect, but there were no suspicious ships to stop, as they had all turned back to Russia. This robbed the US of the chance to show the world how the blockade would be enforced. Finally, the navy decided to board a seemingly random non-Russian ship to perform a demonstration.
On this morning of October 26th, 1962, this ship, the Lebanese freighter Marcula, manned by a Greek crew, which took on cargo in Riga on its way to Havana, is moored to a US Navy destroyer in the waters East of Cuba. American President John F Kennedy is following the board and search operations via radio link from the White House. As expected, the ship has no contraband on board and is allowed to proceed.
At the same time, Kennedy has just received the morning newspapers, and they’re full of rumors of an imminent American invasion of Cuba. Considering that the US Army, Navy, and Air Force have now amassed the greatest amount of men and equipment seen since the Korean War both on and off the US East Coast, this is a fairly reasonable assumption. The letter from Khrushchev- a long one- offering the trade off has not yet arrived.
Khrushchev has other problems on this crisp Moscow morning. His ally in Cuba, Fidel Castro, is getting very nervous. Yesterday evening, he held a passionate public speech in Havana promising to shoot down any Yankee spy planes that fly over the island.
That’s already not great for Khrushchev, but it gets even worse when he receives Castro’s’ “Armageddon Letter. ” It says: “If […] the imperialists invade Cuba with the aim of occupying it, the dangers of their aggressive policy are so great that after such an invasion the Soviet Union must never allow circumstances in which the imperialists could carry out a nuclear first strike against it. I tell you this because I believe that the imperialists' aggressiveness makes them extremely dangerous, […] However harsh and terrible the solution, there would be no other.
” In other words, in case of an invasion of Cuba, Castro wants the USSR to strike the US with nuclear force before the US themselves resort to nuclear arms. Khrushchev could just simply not grant Castro’s’ wish… if it wasn’t for those tactical FROG missiles on Cuba, which if he wants to, Castro can seize and use himself. Not only could he fire at invading troops- from a boat, he could get someone close enough to Florida to fire a couple at the US mainland.
Needless to say, that would force both Khrushchev’s and Kennedy’s hands and launch a nuclear war. While Khrushchev deals with Castro, a US invasion of Cuba is not fake news… President Kennedy is once again considering it. Remember… he still hasn’t received Khrushchev’s proposal.
The topic of the day is what to do next since the blockade itself won’t eliminate the nukes. Now, at the beginning of this EXCOMM meeting there are two remarkable things that are covered. This happens before the President starts recording and in portions of the recording that have been excised and are still classified, but it’s easy to piece together what’s going on by looking at the references to these parts during the rest of the discussion and through other declassified documents.
First of all, it’s now known and confirmed that the US knows about the tactical FROG missiles. They were photographed and identified on October 25th in one of the low altitude flybys. This doesn’t stop discussion of an invasion; instead, US forces with tactical nukes of their own are being made ready to take part in such an invasion.
Second, Director McCone of the CIA, now distances himself from a CIA operation to send small groups of Cuban exiles as sabotage crews to Cuba to take out the missiles and assassinate Castro. Remember on Day One when I mentioned that Attorney General Robert Kennedy had been made the unofficial chairman of Operation Mongoose - the secret sabotage operation to disrupt Cuba and possibly eliminate Castro? Well, it turns out at that ever since that first day of the crisis, McCone and Bobby Kennedy have been adapting these plans as an alternative to invasion to end the crisis.
Now McCone doesn’t want to proceed for fear of failing and getting the blame for another CIA led debacle like The Bay off Pigs Invasion, so on the advice of National Security Advisor McGeorge Bundy, it becomes part of the post-invasion plan instead. Mr President, my suggestion is that we should reconstitute Mongoose as a subcommittee of this committee in the appropriate way, and I think we can work that out this afternoon. I think that’s good because this matter you called me about last night, you see, which is as to what kind of a government [there should be in Cuba].
And have this all part of Mongoose. Yes. I called Mr McCone last night and I then told Mr [Edwin] Martin that I thought we ought to be making a crash program on .
. . The problem becomes, then, what if [there is an] invasion?
What kind of people—how many Cubans we’ll have, what would be the civil government arrangement and all that? These are very important matters. Well, now, who will take on that?
McCone informs them that the meeting to set that up is already under way. So… this is how serious they are about an invasion; they’re already planning how to take political and administrative control of Cuba afterwards. Another piece of important intelligence they receive is that the work to make the Soviet missiles launch ready is continuing.
Many years later it will come to light that at already at this point a mobile unit of two SS4 missiles is deployable and set up only a few kilometers away from Guantanamo, the US military base on Cuba. The EXCOMM members have concluded that even if the blockade is stopping new arms from coming in, it’s not doing anything to get rid of the ones already there. With more and more missiles being readied, there’s now a sense of urgency.
In the next meeting, they look at their options to solve that problem. After the UN Session and meetings with UN General Secretary U Thant yesterday in New York, Adlai Stevenson and Presidential Advisor John J McCloy have now travelled to Washington and are also part of that EXCOMM meeting. Both of them are in favor of negotiating with the Soviets through U Thant, possibly even lifting the blockade before those negotiations start.
McCone is not impressed. But I want to conclude by making it very clear that the intention here was a standstill, not positive acts. And the standstill was to include the discontinuance of construction, discontinuance of shipping, discontinuance of the quarantine which we, we’d have to agree how to do that in 48 hours.
After that, we’d negotiate a final settlement which would relate to the withdrawal of the weapons, or the inoperability of weapons already operable. I would think inoperable becomes meaningless, because during the long-term negotiations we’re concerned with the withdrawal of the weapons from the hemisphere. I don’t believe, I don’t agree with that, Mr President.
I feel very strongly about it. And I think that the real crux of this matter is the fact that he’s got these pointed, for all you know, right now at our hearts. And this is going to produce I think, it may produce, a situation when we get to Berlin after the elections, which changes the entire balance of world power.
It puts us under a very great handicap in carrying out our obligations, not only to our western European allies, but to the hemisphere. And I think that we’ve got the momentum now. We’ve got the feeling that these things are serious and that they must be .
. . That threat must be removed before we can drop the quarantine.
If we drop that quarantine once, we’re never going to be able to put it in effect again. And I feel that we must say that the quarantine goes on until we are satisfied that these are inoperable. [He hits the table.
] Well, now the quarantine itself won’t remove the weapons. So we’ve only got two ways of removing the weapons. One is to negotiate them out—in other words, trade them out.
Or the other is to go in and take them out. I don’t see any other way you’re going to get the weapons out. While these deliberations go on, others are suffering the consequences of the decisions made by the leaders on both sides of the Iron Curtain.
The US Navy is now hard on the heels of the four Soviet submarines. They chase them from one location to the other, hitting them with signaling depth charges to try to get them to surface. The chase is so intense that the subs can’t even surface for fresh air, or to reload their batteries.
The conditions on board are becoming absolutely horrifying. One of the seamen writes in his diary, dedicated to his wife. “We are in the enemy's lair, and we can't reveal our presence to them, but they sense our nearness and are searching for us.
[…] here, inside the sub, the situation is very serious. The men are feeling notably worse, a lot of them are ill, people are fainting, many have swollen feet, no one can sleep in this monstrous heat and stuffy air, even though everyone is very tired and weak. […] The worst thing is that the commander's nerves are shot to hell, he's yelling at everyone and torturing himself.
[…] He is already becoming paranoid, scared of his own shadow. […] For four days we haven't been able to get a breath of fresh air, to emerge at least to periscope depth. […] It’s getting hard to breathe in here, too much C02, […].
” Today, two of the submarines run out of electricity and have to surface. They’re allowed to recharge and are escorted back towards the USSR. The other two, the B36 and the B59 are still submerged and still evading the US Navy.
By now, they have lost all contact with the outer world, most significantly with central command in Moscow. In such a scenario they have orders to determine themselves whether or not to deploy their tactical nukes. In Washington DC, EXCOMM meets again.
I mean, there’s no action that, other than diplomatic, that we can take, which does not immediately get rid of these. There are only two ways to do this, as I said this morning. One is the diplomatic way.
Which I doubt, I don’t think it will be successful. The other way is, I would think, a combination of an air strike and probably invasion, which means that we would have to carry out both of those with the prospect that they [the missiles] might be fired. Now, let’s be very clear about one thing here: these are plans and not actions - we shouldn’t misread this as saying that either of the two leaders want a war.
As we have seen before, both are terrified of the idea. It’s just that one action after the other on both sides have now led them down that path, one little step at a time. It’s safe to assume that the President will gave a small sigh of relief when he finally receives Khrushchev’s offer this evening.
That is, once he’s spent time reading and deciphering it, because it’s long, rambling, and at times not very clear. What is crystal clear is that by now both of them have long lost their grip on the leash that was supposed to hold back the dogs of war. Tomorrow they’ll bark and bite as one insane event after the other escalates the crisis to the very brink of nuclear war.
See you then on day 12. If you want to hear more from the diary of the submariner, Spartacus has recorded it for you and it’s right here. Don’t forget to subscribe, and please support our efforts financially at patreon.
com or tg. tv so that we can make more awesome history like this. Good night and good luck.