so hello to everyone it's very nice to be here uh I hope you still have some energy since we're on Friday late in the in the day uh I hope this will be interesting for you guys I think uh it will uh I mean I will try to make it interesting and I think it's um especially um important to think about media now uh it's always been a subject but it's getting more and more important and that's why my presentation was um redone until this very morning because the last days with the the election of
trump uh has made um some new um some new subjects uh worrying and um I think it gives a better understanding of why media parts model matters and why independent press is uh important so my name is Cecil as you know uh I'm the executive director of media part I've been in media part for seven years now so I'm not one of the founders I will tell you about the story of Med about but I wasn't there all the time um and um I I am not a journalist I have to say uh the president
and the director of publication is a journalist we have we are the two um leaders of the newspaper uh but I'm more on the business part uh making uh the newspaper um be able to do its job U making sure we have enough you know money and people to do good journalism and to be heard and well known uh by the audience uh first of all I would like to ask you how many of you guys actually do uh follow every day um political environmental social information do you guys all inform okay good and how
many of you have purchased a subscription to uh a daily newspaper in your country or here in France yeah that's not bad okay good how many of you are um have a subscription to Media Parts okay you're my favorite I'm just kidding okay so um okay I know so first of all a few words about what is media Parts uh you see a picture of of The Newsroom that's the daily uh conference where every today journalist but also non-journalists discuss about the subjects that we're going to write about that's one of the specificities in mediaart
it's not only journalists being able to attend these meetings usually in big media it's only the the Chiefs that are allowed to discuss these topics but in media part uh we think we have a very uh strong Democratic uh vision for journalism and for um Enterprise and business as well so everybody is welcome to to part participate in this daily conference um it probably was a Friday because usually there are more people um so it's uh what should I okay all right uh so media part was founded in 2008 by John lists the most famous
one you maybe you've heard of it is Ed pel he was the former director of Lund which is the main uh daily French newspaper in France yeah and um it's uh an investigative online newspaper which means when it was created the founders decided that they would not not uh go to print uh newspaper it was uh the beginning of the internet I mean not the beginnings but it was not uh usual to put news uh on the internet all the news were free on the internet but the founders thought they there was a value to
information to real um verified [Music] um um how do you say it um I can't find my word uh yeah to Value to information and that people would actually pay for news because media part is behind a hard pay wall uh today it's grown uh big and I will tell you more about the story uh we publish about 10 to 15 stories each day so investigative stories but also analysis and Reporting uh everywhere in France and in the world and we are on the reader Revenue model with a heart pay wall uh today we have
200 and 35,000 subscribers uh which uh puts us in the third position in France behind Le andigo regarding uh Online subscription okay doesn't work uh We've um made about 600 6,500 investigations uh since the beginning we have about 3.5 million visitors per months and we are now about 150 employees half of them are journalists and half of them are non-journalists they are the marketing team product teams um client service teams etc etc and it's a a balance that has been a key for the success of media Parts because at first um the founders thought that
if you had good journalism it was enough but good journalism is not enough if you're not able to put it on um userfriendly um uh application and sites if you're not able to promote your contents all over uh the internet if you're not able to commun unicate etc etc so now we've had this balance for many many years half of the staff is journalist and half of the stuff is non-journalist but we all work together uh we are in the same um uh the same Bureau I can't find my word either off offices yes uh
there it's uh open spaces and we all together because we want everybody to be able to talk to anybody in uh the team and that makes something I think particular to Media part um as an organization so I'm going to tell you about the story of media part and what I like to call the three three steps of Independence and sustainability uh because uh if you read the media most of them will tell you that they're independent but in media part we have a very radical point of view about independence and that's what I'm going
to to tell you about and then in a second time I will tell you why it's getting more and more important to have this kinds of media in France but everywhere to um organize the resistance and to fight against all what's coming uh nowadays and um I think it will be a I hope you will understand why the choices that were made a long time ago 17 years ago are now uh showing how important the were and how foreseeing also they were so the first um Step of Independence was taken at the creation of the
newspaper the founders uh they said okay we are sure as former journalists from L and Liberation that there are some people who are willing to pay to get to information valuable information information has value it shouldn't be for free everywhere and the internet and we will find those people to pay so they decided to go only online with a hot pay wall and uh they strictly decided and we haven't um changed that a bit ever since there would be no advertisement because as you can easily understand when you depend on Advertising you might get some
pressure from the um the businesses that buy public publicity from you uh all of like many many um other newspapers uh are um under the pressure of finding advertisers um of making them happy and so it's um uh it's impacts the content because uh you want to you want to write something that's going to have a big audience so that the the advertisers take publicity in your media we also decided to have no public subsidies uh in France there are some um Ed LA Press so it's the state giving subsidies to the media uh particularly
the the print media but also now the online media to help them uh with their business model and uh we are against like radically against those subsidies because it creates a link between you and the government and U it can be a heavy pressure for you if you want for example one of the very famous stories uh in this the history of media part is called lafer kak it's a story about a former uh Financial Minister uh that was um in place and we found out and revealed that he had a some hidden accounts in
Switzerland which obviously is uh forbidden and uh he he lied for it about it for a few months and we had proof but we had to fight because it was in the beginnings of media parts and we were not that famous at that time so all the media were like no no no they don't have a proof they are saying nonsense etc etc and finally he confessed and he resigned of course from being uh the finance uh Minister and um you can understand how uh if salaries of our journalist depended on state subsidies we wouldn't
have been able to publish this story so our independence economic independence is really giving us total freedom about what we want to write about and there are no uh no one able to pressure us we don't have also remunerated shareholders I will come to uh the capital structure that we have now which is interesting too but from the very beginning uh the Jo was owned by mainly by journalists and a little bit by a few investors but that we knew very well and there that never um gots money out of their investment so they just
followed uh the the project because they believed we needed some independent uh media in France and also and this will I will tell you more about it later also we have no Financial agreement with platforms digital platform platforms uh many many uh newspapers and media in France have agreements with platforms whereas it's on um um Commercial Services on um uh artificial intelligence uh um agreements also and uh when uh Leon for example makes a deal with um Google uh it's worth a few million dollar and uh it creates dependency with those platforms and as you
might have come to understand now uh it's a very unstable uh ecosystem and we are not going uh on the right uh way on this uh matter so this is really the BET from the beginning everyone thought that we were crazy doing that like a lot of people thought media part would never Gather in enough uh subscribers to live and we've been um living and living well for 17 years now um 98% of our Revenue comes from Individual subscription just like your subscription and uh all of the individual subscriptions and the other 2% come from
revenue that depends on our content too uh like um when we have a contract with um libraries for example so it's all about um we only dependent on our readers and that's uh very important because it doesn't mean that our readers can tell us what to write about but it means that we have to report to them so we have a very strong culture of transparency we publish our numbers every year and we have a lot of many many times in the year when we explain our work etc and Etc but it gives us a
very strong um Power editorial power because we have no one who can tell us no you won't write about this or I will do this or that it's very rare rare So this model um uh this is the number of subscribers that we have and you see that it's been going up and up and up uh at the end of 2024 we are about 232,000 uh unique subscribers individual subscribers which is like the most important number we've ever had uh and you see that it's been growing and growing ever since the beginning at first it
was difficult I told you uh you're uh you're not a brand when you create your media no one knows you so you have to prove with your work your journalist work that you are worth paying that took two to three years and then after um La kak that I told you about it became more and more and more um convincing to the to the subscribers um you can see that in 2020 there was a a big rise in subscriptions it's the covid time uh all of the media especially digit media they got a lot of
subscri subscriptions because people needed information they didn't know what was going on they needed some information so we had a very big raise at this time and then for for two years we were kind of worried you see we were like about 200,000 subscribers for three years it wouldn't move so so much we're like oh maybe this is a a ceiling a glass ceiling and we've reached it and we can't go further but we didn't want to think that and uh we changed a bit of our strategies but with keeping our um fundamental values uh
alive like you know like looking for facts uh serious journalism um very um strong connection to the field etc etc and we've been growing again this uh past two years and we are aiming for even more because first of all As you understand we depend on the subscription to live and to do journalism we reinvest the money we have in journalism and second of all we actually do think we have some important things to say to people especially nowadays uh we think um free a free press is fundamental to a democratic system and we hope
that uh Democratic systems will remain in the few next years but we have no certainty about this and this is the sales revenue from 2008 till 2024 and we are reaching about 25 million euros of sales revenue this year so it's huge um I have to say it's um it's really comfortable but it doesn't mean that it will always be the same some papers have been very successful for years and then they just forget to think about what the public wants or they don't look for Innovation or they just you know do what they know
how to do and it's very easy for a newspaper to um to fail suddenly so we don't we're not like okay we're so so good we earn so much money and it's going to be like like this uh for many many years we are always thinking trying to be very humble and to be re realistic about the the ecosystem of news and what we can bring to people that they actually want to read and that will be um useful for them to read and to hear and uh watch because we also have some video and
some podcasts so it's very big numbers uh it's very comforting and uh but at any moment if we lose I don't know like uh 50,000 subscribers because we publish something that is entirely true and people start to think that we are making nonsense and not doing good journalism we could easily uh have some severe difficulties so we are we remain very Vigilant and we try to think about the next steps all the time this is the second step of Independence it's a bit more complicated I'm going to try to make it uh simple so the
founders of mediaart there were four of them uh from a very early time and like 2015 I think um started to think about how to transmit uh the newspaper to the team because they didn't want to give it to their children they didn't want to sell it to any investor that would change their project and they started um thinking about what Innovative uh and creative solution could work for media Parts uh some um some previous experience made them fear about um newspapers that are that are completely owned by the team because uh whenever you get
financial problems might be difficult uh might create some power um fights etc etc and they wanted to make sure that after the uh departure the newspaper will still uh keep uh going so it was not um an easy uh reflection and um finally uh they went to meet uh the guardian and uh the guardian is owned uh since 1936 I think by a a Scot the Scot trust which is a holding that um uh that owns the capital of the guardian and also has Financial reserves and so uh they tried to take this model into
the French legislation which is very different so it was kind of hard they had to discuss with the um the administration a lot and they decided to create a fund uh the F press which means a fund for a free press which is a nonprofit endowment fund uh so it's a found I will show you the details afterwards that has two um major goals one is to protect the independence and pluralism of Journalism and second one is to ensure mediaarts Independence and so that media part can remain free from corporate ownership or or control I'm
going to show you uh this not very easily to understand but maybe I'm can will help so this is Media Parts with its executive committee with a board and the when they went to see the the the administration the administration since uh the the endowment funds are not very uh common in France there were kind of reluctant because when you have a foundation you can get you can collect donation in France and it comes with tax deduction so it's a very specific way of financement and um so they said okay if you want to do
this and you want this structure to buy the capital of media part so that it remains uh protected in the future you have to create uh this uh holding that will be um in between and that and you have to put all the rules so that the money cannot Transit any anyhow uh so there are very strict rules every year um with the results of media Parts we've been uh beneficial for 14 years in a row so we do have Financial benefits every year so every year a part of this benefits goes into this holding
um so it's the dividends and this you like for the first four years uh the spim had contracted a loan to buy Med mediaarts Capital now it's over so now we're putting money here as um financial reserve for the future uh because we want to make sure that we have some money and we can depend only on ourselves uh when the time harder times come and they will be harder times that's for sure and so this we put dividend we put money here and uh a little bit of this money finances the functioning of the
F and press Li whose main role and it's becoming quite famous now in France um for the F past five years since its creation uh it's collected donation as high as β¬700,000 EUR that have all been distributed to little media projects all uh Independent Media that's a way of making sure I mean making sure trying to help the ecosystem of the Independent Media in France which is very Vivid but very very small initiatives everywhere and they uh they have difficulties finding some um uh Financial um stability because it's hard to convince people to get subscriptions
and so the FPL helps them and doesn't it's it's a strict non intervention they can't intervene in a media Parts um editor draw your line or even on the business line etc etc so it's really like everything is um thought in order to preserve media Parts because the capital of media part is now here no one can buy it no one like we can't fear that v b will buy this one because it's it's protected here and now we are also putting some money here because we know that the years ahead of us are going
to be super super strong and super hard and we want to make sure that when we Face difficulties because at some point maybe we won't be beneficial anymore and we will need some money to invest to pay the salaries to develop some new projects etc etc and we want to make sure that when that time comes we don't have to go see any investor we don't have to go to the bank and ask for a loan and we will have sufficient money here to keep uh doing uh good journalism so maybe it's a bit um
harsh to understand um but it's a unique model in France I mean unique no uh some other newspaper um copied the model but it doesn't function in the same way and as for us it's not really guaranteeing any Independence uh so we we're really proud of this and it's um the second Innovation that the founders of media Parts did so they had this only buyers like only readers can um Finance us and then this Independence Everlasting Independence we hope uh for the newspaper and the the third step um I know of Independence uh is as
I told you to put some money some Reserve uh to make sure that in the future uh we can uh rely on ourselves to keep uh the newspaper alive and so these are the four co-founders Ed plenel Laur FR Bon and Mariel and sman was the executive director before me and um I always when I talk about the story of media part I always want to tell this because I think it's super important for any business that you might want they create if you do so it's those people not only they created a very very
successful model but also they started very early thinking about how to transmit it to a new generation and we've been preparing for years this transition uh they left one after the other and today since last March uh it's a whole new um leading team that is uh re ruling the newspaper so that's me Karen Futo is the president and director of publication and Lin and Valentine are the two uh editorial uh directors so as you see it's an only woman uh leadership and we're really proud of it also and um if you've heard of any
other companies uh transmitted from the founders to new teams it usually fails because it's unprepared because it's uninc the way they try to give the the the keys to a new generation and in our case was really well preparated because they are the founders are really humble and generous people who are so they they just want um the goal of the of media part to be able to continue they really think that uh good journalism in investigation and democracy is more important than everything and they've done this and um they're still around us they're still
here if we need some advice Etc but they really transmitted uh the newspaper and we are really proud and thankful also of them uh for that um so the third uh step of Independence as I told you is to be um profitable and to have longlasting Financial Independence uh we don't have any bank loan we've been profitable for 13 years as I said uh we self Finance all of our investments and uh we are building Financial reserves for the future uh why is it so important it's not that we like to make a lot of
money uh we actually have a very strict um policies policy about salaries uh it's it's um a gap of one to three uh from the highest salary to the smallest salary so we have like rather um we have very good low salaries and very the highest salaries are pretty low for what you could find elsewhere so it's not because we want to earn more money or to be rich and ambm Etc it's because we know that if you want to invest in journalism you need money because it's expensive investigation is very expensive it takes time
it's not like you can write your investigation from behind your desk in two days you have to take some weeks you have to make some travels you have to sometimes it takes a year to write the story because the sources they're not going to talk so easily because you have to crush check everything we don't publish anything unless we are 100% sure that it's true we also work with our lawyers a lot to make sure that the way we write things is um is correct and we've had I think like 500 um Justice uh trials
uh since the creation and we've lost only five of them because we really want to make some serious work and we would never ever publish something unless we are completely sure it's true and I think that's why now people Trust in Media part so much because they know if they read something that it's true and that's something we will never uh change and that's a high quality journalism we believe in but it's um it's expensive and we also uh send journalist everywhere in the world to reports and we also do some video video is very
expensive we also we try so many things and we want to be able to finance them alone and not depend on what other uh media do like Google has been financing a lot of developments for example uh but when you're being financed by Google you have to adopt their tools for example and you become dependent and we don't want that so we also develop our own um technical tools most of the time unless we really don't have time but most of our tools the main strategic tools are self-developed by our inner teams so why is
Independence so important because you could be like okay yeah that's cool you can read something you wouldn't read elsewhere how is that so important in democracy and uh I think I have many many examples to show you uh to make you understand why we think that um it's always been important but it's getting more and more crucial these days first of all in France as you might or might not know we have a growing concentration of mainstream media in the hands of a few uh billionaires or millionaires but um it was the case in 2008
but it's getting worse and worse some very few um billionaires uh from the arm industry from all kind of industries by themselves media and uh media business is not uh the one who which is going to get you some uh some money it's usually uh non-beneficial it's usually um very highly expensive for the people invest in in it because every year you have to put more money more and more and more uh for example the journal Liber um it's it had uh it said two loans uh in the three past years from Daniel kensy uh4
million EUR each so 28 million EUR so how are you going reimburse all these millions when you can't make a benefit from your activity so journalism and the the media in general they don't make you earn money so why would those people buy themselves some media of course it's to buy influence and it's been getting more and more um worrying in France because uh lately um uh it's been uh growing so you can't read everything but it's um another medialon diplomatic who every year launches this um uh this uh plan and you can see that
only a few people most of them being in the highest Fortunes in France and in the world they own most of the private media so for so that's uh preoccupying because of course uh when you buy a media um when you invest money you are uh going to uh ask some things in return so of course don't uh ask any question about my business uh don't write about my friend because you know he's struggling a lot so you shouldn't write this paper um and it's the case also uh in other country you've all heard of
Jeff Bezos for example who owns the Washington Post and decided to not publish uh the the article um before the presidential election usually the Washington Post is supposed to be a democ rats newspaper uh takes side and so there was a paper that had been written by the editorial team endorsing Camala Harris and Jeff Bezos the owner asked for that paper not to be published so it's it's a really direct way of influence from the billionaires to the people in the media and there are many many examples of that in France I want to tell
you about van in particular because he used to earn uh Canal plus sen their um TV channels but he been buying for the last three years other media especially europan which is a very listen to radio the journal D Deon which is a very historical and famous newspaper in France and with a very clear and uh even uh and well a very clear strategy to uh change the editorial line and to um give some more media space to his ideology is uh close to the far right in France and uh ever since he own those
media he changed the teams there have been some strikes every time he's taken over a new media there've been some strikes from the journalists but they never got anything lot of them left but still those media keep going and uh for example on Europa during the legislative election that we had in June in France he decided to put uh one of the very very famous um Anchorman he has that's usually on TV for two hours a day on Europe one uh just to say all the bad things uh that they think about um the left
uh side of politics in France and so it's it's it's really obvious it's not even hiding itself uh e ebbi media to make sure these IDs are uh getting a larger audience so it's um very preoccupying in France and it's it's working so you can think about if you want to have parallels it's the same with Fox News in the United States it's been a long Trend which it's like some people seem to discover this but it's been a long Trend it's been true in the USA for the last 20 years it's been true in
France for the last 10 years and we have media that are more and more po polarized and uh that um you know make uh the far right IDs accessible to many many audiences I want to tell you also about Bernard know that you might have heard of is the president of elv Amash luxury group very famous luxury group and uh is the owner of Leo which is the main uh economic newspaper in France so you're one of the richest men in France and you own the main newspaper economic newspaper so of course you might conclude
that there might be bias in the way that Leo speaks about some uh some businesses he also owns the parisan which is a newspaper that's has a large audience in France too and uh he owns many others too exactly that's my next who do you see behind Donald Trump Baro is one of the most fortunate men uh on Earth and he was uh at the pledge of oath of Donald Trump this week so it gives you an Insight of what kind of the political board is on and uh that's a second um danger and risk
for the media now you have concentration of the media and it's true in France it's true elsewhere but now we also have farite regimes taking over many countries in Europe in the USA we might say and um and those regimes they are really clear about the media they don't want any free media they want media that um tell the stories they want to tell so either they own the media which is the case most of the time or uh they put pressure on the media and it's that's why I put also Victor Orban from Hungaria
and uh Georgia melany from Italy in those countries in Europe ever since those people are uh in power they've made some you know small changes and attempts uh georgo Maloney uh tries to intervene more and more in the public media in Italy uh Victor Orban like many many Hungarian uh journalists just flee the country and um it's um it's not a a hidden agenda like the farri regimes don't like freedom of the press they want other speeches other stories to be in the heads of the people and of course in France when I was going
to say if but let's see when the far right comes to govern they will have some major actions against the media they can stop and they say they will they will they will stop the public subsidies that I told you about many many newspaper including Independent Newspaper depend on those subsidies if they stop many media will die they also um they're also preparing a change of um T TVA uh how is it in English vat because in France the Press has a very small vat and they're preparing uh a higher V8 for the media and
if you put the v80 to 20% as it should could be like many many media in France won't resist it won't take a year they will vanish so we know that when the time comes it will be very hard to to fight and to stay alive and that's why we're so happy at media par that we made those choices so much time ago because now it's becoming critical and we might be some of the very few that could actually survive uh the far right U government and that we we will have no pressure we will
be able to write on everything so that's why it's so important and I think it was it's it's nice to highlight and to watch the the big picture those very old choices are now proving their um efficiency and necessity and then I have to tell you about also Tech Giants social media platforms uh artificial intelligence etc etc because that's another huge problem and it's getting bigger and bigger and it's linked to also the election of Donald Trump I'm I'm sure you've all heard of this so I'm not going to uh go into details but uh
it's been um for some time now um the social media platforms have been changing their policies um a few years ago the media would go on social media and they would be able to you know promote their content to have some interesting sometimes conversation with the audience etc etc then in 2022 Elan musk bat X I mean Twitter at that time that become X and uh changed uh the way it works changed the algorithms etc etc and made it um a place of violence and discrimination and um somewhere you can't even begin to think you
can convince people on other points of view so we decided uh to leave x a few weeks ago uh but it's it's late and it's uh so powerful we are facing like these huge giants that are changing if you think about Mark zukerberg is changing his uh position completely uh stopping the fact checking on his products at meta um saying that you know woke people and Progressive values have been too present on these social platforms and now it's going to be back with more masculinity and more um you know all those nice values so these
people they are the richest people on Earth they all agree that um the truth doesn't doesn't matter so much um they are only about ideology they only about um Can cannibalizing the the resources like your personal data but also environment resources because uh as you know I'm sure uh AI is a very huge problems for uh environmental resources as well so these people they're just thinking that the world is theirs and they have every tool and money to control the minds of the people so that's a huge challenge we've never known this before it's um
and we can't fight those people on in their fields like media can't fight Elon Musk on X it's like and many French media are living X right now it's it's it's a lost battle we have to go somewhere else and the thing is um it's not so easy to project ourselves in how do we do that because it's a French problem but it's a international problem uh it's very scary and that's something that um in media part we also think might be an advantage that we have first of all we're independent we have no pressure
from advertisers we don't have Financial shareholders that might tell us you should do this or or that more because I want some more money from my investment we don't depend on state subsidies we don't depend on Tech Giants and platforms we never agreed on any deal with the platforms so we never had it one cent from Google or meta or any of them but also we've always had a very strong participative philosophy media part actually means media and part is for participative we have uh which is called L club which is it's kind of growing
old now but uh in 2018 it was still modern I guess um it's free blogs that all of our subscribers can have and write they can write anything and it's um it's an entire column on the on the website so we actually work with the contributors to help them Express points of view uh show talk about their experience contribute to the democratic debate and that's something really important we we don't we have to think about how to modernize this because so many people won't uh give their um opinion now on a text some people might
record a sound people might film themselves but we have to I think go further on mod moderniza our uh tools but it's it's a pillar of democracy that we've been working on and that has is becoming very important we think we've always had free events and Gatherings like many times in a year we meet uh our public we talk about them we respond to their questionss we explain the work and and it's always crowded that gives us hope really because we think there are still some people wanting uh to defend democracy and to defend the
facts and Truth um and so we we we really try with different um participative projects also to to stay in touch with our communities and of course we we would stay in touch with our communities through social media so far but now we are we are going to stop I think we haven't decided to leave meta like Instagram and Facebook so far but I'm sure it will come very soon so we have to have a direct link with the people and not only with our 235,000 subscribers because it's not enough to organize the resistance so
we have to find a way with our brand which is quite famous with our legitimacy to gather people people and to you know be a place I hope uh to resist what's going on uh in France and uh in the world so I thought it was very interesting to put that in perspective with what's going on these days especially in the US but in France also very soon and um because that's really the the role of the media the media is the fourth power that are supposed to be um fundamental to a vivid democracy because
they reveal facts because they give people uh the information they need to make themselves um some opinions enlighted opinions and we see that it's getting less and less easy because Young Generation get information from social media that we've seen are really not uh interested in information anymore so that leaves us very worried about how the youngest generation get information how they exert their uh critical mind because you have to have a critical mind to be a citizen so I think I'm finished did was it too long oh no 52 minutes perfect wow [Applause]