Okay um yeah so I'll start our presentation firstly with saying thank you for such a great presentation um as I'm sure everyone knows I'm Charlie and myself and my colleague Sarah and Antoine are going to be giving our take on media part and also the topic of media Independence more broadly um in the first section I'm going to be talking about media parts Model and yeah of course yes so I'm be talking about uh media parts model and The Wider context of media ownership so to begin with we'll just introduce media part although it doesn't
really need reintroduction um so media part was established in 2008 and they sought to create a completely digital completely participative and completely Independent Media Outlet they've had Quite a lot of success in achieving this and as was mentioned earlier they are now the third place French daily by subscriber numbers what makes media part so interesting at least to us as a fre and I'm sure everyone else in the room is their commitment to their independence and the rule Vigor in which they sort of protect this and media part maintains its independence in many ways and
some of these are by refusing State subsidies By not allowing for any advertising on its websites by establishing a not for-profit uh organizational structure and crucially uring that revenue is only generated by its subscribers and that key decisions are only taken by it journalists um we also thought it was quite important to take a step back from media part and look at the wider context as to why media part might be important and on the very right we have a Selection of French household name media Outlets from television radio and uh newspapers and on the
left hand side we have the billionaire or the billionaire family which owns them and um in the spirit of their wealth we ranked them by how rich they are and what we can see essentially is that a select few people in France have a hell of a lot of power and influence over much of the French media next SL please um I'm myself from The UK and Sarah is American so we also thought we'd have a little look at whether this was a similar Trend in our own countries with respect to the amount of uh
influence certain companies had and so in the UK 90% of UK National um newspaper readership is owned by just three companies and with respect to online news the top five Publishers in the UK account for over half of all online news in the US there's a fairly similar Picture with four broadcast media companies making up 70% of the market share and with regards to the media industry more broadly the top four companies also make up uh 35% of the market share so we sort of came to the view that the cases of France not just
France but also the US and UK um present a bit of a threat to Independent Media we've seen billionaires and Powerful companies Essentially try and Gobble up their competition and expand their own influence so media part as highlighted by the previous presentation was aware of this um but in fact the guardian had this sort of vision many many years ago um back in 1936 and the scotch trust was set up um to essentially take ownership of the guardian and to place it in a not for-profit structure with basically the idea being that the guardian cannot
be Bought or sold today or tomorrow so they will maintain its independence forever when media part was first founded there was four founding journalists which had some capital in the company and of course this opens up the potential risk in the future of this Capital falling into malign hands maybe even one of those billionaires we mentioned earlier and so media part evolved and set up the font press leap which I'm Sure I've butchered the pronunciation of um to hold 100% of media Parts capital in a non-for-profit structure and the main aim of this is to
ensure that private capital and private interests are excluded from media Parts organization today and tomorrow and the final point I'm going to make is so I myself are much more familiar with how the guardian works and in our research on media part and its organizational Structure it's often compared to the guardian and they're given what we would say is a a false equivalent um we don't think this is fair to Media part they do like a better job even of protecting their own independence so we created this table to show some of the differences between
the two and media part gets a lovely green tick for all of our six categories um as we've mentioned there's a not for profit ownership structure structure and they refuse all Of the source of the revenue the guardian also has this ownership structure but it does accept revenue from adverts from private donors money from Ai and from search engines so our final point was essentially we think media part does really well to maintain its independence and it should even make this point even more so uh and there's not to give this falce equivalence with the
guardian to say so in the second section we're going To talk about how media is so successful how that came about um we have a little bit timeline it was on the 15E anniversary of media part that they selected their 15 most influential stores from their viewers um but I just wanted to highlight two which one of them you already kind of talked about um the first one is the beton court um The Stolen secrets of the Republic this one if you're French you might already know because it's pretty famous but the owner Of L'Oreal
they found evidence from private recordings with her Butler um of a whole scandal in which the um then president was implicated and then as you can see they went from 15,000 subscribers in the beginning of 2010 to 50,000 so one part of the success is finding these breakthrough stories again with the K cahusac account that we talked about already um the subscribers in two years went from basically doubled um but in 2013 there was a tax battle That they said might have been retribution where they had to pay um over $3 million in taxes for
being in online platform instead of a newspaper um even though the legislation got changed anyways and the taxes were lowered for um online PL platforms down to newspaper level um but then the one I wanted to highlight actually happened last month into the organized crime and Corruption reporting project um this article revealed a structural dependence On the US government um by one of the largest investigative reporting organizations in the world um and they had funding from the USA and also a state department Bureau and they have they found that they had the right to vtoy
sta staff even though they haven't and that the funding of from Washington couldn't be used to investigate the US nowadays they have even more funding but in the Inception um it was confirmed to have an Impact in avoiding us investigations and some funding is directly um towards us interest invested and so you can see the graph of the budget media part um had the unique position to resist this pressure um despite consequences actually this one's first um the German public broadcaster ndr initiated the project but actually it was censored and never got released media part
was the one to release the investigation because of pressure from The head of the ocrp I forgot his name um but um media part's been threatened with legal actions and accusations even against a journalist who was involved in publishing the article um but they stand by their values of Independence despite consequences um potentially um for example um the Modi party using this to discredit um the organization doing the reporting but they said even though this is inevitable that these Revelations Will impact um press everywhere it's better to be transparent and still publish than to give
into the pressure of either um political retribution or of um consequences on journalism because that'll make it even more credible in the long run yeah so let's maybe um take a step back to understand why is such thing possible to understanding the role of Journalism and why should it be free uh so first you can go back to the the Development of the bour public sphere where press appeared and then until the mass media time last century uh what is true is that in both case uh media is a way of organizing society and according
to media studies there are various uh theories about how what exactly is the effect uh but for example agenda setting um but thanks to the example that we uh made um that we showed from medart or for example the his historical case in front of the dri Affair it makes clear That media shapes politics um at the same time with the new uh social media and new technologies um there is uh this fact that the the the journalist representation uh are quite undermined not only uh these Technologies not only undermine uh the the revenues of
Jers but also the represent the representation of Jour journalists you can uh maybe uh like phrase this with sentence the medium is the message I'm sorry if you have heard It already a lot a lot of time before by Mar mcluhan that says that uh the technical sphere so the new sphere convey conveys a a message um and uh by that way uh some people could claim that journalist uh are the establishment uh whereas whereas um journalist uh the rational of Journalism is more about counter emony and exclusivism according to literature um so media part
is by the way a great converence of uh the different the the Two uh rationals of Journalism uh because it leads independent investigation s uh because uh it has a r participation participation and if we frame that in the knowledge economy the RO journalism um uh it reduces the information Symmetry by reporting investigation that have a high Sun cost so it's difficult to sustain the business um this is also a public good uh for democracy and if we can also phrase that by the institution Reorganization or institutions renewal uh that is the of democracy uh
yeah skip um and th uh we can say that this is role this role is undermined by uh the privatization as we say uh of the capitals of the Journal of the government funding because it gives a loyalty of the journalist to the owner uh J kit proposed a Model A hybrid model between uh Foundation Crown funding and public companies to counter that I think media Parts fall some somewhere in Inside that model and also Baker argued for the dispersal of ownership as well to have a functioning journalism yeah now we're going to get get
discuss uh some other things yes so media parts place in the world came about not only because of the successful investigations that captured public interest but also the specific French context the failure of leg Legacy newspapers like leig and handling the online transition unlike the German Context um they ended up being sold to Media Giants and then in general a public distrust of newspapers there's a long history of newspapers in France that we didn't have time to get into but there's a relationship between journalism in the government and in the Social Circles of Elites um
even a book published called La Marta Fran comparing it to the mafia um loyalty framework um and there are strong foundations of the four co-owners this didn't arise out of Nothing the four co-owners were all veterans of the traditional French plus and also had a starting Investments % of the co-owners and 40% from the Society of Friends and two private investors that each contributed 550,000 um of 2.9 million Euros so it's not exactly the Grassroots organization but um they're supposed to be representing more than just the elites and then the business model of course is
subscriber Based with not the free articles and not published uh not paid per article or beholden to advertisers okay uh yeah to uh like just name one challenge we're going to talk about the digital uh problem that Med face uh because media part tries to reach higher audience on social media to be more transparent like other media Outlets it seems normal uh also to capture new audience at the same time it might not Be sustainable over time uh because uh social media are monetizing engagement and uh media part is not in C of that nor
any media uh so I just take a screenshot in Instagram of one post and the first comment we see is something about uh the discredit and the the bad honesty of the journalist uh so very negative for the for the for the media and for example for young people to see that at first is a problematic and this is because uh not because this Has more more likes but because it has a lot of reactions in the comments uh to to claim the truth back uh then we can uh try to understand how media part
could invest this uh struggle uh for that uh we would need to understand what's exactly happening for that I like to mobilize a medology and of re de that is um uh talking about mological evolutionism and how different media evolves across time so this is just a summary of His Works uh you have Uh media sphere grouping different mediums the writing printing press audio visual digital and all a list of attributes um that is informed in his books um so these uh media spheres are interesting because it helps us to um yeah sorry to uh
let's say um understand how to how the the interaction in the organizations are shaped by the technical supports uh inside politics inside the economy um th for example with the printing Press at the beginning uh of the history uh you like the the the owners and the one who access prin P has a Hu a huge uh Power because they uh they had access to this uh media um they are called the medoc crats you can think of Luther for example um and uh at the same time eventually it led to uh the empowerment of
other people because the technology diffus because of Education it least to for some people to lead revolutions Etc with than to the preaching press but With the New Media the digital sphere uh it's um different so for um and that's why I think it's interesting to study this maor media spheres because um it's beneficial to apply the counter hemony of the journalism um rather than just studying ideology itself like the medium itself carries ideology as well uh so for example R de is framing that be debatable and I think it can be changed but uh
uh the reference acem of uh the Digital fair is no longer it's true it it works so if we see for example the comments on Instagram uh we can see that uh if uh negative comments or uh something that is denying the truth uh is um let's say put at first thanks to the algorithm thanks to the complex engineering behind um then it works and they don't need to tell the truth or reference they just uh U win the battle like that so that's how New Media can undermine the uh last uh medium and that
Interin in uh circle of reactions to deny let's uh ideological comments without reference is uh maybe uh a trap next and uh for that we so to as a question of how media part could invest in this battle uh it's uh to uh uh lead the technal in Innovations inside media for example the guardian Scotch trust uh created a venture capital and mobilized 42 million pounds to innovate in media Technologies uh of course maybe you might ask why I'm talking about Venture Capital why I was talking was re de who fought with CA in South
America was talk was clear inter capitalist and now I'm talking about Venture Capital it's true um we have to think about economic model of innovation in that uh journalism objective and for that to our eyes it seems that the f for um uh a free press could be uh a way to invest in Innovation with a team of people of uh To um build those common based innovations that tries to tackle um the let's say the the current uh reference ation of uh the Technologies which is it works and no longer it's true so with
the FPL you could for example build a common fruit and have more inertia also because it can um um uh let's say uh uh interact with other initiatives in in journalism as it's already the case so Med par Club could be part of the Innovation but Think the same that uh switching on Blue Sky it may not change the design and it's more about the policy moderation policies but the design is not to to make consensus based uh technology that can be uh beneficial for the Ives of of journalist counter Agony goals so yeah yeah
well the next slide is about the challenges facing media part just um to wrap it up so that we can ask you questions off the top of my head um we were talking about the transition from The last presidents I'm glad you already talked about the transition from the last CEOs and the directing board and then we had um um transitioning from X and the like and the current social media political media scape um the success of the subscriber model but competing in the attention economy um the independence from pressure and how really independent can
you be when everything is politicized And interconnected um for example the taxes and the many many lawsuits so far successful but fears about the future um better representation um regarding the class structure surrounding journalism in itself and the fact that it takes money and then yes upholding the values when everything's gone to these are our final questions no yeah H it says start from beginning Okay quick recap yeah uh what is uh first mine is uh could uh the FPL uh serve or did the FPL already serve Innovation activity inside media part or another organization
linked non necessar high-tech non online uh Innovation that can takes advantage of the organizing potential in reticular media so that means the digital media uh given that the new forms of media redefine journalists methods to get to their aim And how much could it um invest in there yeah so my question was how do you see the future for Independent Media Beyond just media part itself and do you think we'll see an increase or a decrease in the number and size of Independent Media Outlets not just in France but across the world and mine was
what unique difficulties do journalists face today especially with the changing political landscape and how does media part help Navigate or transform these risks what dangers or successes stand out with media part or the field overall and are there any changes you would [Applause] make thank you uh thank you for your work was really really interesting um so that are many questions um okay uh what unique difficulties the journalist face today and how does may have navigate to transform these risks what danger or successes stand out Without there are many difficulties of course that journalists face
today um on the top of my head of course um it's the same for many discriminated people uh there's a lot of violence we receive a lot of death threats and we have very strong um security um problems I mean we do what's best uh we really think about it we used to be a very Carefree uh collectivity like we would you know just work with like an open door and anyone could enter The the The Newsroom it was when I came in 2018 that was the way it was and the the times changed and
uh of course um the fascist sphere became more and more organized and more and more violent and more and more threatening so we have a lot of them that's um we're dealing with it really right now uh especially because we revealed something like really crazy um was an investigation on um there's a platform that's called Kick uh streaming platform that I don't Really know but and um our journalists uh discovered that um investigated the fact that they were earning money from hitting uh people with uh handicaps that was the way and they were like telling
that Community give us money and we would you know just uh violent uh these people etc etc so the story came out and uh the people did that of course they were um arrested and they might go to prison and their Community is furious because they were enjoying it so much so Now they're attacking us all the time uh but we really used to it we usually um uh try to deal with it but that's a a strong difficulty and it uh requires um changes and reflection in the the structure you know we have a
like evolu HR policies uh because also we started sending people uh in war zones which we didn't know before it started with uh when Russia attacked to Ukraine um so we are spending more money on uh giving information so that they Are safe when they go and they don't go too close to the the the war line but uh that's um you know we've had we have a very strong sense of social dialogue inside the company uh we discuss a lot and we always try to be better um about those security concerns um I don't
know if it's a difficulty um but it's we also really um Vigilant uh on diversity questions um be and renewing um and um hiring journalists Outside the the Box because it's true that journalists in France they all come from some kind of uh the same social uh um uh places and uh we try to to have a active uh policy on um diversity like social diversity uh diversity of Origins sexual diversity uh we have um many many like we have a um someone who's uh Trends we have like we we try to resemble the the
society we talked to so and there's a lot of journalists that were there at the Beginning there were like 25 30 years olds at the beginning but then they're like 45 so we're a aging news room and uh even if we think of us as being very young uh we are not so we also try to put young journalist in The Newsroom because they they bring something else uh and from very diverse places um social uh environments Etc Origins etc etc because that's the society as it is that's the society we like and we want
to talk to and that's The progressive idas we we value so uh that's a challenge also because uh it's a very it's not always easy to to do and we've um we have two um positions in media we have one uh gender editor and we also launched a a racial editor those two position are made to help us be vigilant about B bias in the way we write uh about gender about races and uh we try to you know to to work on ourselves we want to be as exemplary as what we write in our
Columns we can't you know point fingers at everyone saying oh you do this you do that and not you know do the work in our place so that takes a lot of time and it's really interesting and uh but there it's challenging I think bringing new people young people different people into Newsroom is a very big challenge for papers in general um there any changer your bu would benefit media Part that's a big question oh I'll go to the next one how do I see the future for Independent Media Beyond media itself do you think
we will see an increase or decrease in number and size of so um ever since media was launched we've always tried to help other Independent Media so we took uh some small participation into media capitals uh and uh um we also give advice as much as we can when people ask for and uh I have to say it's it's been Quite uh an an enthusiasm lately because there are many many many people especially young people launching uh news uh projects Independent News projects uh using uh the new technologies as well like they go a lot
on social media uh they share the codes of this uh culture and um they're doing some very very good job in France I think about Street Press we which works on a far right movements or ver media which is an ecological media and they're Doing very good and the the is helping them we try to help we we really want to we don't want to be like uh the only ones succeeding in being being independent and successful we really think we need Independent Media uh in um in France and everywhere else and um as for
the future um I don't know some of me think the the latest Evolutions um are a good thing for independent journalism because I think Consciousness might you know rise a bit because of all the dangers that are that are coming um so I think that might be a dynamic for Independent Media but at the same time I think uh all those illiberal and authoritarian regimes are going to make it so hard for the Independent Media to do their jobs that it might be complicated because they they have many many ways to um to put difficulty
into those media they ALS there's also uh judici Arian harassments Like you put some media in front of court all the time and it takes a lot of money to defend your media in front of Courts and if you're not media part media part we spend like I don't know maybe 300,000 a year uh to pay our lawyers uh but we can afford it because we win 25 billion euros you see so for the smallest and the smaller Independent Media if you have like three or four trials you might be uh dead because they Always
go and appeal for donations from the readers usually works but if you have too many of them you can't stand and if you are building strategies to defend yourself in front of the court you don't have time to do journalism and I'm talking about Independent Media that are like four or five jist they're very small and they need all their time and energy to do journalism and to promote their work so I'm so I'm a bit pessimistic because if really the the Liberal regimes uh go strong on Independent Media there won't be many many able
to survive I'm afraid but I'm sure that there will be many people wanting to to do some uh investigative and independent journalism so we'll see about that uh could did the serve Innovation activity inside media okay so the FPL um can't Finance anything for media it's a strict line they can Finance any other media but they can't Finance media Parts Um uh Innovation activity Hightech Innovation I mean they they've been financing some technical developments for some media uh because it's usually what's uh Missing the most it's not talented journalist like small media they have that
but it's uh building uh technological tools uh that are um most usually also independent from you know like main uh Brands Etc it's very expensive developing your um application is expensive developing your um the System you work on to make your website is expensive etc etc and the FPL have been financing uh this kind of developments but um the f is still uh short in money to finance this because it's very expensive so and it usually gives like grants from 10,000 to 30,000 but it's not enough to finance uh very strong uh Tech Innovations um
and there was another question after I think I don't no it's Good okay I see other questions here yeah hi my name is nikil Ral I'm from India and I was a journalist in India for six years and I have some questions uh regarding the independence and free freedom of press and governance so first of all uh the idea that taking the money from government is wrong is somehow also undemocratic in a way that if you look at the example of BBC right so BBC is funded by the taxpayers and yet it has Continued to
be as unbiased and free so that is one and also the billionaires like we agree that all billionaires are bad but some are better than others you look at the case of Michael Bloomberg he ran Bloomberg without having much political interference and it is also very unbiased compared to other business organizations which do not have ethics and all of that so that is one disagreement on that part and on the funding part so in India we had this Great difficulty I was working in a startup I was working for a unbiased political digital news portal
called theprint.in and our biggest Contender were propagandists so I wanted to ask like so the numbers of propaganda websites the ones which are throwing free news free links free everything they publishing all Praises of the governments or there will be propaganda websites which will be publishing all sorts of Anti-government narratives so when your readers are biased when your audience has a biasedness themselves how do we guarantee that the subscriber LE model is also not unbiased for example if for if I I don't know the ideology of media Park but if of the 200,000 subscribers that
you have all of them are leftwing subscribers and the dare you publish some report which criticizes a left leaning politician or some policy of the Left that destroyed environment or coal mining or something then do you also risk losing subscribers you would not choose to publish such stories one and second second question is on on the digital uh platforms so what I have seen and what we have work as as newsrooms um it's the content that always sells so the advertisement LE model uh first question is do you use YouTube are you on YouTube yes
is your YouTube channel Monetized no no your YouTube channel is not monetized so the the thing is that when yes yes sorry sorry just just just small I'll keep it small the thing with with with digital digital media is that the numbers the numbers matter because they are Drive they're also driving forces of revenues and like the in the presentation also antoan mentioned that the the Press not just only needs to be free what's the point if the propaganda Is being spread like wildfire while for Quality journalism I have to pay 10 or 12 a
month right so so what what's the purpose of media in that case right that that that uh sorry for being usually we collect question already uh so uh yeah on your first disagreement of course uh Public Service Media are useful but um un important but they're not independent I mean they have a public service Mission and they do it pretty well but they're not independent Like the the budgets in France of France television and radio France which is the public service broadcast in France uh they've been uh they're going to be very reduced this year
and that that makes them pretty fragile to pressure so it's it's it's hard when you financed by the government to be completely independent it's it's it's easier when you're financed only by your readers um on about the question of um writing about I mean we write about any Fact that we think is of public interest so we don't choose if we have a good story whether it's about you know a very good human humanitarian Association a very nice civil movement uh the O ocrp that you mentioned was really hard because we basically we say the
biggest investigative Consortium in the world is being financed by the USA which actually chooses is the subject that they can investigate on and cannot and we've been Receiving a lot of pressure and a lot of friends I mean um media friends said you are doing so much damage to investigation it's hard enough like this and you pull that out outside and and it's very bad for her for us and it's kind of hard it still is today we still have to explain why we did that because we can't be what we are and have this
story and not publish it because we think it's going to harm some interest that we actually share values with Because we believe in investigation but when we discover that it's completely hidden from the journalist that work in this Consortium that the USA are financing and you know uh giving uh some um some insights about what should be investigated it or not we have to publish it but it's it's been very painful lately and the journalist Yan Filipa is it's hard for him because he's getting attacked but we had to publish it and we were the
only ones who did and Uh we also publish about uh leftwing parties in France which um creates a lot of anger sometimes from our subscribers especially when we write about la which is radical left party I would say and um they get mad they write to us uh they say we are um saying nonsense and we are biased and we're harming the cause Etc but we we still do sometimes we lose some subscribers but REM remained loyal to our values and um that's how I think uh we make our legitimacy strong and we Have some
readers and subscribers that are from the the right side even far right readers because some of them in if they're int intellectually honest honest they um they don't agree with us but they know that what they read is true so they respect the journalist work and was was your s question yeah that's um that's a huge uh problem um to to make it the the regular price for mediaart is1 a month but we also have a a lower fee at five EUR a month That you can uh subscribe to uh if you think uh that
you're uh you don't have enough money to pay 12 and we don't ask for any document or whether you're a student or you're unemployed Etc you just say oh I can't pay I will only pay five EUR a month and that fee hasn't changed for 17 years because we want to make our journalism accessible as much as possible but we also need to live from it and it's very often that we have some um free content as well um most of Our videos are for free uh some very um important articles we put them for
free also and uh and um we try to yeah I mean we can't fight all the misinformation that's for free elsewhere it's like we can only say where we stand at from where we talk and you know just defend our work but um it's not enough to really uh opposite the free propaganda and also disinformation that's online everywhere Now yes but we don't publish I mean we publish some pieces uh because we don't use our artificial intelligence so far unlike many others so we have two real uh English translators and but they publish only a
few pieces and it's not very very famous we don't promote it so much but we might at some point uh develop our English version okay questions hi I'm Lou from fren and um I Was reflecting on how the job of journalist like many other jobs the last 30 years but got PR priz like love insecurity and it's hard to get a stable job like a c c and you mentioned I think even yourselves that most big major take on inter Journal is going out of the three top major schools in France so what are the
kind of ways that you see for young independent journalists or journalist that doesn't fit in that mold or to create more diversity in term of Journalistic formation especially because this top um media Journal um school don't really see something we see as a priority as a priority we can talk about ecology that they don't really format journalist young journalist to be educated on and Val media in a conference was mentioning this so this is my question and also I saw yesterday the sarosi documentary media par made uh crazy first and second I wanted to know
um what was The intention behind making a documentary versus just artical and how hard was it to resist the pressure when the police was involved and the government was involved at such a high point okay I'm Roma also from France I had a quite a similar question from nikil like that the one Nik asked because so uh so you refuse public subsidies like from because of the situation of the public services in France uh but I remember that in some Radical left wi programs such as um the one from melon in 2022 like there were
plans for neutral subsidies to uh the Press would you have accepted Public Funding of that kinds okay uh okay so yeah there's a lot of yeah precarity uh for young journalists and it's getting worse and worse all studies shows that um and also there's you know there are Some uh Renown school but there I think there's so many ways to do journalism now and I see a lot of young people like really brilliant young people that um that have um you know themes they want to defend in a very uh uh personal way so I
mean in media paath we work with non-permanent non journalist as well but we try to treat them as well as possible uh We've increased the the price of the the article by uh 30% lately uh but it's not enough to uh make Them live as well as they should so it's getting more and more complicated many many media rely on non-permanent journalists for example you might know L they're they have a ton of money but they have no just a few journalists on CDE and all the rest are some non-permanent journalist so we try not
to do that but we're and we we engaged in every reflection we can to help the Young Generation uh we take some alter I don't know how to say it in English uh We try to to we go a lot of journalists go to um uh give conferences and lessons to help the new generation but it's true that it's becoming harder and harder and that when you start in journalism you have to be able to write to film to make some podcasts you have to do everything by yourself you have to be able to put
your video together and it's you know it's a lot of [Music] Um competence uh competency and skills uh for very few money so I mean yeah it's it's it's a hard job uh but in media part we when we hire someone it's always on CD and uh with good salaries we try to do our best where we are but it's very very complicated and as for the person we just launched um a a documentary in the cinema in France about the sarosi CI Affair which is the presumed financement of the presidential Election of Nicolas sarosi
by um the Libyan dictature um we wanted to do that because it's a very complicated story uh we have like 160 articles uh on media parts and uh the pro the trial was opening on January 6 and we think it's it's huge I and it's there's nothing uh to compare to in the fifth Republic it's a huge Scandal if the Justice uh says it's true which might be and we wanted to make sure that people could access The story understand and um it was it's an experimentation because we don't usually do movies uh and we
did um participative financement uh we asked people to give money if they want wanted to see that movie and we collected 500,000 in like a month it was crazy and uh the movie is um doing really good A lot of people are seeing it are very happy because they get to understand the title means no one understands anything About this it's um it's a phrase that's from Nikolas sarui himself saying uh this is all lies and nonsense and no one understands anything about this and that you know the we tried to make it funny and
um and we're really surprised actually that so many people are going to see the the movie really happy to uh because it's um it might end up with our president going to prison this time and not just electronical bracelets so um yeah that was um and we we feared until The last very moment that they would try to prevent the movie to go uh into the cinemas uh to some trial uh pressure and didn't happen so it's all good so far and you were asking about H yes I know okay public subsidies uh if there
were I mean some of the people we work with are thinking about having an independent Center who would distribute public subsidies so if such a virtuous model could be found maybe we would take them But we don't need them so we prefer to so far we don't need them so we would let it to the others until we can do anything else okay so plenty of questions so here here so we'll take four um hello I'm praa from Nepal um my question was in Nepal we have like a like a transaction act where if you
are a media registered you have to abide by like uh certain um uh certain like operation guidelines where certain Contents if they are like deemed harmful for National interest or like social harmony you have to like takeen take it down and you can often bypass it if you are in good terms with the government in power but you know it's a tricky zone so I was wondering um how like I'm guessing it's still a registered media company in France so what is the case like that here and a little bit on um the tech platform
aspect where um to get away from the big Tech platforms and still Keep the media Parts Vision intact I was thinking maybe um H have you guys looked into building your own applications like like an app which you can download independent from any big Tech platforms what is it like hi I'm Arthur from Netherlands and I was wondering it's more of like a strategic question in the sense that now now nowadays like the mainstream and Independent Media are often painted as like left wi by far right Parties and I was wondering how you guys uh
view your own rule role within this media landscape is this uh term that you like to embrace or that you want to fight as um as a media Outlet yeah and also more largely like uh how do you view your own role uh within the media landscape hello I'm Thomas from Norway I also a question a bit similar to what asked it's about like what political decisions can be made or what What uh policies can be implemented to to yeah one to to avoid concentration of the media do you think and to to support Independent
Media like yeah I guess this fund thing was talking about this one thing but especially both in countries where like in France where the the far right is G gaining influence because of this media concentration but also countries where this hasn't happened yet and there's a danger that would happen like what should you do to to avoid it From to uh hello uh first of all thanks for the presentation and I was wondering uh if this uh like how is the environment with this other smaller indep Independent Media if there is a bit of Doubt
uh from that them towards media part or if they uh are think it's great to fund yes okay thanks I'll answer yours first um uh media part is seen I mean I tend to think that smaller media uh refer to Media about as you know something they value and admire and um yeah that's the positive way of seeing it but lately one of them told me that we might at some point be seen as you know the lesson givers or because we are we are so much bigger than the other ones it's it's it's particular
it's um we're in between we have this Independent Media ecosystem but they're all very very small and then there's us being the Third um national uh general information um paper uh Online and then the rest of the media and we are kind of alone in between uh we're like the the big fish for them but the small fish for the others and um so it's it's not always very easy because I mean we created the FPL to help them and uh we Finance the FPL and we also help as many media that we can etc
etc but I think our leader position also creates um something that's not always um nice for the others uh because we are So much more powerful so many more and uh but we have very good ter in good terms and uh especially since the last uh election in June because all the Civil resistance that was organized in Paris PL Republic which the the events Etc that came from the Independent Media none of the none the other media not even Liberation which is supposed to be leftwing also they didn't come there was only Independent Media and
humanity and um so We are we really share some strong values um no no no your question was about what could we do on a national scale that's complicated because um there were what's called um information General discussion that was organized by the government a year ago um but um we think that it's not the government that should uh lead those discussions but the parliament they representative of the real people and um So we organized some uh independent press uh talking and we made up some prop proposals uh but uh as far as I know
um only a few uh proposals are being uh retained by uh rashti the minister of culture and it's not uh going anywhere we want it to go um I mean they the it's not that they don't care about concentration I think it's a supported because they're friends with those People uh they it's it's there's always this discussion in France about Public Service Media also so it's there's no political uh uh willing to change that for the moment so there there could be a lot of ideas uh to make sure you can also you could make
it mandatory for The Newsroom to have a vote for or against the director of the publication in media part the director of the publication is a journalist is the one responsible in Front of the Justice uh about what's written in the paper but it's really rare most of the time it's a non-journalist person it's a representant of the owner and so if the represented of the owner says oh no this paper no no no I don't want because it's my friend etc etc it can put a big pressure on the news rooms and there could
be some very simple uh rules that you could establish that The Newsroom have a right to vote for or Against the director of the publication but even that is complicated and is not so um so well uh appropriated by the media so it's it's kind of a you know subjects that will take a long time I think to to evolve and I'm sure it's not in the next years because I'm pretty pessimistic about what's going to happen in France and uh in the media in general um yours was about sorry being paint ah Yes yeah
yeah um that's three people from the far right that's paint people the media being all from the left uh Wing uh mostly um because um not so many of them are actually from my point of view and um we uh media part we we say we're not from any party from any side we write stories about you know even structures that we value etc etc and uh we don't we're not here to do politics we're here To give out facts we don't want to convince people to think this or that we just want to put
them uh in their hands some facts and they make up their minds um so it's um and it's and in general I think it's really false that the media are uh leftwing and um I read something that's pretty um critical and worrying uh CNN was supposed to be a Democrat uh channel in the USA uh lost like half of its audience after Trump Was reelected uh last month and uh it show shows that um and the the th the boss of the channel he gathered his main journalist and he told them okay now you stop
uh editorialization you stop uh you know like being too much uh Democrats because we're going to lose everything so it's not that true like many media leaders uh they're turning their vest I don't know if you can say it in English but they're turning their vest now because business Is so complicated so um yeah and we try to we are seen as left radical left uh but we we know we don't uh I mean we we just talk about facts um and Nepal now um first question was about uh how yeah um in France you
have an agreement when you're a media you have to go through a commission pararan commission that gives you an agreement for five years um so it's it's a Recognition of a journalistic structure but then it puts no pressure on you uh on what you can write or cannot write but you can have uh trials if you don't respect some um some legal uh points uh in media part we there's some regarding U personal data there's some regarding defamation I don't know if you can say it uh but it it doesn't put it just a label
saying okay you're a journalistic structure and it's being verified every five Years ah yes um yeah um I I mean we have an application where you can read the paper on uh but we are starting to think about what what we could do um regarding um new technologies and applications um and uh you know um with the free uh free Technologies um so far yeah we've we've been on X and Facebook etc etc because at some point you could was still okay It's not anymore and um Facebook have have been U have put media uh
invisible for a long time now so um there's no no point in being on those platforms anymore but you have to think about how you can Embark your community with you because we have a lot of followers and where to go there's some safe spaces you can go to but we have you know to uh uh to adopt them we're going on Blue Sky and on uh Mastodon now and we are launching some tutorial for our audience So that they know how they can leave X and go to Blue Sky or masteron taking all their
because you there's a lot of value on those platforms there's everything you've been writing about for years and you don't own this the platform owns it and so we're trying to find ways to take this value out with our audience and we're thinking for the future of new developments we could make to you know to diversify the ways we could interact with our audience and you Know create some safe spaces for the future uh to yeah to think together and maybe act together maybe about the pressure of the state on the media you can me
it was mentioned by Sarah in Her speech but maybe it was not Cote by all all of people here vat uh is different from for Medias for press and and for common goods and at one uh it was a supposed to be leftwing government fromand maybe you can mention this this story very shortly because I think it's Important yes yes that's one of the there were many fight in the history of media parts and one of them was the the vat that was applied to the press it was 2. 1% for printed press and mainstream
press and when um media part launched uh it's a website he said we're doing journalism we're not just going to print anything so as journalists as a media we should benefit from the same VI vat than the rest of the press because you can read the same information online or on Paper and uh that was a that's a long story I'm going to try to make it short we got we went public on this we would write to the administration saying uh we should benefit and not only us all of the websites that do some
uh news should benefit from this V8 um as the rest of the press uh we also uh said we're not going to pay 20% so we didn't pay 20% but we were public and the administration knew and at some Point uh when the and Nicolas sarosi had said in 2008 so just when we launched we are going to put all the V8s at the same level 2.2 person so we thought it was okay you know and uh after we launched uh the story about Jerome kak we have no proof there's a link but we have
save doubt yes uh we had um the administration came for a control on our accounts and everything was uh all right except for this V8 uh and so they um they en enjoy they they told us to pay the VA 20% that we should have been paying even if uh the legislation was just turning around at the moment uh we think at that point they thought uh that was going to be the end of media part because they thought we didn't have the money to pay but we had been uh making some reserves so we
were able to pay without shutting the newspaper and we went to Trial for many many years and we still are in trial about this because uh first trial we won second trial there was an appeal the state made an appeal and we lost we tried to go on court of c and they didn't take our file and we are now uh in front of uh thean European Court of Human Rights um because we think we haven't been uh heard as a normal structure a citizen we think there was a bias because it was media parts
so we are trying for our Honor and also because we would maybe get back some of the money we gave we're still fighting about this but that's a big big way of pressure uh for the media it was really intended to uh to kill us it didn't but um it could be the ways that the far right does it when it comes to power and a lot of media won't be able to resist that okay questions yes and it was under the left left wing frand presidency thank you um there was a Question about uh
ecology and the ability for the press to to deal with this problem and for the journalist to understand those question and I want to know what you think about that any other question yes you already had opportunity during the break I mean dur okay oh okay no frustration no it's just to ask because I as I know I thought that the a lot of journalists use Twitter to um gather Information collects at the first steps just wanted to know like what's happening now and and yeah if it's true uh about ecology first um that's one
of our main priorities in uh media Parts uh we think it's um a main topic we've um multiply the journalists working on uh ecological investigation uh because we think it's a absolute priority and um we are happy that others Independent Media uh are are growing also on these Topics um I have to say that of course we are more and more worried uh because um yeah it's becoming not a priority either in the USA or with the new government in France so it's really uh scary but we we just launched a story uh about uh
water lately I mean you've been heard about maybe the scandals about the water and the PE faces that in the water etc etc so we're uh trying we're working hard also on um Agriculture and it's uh you know the way it uh contributes to Polluting the soils and Etc and we are we have four journalists work no four six journalists working on uh eological matters uh analysis and investigation and uh Twitter X um yeah um so mediaart left X we strongly encourage the journalist to leave X also but they remain free to do what they
want but some of them are going to stop posting on X but still uh investigate on X because it's a it's a source of information that remains uh Important maybe in the few months to come it will be less interesting because a lot of people are moving away from a uh but they can still use it as a tool for journalism thank you very much thank you