[Music] Matt I feel this one I feel this episode um I've been at West brenon now for nine years um and uh my church just actually gave me a very nice uh anniversary gift I was not expecting it I got a new watch for those of you who don't know I'm into watches and so they were very gracious uh to to buy me a watch that I really really like they picked it picked out a good one um and uh they said they said in the presentation to the whole church which I was not I
was not aware they were going to do this they said we here's a watch we want you to stay for a few more years um which which is good you know I was glad to get to watch and I was also really glad to hear that I was uh wanted as a leader for for the next at least for the next few years uh I think that's a very healthy situation I think long tenure is good for churches and generally better but we're going to be talking about staying too long and how do you know
and what are the warning signs but before we get there I want to thank our sponsor doing something different for December uh we've got a church answers resource that we want to tell you about it's called my church staff so you can develop your next staff member for $100 per month you heard that right $100 per month you may say can I get a stewardship Pastor for $100 a month can I get a worship leader for $10000 a month yes you can both of those positions are where we are starting we hope this thing grows
beyond these two positions uh we can start Staffing the church at a very affordable price uh stewardship is being led by my brother art uh even though he is my brother I will say art reer is pretty awesome and then we all know the worship Guru worship guru's been long time connected to the show even longer than I've been on the show Mike Harland is going to be doing that so we've got a link in the show notes you can also go to church anwers.com uh to go get this resource cancelable anytime although you're not
going to want to cancel it after you get into it $100 a month we would love to have you as part of my church staff all right Matt how long have you been at Barto just a little shorter than me I just celebrated seven years seven I okay so we're close I'm nine you're seven um and you really like it there and you want to stay I do I can't wait to get a watch at nine years yeah uh so in case anyone is wondering it's a a TSO Powermatic 80 um it's got the framed
date window 100 meters of water resistance uh 21 millimeter lugs uh lug to lugs 21 millimeters uh I really like the applied indices the ice blue dial um and the 80 hour powered Reserve along with the butterfly clasp so there you go uh no one cares though no I like watches not as much as you do Sam but I do like watches and my church I've mentioned a few times that I like pocket knives so once in a while I'll get a pocket knife oh okay so you collect okay you've told me that before that
that's kind of a thing like they have knife shows and all that stuff and um there's people that like hand make them and uh they can get you know they can get uh very ornate uh very ornate absolutely are you collecting a brand or are you collecting like designs or just anything I like any quality pocket knife my favorite brand without a doubt is case c a e case pocket knives that's my favorite brand I've heard of them I don't know much though I probably know as much about pocket knives as you know about watches
that sounds probably right that's accurate I think all right so let's talk about uh we we're talking about anniversary gifts and boy we have been dropping some hints to our churches I hope they are listening um you know how do you know when you stay too long everyone talks about you should stay forever go and stay and 30 years and 40 years and you hear these stories and they're beautiful they're wonderful stories brother Bob who was uh the pastor of West Bron was here for 29 years uh just an incredible story of God's faithfulness and
the he's still around he's still with us um although his health is a little less than what it needs to be the church still speaks very finely of him in his era uh so hey go and stay and have a wonderful time with your churches but there comes a point to where it's like I might be staying too long is it possible I think it is so what are some of the warning signs and I'll start here when uh so this really applies to really any tenure I mean you could if you've been at 20
different churches for six months and you're it's not like a um a placement sort of thing uh where you're in intentional interum that's probably a problem there's a point at which you know you okay you've just changed too many times and Too Short a time frame uh but this particular uh piece of advice is really for anyone at any stage but it tends to be more on the shorter side than the longer side so let's just assume you're a younger Pastor you've been at a church three or four years and you're like man am I
stay you know what should I go and I would say this when you become the lightning rod for every change effort that doesn't mean you need to leave but it's a warning sign and I've been this I've been this guy I I speak from experience and there's a reason I put this as bullet point number one because this is my story you know I got to the point to where I was you know every change effort that I was trying to make I ended up being the problem now I think that was unfair and I
don't think I deserve the criticism at least not all of it but uh I ended up not staying at that church a long time although not for these reasons we ended up working things out for a positive way but you know when you become the lightning rod for like everything you yourself are the lightning rod those are that's some self-reflection time let me just put it that way yeah I I agree with that Sam and um I I appreciate uh you speak speaking about your own personal experience I've had that experience as well particularly when
I first came to our church we had we had gone through some very difficult times and quite frankly a lot of change needed to happen before I before I came and then but the reality is I was being blamed for some changes that I wasn't even doing and so I think I think I was a lightning rod for a lot of change early so I think one thing that can help with that is just clear communication and getting things out in the open let's what really happened here and let's talk about it let's talk about
who made this decision however if this is a sustained period of time that you are the lightning rod I think you're absolutely right that is a sign that you need to do some serious self-reflection and see is this where God wants me to continue to serve yeah it's a warning sign doesn't mean you need to go you may reflect and go you know what this church just needed a lot of change and I'm just going to have to be this person I'm going to have to be the villain for a little while but you can't
stay the villain forever as the pastor um sometimes leadership requires that and sometimes you have to do it but man you can't stay there uh so that's definitely a time to just whatever your tenure is to really start doing some self assessment um another thing to look for and again we're not just necessarily talking about you're too old that we're not that's not what we're talking about um we're talking about just anyone at any point in their tenure uh so the second point is this when you give up on Innovation and you find deep comfort
in the status quo of the past that could really happen to anyone of any age of course um but you're you're basically giving up on leading is is what we're saying there yeah absolutely again uh that that's a a warning sign in fact I would say in my observation typically the status quo is not really the status quo when you accept the status quo generally churches are more susceptible susceptible to dying they're not actually maintaining that status quo they're actually suffering and so anytime we have the posture of the status quo is okay that that's
a terrible situation to be in long term we need to seek the Lord seek in inside ourselves and ask ourselves let's not accept that challenge ourselves to not accept the status quo yeah and I think the key term here is deep comfort in the status quo if you're reading the show notes like I find deep comfort and just things never changing uh you know you're supposed to Shepherd people which means you know things are always Chang and every new person that comes into your church is change right uh if you're winning people to Christ and
you're reaching the Next Generation your church is going to change quite a bit and so if you're not leading people to get out of their comfort zone and you yourself are in your comfort zone that's that's certainly a warning sign that it may be time to think about what's next uh this next Point's a hard one um but it's true uh I I certainly feel it at 44 years old I feel these things I am getting older and I certainly uh sympathize with people who have uh physical issues uh you know but sometimes you're physical
body can just it just can't take the demands of ministry I preach three times on a Sunday morning it's a requirement of the job and at some point I don't know when it will be hopefully not for a long time but at some point I'm just not going to be able to do that physically uh and and if I were ever to get to that point where I can't preach three times I can only preach once um on a Sunday that's a major problem and it's definitely a reason to begin to think about you know
is it is it time yeah I agree with that Sam in fact um my previous church we had three three services in the morning and I have a really good friend at a mega church here in the area that has three services and I've preached in both those context uh and I can tell you it's challenging I understand that it is challenging to preach three times on a Sunday I I'm blessed right now to generally only preach once on a Sunday when I first came I was preaching twice uh so yeah that's something we need
to keep in mind our sleep schedule is important that's a big part of our health as well and also not just for senior lead pastors there are other Ministry positions that have different levels of physicality those are things that people need to keep in mind for those positions as well have I been in this position too long and so physical side's definitely important yeah um another thing to consider as you're kind of self assessing you know am I staying to too long or not and by the way I think these are I think we're talking
to the minority right now I think the majority of people it's hey you you you're good for your church you need to stay and I think that needs to be the dominant posture I want to be very clear about that but I'm sure that there are people who have been through this process there pastors and church leaders who have been through this process and there may be people listening right now the reason you're listening is because you're thinking about these things um so this next Point um I don't think it is um something that happens
a lot but it can happen and either you got to correct or move and that's when apathy or anger dominates your feelings um so there are times to be angry there's really no time to be apathetic but there are times to be angry at your church but man when you're dominated by apathy when you're dominated by anger you're you're not in a good place to to love people to Shepherd them to discipline them to encourage them and to move them forward in leadership yeah 100% that word as you said that word dominates is a very
important word there because we all go through bad days bad moments sometimes bad seasons and that doesn't mean we can't make it through that recover get some counseling get some encouragement from other Pastor Ministry friends we can get through that and God could continue to use us to flourish in our ministry positions but if it's dominating that is a warning sign that you've been there too long because and quite frankly if we're all honest nobody wants to be angry and apathetic nobody wants that so uh we something definitely needs to change if we're in that
situation yeah this next warning sign we' got a few more here um when you consistently blame others for the lack of progress uh this this is a pet peeve of mine and hey I've done it I've done my own pet peeves right I'm guilty of my own pet peeves but you know when you can uh when you consistently blame others for the lack of progress is something where I'm like no you're the leader you're the leader you're the one who is supposed to be showing what progress really looks like and taking people to that better
place it's one of my favorite I'm paraphrasing I think Max depri on this in terms of uh leadership Theory uh forgive me if I'm getting this wrong I don't have my notes in front of me but I think he's the one who said something like leadership is just taking people to a better place um and I'm pretty sure that's Max depri although I might be misquoting there but whoever said it I love that idea what are you doing as a pastor what are you doing as a Shepherd well what you're supposed to be doing is
taking people to a better place that's why I lead with optimism that I don't lead with anger I don't lead with apathy there's times to have be angry but you I don't lead with those things I want to see my church get to a healthier spot to you know Promise of Greater things in John 14 you're you're going to reach more people you're going to go to more places and that's on you that's I mean I I hate to because we got a lot of leaders that listen to this and a lot of leaders that
go through some tough stuff and you know get a you know really just um you know they go to difficult churches and they they struggle um not because of their own uh inadequacies just because it's difficult church so you know I really want to be careful because sometimes you can go to a church and you're just like this church ain't gonna go anywhere and the lack of progress really is on the congregation uh but man if you're just consistently blaming others for the lack of progress let's say you're right like this congregation is just going
to go nowhere Jesus himself could not lead them you know Rick Warren could go here Stephen fdick could go here Alistair beg could go here name your favorite whoever and they're not going to do anything well you know what you know what I'd tell you if if I was having that conversation with you and you were my coaching client you know I'd say uh time to get your resume out you know it's time to time to go someplace else uh so there's no need to blame the congregation all the time because even if that's true
it's time to go yeah agree 100% % Sam I I would say too this is a particular challenge for us as Leaders because when you look outside the church and the leadership culture at large there is a lot of blame people do blame others people rarely take responsibility for mistakes and so that's kind of the default position in the western culture right now so we need to be different though we are called to lead the Church of the Lord Jesus Christ so our default position should be one of humility one of examining ourselves and one
of not blaming others and then in the rare situation that it is just a really poor situation to be in it is time to find a better place where the Lord can use you where people will follow your leadership so let's talk about motivation um you know the motivating factor of hanging around at a church should not be the money it should not be I just need to hit retirement um now should that be a goal like should you be fairly compensated yes should you retire well yes should your church take care of you absolutely
but it's the the key here is primary motivator what is what is the primary motivator and if it's like man I don't want to move I don't really want to go I know that my time here is done I just need two or three more years to get to this Mark so that I can retire you know that's a um it's an understandable thought but it is an it is a burden that you should not put on your church like I get it I'm 65 years old I've got good energy I'm doing all right I
don't really want to start over again in another church I've been here 20 years I want to hit 68 and that's just where I want to be if I'm talking to somebody in that camp I say man I understand like I I could totally see myself thinking that too but that's not the right thing to do that's you know your your church is going to end up suffering they probably love you they're probably glad for you to stick around for another three years but if that's your primary motive motivator and you can't get past that
I I would say you you might want to do something else for three more years yeah and I would recommend a few things in that situation one is remind yourself of why you first got into gospel Ministry um remind yourself of that and just seek to Finish Well honor the Lord in that too uh I would seek uh some influential whether they're friends or other Min Ministry influencers in your life and just tell them what you're going through just be honest with them ask them how they dealt with it if they gone had gone through
it as well and also just be honest with your church you know um just tell them hey maybe maybe I can shift my role in a different way maybe we can have some of the other pastors preach some more just things like that just be open and honest to a to a certain level and uh just communicate and seek to finish well but uh if you're in that situation it's just not healthy for your soul and it's not healthy for your church no it's not uh and last Point here uh what's a warning sign that
maybe you've stayed too long at a church uh when you would rather let the church die than try to save it um you know I've said this so many times um and I you know it's kind of my Spiel I guess is uh no church should die you know some churches will unfortunately but I do not like to hear well that church should just die no no every church should live every church is a kingdom Outpost Jesus loves every church and every church should be doing his work and his will um so if you're not
willing to try to get let's say the church is just in horrible shape they are very unhealthy you know just being there to just let it die you know I can't do that I don't think you should either now you may say well I I realize it is going to die and I'm going to Shepherd them well to that point okay I I've we've had a few clients of church answers who've had to do that they understood their role what I'm more talking about is I'm just not going to go there with them I'm going
to collect a paycheck for a couple of years and when they die they die when they can't pay me anymore is when they can't pay me anymore and you know you know they certainly need a pastor but you're probably not the one that they need um because they need somebody who's going to push them a little harder than just you just being there and collecting a paycheck yeah absolutely I mean quite frankly it's it's tragic that anyone would just stand by and let a church die when something could be done about it um as you
said there is a right way to help a church whether they merge uh whether it's an adoption situation or they seek to Foster or be fostered by another church or whatever it might be there are options to still finish well both as a pastor and as a church and so we're not saying that that that can't ever happen but to just sit by idly and let it die while you Coast to the last few years of your career that that's not honoring to the Lord and it's not helpful for you you obviously it's not helpful
for the church yeah absolutely hey thanks for tuning in today thanks Matt McCraw M Kur um just make sure that you spell it right you've dealt with that I feel honored when you say it correctly you know well reneer it's Matt McGraw and Sam reneer is what it is there you go um we we both have dealt with that in different ways um I've been introduced at speaking engagement since Sam reneer and sometimes I'm just like I want to say something because I really don't care but you I like awkward and embarrassing um even when
I'm getting embarrassed and I I'm the awkward one uh I still get kind of get a kick out of it uh but I've never done that I wouldn't do that so anyway it's Matt McCraw uh comma uh we we talked on I think it was on the last episode like what's your title or maybe it's a couple episodes ago and we've just come up with comma because he does so much there's it would be Dean consultant director there's several different things there that have to be so you just call you comma there you go there
we go it fits it almost sounds like the Boy George song comma comma comma come that's a really bad I don't know I want to be compared to Boy George but in any way but you know I'll take I like the comma though it's a catchy song It's a catchy song all right let's talk about our sponsor Tindale they are a sponsor for December when it comes to Bibles I love the New Living Translation I love what they do with the filament Bible app and you need to know about the daily walk Bible this is
a great gift for Christmas this is a great way to start your year um you should get this Bible and walk daily with God immerse yourself in these great devotions that they have and it is filament Bible app enabled which means all that you got to do is scan the little top part of that page and it's going to pull up all of these resources uh written video any number of things that connect to the passage that's on the page it is absolutely brilliant um so anytime I'm buying a New Living Translation Bible and I've
bought several uh because I just love the translation uh I'm always asking the question is it filament enabled um and this one is so it's called The Daily walk Bible your guide to walking daily with God very simple great way to do 2025 for your devotionals we've got a link in the show notes you can also go to tindale's website and just type in Daily walk Bible and it will come right up so we do appreciate you guys tuning in as always we will have an episode for you next week if you're watching on YouTube
give us a thumbs up make a comment if you're in your podcasting app hey give us a review give us a rating would really help us out we'll see you next time