[Music] all right everyone we're going to be talking about money which can be a contentious subject in the church but we're specifically talking about ways that Financial mismanagement can occur so while sensitive this is a very important subject in fact it's always right in front of people when churches publish the numbers for the week typically it's worship attendance and giving Matt my friend Matt who uh is a part of church anwers many of you may not know who Matt is Matt what is your I'm president of the company I don't know what your title is what is your title Sam I'm not sure what my title is either with church answers but I do a lot with Consulting certifications and Partnerships well just put a bunch of commas in your title that's what we'll do um so anyway Matt MCC is not mcra uh not not related to Tim uh there's an extra seat in there is part of our team he's been on the show before but uh some of you may not know him because you don't appear often but you might be seeing a little more of him going forward so uh glad for that uh do you publish my question is do you publish your worship attendance and your giving what what numbers do you put out there for everyone to see we publish our giving we do not publish our worship numbers in the weekly book bulletin uh we do have them in our uh business meetings generally we publish our giving once a month so we update it monthly and our expenses we include our expenses as well giving and expenses so there it is front and center just like a lot of other established churches hey uh I want to talk about uh Church growth Services um they can really help with generosity uh that's kind of pertaining to today's subject matter uh so we'll put a link in the show notes 've got a um a free campaign Capacity Analysis which is really neat so go check that out and I also want to thank our sponsor upward um upward is uh longtime sponsor I guess I can say that now Matt you manage sponsorships too like yeah long time very faithful great sponsor and love working with them when uh we were able to to have them as a sponsor I was uh cheering along because I absolutely love their Ministry it is awesome to be able to support them um now it's November so you should be looking at 2025 at this point they would love to talk to you about creating a sports Ministry in 2025 they can Bridge your church to the community get the question all the time we see it all the time in our Forum right how do I do Outreach in my church and we have some answers that we often give ESL classes fostering and then there's always Upward Sports it's a great way to make that connection so go schedule your call today you can go to upward. org church anwers again upward. org Church aners to do that it's worth the financial investment to tie back to the topic at hand all right but let's talk about financial mismanagement which does happen at times um and some common ways that Financial mismanagement occurs in the church Matt I'm going to put you on the spot have you ever encountered this uh whether it be a church an association at the denominational level have you ever seen Financial mismanagement occur and what was the story yeah so I certainly have and so I I'll keep it sort of vague but on a denominational level uh I saw where a particular organization was defrauded of lots of money because of not double or triple checking uh basically they were scammed so I saw that happened and I've also seen um on just a an unwise level I've seen uh finances handled in several local churches of which I've been a part just not handled in a wise way not necessarily unethical but just where a little more wisdom would have been helpful yeah I think that's a good distinction the difference between unethical and unwise um just because someone made a poor decision and did not exercise wisdom does not necessarily mean that they were maliciously trying to do something and I know that story that you're talking about it was a um it was a link that you that would be used to uh send money and the scammer kind of knew the link and put a uh a link that was uh very similar looking and the page looked identical and so the person that was responsible for punching in the numbers was punching in the numbers to the wrong bank and it was the bank of the scammer yeah that was a terrible sad mistake uh it wasn't uh one that was easy to spot quite honestly but it but it was a mistake yeah that's actually a very difficult one and and pretty rare you don't often see that but in this case it was big money um involved and so it was kind of worth the effort um but uh let's talk about some common ways that mismanagement occurs in the local church I think that's what most uh of our audience is connected to although we do have plenty of denominational people listening check those links make sure you're sending money to the right place um so one way that you see Financial mismanagement occur and again this could be unethical or it could just be unwise uh is uh major spending outside of the budget um this is where the church sets the budget and then somebody in leadership whoever it may be could be a pastor or committee or Elder board starts spending money outside of that budget Matt where where would you say that's most common that major spending outside the budget I would say in the churches I've been a part of that's mostly in deferred maintenance uh things major maintenance projects that were not budgeted and they don't have a deferred maintenance fund something comes up and they have to deal with it yeah I would agree with you and honestly uh in many of those cases you just kind of have to do it I don't know that I would call that Financial mismanagement that may be facility mismanagement budget mismanagement uh you know it's almost like when I just I just got word that we're going to have to uh do mix yourself with the air conditioning project nothing too major and it can be handled the way that we were planning on handling it but my executive Pastor just let me know so I was like yeah we got to spend that money we weren't planning to spend that money but we have to spend that money um you know I've actually seen here this is the case the case that I will uh I gotta be careful what I say but I won't be careful I'll just say it anyway um I know of a church let me put it that way I know of a church not my church uh I know of a church where one of the pastors wanted to feed the entire Community for Thanksgiving like the entire town like turkey dinner or whatever it was I forget the specifics and uh it was a good thought you know hey church is going to be generous and feed the entire Community guess what it wasn't budgeted and they spent and I forget the exact number I don't remember the exact number but it was five figures um well into the five figures 30,000 40,000 50,000 I forget exactly um but it was that expensive just to give everyone a free dinner and the church had not budgeted it so is that unethical well if somebody means harm yes but in this case I think it was just more unwise but certainly mismanagement so if you're going to feed everyone a turkey dinner in your city make sure you budget it next that might that might fall into what we call pastor's pet projects you know something the pastor really wants to accomplish and get it pushed through and it's not budgeted and sometimes they just go go ahead anyhow so we gotta be careful with those I like that pastors pet projects um the next thing is using part of the budget for unintended purposes so the money's there it's in a line item uh that line item has a a specific purpose I'm GNA take this money and I'm going to use it for something else Matt where have you seen that in the church yeah well again pastor's pet projects could fall there as well you know you could say hey we have this money set aside for curriculum uh for the church and you know I'd really like to get a new computer once in a while I view curriculum on my computer so let's use the curriculum budget to buy a new computer you know it's just not what it's intended to be used for so I think we really have to be careful with that because the reality is sometimes in the budgeting process we don't do a good job accounting for everything that we might need and and so we do need to be uh careful on that but we also need to to be wise and follow the budget items that we've that we've set in place yeah so an example of this would be um wow we've grown as a church uh we're just buying a lot more coffee and snacks and Hospitality stuff and oh man the hospitality budget is not nearly what we need it to be and we've got our big church dinner coming up so you know our volunteers dinner or whatever so we're going to pull from uh children's ministry because they've got a few little extra funds well the proper thing to do there is to just run over your budget and account for it to just show that you went over a budget is a guide and you know granted there are some Churches like ours that you're not really supposed to spend over your budget um unless you have permission uh but you know you could just say hey we realize that we're going to be spending more here we're doing the Lord's Supper more often so we're spending more on Lord's Supper supplies uh so you run over on that budget so that the next year you know what to budget um so don't be moving things around in the budget to even out all the budget line items and I think lots of churches do that yeah just a real life example Sam uh at the time of this recording we're just a little past our trunk r Treat at our church and we had more people than we expected we had to go buy a lot more candy on the the spot and one of our other pastors mentioned hey we're at budget for this I said well we'll just go over budget rather than trying to take it from somewhere else we'll go over budget uh we've got the blessing of the stewardship committee to do that and it will help us budget better next year another way that Financial mismanagement occurs is by hiding personal expenses so let me tell you one way that this happens frequently and if you're doing this you need to stop um but I realize that you may not be doing it maliciously um so I have a budget for taking people out for like lunch and dinner um and the church has been very gracious West Bron's been very gracious to know hey all the new people you're going to want to take them out you know person who's thinking about joining the church um let's let's do lunch let's do dinner and they provide me it's not a big budget but it's enough to get you know to go out to several lunches and dinners a year um on occasion I will take my family um um and I try to remember to reimburse the church for that part because I really should not be charging I should not be including my family in that expense that is a personal expense now very rarely is my family with me at these meetings sometimes my wife comes and I really do work hard to kind of pull that out uh a rare occurrence is not a big deal in this but if you are regularly taking people out for lunch on Church money which is a fine thing to do you really shouldn't be including your family and particular if they're there a lot uh it would be better to strip that out um but that's a small thing but that's one way that personal expenses can get hidden in the budget yeah I would I would say also another way would be conferences you know just going on a conference paying for certain things while you're gone sometimes we may think well this will just blend in with all the expenses but that's not a healthy way for us to think that can lead us quickly into unethical practices so I think having a good paper trail and win in doubt pay for it yourself is my rule of thumb yeah this next uh way that Financial mismanagement occurs in the church is by um burying unnecessary expenses in vague line items um there's a uh there's a documentary out there right now on a famous mega church pastor and I don't want to get into too much detail about it but that is whether true or not that is the accusation of him that you have this big fund that money goes in it and we're not it's a vague line item and we're not quite sure what comes out of it either and in this case they're claiming millions of dollars uh I think for most of our listeners it's like yeah my church would never let me spend millions of dollars in a vague line item but uh Matt do you do you have any experience here like what's what's something that may come to mind is like hey don't bury that in a vague line it don't be clear about it well actually Sam we just fixed this we went through the budgeting process this uh this past month at my church and we just fixed an issue we've had for a few years we had a category it was actually labeled uncategorized expenses and I said we cannot keep the label uncategorized expenses on a budget line item we have to label it as something and so we set ourselves up for that really it was used mostly for Bank fees and so I said why don't we name it Bank fees you know or something like that online transaction fees and so yeah we've had experience with that and there was a time when we used uh someone made a um request and we took an expense out of there that was just nowhere else to take it and I thought that's not the best practice so we've tried to do better in our own church in that regard so let's talk about solving these problems you know major spending outside the budget using part of the budget for unintended purposes uh hiding personal expenses burying unnecessary expenses and vague line items what do you do to solve this and I think the first step is just very simple have a consistent process you know just if you want to change your process change it just be clear that you're changing it and stick to it whatever you say you're going to do you should do Matt what's your what's your budget process look like yes so we have a a stewardship committee and our stewardship committee works with our financial secretary to kind of see where our spending is we look at the process um we see if we need to make any adjustments our pastors speak into that the stewardship committee approves it then the church approves it with discussion and so that's our normal budgeting process and then if we go above and beyond the budget um if it's a $500 expenditure or less the pastors can approve that without getting special permission if it's above that we speak to our Treasurer and our stewardship committee chairman and then if it's above $10,000 the church has to approve it if it's beyond the budget if it's under $110,000 the stewardship committee can approve it those are some of our general guidelines we go by pretty good guidelines we have we have similar ones as well um another way to solve this problem is just to have multiple checks by multiple people so we never have money is never alone with anyone children are never alone with anyone in our church and money is never alone with anyone in our church so anytime we have somebody counting transporting uh anytime money needs to go in and out of accounts there's always two sets of eyes on it we do have a bookkeeper um who uh sits down at a computer and works through things but then we have a treasure and a stewardship committee that goes back and double checks to make sure that everything is done the treasure is in bookkeepers office quite often uh just to make sure that uh all processes were followed uh and I'm very grateful for uh the the tight processes that we have at West Bradon multiple checks by multiple people Matt is that something that you guys do as well yeah we do that as well honestly Sam we're trying to do better with uh no money alone with people in years past we were short on volunteers and if you know the offering had to be counted somebody would take it down to the office and I and I we've tried to do better there I said we can't be alone with money so we're trying to follow that process as well the other thing I would add to that is not only having the policies but knowing the policies a lot of churches have great policies but people don't know what they are are they haven't seen them in a while and they may not follow them so I think it's important to to keep them in front of your people as well yeah and then another solution is just transparent reporting um you know it boggles my mind how many churches don't produce like quarterly financial statements I don't know that monthly is necessary I think that's fine if you're producing a monthly financial statement and providing it to your people that's excellent I don't know that everyone wants to see it every month maybe some do but at least quarterly you should be putting something out there and and not just the fancy smancy pie charts that everyone has and look at what we did and those are great you know I think that you should absolutely Champion your cause with those very fancy uh booklets that people put out they're very impressive but man just put out your financial statements people should be able to see every line item and uh you know what came in what went out uh where you are in the budget um at a bare minimum a profit and loss statement we actually do a balance sheet and a profit and loss statement every quarter for our church I don't know if that's necessary but Matt do you do do you do a balance sheet as well what do you do yeah so we we developed a simple uh we call it the treasurers report and we have that every month for our stewardship committee and then once a quarter for the church now we do make it very clear if you want to come in and see it every week you're certainly welcome to do that but we provide it in print once a quarter we simplified it it's only two pages the reason is we found with some of the balance sheets profit and loss reports some of our folks couldn't read them they had no idea what they were looking at so we offered a simple version and we still have the more complicated more thorough version available yeah and I think you're on to something uh We've encountered that as well we've had to simplify our financial statements uh only because there are a lot of people that don't know how how to read them um hey while we're talking about you know simplifying something that can be complicated uh check out brown church Development Group uh they do Master planning and they can certainly help with your facility so I would encourage you to reach out to them uh if you're thinking about master planning and putting that in your budget if it's not something that you've ever done before hey Now's the Time if you have time to put it in your budget put it in there give them a call uh they are awesome at what they do and so they can help you on the facility side uh while you're thinking about the financial side so transparent reporting uh is always a good thing and again if you want to change your process change it if you want to do something different do something different just tell people what you're doing and tell them why you're doing it and most times it's uh it's going to be fine last thing here all right how do you solve this problem of financial mismanagement again a lot falls on just leadership accountability um just making sure that there are clear ways that people are held accountable to do what they're supposed to be doing uh one of the things that I do as a lead Pastor is I have zero access to any of the funds I have zero access to the books um I don't see who gives what uh I realize there are different perspectives on that and they good perspectives on either side whether you should know what people give or not uh at my church I I get reports and I get ideas of people but I don't get a name and an amount um I never see that um we just went through a hurricane so an example here I got a list of people that gave to the Hurricane fund both inside and outside the church so I'm gonna write them all a handwritten note uh but I don't I didn't see what they gave um so I think it's good to just understand lead Pastor executive Pastor staff Elders what are they seeing what are they not seeing why and how do how do we make sure that they're being held accountable to those standards Matt I'm sure you're similar there too yeah so we have a policy see even with even with two pastors together we still we don't handle money we don't take money we have dropboxes so we have a no pastors touching money policy very similar to you in terms of knowing who gives and and and how much I don't really know much of that sometimes folks will tell me I just had someone recently they sent some money in from an investment they wanted to make sure I knew it was coming just so we could look for it things like that but generally I I don't know I would also say sam just this goes not only for for past and staff but just for anyone we should never be defensive to answer questions about money or how we handle money we should be totally open we should we should be just totally transparent totally humble totally willing to answer any question we should not hide anything when it comes to money of course Jesus warned us about the dangers of money and so we need to take that seriously and we need to be above board with with finances for sure yeah and um we actually have a module on this in a new resource called make my church safe so go to Makey churchs safe.
com and uh it's it's a comprehensive training for church safety But it includes financial management um so there's a module in it for that uh that your financial team can review it's got everything else too that you would need for church safety uh but financial management is part of that and you certainly don't want to mismanage things financially so check things out it maky churchs safe. com and we also want to thank our sponsor California Baptist University University uh they've got a full breadth of courses through their online degrees also a beautiful campus if you want to go in person uh so you can learn more about them at calbaptist that's calbaptist. edu uh they've got a great online bachelor's degree in Christian Ministries which I really like so um if that's something that you are more than interested in or even if just partially interested in you should still reach out to them calbaptist.