[Music] you guys we are now recording and I just want to tell youall you'all need to listen to instructions she said do that at the end and y'all started doing it right then so please listen to our producer smile at the end for the thumbnail shots we are live and I do apologize for all of our listeners uh that was a carryover intro that my father just decided to do so yes our producer Lana who does a very good job has instructed us how our faces need to look because thumbnails get on YouTube when we do this right and I'm I'm I'm the worst offender I have no expression most of the time well now we make faces at each other and we make her choose really awful looking pictures I know you're going to introduce the sponsor in just a moment before we start hearing the wonderful pontif ation of Ryan Burge but I I got I got to tell you this this content is something that I have been looking forward to this online church or the online worship service man he is going to peel back the layers and we're going to see reality this may not be your most widely read article that you uh wrote about Ryan but it was it has been my favorite um it's just just my personal favorite uh because it uh revealed a lot of things that I was feeling and kind of love confirmation thought but now I have data behind it and so now I get to say well I actually know this for a fact because DrRyan bird showed me the facts so we're going to be talking about online Church who attends and who's tuning in and all of my speculation was proven right by Ryan so it's always a good thing but before we get into today's episode we certainly want to thank our sponsor tidle tidley has been very generous uh to pay our bills for us um and to have this show together um tidle provides churches around the world with all sorts of software tools I am sure that they have something for you if uh you happen to be in the market for any sort of system operation that your church needs whether it be text to give managing people's information volunteer management check in check out they do it all they've got church apps they do websites um and they're you know they're a team of ministry minded people that love the local church so get this you can go to tile. com and sign up for free tile's platform comes with no monthly fees or contracts so you can get started taking donations at tile. com they also have a great state of the church giving report that you can check out in the show notes of today's episode it's a free download as well uh so thank you tidle and all of you listeners go to tile.
com and a shout out to Dean Sweetman shout out to Dean Sweetman the CEO of tidley our good friend who uh has just done so much for us we greatly appreciate the te indeed Ryan um when you wrote this I was like this is gold this information is so important every church out there thinks that when they post digitally that the community at large is tuning in to their services but that's not the case tell us what's going on oh I just give you an anecdote I there's a big church somewhere in Kentucky that uh some of my former High School classmates work at now and they post on Facebook and I go on their YouTube channel to like see what they're up to they have an entire online campus I looked at one of their videos YouTube had 48 views 48 views and I'm like they they have like a whole staff I mean I bet you they spent $100,000 on equipment for this whole thing and and and and and and Guys West Bron level that's like how many people are tuning in to me a look out we're actually more than that we're our views getting a few hundred toot toot to horn look at you you're so successful well I think that's the problem is like and and the more you live in this online space cuz like listen I'm one of those guys who goes and looks at metrics because I'm a data guy and my own stuff and other stuff you realize that everyone's producing content but almost no one's consuming said content it's like that it's like a 90 9010 principle like 10% of the content is consumed by 90% of the people you know like it's very few getting a whole lot and most people don't get any I think that's very much the case when it comes to online worship and so here's here's how I think this happened as best I can before covid there were some Churches larger churches kind of those non them those younger churches like let's go heavy online let's invest in a production team and cameras and yada y y and they built up these huge online followings I think we all know we're talking about here Life Church and elevation and Joel 's deal those kind of places right there were probably 30 or 40 like big ones then covid happened and every Church in America is like holy cow we've got to figure out a way to stream our services online so you know they spent a little bit of money maybe you know a couple thousand dollars getting better cameras and better streaming and Bing Bang Boom now they're online a lot of people were well not a lot of people some people were watching online because they couldn't go in person because of covid and now they still see that 20 or 30 people log on and watch the service because they kept it going and now they don't know what to do right do we continue to put the man-hours behind that and the money and the time and the energy behind that keeping that stream going on are We growing this big online community should we shut it off should we invest more resources in it how do we like build a community with our just our online people and I think the data points to a to a solution where it's Man online church is probably never ever going to even come close to what in-person Gathering is and for most churches it's probably not a great use of their time and resources and when you look at online Church you have to ask the question how much of that is really the church I know that that's a deep theological question but how much of church is supposed to be incarnate how much is supposed to be you're supposed to be there there are a lot of liberal Scholars arguing that even atheistic liberal Scholars that are saying we want the church back we want the religious community back and we want them to come together because they're seeing the benefit of and you've talked about this in terms of a lot of organizations Ryan but we want to see them come together in person because that's where the benefit is and we're seeing particularly for this Gen Y generation that uh is a lot of nuns a lot of nuns let me just tell you there's empirical evidence there was a paper that was just published about six months ago question psychological distress what predicts psychological distress or lower psychological distress uh they looked at church attendance no matter how much you attended online there was no difference in your psychological distress but amongst people who attended in-person church on a weekly basis there was a lower level of psychological distress amongst that group wow so going to church only in person relieves some psychological distress and helps with mental illness going online has no demonstrable impact on your mental health and that's why I tell people like it's not this is not just like I prefer something it's the data tells us that online is a poor substitute for in-person Gathering whether it be by the way religious or non-religious but especially in the religious space we talk about you know communing together and being in one space and the embodiment of what that means I just don't think that online worship should be seen as a full substitute for what it means to gather together on a regular basis but you you do like it as a something that points to something else and I think that's an important point though like so who is watching online church that's a really important question and here's what I found the people who attend inperson more are more likely to also watch online services okay like there's this term in consumer uh economics about like super heavy users these are like people who cannot get enough of a certain type of content like they'll watch eight or 10 hours a day like this is an example of super heavy users we're talking about people who go to church multiple times a week in person so means Sunday Gathering but also midweek Bible study and maybe something else they're also watching a ton of religious services online too so they might go to First Baptist Church of you know Jonesboro Arkansas but then on Tuesday they're watching elevation or they're watching Joel oin they're watching TD Jake they're watching somebody else so it's not like it's the online Church is drawing in people who don't go in person it's actually just giving those super heavy users more content to consume I mean we can talk yeah but like we can talk about is it objectively good or bad I got no strong feelings about that but like I'm a big believer in Orthodoxy and orthopraxy like both matter right belief matters but also right Behavior matters nearly as much and if all you're doing is watching church services every day all day and you're not serving your community seems kind of bad you know like we should motivates you to go into the mission field and do things not just watch another another worship service after we're done hey the heavy the heavy users Nelly Joe you haven't met Nell Jo Joe my wife his mother oh boy yes you'll meet her in in Bradon very soon uh Nelly Joe is a heavy user of online services so this is an example we were at West brington we heard sound prge we're driving somewhere else she's on her phone watching service I said which service are you watching oh the one we just came from and and and I said why because don't you know he is the best preacher in God's creation right there with his brother Jess so there's an online user that's probably not your subsample though your wife is not my only by the way people attend church more than once a week or 60% of them watch Church online at least once a week as well so think about that wow you're going multiple times a week in person and most of you are also watching online so that I think that also distorts too because this is the thing I hear oh our view count or like the number of people we have log in is D du and it's like 10,000 or whatever and you're like okay you cannot create that's not an equivalent of 10,000 people in the butts and seats it just does not work that way it's passive versus active it's how many minutes they were there like you I there's no way to create a metric that that evens the scale between inperson worship and online attendance like you you and I think a lot of times these algorithms will will inflate numbers in such a way that make you feel like you're doing a lot better than what you are like I mean like I've done certain media appearances where like oh I'm going to get a a big bump on my side like in terms of views and you know follows and subscribers and you don't even see it you know I mean so I think there's there's a lot of like smoking mirrors going on here too I think a lot of churches are just stuck because they're going oh we got 300 people that log on online we can't turn it off but it takes a lot of time and effort and all these people are watching and it's like are you sure they're actually watching like I'm not entirely convinced that you're actually providing the service that you think you are you know you bring up something very important because when we consult churches we just did one recently won't get into all the details here but they told us their attendance was at a a certain level let's just say a thousand you know that's roughly where they were um and then we go and we visit on on like in in their service and it's 3400 you go where are the rest of the we 600 people well that's our online attendance well how are you counting your online attendance well we're taking our views and we're multi multiplying them by a factor of two and a half because we assume or three and a half the multiplier effect or three and a half or whatever it is yeah we'll just say two and a half because that's a pretty common multiplier we're just assuming that there are more people on that screen watching it and it's like you have you that is a terrible way to count your attendance because of the things that you have revealed here the the view is actually now some people live stream so they know that those views are not butts in the seats because they're watching the same time that people are there but for a lot of people that are counting views it's people viewing it afterwards and in our case we pre-produce our services so it's a lot of our own people that are watching you know I didn't catch that one part of a sermon so I want to rewatch it you know in the service that's online and uh I I'm gonna call this Dad I'm gonna name this phenomenon and I'm gonna call it the mar the Margaret effect the the Miss Margaret effect Miss Margaret and she's listening right now so hey Margaret we love you um absolutely Ryan loves you too she's a super she's a super consumer you know she will come to church she's there every week she's there anytime the doors are open but she's also watching so we post our pre-produce service on Saturday night so she's watching that before she comes to church she may watch it again after church she then Tunes over to Jess I don't know if you know this Dad but she goes home and she watches my brother Jess preach um and uh you know then she's back at church serving again now am I glad that our content is being consumed in that way by our own people absolutely I think it's wonderful but we have to know what it's doing when you're posting your content out there and you get a 100 views or whatever it is on a sermon a large portion of that is Miss Margaret it's your mom it's the person that missed that point in the sermon they want to double check again it's a great tool it's a wonderful thing you're not reaching the community with your online services though and I think that's the important part here stop counting them as attendees in your church they were already there they were there on Sunday and stop assuming that you've got this Mass audience out there because it's more than likely your own people can I give you an analogy to the tech World about this please podcasts okay podcast advertising rates were Skyhigh for a long time because you could go to advertis say we've got this many downloads of our podcast per week because Apple podcast used to automatically you know there's a queue you could automatically download episodes when they came out every morning when you're on Wi-Fi that way when you're traveling you could have them on your thing you know what they did not count how many people actually listen to the episode so they were basically selling advertisers on this listeners ship that was eight 10 times the multiple of what it actually was and now they have better technology that will actually tell you like when people dropped off from the podcast and so now avatarer rates have plunged in the podcast world because the actual number of listeners is a fraction of what we thought it was for a while I think this same thing applies to like viewing thing you know viewing Church streams we overinflate it when really we should probably be like a tenth of those numbers the actual number and I think that that's I think listen you've got to think who's selling you this stuff and if it's like we've got new video equipment you know like this is how many how many streams people get when they go upgrade to our equipment and our technology guys like I think the reality is whatever number you think you're getting online like real honest to goodness people who engage every week in a meaningful way is probably a tenth of what you think it is let's just be real about this that's what we hear from the 23 million who listen to each of our podcasts that uh hey there there's not 50 million there's only 23 million only 23 million that's rookie numbers got to up those numbers well that with you here it'll continue to increase and yes yeah that's why we have Ryan because we we have now realized what our real numbers are and we've got to get them back up get back up by the way can I mention the fact that even young people don't prefer they don't prefer online worship like the whole thing like digital native thing like that's that's the argue oh young people love being online they're online all the time the question was um do you prefer in person do you prefer online or do you not have a preference these are people who went once a at least once a month on both both so they actually have like a you know they have a good comparison group amongst the youngest adults 18 to 29 67% said they prefer in person 19% said they prefer online and 14% had no preference wow so twoth thirds of young people say they prefer the in-person worship and amongst people who were the 65 and up 86% of them preferred in person and 3% of them preferred online so like it's it's bad amongst young adults it's terrible amongst the oldest adults like you cannot find a group of people a significantly sized group of people who really will say I'll go to church online for the rest of my life and it's G to be great it but it's such a conven excuse if you're not showing up oh I'm watching it online that's what it has become but let me let me make this point though and I I know there's people online who are listening to this right now saying well I cannot physically come to worship I hear you I see you and I understand understand you okay and I do think the the move to online has been very beneficial for that sub segment of the population that's without a doubt but what's happened though is people who should be there in person are coming online because it's easier in economics there's this concept called friction right you want to have as least amount of friction as you possibly can for people to make a certain kind of decision and you know what if my choice between going online or going in person which one has more friction going in person does because I got to get dressed and drive my car and show up and all that stuff so here's what you should do here's just a suggestion try this out don't publish your streams easily on social media and YouTube Right make people email someone at the church to get a link that they can use to access the stream on some website that's not publicly available because radical I know right because what that's going to do is if I'm genuinely a Shu in or I'm on vacation or I'm sick I've got no problem emailing the secretary and asking for the link because I need it you know I really need it for my own reasons but if I'm just lazy that's going to create enough friction that I'm not GNA want to email because I'm gonna feel guilty about it and I'll be much more likely to show up because I can't watch the stream online so create an impediment between those kind of people and the stream and you might have a list of people who automatically get the link every Sunday because they're genuinely shuttin makes their life easy but you've got to rethink how you distribute this this this this link and this video stream and this information because now you're making it super easy for people to not show up and you should be the opposite it should be you know what I mean like go coming in person should be easier than coming online and right now it's nowhere close that's radical I think we can I think we can also say that our how this isn't just a matter of who's really tuning in it's also a matter of how well you're tuning in while you're watching now clearly people are on their phones in the Ser in in the inperson services too but I know myself myself and I know how well I pay attention when I've got something just on the screen particularly like a church service and even if you're tuning into the whole video the like it's it's easier to tune out than if you are in person so I think that there's some real practical things here when it comes to why iners is more important than like a an online service but there's some theological considerations here too that you know it's really not the purpose of our show to get to get into all the theology um that's just not what we do here but I personally have an ecclesiological conviction that church is meant to be in person uh there may be those who disagree with me on that but that's fine um but I do think that theologically it's better for you spiritually if you're there in person not online um so we've got super consumers that's who's really tuning in um you're likely not reaching the community uh because unchurched why would they watch church service you know it's like it's the whole we're the we're the church for the unchurched it's like no no you're not you're just marketing to Baby Boomers who think that's cool um you know that's all you're doing we we we're all the unchurched people are tuning in to us well that means they're churched they're not no longer unchurched so listen here's the definition I created right you watch online services once a week but you report in-person worship Gathering once a year or less okay what percentage of the entire sample meets that criteria they go to church in person once a year or less but they go to online worship every week it is less than 5% of America wow less than 5% of America which is probably your Shu inss and people who like can't get out you know and if you look at the demographics here's what they look like in terms of age they tend to be older about 70% of that group are 50 and up okay so they they lean older which would make sense from a shut in perspective um they also are more likely to be on the lower end of the educational Spectrum okay 43% of them have a high school diploma or less compared to 35% of the general population so slightly less educated and it's actually from in terms of race African-Americans are twice as likely to be virtual attenders as all African-Americans in the entire sample so like the mix is older lower educated African-Americans those are a huge chunk of your 4. 8% your your online only attenders so I don't know who you think they are in your head it's not the youths if you think this is like some sort of like program to bring in the The Generation Z people you are failing miserably at that like this should be the opposite of what you should be doing and by the way you're seeing this on service a lot of young people are realizing the screens are ruin their lives like they're really like there there's a backlash coming I feel like amongst younger generations of being a little less online because they've grown up online I don't think they want to go to church online and I think you're going to see if you think that's your your youth strategy you should try any literally anything else would be better than that as a youth strategy now okay can I give you one example of one way online might be a good idea if you have a large shuin community like and you really want to grow that community and there are people there's people who are socially isolated is that better than than them not having online Church it absolutely is is it a lot better it's absolutely not but I think you need to you need to join that coming in every Sunday that that the Shon Community watching online you need to have a pastor or someone on staff who goes out to them on a regular basis and talk you know has like a one-h hour meeting counseling with each of them just to connect them to the larger church that's a lot of work I think that's one area where I would say if you want to lean into online the data says that that is a way that could be successful and productive both from a social science perspective but also a pastoral you know religious perspective as well that's the new senior senior Adult Ministry could be I mean to me that you get I like when retired pastors like want to still do a little bit of pastoring so they'll do like visitation Ministry like to me that's an ideal person to do something like that is just pop in once a month you know what I mean and and say hello and have lunch or whatever it is that's a way to create Community with that group because they genuinely can't come you know they just they can't get there physically I think for everyone else it just doesn't make a whole lot of sense to devote a lot of time and resources to creating online Church fascinating stuff Sam yes and indeed again you can learn more about what Ryan is talking about in the written form at graphs about religion. com that's where his substack is you need to be a paying subscriber this is stuff that you can use a ton it's very practical it's data driven it's the facts and you can count on Ryan to give you the facts you can also count on tidle to give you incredible service around Church Management Systems whether it be giving or check-in whether it be volunteer management or communicating with your church tile can help you they do websites too they they probably do a lot more than you realize they're known for their texting they're known for their giving modules and all of those are great they service 40,000 churches around the world uh the reason it's so many is because they're really good at what they do and they would be glad to serve you so you can sign up for free at tile.
com they've got a giving platform that has no monthly fees and no contracts can't beat that so go to tile.