[Music] you're listening to the sspx podcast and welcome to our fifth episode on the sacraments where father david sherry will join us to look at the sacrament of penance many people even non-catholics are familiar with the sacrament but we'll take a magnifying glass to it today so that we can understand more about what's going on to do that we'll start by Looking at the concept of sin itself this may seem almost obvious but sin does exist it's the whole reason for the sacrament and then we'll take a look at the two players involved the penitent
and the priest what is father looking for when he asks us those questions in the confessional and why do we have to do a penance afterwards aren't our sins already forgiven father sherry will walk us through the traditional form of the Sacrament of penance next as we move forward in the series we're looking for help if you like these series and want to have more of them you can help us by leaving a rating or a review wherever you're listening to this podcast and please share it with someone who you think would like it or
appreciate it or maybe they just need it it's the best way to help you're helping us with this apostolate to reach as many people as possible with the beauty and The truth of what it means to be a traditional catholic now let's join father sherry or episode number five of our sacrament series right now father sherry thank you for joining us it is uh you we were just talking a little bit beforehand because our connection is not quite perfect today because it's snowing where you are shocking i'm shocked it's snowing anyway thank you for joining
us um today we are Talking about the sacrament of penance um and like we've done with previous episodes we're going to be looking first at the traditional rite of penance and then next week looking at the new right of the sacrament of penance or reconciliation as it's called um today where do we start with our discussion on penance on the sacrament itself should we start by looking at sin or start by Looking at the priests or the minister or where would you like to start father thank you very much andrew for having me on again
today and i think we should start with looking at sin because the sacrament of penance is the sacrament by which sins committed after baptism are washed away by the blood of the redeemer just as sins committed before baptism and original sin Are washed away in the sacrament of baptism so what exactly is sin uh because there's a lot of different different ideas about what sin is um now we know that from our catechism that sin is a disobedience to god's law but what does that mean does that mean that sin is simply contravening a whole
list of things Which which god has made up out of nothing as it were so god says okay i'm gonna i'm gonna make a list of things and if you uh contravene these you're gonna have sinned i'm going to punish you but actually these things are not actually necessary let's say for your happiness that's the theory of satan you'll remember how in the book of Genesis at the beginning [Music] eve explained to the serpent which was the devil either under the form of a fake serpent or else inhabiting a true serpent um eve explained well
god told us not to eat of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and satan came out with one of the Biggest lies ever told in in history when he said well the reason why god has told you to do that is because he knows that if you do eat of this fruit you will be as gods in other words the prohibition on certain things is done by an evil god who wants to stop us from being happy and that's the lie which has come down Through the ages you'll be
happy if you can sit but in reality what sin is it is indeed a disobedience to god's law but god's law is like um it's almost like a user manual when you think of creating something let's say you make a car andrew and um you say okay i've made a fairly nice car it's uh it's it's a good car it works but there are a number of things you Need to do and not do so for example if you want your car to run well you have to put gasoline in the gas tank however it
would be a no-no to fill the gasoline tank with peanut butter it's not going to work if you do that and you see how that rule which you the creator of the car have laid down uh is simply uh following the nature of the car and so god created man and he being the creator plays down a User manual if you do this you will work well and if you do that then uh you will you'll mess yourself up and that's effectively what the ten commandments are they're the natural law which is the law of
how our nature works if you want to work well to be happy first of all adore the true god give him the worship that he deserves respect his name and then Uh respect uh the laws of human nature regarding your neighbor and that's the the other seven commandments uh respect your parents respect authority respect your neighbor don't uh take his life don't take his wife don't take his goods don't take his good name and don't desire to do these things because the desire will lead to the sin and [Music] the the the nature of sin
then is not some sort of taboo the catholic religion is the one religion where there are no taboos a taboo is a rule for which there is no real reason so for example you could argue that it is a taboo to drive on the right side of the road but of course it's not a taboo at all There's a reason for that if everybody chooses for himself which side of the road to drive on then we're going to have many many accidents and so the rule drive on the right side of the road is a
rule which has a real reason behind it however on the other side you could say well it is forbidden for me to wear orange the law lays down you cannot wear orange clothes Is there a reason for that no it's just uh the the ruler decided that uh you know he didn't like orange and so you're not allowed to wear orange now that's a taboo and in the catholic religion there are no taboos all of the laws of god and the commandments of the church are all there for a reason and so that's why sin
in fact is a disobedience to god's law but it's when you deviate from the rule And the rule of our actions is double there's a there's two rules there's a remote rule and there's a proximate rule so there's one rule which is close to us and that rule simply is right reason and so if you do something unreasonably that's a sin uh for example if i were to decide that i really like uh the dog that you have andrew um i Want your dog and so i help myself when i'm passing your house one night
get they get a couple of juicy bones out to attract the dog into my truck and off i go with your dog well it's not bad for me to like your dog it's not bad for me to give a dog a home but it is bad and unreasonable for me to take your dog and so that's a sin and so a sin is a deviation from the right rule it's what aristotle said to miss the Mark it's you're aiming at living a good life you're aiming at doing good actions and you miss that's a sin
now the rule is double however because the thing about my reason is that i'm quite apt to get it wrong you may be familiar with the book written by saint thomas more called utopia in which he lays down the story of this Mythical land uh utopia in which there is the ideal civilization but in this land there is no knowledge of the true god there is rather a natural knowledge of god and because of that their reason which seems to guide everything that they do in fact leads them to do things which are bad for
example in utopia there is Euthanasia you kill off those who are too sick to survive there is also a situation whereby encouraging your enemy to kill himself his ruler is a good thing and you see how what saint thomas moore was trying to do was to try to show that reason will only bring you so far if if you have only reason and you use It with the best of intentions you will end up doing all sorts of things which are absolutely terrible and that's why he describes this totalitarian state which is utopia best of
intentions terrible consequences good consequences in some ways but terrible consequences in other ways because reason needs to be guided by god and that's the remote rule of our actions it is god the author of nature And god the revealer of truth and so my reason needs to be conformed to god and if i have those things then my actions are good but if i miss the mark i have sin and sin is uh an evil now let me just introduce a little distinction here uh for our listeners who probably know it already but it's the
difference between grave sin mortal Sin and venial sin so a mortal sin is called mortal because it kills the life of the soul the life of the soul is god and we are united to god in baptism by sanctifying grace which renders our soul god-like and makes us share in god's own life now a mortal sin is something which is a grave gravesim that is a serious matter and It's also something that i must have full knowledge in doing and full consent in doing so for example if i were to have a small matter i
tell a little lie so for example i was a little ashamed that i didn't put out the garbage for collection this morning and my wife asks me did you put out the garbage and i say yeah that's a that's a lie it's it's a sin but it's a Venial sin because it's not a grave matter however if i were to go to court and there in the court the judge were to ask me did you see this man commit the crime and i did see him but i'm scared of witnessing to that or i have
some sort of iron in the fire that i need to protect and i say no i did not see him commit the crime that Would be a grave sin because it's a grave matter and so a mortal sin is one in which there is a grave matter but also i need full knowledge i have to know that is a serious sin there was a case in england about uh 10 years ago or so andrew where a man killed his wife during the night they were in a in a caravan an rv and during the night
She must have turned in her sleep and he in his sleep thought that he was being attacked and he killed her and in the morning he woke up and he found the body of his dead wife and he was promptly arrested by the police because obviously he had killed his wife but when the case came to court the judge said that he was innocent because He didn't know what he was doing he had a history of sleepwalking there was no evidence whatsoever that he didn't get on with his wife in fact they were very happy
together but he did a grave matter he killed his wife but it wasn't a grave city because he didn't know what he was doing in fact it wasn't a sin at all because he was asleep um and then finally full consent you have to want to do it so let's say i Force somebody to commit a sin a mortal sin they know that it's a mortal sin but i force them to do it then it's not actually a grave sin for them here's a counter example of that whereby something which isn't a grave sin if
i think it is is in fact a mortal sin for me in the life of saint john bosco he tells the story of the boy who looked at the moon What happened here was that a young boy was told by an older boy that it's a mortal sin to look at the moon and he believed him and this is obviously wrong of the older boy we should never tell children that something is evil when it isn't but the younger boy really believed him and so he didn't look at the moon and then one day one
night rather there was uh one of these uh super moons when the moon seemed Enormous and the boy cracked and he looked at the moon and then he said to himself well that was really stupid i should never have committed that mortal sin and so he didn't confess this sin but he thought it was a sin and he had full consent for doing it and he never confessed it and so he lived in that state until he came to die and he went to confession to say john Bosco we only know this because afterwards he
told st john bosco the story outside of confession this is because of the seal of confession which we'll come to later uh the boy explained that he had looked at the moon and said john bosco said and so what he thought it was a sin and so the full consent which we must have to commit a mortal sin uh he had for this thing which was not a mortal Sin and so saint john moscow was able to absolve him from his sins and to tell him that it wasn't a sin and he was able to
die in the state of grace and so you see that immortals in them something which turns us away from god is a grave matter in which i need full knowledge and i have to have full consent so this is this is the the background for for sin and obviously There needs to be some sort of a remedy which gets us to our next point about about the redeemer about about our lord uh coming to redeem us i maybe i'll ask it now father i i was thinking of asking it after we talk about our lord's
redemption um but before our lord came before the the redemption before the incarnation was there any sort of a remedy in the old testament for sin this is a little bit of a tangent i we didn't talk about Discussing this at all but it's something that i've been curious about right so in the old testament uh original sin clearly infected all of those who were born descendants of adam and the the way for them to be able to be saved before the coming of the redeemer was through faith in the redeemer to come and this
was done or passed through the The ceremony uh in the jewish people of circumcision and outside of the jewish people by what the fathers of the church refer to as a remedy of nature okay so um the the god does not um sort of give this Possibility of redemption to some only but every single human being has the possibility of being saved now before the coming of our lord grace did not flow as abundantly but grace nevertheless was possible for those born before him to be saved um in short let's imagine someone who committed a
mortal sin before the coming of the redeemer in short he would have to believe in the Redeemer to come and have true sorrow perfect contrition for his sin before he died in order for him to be able to go to limbo to await the coming of the redeemer okay interesting well thank you for that for that side note for that tangent um but yes let's let's talk about uh the redemption and how that plays a part in in the sacrament of penance father Right so we have seen uh original sim which is passed out was
from adam we have our own sins we have almost the the sins of our of our fathers which are passed out to us not regarding their guilt but regarding the example and the uh the culture the uh perhaps in some some Times even a sort of uh inherent um an inherent tendency towards sin which is passed down to us and what is god's reaction to all of this well god is merciful and so he decrees that man will be redeemed now this did not happen for the angels The angels sinned but god did not decree
their redemption and the reason for that was not because god was not merciful but because the angel is irredeemable when he does something he does it completely with full knowledge of the consequences and without any of the weakness or ignorance which may excuse some of our sins or lessen the guilt of some of our sins and so as saitama said whatever an angel does he does Holy he does with all of his being and so the sin of the angel could not be undone because of the angel himself but the sin of man could be
undone and so god decreed that god the son the second person of the blessed trinity would become man and would undo the damage done by sin Now there are different theories about how this happens and there's two false theories i'd like to mention one is the false theory of luther so martin luther was a catholic priest and he came up with his own theory of how this would happen and he said human nature is completely corrupt because of original sin we're not able to do good And so even after we are redeemed even after we
are justified we're still not able to do good and so he said sin is like it's like a dung heap so it's it's something you know nasty and then during the winter as as it's happening uh as it's happening throughout uh canada at the moment uh the snow comes and the snow is beautiful and white and it covers the dung heap so that your sin is no longer visible And this is the justice of christ which is imputed on the sinner god chooses to ignore the sin and he looks rather at the justice of christ
which is the snow not the dunghill which is our sins and this is a false theory which has very far-reaching consequences of course you perhaps saw some of the consequences in the black lives matter uh Affair of a couple of years ago effectively you could put it down to protestant theology it is that uh and i'm not clearly getting into all of the ins and outs of of american history here but basically it was well the sins of the fathers are passed down to the children and there's nothing you can do but you are guilty
of racism and that's a very protestant theory which is well The we are all infected by original sin true and there's nothing you can do you will continue to do bad works all that you can have is have the justice of someone else imputed upon you this is a false theory because it means that we're still corrupt we're not capable of doing good which led luther to famously say sin boldly but believe yet more boldly in other words you can sit away but as Long as you believe you will be saved um i forget who
it was to come up with a very a very funny limerick about that he said at wittenberg when luther had quitted a young man said now i have hit it since i cannot do right i must think out tonight what's in to commit and commit in other words well we can't not sin all you have to do is believe Now another theory of redemption is one in which we don't have the justice of christ imputed upon us but rather we have a sort of natural redemption by which we just explain away sin we say well
sin is not really that bad after all i mean we have said in the past that uh sodomy Is a sin but really if you think about it it's something natural in other words it uh it comes from uh for for certain people it comes from nature therefore it must be good and so we we don't have to be redeemed from this sin but rather we'll simply call it something good and virtuous and this is the way by which someone who's sick says well i'm not sick i'm uh i'm in good health my blindness is
perfectly natural Uh i'm just otherwise abled and so i don't really need redemption what actually happens is that our lord jesus christ the son of god he comes to bring us redemption which he operates by his passion and death and this life which he communicates to us as the fruit of his passion and death actually justifies us and actually Cleanses us from our sins so the dung heap referred to by luther is not covered simply by a blanket of snow it is actually removed and we actually are just we actually are good we are as
saint paul says the errors of heaven and coheirs with christ we are the saints Uh because we have actually been justified by christ now this redemption is communicated to us by the sacrament of baptism but it's important to understand that the consequences of sin so the consequences of original sin were fourfold our intellect was darkened our will was weakened our passions incline us to evil And we are subject to suffering and death all of these things are the consequence of sin and sin was the cause so what is the remedy so the remedy is to
undo sin and then over time the consequences of sin will also be done away with so the the the consequences of grace will be to heal the darkness of our intellect to heal the weakness of our will to heal the uh concupiscence the unruly desire of our passions when they Try to seek something which is not in conformity to right reason and god and eventually at the end of time to undo also the death of the body by the general resurrection and the eternal life which is the destiny of all those who die in this
state of grace and you see how this this antidote you could say that The grace of christ administered in baptism is like the vaccine which slowly operates in the organism to undo all of the consequences of the infection and this is operated first of all by baptism but what happens if you sin after you are baptized what happens if you again fall from grace and this can be undone by what the fathers call The second plank of salvation so the first plank of salvation is baptism and the second plank of salvation the plank being what
keeps you afloat in the shipwreck of sin so the first plank is baptism the second is the sacrament of penance and this sacrament of penance is what makes it uh possible for sinners To still uh still be united with god and to obtain eternal life even if they have sinned after baptism so when our lord instituted the sacraments we've talked about this in several episodes we talked about this at the very beginning with father robinson our lord could have instituted this sacrament in any way he wanted But he set it up in a particular way
so that the penis and the person who had sinned who had fallen needs to confess needs to speak with a priest this is in order to accuse himself or to make uh public in a in a sp well it's private but to but to basically get the sin out of him i'm probably butchering Theologically all the explanations you'll help me clear it up but bottom line right so here's where the uh the proponents of theology fiction you know always come out and say well i don't need to tell my sins to a priest i go
directly to god and i said to them true if god had set it up that way that would be perfectly Fine and then others will say well it's just a symbol so we could have some other symbol so you had the case of the the priest in mexico uh some time ago who set up that at the beginning of lent the members of the parish would write their sins on pieces of paper and then bring them up to the altar and insert them in a shredder So the symbol that their sins were being forgiven uh
interesting symbol but that's not how christ set it up so how did our lord jesus christ set it up and this is very beautiful andrew because on easter sunday the sacrament of penance was instituted the fruit of the passion of our lord jesus christ is the complete undoing of sin and death the consequence of sin And our lord jesus christ rose from the dead on easter sunday to this new life redemption from sin clearly our lord jesus christ himself was not a sinner but he adopted our nature our human nature and he became like to
us in all things except sin and bore the burden of sin which is suffering and death And this triumph over the devil led to his resurrection and he is the first saint paul says of the the firstborn of the dead the first to rise from the dead clearly others rose from the dead before him lazarus for example but they died afterwards uh our lord rose never more to die and so what does he do he goes and he gives the antidote to sin to his apostles comes in on easter sunday it's in john Chapter 20
and he says to his apostles peace be to you so what is peace peace comes when everything is in order peace comes when man is at peace with god and he is at peace with his neighbor and our lord gives us this peace peace be to you and then he says receive the holy ghost whose sins you shall forgive they are Forgiven and whose sins you shall retain they are retained so note two things here first of all he gives the power to the apostles the 11 apostles are together or rather 10 because famously thomas
was not there and refused to believe until the following sunday when he made the wonderful act of faith my lord and my god so our lord gives the power to the Apostles which comes to them as priests they have been ordained on holy thursday when our lord after celebrating the first mass says do this in as a commemoration of me this is the power which he gives to the apostles now he says receive the holy ghost two sins you shall forgive they are forgiven so the power is transmitted definitely to Some people and then it's
transmitted in the form of a judgment there are two things that you can do if you commit sin you can either wait for the judgment that god will impose upon you at the at the end of your life at the end of time you could say well i've committed a sin now i'm just going to wait until god judges me he's going to judge you and send you to Hell or you can go and you can confess yourself you can go before god your father and you can say i have sinned and then the judgment
which will be put upon you is the judgment of mercy but this judgment depends on the the apostles that's why our lord says if you forgive them their sins they're forgiven but if you retain them they are retained that means judgment and it is From that that the confession of sins is necessary because let's imagine andrew you're going to confession to your parish priest and you come up to him and you say uh father please give me absolution and the parish priest says well for what andrew and you say well you know whatever how is
he going to be able to give you Absolution he needs to know uh if you have sinned uh whether your sin was perhaps just a minor lapse through weakness or did you actually plan that uh multi-million dollar robbery which took place down the road last week it's it's not the same thing and so that's why you have to confess your sins so that the priest can judge and that's why you'll notice in the Sacrament of confession we go to the priest and he sits down okay he's not standing he's not kneeling he's sitting because a
judge sits down he's sitting in judgment upon you as it were now this is the beautiful thing about about confession is that the priest who sits in judgment upon you he's going to kneel so that another priest can sit in judgment upon him and Here's the even more beautiful thing about the sacrament of penance is that the judgment is always a judgment of mercy either the priest will absolve you from your sins or else if he retains your sins he will say well you need to go and you need to sort this out before i
can forgive you your sins and then come back and i will absolve you from your sins he never said to you no sorry you're beyond hope uh your sins Are not to be forgiven there is no sin that cannot be forgiven um every sin can be forgiven as long as we are on the way in via on the way to heaven as long as we're not dead uh our sins can be forgiven and this is the very simple fact about confession is that that's what it is it's i confess my sins to he who has
the authority to forgive them and this authority does not come from himself You'll remember how our lord said on one of his cures he said be of courage son your sins are forgiven and the jew said who is this who can forgive sins only god can forgive sins and that's the fact is that only god can forgive sin but god operates by giving giving power and responsibility to his creatures just like the angels are Responsible for the movement of the planets so also parents are responsible for the procreation and education of their children so also
sinful men are responsible for the salvation of souls uh by receiving this power to forgive sins which is like all the sacraments christ operating using his minister as an instrument we saw in baptism that the minister Is normally the ordinary minister is normally the the priest but could in fact be anyone and in in the sacrament of penance the minister is uh valiantly ordained priest but we'll come to that in a moment if that's okay andrew because i'd like to go through the steps of making a good confession very good so you want to go
to confession well first of all in order to go to confession you have to Be a sinner who is baptized if you're a sinner and you're not baptized then the remedy for your sins is the sacrament of baptism by which we are cleansed of original sin and all of our sins if you are baptized but you're not a sinner then you probably need to develop a little bit of humility Our blessed mother never went to confession because she was never a sinner she never committed any sin but all other human beings who reached the use
of reason uh have committed sins are sinners and so in confession we must confess all mortal sins committed before uh sorry committed after baptism not before baptism after baptism And which have never before been confessed that is what we are are that's what we call the necessary matter of confession but before you go to confession you should examine your conscience you know in other words you should think to yourself well have i committed any mortal sins since my last confession or have i committed any mortal sin since Baptism that i've never before confessed and these
are the ones that i must confess and i'm also going to think of venial sins particularly those which are more of a problem for me there are two kinds of venial sins you've got your deliberate venial sins which are serious in themselves they're not mortal sins but a deliberate venial sin is when you say well i know that this is a sin and i'm not Really going to make any effort to avoid it that's a deliberate choosing to do something which is against god's law it's not a serious matter therefore it's a venial sin but
that's that's a bit of a pro you've got a problem there because that's going to lead you into you're getting the habit of disobeying god it's going to become easier for you to commit a mortal sin then you've got your perhaps your in Deliberate venial sins when you momentarily lose your temper or you have difficulty in doing whatever is absolutely uh you know absolutely necessary to do god's will and you uh you momentarily let's say lamps okay well those are in deliberate in deliberate vinyl synths which can also be confessed and if you're working on
one in particular then you're going to want to confess that when you go to Confession so that's the first step examine your conscience the second step and this is really crucial is you have to be sorry you have to be truly sorry for your sins if you go to confession and you are not truly sorry for your sins then how can you be forgiven uh imagine uh a child who uh you know he's angry with his mother and so he breaks One of her favorite ornaments uh that uh glass vaz which was given to her
by her husband your father 15 years ago and child's angry and breaks it and then the mother says okay are you sorry and he says no well guess what he's not going to be forgiven because he's not sorry and so this is the key uh people who do not know what confession is sometimes say well confession is just permission for you to say as long as you Um say to the priest well i did this this and this then you can be forgiven no if you say to the priest that you've committed sins but you're
not sorry you cannot be forgiven you may fool the priest he may think that you're sorry but when you go out your sins haven't been forgiven you haven't fooled god uh confession is not like a it's not like a slot machine where you sort of Put in your sins pull the lever and you get absolution it's the the essence of the disposition of the penitent is what uh is called in greek metanoia a change of heart that's what that's what penance is it's a change of heart i have sinned but now i regret my sin
and i am sorry now there are two kinds of regret two kinds of sorrow for your sin what we Call contrition contrition can be imperfect or contrition can be perfect both of those are sufficient in the sacrament of penance let me explain the difference imperfect contrition is when i'm sorry for my sins because of some good supernatural reason other than the love of god In other words i'm sorry for committing mortal sins because i don't want to go to hell okay that's a good reason for being sorrow it's not a perfect reason but that's enough
to go to confession perfect contrition is when you're sorry for your sins for the perfect reason which is i am sorry because i've offended god whom i love and this perfect contrition is actually enough by itself to forgive sin that's The case of someone let's say who's committed a mortal sin and is dying is it possible for that person to go to heaven without going to confession given that there's no possibility of going to confession well the answer is yes if the person is perfect contrition that is a sorrow for sin based on the love
of god above all things and that that's a grace from god uh that's not something that you can just Sort of hold your breath until i get perfect contrition it's a gift from god and it's very difficult for any man to say well i've got perfect contrition and that's why the sacrament of confession is going to provide a remedy for sin and peace of soul because you know that even if you only have imperfect contrition and it's it's relatively easy to be s to be sorry for mortal sin because you fear going to Hell we
can imagine hell and we we know that that's not somewhere i want to go and then the the absolution of the priest uh will give you forgiveness for your sins and what's more andrew it will turn you from just having imperfect contrition into having perfect contrition you go into confession because you're afraid of going to hell you come out of confession because You love god you don't want to sin because you love god with sorrow and this is the third step to making a good confession you must have a firm purpose of amendment getting back
to the case of our boy who broke his mother's vas so okay he's sorry because he doesn't want to be punished and then his mother says are you going To do it again and he says yeah okay well he's not actually sorry uh i am sorry because i got caught but if i get into the opportunity of not getting called then i'll do it again well that no that doesn't count you have to have a firm purpose of amendment and this firm purpose of amendment must include all mortal sins you can't say well i committed
the sin of murder i committed the sin of Theft okay i'm not going to do the murder again but i might i might do the thieving again uh well i'm sorry that's not a firm purpose of amendment for all of your mortal sins must be for all of them and this firm purpose of amendment doesn't mean that you know for sure you're never going to commit the sin again we know rather for sure that we are weak that if we move away from god and we Grow cold in our further towards him and we start
neglecting god in small things that we may indeed fall again rather it is a determination here and now that i'm going to do whatever is necessary to avoid the mortal sin in the future so i am used to hanging around with bad companions who lead me into mortal sin I'm gonna cut that off or i am used to uh watching movies that are a grave occasion of sin i'm gonna cut them out and that's a firm purpose of amendment and then once you have those things you're you've examined your conscience you're you have true sorrow
at least imperfect contrition you have a firm purpose of amendment for all mortal sins that you have that you Are confessing and if if you have you're not confessing mortal sins at least one of your venial sins then you must confess your sins and this confession is necessary because of what we saw that christ instituted the sacrament in the form of judgment the priest needs to know what i have done what i am confessing and he needs to know whether i am sorry Or not whether i have a firm purpose of amendment and here on
confessing your sins i just want to make a couple of points andrew the first one is that you're not a computer okay this is really for scrupulous people they go to confession and they come out of confession and they say oh my goodness i forgot to confess that or i didn't quite get the number right on That and then they start torturing themselves oh my goodness i made a bad confession no you did not make a bad confession what makes a bad confession is to hide deliberately one of your mortal sins that's a sin of
sacrilege when you go to confession and you pretend to be confessing all of your mortal sins but actually you hide one of them through a false shame the devil before the sin he said oh if you commit the sin it'll make You happy once you committed the sin you found out that it doesn't make you happy the devil came along and he said oh that's such a bad sin you better not tell that to the priest he's going to go really mad when he hears that which is completely false because doctors don't get angry because
the patient is sick they rather are are merciful towards the patient especially a priest knowing that he himself is a Sinner but that would make a confession bad if you were to hide otherwise if you make a good examination of conscience it doesn't have to be you know very long i mean if you're going to confession for the first time in 60 years then clearly it will be a longer examination of conscience but if you went to confession last month or a couple of weeks ago if you examine your Conscience for five minutes you will
have made a good examination of conscience and so you shouldn't worry because god knows that you're not a computer google may be able to make a better confession of your sins than you can but google cannot go to confession because google is incapable of true sorrow and you have a soul and you are capable of sorrow and that's why if you were to Forget for example a mortal sin in confession you simply confess it at your next confession you say father i forgot to confess that my last confession such and such a sin that's perfectly
fine and you see how that fits in with the rule that i have to confess all of those mortal sins which i've never before confessed so if i committed it 30 years ago and i made you know i made 200 confessions since since that and i Forgot to confess it to each one well i confess it to this one now that i've remembered and that is true perfectly fine now the council of trent tells us that we must in confession confess all our mortal sins by number and kind each sin has a name and i
must confess a mortal sin by its name it's not enough to simply confess it in general so i'm going to give a couple of Examples now of confessions andrew i'd like to reassure your listeners and yourself that these are not real things which happened in confession but i'm simply making them up they're they're from my imagination somebody goes to confession and he says father bless me father i've done some bad stuff okay uh uh that You're confessing the fact you've you've uh you've done something wrong but i have no idea what it is uh turns
out that the bad stuff you did well i didn't really pay full attention when i was saying my prayers well that's uh that's a fairly fairly small sin really um so uh it could also mean that i've done some bad stuff i've committed sacrilegious father okay so you need to be more precise so don't bother coming to confession and saying i did bad stuff Or people sometimes might say oh father um i've had an inappropriate conversation okay what does that mean does that mean that you spoke while your teacher was speaking that would be inappropriate
uh for you to chat with your friend during english class that's inappropriate or it could mean that you were talking about peanuts when the teacher had asked you to talk about Frogs that's inappropriate you're not doing the right thing at the right time or maybe you had a conversation in the church that's inappropriate or it could mean that you had an uncharitable conversation that's inappropriate or it could mean that you had an impure conversation that's inappropriate but you see how confessing it in general is not actually enough you have to say right bless me father
for i have sinned I have engaged in uncharitable conversation that's all you need to say we sometimes uh perhaps can go to confession and start telling a whole story father last week uh you remember the day which was particularly cold yeah that day well when i got up in the morning i had such a headache and i thought to myself Gosh i need some tylenol and so i got some tylenol and then the next thing is uh the dog broke out of the fence and you know the whole thing goes eventually so what did you
do wrong well father i used a bad word okay well you didn't need to tell me the whole story about the dog and the headache and everything else you confess your sins in simplicity by number and kind that is i say what the sin is I uh said a bad word or i took gold's name in vain or i blasphemed or i committed the sin of murder three times or whatever it is and the priest has got no business asking for any details other than what is necessary for the actual knowledge of the sins and
their number now when it comes to number of course here can be a little bit difficult you Know put yourself in the shoes andrew that guy hasn't been to confession for 60 years and he goes to confession and he he doesn't know where to start in a way you know how many times did i blaspheme in 60 years you know perhaps i was in the habit of it at some time and so what you need to do here is remember once again you're not a computer you simply do your best you know some sins perhaps
we remember Exactly how many times we did it um i i did not attend mass on sunday through my own fault on two occasions okay that's that's clear but others particularly sins of thought perhaps which are difficult to quantify i should simply try to give as best i can during a period of 20 years father i was in the habit of doing drugs about three times a month Okay that's perfectly fine it's not fine to be doing drugs three times a month what is fine is the way you've just confessed that it's uh right it's
you've said it was approximately that number of times during that duration of period or maybe someone says well father i was living with a woman who wasn't my wife you know over a period of of you know so many months or years etc etc you can't necessarily put an exact Number on every sin and one final thing i would say about confessing your sins andrew is never to be afraid that the priest is going to react badly because the priest is not going to react badly it's you've come to confession not because you're proud of
your sins and you're coming to boast about your sins if that were the case really uh that would be diabolical you're coming to confession because you're sorry for your Sins and so the priest is not going to get angry but rather he's going to remember that he himself is a sinner and he is going to help you in any way that he can to make a good confession and to help you to get back up on your feet that is back in the state of grace and once again uh hit the road for calvary with
our lord so that you will also come to the Resurrection now final step of confession is accept your penance now why does the priest give us penance in confession the answer is it's not some sort of well you got to pay for that sin okay sometimes sometimes we have to literally pay for a sin if for example you have to make restitution right you know that dog that i stole from you andrew i gotta give it back Okay now um there's no other way around it i can't say i'm sorry for taking andrew's dog if
i keep the dog i have to bring the dog back and maybe i can drop him off when you're not looking so you don't know it's me that would be fine or maybe i'll go to you and say andrew look at uh i took your dog here it is back i'm not going to do that again and you know hopefully you being a good Christian you're gonna say okay well if if you're sorry i forgive you and that's uh that's how it works we're all sinners um now the penance comes in because when we commit
a mortal sin or any sin we do two things we offend god and we do damage to ourselves okay this is what uh the prophet said my people have done two things they have rejected me the true god and they've built to themselves sisters i'm the fount of living water they've Rejected me and then they've built themselves cisterns that can hold no water that's what happens in mortal sin we say to god look i don't need you goodbye and then i say oh look at uh money power lust you're going to make me happy and
uh this is damaging to ourselves so you go to confession the punishment for rejecting god is infinite it's hell that is completely done away with it's not god doesn't say Well you deserve hell you know i'll think about it he says no you're sorry for your sins that punishment's gone however the damage i've done to myself that needs to be undone and that's the temporal punishment which is uh done by by penance if i don't do it in this life i'm going to need to do it in purgatory that's when i heal the damage which
i've done to myself by sin and for someone who has supreme Love for god they don't even need to do penance somebody like mary magdalene who committed uh sins for years let's say she she is truly sorry her her sins are forgiven her because she loves much she doesn't need to do penance for her sins she does do penance for her sins but she doesn't need to because her love for god is so strong that it's actually wiped away all of the uh All of the sort of uh inclinations towards sin which penance is there
to to wipe away and that's why your penance normally should actually attack your fault so you go to confession and you say uh i'm greedy i've committed the sin of greed okay priest says to you fast or i don't pray priest says to you pray that's your penance or uh father i am uncharitable towards My neighbor a priest says to you okay do some acts of charity i father i never think about god do some spiritual reading and these acts of penance are going to uh repair the damage which you have done by sin so
those are the five steps to a good confession clearly there are other things that you could uh plenty of details you could put in but that's the Basics for making a good confession and um i just finished off in a moment perhaps with the the person who's going to give you absolution the minister of the sacrament of penance and uh explain how that works okay now obviously as the priest spoiler um when we are talking about the the power Of absolution father does that come to the priest by virtue of him being a priest and
being ordained or is there some other way in which this power comes to the priest to be able to absolve sins right a very good question andrew so it's it's both in fact so in order to be able to forgive sins uh the person must be a priest now you could confess your sins to anybody Uh you could you could say well i'm gonna confess my sins to a deacon and that is a confession but the deacon cannot give you absolution um and i suppose the thing about the sacrament of penance the confession of your
sins is that not only will the priest give you forgiveness if you're truly sorry but also psychologically it's of great help you know again some people who are Engaging in theology fiction will say well you know clearly you're not actually having your sins forgiven let's face it i mean how could you have your sins forgiven by a man well the man is acting as the instrument of christ that's how but anyway uh but i can see the psychological benefit and that's why non-catholics are those who don't go to confession will they end up going to
shrinks They end up lying on the psychiatrist's couch and confessing their sins or confessing whatever is going on and this a confession of our sin is like it's like vomiting it's you've got this poison within you which is sin and you have to get it out and so it you vomit the sin out and the priest is going to be able to repair the damage by giving you absolution and forgiving you your sins Now that's why confession is not enough and in fact in extreme cases confession's not even necessary if i um one of those
10 000 soldiers ready to go over the top in the trenches in the first world war um the priest doesn't have time to hear all of our confessions so he gives general absolution and that absolution is valid but i will need to confess my sins next opportunity I have for confession or i've just been hit in a car crash and i am not conscious uh the priest sees in my wallet i've got a little uh tag saying i'm a catholic in case of accident please call a priest says well this guy's a catholic i can
give him absolution and i didn't confess my sins because i wasn't able to what is necessary is my sorrow at least Habitual sorrow because clearly i wasn't thinking of going to confession when i i was in the car accident but my habitual sorrow for sin and the priest has to have the power of the priesthood which is the power of order he has to be an ordained priest but he also needs the power of jurisdiction because the power to forgive sins comes from the jurisdiction of the pope and the bishops To to bind and to
loose to uh to bind the faithful to certain things such as the precepts of the church and to loose the faithful from the bonds of sin and this jurisdiction can be either given by the bishop so each diocese the bishop will give jurisdiction to the priests in the diocese to hear confessions and he may limit that Uh the famous case in uh detroit was that a father solanus casey who was a priest but he never heard a confession in his life because the bishop did not give him uh permission either to preach or to hear
confessions he was a saint he was a very saintly man but he didn't do these things he had the power to do it but the bishop did not give him the permission the jurisdiction to do it Except in certain cases where jurisdiction is given by law and this is the case particularly in danger of death so in danger of death every priest in the world whether he be good bad or indifferent always has the power to uh absolve from sin so even though the priest may be an unfaithful priest he may have left the priesthood
so to speak And he may be now living as some sort of terrible person well he has the power to forgive sins in danger of death and what's more the person who is in danger of death has the right to call him so let's imagine i have padre pio waiting by as i die and i've also got father judas who's a couple of doors down on the street i can call father judas if i want to the church gives me that uh that power because all the church wants is For me to save my soul
and this man even if he's unfaithful has the power to absolve from sin now clearly uh you know maybe i should rather call patricio because he's uh clearly closer to gold uh but i may do both because he has the power given to him by law and there are some other uh cases given by law which i'm not going to go into today but basically that's it i need the power of order to be a priest and i need the power of jurisdiction given by the Pope given by the bishop or else given by law
well father that's um that's fascinating thank you for going through that all with us yeah okay thank you andrew um apologies for that that's just the connection is a little uh a little uh slow but yeah i wanted to wrap up on this beautiful sacrament of penance by giving a quote from father gary legrange who said that The church the body of christ so the the uh the body of christ which gives the life of christ to us the church is not an organization like any other the church he says is intolerant in principle but
tolerant in practice and the reason it is intolerant in principle is because it believes and it's tolerant in practice because She loves it so the church holds fast to the faith holds fast to the doctrine of the faith does not waver on these things but then when people come and say we've sinned she doesn't go oh okay i don't want anything to do with you you're a nasty person rather the church says okay are you sorry for your sins and this sinful uh child comes back to god through the church whereas the world he says
is tolerant in Principle but intolerant in practice and the reason it's tolerant in principle is because it does not believe and it's intolerant in practice because it does not love you can you can think that the world says yeah you can believe whatever you want but actually in practice if you don't believe what they want you to believe and act as they want you to act then you're a nasty person you're uh you're Somebody who stops women from uh vindicating their rights over their body because you say abortion is wrong and so in theory you
can believe whatever you want but in practice no whereas the church says no you must seek god you must follow god and if you fail then go and repent confess your sins to christ to the ministry of the pre of the priest and then with his help with gold's help you will again begin to live the Christian life and that is the great uh great beauty of the mercy of god is god is merciful to us not because we deserve it but because we don't deserve it because we are sinners right we are weak and
we are ignorant therefore god is mercy on us whereas the devil will say well no mercy it's because uh he does not have the love there's not one ounce of the love of god within him and those who who are along the same Lines as the devil are the same and so i would finish by encouraging all of us to have a great devotion and faith in the sacrament of penance true confidence in the mercy of god not a false confidence that thinks well i can sin and it doesn't matter god is never going to
punish me but rather one that says i am a sinner i repent of my sins god will forgive me he will help me that's beautiful father thank you so much for taking the time to go through All this with us and and lay the groundwork um for what we'll be looking at next week and could you give us a little preview of what we'll be discussing next week then father so next week we're going to look at the modern version of the sacrament of penance and here okay we can look at some changes in the
right of confession or the right of the sacrament of penance but also the change in attitude towards Sin in general and the uh the effective sidelining of the sacrament of penance as sin is sidelined is that those things that we used to think were sins well they're not anymore and so we don't need to go to confession so that will be quite interesting to see how uh things have changed over the past 50 60 years Father looking forward to it thank you again for taking the time with us today and uh we'll see you next
week thank you very much andrew you're very welcome [Music] you