we learned already to structure different kinds of innovation regarding the object product process service innovation and we learned that the degree of innovativeness is a very important measure to really distinguish different kinds of innovation a further famous differentiation is this of component versus architectural innovation relating a little bit to the degree of innovativeness but now rather technical to the degree of change in the product system will explain this in a second with an example but the idea is that we have to distinguish with different innovations on the one inside regarding the components or concepts the
building blocks of a product and on the other side on the interfaces the system linkages and that connects these components in incremental innovation of something where we really keep the architecture and the interfaces unchanged and just improve a little bit our core components a radical innovation is one they will really change everything we change we set up a new architecture and we over tune and develop new components then there's so-called component innovation which is now new to this game here the component innovation is I take the existing system and adjust radically modify one component this
could be a little bit an electric vehicle and many electric vehicles for long time looked like normal cars just the combustion engine was being replaced by an electrical energy the entire architecture of the car were more or less the same but we exchanged an important component when an architectural innovation is one that really recombines existing components in a very novel way just let's look into this in an example and the innovation of bicycles provide a great example for this you may know that when bicycles came up at the beginning when it was really a new
technology there was many different competing designs how bicycle should look like and you all know from some museums this design shown there at the bottom of one very big wheel which is good to put your power your first from your body to the wheel but we're just very unsecured very unstable and so then quickly this common bike design that we still use nowadays came to market it was called the safety bicycle as it just was more safe to ride and to really and keep on track so think about it what was it the change from
the old big wheel design to the safety design can you classify which kind of innovation it was well it was definitely not an incremental innovation as this was mean really to just improve perhaps one part of the bicycle here however it also was not a radical innovation as a basic way of a bicycle for more or less the same we can say the bicycle itself was a radical innovation replacing the horse it was exactly an architectural innovation it's the basic components of wheels of change remains the same but the way how we compound and how
the infrastructures the system architecture is being designed was changed radically then later in the history of bicycle innovation the safety bicycle design was improved in many ways and now we came into component innovation there are some more radical ways to the breaking of the gearing systems while the system itself the architec is being unchanged and this is still apparently the best design they have been a lot of experiments with design and the Internet again is full with funny looking bicycles which either were component innovation or here we could say another architectural innovation as a way
how to use this bicycle is very different to the common design in this differentiation of different kinds of innovations is important for similar reasons as a degree of innovativeness as defined before first if we just go into incremental innovation this is probably Mary and whisky but also providing not too much in your opportunities to differentiate component innovation where you often is a main driver of technical innovation we can either patent am a protection for just improving the component if we don't really have to deal about changing the system of me don't have to we educate
the customers or the markets or stakeholders regulation and all are the same of course we have radical innovations the Holy Grail so hub to really change everything but this is very risky and happening not too often but Henderson Clark and two scholars from MIT and Harvard and introduced this concept said there is this interesting thing of architectural innovation that you take what is Oxley already existing there on the component level and we composers in a novel way some people say this was exactly the iPod most of the components of the iPod were already existing they
were not invented by Apple but Apple combines this existing inventions on the component level in a very novel and successful way and this leads us to the final differentiation of different types of innovation that between sustaining and disruptive innovation and it really builds on something what we already had before and this now is really about the degree of change from the firm perspective it starts with incremental innovation or here called sustaining innovation improvements of merits replacing an old model by next and the better version second roses are so-called efficiency improving innovations or so-called low-end disruptions
the idea here it's not just average process innovation but it's really that there is a radical process innovation that it allows us to offer the same solution to the same customers at lower price think about Walmart the big big largest retailer of the world they did not invent the supermarket and if you shop at warm at the supermarket in the product that say look more or less the same but they were the first of really using IT to a very large degree of better planning their assortments of optimizing the positionings of the product in the
store they engaged a lot in innovation in logistics and warehouse systems so they offer exactly the same but in a radical new way and not just improving some of the components but many of the core processes behind the same was just in time Manufacturing by Toyota the same cars but what we used in a very different way and finally there are disruptive business model innovations in this framework which by the way comes from Clayton Christensen another really innovation and another very famous innovation scholar colleague teaching at Harvard Business School and clay Christensen became famous for
Willie defining this term disruptive business model innovation and when he said there are sometimes innovation coming up that really transformed an existing solution which often has been complex or rather expensive in such a radical manner that an entire new market is being created so it's often the result of a combination of cost reducing technology with a new business model think of video streaming video streaming is currently totally replacing the video rental store and at the beginning main video streaming came up the quality was not so good the download times were not so good so it
was first adopted by some niche markets that really cared about a special assortment of very special films that a normal video end of store could not later on however it really changed the business model it has different revenue and pricing models where the video rental store mainly builds on price per day most of the on-demand services are streaming services they play of pay a flat fee per month and can see as much as you want to have very different cost economics behind and it was what we call a disruptive business model innovation creating a new
market this letter example also corresponds to one of the most famous frameworks in innovation management with regard to structuring different type of innovation the so called ends of matrix ends of is again one of the early scholars of innovation and he published this already in 1957 and the Harvard Business Review and he said if you look into innovation you have to distinguish two perspectives one is the product opposes perspective are we talking about new products or old products and then it's a market perspective are we talking about new markets or old markets from the perspective
of our firm and similar to this are we talking about usage situations or problems we solve for the customers which are novel or already existing so traditionally with status product development and product development means we have an existing market an existing problem and we develop a new product when market penetration category 2 here is something where nothing has changed we have an old market an old product well and all innovation here is probably market innovation its communications and just selling more of what is existing so here it's not really an innovation while this is the
typical case of innovation management creating a new solution to an oil problem think of new medications or just-in-time manufacturing process then the other categories are relating to really having new kids and this goes in line with a disruptive business model innovation a talk before in the previous slides so diversification category theory is something what is often considered as the most innovative this was executive Christensen's disruptive innovation case we new product leads to really new opportunities think about the PC that replace the mainframe computer but it was not just replacing the mainframe computer but really creating
entirely new industries and users scenarios finally what could this be we'd have an old product and put it into a new market well this is something what is often called market development and really find new uses for old products there's something that sometimes happen happens in the pharmaceutical industry we are an existing pharmaceutical is found to also have an application for different indication and brought into this market could be other uses for a paper clip or for DVDs or in process innovation that use satellite imagery for testing salts bringing something from the military into the
agricultural field so what we see here we can structure our innovation both with regard to Swizzle but also how it's set up and project in these two dimensions do we want to achieve something with a new product or do we really want to create even a new market so as you saw on these two models there are many shades of innovation and it's really important for you to know what you want to achieve and the academic term for these are the contingencies of an innovation project we have to know the context and its objectives