During the course of the Russian Revolution the Bolsheviks were caught in a conundrum although they are nearing Victory the war had completely devastated the Russian industry the economy was in Ruins and millions of people were left destitute and going hungry worse still the rural peasantry who the Bolsheviks have been courting since 1917 were starting to turn on the Communists as a result of the bolic proa Peasant revolts were occurring all across Russia with the largest and most successful happening in tambov in the middle of 1920 it is commonly believed that the konat Revolt led to
the enactment of the New Economic Policy but this is not true as Leonard Shapiro demonstrates although the New Economic Policy would ironically satisfy some of the desires of the croners the policy had been in the work for some time since the beginning of the year 1921 the Kronstad Revolt only served to hasten linen introduction of it to his party and the implementation of it in Soviet Society the principle document which delineates the procedures on how the New Economic Policy was to operate was Lennon's pamphlet the tax in kind which he completed and had published near
the end of April in this document he analyzes his pmic with the left communist from 1918 and admits that it contained a number of mistakes but that The basic character of the Russian economy remained the same that is that the Russian economy was dominated by Petty bis relations emanating from the countryside lenon argues that the Civil War has caused a crisis that required urgent measures for the Improvement of the condition of the peasant masses which was linked directly to the condition of the workers he writes the dictatorship of the proletariat is the direction of policy
by the proletariat The proletariat as the leading and ruling class must be able to direct policy in such way as to solve the first most urgent and vexed problem the most urgent thing at the present time is to take measures that will immediately increase the productive forces of peasant farming only in this way will it be possible to improve the condition of the workers strengthen the alliance between the workers and The Peasants and consolidate the dictatorship of the Proletariat the condition of the workers then and the survival of the dictatorship of the proletariat was directly
linked with the attitude of the rural peasantry and the dictatorship of the proletariat the proletarian class is placed at the head but since the proletariat was outnumbered by The Peasants it was crucial that the peasant masses were on board with and Allied to that dictatorship therefore in order to improve improve and strengthen the Alliance with the peasantry it was necessary also to improve the productive forces in rural agriculture the means of doing this then was by substituting the system of requisitioning with the tax in kind this meant that the state would no longer seize grain
at fixed prices to forcefully meet its quota instead they would now Engage The Peasants on the free market after a minimum of grain was taxed this would be the basis of the alliance between the proletariat and the Peasantry the smitka this economic Alliance lenen stressed was of utmost importance and the development of quality industrial goods for consumption on the peasant Market was the main task of the party he writes our aim is to prove to The Peasant by Deeds that we are beginning what is intelligible familiar and immediately accessible to him in spite of his
poverty and not with something remote and fantastic from the peasant's point of view we must prove That we can help him either we prove that or he will send us to the devil that is inevitable to prove that they could help the peasant meant to cease any antagonistic policies that were currently being taken against him lyen argued that the previous policy of War communism was correct in so far as the war itself had forced them to adopt it so that they could maintain the Army but that this new policy was the correct policy for a
revolutionary State Evolving towards socialism from Petty bu economy but lenon maintained that this new policy of concessions was not a cessation of the class struggle but its Evolution he wrote the moderate and cautious application of the concessions policy will undoubtedly help us quickly to improve the state of industry and the condition of the workers and peasants the scale and the conditions under which concessions cease to be a danger and are turned to our advantage depend on the Relation of forces and are decided in the struggle for concessions are also a form of struggle and are
a continuation of the class struggle in another form and in no circumstances are they a substitution of class peace for class war all in all the New Economic Policy represented a retreat but as lenon emphasized a necessary one for through the restoration of capitalist trade the bolicks would have ground to stand on for the eventual construction of Socialism Lyon also made clear that as Marxist they understood that capitalism was not a historic evil but a stage in development large scale capitalist Enterprise was Superior to Petty bis and small scale production lenon stressed that through this
policy they may have taken one step backwards from socialism but they were also taking one step forward away from Petty capitalism a few months later bukar would then take up the role of explaining the New Economic Policy and its significance to foreign delegates to the Comon turn in July according to bukharin the experience of the Russian Revolution had showed the Bolsheviks that their previous conception of the Revolution was naive that practical experience had showed the Bolsheviks that the Orthodox Marxist interpretation of the Revolutionary process during the course of a successful proletarian Revolution did not account
for the additional Difficulties that a revolutionary movement would encounter upon coming to power bukharan then argues that the Russian experience was not a unique experience and that its backwardness was not the only issue he States quote we are convinced of the absolute inevitability of an economic disorganization generally during the Revolutionary process that is that even in an advanced capitalist country because of the devastation in which a Revolutionary upheaval would bring a period of reconstruction would be necessary everywhere the course of a revolution in other countries then generally would follow the bolik model every Revolution is
a process of reorganization of social relations in a bis Revolution this process is not so thorough or extensive as in a proletarian Revolution because capitalism has already been developed and only a political transformation Becomes necessary even A bgea revolution is accompanied by a temporary decline in productivity such was the case in the great French Revolution the same was manifested in the American Civil War where Economic Development was thrown back for a decade in a proletarian Revolution the same thing takes place on a much larger scale during a proletarian Revolution we must not only destroy the
state machine but completely reorganize the industrial relations that is the Most important Point bis Society according to bakarin was structured in such a way that simply seizing power was not enough the entire industrial apparatus needed to be torn down and built back up upon New Foundations this process implied not just a setback productivity but as bukharan said it would bring the entire process of production to a standstill according to bukharan quote either the revolution will win and then there is an inevitable Disorganization of the process of production or discipline will be maintained and then there
will be no Revolution at all sacrifices needed to be made as they say one cannot make omelets without breaking a few eggs still in the course of a revolution and Civil War the economic life of a country is disrupted the ties That Bind the town in the country are severed and economic equilibrium is upset by the Revolutionary process but no one can Survive without bread what is to be done about the bread question during the Civil War the bik's answer to this question was with compulsory measures with war communism but as the bolik soon discovered
this measure was rought with its own contradictions laran writes it was proved economically that if we take away all surplus of the peasant's produce we take away almost all the incentive to further production if the peasant knows that he'll be deprived of All Surplus produce he will only produce for himself nothing for others the only incentive that remains is of an intellectual kind the knowledge that he must support the workers who defend him from the landlord after the victory at the Civil War fronts the effect of this incentive was destroyed agriculture was in a critical
condition and we were in danger of being left without sufficient bread a crisis in agriculture also represented a crisis in Industry workers Then were ejected from industry they were forced to find an alternative means of making ends meat and in an environment of economic collapse and uncertainty that unfortunately means a large mass of people are forced to start hustling proletarians were becoming declassed and becoming Petty bat Tradesmen and small producers just so they could feed themselves the direction that the Bulls had decided to take was based on considerations of what was Occurring around them The
Peasants Rose in the countryside and the sailors Rose in konat the peasants spoke under the slogan for the bolik and against the Communists and the sailors under the banner of Soviets without bolik the purpose of the NEP then was to maintain the political Monopoly of the bulvik party to maintain the dictatorship as buaran says quote there is one principle which we had to maintain at all costs the preservation of the dictatorship the Bolik were prepared to make economic concessions as a means to avoid making political concessions all in all the features of the new policy
were summed up in three parts by Eugene Varga first the abolition of the food Monopoly and its replacement by a taxing kind secondly the surrender of some Industries which were run by the state and the leasing of the same to syndicates or private Enterprises lastly the reorganization of Industrial Enterprises which remained under State Control in a manner which will ensure them a greater freedom of movement in the Market at the same time gold which lost its importance during war communism would once again become an economic necessity currency which was effectively abolished by War communism was
being reestablished and the state would retain control over the largest and most important industries the so-called commanding Heights while smaller Industries would be denationalized and left to private persons these were the theoretical justifications and explanations for the New Economic Policy but during the course of the seven years that it was implemented how did it actually operate what were its practical results and what did NEP Russia look like before we can discuss that we must return back to war communism to understand how it actually functioned as much as War communism is depicted in a Manner in
which the bolck had total control over the economy the real picture is far different when the bolix took power in October 1917 they issued many decrees but intent and capacity are two different things and the bolix quickly found in their situation that the actual capacity that they had to do anything was quite narrow in November 1918 the Supreme Economic Council put forward a decree that sought to set up a system of retail trade through state and Cooperative stores placed under local Soviet control in these stores prices would be fixed and private trade would also be
eliminated but in 1918 the bolik state Enterprise was weak and there existed a shortage of goods this meant that most ordinary Russians and including the Communist acquired food and other necessities on the black market that is through private trade as Alan Ball writes the urban population obtained approximately 70% of its grain Products through private channels despite Lyon's attack Ta on the practice nor was grain the only product involved throughout War communism private entrepreneurs accounted for the lion share between 1 half and 2/3 of all retail trade so essential was this activity that officials in many
regions cracked down only intermittently and looked through their fingers the rest of the time occasionally during particularly acute food shortages the Government even felt compelled to legalize some petty private trade War communism did indeed obstruct private trade but only in so far as making making it far more informal and clandestine when before Goods could be acquired from permanent stores following the introduction of War communism private trade became illicit and mobile Hustler Traders known as bagman would Journey to the countryside and trade some good for grain then they would Return to the cities and resell their
grain at markets and bazaars and then rinse and repeat these sorts of activities in trade were further encouraged by the virtual abolition of currency during war communism with money becoming increased L useless due to inflation both private and state Enterprises would instead pay their workers with a portion of the goods they produced as remuneration Allan Masters determines that 90% of industrial wages Were paid in kind therefore many workers wound up becoming bagman themselves just so they could get food I hope you're understanding the bigger picture then at this point the bolck didn't really have control
over what was occurring much like how the peasants began seizing land even before they decreed it the Russian people were engaging in private trade even before the New Economic Policy was enacted much like the land decrees all the New Economic Policy did was legalize What was already largely occurring the policy of War communism coupled with the general disintegration of the economy and the Bloodshed wrought by the Civil War was a grand tragedy for the Russian people the picture is demonstrated by Alan Ball even though the volume of private trade during war communism was impressive compared
to the trickle of sales in state and Cooperative shops it was merely a fraction of the business conducted in the years before the first World war this was a consequence of the attempt by the state to abolish private trade and reflecting the collapse of the economy in general during this period the countryside reverted largely to a self-sufficient natural economy with agricultural production in 1920 roughly 34s of that of 1912 people abandoned the cities and droves hoping to find food in the countryside weeds normally founded in uninhabited Marshland were common sight in petrograd main streets the
Population of Moscow was estim aded to have plunged from about 2 million in February 1917 to about 1 million in August 1920 for petrograd the drop was from roughly 2.4 million to 740,000 acute shortages of food fuel shelter and warm clothing were Common Place livestock died as humans ate the feed normally given to cattle and many people consumed food considered unfit even for animals and more prosperous times as the situation grew more desperate crimes Committed to obtain Necessities multiplied and there were even numerous reports of cannibalism in the newspapers while the people in the city
starved the peasants in the countryside were greatly agitated by the requisition drives the Red Army itself was majority peasant when those soldiers returned home it only exacerbated the crisis as those peasants who formerly fought for the Bolsheviks were now taking up arms against them the only solution then was To end that policy which was only making things worse hence the enactment of the New Economic Policy in 1921 initially the New Economic Policy policy was only to be limited to barter with peasants State manufactured goods for their surplus of grain this eventually was extended to include
private trade in general ordinary buying and selling as lyen put it Alan Ball writes in the early months of NEP lyen spoke of Permitting only local trade by peasants Of surplus produce they might have after paying the new tax in kind plans to restrict private trade within such narrow limits were rendered nugatory by the swelling Army of private middlemen vendors and shopkeepers as the months went by government acceptance of this new reality gradually became evident in official directives on May 24th a decree from sarcom permitted not only the free sale of surplus food by peasants
but also trade by other citizens of goods Produced by small-scale private manufacturers these sales were not restricted to marketplaces and bazaars but could be conducted from permanent facilities as well as from stalls booths and Hawkers trades for example further state agencies were given permission to Market their products through private Traders if Cooperative Outlets were unavailable are not up to the task switching back to the market form of the economy the buwick stabilized the rubble Reinstated the National Bank begun to construct the typical finance and credit institutions of a standard capitalist society and enacted a monopoly
on foreign trade over the years new policies were unfolded describing how an upand cominging entrepreneur could join this new economy under the New Economic Policy at the age of 16 and above you could acquire a trading license the state would set time frames from which you could trade your wares while also Enforcing safety regulations according to Alan Ball in those early months however many private Traders were afraid of biting the worm that the bwick were dangling in front of them it was only after months of encouragement on the part of the state and the press
that nepman would take up a new role in the new economy and increase the volume of trade throughout the months sarom would legalize the selling of more and more Goods by private Traders all in all Between 1920 and 1922 the new laws made it possible to sell medicines purchase and own municipalization clinics open private publishing houses buy and sell horses and the state also legalized the owning of foreign currency gold and precious metals along with this the government repealed its Monopoly on the sale of agricultural equipment and allowed netmen to use the railways to transport
their goods various small Enterprises And manufactures were denationalized or at leas on to private owners but as we mentioned previously the state was still to control the commanding Heights of Industry Cohen states that even though 88% of Enterprises were private only 12% of the industrial labor force were employed by private companies the state encouraged the growth of small manufacturers and Artisans and allowed State Enterprises to conduct business with private Traders and netmen which is Something they did quite often due to the insufficiency of the government's own system all the rights afforded to those engaged in
the private sector of the economy were then codified in the civil code of the rsfr in 1923 in 1922 the consequences of one year of the policy were already showing themselves in 1921 the menic Theodore Dan was arrested he would be released from prison in 1922 and following his release he was shocked at how much had changed This new private trade clearly dealt mainly with the luxuries of the new Rich shamelessly standing out against a background of general impoverishment and appalling hunger troubling Echoes of which reached to mcow in the form of reports of widespread
death terrible instances of cannibalism and so on but all of these reports were received as if they came from another planet and Moscow made merry treating itself with pastries Fine Candies fruits and Delicacies Theaters and concerts were packed women were again flaunting luxurious apparel Furs and diamonds a Speculator who yesterday was threatened with execution and quietly stayed to the side trying to avoid notice today considers himself important and proudly shows off his wealth and lecture this is evident in every little custom again after a number of years one can hear from the mouths of cab
drivers waiters and porters at stations the Sural expression which had completely disappeared from use your honor Baron and these were not just the propagandistic words of a menic counterrevolutionary who was hostile to Soviet power many in the bolik party itself were also horrified at what was occurring some were even speaking of the Betrayal of the Revolution many biks spoke with great disdain of the growth of this new bisi which openly flaunted its wealth Russia in the NEP period had Its own variation of the Roaring 20s with all those characteristics of AA High Life Exquisite Goods
exotic and foreign products the life of luxury which the Revolution was supposed to extinguish seemed to have reappeared but now it was the Communists who were presiding over it but as we have shown lynon sought to explain the seeming contradiction of using the bisi to build socialism while some like bukharan accepted the NEP ful Many others could not come to terms with it and that sort of openly hostile attitude which most of the party had to the policy would affect its function over the course of its seven years of implementation as the government would flip
and flop on its policies and local administrative officials would act on their own initiative Allan ball writes many Bolsheviks had serious misgivings about the legalization of private trade and those in positions of local Authority often showed little inclination toe build communism with bgeo hands thus a number of provincial officials attempted to restrict or suspend private trade on their own authority in December 1922 for example local decrees of this sort were issued in tambov simers styo pinza Minsk G and other ger this activity prompted stto to send out a circular stressing that such decrees violated Soviet
law local authorities were reminded that they must Not take measures that contradicted the basic principles concerning trade set forth in the decrees in and Orders of the central government besides s added as if for good measure these attempts to ban private trade simply did not work the NEP was always treated as Retreat as a necessary evil as a temporary cancer the government was not accepting or working with the net men simply tolerating them lenen constantly emphasized that the net men represented A danger and that the Fate not just on the bovic dictatorship but on socialism
as a whole hinged on eventually overcoming them and this was not guaranteed the NEP was seen by lenen and especially bukharan as the newest phase in the class struggle during the time in which the Soviet Union would operate the New Economic Policy the idea was that the state the Communists would be fighting an economic battle with the private Traders for the allegiance of The peasantry this was a class war of a new type the arena had shifted from the battlefield to the stores the new challenge of the bolik party was to demonstrate to The Peasant
that they could provide more to them than private capitalism could to quote Alan Ball this struggle was primarily one between the state and the nepman to submit a SCH smitchko with the peasantry would the state be able to supply the cooperatives with enough consumer goods to encourage The peasants to join the cooperatives and provide a grain Reserve to support the government's industrialization plans or would the peasants find it more advantageous to sell their produce to private buyers and patronize private shops this was the question that the bwick ciled over for the next seven years and
the anxieties and paranoia that plagued the party hampered the maximum implementation of the policy Lenin before he died never even gave a Detailed explanation of the policy only scattered remarks which his followers picked at in order to justify progressing or reeling backwards the allowances granted by the New Economic Policy as the NEP unfolded new amendments rules and regulations as well as a more systemized approach to its policy were created in July of 1921 it was announced that a leveling fee and a business tax were to be imposed and the size of this tax increased obviously
With the size of the business lone handicraftsmen were exempt from the tax but businesses employing between four to 75 workers were subject to varying degrees of Taxation private trade as a whole was divided into three tiers tier one included small scale Petty Street trade from Hawkers and the bazaars tier 2 encompassed trade from stalls and kiosks and the last tier included trade from large permanent establishments like retail stores in 1922 this was changed And the number of tiers increased to five and the sixth one was added in 1926 the new tiers were as follows rank
one trade by a person selling Goods that can be carried by hand in a sack and haw tray and so on tier two trade by a single person or with the help from one family member or hired worker conducted from temporary facilities at markets and bazaars or trade by no more than two people from small permanent facilities that the customer did not enter tier Three retail trade by the owner of the business and no more than four hired workers or family members conducted from a modest permanent shop designed for the customer to enter tier four
partial wholesale trade I.E the sale of small lots of goods from Enterprises with no more than 10 workers and Retail trade from permanent stores employing 5 to 20 workers or family members and tier five wholesale trade partial wholesale trade by businesses with over 10 workers and Retail trade from large stores with over 20 workers throughout 1921 a number of new taxes were announced that the netmen were to be subject to but as Alan Ball says quote it was one thing to announce these new taxes but quite another to collect them a numerous set of circumstances
such as the size of the country itself allowed many Enterprises to evade paying taxes in the early years of the NEP as a result this led to changes in the Soviet bureaucracy such As the creation of a new agency the domestic Trade Commission whose purpose was to circumvent the problem it is from here that the lack of clarity on how the New Economic Policy actually operated comes into play the state was vague on what the rules were neither local officials nor the netman had a grasp on what was or wasn't allowed and this led to
inconsistent treatment from local officials Alan Ball writes many netmen were also UNC about the new rules and Not only during the first months of the NEP in May 1923 for example a correspondent from the trade and Industry Gazette talked with a number of private meat vendors in Moscow more than anything else they complained that the state had still not worked out a definite set of principles to guide its officials in the supervision of the private sector as a result The Butchers claimed they were subject to widely varying treatment from different state Agencies and individual inspectors
most often this took the form of arbitrary tax assessments which could fluctuate dramatically even within a single District sometimes an individual shop was hit with such heavy taxer charges that it had to close while stores nearby remained comparatively unscathed local officials at times did whatever they pleased they might arbitrarily increase taxes on a private Trader or add an additional tax without approval from the Center they could overcharge for a license and effectively stifle private trade in a given area where still the ambiguity and arbitrariness was never consistent this was mirrored on the local level but
also in the highest organs of the government which never enacted a single consistent policy for the ne's implementation one year the net men's business is tolerated and even engaged with the next he is sent to the wolves and one Province and official Cooperates with your business and you work hand inand over in the next he is attempting to have you arrested one month you pay one tax the next you're told you have three to give an example not just of the arbitrariness but the ineptitude present in 1923 and 1924 the state resumed an offensive against
the netman they reduced the amount of State Credit available to a private individual and they also sharply reduced or completely ceased the sale of goods to Them the very next year the government reversed his policy Alan Ball writes in early 1924 an article in socialistic chesnik predicted that the campaign against private trade when inevitably produced an economic crisis that would prompt the biks once again to offer concessions to the netman the accuracy of this forecast became evident by 1925 when the netman experienced another abrupt change in the business climate this time it changed toward a
more Hospitable environment the rationale for this new policy was that in 1924 as during war communism the state had B off more than it could Chew in trying to rapidly replace the private sector oras one Observer remarked it was better for a region to have private Traders than no Traders as we all know there were constant switches back and forth between the socio ideological line pushed by the party leadership since in the period of the 20s the top leadership of the party Was in a free-for-all battle for control the period in which the netmen were
given a breath of fresh air was when bukharin was effectively the ideological head of the Bucks in the mid 1920s this however was not because he supported capitalism or because he liked the netman but because of two things firstly in his evolution of thinking following the war communism Fiasco he came of Mind in thinking that a society in the period of construction should not be at War of Itself and antagonistic measures would only be detrimental to economic equilibrium and thereby also to socialist construction secondly he was certain that the state had nothing to fear from
the netman since the bolik held political power therefore the unbothered dictatorship should work to utilize the netman to the best of its ability before their inevitable elimination and that the transfer of certain private Functions over to State Enterprises this meant the state needed to stop hampering the business of the netman and consequently economic growth with administrative measures I.E arbitrary over taxations arrests or confiscations according to Alan Ball in 1925 after the party switched to bukharin's new Trade Practices the volume of trade and the value of their sales increased however even bukharan the np's greatest Defender
was subject to flip-flopping the literal Next year mukar switched his policy to a more aggressive stance that called for heavier taxation as a means to acquire the finances for investment in industrial expansion even with bukharin's quote defense of the netman local antagonism over the existence of private Traders never ceased early in the existence of the NP one administrative Department even led a check of Detachment to arrest local netmen and impos price controls but These administrative actions usually did more harm than good because when the private Trader was on so is his Wares when people think
of the New Economic Policy it is likely that they think of the netman as the typical capitalist Robert Baron however this is far from the case whatever private industrialists did exist were limited to smallscale handicrafts Industries in fact the word nepman wasn't applied to Men of industry but speculators during The duration of the nap the large part of the private Endeavors that people were uptaking was petty bis trade furthermore the vast majority of these netmen were not from the previous cast of Private Traders but parvenues that is they were entirely new to this economic lifestyle
and as newcomers and rather poor newcomers mind you they were unable to produce the capital required to enter higher forms of capitalist trade Alan Ball put it perfectly when he said that Most netmen were rather primitive Petty Traders and Artisans hardly meriting the label of capitalist to quote him once more trade was without question the net men's most important occupation in the newly legalized realm of business both in terms of rubles and in terms of the number of people involved nearly all private trade was of simple basic consumer goods such merchandise required relatively small amounts
of capital to produce and was much in demand given the Widespread shortages of so many Necessities food was the commodity most frequently handled by private Traders particularly in the first months of NEP the food shortages in most cities and towns ensured that virtually anything edible could be profitably marketed but even in later years food represented 40 to 50% of the volume of private trade in the first months of NEP private trade was confined almost exclusively to Petty transactions and markets and bazaars Nothing more sophisticated or elaborate than that existed illegally during war communism people from
many different professions and walks of life Factory workers intellectuals demobilized soldiers pre-war Merchants Artisans invalids peasants and a large number of Housewives plunged in the trade in the quest of food clothing and fuel this was the essence of the first stage of the New Economic Policy food and Petty trade as we have seen the whole reason the Bolik even made the step back to enact the NEP was because they were unable to feed anyone the point of the NEP was to make it possible for people to acquire food and the goods that they needed because
they had largely disappeared as a result of the war and the state did not yet had the ability to take care of the needs of the people in the early days of the NEP Ordinary People were selling their household wees just so they could buy food from The Peasants Going into 1923 private bakeries made up 90% of the nation's bread output and even as late as 1926 half of the ussr's produced food products came from private manufacturers the goal of the NEP was to regenerate private trade but even during the New Economic policy's Peak the
volume of private trade never got past pre-war levels throughout the new economic policy's duration most of the trade that occurred was the previously mentioned small scale private trade and Not sophisticated or large scale capitalist Enterprise and even despite that fact it was still private trade that represented the vast majority of trade throughout all the SRS in the union especially those far-flung regions where the state had minimal control Alan Ball states that between 1925 and 1926 the net men's share of all trading operations was 97% in the USC Republic 97% in transcaucasia 93% in the turkman
Republic 80% in the Belarusian Republic 81% in the Ukraine 76% in the rsfsr and 79% in the USSR generally as the NEP progressed the scale of private retail trade and the number of licensed Traders was actually decreasing but it was decreasing at a faster rate than the state distribution system was growing therefore when the state sought to eliminate private Traders it often did so at a rate that they could not keep up with Alan Ball writes given this prominence of the private sector in the First 2third of the NEP the headlong elimination of the netman
after 1927 could not help producing Fallout across the land it was not unusual by 1928 to see such newspaper headlines as private entrepreneur eliminated but not replaced tgoo proma gazetta correspondence filled reports from around the country on the appearance of trade deserts which as the name suggests were regions in the countryside where no socialist shops appeared to fill the void created when The local netmen are driven out of business in such cases peasants often had to travel several sometimes even 30 to 40 kilometers to purchase essential products even if a village had a Cooperative store
or two they were frequently empty of desirable Goods when a shipment of merchandise arrived the useful items were snatched up in a day or two by customers who had been standing in line for many hours these problems were most acute in the Countryside but the rapid liquidation of private traders in Moscow prompted at least one Soviet reporter to apply the expression trade desert to the capital itself a colleague in smolin wrote that the elimination of private Traders there was proving to be something less than an unmitigated blessing for consumers this premature war against private Traders
created a Goods famine both in the country and the towns causing inverse streams of City dwellers and countrymen Traveling to each other's domains searching for those products they desired but were now absent the neb men had always had an advantage over the Socialist Industries which they competed with not due to the superiority of capitalist Enterprise but because actions on the part of the state at the start of the NEP the state industry had to make a series of cost cutting measures and Quick Cash grabs since they were not guaranteed funds by the Government one method
was the quick selling of products they had at low prices to the only available customers the netman many netmen then acquired a series of goods at very low prices even later into the NEP the state Cooperative system was still very weak according to Alan Ball for every 10,000 inhabitants of the countryside in 1924 there were six Cooperative stores one state store and 31 licensed private trading operations for most citizens and even For the state itself the only place to buy products from were from private retailers when there was a socialist store that had the goods
that a citizen or government official might have needed the product was often in poor quality and not desirable here also we must take into account the general incompetence of the Soviet bureaucracy in the early days a lot of the new bolic members of the Soviet bureaucracy didn't know anything about trading and so they s out Middleman many of them did not know that they could just acquire the materials that they needed from other state agencies one government agency contracted a netman to buy a shipment of coal and they gave him millions of rubles he simply
went and bought a large amount of coal from another government agency for a cheap price and kept for himself the large quantity of coal left over after fulfilling his obligation one netman even managed to sell to the state A warehouse full of goods that they already owned the New Economic Policy as it was was not exactly leading the so anywhere especially since their primary goal was industrialization during the course of the New Economic Policy most of the products being produced as you might have already assumed were consumer goods there is little incentive or even ability
to create the heavy machinery needed for large scale industrialization or Capital expansion for example in the Year 1924 only 100 trucks and 11 tractors were produced this is clearly not viable for the sort of industrialization dreamed by the members of the bull party and that industrialization desire so greatly by the top leadership of the party caused a new variation of the class contradiction traditionally expressed in capitalist Society in order to industrialize labor productivity which had sunk because of the war needed to increase and through The duration of the NEP the party with which theory of
the SCH smitka constantly pressured the workers to increase in productivity so they could have more Goods to sell to The Peasants the state increasingly relied on managers and was forced to follow the principle of profit making thus workers were laid off left unemployed and those who did did remain were encouraged to produce more and more faster and faster this sort of exploitation logically Culminated in the formation of a spontaneous workers resistance throughout the years of the NP from 1921 to 1926 there a series of Wildcat strikes walkouts and general disturbances in labor over such issues
as late payments layoffs Factory closures labor intensification demands for wage increases and against the introduction of peacework most of these disturbances and Strikes occur Union sanction they were spontaneous but not Anarchic the workers organized amongst themselves during the NEP the mass of wage workers had increased and this was due in part to the migration and proletarianization of peasants coming to the cities from the countryside the influx population as a result left many people unemployed the USSR now had its own Reserve Army of Labor which the state indeed made use of for its own cost cutting
ends when workers went on strike the state loomed the threat of Entering this Army over their head however the workers were granted an apparatus to resolve labor conflicts which they used to great effect but all in all the prime directive was to increase productivity economically speaking the New Economic Policy was not the sort of advanced capitalism that the bolik had desired now all that existed was a bureaucracy that was hostile to its own economic system and actively hampered it to the detriment of itself And its own citizens there is a depiction of the New Economic
Policy as a form of State capitalism but that does it too much just I think PR brainsky put it perfectly in 1921 when he stated some people tried unsuccessfully to give the name State capitalism to this variegated and mixed type of economy as a whole the name was inappropriate because it completely failed to embrace the whole diversity of Economic interrelations and was stolen from another economic form Real estate capitalism that is a system in which the capitalist state is interlocked with private capitalist production organized in trust and headed by the Banks the capitalism which existed
in Russia and which grew up mainly on the soil provided by private trade was very little state in character and the state had nothing in common with capitalism as it was an organization of the proletariat for smashing capitalism this mixed type of economy can be Depicted in the form of a pyramid divided into sections with the main section or fifs of the value of total annual production consisting of two dozen million Petty booa Enterprises with a stratum of patriarchal tribal economy Above This Petty boua Foundation arises a very much narrower zone of small and medium
capitalist Enterprises in trade and Industry not regulated by the state and then a still narrower zone of capitalist Enterprise under State Regulation the actual development of a truly modern capitalist economy begins with Stalin's first collectivization campaigns in the first 5-year plan W communism is often treated as an attempt to jump to socialism but in the case of its 1930s implementation during so-called primitive socialist accumulation it became a leap to Modern Industrial capitalism although the state liquidated the netman during its expanding control over the industry in The 1930s their number were already decreasing and much more
could have been done to destroy the netman by creating consistent means of employment than anything else since they were hardly real capitalists to begin with the New Economic Policy wasn't just an economic phenomenon but a cultural and social event the bolix had won the Civil War and we're now looking forward to the political and social evolution of Russian society and more specifically The Russian proletariat it was then important to determine who exactly was a proletarian and who therefore took up a position in the dictatorship of the proletariat the issue however was with the disintegration of
the Bazi and the disintegration of the industry there was also a disintegration of the proletariat millions of workers had left the cities for the countryside become Petty bouah Peddlers or join the Soviet bureaucracy how then was the dictatorship of the Proletariat supposed to operate with no proletariat in this environment of declass Soviet sociologists sought to determine who was and who wasn't proletarian through extensive research and study this was a difficult but important task because the information was necessary to enact discrimination against class enemies one interesting detail in their methodology was the idea of a supposed
proletarian conscience there still existed many millions of Proletarians in Russia but during the course of the Civil War the Bolsheviks had alienated many of them however since the bolik party was the party of the proletariat it was in their eyes not possible to be a proletarian if they did not support the party or the revolution these proletarians thus had a petty bgea mentality Sheila fit Patrick writes discussion of bis and Petty bgea Tendencies could sometimes be taken more or less literally for example a worker Whose wife was in trade might be said to be under
Petty bgea entrepreneurial influence and a worker peasant who clung to his plot of land in the village might be thought to show Petty bah proprial instincts in other cases however the accusation had a more tenuous connection to social reality for example for example bolic oppositionists and persons who had once belonged to other political parties were identifiable ifof facto as bgea or Petty bis when before the Revolution social stratification of society was evident and obvious afterwards it was not so clear the aristocracy was basically eliminated and the well-to-do Russians had already left what remained still were
elements of the clergy and the large mass of peasants who in the aftermath of War communism were joined by a newe Tye of class that of the worker peasant that is a worker who also managed farming in his spare time a worker who was tied to the land When before the Revolution most marriages were interclass in the totally scrambled social composition created by the crisis new familiar Bonds were created thus further adding to class confusion the bulwick would come up with a system of determining someone's Social composition by using a before and after system the
demarcation being the year 1917 but between the two categories your social composition before 197 17 was What mattered Sheila Fitzpatrick writes For bolic purposes the before category was The crucial one what really mattered about class from the boli standpoint was its implication for political attitudes if someone had been a member of the exploding class on the eve of the Revolution he or she was likely to regret the passing of the old regime and to dislike the biks but someone who had belonged to the exploited masses was probably on the side of the Bucks and Revolution
there remained a residual Problem about the before category namely that social origin and pre-revolutionary occupation did not always coincide for example it was common for a worker to have been born into to have spent his early years in the village for purposes of party entry and the like his social composition was defined as proletarian but what was the right category for a former worker Village born and now a Cadre the answer was still proletarian even though the individual in question Might have spent less than 10 of his 30 years actually working in a factory being
a proletarian then sometimes didn't involve actually being an exploited member of the working class but a formative experience peasants who served in the Red Army thus could be considered proletarian through the formative experience of fighting for the proletarian Revolution to be a proletarian was to have a great deal of social advantages in a sort of inverse Of what you would see in bis Society the Bushi the old Elite that still remained had also been declassed they now occupied much more humble positions but this did not stop them from facing discrimination a child of abushi was
was prevented from joining the commo or from receiving higher education kulaks members of the clergy and other members of what you would have called the upper class were deprived of the right to vote but sometimes the matter wasn't always As simple as Sheila fish Patrick demonstrates one might be the child of a priest but live his life married to a peasant he might therefore cling to the identity that had more sway on his actual economic life methods of avoiding this form of genetically inherited discrimination was adoption by a proletarian family or by breaking ties and
renouncing your family the NEP period of Russia created amongst the Russian youth a sort of romanticization Of the proletarian lifestyle they desire to toil and work in the factory to be an authentic proletarian in the aftermath of the Revolution the Communists sought to construct a new culture based on proletarian principles out with the old in with the new those rituals of the Zars era would be supplanted by Soviet proletarian ones when before a child would be baptized now they would go through a red Christian in October ring new re evolutionary holidays were added To the
calendar in society at large appealed to the Revolutionary idea and all of its cultural Dimensions another of those new aspects of society was the introduction of women into those historically male-dominated Industries like typ setting another new was a more concerted effort in struggling against alcoholism Leisure Life for the average Russian proletarian was marked by drinking away his wages at bars this was hardly the lifestyle befitting of a Proletarian revolutionary those old cultures which the Communists sought to eliminate were labeled as bis M chonski or neovi the Communists made great efforts to cease those cultural habits
of alcoholism and sexual misconduct on the part of Russian men a campaign was made to advertise workers clubs and alternative methods of recreation as well as to instill within the workers class Consciousness and dedication to communist ideas Dian coner writes Workers would replace the pernicious old pastimes with participation in public life through party unions cooperatives voluntary organizations such as Friends of the air fleet and Friends of Children through Goodwill missions to adopted Villages and military units workers would celebrate the open air take excursions to Scenic and historic spots swim engage in athletics all of these
activities receiv received extensive coverages in the trade Union press and a Few overworked Union organizers labored diligently to provide Leisure opportunities for workers particularly in clubs and rest homes there is so much more to explore on the cultural experiences of not just Russia but the whole of the Soviet Union which consisted of numerous republics during the seven years that the nap operated but I'll conclude here with a short summary despite the overarching control of the state and the party during the NP In comparison to other periods of Soviet history it was comparatively liberal in fact
During the stalinist period the cultural aspects of the nap were denounced as rotten liberalism characterized by bgea culture and during the NP and during bukar and's Reign specifically the USSR was far more Pless and cons at there was lots of experimentation going on in the Arts as well as noticeable Western influence you can certainly see this in the Advertisements of the era there are often attempts made by historians and cultural analysts to determine if the NEP could have been an alternative path for Russia but from my perspective it was the economic realities of the NP
itself which directed the USSR on the path that it took if there was an alternative it would not have been one which the bolic modernist would have wanted to take