[Music] well it's an enormous pleasure for me to be here and I particularly like also speaking to audiences where you have legal scholars because that is forever an engagement in the kind of work that I do and forever the need to discover how far does my argument go if i factor in notions of law which inevitably contain de limitations not limitations the delimiting of an argument so I also really look forward to your questions to your comments because I learned that way I'm by now a nice old little professor who keeps discovering I'm so happy
that I'm still living because there's so many things are changing you know it's like a little revolution continuously and as I travel around the world believe me there are many unsettlement that are taking place in many parts of the world so let me well you already love that and and what I want to talk about is precisely that the rise of extractive logics we tend to think of the extractive as in mining you extract once you extract the the characteristic of an extractive logic in in my my reading is that once you extract you don't
care what happens in the site where you have extracted it's an absolute effect whereas in other fields you want wherever you take something from to grow and to expand because you will need more of it and when you when you think of am particularly also thinking about extractive logics in our economy it in high finance is really algorithmic math you know it has nothing to do with the traditional economics and it really functions as an extractive sector and I'll be talking a bit about that so it is a very radical and extreme component of our
current reality that I want to talk about with you and I repeat it is very extreme but it's happening and in a way it is spreading and some of the research I've been doing most most recently again confirms that this now has to do with the buying up by major financial firms of modest housing complexes not just little houses housing complexes all across the world not in China they haven't gotten into China yet these are mostly Western entities so when I talk about the rise of extractive logics I'm talking about something that is very real
that is happening even though it is still confined only to certain settings you know it's not happening everywhere I'm sure it's not happening here in your time the who knows we have been surprised you know we have a whole team doing research across the world now let me start with this notion that we make sounds good there are good things that we made but we also made this the RLC you recognize it in 20 years we managed to destroy one of the largest internal seas that we have you have to stand back and say wow
it's an accomplishment of sorts we did that we also did this you know these capabilities the questions that this raises in my mind is if we could do this what else could we do that is profoundly transformative so over hovering over the negatives for me is also the notion of wreck recovering a capability that now is a negative how do we make it into a positive now this is something I just brought that in because I thought maybe some of you would would see the point here but this notion of key codes and the capacity
to aggregate the capacity to jump up how we can with existing capabilities not stick it in the negative vector but also take it in a positive vector so I'm doing this with my son who is a crazy artist unlike his mother who's not crazy that's mean by the way the mother because you know it's really interesting to see how artists are dealing with some of these issues let me start with raising a question to get at the the properties the particularity 's of our current book I don't know if I can do I need the
mic I maybe need the mic so what is the steam engine of our aerbook if you want that which can make no ordering without changing everything because that is one of the crucial modalities of course of transformations that which shapes what is in and what is out and we have had such argue that today it's high finance and high finance has nothing to do with economics I think this is a crucial issue and maybe there are some of you legal scholars who will disagree with me and let's have a discussion let me use as an
example this this is a fairly known element and it's just one little element this is credit default swaps outstanding nineteen nineteen billion in 201 62 trillion just a few years later question invitation think of anything that has this capacity of growth and this which I described was only 10% of the value in play of finance so just know how I'm not I lose the plot up why isn't this oh you know what this is it attached to moving here yeah okay it's okay now this is another element that I want to put on the table
and then I'll return in in a more generic way to some of these capabilities footnote we tend to think of the term capability as a positive a capability sound positive but of course there are capabilities there are very dangerous there are negatives that are marked by extractive lodgings so here but now returning to this so dark pools in finance I'm told I don't know how many of you heard about this but it's a growing condition in in high finance in the financial world and see here we have Europe and the United States as you can
see you know a bunch of these dark pools the term dark pools is not my turn it's a term of the head of the central bank at a given moment in time about ten years ago when this sort of begins to get going now United States very number one likes being number one and Europe number two there are other countries that are also engaging this I don't know how many of you I repeat heard of dark pools in finance but they are private networks owned by private firms that are today the main instrumentalities in the
world of high finance it's not the the the publicly known and recognized like the central bank or the whatever other institutions it's private networks number two there are very long lists of firms are talking business firms waiting to be accepted in one of these private pools number three and these are the words by the head of the central bank we do not know what happens in these dark pools and he going to term dark pools for them so what we see we the citizens we see the stock market moment when it comes to high finance
and a lot of this stuff would also have a moment in the stock might stop our market is a public entity in principle anybody has access to it I mean you have to go through a few parameters so to say radically different from this dark pool in finance I mentioned this to just emphasize a capability a capability that is really quite extraordinary quite private we know very little the head of the central bank also knows very little and there are long waiting lists of entities the owners of these black dark pools are private actors as
you can see it's also entered in Europe and I would love to know if there is somebody here who is working on what's happening in Europe because it's not so easy to get the date I let's put it that way why am I having oh yeah right okay we discovered that that's there we go so so finances capability in both direct and indirect pathways so here I want to just give you a few examples this is what became a crisis in the United States it was considered a crisis generated and this is very important by
fairly low income people who and I quote thought they could afford to buy a house put whatever money they had signed whatever contracts got a house and five or ten years later they all went bankrupt fourteen million house forty point 14.5 million households went bankrupt that's a very large number certainly if you think of a country like the Netherlands you know what that would mean that we were like over the whole country is bankrupt 14.5 million households could be you know you multiply the effect of all the people involved in a given household etc it
affected a lot of people in a big country like the United States in a country like the United States which is still living a bit sometimes in the Wild West it doesn't need to know what all is happening all over it many people never found out that this happened now I want you to think what does it mean to spell 14 million households from their home because that's what happened basically I mean it took years we're talking a period of about nine years but it's a vast number of people and it was invisible every household
could have been ten people five people three people we don't have a visual on it because that's another modality you can engage in massive operations that never reveal that they're massive because you know it happens over years it happens in many different districts it happens so many people never really in the United States never really found out that you had this little history going on and here are just some of the figures foreclosures for those I mean you are some of you at least you know are familiar with these guys and so this is also
includes repetitions now because it's not just singles that we are talking millions and that's another thing what is it about our current system anticipate that a huge number can sort of navigate the situation as if it never happened many people in the United States never found out that this happened that all these people were expelled from their homes I mean 14 million households again it could be 20 million people 30 million people okay now here is something something else that is also connected well this is the this is Europe in Europe but we they have
stopped counting I've been trying it if any of you knows after 2 or 9 it's very difficult to get access to these figures but Europe went through something similar on a much lower scale and so here are some of those figures and as you see you know and and this is what European countries with either highest or lowest number of foreclosures and I don't know why we can their data after 209 but I would really like to know if there is anybody who knows why but again it gives you sort of a sense and and
really the list goes on and on I just don't have it now you understand the language of foreclosure so I don't know it's an English term but other LM I'm just putting elements here on the table ratio of household credit to personal disposable income right so you now I want to find out so we all know that in 2000 the figure the dates your matter 2000 to 2005 mm is when Eastern Europe especially I'm especially focusing here on Eastern Europe when Eastern Europe sort of you know enters basically the western-style economic system and certainly in
finance and in loans and all of that whether modest so I just want to so let's just go to this title ratio of household credit to personal disposable income credit credit is a very special word credit suggests that you have it you can spend it it's a bit yours well and listen to it happens Czech Republic ratio of household credit to personally supposed to be credit is dead by the way right it is dead for the household it's credit for its peculiar language so on this is not my language in other words I'm sort of
also engaging in a critique of it of this language the so here of Czech Republic 2008 point 5 by 2 or 5 and these years are crucial here 27 percent ah hungary 11 percent household credit debt 39 percent so yeah so it just goes on now it's a same time the united states it was already way of the chart right look at this 104 105 germany on their hand admirable stability and 70 is very reasonable 70 70 70 70 70 is my name and so you look at these different countries you know I mean most
of these countries down here have been rather reasonable now when I see these type of data and this is just one microcosm there it is a microcosm that is why they're mostly a certain type of country I immediately have a few questions and so and so I want to know who owns that debt that you know those contracts that modest households bought in this case in Eastern Europe etc now here we see share of foreign currency denominated household credit and to a five in percent original household etc so Hungary Romania etc are some of the
countries where you had a lot of this debt functioning right and oh you know what I have a slight missing here I'm really sorry well let me I'll elaborate on it so these columns that you see here indicate foreign ownership of this household debt Germany owns a lot of this debt you know there are a few countries that own a lot of this that all the Germanic countries in this particular group that I was looking at in Eastern Europe Germany Austria and Switzerland owned that debt of those modest households in those other countries that to
me is significant because you know if the local bank in your neighborhoods owns your debt that is something totally different you know that's a little neighborhood effect and you pay your interest rates then the bank you know etc etc can develop more business and whatever you can imagine another nice local bank these models have became part of a grabbing operation soup a little bit brutally but it was in a way a grabbing operation that is happening right now in many parts of the world including in in Asia etc and not in China China's totally different
where you have using the use of modest localized households where international banks move in and take out they and if you have a million of those even if there are low payments it accumulates but on top of that there is an extractive mode it's not like your local bank that wants to enable you and wants to enable your sons and daughters no it's this extractive and now it's in the housing question I've I recommend to all of you who might be interested a film called push not a good title that anyhow push tracks one of
the major corporations that we think of as a financial firm based in the United States which in many parts of the world including in Asia is buying up huge housing complexes is for poor people for modest income people and redoing them now they're making money of this and the result of doing all that upgrading is a doubling of rents you know the story right and so the poor the lower-income people who used to live there are out this is something now I don't want to mention the corporation that is doing this this is just one
we are tracking and now we have all the documentation etc it will enter the public domain pretty soon parts of it already half so this is one huge firm a global firm that does high finance and they're doing this this is this the this is you know buying up all these modest or all these big buildings with modest properties this is new this has a bit of it has always happened but on this scale that you have major financial firms buying up housing modest house housing complexes all over is new and and it raises a
whole bunch of questions that I don't want to dwell on now but that are worthwhile sort of thinking about in short extractive sectors an extractive sector is a particular type of sector can extract even from modest households so there was a time when a modest household was a modest household was a modest household today you actually need to check it out that very modest household is actually likely to be part of a huge field of materiality that the financial system has generated is interested in and has been generated and with algorithmic mathematics as I already
said you transform a million little houses into something that is no longer we see the house the building by algorithmic mathematics you have a field of material assets and that is what the high income investment sector wants they do not want derivatives derivatives are for you and me they're out for the high it used to be you know the derivatives have been around for a long time they were a success but now what they want is asset backed securities how do you generate asset backed securities you need some meta realities in there all those the
acquisitions of all of very modest houses and we're talking millions now has to do not with the little house it has to do with asset backed securities so you have a real asset I don't know if you're following what I'm saying but this is pretty disastrous if a modest building can be transformed in something that can produce high value as an asset as an asset-backed security not good not good now here's another extractive mode so I think of these all as logics that are centered in extraction in not generating not building or taking a risk
in extracting this is something that I'm assuming some of you have heard about which is really a very significant buying of fancy buildings in major cities the full list is a hundred hundred cities in the world which are sort of the top you know the Liveris if you want or objects of desire and so this is just one year it happens to be a very significant year because it is when it first really takes off and the figures so that we are talking 2013 to 2014 have read sort of over a year now what you're
seeing here is first in New York in the metro just in one year 55 trillion bought in-house in-house billions and that tempera nine ten per ten point nine percent is growth over the prior year London 47 Tokyo and then he goes on so you have a hundred now you have Hong Kong this - does not mean that this is a - this is a positive but compared to the prior year of acquisitions this is lower now I am working with a hundred of these and it is quite enjoyed know if I'm if I'm communicating what
this is about but this is about just buying property of all sorts and I will develop what comes next right but it is buying buying buying and this is just looking at foreign buyers and foreign investors so you have London is the queen of the domain no and then New York there is much less so but again the list you know and again the the list of the hundred is is quite interesting now I must tell you that term in London now just as an example London is an extreme SOI the Qatari Royals own more
of central London than the Queen of England which I sort of find same party almost you know what I mean sort of how mean she really good number two you can't see that it's not like the buildings are telling us now we belong to the Qatari Royals so again how we're losing traction in terms of what the material world tells us because I think there were earlier times when the material world really told us a lot I think we're moving into a time when between algorithmic mathematics and I don't know what all certain certain elements
of our current internationalism like anybody can buy anywhere we are losing that the material is written in the capacity if you want to tell us what is actually going on okay the total value of these types of acquisitions which is a limited number you understand it's a minority of buildings anywhere in the in the 100 top cities by acquisition this is just acquisitions of existing buildings not new construction that is all that so you have mid 2014 to mid 2015 it was 600 billion May 2015 to May 2016 over a trillion so there is a
lot of money in play sort of circulating as if it doesn't know what to do with itself this is why these housing some are empty some are not many are empty though I want to emphasize that I'll come back to that point okay yes so the top 100 cities by property investment in 2016 account for 10 percent of the world's population 30 percent of the world's GDP 76 percent of property investment now I put this these are not my figures I put this in this type of separate modality because I don't think it's investment that's
the language that they are using I think it's something else an investment we associate with certain types of product productive molds something this is different one result by the way our empty buildings in Manhattan London in Paris we have a lot of empty buildings I alluded to it earlier already and people think oh poor investors something went wrong and the question is did something go wrong or is an empty building actually better than an occupied building it's a real question I'll come back to it too so here just collective figures worldwide real estate assets these
are figures that come from Seville and Seville's is really everywhere in the world it's a it's a it's a money-making corporation hey it's not a research operation so I was in Phnom Penh trying to get some data having a hard time surveillance they had the data I needed I was a bit in shock because I you know it's not my mode to work with her with commercial operations but on yeah well but real estate assets comprise nearly 60% of the value of all global assets that's an impressive number and that takes a lot of people
by surprise including equities bonds and gold so this is sort of a total figure of all these buildings that are in play if you want again the the figures come from Seville now one one question that I asked what do I see what do my eyes tell me about that reality in the making so one way of putting it is what does this all look like this is civilized London central London here is the Thames and here are these buildings mostly their old buildings so a journalist a German journalist they're always so serious the German
journalist said after we had talked he said let's go through the place what you're talking about and I don't usually do that by the way you know I just sit there dude and so I found myself in this very touristic area in central London there is no and ah and I heard the tour is it's full of tourists that's why I never go there I don't know that I'm a tour across myself too but I'm at and so I heard them say look at these beautiful British buildings these are all owned and they are beautiful
British buildings I think that's an ugly but anyhow most of them are very beautiful they're all owned by one Chinese company now I don't hold this against a Chinese by the way I want to emphasize that very very clearly I just find it interesting it's an invitation to think what am I actually seeing what would he and I'm dealing both with something quite abstract which is what is the capacity of the material today in today's world to have speech there was a time I think when the material had quite a bit of speech I'm not
so sure today and this is one of those examples that you see all these nice British looking things and none of them is owned by a Brit so so you know there is something to me very interesting about that besides the fact isset ease on the ground in our ground level which is the business is involved in all of that let me move totally different just on Peshawar on property purchased by overseas companies all of these companies I have the full list are abroad none of them has a name that we recognize they all have
you know this is a certain kind of formula that gets used for some of these firms no that's a lot of buying I don't know if you can see that that's just a larger London area this is something that is repeating itself I am tracking this in many different parts of the world I am not sure where it all goes I think that there are different utility functions involved so different projects if you want but there it is and it's probably growing as we speak okay baby come on now this is another thing that you
see in Manhattan and you see it in London and you also see it in bit in Paris were more difficult to establish the New York has had a mode of building as you can see that sort of stands out if you go to Paris you rarely would see that the Queen standing out there like that I mean the Queen's at the buildings I don't mean any real Queen and so you see in Manhattan I mean happen is a little bit of land it's not huge you know it's not big these towers that are actually mostly
empty and by now these are all dark why am I having such trouble yeah so 57% of condos are owned by shell companies you know this is a familiar bit I'm just going to show one more right and this is the plaza these are all very fancy buildings and the point I want to make here is that gradually less and less people are living there because they don't like living there because it's empty and in fact the buildings now they want them all out because the building can function as a physical element that can feed
a different type of instrument having people is bother having people is a drag having people means that you have to pay for this and for that leave the building empty it's the best business deal that is a bit alarming and now I told you we just did this huge project tracking across many countries in the world there is a film is out it's an amazing film called I repeat push that name Daniel how much of this is happening in different parts of the world that they're buying up the buildings and leaving them empty and an
empty building can produce more better types of income than an occupied building why because it's not the building it's what I started out with by algorithmic math you have a pile of assets doesn't matter what is the toilet the wall doesn't matter it's not a visual thing and there you built asset backed securities which is what the high income sector wants they don't want derivatives I repeat myself derivatives are for you and me they are tired they don't deliver much they have been overused so I elaborate for us the high investment circuit asset backed securities
that is what they want how do you produce an asset-backed security you need a lot of materiality to produce the asset part of it and then you bring in you know all the other instrumentalities that make it a financial instrument you know all right yeah so one I don't quite entir that this was also meant as an ending you know when I asked myself as I go around the world and believe me most countries and most continents are not like this continent here what are the format's of the future when it comes to this kind
of stuff you know of the the how people will live how what is the meaning of cities etc and thinking of our larger world where most people are poor and are getting expelled from their land because this is a thing that is happening so with those kinds of elements I spoke a bit in shorthand but I'm sure you could follow so this is one juxtaposition by the way there is no part in the world where you can stand and see this I just want to alert you to because every hour very often questions can you
tell me where that was both are real though the one up there is a mix this is real but it's not like there is a place where you can stand and then also see that other but this is the juxtaposition that in many ways captures the future in most parts of the world except me Europe is really different there and the United States a bit the Americas because it's so huge you know but this is you know this very dense not fully regulated but not criminal either you know the this side of throne and then
the towers and if there is no land we're building on water now we might ask why does all of this matter you know so what you could just say so there they do it that with it here where there are a few crops involved in the whole thing but but for me the city is a critical space for those without power in today's world where most land we may look at a map and say oh but there's so much empty land it's all owned there are 30 governments that have been buying land all over outside
the wrong land and there are over 150 corporations that for a whole variety of reasons in all kinds of different economic sectors have been buying land there is almost no open land there is a bit you know in certain parts of Africa and certain parts of Asia but basically we're out of land as we are also out of sand for building you have heard that part right I love adding that I just thought about it it has nothing to do with my lecture here but yeah so so the city so why does the city matter
the city as a space where those without power get to make a history and I think that that is very important and when you look at I repeat where I started at destroyed you know over the centuries what has survived remember that cities have outlived very powerful actors governments kings queens you name it the city is still there after all these regimes are gone and what has especially survived are the neighborhoods of the poor which in a way were Untouchables in one version or another in Europe we didn't call it Untouchables but they were basically
and the the big palaces or the BEC you know public monuments and all of that what has gone on and the errors of the middle class is the broad middle classes so but this notion that the neighborhoods of the poor and the sort of the central part of the representational side of the city has outlived across centuries all kinds of forms of power kings queens you know whatever is to me also an interesting datum secondly the capacity of urban space and I'm thinking especially now of big cities cities that are a bit messy that cannot
be fully controlled so in the u.s. we have a few of those but around the world we have a lot of those so the capacity of the city to make us all whether rich or poor into urban structures even if only for a moment of the day now I think in here in your beautiful city though I haven't quite gotten to know it clearly but I've got to know very nice parts of it maybe this all you know is sort of I think the Netherlands especially Europe is very special Europe is different really from most
of the areas that I am talking about right and when Omega and how this notion that everybody like in the subway in New York where you have I wouldn't say the super-rich but many very high income people you just take the subway because the only way to get quickly to your home or whatever it might be and the poor the homeless and those who haven't been able to wash themselves for a month all of it is together in our subway our subways are also falling apart I don't know if anybody has recently been there it's
a scandal huh public domain doesn't get any money then yeah there are moments in the city where this is possible this absolute intersection of all subjects and this matters one instrument in supporting the notion of a civic subject you know is that that there are moments and there are conditionalities that make us all into urban subjects sort of the notion of a civic subject beyond wealth and beyond poverty and not to do with poverty the city and and so another language that I like to use I've written whole all text about this the notion of
the city as a hacker hacker you know what I mean by that right service that you unsettle the hacking is unsettling that you unsettle the basic meaning the traditional meaning and a city is an extraordinary place not a tiny totally controlled City but a big city that cannot be fully managed you know where you are really it sort of hacks subjects that think themselves all powerful and it hacks the poor because the poor certainly have also a kind of presence this is a bit romantic I admit it it doesn't work with with legal scholars but
ah and so this is unlike the typical trends for the post-world War two patterns because then you had a after world war two there is a lot of quite civilized building and and sort of a sense of the Civic and you know it's a very interesting period actually after World War two that happened certainly in the West and and now I feel that after 1980 for me 1980s is the break when we globalize deregulate and privatize a lot in many countries extreme case is of course the the Americas but Europe also begins to do that
then you enter a different period and so I think one way of marking that difference is this very they have always existed logics of extraction have always existed that we really see an ascendance of logics of extraction so traditional banking coming back to that initial example traditional banking is Commerce it sells something for a prize money well we all need it we can get better whatever a better education better I don't know what ah but when you extract that's it there is no it's up and that's what high finance is its extracting so a lot
of the stuff that I've been talking to you about actually it's very much linked to extractive notes where as we tend to think of housing the housing question as something we all needed a city needs it you know there is our deep histories around the question of housing and I I really think this is a change again I urge you to see this film called push which looks at what I have been describing here on par saw a bit in in many different countries including countries in Asia where the housing question is no longer the
housing question it's a different question it's really a different now very quickly I I just wanted to show these this is a particularly crucial moment these are just big trends I'm sure that many of you are already familiar with it but I just wanted to put that also on the map this is one way of capturing a lot of what I talked about these these these are the logics in play corporate profits corporate profits have long existed here is the difference what what happens here goes up the crisis famous crises to await to attend it
lasted about three minutes for them and then higher than before for most of the people in the US it was a crises I don't know if every where but in many parts right and this is even better corporate assets the crisis is that little little wrinkle there you see that where it sort of goes down a bit it goes up so we have two worlds in our big cities we have two worlds one that really can have a crisis and the other one that can feed off a crisis which is a relative different proposition this
I don't know if people can understand the graph but anyhow this is 1917 to two or five but it really goes on I'm sorry it's cut off their income share of 10% top earners so you have a high I there you know and then it becomes this nice lower level curve for the majority are middle-class households that are doing very nicely etc and 1987 1999 it goes up again in other words concentration of wealth and of advantage right so we have this period in our West now this is the United States United States always a
bit extreme but this is the same curve you see in many of our countries certainly in the UK and in Argentina and in the well you have a period here this you know this is like after a World War two you have several decades where you really have a sense of the growth of the middle class more opportunities of blah blah blah and many people still think that this is now no that really begins to change in the 1980s and you have again a concentration rather than this sort of more distributed notion I don't know
if this graph I'm hoping that it that it is clear I want to end with something that I like to think of as unstable meanings a lot of what I've been talking about is marked by a certain kind of instability of meaning now legal scholars are very good at detecting where is the stability of a concept of us so I like throw this notion of an unstable meaning now given all of these negatives we have now grown rapidly now you can all read that etc this is the question who are we the citizens in this
setting you know there is enough negative and the United States is certainly an extreme case so I want you to show you this map and this map is in the public domain how many of you have seen this any I see somebody there you have seen it oh no you were maybe saying hello okay in the United States almost nobody has seen this map this is suspending actually and people often think that I'm showing something that is secret you know these are here are the numbers all buildings that are tracking all of us if you
were there for two days or half a day you're in that system if my old grandma went to have a cup of coffee in the village in New York she's in there we're all in there the entities are a vast number of institutions that are gathering data on all of us gathering data gathering data huge buildings are being built also in the middle of the country to house all the information now and it's in the public domain because the Washington Post with enormous courage and they have to pay a big fine because they were said
we're going to put it and you find it in the Washington Post 2010 here's the information it has a lot of data I'm just showing you this one map to me it is very important to realize how few people in the United States know there that there is this capacity to track all of us there is an ironic point that I make that not everybody agrees with me they have gathered so much data that we really could use it they can't they get lost you realize I mean all those buildings are continuously gathering data so
you know it's like the curve yeah good good good good and then you have so much forget it so they often what happens is they track the person in the field you know on the street or whatever and then they try to find more information in this enormous collection of data all electronic you know gathering and I you know they don't tell us really very much I don't know that it doesn't always work now if I may I'm just going to run through this so I'm thinking Joe D of Aragon and Snowden you know snow
right so this is what we know and I emphasize what we know which is very limited but this we know that the NSA the National Security Agency can do so far because by now you know who knows where they are so when you read it goes on and some of it is so ridiculous this is it really like I don't know if I can see one of them here but I can spy it can spy on US law firms representing foreign countries and trade negotiations okay that is sort of a meaningful thing but I went
there is another one that they have here that chose you I hate some of the stuff is just so preposterous it's like a system that has gone out of control like they can they can they can enter for instance the United Nations discussions you know which I foreclosed Dorothy I got if it's top secret you know it's any up so I just want to end with this now in Europe you know you also have this right started in 2015 right and it breaches recent European Court of Justice you know you know more about this than
I do and that's it thank you very much [Applause] [Music]