okay I have a lot to talk about today and we move one century and then move into another culture both are very important it may move from 17th century England to 18th century France we move from a situation which was dominated by civil war chaos and the yearning for a clear suberin and we move in a century you can call it of enlightenment that's where the term enlightenment comes from the French context and the century of decadence eventually it leads to a revolution but before the Revolution there is a lot of fairly juicy decadence so
two different epochs and two different cultures British individualism Hobbes and Locke were methodological individualists they thought the analysis should start always with the individual you remember Hobbes right individual drives and fears and then he builds up but society is starting always from the individual not the French the French are methodological collectivists they believe there is such a thing as society which is more than the sum total of the individuals and somehow they know how to grasp it so these are the changes what you will see today Thursday and next Tuesday when we will be discussing
Montesquieu and jean-jacques Rousseau before we return to British individualism Adam Smith and John Stuart Mill don't ask me why this difference between the two cultures but there is an lasting difference today's topic is Montesquieu and I have a lot of fun stories to tell but I try to limit my anecdotes so I can focus enough on the text and do not run out of time by the end okay so that was Montesquieu he was born as char Slough ásecondá Baron dura bread was born in 1689 near Bordeaux his father was from a noble family but
because he was a younger son he had to become a mercenary and in fact he was fighting Turks in Hungary he received a law degree nevertheless from the University of Bordeaux and and in 1715 he did what many aristocrats did he married a wealthy woman Jean lar stick which was helpful for him because it was not all that very bossy though he was a nobleman his uncle was a Baron de Montesquieu and when he passed away Shalu II received his title he became Montesquieu and inherited his office the presidency of the Parliament of Bordeaux don't
think about it was not a very big deal and certainly did not offer income for a luxurious life was not particularly affluent stuff and was not particularly powerful stuff now a bit about the times and well here it is Louis quatorze the heights of French absolutism well he caught him he was called the Sun King and here is his emblem the Sun he you know the Sun he's shining like the Sun well he actually claimed that's a famous sentence and important to understand Montesquieu later Sam what I am the state well was a kind of
an overstatement not quite he pretended to be more powerful than he actually was the French absolutism shows you ordered it cracks and the bourgeoisie was becoming already quite powerful under the times of Louis quatorze but he had the notion of French glory the glory right and and he built his wonderful palace of their size showing what you are or glory is president to go right also emphasize emphasize the French go ah the French are very fond of it okay the 18th century was the century of enlightenment they call the cycle of linear linear means light
it was the car who transformed philosophy towards the cold view cold look of reason and that was the van which was spreading in 18th century England culminating in the 1789 revolution and we see two major steps in this direction Montesquieu and Rousseau well one of the major accomplishment of the Enlightenment were the publication's of encyclopédie the sort of predecessor British encyclopaedia britannica Alva D Joe and Dalembert edited and which put together rationalistic scholarship of the time well here you have the first edition for encyclopédie as Louie Catorce passed away his five-year-old great-grandson Louis fifteen became
the king and route for a very long time well the decay of absolutism and royal authority continued and we are really entering now with 1715 one probably the longest in modern history the longest epoch of decadence and sexual permissiveness it's interesting kind of seemed to recur in human history right then you had a similar kind of permissiveness and sort of decadence 1890s until 1914 probably 1930 and then the 1960s of course right when everything goes well this was a time of this kind well he was not particularly interested in governing but he was very interested
in the beautiful women well he was quite a good-looking guy when he was young as well so I'm sure women were quite interested in him too and you know the name Madame pompadour was the most famous and most influential of his mistresses as I said it was becoming right a time of sexual permissiveness promiscuity divide spread also affected Montesquieu here is madame pompadour indeed a very beautiful person but not only beautiful she was extremely smart as as far as we can tell Eva was an intellectual of very distinguished States taste he knew all people of
the Enlightenment both they're one of the big trouble makers of his time and he supported the draw and the project of encyclopédie which is was unusual because you know royal authority did not really like this one well and let me just give you a little ethnography if you are interested the liaison dodgers pierre short end o la claw wrote a novel about the sexual mores of this time which is called the dangerous relationships the liaison dodger is well there was two movies out of made of it and anybody watched any of these movie nobody watch
it wonderful movie where there are two versions one by Roger Vadim and that puts the whole story in French society of its time and the other one is an American one seven fairs and it is Glenn Close who features in it now this is the Pierre Vadim movie you can borrow it do you will have fun and you will have an understanding right but meet an 18th century in France was and there Montesquieu and Rousseau are coming from and of course this is the American version with Glenn Close she's already you know the person what
she likes to play right the dishes woman okay now Montesquieu well he lives in the century of enlightenment and Thomas curiousness he sells his office though I mean he mainly lives from the verse of his wife salsa band business but then he leaves the vine business to the wife and he beginnings to travel in Europe and in England then when he returns he settles in Paris leaves the wife back you know to run the Rhine business and he beginning to write he writes publishes in 1721 already the Patterson letters I talked about this before and
then he was elected on the basis of this to académie française the French Academy of Sciences and part a very big accomplishment at this very early age and finally 1748 he publishes the major book this is really a very important book I hope you did what I asked you glanced at it not an easy read a bit drier and then some of the texts we read but very important fundamentally important stuff did you ask him to write something for the encyclopedia about democracy but he's bored with the question of democracy he wrote enough about this
so he writes an article on taste okay and he died in 1755 in Paris so these are the times and this is your order Montesquieu let me move on to the work yeah so here we go the spirit of the laws and here is the first edition so what is this book the first part is law in general and different modes of governance interesting not path-breaking this is not what he will be remembered for though I mean that he is opening some very important subject matters the second one is law and politics and separation of
powers viv you see right he builds on Locke and takes Locke him a big wave forward great improvement in many ways you know to the extent that is improvement of course Locke has some insight which is missing from the Montesquieu and formulation of separation of powers then he has this extraordinary section on law and climate this is one of his big contributions I will show you I mean the way how he formulated is extremely naive and almost borders on the ridiculous but given at the 21st century there are very few people with the exception of
even cardoon whom I named already right in the introductory lecture who was so sensitive that society lives in this globe right and how society is formed and structured and how its laws are being shaped is actually greatly influenced by the nature of environmental and climatic conditions so he is the first of ecologist he is the first environmentalist right who understand the interaction between social organization mores ethics ideas and society right and then there there is a bit on law Commerce have your very briefly talked about this law and religion and I will skip this section
altogether and lo and history I also skipped so what are the main themes first you know will be about classification of governments then I will talk about separation of powers and then environment law and social structure these the issues they will be rushing through there's a lot of stuff to look at it well before Montesquieu the question when they classified government was who rules who is the sovereign Montesquieu changes some what the discourse he's interested in the manner of governments how people who are in authority grew the real basic distinction whether a government is moderate
or whether it is despotic now what are the questions in when you try to judge the nature of a government one important question you he said you should ask are the various power separated or not irrespective who rules whether it can be a king it can be an elected president it can be a prime minister the question is are the power separated and the next question is this is very important why do people obey the question why people obey orders is touched upon by Hobbes and Locke but it's not really elaborated this is the issue
but if you call the question of legitimacy right what are the principle why the obey orders and we will see much later in this course that it will be Max Weber who elaborates on this issue at great lengths and then the next question is okay is the ruler and individual or is this an institution you see this is all very interesting enrichment of the idea what the nature of governments are he himself supports a constitutional monarchy and he supports a monarchy right in which there is a king or queen but King and clean which operates
on the rule of law that's what constitutional monarchy is the second major theme is separation of powers I'm still elaborating what will come well you have read Locke distinguish between legislative executive and Federative branches of government Montesquieu that distinguishes between legislative executive and you ready call well this is the one which is has been so influential on the American Constitution what we all believe now in this country that these are the three branches which should be separated though of course the Federative remains to be an interesting issue who should exercise Federative powers the powers of
war should it the legislature or should it be at the executive branch as such well a Montesquieu suggests that the three powers will have to be separated the legislative power and this is a departure from Hobbes and Locke should be by elected representatives and then he makes an important new contribution he said the right of minority should be respected he kind of foreshadow something like universal voting though is not quite explicit about this but you can read into it but then he said the minorities right should be reserved and he said well the legislative power
cannot and should not be held by the Monarchs but and but it has to be limited there must be a limitation on legislative powers and the executive will exercise checks over the legislature and we will again talk about this in more detail and but there must be some checks and balances over the executive branch as well when it comes you know who controls what he puts more emphasis on the executive limiting the legislatives than the other way around but we will see what the arguments are and what the rationale for this is and how this
affects for instance the functioning of the US government today I think it is not all that far away for the blueprint Montesquieu and established laid back and in the mid 18th century and then the last issue will be environment how social conditions are shaped by environment on on conditions but he said but that is also a general spirit a spirit which is above the individuals and this is the very French team right you cannot explain it from the individual there is some general idea Durkheim vehicle collective conscience who so we called it the general will
write the very French idea right that there is some consciousness above the individual consciousnesses this has formulated so powerfully first time by Montesquieu that he actually said the civilization is progressing the influence of the natural conditions declines and the importance right of general spirits increases or to put with your crime the collective conscience becomes more and more important I'm just foreshadow that you have a sense right that this course really hangs together right we are not talking about separate authors we are talking about a set of authors who are talking to each other debating each
other right yes I think what is so fascinating about the foundations of modern social food deaths cannot be said about 20 or 21st century social theorizing where we are at each other's throats and the ignore each other right that's more typical okay as I said you know he's a methodological collectivist right and I just explained this to you a little right methodological individualists who begins in order to develop a conception of society you have to start with the individual the only reality but you can observe in individual action and individual consciousness everything else right but
you suggest is speculative right this is British individualism and empiricism right the French emphasizes there are stuff like law this is my the legal system the law is so important for Montesquieu that's why the major book is called like the spirit of law because the law is not simply a sum total right of individual consciousness it sends over us right and we get into a society and the law the legal system already does exist maybe cedar can does the same thing this is why the legal system is so important for him okay now let's move
into the first team and talk about the different forms of government well he makes a distinction between republican government monarchy and despotic state republican government in his definition means that either the people rule democracy or a subset of people right aristocracy has the sovereign power are the source of law as we will see he is not all that certain whether the people rule is all that good right he prefers sort of selected see it will be even true for whoso is much more radical than he s monarchy in which one alone governs but by fundamental
laws the monarch itself is bind by by laws a despotic state that there are no fundamental rules right the despot exercise it is power at its Vail Adolphe Hitler's Germany or Stalin's Russia or Soviet Union a despotic stays right there is no proper rule of law now about the Republic well as we said there are two forms of it the Democratic and then the eros aristocratic run in the Democratic you have a selection of people to office by lot well is not talking about elections but by lot and indeed in Greek democracies people were occasionally
selected to major offices right in ancient Greek by lot by lottery in aristocracy people are selected by choice right the best people get into the office that they have the best skills to perform well he said well everyone can vote but not everybody's prepared to serve in the office there speaks right for it is aristocrats by choice but whatever the republic is that is a principle legitimacy is based on virtue the person who serve should be virtuous right and if the virtuousness of the person is questioned then you know the legitimacy of the person is
in some trouble verbally the virtuousness remember Bill Clinton you know into some trouble you know because people started to question his virtuousness right in the very narrow sense of the term okay anyway that's the guiding principle then monarchy now here the prince has a sovereign power and is the source of law but master law is established has to follow that law that's monarchy and the principle here is honor the prince has to be honorable right in order to be obeyed again the basis of legitimacy is honor and despotism as we have seen the one who
governs can do whatever it wants to do is above the law right and what is the principle of despotic rule Yeah right you obey those in power because you fear them well the next theme is separation of powers and we see that the three powers well write the legislative power executive power and they will see the power to judge later on executive power over dings depending on the right of Nations executive power over things depending on civil rights he said the first power executive power executive you know that is legislative power in fact can be
exercised by a king or a magistrate it can be exercised by even elected body but the second one executive power well and it has to be executed he believed by usually by a monarch and there is the last power the power of judging which has to be separated from both the legislative and executive power let's see the argument what he puts forward he said when the legislative power is united with the executive power in a single person there is no Liberty because one can fear right that the same monarch who meets tyrannical rules will execute
them in a tyrannical manner so therefore you have to separate legislative and executive powers well this separation is not complete right because it takes time for the legislative body to pass laws and therefore very often executives even in the United States operate with executive orders right these executive orders kind of substitute right for laws or legal regulations right so the separation even in modern society like the United States is relative and in fact many constitutional lawyers in the United States we were concerned during the last two administrations that the executive branch too often operated by
executive orders right rather than to ask the legislature right to legislate about those things okay now then he goes on and he said look this is not really a question of Republic versus monarchy he said look in in his times in most Kingdom of Europe the government is quite moderate he said well the prince who exercises the first two powers well leaves a great deal of autonomy for its subjects in the Italian Republic's they are republics in of his time 18th century the powers are united and there is less Liberty actually in this Italian Republic's
well it's an interesting point now about the legislative power he said well it better to be an elected body which exercises the legislative power passes the laws and become close to the idea of universal suffrage in choosing the representative all citizens should have the right to vote and then comes a qualification except who said is so humble that they are deemed to have no Ville of their own in order to have a will you better the be a property owner right there is a suggestion here of property qualification which was quite dominant in the United
States and until the twentieth century right but on the other hand he elaborates on it people should not enter government except to choose their representatives because in order to be in the executive you need skills well you may know who could be the right person to run the office but you may not be able to run the office right that's the fundamental idea it's also important right that is representative body the legislature should be separated from actual action now comes the idea right the right of minority this is a novel idea cast in a very
conservative way but though it is cast in a conservative kind of feudal aristocracy manner an aristocrat is speaking he's formulating a very important principle what we are still struggling with right how to defend the rights of minorities against a despotism of the majority just because 51% voted one way does not mean that 49% is wrong right and that the rights of that 49% or even just 1% in some days has to be guaranteed and that's what he's struggling with now here in these contexts and we'll put the citation on the web so I don't want
to reread this very long citation the argument is for the nobility he said well the nobility has more rights and therefore if they have more rights more stakes in it they have more than one voice therefore the solution is a two-chamber solution right a chamber for the aristocrats an upper house and the chamber popularly elected by everyone a lower house they are not in the aristocratic sense but in some ways representing the defense right of small states and agrarian states this is by the United States Senate every stage since to senators rather irrespective of the
size of the population right and therefore though not in a sort of feudalistic way as Montesquieu meant it but it is the whole proposition is very much alive right in our current political practices ok let's me then move on and talk about the executive power well the executive power should be stable that's why he believes it better be in the hands of a monarch because the government needs immediate action it cannot leave right to messy Congress to debate things all the time the government has to act instantly and therefore it has to be in one
hand well there are he elaborates a number of limits of legislative power some of it applies to the United States others don't but may apply to Western democracies it should convene at regular intervals and that's quite true for all democratic states right the legislature is called very often and with some regularity well it should not be in session without interruption the US Congress is virtually right in session almost without interruption but other parliament in continental Europe are not necessarily so the reason is that it they don't want to make membership in the legislature the sole
source of occupation and income and there are dings which speaks for this idea right that the legislature is not in permanent session and then he said it should not have the right to convene itself well the US Congress convenes itself it doesn't need the car of the executive but in England for instance right it is the queen who dissolves the parliament and caused the session of the Parliament doesn't give her much power but nevertheless it the idea the more Montesquieu an idea is present in a number of destined democracies now regular intervals that's obvious right
mean it should not be left to the executive especially if the executive has the right to call into session the legislature right that may mean the executive will not call then new laws are needed and will become a despotic that's why it has to be called by regular intervals and it you know it should not be in session without interruption because he said it would over burden the executive power as well and it cannot convene itself he said and the arguments are known because if it would have the right to decide whether it dissolves itself
it will never the so this that's the fundamental argument here as I've said in many countries this is exercise way now the executive he said should be able to check over the legislature and in what way because it doesn't want the legislature to paralyze the action of the government and the mean they how the executive exercises checks over the legislature is the veto right of the executive exactly like it is done in the US Constitution right the president can veto laws which are passed by Congress has to send back to Congress and the Congress has
to overrule right the veto of the president but there is a clear light check of the executive over the legislature the executive has the possibility to remind the legislature this may be a bad idea to pass this law you better rethink it before it becomes a law they all checks and balances over the executive branch he is quite a conservative here and he said the executive power belongs to the legislative only through its faculty of vetoing the executive power it's very important right and that's the rising of public funds only with the consent of legislature
this is again a very important principle the ruling all democracies rather the budgets have to be improved by the legislature just see the mass what we have seen in California recently right but where the legislature was not giving the budget to the governor but this is certainly a very important principle of democracy and now let me come to the question of environment and society and the whole idea that the physical condition shape social conditions and let me give you a couple of as I said quite silly notes he said the spirit and passion are extremely
different and in various climates laws should be relative to the differences in these passions and now comes the real silly Varna call in cold climate the blood is pushed harder for about the heart this produces confidence in oneself and courage and better knowledge so you are more courageous more active and smarter if you live in cold climates like in France or in England people in hot countries are timid like old man motto that timid okay and then interestingly you know to sort of distance himself from racism which did not exist is that he said even
the children of Europeans born inside the Indies lose the courage of the European climate at least it is not based on a racial argument but indeed mate based on a extremely naive ecological argument but let me emphasize there is fantastic inside here I for another 200 years nobody took the environment seriously I mean the exception of Emile Durkheim we will talk about this when we're talking about their time coming from Montesquieu for Durkheim Montesquieu and Rousseau the the gods right that's where modern theory of society came from it was Montesquieu and Rousseau both of them
so and now about the general spirit he said well many things government climate religion laws the Maxim's of government mores and manners there is this all s together a general spirit which is formed as a result right I hope you get the idea of the general spirit right that there is a set of ideas which is above our individual consciousness in childhood we learn right we internalize those ideas it is not coming from the individual it is entering the individual in the process of Education right and therefore the argument what Montesquieu makes repeated by Rousseau
and their time that we can have and should have an idea of society or collective consciousness standing over and above the individual this is a big debate right which informs most of the debates in social sciences today in economics in political science in sociology in anthropology you have some scholars who regard themselves in economics view methodological collectivists and those who call themselves methodological individualists rational choice people right are the methodological individualists the cultural analysts are methodological collectivists right we have that distinction virtually everywhere as I said list in economics but even in economics you have
the institutionalists right who are on the edge right or between being methodological collectivists or being methodological individualists and then well he says as civilization unfolds the importance of the general spirit increasing and the impact of climate is declining not that climate doesn't matter but over time it's important declines and the importance of general spirit increases well that's about it for today thank you