good day i'm dominating dean of the college of law of the ateneo de nada university and a member of the supreme court oversight committee for the implementation of rule 138a i am also a proud product of the clinical legal education course of the ateneo de manila university where as a fourth year student i won my first case in court i honestly believe that my experience then as a law student practitioner helped me pass the bar and gave me an edge over my colleagues during my first year in practice today i will talk about experiential education
in the context of rule 138a particularly what experiential education is how it is different from other courses it's components and some supervision techniques that you may employ in conducting your clip courses let's begin we've all heard the phrase learning while doing or learning through experience this concept is not really new in fact as early as 350 bc aristotle and his nicomachean ethics wrote for the things we have to learn before we can do them we learn by doing them the most simple and practical example of this is perhaps learning how to ride a bike you'll
never learn unless you actually sit on it and pedal your way to bruises and whatnots until you're actually able to hold your balance and successfully maneuver the bike to your intended direction however not all learning through experience may be properly considered as experiential education technically speaking experiential education is a teaching philosophy that informs many methodologies in which educators purposefully engage with learners in direct experience and focused reflection to increase knowledge develop skills clarify values and develop people's capacity to contribute to communities from this definition by the association of experiential education we can see four critical
elements first there must be purposeful engagement meaning that the experience did not just happen by accident instead it was brought forth by careful planning and was intentionally designed by someone to create a certain experience for the students second reflection we only truly learn from experience if we take time to reflect upon it processing the experience helps to completely articulate and identify the insights drawn from the experience that are relevant useful and applicable in future action and decision making and it is from these insights that learning truly emerge it is even said that we do not
actually learn from experience rather we learn from our reflections on our experience reflection then naturally results in the third component and that is increase in knowledge and skills development and the last element is societal value experiential education must necessarily have a societal value it is not done for education per se but to bring about a common good now if we compare this definition to the definition of clinical legal education program or clep in rule 138a we'll see that they have more or less the same elements section 2a of rule 138a provides the clep is an
experiential interactive and reflective credit earning teaching course with objectives of providing law students with practical knowledge skills and values necessary for the application of the law delivery of legal services and promotion of social justice and public interest especially to the marginalized while inculcating in the students the values of ethical lawyering and public service the only difference then is that clep is defined as a credit earning teaching course while experiential education is a teaching philosophy in other words clem is the course while experiential education is the philosophy behind the method of teaching the course by creating
meaningful and relevant experiences for the students now how is clep different from other courses as opposed to what we call doctrinal courses which only teach legal theories through either the socratic method and the landau case method clep is more expansive in that it integrates theory with practice and of course ethics and professional development however it must be emphasized that clep is not meant to do away with doctrinal courses but rather just to supplement them now how is club different from traditional apprenticeships clep recognizes that the education of the student must be balanced with the interest
of the client of course in law firms government offices and other legal service providers the interests of the client or of public service always comes first then usually the interest of the handling lawyer comes second and the apprentice's education is relegated to the background or sometimes not even given any importance at all because the handling lawyers are either too busy or have no experience in teaching an apprentice so the apprentice becomes a mere passive observer in the office but of course there are exceptions to this particularly those law firms and government offices with strong internship
programs properly designed in the method of true experiential education also in clep learning is structured there is a syllabus and a logical sequence of learning is followed in most apprenticeships the tasks given to the apprentices are not really given much thought the educational value of the tasks are usually not even considered and the apprentice is seen as just an extra set of helping hands to work on whatever task is available and because learning is unstructured objectives and outcomes are not clear and without reflection learning is done through trial and error because there is no insight
that could guide the progression of learning now let's go to the components of click following the tenets of experiential education a club course must necessarily have two components the clinical or practical component and the classroom component the clinical component is where the student is immersed in various experiences via the practice areas that they are allowed to do under the student practice rule such as client interviews and counseling representation and appearances in court and quasi-judicial bodies public legal orientations and seminars and so many others now let's talk about general supervision techniques that the supervising lawyer or
clinical faculty may employ in each of these components so first in the clinical or practical component we have the non-directive approach here the supervising lawyer instead of telling the student what to do in each and every situation the supervising lawyer merely guides the student in analyzing the situation in order for the student himself or herself to come up with ideas and strategies to handle or resolve the situation this is akin to a socratic dialogue where through a series of questions the supervising lawyer leads the student to the aha moment and thus giving the student ownership
over the work product that results from the experience this in contrast to the directive approach where the student merely obeys or follows the direction given by the supervising lawyer the directive approach is usually employed when time is of the essence for example you have to file a pleading in an hour of course it would be impractical to engage the student in a lengthy explorative process so the supervising lawyer might just as well tell the student what kind of feeding to file the basis or authorities for finding the readings and everything that he needs to get
the job done next we have the collaborative approach here the supervising lawyer and the student treat each other as peers and bounce ideas off of each other this usually resorted to when faced with novel questions of law where precedents are hard to find thus the student and the supervising lawyer collaborate with each other to come up with new or creative legal strategies or solutions finally we have the intentional intervention in technical work where students have clients it is important for the students to establish rapport and gain the trust and confidence of the client this will
not happen if every step of the way the supervising lawyer is always there because as we know the client would most probably instead of relying on the student would second guess the student and seek another opinion from the supervising lawyer so the supervising lawyer every time he intervenes between the student and the client the intervention must always be intentional with clear and specific goals for the intervention such as to move the case along or to respectfully guide the case towards a different direction but it is important to note that supervision is an art dependent on
the goal and context there is no one way of doing things and it is up to the supervising lawyer to develop his own techniques through time and experience now let's go to the general supervision techniques that may be employed by clinical faculties in the classroom component of the clip of course we have the most common number one simulation and role playing this is usually done to teach client interview techniques and etiquette and of course trial technique through court proceeding simulations such as what we do in our practice court courses next we have guided reflection it
is guided because questions are provided to the students which would lead them to uncover certain insights about their experiences we also have self-reflection or journaling i really get good feedbacks from students every time i employ this method many of them feel that it is a good way to track their progress and they get to discover so many things about themselves their strengths weaknesses and even personal biases that they were not previously aware of but my favorite is the cage rounds where students share to the class updates or strategies that they employ in the cases that
they are handling and they would get suggestions ideas and even criticisms from their classmates for me learning here is exponential because all of the students are able to learn from the various experience of their classmates their collective experience brings forth a vast array of knowledge which they could have not learned or know about if not for the experience sharing of their classmates and they learn from the mistakes of their classmates which i personally believe has tremendous value not only in their studies but also in their growth in the profession again there is no one way
of doing things feel free to design your own club courses in accordance to your unique situation what is important is that you are able to identify the goals and objectives of your clep course and of course the specific experiential teaching methodology that you will employ in order to achieve them don't be afraid to be creative don't be afraid to create meaningful experiences for your students that they will learn from and treasure for the rest of their lives i for one truly benefited from the experiences created for me by my club professors back then so i
sincerely hope to pay it forward that ends my discussion i hope that this has been a fruitful session for you and that you have picked up some insights and ideas that you can implement in your own club courses enjoy the rest of the day and jos navalos you