hello and welcome to lesson seven of the advanced psychology course for high performance trading this video is looking at probability and probabilistic thinking and in my opinion this is by far the most important topic related to trading success despite everything I've talked about in the last six lessons and all the many Mal adaptic mechanisms that sabotage our trading a lack of understanding of probabilities is often the root cause that triggers all of those faults to start with if there was only one thing you could work on to improve as a Trader probabilities would be it I originally intended to put this as the first video in the course I'm so convinced that nothing else makes sense in trading without probabilistic understanding but I decided it would actually be more beneficial if we look back at this in the context to the other trailing problems that we've already covered so far now split the topic into two videos with this first one being more on the theory side and the next video showing you practic examples especially as it relates to trading directly now in terms of system 2 oversight objectives what we're focusing on is system 1's false assessment of probabilities and its need for certainty any system one assessment of probabilities in trading will usually be presented as a strong feeling that something is about to happen it feels like good intuition and of course we're used to going along with what feels right particular particularly with our intuitive assessments of probability because actually our intuitive feel of probability is usually right for instance if you see a black cloud veiling on the horizon and the temperature suddenly drops and the wind picks up your intuition will tell you that it's probably going to rain soon and most of the time it's correct because it's been exposed to a lot of weather and it's learned to evaluate the chance of rain in the next hour or so reasonably accurately but in trading it's much harder to build accurate intuitive probability assessments because our brains did not develop to function in financial markets so let's start with looking at how system one struggles with probability let's say I've got a deck of cards and I pick two cards randomly from the deck what do you think the odds are that the first card is red and the second card is black pausa if you want to try and work this out well the first part of the question is quite easy the odds of picking a red card first is simply a half or 50% or5 depending on how you want to write that that's easy because half of the cards in the deck are red but what about the second part of the question well if the first card I picked was red then the back is now one red card down so the odds of picking a black card second are now 26 over 51 or 50. 9% and to answer the original question on the probability of picking a red card followed by a black one we need to multiply those two probabilities together which gives us 25. 5% now of course this takes time to work out and your intuitive or your initial assessment of the probability may have been completely blank but if you did have any idea at all it was probably false until you've done the hard work using system 2 but historic Al we haven't used maths to calculate probabilities accurately we've used Intuition or experience to make estimates like that ring Cloud example even if we did have maths available to us it's just too slow in most real life situations system one wants to act right now not get out of pen and paper and work this kind of stuff out throughout nearly all of the long human history our understanding the probability was very simple and it thought more in terms of certainty we would intuitively conclude look this line is almost definitely going to kill me unless I run away that is far more useful to us than sitting down and trying to calculate the exact specific odds that could be 8 to 7.
56% as far as we know the earliest record of humans playing gambling games was only about 3,000 years ago which in real terms is extremely recent that would have been the first time that we even attempted to think to about proba probabilities more mathematically financial markets for speculation have only really been in our culture for a few hundred years so historically system one has barely had any exposure to Accurate probabilistic thinking which is why we don't really have a particularly Advanced mechanism for calculating or assessing probabilities instead system one has 3 seconds yes maybe and no or in other words it definitely will it might or it definitely won't but as I explained in the second video of this course on decision Evolution system 1 does not like the maybe state it hates uncertainty because it doesn't know how to react and that makes the maybe State highly stressful when faced with a tiger it's no good thinking that it may or may not attack us and waiting there in in decision we need certainty quickly so we'll assume that it will attack and we will take precautionary and defensive measures this really sums up system 1's probabilistic assessment mechanism and out of the box it's just not refined enough for trading if we zoom in on our more recent history of the past 2,000 years we can look at how we've tried to cope with this poor understanding of probability in an increasingly complex world in the first 1500 years of this period we were playing games that involved chance but we didn't see things probabilistically as such the outcomes were usually attributed to fate luck or divine intervention and we very much saw things as a cause and effect we were winning because our lucky charm was working or the sacrifice we just made to the gods was being rewarded or our skill at rolling the dice and if we were losing we had the wrong lucky charm or because we defended our favorite God or we'd roll the dice poorly system one always looks for cause and effect and has never really grasped the randomness of the world around us odds and probabilities as we understand them today just weren't a thing back when probability proper only appeared in 1654 when mathematicians pascow and ferat were trying to work out how to improve their chances at winning a simple getting of dice that was when the mathematical age of probability was born allowing humans to calculate probabilities with much greater accuracy using system to this is what allows us to calculate the exact probabilities like the card question I gave you a moment ago we can be precise because we have all of the necessary information and data points when financial markets came along we might have hope that we could simply apply a formula and calculate the exact probability of a trade working out but in markets we don't have all of the information needed financial markets are far too complex with far too many unknowns and and different variables that change from one second to another it's impossible to be mathematically precise in trading so we've got no option but to fall back on system one's intuitive estimate so we're back where we started with this A system that only understands probabilities in terms of it will it might or it won't and as I said that may be state is uncomfortable so we'll do anything to reduce that uncertainty our ancestors survive D because of this mechanism they weren't taking any chances with Mayes and we still do this every single day when you get into a car you put a seat belt on but if you think about it Matt produces an error 99. 999% of the time in the overwhelming majority of those situations we drive our Ang strapped into an irritating harness that provides no benefit it isn't needed or used but the may be state of wondering if you might need it just this time well that's too uncomfortable for us especially when the consequences are so severe they could be fatal so rather than trying to accurately calculate the odds of the Belt being required on any given individual Journey it's just far easier and more comfortable to remove the uncertainty and just assume it is needed no matter how improbable now because this is such an important and detailed topic I'm going to summarize this as we go along to help this information sink in we understand now that for most of our existence we have only really required a two or three stage perception of probability it will it might or it won't this is great if you're trying to work out whether you're at risk of being eaten by a predator because the uncomfortable maybe State pushes us to make a quick decision and take action the bad news is trading is by definition an active ativity is always in that maybe state it is more like a dial with the possible outcomes in a continuous range varying degrees of maybe which is not comfortable for us at all a system one seeks certainty and it will do anything to get out of this maybe State this is the major reason why retail Traders even with profitable systems don't succeed they assume that the uncomfortableness they feel init takes that something is wrong so they spend most of their time trying to reduce this uncertainty by layering more tools indicators and filters on to their system and we all have this tendency towards wanting certainty it's not just in trading but in everyday life the best example of this is weather forecasts weather forecasters the world over get very frustrated at their viewers lack of understanding of probability but more importantly they need for certainty they get complaints all of the time that their forecasts were wrong but people mistake high probability for certainty if the forecast says is there's a 90% chance of ring most people will just take that to mean that it will ring or that a 10% chance of ring means that it won't ring That's a classic case of system one moving things from the uncomfortable maybe category into the it will or it won't category whatever the forecast and whatever the weather everyone can easily believe the forecast got it wrong it's not that we're all stupid or that we all enjoy complaining we are simply grappling with system someone's inability to accept the true nature of probability the US election back in 2016 was another fantastic example of the general population's difficulty with probabilities there were long periods where Clinton was way ahead in the polls and by the election day she was forecast with over 70% chance of winning and most people especially the media took that 70% to mean certainty when Trump won both sides Democrats and Republicans turned on the pollsters claiming that they've got it all spectacularly wrong now whether the pollsters had failed to take some information to account or not is irrelevant claiming they were wrong is in itself wrong the probabilistic assessment of a single event cannot be wrong by definition if you thought there was a 95% chance that a trade would move in a certain direction and it didn't the assessment wasn't wrong because obviously there was a a 5% chance that it wouldn't go that way and that is what happened this time the only way to say a probabilistic prediction is wrong is if you can look at a track record of the same prediction under the same circumstances over multiple occurrences we all struggle with probability not least because system one mistakes high and low probabilities for certainty if I put 700 gold coins and only one copper coin in a bag and then asked you to pick one out randomly you might feel absolutely certain that you were going to pick out a gold coin but if you didn't you would find that hard to accept you know what are the chances this can't be a coincidence and that's the point we really don't understand or accept Randomness here's a picture of someone who wanted be Flor tiles to appear random so they shuffled the tiles and they pick them out at random and this is what they got and they weren't happy why have so many dark tiles clustered around the edge instead of being distributed more evenly it turns out we don't even understand what random looks like this is random but this is what people expect when they ask their bathroom or kitchen Tyler to create a random pattern we expect an evenly distributed pattern which is not random so why don't we accept Randomness or at least recognize it well system one is a pattern spot in machine I would argue one of its main functions is to look for patterns in the chaos to make meaning and order in the environment you can test it almost whenever you like simply by looking up at the clouds if I ask you to look for animal faces eventually you will see them and the more you see the more you'll find you don't derive meaning from the clouds because you are aware that this is just an enjoyable optical illusion but in our past there have certainly been many situations where we've faced random information spotted patterns and we have seen meaning from it that have shaped our lives look at the way our ancestors have interpreted stars from Millennia in every culture people have seen shapes in the random positions of stars literally Jo the dots to create constellations characters and people not just for a good Campfire story but to actually help us make sense of Our Mysterious World and remove the uncertainty so that we have more control and can predict the future but here's one of my favorite examples of system one struggle with Randomness it's from when the iPod was first released they had tens of thousands of complaints saying that the random shuffle feature wasn't working correctly certain songs were being favored again and again and other songs were never played at all and Steve Jobs tried for over a year to explain that this was a problem with our perception of probability but iPod owners weren't listening so in the end they created an algorithm to evenly distribute the songs and the complaint stop now every single device that has a random mode is not random at all and this really highlights a big problem for Traders if system one spots a pattern in random information by default it will assume that it is not random and it will assign mean to it now most price moves in all markets are random so you can just imagine the false patterns that Traders are seeing on their chart and falsely using to make decisions about the future now I'll cover patent recognition in detail in lesson 11 of discour we'll come back to that but the way people play lotteries is another great example of system one's Malad active understanding of probabilities let's say I have five Lotter tickets and I offer you one pick the one you want but order all of them from the least likely to the most likely to win and again you can pause the video if you want some time now if you did place them in any any sort of order even if you intuitive you felt you did you've been tricked by your own system one all of these tickets have exactly the same odds of about 14 million to one in this case but when we see any kind of pattern we assume that it must be ordered not random let's be honest who buys a lottery ticket with 1 2 3 4 5 six as the numbers but that sequence is just as likely to be picked out randomly as any other sequence and if you won with those numbers you'd likely keep all those winnings yourself whereas sequences that seem more random tend to actually be picked by more people this next slide is part of a common University question that is given to students studying statistics here are three possible daily results of the sex of the babies born in a real Maternity Ward picked randomly from one day of the year only one of those sequences is real the other two are false which do you think is the real one remembering that the odds of a baby being born a boy or a girl are 50/50 you're probably on to me by now and you know not to go with your instinct the answer was B on that random day all of the babies were girls but nevertheless you will agree even if you know what I was up to that your intuition by itself would immediately think that c looks more random and B looks like it has order to it in Truth all of the sequences are just as likely to appear randomly but you can see how difficult it is for system one to understand Randomness let's have a look at a series of eight point flips let's say the first comes up heads but then the following six all come up Tails if I offered you a $100 bet to guess the next result do you fancy your chances well you might because you're in intuitive understanding the probability may have assumed that because the last six were Tales it's much more likely to be Heads next you may not but the vast majority of people would take that bet or think that way confidently assuming that the odds are now in their favor for then they think there's only a slight risk of being wrong and this is one of the simplest yet one of the hardest concepts for system one to grasp the past does not affect the future the last six conflict be entails does not change the odds of the next one and we may all agree with this intellectually but even so many people admit that although they know that this is true it just doesn't feel true what's really happening there is system 2 agrees with the odds but system one disagrees to some extent this is a form of mental accounting you've remembered the results from the last few flips and they're mentally counting is distort in your perception of actual probabilities but the odds on every single coin clip is always 50/50 to believe otherwise is called the gambler's fallacy Traders need to be very careful of this you'll often see people increase their position sizes after a string of losses because they think that a win next is more likely or has a higher probability or vice versa after a win and streak they reduce their position size because they think a loss next is more likely the outcome of random events like coin flips or individual trades do not affect the next outcome you'll often hear experienced Traders say that the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent what they really referring to is this misunderstanding the probabilities and the connection between past and future system one is always trying to reduce uncertainty and look for cause and effect so it's always on the lookout for patterns and it will find them even in random information and it will then assume meaning and even make us think that the odds are changing the problem is even worse when the numbers are large we intuitively get 1 in four or 1 in 20 because we can relate to those small numbers from experience in everyday life but with very large numbers we just can't comprehend what they even look like if you place a 1 cm coin anywhere on a tennis court what are the odds of a randomly dropped ball landing on that coin is it one in 1,956 277 1 in 12, 35577 or one in 759222 well it's impossible for you to calculate that intuitively using system one each of those numbers is so big as to mean nothing as far as our understanding their probabilities one guess is as good as another the answer is a by the way so when it comes to probabilities odds with large numbers even just over a thousand are very hard to grasp we just lump them all together making us bad at differentiating between an unlikely event and a really really unlikely event and when unlikely events do happen we can't accept that it was random we assign meaning to it cause and effect if you've just had 15 losses in a row rather than accept it as being the random distribution of results your system one is going to infer that unlikely is the same as impossible and it will instantly assign some meaning such as your system or indicator must be broken and you need to look for something new now an interesting if not somewhat tragic consequence of this especially for financial markets is our Reliance and Trust in Talking Heads when it comes to any prediction of Market activity or Direction some somebody somewhere will get it right not because of any skill or Insight but simply because if enough people are making predictions someone will be correct the media especially struggle with this basic concept when an event happens the TV companies scam their records for anyone who supposedly made the right prediction and will question them endlessly about what they think is going to happen next on the false assumption that their next Insight is worth following simply because of the success of their life last one one of the most famous examples of this was when elain garelli a financial analyst was suddenly catapulted into the media Spotlight after apparently calling the Black Monday crash in 1987 Financial journalists went crazy dubbing her the wizard of Wall Street and for the next 10 years she was a regular on various shows with everyone hanging off her predictions now as you might guess someone who actually understood probabilities a guy called William Sheridan did some analysis of those 10 years worth of predictions and it turns out she was wrong 62% of the time the point is in the short term with single events predictions and probabilities are almost meaningless somebody will get it right purely from Randomness outcomes that appear to follow patterns and appear to have a cause and effect are Illusions one of the best programs you can watch to demonstrate and understand this fcy is Darren brangs the system it is on YouTube and I'll put a link in the description I won't spoil it but it is a fantastic explanation of how people fool themselves about their own trading system or get away with convincing other people that they have over your Edge and put it to Ability when really it is all random luck now you've obviously grasped that system one and system two process of evangelic probabilities very differently system one relies on its experience its ability to recall previous situations and maybe even simulate the possibilities so it's easy to intuitively grasp the probability of rolling a six on a dice because the odds are in a simple range and you've done it many times so you have experience to call on but in most cases intutive probability is only an estimate for instance if you were trying to work out the probability of hitching a ride on the road you wouldn't come up with a specific number like 1 in 36 or 2. 77% instead system one would estimate that your best chance might be in the morning if you were dressed smartly and you had a well- written sign you would intuitively calculate the better charms not the specific value intuitive probabilities are just an estimate they're first but they are limited by our experience and have a complexity limit objective probability on the other hand is what we use to assess more complex probability problems it's more meical mathematical and therefore is a system 2 process intuitively estimating the chances of rolling the six may be relatively easy but what about two sixes in a row pause the video if you want to have a go at that you'll notice that you didn't instantly come up with an intuitive answer system 2 is needed and that is much slower and it requires much more effort to get the answer you need to multiply the probabilities together which gives us one in 36 or 2.
77% chance of getting two sixes in a row and the more the complexity grows the more methodical we need to be for example were there the odds of rolling four sixes in a row well now even system 2 struggles and we need to involve a calculator and the answer this time is 1 in 1,296 or .