I want to walk you through all the steps for Designing a race car suspension in this episode we'll design together the pickup points for the actuation systems rockers and intro bars hello everyone this is Bruno in this series I'll walk you through all the process for designing a race car suspension today we're gonna design together the pickup points for the actuation the stems such as rocker brings and enter roll bars before we start I want to give a quick recap of what was done so far so this exercise is a case study where we are designing together the front suspension of a GT3 car so we are focusing more on the design process and not so much on the values meaning that all the values used here are only examples they are not meant to be used as recommendations besides that obviously there are many important parameters that are not considered since this is just an exercise alright so in previous episodes we have already designed the outer picker Point as we have discussed in line on video number two and we have also designed the inner picker points meaning the Picker points on the chassis on episode number three now that we have all of the inner and outer picker points defined it's time for us to attack the actuation figure Point as you can see all of the design is documented using this notebooks like this I can show you how to properly document such a project and also you can get get access to all of these notebooks in the video description alright so now when designing the activation pickup points these are the figure points we're going to focus on so we have the Picker points of the rocker we also have the coilover pick a point as well as all the bigger points from the anti-rowbar system if you remember well before we start our design we Define our design Target so this table includes what motion ratios we would like to see for our activation system also what is the wheel rate variation that we want as the car moves up and down and the same is valid for the anti-roll bar so we're gonna come back to these parameters once we are designing our suspension system and understand better each of them so without further Ado let's jump right into Optimum kinematics and start designing our suspension if you remember last episode we finished with a V6 with all of the wishbone anti-rod picker points defined now I just created a V7 and I added a activation system so here we can see a push rod we can see the rocker system and its attachment on the chassis that we call pivot access as well as the coilover so here even before we look at other parameters such as motion ratio motion ratio variation let's make sure that all of our pickup points are on the same plane and as we can see they are actually not so this was just an initial draft that I created I think that by looking at the chassis the current chest is designed this is a good placement for the system in which I can minimize loads I can minimize weight it's good packaging it's not in the way of other components of the car however I just need to make sure that everything is on the same plane in order to make sure that all the pickup points are on the same plane you can use for example a catch software in our case we're using a simple geometry tool where we can first Define the plane of The Rocker by defining its three picker points and one of them being the pivot axis which must be perpendicular to it and then after that we can look at all other picket points for the push rod for The Rocker always making sure that they're they're on the same plane so throughout this exercise whenever I make changes I'm always going back to this tool in order to make sure everything is on the same plane okay now that we have all this bureaucracy out of the way let's start looking at the kinematic parameters that will Define the behavior of the car the first parameter we should be looking at once we have our initial draft of the activation system is the motion ratio as you can find in our documentation page the motion ratio is nothing more than the displacement of the chassis or wheel compared to this displacement of the damper so there are two different ways in which we can create this definition one of them is wheel displacement divided by damper displacement while the second one is damper displacement divided by wheel displacement in our case here in this exercise we're always going to use the first definition we'll divided by damper why is the motion ratio important because it will Define for the same suspension movement that you get how much compression you have on your damper besides that it will influence the effective stiffness of the car of the suspension called puree next when we Define our motion ratio it will be a main parameter defining also the wheel rate so as you probably know the wheel rate is basically the measurement of the stiffness of the suspension as thin on the tire or on the wheel so in this case we do have the spring stiffness over here but it's not the effective stiffness of the system you have a mechanical conversion over here and then you can find the view rate meaning when you push the tire how much displacement you get or the force that you applied and for vehicle Dynamics this is what matters the most so the wheel rate is defined as spring stiffness divided by motion ratio squared based on the definition that we are using if you change the definition of the motion ratio this equation will change as well alright so now let's get back to option kinematics understand what motion ratio we currently have and also what motion ratio we want to achieve if we look at the quick outputs that Optimum kinematics gave us we can see that the motion ratio is about 1. 131 this means that we get more or less the same movement on the wheel and then just slightly less on the damper for this design we actually Define the motion ratio of 1. 35 how did we come up with this number in our case we're trying to get a damper that does not have a really long stroke so we already know more or less how much suspension deflection we want in maximum condition and therefore we need to minimize how much damper displacement we get so in our case we saw that by using 1.
35 we're gonna be safe and use all the range that we want from the damper now we know that we want to go from a motion ratio of 1. 1 to a motor ratio of 1. 35 how do we do that well it's basically by changing if we look at the rocker design we have the rocker pivot axis we have the push rod pick a point and we have the damper pick a point all a matter of mechanical gain so we have to play with this distance as compared to this distance and then we're gonna get the motion ratio we want so let's go back to our design software and try to play with this distance as you'll see I'm going to take a menu approach for the sake of the exercise but then later on I'm gonna show you how to use optimization to make it a lot more efficient so we saw that we have two options either we increase this distance over here or we decrease this other one we're gonna start playing with the push rod attachment and try to send it a little more forward so let's do just a couple millimeters because the motion ratio is extremely sensitive to that so for that I'm gonna do an x value a little bit forward which will be let's say -4 and then remember that I also need to compensate y or or X in order or Y and Z to make sure they're on the same plane for that I'm gonna increase Z slightly okay so we can see that the motion ratio went from 1.
1 to 1. 2 so it's already halfway to where we want to get the number of 1. 35 let's try now the opposite with the coilover bigger point in this case we need to decrease this distance so that for the same rocker rotation we get a smaller linear displacement of the dampers since the arm is a little shorter here we have to change the y coordinate so let's make it a little more to the outside of the car let's pick three millimeters and then I also need to decrease z a little bit just to make sure that it's on the same plane and you should be using a CAD software in order to accomplish and make sure that it's on the plane alright so 1.
29 so not quite there yet I'm gonna do another route of iteration until we get you something close to 1. 35 all right so we got you 1. 347 which is pretty close to the number that we want and I'm gonna be happy with that consider is just the first manual iteration it will be very dangerous if you stop the design here once you achieve the motion ratio that you want because motion ratio variation is as important if not even more important than the static number for motion ratio which is what we are getting here so let's look at how the motion ratio is changing as we compress and extend the suspension let's see if we are in a good place for that I'm going to run a simulation in which we are compressing and extending the suspension by 35 millimeters we get the result and now we're going to display them and there you go you can see the crazy amount of motion ratio variation that we get here so even though static is 1.
35 as we would like to have if we compress the suspension by only 20 millimeters which will happen at the track we are already at 1. 45 it might seem small however remember that the motion ratio squared is influencing the wheel rate this means that you would heavily change the suspension stiffness at different heights of the car besides that in this case as we compress the car and we go towards a negative number of Eve the motion ratio is increasing in our definition a higher motion ratio will soften the front suspension which is not great why because when we're running at low speeds we're running up higher at high speed Corners we have more downforce so the car is running lower we are softening the front axle and what does this give us it gives a more over steering mechanical balance you are increasing the help the grip on the front and therefore creating more oversteer in high speed Corners which is not something we necessarily want unless your car your car really asks for that we would be doing actually the opposite in my designs I will try to Target a car that is slightly more understeered at high speed Corners meaning that I would like a motion ratio variation on the opposite direction so like as the car compresses the motion ratio is lightly goes down increases the front axle stiffness and provides a little bit more mechanical understeer meaning a more stable car alright so we saw that first we need to reverse the direction of motion ratio change and next I also want to minimize or to lower this motion ratio variation how do we do that so let's go back to our notebooks and understand how can we get a higher or lower motion ratio variation if you look in this image we have the case where we have a small motion ratio variation at a given rocker configuration and then we have another option where we have a larger motion ratio variation with a different rocker configuration so let's understand the difference between both well for this first rocker configuration where we have again the pivot access the connection to the push rod and the connection should put the coil over we have the push rod angle versus the line connecting this speaker point and this bigger point similar to the angle of the coilover and the line connecting this other pick a point and the pivot axis again so whenever these angles are similar we should expect a small motion ratio variation the other case where we have a larger motion ratio variation look at what's going on even though the angle of the coilover and these two picker points is still similar to the one before it is different compared to the angle of the push rod and these two other picker points so now we see that here we have an angle close to 90 degrees meaning that whenever you are rotating The Rocker you have a lot of transfer to a linear movement while for the push rod picker point we have an angle lower than 90 degrees meaning that whenever the rocker is rotating the linear movement is not as effective well in the end the static motion ratio can be the same so when we go back to our Optimum kinematics project we need to check these angles are they similar are they not in what direction is one a little higher than 90 degrees the other one is slightly lower how should we play with them should decrease first change direction of the of the variation and also decrease it so from the top view we can quickly see how different these angles are so let's look first at the coilover angle we can see that the angle is close to 90 degrees when connecting the pivot axis to the coil over slightly low lower than 90 degrees maybe 85 to 88 something around that range but if we go to the angle of the push rod versus the pivot axis we can see that it's a lot higher than 90 degrees do you remember on the second case where we had different angles for these two components the motion ratio variation was higher so it is the case here so I think that our best first bet is to try to put them at more similar angles and then from there where we when we have a small variation we can play play with these angles until we have the variation we want in the direction that we want okay so since we see that one of the angles a lot different than the other we have to make them similar in this case I prefer to change the push rod pick a point in order to have a more similar angle in this case we would have to send this bigger point a little bit more inward and then we should get an angle closer to 90 degrees as well so let's do that I have to change the speaker point and we're gonna be using a number let's try to guess an initial number in this menu iteration 10 millimeters to the inside I'm gonna correct it on the Z coordinate as well and we see that the number is getting a little closer to the 90 degrees that we're targeting or slightly lower than 90 degrees I'm gonna try a little further a little bit more and then we run a simulation to see where we are so now with the simulation performed we can compare both of our results so we had the previous previous results in blue why we have the new result in Orange well first thing we notice is that the motion ratio changed a little bit of course it did when I'm playing with the bigger points the effective arm length or the proportion of them also change meaning that we need to to iterate until we get to where we want on the other hand we see that it happened exactly what we were expecting the variation changed from a huge variation to a much smaller variation we can also see that when I am compressing the suspension the motion ratio is slightly going down even though it's going up whenever you are designing a rocker system it's normal that you are going to see this fine behave of the motion ratio in any case it is going in the direction that we want I would just like to amplify a little bit more and get a little bit more motion ratio variation in for a lower number when I'm compressing the suspension so I'm going to give it one more try with a manual approach before later we run an optimization all right so now we have our next iteration and I'm getting pretty happy with the results so again the static motion ratio is not correct I'm gonna have to fix that by adjusting the arms just like we did in the first step however the variation is getting pretty good so as we can see here if I go from zero shoot 20 millimeters compression it is going from 1. 395 to 1.
38 which things should be in the range that I would like to to see this variation but let's try to be more data driven what is the variation of motion ratio we want and why how do we determine that as we discussed previously I would like the car to have different Behavior at different height meaning at different downforce values and different cornering speed so instead of purely looking at an arbitrary number such as the motion ratio I want you to think in terms of wheel rate in terms of growth speed so my target here will be as the car goes down 10 or 20 millimeters at a high speed Corner how much more stiffness I want on my system so for the sake of this exercise I'm going to say that as I compress the car by 10 millimeters or every 10 millimeters that the car goes down I would like to see a two percent increase in wheel rate so how do we go from motion ratio to wheel rate let me show you a very simple spreadsheet that will help us so in this case I defined three different levels of heave 0 which is a low speed Corner let's say static position 10 which is a medium to high speed maybe high speed can can be even lower than that but I want my my reference to be 10 millimeters and I I also put the maximum displacement that I expect for hours pension design so let's say that in this case we found a motion ratio of 1. 395 so we have static 1. 395 all right so what matters for the wheel rate is the motion ratio squared meaning that the wheel rate variation will be proportional to the motion ratio squared this means that I don't even need to define a spring stiffness at this point I just look at motion ratio squared and I want to see a change of let's say in this case two percent for every 10 millimeters so in this case what is the motion ratio we need at 10 millimeters compression in order to get to this two percent variation which is the number we see over here so let's try to play with the numbers and I see that if I get to 1.
38 I get the two percent variation every 10 millimeters I want now going back to our analysis I can see that if I go from 0 to 10 millimeters compression I am getting some motion ratio of 1. 3 85. so I actually have less than two percent variation for every 10 millimeters which could still be acceptable for a race car remember these numbers are just examples I'm not focused on them in any case we see that after that we will need to iterate in two different aspects number one get back to the Baseline static motion ratio we want 1.
35 number two get to the motion ratio variation that I want in this case the two percent um motion ratio squared every 10 millimeters this would still require a few more iterations I'm gonna leave it like that for now because in a few minutes we're going to run an optimization to find everything at the same time not that we're happy with the first version of our rocker system it's time for us to document remember how important it is for you to document all of the steps so later on you understand what decisions you made and why and what is left for you to do okay so now it's time for us to get back shopping kinematics create a new V8 and add the activation of the anti-roll bar system so that we can start working on it so this is the initial draft I created for the intro Varsity stamp in V8 as you can see here I'm connecting the group link directly to the rocker even though it could also be connected to the wishbone for example or even upright with a different integral bar configuration and I'm using what we call a u-bar which is the most simple or distinct list anti-robar that we could use in the case of the intro bar I cannot highlight how important it is for you to minimize again compliance why because if you have the intro bar attachment over here that is not not stiff enough or this attachment is going to or it's being attached to the middle of a chassis tube you might have the chassis tube twisting and decreasing the effectiveness of your intro bar meaning that the whatever row rate you design for the intro bar will be a lot lower because of these deflections since you are adding another spring series just like in the case of the rocker system here we are going to start by analyzing the integral bar motion ratio there are many different motion ratio definitions for the intro bar the one we are using here it is basically car roll divided by enterobar twist this is the equivalent of the motion ratio we use in terms of wheel displacement versus damper displacement we can see that in this case we are finding a number of 0. 07 over here this means that the as the car is rolling the anti-roll bar is twisting a lot which we have to be careful not to even break the intro bar so let's look at the Target that we defined initially and then we're gonna get back to changing it we can see that in our documentation we Define the target anti-robar motion ratio of 0. 1 again just for the sake of exercise but in real life how do you define and determine the motion ratio that you need for this system well one thing you have to be careful is the following if you have a very aggressive motion ratio let's say that the car is rolling one or two degrees or GT3 car your anti-roll bar could be wasting a lot to the point that you break it so it is very valid to run an analysis or even preliminary structural simulations in in order to understand if with that given motion ratio you're targeting if your anti-roll bars will not break if we go back to option kinematics now we have to change our pickup points again with this manual iteration and after with optimization in order to get to this 0.
1 so basically here we need the intro bar we need to increase this number meaning that the intro bar will rotate less we have two ways of doing that again number one is for a given rocker movement over here we want the anti-rowbar being displaced less and how do we do that by decreasing the length of this arm over here so we can take this speaker point and send it a little bit closer so let's try this first approach first in this case we got a number slightly higher close to 0. 8 so we are still not at the 0. 1 and the second approach we could take is to change the length of the blade this could be done either by changing this pick a point or this other pick a point here so if we increase the length of the blade for the same linear movement on the upper pickup point the integral bar will rotate last so let's try to change the speaker point and see what happened foreign so we are getting a lot closer to 0.
1 I lowered the speaker point the blade got longer and then we decreased will we increase the motion ratio so I can keep running iterations to see where we get but things later we're gonna use the optimization I'm gonna say that I'm happy with this before we move forward there is something extremely important just like all the other picker points on The Rocker should be on the same plane so that you don't introduce twisting moments on The Rocker you should have the same consideration for the intro bar remember that there will be a force coming from the from the drupalink to The Rocker and if it's too out of plane It's Gonna Make The Rocker twist and bend so we should be taking that into account so in this case we can see that we are not too far off from the plane at least typically the forces are smaller than the Springs so you do have a little bit of more tolerance over there but you should keep that in mind so you might have to adjust this point up and down or even to the sides in order to keep the droop link on the same plane as The Rocker the second consideration is the following not only you have to think about this plane you also have to think about the blade because if the force is from the droop link are true out of plane with the blade let's say that over here we would have a drupalink in a completely opposite direction not only you are twisting the intro bar normally you are also creating some flexion and some deformation on the blade so you have to be mindful of that as well now that we are relatively done with the static motion ratio we are going to go for the motion ratio variation again sometimes even more important that the static number is the variation that we get for that I'll run a heat stimulation to understand that different vehicle Heights how are we changing the intro bar motion ratio and now with the results ready we can plot them this is what we got as we know the initial number was close to 0. 95 for the static position even though later on we want to bring it to closer to 0. 1 so that our intro bar is not twisting as much but the second thing is we need to look at the variation again we see a really high variation which is normal if you were not thinking about variation when designing the system it's normal that you're going to get such a high variation in this case at least so we are getting to a smaller number so the number is going smaller and smaller meaning that we are increasing the stiffness the roll stiffness of the suspension as the car lowers so in this case at least we're inducing stem under steer for high speed Corners however in this case it's way too much in this case the car would get too much mechanical understeering at high speed Corners so what I would like to achieve here is not really to change the direction of the variation however I want you to decrease the intensity of the variation how do we do that well first let's define our Target in the same way as the spring we can Define how much Rogue stiffness variation we want for every 10 millimeters of car deflection and once we know that this will be proportional to motion ratio squared variation just like in the case of the rocker the motion ratio variation is all about the angles so the angle of the drupalink versus The Rocker or even more importantly the angle of the drupalink versus the blade will heavily dictate the motion ratio variation you have so let's stretch a look from a side view and we can see that we have the intro bar down here we have the blade and we have the drup link in this case the blade has a high very high angle compared to the drop link which will typically induce more variation let's try to decrease that let's try to have something closer to 90 degrees and then from 90 degrees we can move a little bit backward or forward in order to determine the direction of the variation in this case I'll simply send this point a little bit forward and then get this angle closer to 90 degrees now with the angle closer to 90 degrees I'm going to run another simulation to see where we are these are the results we got now in green we can see that the motion ratio changed a little bit which is normal we are changing the parameters it actually got closer to 0.
1 which is what we want but on top of that just look how much the variation of motion ratio changed now we have maybe three or four times less variation than what we had before and then we can look if for 10 millimeters of wheel displacement if we are getting the variation that we wanted actually we're pretty close we're changing 0. 001 0. 0015 which is more or less what we wanted so we see that by running a menu iteration we got closer to what we wanted but in any case we would have to run a couple more iterations to get to the exact shape of the curve that we would like as well as to the static motion ratio of 0.
1 that we would like to see so now that we're happy with the intro bar motion ratio and motion ratio variation versus Eve there is one less topic for us to discuss about the intro bar which are integral bar adjustments so intro buyers are very powerful to add the track for you to change the mechanical balance of the car and how do you do that you change something on the stiffness of the system that will influence the roll stiffness of that axle which will then change vehicle balance in this example we could have different options we could have the blade being a flexible blade where you just adjust the angle and it changes the stiffness of the component or what we're going to use for this case since it's just a little simpler we're going to Define different pickup points over here so when we look at the blade we would have different attachment points a little further away or a little closer to the intro bar and this will change the stiffness of the system so if we have picker points a little closer to the intro bar for the same suspension movement the anterior bar will twist more meaning that you make your intro bar effectively more stiff and if you make the speaker point a little further away you're gonna get a softer anti-roll bar from that so in our case what we want again we don't want to Simply find pick a point at 10 or 20 millimeter steps we want to Define first as always what the targets that we're trying to achieve are and then how much adjustment we need on the intro bar to get to that so we could be thinking what is the range of mechanical balance adjustment that we want or if we want to be more specific what is the roll stiffness variation that we want from the integral bars from the different pickup points now I would say I'm pretty happy with intro bar motion ratio and anti-roll bar motion ratio variation we also determined different anti-robar adjustments and the only thing missing is for for us now to iterate and then get you the exact values that we had in mind when we defined the design Target for that instead of keep doing manual iterations which are very time consuming we have two different options either you could have a parametrized cad model that we have discussed in previous episodes to help you with the design or we should be running optimizations which is what we're gonna do right now so I already have an optimization setup where we're going to define or indicate what picker points the solver can play with or pick a points he can change in order to achieve the objectives that we would like and I also defined the objectives in this case since we are designing the actuation systems I Define a few different parameters number one is the motion ratio in heave as well as the motion ratio variation basically the green line how it is changing as we compress the suspension and I also Define the same for the intro bar what is the static motion ratio for the introvert and what is the motion ratio variation that we want to achieve besides that it is also very important and Optimum kinematics is powerful because it allows us to do that is for you to make sure that all of the components are still on the same plane and aligned and you can do that by ensuring that the angle between the rocker and the coilover is close to zero meaning that they are aligned as you can see here the target is zero but also that the angle between the push rod and The Rocker is also close to zero and remember it's not only about the static position it's for the whole stroke of the suspension Movement we need to make sure that these angles are not critical they are close to zero we can then run this optimization and see what we can find so an optimization will be very powerful because it will find the best compromise between all the different objectives that we just defined so let's run the simulation once we start it you're going to see that it will be fine in different picker points that optimize to the objectives that we're defining so you can see that each generation will find a Best or a new best suspension we're gonna leave that running for a few iterations and then we're going to be able to look at what objectives the optimization was able to achieve so after running about 100 Generations let's see how the optimization module in warp Optimum kinematics performed first let's look at the objectives so we Define the motion ratio and motion ratio variation that we would like as seen in green which is our objectives and we see in blue what the optimization was able to find so it's trying to look at different many different compromises at the same time in terms of angles static motion ratio motion ratio variation and we can see that it got up to a pretty good result so the static motion ratio is off by only about 0. 01 and the motion variation is pretty much what we wanted in compression as I mentioned it's normal that we have a little bit of a sine shape when dealing with rocker so this is common now if we go to the motion ratio of the integral bar this is what we get we had the objective in green with 0. 1 defined as Target and the optimizer looking at everything at the same time found 0.