Bang and Olufsen Ex vs Hifiman Svanar Two of the most expensive wireless earbuds on the market. And two of the best sounding ones. For us, the choice between the Bang and Olufsen BeoPlay Ex and the Hifiman Svanar Wireless is kinda clear.
Namaste - we’re DHRME Dutch Headphoners Review Miraculous Earbuds Guys - these two sets of wireless earbuds, IEMs, in-ears - whatever you wanna call them cost close to $1000 dollars in total. So they better bring something special. Build and Design And well - the Svanar is bringing a special sound, which we’ll talk about in detail later on.
But on the hardware - you could say it’s trying too hard. To start off with, the buds are built using premium materials including carbon fiber whereas the Bang and Olufsen leans into metal and glass on the touch surfaces. The Svanar does stick out more from your ears and the shiny metal and the angular shape is gonna catch enough light to not be subtle.
The Ex has probably gone too much the other way with being subtle to the point of boring. On the cases, the multi-faced and multi-shaped case on the Svanar is anything but pocketable. Tight jeans will make you look like you have a medical problem versus the cool metal and flat case of the Bang and Olufsen Ex.
You won’t have medical problems with the buds though - both were plenty comfortable for us, but the Svanar probably had the more secure fit. Both of these luckily support wireless charging as well as charging via lightning. -smirks- USB Type C, we mean USB Type C!
And when on battery life - Bang and Olufsen claims 6 hours with ANC on and Hifiman claims 7 hours… on transparency mode? But we got a bit more than 7 hours on the Ex WITH ANC on and APTX Adaptive, whereas on the Svanar, we got 4 and a half hours with ANC On and LDAC which is a little concerning for the long-term durability of such an expensive product since batteries are the first things to give way. And while these are both probably too expensive for us middle class folks to work out in, it’s good to know that the Hifiman has an above average IPX5 rating for liquids and the Bang and Olufsen has probably an industry leading IP57 dust and water resistance rating.
But we can’t talk about the buds without talking about the controls. And here’s where the Bang and Olufsen Ex clearly races ahead for us. Having the touch controls housed under the glass circle clearly makes it avoid any kind of accidental taps while adjusting earbuds.
Whereas we kept activating the Svanar touch controls even while just putting them in our ears or taking them out. It’s not a deal breaker, but it is quite annoying. There is thankfully a clear audible signal indicating you’ve tapped the earbuds.
Beyond that both can do track, ANC and smart assistant control. The Bang and Olufsen does have the edge with volume control from the buds for calls and media. ANC and transparency But you’re not here for just the build and design.
So let’s talk about ANC and transparency. We were surprised and we had to double check our ears and testing gear for this, but the Hifiman Svanar takes the win here. The ANC, especially, was surprisingly good and we put it in Tier A of our ANC rankings with the likes of the Status Audio Between 3 ANC and the Sony WF 1000 XM4.
Also on transparency, the Svanar kicks the Ex’s ass with a reasonable Tier B ranking - enough for a short conversation, but not really a replacement for taking the buds out of your ears. The Bang and Olufsen just manages to be in Tier C. And what we also really enjoyed is that the Hifiman has very little white noise - making it very usable for longer periods of time in this mode, unlike something like the Status or the Sennheiser Momentum 3 which are very hissy in transparency mode.
Calls and Microphones Now we know - the audiophiles among you are going to whine - I just need to be able to hear my music - forget about your popsicles, icicles and testifying to the government about my audio cables. --mic samples-- The Bang and Olufsen lets in more background noise and the Hifiman tried to filter out outside noise at the cost of the voice clarity. Both of these struggle with heavier gusts of wind, but are fine with gentle breezes - about 2 metres per second was what we thought was usable on the Bang and Olufsen whereas the Svanar could handle a bit more wind.
Even 3 m/s didn’t break the voice down completely. In quiet conditions, we used both of these for phone calls and there were no complaints. In terms of vakman controls on the Hifiman - it’s just answer, hang up.
The Bang and Olufsen lets you control volume as we said earlier, but neither of these allow you to mute the call directly from the buds. --mic conclusion, vakman-- Extras and Features The Bang and Olufsen Ex clearly destroys the Hifman Svanar in one area - smarts. The Bang and Olufsen app gives you a ton of customisation using its iOS and Android app.
You can tweak settings, sound, ANC - you can do NO SUCH THING with the Svanar wireless, which is also app-less at this moment. Which is kind of a problem as we’ll see in the sound section. Unlike the Ex, you don’t have any kind of multipoint support on the Svanar, although it’s pretty easy to put into pairing mode - using either the button on the case or long pressing both earbuds when they’re in your ear.
And the Hifiman lets you pull connections from a previously paired device. A handy feature that the Bang and Olufsen doesn’t have! However - we did some face issues while pairing the Svanar - it at one point straight up refused to connect to one of our phones!
Frustrating! But let’s talk about the sound, because we have very few ‘frustrations’ about that. Audio So guys - let’s be clear - these are two different sounding products.
I mean the stock tunings are VERY different. Neither is necessarily a bass focused IEM. "We have generated frequency response charts, and they will help us tell a story.
Don't get too caught up in the charts themselves; we used standard equipment this time, specifically the 711 coupler, so there are some industry standards behind it. Let's start with the Hifiman Svanar. There's a clear bass bump that stands out the most to me.
The mid-bass bump is interesting, but there's not enough sub-bass, so that's something to take into account. Additionally, there's a significant midrange recession. It's not necessarily big, but it is there, and it sometimes causes vocals to recede into the background.
The treble is a standout feature, but also a bit of a disadvantage, especially the lower treble peak around 6K or just under. It can make it feel a bit unnatural, particularly with real instruments. Overall, though, these sound fantastic and very clean, especially on LDAC.
Now, let's talk about the Bang & Olufsen Beoplay Ex in comparison. We'll start with the neutral profile and the optimal EQ, which is the default setting. Note that you cannot enable any kind of EQ on the Bang & Olufsen unless you switch out of ANC mode.
They seem to suggest that ANC mode has a particular sound, and the neutral is the best place to get the sound. Comparing them, you can clearly see that these are two different sound profiles. The HiFiMan has a big mid-bass bump, while the Bang & Olufsen goes a bit heavier on sub-bass.
There's a difference in the midrange as well. I think the texture on the bass of the HiFiMan is slightly better, but both sound pretty good to my ear. Now, let's talk about the mids.
There's a clear recession in both of these, so I'm not saying that the Bang & Olufsen is a great neutral-sounding set of earbuds, quite the opposite. However, there's a bigger trough here on the Swanner. And now, let's talk a bit about the treble.
Clearly, the treble stands out much more on the Swanner, shown in red here. The general shape of the higher treble is the same on both, and I really like it. But on the lower treble, they're a bit different, especially around the 2K region.
Overall, both sound very good. An interesting thing about the Svanar is that it has no other sound; this is the only sound you get, no EQ settings, at least not from the first party. In contrast, the Bang & Olufsen Beoplay E8 does have EQ, and we've measured the top three EQ settings.
This is how it is with ANC on, and it's not necessarily our favorite sound with active noise cancelling enabled; it's a bit boomy and low-end heavy. It does sound pretty good, but not as good as these earbuds can sound. Then you have the neutral sound, and if you compare it to the ANC, you can see that the ANC really boosts the low-end, making it more focused on the low end.
On the mids, they're quite similar, and the treble is also quite similar. The good thing about the Bang & Olufsen Beoplay Ex is that it can really take EQ very well, even though it doesn't have a traditional EQ setting. Instead, it has that disc thing which you can move around.
For example, I wanted to compare one of those settings, the clear setting, which is more treble-heavy, and it compares quite well to this one. You can see on the clear setting that there's a clear reduction in bass, and it catches up with the other two on the mids. On the treble, it surpasses the other two.
If you want a more treble-forward presentation, I really like this clear setting as a starting point. Overall, there is a difference here, and now, if you compare the clear with the Svanar, you can see that the treble has caught up a bit, and the bass is much lower. My preference is the Bang & Olufsen Beoplay E, if for nothing else but the fact that you can really tweak the sound to your liking.
On the bass, I slightly prefer the Swanner, even though neither of these is bass-heavy earbuds. That's the conclusion, guys. " But a 2D chart is just a data point, so let’s add some more ‘objective’ data.
I’m not going to pretend I know what Svanar’s R2R DAC does, but the Svanar does employ LDAC and that can be leveraged across ALL Android devices. Whereas the Bang and Olufsen leans on APTX Adaptive - which has very limited support from phones. The lower APTX is supported on Android as well as Windows though.
For use with iPhones, both of these support AAC. So keep that in mind. So that’s it guys - we bought both these products with our own money.
We never accept monetary compensation from companies whose products we review, so if you wanna support we’d be happy to have you guys as our patrons and YouTube members. You’ve been Banging and Swanning And we’ve been DHRME. Doei!