so short suitor that I'm interested to your thoughts on it's the OOD ala chapter 7 the eighth two days about catch Anna so on one occasion the Buddha was living in savatthi in jeta's would in an Asif indicas park now on that occasion the venerable maja catch anna was sitting not far from the buddha having crossed his legs keeping his body upright having properly set of recollected nests of the body internally and then it would pemmican which so internally means properly recollected the mount very firmly the mother is the representative of the body if you
are mindful of the entry points of the body mm-hmm with the mind converges yes it's funny because those two words are jet time and Perry mocking but quite clearly adverbs the boat together that they're both describing mmm having set up properly set up manifested the body in this way magic time Parimal so our Jets hanging so the reason why I did Forellis because it's not about attending to your mouth right about watching sensations and your lips or something that's not what mouth is by the way your mouth is not your lips yeah so why would
you be concentrating on your upper lip or whatever yeah ask yourself what is my mouth yeah okay so it has the physical aspect but what is the significance of that physical aspect so the whole thing that's what mouth is so the physical side of it with the whole significance of it yeah consumption again point of relationship with the world pretty much a very personal thing consumption internally the speech expression communication relation everything converges on the mouth you taking up the mouth in that manner as in being ignorant of its nature means you take up the
entire body or body the aspect of the mouth which is what the body is so it's almost like the the mouth is the like first twenty contact the pretty much yes as I said before it's a point converging between like what's obviously mental yeah and what's obviously physical well this is that in-between where you are sort of muddled about yeah like how can your thoughts enter your mouth yeah yet you are speaking of this fact you're my heart is open your mouth is almost more your thoughts than any other part of your body it seems
to me that's is where the conceiving have yeah you regard your mouth as internally very thoroughly as that which actually belongs to the mental but he doesn't I think also I'm right in saying that there's so much more muscular like physical muscular control around the mouth they sure joke about it the way we it is what animals even more so the entire existence revolves around the mouth touch communicate do everything is going to mouth more often do not so if you so it's one way in which you can be mindful of the body hmm so
PI peripherally disowning the image the image of the mouth yep and then for you while you're doing that and that mouth stands for the body exec and that's what it's meant in those like anapanasati Souter yeah which is whatever body there that he discerns through his directness of breathing yeah that's what the body is for him yeah yeah that's one body in the body what is basically that is what your body is yes but by using that point what is that point for using using using the mouth as the body hmm just um yeah yeah
just down to the body your you're choosing something like the most fundamental link between the mind and the body when you're choosing you well so why the mouth why my parent were mouth well because the mouth just happens to be yeah this it has to be something this most fundamental primal primal hmm connection or not connection but place where they do kill yeah well even yeah like primal but in a sense natural way of sort of relating between the point of view and the body good because as you know in the other suitors it said
the body paired with consciousness consciousness is not in the body yeah no the body is in the consciousness it's just two simultaneous things and their relationship results in the entire nama Rupa pretty much that you can anything adequacy feel intend is the result of consciousness pair with the body or body in constant being there and that whole relationship between body and consciousness is inconceivable to you because if you were to conceive how is your body conscious or how the constant has the body they would imply that you can step outside of the those aggregates and
see how they relate that in you are fully within so the way this relationship is of the five aggregates is that like mental and material so to speak superimposed together and perception feeling intentions they're all already points of converging so to speak action on account of mental in regard to physical action are kind of physically engulfed mental so net if you look at it phenomenologically they're gonna be some points with these things converge yeah where the taking up of the body happens first and like why is it the mouth it's quite an airy and eleven
question because if it's not that it would have been something else but why it was probably revolves around the whole you know need for food hunger breastfeeding as a baby the first basically point of pleasure entrance into the world is through your mouth it's a kid as a toddler you're completely unaware of your limbs and everything else but you have awareness that's what your mind is and then you kind of grow from there but not at the expense of it but through it in other words that framework of your mouth being the point of the
laser remains in the area so you can only prove you can proliferate infinitely so within that framework yeah and then usually becomes more exactly because it's the pleasure that governs the direction of your proliferation if the mind is ignorant which every mind is in the beginning you go after pleasure so every point of of pleasure will kind of create a channel for possible proliferation so your mouth being the main point but then within that you know once say you're not starving you don't go hungry you eat five times a day you completely you stop seeing
it you stop seeing the point of pleasure being your mouth and you start looking further yeah that's the way the whole sexuality comes in the groin that's so literally in that suit up Anand I was teaching Ted none when he said it's it's the bridge yeah so sexual instruction the bridge but she compared it basically to the food you have to eat yeah and you can't stop eating yes so the food for your point of contact of what the mouth is is what the food is but the food for the point of contact of growing
is sexual integration so it's the same thing in a way just one is proliferated further yeah but it's the same principle and theoretically you could understand that principle but not before you actually stop providing food for the ground literally so that we said like no this this food is necessary sure so as a principle the food is necessary to some extent but not to the extent of of sexual integral that must be a band there is absolutely no justification for it but then you can't just stop eating food then in order to do the principal
on the level of the mouth now you can't stop having sexual intercourse and you will undo the principle of depending on the own sexual pleasure but you can't do that to the food cause it's it's much more fundamental and that's why again as we spoke into this routine the first jhana the at that you can't speak yeah as in the speech has subsided yeah because you're not taking up the mount mouth to the point of actual possibilities of breaking into speech and that's when the first jhana sexual sexuality or any sensuality becomes inconceivable you're fully
secluded from it because if you're not taking up your mouth in such manner how can you mind proliferate further to the other parts of convergence of pleasure on account of body yeah inconceivable so that's right so so this pairing mocking word which is usually translated as just in front hmm it's I think it only appears in this stop phrase with my front with mindfulness yeah and but it but it is different types of my mindfulness in the body of mindfulness because again it's the mindfulness is the recollect Nisour the same thing yeah that that if
we to think of it as primal congress which is what it is literally a parry around mocking mouth around the mouth yeah again that's what physical solitude was always like the Buddha would urge monks because you are not communicate yeah there's no chit chat there's no speaking there's no listening to the other because all those things imply convergence point of your mouth or whole domain of relationship through through verbal yeah and although although this like for example most of these who don't talk about jhana although one of them does but but if this is to
be understood as around the mouth then it just definite all this mindfulness is how much more closely related to Jonah then sure sure well that's that's how it's firstly related around the mouth means properly mindful yeah mindful proper representation of the phenomenon of the body and your experience as a whole yeah you can take that now in the direction of Johnny you want because you can then because it's on the basis of that same direction activeness exactly yeah so just twelve on particular characteristics of that yeah oh you can take to the direction of brahma
because as that city says yeah so you can take in many other directions yeah properly established established recollect earnest of that which is which happens to be the point of convergence between your mind and your body yeah usually and again like you see if you were to start to think like what is messy as we said before what is speech can you speech when you speak or when you don't speak is it speech the sound that comes out of your mouth yeah is it speech your thoughts being sort of you know solidify into the verbal
frequencies but how does that work exactly it's the air from my lungs that comes through the throat the only micro thing so basically my speech is the air from inside of me coming out and producing vibrations so are my thoughts in my belly and today it's ridiculous yet by not thinking about it you kind of merge it you merge the two together your thoughts in your feet I cannot see how they're two simultaneous phenomena not completely separate like they cannot possibly merge or relate it's just and that's why as Buddha said having thought important as
in having thinking and pondering they're enduring one breaks into speech the thing is funny how they I think it's the philosophic the tradition philosophers I think since Thomas Aquinas the this idea of to be human is to be that talking animal the rational animal languages like really well it's the domain of yeah of thought of reflection yeah of expression which is kind of limited to well certainly doesn't go love it into humans yeah Ricardo Ramos might be to communicate yet result but it's fast on establishing a domain of of speech these are significant so a
whole what we are is based on this idea of this connection between the mind in the mental file but magnify the mouth either speak the mining the material the mind and the material yeah yeah exactly yeah and it's same with the food again like you know you think look but consuming food yeah but disappearing in you you think like it's in you yeah but the food is in the belly which is out there with this table and this pot and the food so the food is still closer to where it was before then it's inside
of me yeah the whole notion of consumption is like literally you are dead barrier through which passes now it's in you but oh wait there is no in me it's just a point of view in regard to this whole thing yeah and all that in its peripheral to from what in regard to what you're looking for that's what I just add of the poly internal yes literally at I mean significant it is literally what what what peripheral is that's why the more you develop it the carnal less mine it sees it continues to be a
yeah so maybe we can say having crossed it like this is marker Charlie sitting having crossed his legs keeping his body upright having properly set up recollecting us of the body peripherally around the mouth hmm so the Buddha sees this having seen the meaning of this on that occasion he altered this utterance for whoever and it's a verse for however there is always recollected Ness constantly established on the body it's in the person inspired by what exactly what I described so when I said mean firefighter collecting this means basically recognizing the image of the body
but it's not actually attending to what you're perceiving which is the result of the body being there yes your perception of your own body is secondary yeah can't serve it's always and constantly always we've always record for whoever there is always recollecting this constantly stops on the body that doesn't mean focusing on something body body body yes no means like big collectiveness the context yeah anything that occurs is within it and fully full discernment of that makes the context imperturbable so it's always constantly there and then he says this because the body is always constantly
there yeah the way whether you where do you want to have not really aware about him so then he says it could not be it could not be mine hmm it will not be it will not be mine he who regularly stays in that place at the right time he crossed and destroyed all the conceit because as we just said when we started this that mindfulness offers peripherally the mouth is a convergence point that's not speaking he's mattress or the body yeah and it you you trained in that kind of peripheral image peripheral recognition recollected
miss you become familiar with the nature of it and the nature of their body is there like like a lump collection like pile of elements like other things that are around here that are clearly not yours clearly cannot be yours that's the point of that the cryptic verse no no it does think it's means likely not just that it's not mine but even in the future things cannot be any different so that things could possibly become mine it's inconceivable so not just that it could not be for me it won't be for me either way
it cannot be for me in the future because it's all on the basis of this right now which is unburnable so I mean basically it could not be it means like okay so there's this thing here but it could not be yeah that's a first you had no saying the thing that's here yeah so he could have not been yeah it could have not been here but whatever it is you won't be mine or for me because again it came on its own yeah so it's nothing other than like full development of the principle that
already so define understand yes and whatever is the nature to arise that's why it's a nature to cease yeah there's nothing it's not like cryptic it's not like some Vedic old verse or something it's just a description of an each other yeah on a most more secular level because there is absolutely not even a slightest room yeah for the sense of I am to remain lingering and in regards to that we did know like could have not been which means you know sane it's arising so and if if it could have if it's like it
could not have been manifested in which case there's no there's no possibility for it to be mine of course yeah so that that possibility for it to be mine isn't is not done through me it just happens to be because that it becomes possible because that things happens to have manifested yeah which which means does rubbish it it depends upon something which I have no control over so doesn't matter how much of it it is felt as mine how much of it is mine yeah fundamentally cannot be mine yeah that's right yeah yeah because there
is no mind we don't think given beforehand yeah there is no mind so that that hole those those that whole verse it's not it's it's it's it's not like a description of a process of what happens or how you have to reason it's just a direct insight of whatever is of the nature eyes that's why it's impairment no because I wait for it to see it disappear or because I apply my said no it's because it has a reason on its own yes that's why it will have it simple that's why I cannot own it
that's it let's be explicit it here means but the body we talked about is this mindfulness the shoddy in mindfulness of the correctness of the body body being the necessary basis for everything yeah your whole universe is within the body within the basis of the body so that you regard the body yes that which is just could have not been as in I've not seen it as much I are not I'm not it's master with that means there is i cannot entertain ownership even if I want to yeah and that's automatically felt by the way
the absence of ownership yeah once you see it correctly you don't need to then go and take let go of your ownership on account of what you understood your understanding means letting go of the ownership and that also will start to pertain that to the possibility of the future body as in later on you can see if you're not completely free from doubt like it might be apparent that now nothing can be used but there is a still tacit assumption record if things might be different in the future to some extent and to that extent
to allow you to own them yeah but now even the whole domain not a particular possibility of this so that but the main of the possibility as if the nature of possibilities has to be of the same nature that it's unknowable because it's it could have not been thus it won't be for me whichever way it is yeah cannot be for me even if I wanted to and so regularly staying in that place yeah clarifying recollecting and then clarify what you recollected the context of the body correctly which is that peripheral recognition that the body
is here see I'm talking to you feeling like this thinking that want to do that because this body's here enduring is a necessary basis for all these possibilities and actual engagements so it's not about you finding in like the particular points of your body sensations and attending to it because I think that in order to do that you need to ignore the context yeah see that's another act you're caught up in am I telling this I'm pretending this and feeling tension moving moving whatever else no all of that is possible because the body is there
beforehand already and that's where your mindfulness is recollecting that right order recollecting the correct image the mind comes first because the right image comes first that's that's the entire point the clearly that becomes the harder to lose it it will become the harder to distract yourself from it it will become and that means you're gonna be your experience will be more and more and more dispassionate yeah and at the right time he crosses over attachment yeah I think all of the conceits all the attachments all the senses of ownership or whatever else you've been sort
of entertaining however vaguely it ceased because you stopped providing fertile basis for it