[Music] okay you can hear me very good my field my academic field is national relations international politics and in that field there's a lot of talk recently about something called non-western IR IR means international relations non-western means well that which is not from the West so why are they talking about this well basically because the Western understanding of international politics has dominated universities around the world that is to say Western concerns about the Cold War about Russia about capitalist system about how to dominate the rest of the world is what's always discussed within this field
and in other parts of the world of course they have other ideas they're interested in other things they have other interests so this is why countries are growing quickly that have a lot of self-confidence like China for example they have started to demand a different kind of study of international politics different kind of IR China Brazil India Turkey as well right why should we read these books these Western books we want something different so the question is what would this be and this is not so clear so even though there's a very strongly felt need
that we need to do something come up with something new it's still the case that scholars are sort of Europe and North America they think in the same old terms in the same old ways so this is where I have some ideas ok I was thinking we need to do something about this we need to come up with a truly non-western IR we need to be much more radical so to begin this argument let's start by seeing what does Western IR mean well above all it means the state it's always about the state and the
state is sovereign meaning that it can decide for itself its laws its actions its foreign policy no one can interfere with the state it has borders it has a community of people has a nation it has a way of regulating who comes in and who goes out it has a flag it as a foreign ministry all this stuff but of course one state always exists together with other states and they are functionally equivalent to each other they're all similar as the states and they all belong together in a system of international international system system of
states so this is the Western view of the world but it wasn't always like this if you go back in history you'll find but there were other international systems organized in different ways if you go to ancient China East Asia totally different you go to middle America the Mayas totally different again Yoruba city-states in with today's Nigeria totally different logic so in other words there many different ways of thinking about international politics they're not the Western ways so how did that happen that the Western Way became the predominant one why are we today all living
in a Western world well it had to do with colonialism above all in the 19th century however colonialism is of course the radical opposites right colonialism is not self-determination and sovereignty it's it's controlled from from your so really it was only when the different states are the different colonies made themselves independent from Europe that they became European type states they liberated themselves on European terms and what happened here was some in one colony after another a leader would emerge who would say I can run this country I can be in charge and I'm going to
do it exactly in the European fashion I'm going to create a sovereign state which is just like the states in Europe and at the time Europeans were very worried about giving independence to all these countries because well you never knew what was going to happen right but these nationalist leaders that emerge in one colony after another are enormously reassuring because he often gone to school in Europe they speak European languages the rhetoric was very anti Western but in practice they were in cahoots with the Western colonial powers they took over the colonies created European type
States and perpetuated the European the Western international system so in other words it was the terms on which Independence happened that created a world made up of only European states and an international system which was a Western international system now this didn't work very well in one country after another the states failed there were no States there were no peoples they were nomadic groups there were tribes there were clients but they didn't fit with the maps that the Europeans had drawn up and of course the nationalist leaders had a problem then you have your own
country you're in charge but what are you going to do if there is another institution since there's no people so in their desperation they turned to the West for help and there we given help from agencies to be helped build these nations helped build these states they were given weapons very important all the Nationals leaders were given weapon so that they could defend the state defend its borders and of course this was also a way for Western countries to make money right selling weapons but failure in some cases was total we had one country after
another in Africa and in Asia it just couldn't do it and it's not so strange you know because non European countries are not very good at being European Western countries are so much better at being Western countries they were trying to live up to standard there was just unfair so of course it failed but there were also successful cases we had countries like China Israel Turkey of course they were able to emulate the West they could create strong States and they could create very strong nations but this only happened at a terrible cost because in
the process of creating this powerful non-western nation-states other groups were killed off chased away murdered and the nationalism that is created is a very stupid kind of simplistic artificial nationalism the nationalism of Ataturk the nationalism of Zionism the nationalism of of the Chinese Communist Party so even when there were successes the situation was terrible because these people who didn't get a country like the Kurds like the Tibetans like the Palestinians they didn't go away they were still there creating endless problems so my suggestion in other words is that if we really want to think in
non-western terms which is start from the beginning we should reject this basic model of Western international relations the basic model of the state and of the state system we need to go back to something different something pre-european something that existed before the Europeans showed up it seems to me that we can look to past we can study the present we can also look to the future we can get some inspiration now compare the Ottoman Empire with the situation in today's Middle East the multiple Empire was a multicultural multi-ethnic Empire where lots of different people could
live and we could live according to their own laws in today's in the Middle East instead we have the European system we have rigid borders we have nationalism which is very exclude Neri imagine how great it would have been if the ottoman empire hadn't disappeared in 1923 we imagine if you could recreate an ottoman empire today it would be very easy for example if you're a Jew to live in Israel and the Jewish person's Palestinian neighbor could at the same time live in Palestine because everyone could live in the country of their own imagination if
this still was a Ottoman Empire today they'd be a lot of Jews in Cairo they'd be a lot of Jews in Baghdad they'd be a lot of Greeks in Constantinople to be a lot of Greeks in Smyrna or look at today's world everyone's favorite example of a failed state is from Mali oh now Somalia clearly has problems but they also have resources in Somalia you have a very strong nomadic tradition nomads have a different way of organizing politics they don't have a state but they have institutions with constant conflict resolution and justice thematic institutions what
will happen if we focused on those forget about trying to rebuild Somalia Institute some kind of European country take what they have take their nomadic traditions and improve them strengthen them I think this is important for a very particular reason because there's always an assumption that nomadic way of life belongs to the past and the state is the future I don't think that's necessarily true at all in a globalized world we are all moving around more and more we are pushed and pulled by the forces of global capitalism and as a result we are becoming
more nomadic a lot of people here are from all different corners of the world we are becoming no it seems that we need different kinds of institutions that worked better for us we need political institutions that we can take with us as we move and it seems to me that the nomads of the past has a lot to teach the nomads of the future failed states don't always only happen in Africa or Asia they happen in Europe too in fact the EU is premised on the idea of failed States States failed in Europe they failed
to provide peace there was a first world war there was the Second World War the problem was exactly nationalism and sovereignty and the EU is created as an attempt to deal with this problem with the failed States of Europe and today of course we have an additional issue which is that of globalization one state just isn't strong enough big enough to deal with his problems for pollution migration internet companies drugs whatever so the states have to pool their resources sovereignty has to be pooled United and this is what the EU does EU is the EU
is an organization for pooling sovereignty why is this necessary because the states have failed the face of Europe can't do what they're supposed to do in fact it's interesting you know if you go back to the Middle Ages you had an international system in Europe they looked an awful lot like the EU that too was a big community organized around the church but there's also a lot of Independence for different kings and rulers this is something very similar to what we have today in Europe so it seems to me even in the case of the
EU there's a way to go back to previous system which perhaps is more viable so this is the basic lesson if you made yourself independent on someone else's terms you will never be independent if you gain sovereignty given to you by the Europeans if you're lucky like Turkey you will become almost European not quite right you're never quite good enough but you're sort of almost there at least you think in your mind you are but if you're unlucky as most countries were you completely fail your society your economy your politics is ruined and devastated and
you become a failed state in a basket case so the way to think about non-western I R I suggest is to go back to the previous non European non-western ways of thinking the day we do that we will all be living in a better world and perhaps also a more peaceful world thank you very much [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]