September 11th was one of the darkest days in American history that ironically began as a clear sunny day and to add to the irony it was a sunny relief to the stormy weather of September 10th it was the beginning of New York Fashion Week JLo and Ja rules I'm real set at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 competition reality TV Mainstay The Amazing Race had just premiered for the first time the week before an NBC's must TV lineup led by a plethora of shows based in New York City was the tele Vision Delight of
millions and the soundtrack for Mariah Care's critically pan romantic musical drama glitter had just been released up until 45 a.m. it was just another day and nearly 60 seconds later the world would never be or feel the same again the immediate aftermath of September 11th found millions of Americans glued to their television screens ingesting hours worth of gruesome footage of what once was the Twin Towers that had been a part of New York City skyline for more than 30 years at that point Millions remained in a state of Arrested Development unsure of what to say
or do or feel oscillating between anger angst sadness and confusion none of the usual Comforts of Pop Culture felt all that comforting or even appropriate at this point in the face of mass Devastation in fact there was a heavy sense of apathy with everything feeling frivolous and nothing really mattering with a lot of news Publications saying that the innocence was over but to the US government that couldn't become a reality because very very soon after we were told to get out of our houses spend money go and see a Broadway show try and live life
like it was September 10th there was a call for everyone to go back to normal but just remember we're all Americans and we're all United except for the ones that we deem as not being American enough and if we sit by and do nothing then the terrorists win and 20 years later the United States is still using that same Playbook of smiling and spending through trauma as when face what they Global pandemic it told its citizens to go back to normal it's a very there is no war and bossing say approach from September 11th onward
the American pop culture sphere was completely changed and we're still experiencing those changes to this day almost 25 years later hi I'm Bobby this is culture kit and today we'll be taking a deep dive into the impact of 911 on pop culture disclaimer this is a massive topic and I won't be able to cover every single facet of it in this one video but I will be linking a lot of sources that I use for research for this as well as a lot of really great channels that have gone in depth into specific topics that
we'll be talking about today so if you'd like to learn more all of that information will be down below also I am not here to tell you how to feel about the event of 911 and the ensuing aftermath of it if you were alive to remember it and to have very strong feelings about it this is simply a cultural overview if you have any personal anecdotes that you'd like to share I'd love to read them down in the comments pop culture was already looking very different by 12:00 p.m. on September 11th major channels had halted
programming to switch to the major news networks like ABC CBS NBC and fox and you know it was serious because they also halted commercials it's only something very very serious that happens in America that causes capitalism to not stop but pause sporing events were also canell though WWE formerly wwf's then Thursday night SmackDown would air live on September 13th from Houston Texas making it the first major public event to be held of its size a fact that they really Relish in still and in hindsight might not have been the safest thing to do two days
after a major terrorist attack but USA USA Disney World was closed for the first time in its history and this wouldn't happen again until the beginning of the covid-19 pandemic in March of 2020 and most prominently by the afternoon Clear Channel now iHeart media had sent out a memorandum of 150 plus songs that were to be pulled from radio stations Across the Nation that had content that was either too close to the events of the day or were deemed too celebratory these songs range from maybe understandably it's the end of the world as we know
it and I feel fine by RM and Jump by Van Halen but they also pulled any largely political songs or groups like The memorandum band the entire discography of Rage Against the Machine which leads us into our first section music music was interesting in a post 911 world and it began with that memorandum I mentioned almost immediately we were curtailing our artistic taste to take into account this very new and fresh tragedy the musical identity of our new state of mourning was marked by being sorrowful but hopeful but not too hopeful as to forget the
sorrow remember that we are coming off of the 1990s which was a decade of letting the good times Ru and a lot of ways with bubblegum pop hip hop and new metal dominating the Airways by the end of the decade the headset Mike ritten catchy works of the Backstreet Boys in sync and most prominently Britney Spears were the rhythm of a youthful nation that had its downfalls but was doing all right for the most part the sounds of artists like Missy Elliott Outcast and Jay-Z whose album The Blueprint was released on September 11th were taking
hip-hop into the New Millennium and new metal well they just wanted to break [ __ ] but now what dominated stations AC across the country were songs of resilience and sadness that might have been the only thing that made sense at that time in the weeks following there were countless musical tribute specials like America a tribute to Heroes the concert for New York City and United We Stan that brought together musicians from all genres to to memorialize victims and raise funds for Relief efforts and even Congress thought it necessary to sue the nation with a
pitchy at best rendition of God Bless America as if we weren't already going through enough soon after we began to see original Works about the events themselves and there are a lot of them like Cold Play's politic and Bruce Springsteen's 2002 album The Rising which features many songs about the day from various perspectives however not every song about 911 was reverent and sorrowful one genre embraced a rather aggressive and retributive sound country the growth of American Jango ISM due to 911 was certainly not a shock but country music's Embrace of it was something for a
solid 5-year run the sub genre of country music that can be best described as this was turning out chart topping hits that were all about America and freedom and the flag and most pronounced the military it's worth it to note that less than a month after the attacks the United States would announce an invasion of Afghanistan in October of 2001 seeming jump starting their revenge tour for the events of 911 the Hallmark of this sound is Toby kei's Courtesy of the Red White and Blue that features the lyric cuz we'll put a boot in your
ass is the American way this genre that sounds like if an American flag gains sentience and started making music had had a place in the charts for years according to executive director of country radio broadcasters RJ Curtis when he talked to Rolling Stones saying if you put USA or America in a song you had a pretty good chance of getting attention to be fair there were also songs like Alan Jackson's where were you when the world stopped turning that were what Joshua huuk for Rolling Stones described as quote explicitly a song for those who like
Jackson and his listeners live far away from New York or DC and were struggling to make sense of what happened there these songs in the ensuing sentiments and culture around them became a defining factor for country music for almost 20 years and hasn't until now began to let up but as the war on ter again some country music artists began to diverge from this messaging most famously the chicks whose lead singer Natalie Ms criticized then President George W bush for the US's involvement in the Iraq War an action that would get the group blackballed and
spur the song Not Ready to make KN which would then in turn inspire a new crop of country artists including Casey Musgraves back in the sphere of popular music there was a sentiment in the early days that bubblegum pop and its princess Britney Spears were going to be p and out of date in fact there were many cases of vandalism of her upcoming HBO special because she was in turn a representation of all that was frivolous in American pop culture but not too long after this the crowds of TRL began to fill back up again
and American pop music was back on top its brief moment of reference had already alleviated by the end of the year on the fringes of popular music anti-war songs began to crop up like Rage Against the Machines 2003 song March of death and most popularly Green Day's American Idiot Green Day's American Idiot is perhaps the best example of what a lot of young people felt at this point having just seen the events of 9/11 and in turn also seen many of them be sent off to fight an unjust War Green Day's American Idiot felt very
representative of their disillusionment and in turn angst to what was happening with their government American Idiot was certainly a hit but many critics have theorized a sort of wave of political defanging that happened with post 911 American pop culture there was melting disapproval of the war and growing disgruntlement with how long it was going on it's here towards the end of the 2000s that we get songs like John mayor's Waiting on the World to Change or The Black eyp Peas where Is The Love that began to lament about the state of the world and how
the US still has many domestic problems to address instead of fighting its forever war overseas that got millions of innocent people killed the music of post on 11 America does retain some of that political defanging that I mentioned earlier this could be due in large part to the fact that many Americans have grown very disillusioned with their government and the interest that it has in the health and well-being of the average American citizen we didn't see a great Renaissance of protest songs coming out around this time but we did see a slight Resurgence of it
in the early 2020s mainly with Kendrick Lamar's all right that was used very prominently during the black lives matter protest but as a whole music in post 911 America definitely felt different almost immediately after the events of 911 the Silver Screen began going through a very drastic change starting on September 11th and for the next couple of weeks many films that were pending release had to hastily re-edit many of their scenes that would potentially either evoke images similar to the events of 911 AKA large explosions or completely erase images of the Twin Towers films like
the first of Sam Ry Spider-Man trilogy and Disney's Lilo and Stitch would famously have to re-edit much of their imagery to take into account the tragedy for Spider-Man many of the promotional material and the trailer for the film would feature a spot with the twin towers and one of the ending sequences of Lilo and Stitch would have Stitch flying through downtown Honolulu and a hijack jetliner weaving and bobbing through buildings which obviously was not going to be received well for its 2002 release Spider-Man is an interesting case as New York City is basically a character
in the cannon of the superhero so The Disappearance of the Twin Towers from its Skyline had to be taken into account scenes that were meant to show the resiliency of New Yorkers and a love of the USA were added to the film like the fight on the Queensboro Bridge where the citizens fought back against the Green Goblin uttering that if you mess with one of us you mess with all of us and one of the final shots of the film which features the man of spider holding on to a flagpole with an American flag Flying
high in the case of Lelo and Stitch this entire sequence had to be reworked very quickly before it's released in 2002 which if you know anything about animation that is a crazy feat to accomplish the initial cut of the scene was put on a special edition DVD some years later and you could see that the things that had to be reworked or making the plane that Stitch flew look a little bit more alien and like a spaceship making its interior cabin look a little bit more Star Trek rather than the cabin of a commercial jetliner
and of course changing the surrounding location from being a Downtown City Center to a remote beach that was devoid of any humans most films had to release in the month of September that had remotely anything to do with action and could potentially evoke the images of September 11th were also pushed including Martin scorsese's Gangs of New York and Training Day starring Denzel Washington Independence Day Deep Impact and Armageddon all featured scenes that featured New York specifically the World Trade Center in Peril with Armageddon featuring a scene that looked eerily similar to a lot of news
footage of the towers after they had been hit they also had to be pulled from any television syndication and quickly re-edited in fact a lot of films that had been released but just happened to take place in New York had to be digitally re-edited to erase any image of the Twin Towers in a sense Hollywood was trying to completely erase the image of the Twin Towers from its cinematic history as not to evoke sorrow so far you've noticed that the immediate cultural response of 911 was a lot of censorship it was the equivalent of sending
a child out of a room during the violent part of a movie in an attempt to protect its very fragile public censorship loomed heavily over Hollywood and other related Industries on the one hand it was completely understandable as many people were regularly taking in this very devastating imagery and lots of Hollywood films could potentially become triggers for them it's almost important to know that all almost every second of the terrorist attacks of September 11th both in New York City and Washington DC were being documented in real time it's a bit different to an event like
the sinking of the Titanic that was largely recounted and documented in the stories of people who were on the ship and survived 911 could be recounted in multiple ways including Survivor stories news coverage the work of photojournalists and there was a massive growth of amateur film making that was happening around this time as there were many consumer grade camcorders that were on the market and were owned by lots of people so your average Joe scho could go out on the street if he lived in New York City and also record his own recollection of the
day's events everyone basically had a connection to the event in some way on the other hand they were very understandably critics of the censorship of post 911 media with many calling into account the question of autonomy in art on a grander scale it could also call into question of what narratives and images are being disseminated to the public around the events of this tragedy which led many scholars to theorize that this form of censorship could influence the emotions of the country and almost provide a blink check for imperialistic aggression in the name of protecting the
country and saving democracy the headline from the onion funnily enough does the best job of summing up what the potential fear was when it comes to this type of censorship us vows to defeat whoever it is we're at war with it would be another four or 5 years before Hollywood decided what it wanted to do with the events of the day in the immediate there were thoughts that there would be no more films that would show widescale destruction and that Hollywood media would become a lot more Kinder and gentler almost as if to serve as
a security blanket for a very wounded nation that would not last films like Z spil Works wor the world dealt with the events of 911 in a more indirect way with academics Maria Flood and Michael C Frank for the conversation saying step Spielberg 2005 adaptation of the world of the world transplants HG wells's late Victorian story to post 911 New Jersey and Boston the tagline of the film quote they're already here Echoes fears of sleeper cells suggesting that the enemy is already in the US undetectable and waiting to be activated after the alien tripods have
emerged from below the ground to wreak havoc on innocent bystanders the prot an agon's daughter asked her Ash covered father is it the terrorist and in the fifth anniversary of the attacks Hollywood was ready to take on the events of the day had on with Oliver Stones as World Trade Center and Paul Green grass's United 93 both released in 2006 the first of which depicted the events in New York City from the perspective of two police officers who found themselves trapped in the North Tower during the collapse of the South Tower and the second which
told the heroing tale of the passengers who took back the hijack playing 93 potentially thwarting another terrorist attack both films involve the families of victims and the survivors in their production with the United 93 having real people play themselves in the film and World Trade Center having the officers John mcclaflin and will jamino and their wives involved in the writing and production though it is important to note that both films did face some backlash from the family members of victims with how their specific family members were depicted or just simply with being involved in the
production that does commercialize their loved ones death these films were decently well received and did pretty okay at the box office but they weren't carried through cinematic history in the same way as something like 1997's Titanic which has essentially eclipsed the historical event that it's depicting one could argue that the reason for this was that 5 years was still a little bit too soon and the audiences that would be going to see this movie also live through the event as it just took place 5 years prior and so they may also not have been exactly
ready to reckon and see depicted with a Hollywood lens this incredibly traumatic day Hollywood didn't attempt many more movies that dealt with 911 directly from the perspective of sorrowful remembrance and instead opted for Escapist media centered around superheroes and Fantastical worlds that could explore themed around 911 without irly recalling the events scholar psychers for Nolan's The Dark Knight trilogy as being the impetus of the superhero genre beginning to explore this kind of grim dark aesthetic but of course it is the Marvel Cinematic Universe that became a very large figure in post 911 film and it
certainly makes sense why they were so popular as their narratives are about superhero figures coming in to save everyday people and terroristic situations almost as if to rewrite the events of 9/11 in a much more Fantastical way and it's also worth it to note that there is government interest let's just say in these particular films when it comes to depictions of American government that tend to be centered around American exceptionalism that could also breed some pretty harmful rhetoric that the government used to its Advantage around this time these films came in tan with films that
are about the Fallout of 911 and the ensuing military activity in Afghanistan and Iraq like American Sniper Zero Dark 30 and other films like Overfield remember me that is not a 911 film into the very very end and Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close we also have to note that there is a looming presence of stereotypes that plagued a lot of post 911 media specifically with how people from the Middle East were being depicted we all know the famous seia tone that went rampant in a lot of 2000s and 2010's film when depicting any country that
was inhabited by mostly brown people and there was a sense of just a general flattening of a lot of Middle Eastern cultures and you can definitely see how this flattening of culture would do harm in the real world many black and brown people especially Muslim Americans in the country were being faced with a lot of heavy stereotypical material that came out around this time that was heavily influencing how they were living life in this country the topic of film in post 911 America is far too vast to cover in one video and would probably have
to be its own video but in the meantime I highly recommend Lindsay Ellis's Loose Cannon series that covers films directly dealing with the events of 911 both from a domestic perspective and an international perspective television perhaps has the most interesting relationship with 911 as it was how many of us received news of the event the 24hour news cycle was all but cemented in our everyday lives as Millions were watching every single day hours worth of footage of the towers being hit them collapsing and in the very early days of news coverage some very horrific images
that featured people falling from the towers to their deaths the ramifications of seeing images like that for days and hours and weeks on end we are still figuring out to this day television was essentially the door into this new world that we were getting to know and would be for the next 20 years on the news front the presence of the news ticker became a main stay for many news channels allowing for multiple pieces of news to be reported on at the same time Federal investigations Survivor recounts and relief efforts were pretty much all that
dominated TV for the coming weeks especially with the announcement of the US invasion of Afghanistan less than a month later for non-news TV the first steps forward came from the world of late night television as one by one the host of very popular late night shows came back on air many of them taping live from New York City the first of which to return to air was David Letterman who delivered a powerful and honest monologue that was a more cathartic heart-to-heart to a nation that didn't know what to do either than an opener to a
late night talk show hosts like John seart who then went on to be a strong advocate for healthc care for 911 First Responders delivered a powerful and tearful opener to political satire show The Daily Show that very briefly revealed that the people in our TVs were not just entertainers but people just like us people who were sad and angry and Confused just like us the death toll of 911 has almost doubled due to the fact that more people have died due to toxic exposure from Ground Zero including survivors and First Responders then people who were
killed on the day so we are very much so still dealing with the healthc care aftermath of an event like that 25 years later jokes weren't completely devoid at this time but there was a looming sense of feeling like we had to ask if we could call on the security blanket that is comedy and humor live from New York Saturday Night Live returned with a group of firefighters wearing their gear that was covered in Ash from the rubble and then New York city mayor Rudy Giuliani who if you can believe it had been deemed times
person of the year and was seen as America's mayor crazy turn of events the tone of the first Saturday Night Live post 911 was humorous but a bit somber and also for some reason featured blackface like that was supposed to help I don't know because of what used to be a much quicker production cycle television was one of the first mediums to be able to respond to the events narratively like NBC's political drama the West swing that aired an episode dealing with terrorism airing 3 weeks after the attacks and many shows like 24 and Homeland
were very guilty of perpetuating the insert brown person here and cast them in a negative light concept and also made very regular practice of normalizing torture which no doubt had very terrible in-person ramifications for black and brown people in the country who by the way were probably also in mourning and also angry and sad and what if shows that were said in New York City in the '90s many of the most popular sitcoms were said in New York City like friends Living Single and in Seinfeld New York City was the place for sitcoms and by
2001 it felt like sitcoms were starting to move out of the city perhaps the wound of the city was too fresh and in the minds of many Americans New York felt very off limits and so that's when we see the growth and prominence of shows like the office and parks and wreck and My Name is Earl that take place in other parts of the country of course this isn't to say that TV avoided New York City as there were still plenty of shows that were set in the city like HBO Smash Hit sax the city
and 30 Rock many of these shows that were airing pre 2001 obviously featured imagery of the twin towers and the World Trade Center and much of that imagery had to be scrubbed in doing research for this video I was very curious about what the response of children's media was I don't feel like we often think about the impact of Pop Culture when it comes to kids but kids media is incredibly important to the growth and development of kids so how do you explain something of the scale to a child when the adults that are making
them are also trying to make sense of it one of the most prominently remembered for perhaps good and bad reasons is Disney Channels Express Yourself series these were originally a series of interstitials that featured Disney Channel stars talking about friendship and being yourself and general kid stuff but but the channel decided to do a special run of the express yourself series with its Stars discussing albeit mostly indirectly the events of 9/11 there's really great article from team vog that I'll link down below that goes into much deeper detail about the general response and what the
place of something like that was in media at the time many at the time saw it as a necessary and maybe cathartic message for kids who were dealing with the events that they saw probably in real time and others saw it as much more propagandic in nature not too long after that in 2004 Disney Channel features the events of 911 in a decom called tiger Cruz starring a very young Hayden year that is too much for this video but it's just as crazy as it sounds it was a noble attempt I think but still the
other side of the spectrum children's media's most trusted teacher PBS also put out a lot of material around educating kids on the events of 9/11 popular series zoomed in an episode talking about firefighters and how they help communities Reading Rainbow did segments about 911 where host Lar buron talked to the kids of ps234 in New York City about how they cope with the events of the day and how children from around the world were sending messages of hope and love to the kids of the US Fred Rogers came out of retirement to speak to kids
and adults about how to deal with this difficult situation and encourage parents to have open discussions with their children Arthur had a two-part episode dealing with the events of 911 indirectly as the episode is set around a fire that takes place at the school with each of the characters meant to depict a different emotion that the a audience might have felt while watching the collapse of the Twin Towers according to the Arthur Wiki quote in the September 11th attacks Min experienced loss in trauma directly which correlates with suelin losing her Irreplaceable diary and Binky is
traumatized by the sight of the flames and others felt tremendous anxiety after the disaster with Arthur who was anxious about his father's well-being meanwhile many people were not directly affected by the attacks yet still felt the impacts of the aftermath which is represented by buster who was absent from school during the fire and feels disconnected and finally the show that has had New York City as its background for more than 50 years Sesame Street also did a segment talking about the events in a segment featuring Elmo an accidental fire breaks out in Mr Hooper's store
which is promptly put out by real life FDNY firefighters who calm Elmo ensuring him that firefighters are a very important members of the community that keep everyone safe television eventually found its flow again but you can tell tell that 911 made an indelible impact on the industry and this finally brings us to internet culture in 9/11 and 911 almost as Pop Culture in and of itself one of the most famous fallouts of 911 is chronicling the pop cultural journey of works that were inspired by or kind of directly related to the events so there is
a very popular chart that has appeared on Tumblr that Chronicles that because of 9911 Gerard Way started My Chemical Romance which then inspired Stephanie Meyer to write Twilight which eventually led to the creation of 50 Shades of Gray and there are all of these different pop cultural things that wouldn't have happened assumingly without 911 which in turn does lend itself to this uptick in what I'm calling the memeification of 9/11 that has been happening much more prominently in the past 2 to 3 years it's mainly centered around a lot of gen Z people feeling very
distant from the event and in turn finding some humor in it but I think that's a video for next year as we can see tragic events shape culture in ways that many of us can't really anticipate in the 20 plus years since the collapse of the Twin Towers what we're listening to what we're watching and what we're wearing has been reflective of our Collective uncertainty and anxiety for the future the pop culture of this era was a snapshot of our colle itive anger and sadness and general confusion that ran the gimmi from Justified and vengeful
to irrational and destructive to disillusioned and apathetic the pop culture of a post 911 America is intense complex somewhat Nuance at times aimless and above all an incredibly fascinating snapshot of modern history