hey everyone this is Andrea from doctors of running and today I'm here to do a head-to-head comparison of the Nike alphafly 3 and the hoca cell X1 I've really been enjoying running in these shoes this winter and while they definitely have S similarities they're also some significant differences so let's get into both let's talk about the specs first so for the alphafly 3 we've got 40 mm of stack in the heel 32 in the 4 foot giving it a drop of 8 mm the cello X1 is almost the same 39 in the heel 32 in the 4 foot giving it a drop of 7 mm but where these two shoes really differ are their weight this yellow X1 is significantly heavier than the alphafly so first of all Hoka gives their men's weights in a size 10 whereas Nike and most other brands give their weights in a size nine so it's hard to do a direct comparison but they're women shoes they both give us the weight and size eight so the alphafly 3 in a men size 9 is 7. 0 Oz and the cello X1 in a men's size 10 is 9. 3 oz so that's 2.
3 o different but again we're comparing a size 10 to a size 9 but in the women's size 8 the cello X1 comes in at 7. 4 o whereas the alphafly 3 comes in at 6. 1 so that's 13 O different between the two shoes that's pretty significant especially for a racing shoe um I'll get in a little later if I actually felt that difference in weight between the shoes but definitely in terms of specs the weight difference is the most significant thing price Ally 3 is 285 C X1 is 275 so pretty comparable all right let's talk about fit now so the C X1 is hands down the most comfortable best fitting Hoka I have tested most hokas I've had issues with their sidewalk walls rubbing on particularly like the inside of my big toe so most of those shoes I haven't been able to do really long runs in I was concerned when I got the CLX one that I would have that same problem but I had zero issues in this shoe this shoe was so comfortable for me so I was really excited about that um not only for the fit because I like how it runs too but fitwise if Hoka sidewalls have bothered you in the past they're probably not going to bother you in this shoe um I found the cell x one to fit true to size in length um the width of the 4 foot is really nice I had plenty of room for my mtps without feeling like it was too wide or sloppy whereas in the alphafly 3 um I would definitely go up a half size in the alphafly 3 for length I got my usual size 9.
5 and it was just a little too short I got bruised big toenails every time I ran in the Sher um so if I was buying the shoe I'd definitely go up a half size for the elfly 3 CX one fits really nicely true to size couple other fit notes about the shoe in the clo X1 you can see you've got a pretty wide platform the whole way it tapers a little bit in the midfoot and I'll talk a little more about this lateral midfoot cutout here but if you look at the alphafly 3 you can see how much it Narrows in the midfoot and that is noticeable both in terms of fit like I know a lot of people had issues with how narrow the midfoot was in elfly one um I never had that issue but you can definitely notice that it fits the most snug through the midfoot so if the midfoot of elfly one was too narrow for you then the midfoot of Ally 3 probably will be too so comparing the two shoes definitely a little more width in the midfoot of C X1 little narrower in elfly 3 both shoes in the toe box there's pretty good width I didn't have any irritation in the elfly 3 in terms of width um no irritation on my first MTP or anything but like I said the length in the Ally 3 definitely made my big toenails pretty sore um another important fit note here the laces in the cell X1 are not great um they're really flat and stiff and they're actually a little bit wider than the eyelids so it's hard to really pull on them and get them to lock down at each eyelet row um the alphafly 3 has the typical um like textured lacing system that Ally 1 and two did you don't have to pull really hard on the laces to get it to lock down I've never really had any issues with tightening down the laces and Ally one and I definitely didn't an elfly 3 so in terms of lacing and lock down definitely prefer this structure with alply 3 over the not so great laces of C X1 that being said once I got these laces in the right place I had no issues with lockdown it's just a little Annoying to get there so those are the major fit things um let's move on to Performance so Ally 3 definitely has a more aggressive ride for me and I find that that's because of the placement of the airpods basically the airpods are right at the start of the 4 foot rocker so for me I land at my lateral midfoot here and then I'm immediately on the airpods and then kind of get shot forward and push off I did find that the ride of elfly 3 was a little less aggressive than elfly one because the three encapsulates the airpods whereas one they weren't encapsulated so you really could hit them hard and get like a really big boost um so just a note for those who are fans of elfly 1 comparing the 4 foot of elfly 3 to C X1 this is a really rockered shoe too and it definitely has an aggressive ride what I would say the main difference is that this is a softer and more compliant shoe so for me I land basically where this cutout is and first of all I was really worried about what that was going to feel like I actually like Landing there it makes the shoe feel softer at initial contact but not like too soft it's not marshmallowy soft it didn't feel unstable it reminded me a lot of the New Balance SC Elite version 3 in terms of the amount of softness at initial contact there but once you land you get that initial bit of softness but then again you're right at the 4 foot rocker so just pushes you forward so it's a really nice balance between some cushioning when you land but then that really aggressive rocker feel to push you into push off um as far as pacing for these shoes so I disagree with a lot of people as far as what alphafly 3 is best for I don't like it as a marathon shoe even though that's what Nike kind of says it's for I've said 5K through half marathon PRS in Ally one and that's how I feel that elfly 3 would be for me too it just feels better at faster Paces for me and I think that's because again I'm a lateral midfoot Striker if I load these airpods right I get such an aggressive push into push off that the shoe just works better for me the faster I run it actually feels a little sluggish at marathon pace CU it feels like I don't load the airpods enough I find the opposite with SEO X1 this shoe feels really great at 10K to marathon pace I did a 20 mile on the treadmill in this shoe and my feet felt awesome when I was done and you really can't say a lot for 20 MERS on treadmills except you only do them when you have to when you're training for a winter Marathon um so this shoe because it's a little softer it I I actually would say it's it performs pretty well at fast Paces like I did some mile Pace intervals in it but the main thing holding it back from being a faster race shoe is really its weight at for the men 7 o or I'm sorry 9. 3 o for a men size 10 7.