hi there what you're about to see is a talk between me and Matthew Miller the current Fedora project leader regarding Fedora flat packs the OBS Fedora situation and just generally how flat packs fit into what Fedora is doing now normally a talk like this would be available over on my podcast channel that being Tech over te but considering this is a much shorter talk and it's a lot more focused more focused not super focused it made more sense to upload here more people are going to see it but if You' like to see more talks
like this the podcast is where you go that is Tech overt on YouTube it's available on Spotify and various other platforms as well if you search Tech overt you will find it so without further Ado here's the video I don't know what this video is um I I I'm probably going to put this on the main Channel I I I'm not too sure um but today we have Matthew Miller here uh he reached out to me actually before before we get into that um you are technically still the Fedora project leader yes I am I
am we we haven't gotten a replacement yet and once we do I want to have a little bit of overlap the uh Fedor Linux 42 release is g to be I think the Handover moment because you know that's an auspicious nerd number and also my first Fedor release as project leader was 21 so doubling it seemed like a pretty good end point right um I I don't know if you guys have said anything about who's going to take that role or if there is anyone lined up for that role or not we are in progress
okay okay so it's there there's definitely contenders there but you can't really say anything yet yeah I'm afraid not okay no that's to Fair um it's some good competition I'll say that oh yeah no I I could definitely expect that Fedora has a lot of very competent people involved in the project there is no shortage of people who uh would be able to fill a role like that maybe you know maybe not as good as you've been doing over over these years um thank you but there's definitely no shortage of if you need someone immediately
there's someone there yeah it it's a pretty robust project I guess so okay you reached out to me to talk about the fedora flat pack and OBS situation and I thought we could chat about it a little bit yeah yeah um I have I have strong opinions about it um you have the Fedora perspective there someone from the um Joel who who filed the legal claim against OBS he commented on my video um from at least from the OBS side he agreed with a lot of the things that I brought up but you said that
there are things that maybe I got wrong that you wanted to correct and yeah but before we get into like any of the stuff that we disagree on um let's just foundational stuff what is Fedora flat pack and why does Fedora flat pack exist um yeah so Fedor flat pack is our flat packs that we have con we construct in our build system out of RPM packages so Fedor uh at its core we are a packaging project we in take things and we integrate them all together into Fedor Linux and um traditionally we've done that
through RPMs and in some ways this is an experiment in distributing things in a different way we also do some things where we provide you know Docker containers for like postgress and things like that Fedora uh so this was kind of in in that vein um when we started doing this uh flathub was very young and it wasn't quite clear that that was going whether it was going to be a there's one registry for everything kind of situation or whether there'd be lots of Registries everywhere and uh we were also um asked by Red Hat
legal to not have flat be um an easy basically an easy to install option um and we we worked on that for a while and so things have changed so now at first we had a version of flat Hub that was called was a filtered view which I think was very confusing because basically it was a f Hub where you couldn't see everything and you had no idea why not right so now we have just kind of if you opt into third party repositories you just get it all there what was the criteria F fi
to Flat Hub um just before we go on from further from that sorry what's that what was the criteria for the filtered flathub so what was being filtered out um I I'm not completely sure but I think it's a matter of legal risk that um whatever those were and I'm going to Le that vague because that's the whole point of that I guess but I do agree it was confusing yes yeah but um so uh why do we have these I think I kind of have to go back to the dawn of time to really
explain this and there's there's actually even before we're talking about the flat pack um packaging format there's a tension that we've had between some developers you upstream and drro and there like I've seen this in Debian too it's not like a fedora specific thing and generally we work very well with our upstreams that's one of our like basic principles of how we do things the Upstream first it's not it's not officially one of our modos but it's it's there um but uh back in the dawn of time when we started drro so I've been doing
Linux for like I don't know 30 years now almost and Dro working on dros specifically since uh 1999 I think so uh things were very different back then um it was really hard to get a working system together with Linux and basically you know there's a lot of Open Source software out there not as much as there is now but a lot of it but most of it was distributed on like an FTP site and a tarball as source code somewhere you didn't really get like here's a nice polish build and so and it was
all scattered around all sorts of different things so distributions are basically an integration project to take all that and make it be nice and Polished uh and uh especially back then like it wasn't always easy like often now um if you if you know what you're doing it is fairly simple to build most things um you if it's C you know you you un untar it and then you do configure and then make and there it goes make install maybe uh it didn't used to be that consistent a lot of diff you different different developers
different people would have completely different practices and everything would would work a different way it was hard to figure out how to build things and then they would have different opinions about you know how to organize stuff like uh there was a guy who there's a software called qmail which was a um you know mail processing email processing server uh that guy wanted to put everything under VAR which is supposed to be for like your variable data on your system and not supposed to be where your actual lives um it was all and so people
had all these different opinions about where things should go and how it should be and so a drro one of the other things about dist we basically have rules about okay that we're going to make it all work together nicely so that as a assist admin or a user you can basically assume even if you haven't worked with this package before it's going to fit basic standards of the distribution um so um in doing that you know kind of like Debian and you all the other uh Proto distributions um the a lot of the the
people we attracted to the project you know the work is we're going to take the software out there that's hard for users to get and hard for users to um access and make it nice and present it to them as you know um a polished sort of way and there were all there's always been developers who care about you know care about users and care about you know that path and there um even still today there are ones that don't they're just like I'm dumping my code out here good luck and that that's cool um
and you know as a user it's hard to always know what is what um but I do think that's been a really big change in the last like I said 20 years where there's a lot more software where it's you know the Upstream is very polished organized it has um you know releases something like OBS they've got to have that uh and so in those cases yeah all the things that people are frustrated with um it isn't just the flatback but the one you know when distro makes a package and makes different decisions than the
developer that can cause all sorts of difficulty and we may providing that value that um that we try to there so U that's a long way of saying I think we um something like OBS we're not really providing anything by packaging that um I think there is an overall place for the Fedora the excuse me flat packs uh because flathub um part of the reason it's so popular there's a you double-edged sword kind of thing it's so popular because the rules are fairly LAX about what can go into flat hub and the idea is you
you throw you know but we want to make it easy for developers to get their things to users which which is cool but um there's not really much of a review the thing that says verified just is verifying that it's from the developers themselves and it doesn't necessarily verify that you know it was built with good practices maybe it was built you know in a coffee shop on some laptop or whatever um which you know could be infected with malware or whatever could happen where it this um the Fedora system you we build it in
our pipes you know basically our our whole build system is set up to be a secure Pipeline and so uh you can have you know more trust as a user that this packet software is going to be what it says it is and that it's going to behave in a way that is um you know friendly towards the user and I give an example of something that I installed for flathub I was trying to get some get one get a nice gooey thing that would show me like my system Hardware stats thing because I think
this was when uh lanus Tech tips was playing with Linux and they were complaining that there was no such thing and I was like there's got to be so I was looking of them I I yeah but um I one of them once I picked seemed to do nothing and it turns out that what it actually was doing was there was no graphical application it was just a script it was running that script in the background and that script and uploaded my system stats to a server somewhere like oh yep okay yeah right like and
um that you know that's Pro I think that's spef specifically been fixed but no one's checking for things like that and there's not necessarily even agreement that that was bad so um I I'm not trying to be down on flathub because I think flathub is a great and a um really really good resource but that is a distinction between the way we do things in Fedor and in a lot of ways flathub is a kind of a competing distribution to fedora's packaging of all these applications and so um I guess I also need to talk
about Fedora and opinions right because are a lot of different people and I am technically the voice of Fedora but um it can never really be a completely unified voice because we really there's a lot of things we just don't consistently agree on and so you know whether like there people who work on sorry I want to be careful um some of the people who work on just the core like the core gome distribution or KDE or those kind of things think look this is the important part we're putting together this core operating system and
the applications that that's out there in the different you know rings and someone else should worry about that Fedora should focus on this little part but like I said a lot of people have come to Fedora really from here's an application that I like and I use I want to make sure that's packaged up and you know they've done a diligent job for the last decade or whatever of making sure that that package is in good shape and I don't think we want to kick those people out of the project especially because in a lot
of cases there isn't really a diligent Upstream I don't know what happened there um you were saying uh you don't want to cut out your packages yeah people have been working at this for a long time and you basically doing just user support for people and those kind of things um that's an important part of the project too and and people doing that have done a lot of good work so even even when it's not like a problem with the Upstream we often find things where the license that they say it's distributed under isn't actually
like there's some parts of it that aren't really open source and we've in the worked with people to you know fix those things and make you find open source parts to it or get just get the licensing statement right if that's all it is um and so you can be sure that everything in Fedora really is reviewed at you know open source at least to the best of our knowledge of course there's a lot of code and surely some you know things things slip through but that's the intention and I don't want to I don't
want to say that's you know people in the project shouldn't be doing that anymore uh but again I think there's also a case-by case basis when it's something you know like Libra office or whatever um the developer packaging probably is the best um but we're still we have still some unanswered questions like that so one of the things is you know when we ship a fedora an addition a product product basically I put product in quotes because we don't sell anything and my employer red hat would like to me not be confused about what products
are um but uh when we when we ship something like that to users uh all the code we have there is something that we've built from source and know we can build from Source again which wouldn't be the case if we would you know um say we wanted to have something for home assistant for example home assistant software um it's not packaged in Fedora there you dock it's not flat pack but there's Docker containers for it which is a great way to run it but um if we were to ship some sort of like Fedora
iot with you know home batteries installed home assistant like that we would probably want that to be our own build rather than the Upstream build unless you know we've never done anything different than that maybe we could do something where we're collaborating um but so far that's not been a thing it's just if we're building it you know we ship it and I think that as we are going to more and more of the immutable OS where flat packs are more important because we have we do have the separate um Atomic desktop kind of thing
and then flat packs are are the way to get applications on there um we're going to need to figure that out and so for now you know I I think Fedora versions of them are there uh I think one of the problems is that and I I don't know how to solve this that you know you don't know what you installed as a user sure and we don't shout at somebody hey you've picked the wrong version or put a list of if you want to have these properties pick this version if you want like that's
confusing um but I think people should know where they you know where where it's best to go to help and you whose fault this is right if people sorry I was gonna say this is a problem that auntu has sort of put itself into where um people installing with apt in certain cases will install the snap it's just a redirect over to the snap so it's in some cases like with Firefox like that's intended with Upstream like Upstream wanted that um but I believe they do the same thing with steam as well and this puts
this this creates a really weird issue where auntu users installed it with apt thought they were getting the Debian package then got the snap so they might send the bug report to uh steam where they don't have anything to do with that where it's actually a bug with the snap system this is sort of the same issue that arises here where if somebody installs the OBS flat pack or what whatever application ends up being and they thought they were getting the flat pack from flathub but they ended up actually getting the Fedora flat pack it
creates this confusion of it's still the same software but the issue at hand might not be because of the package they thought they got it was actually or because of the software they got it's because of the packaging they got yeah exactly um and I yeah I don't know how I'm not a designer I don't know what a great solution is for that um I think that there probably could be something that's better um I would like for Fedora package things like going to ask Fedora is probably the first thing and honestly if you if
you're not sure which package you're using or whatever if you're using an on Fedora bring it there and people will help you figure out where to take it if you're having problems with anything but I obviously people are also going to go right to the upstreams again especially and I think ironically like the more helpful the Upstream tries to be the more people are going to be like oh that's the obvious place to be and then it gets a little bit confusing right um one of the other things I wanted to talk about about with
flatpack in general is the security and like the sandboxing around it so um although this is nothing to do with OBS because I don't have think I'm not causing them of anything malicious but um like I said the stuff in the flat pack in flathub is not really reviewed um for in detail and can do a lot of things and uh flat pack uh basically the developer defines what their permissions are so there's a Sandbox but the sandbox is basically what the you know what the person who put it there is and one can imagine
that if you are going to put mware there you might make your sandboxing pretty loose well one of the things you can do is just say I want full file system access and then you can just do anything right yes and this is also this is a problem versus um Android Apple have pretty they have strong leverage against application developers to use you know make it work in their sandbox they the other way around where the they request permissions and then the user grants them whereas flat pack it's they get the permission and then you
could reject them later yeah but again going back to the dawn of time it didn't used to be that way and and in fact um Android had much weaker sandboxing like you could know read the whole file system from one app and things like that um which you know turns out to be bad and so they slowly tightened it and then app developers had to adjust so I think um with the Linux ecosystem we don't really have the way to tighten that kind of thing on app developers and so the answer to make this work
so flat pack actually has that kind of ask as you go along functionality but in order to do that your your program has to use portals which Katie Ean gdome both agree on this but uh if you're not then can't have that feature at all so um and there's not really a strong incentive for developers to do that because you know well first of all of course my software is not going to be bad so why should I you know work on Sandbox in it um excuse me but it's just yeah kind of extra work
and I I don't know I don't know how to solve that I would like to get to the utopian world where we have that same security for applications and you can it it would be nice to be able to install things from completely untrusted places and know that they can't do anything to harm your system and that's not the case with it right now um and yeah so um I think think that the Fedora flat packs in general have a a better supply chain security story when it comes right down to it that's one of
the things that people were arguing about in the OBS situation where one of the libraries that OBS uses to guey library is was out of dat in their version of it and there's you know some known security vulnerabilities and so on um we try to keep all of those things up to date and make sure everything is patched across the dist even when it's even when it's difficult um I think that really is one of the best ways to keep your system secure and because the sandboxing isn't very strong that can really be a problem
um one can you know like the XZ thing that happened before uh if XZ is just one place it's not that hard of an update but if you've got a 100 flat packs from different places like how many of them have which and in this case that mware wasn't was only targeted against one particular thing but it could have been something else and if you've got a 100 different sources and no consistency to it it's pretty hard to manage that sure in that regard you said um with the out ofd dependencies I would say is
there any reason why that needs to be done in a downstream like Fedora rather than working with Upstream to improve their packaging yeah and in in general um like I said you Upstream first is one of the mots and people do try to work with upstream and that's something packagers should do um sometimes it's complicated uh and um sometimes you know Upstream has uh a different just a different approach and different priorities there as well um a lot of times developers don't really care about that the way you know um I think that a lot
of people in Fedor come from a sadman world in in and kind of that operations kind of mindset about making sure that it is you know production ready even if it's not for the Enterprise it's you want something that's solid for end users as well and um I think this is uh people in Ops may have may have unfair stereotypes of developers but um the developer stereotype is you know they grab whatever you grab whatever things are out there it works okay now don't touch it um which um is not sustainable for security and I
think I think most developers know that too but uh part of the idea of having a distro was to keep all those things consistent so that it's easy for easier for everyone including the developers so yeah um that these kind of things things end up being intention with everything else and I don't have a solution to everything but that's part of why things are the way they are I guess so basically it's it kind of like took us 20 minutes to get to an explanation to what foor fly got a little bit roundabout here um
background uh the tldd Fedora flat pack is basically it is built off of the Fedora RPM build system and because that is more well tested and sort of intended even if not entirely for the Enterprise designed in a way as if an Enterprise user was going to use it the idea is this is more well tested and more secure in a lot of cases not every case yeah I think I may have put Enterprise in there too strongly um sure but yeah I mean this isn't like a um you know red hat made us do
it for well kind of thing this is a it's the right thing to do to make a secure distribution for users but yeah that's that's basically it um I I would like to be a world where um if people weren't interested in making the flat packs themselves as developers like we could we could um have Fedora flat packs being pushed to flathub as a service Fedora being a place to package things together um that that never came to be so I and it probably won't just because it's a lot of work and flat hope seems
to be going on just fine as it is but yeah H what I was going to say is um most historically it makes sense why there is this split between flathub and Fedora flat packs with the way it is now where it's clear that flathub is just that's it's not going to change it is the place where people get flat packs um is there any reason why again the Fedora flat pack needs to exist rather than just you know collaborating with flathub and sort of merging this all into one cuz I I can see there
being value in especially for those unofficial packages um where Fedora hopes those flat packs be a better flat pack than they would be just by some random you know random developer making it I I do see there possibly being some value in exploring that route yeah I think some of it is the um we've got a tool you know the hammer of of we put this through RPM and that is the that is the way all of our processes work and so people are inclined to look at it that way but yeah um I think
people um you know going and working with the upstreams is also helpful um some ways it's kind of hard to uh hard to keep that feeling like it's all under a fedora project Banner uh and like just rather than the individual people going off and working on an upstream so maybe that's something we could work on and know building a group of people that are interested in that kind of thing to work that way um it would definitely be a worthwhile thing to try I think flat help integration Sig yeah something like that I don't
know if that would solve all the problems but uh yeah I I think people are really proud of a lot of the work that they've done to you know make Upstream just us Upstream software better that's part of what we do in Fedora we you know um there's a Temptation when you're when you're working with open source to just be like okay well I've got got that I've made some improvements sure I'll publish the source code but you know I don't need to do the work of going back to the developers and it turns out
that in the long run that's a really hard way to do it because now you're owning the maintainership of this different thing and if you can get that back to the Upstream like it's just it's better it's easier for you and it's not sustainable will to do it at scale in any other way and it you know helps benefit everybody that way even if you're not using if even if you're not a fedora user uh you get better open source software so yeah I think that's been part of fedora's mission all along um and I
think we need to maybe figure out how we can adapt that for this world I think an area where Fedor flatback really does fail is explaining the value of it to people who don't already just happen to have it like why with it existing with a overlaying existing packages right if someone's looking at trying to download a flat pack they see it's on flathub they might and they know about fo a flat pack and they see the package in this in these two locations I don't think it does a good job at explaining why that
is the case and you're doing a good job here it's just getting that message out to people who might benefit from using those packages yeah I think part of it is um don't want to like bad talk things or sound scary and it's kind of hard to present this in a way that isn't I don't don't want it to be like watch out don't install from Flat Hub it might not be secure um and you also don't like there's already enough information people are in dated with if you look at um you know the gome
software screen there's a lot of information there actually and um there's not I I don't know maybe again I'm not a designer maybe there's something that could be done to better present things yeah yeah I I I have some issues with the way that you know software presents and and flathub presents things like um the safety of an application you know where it will say this is potentially dangerous or sorry what is it potentially unsafe is that the phrase it uses I don't want to get that wrong um potentially unsafe uh where it has like
a list of down down from what it was before yeah uh and I I think that um some of the safety might be overstated on the things that aren't you know aren't sandboxed or all those kind of things um I think it's a I think those those like safety labels are a good idea in general but yeah there's arguments about what is safe and what it means and all that right I think another thing that is I don't know um gome software as an application is not not something that is like very well resourced because
the companies that are putting together like um you know Enterprise distributions or corporate distributions like their customers are not installing stuff randomly from that they they have some sort of centralized mechanism and um whether it's satellite or anible or whatever to control installing your application so that doesn't really come into it so there's not a lot of like interest in funding that from from companies um and there just isn't like there's no market for a Linux desktop operating system that's going to bring anybody bring in any money um good job analysts for trying as much
as heroically as they could um but and then uh with canonical going off in a different direction for their snaps thing um you know uh it's all volunteer effort so the people working on that even even people who are you know paid by red hat or some other company um they're doing that out of love not out of their day job right A lot of them are pay to do a job and then do this on the side as well yeah absolutely okay so unless you got I think I've covered everything I wanted to say
here H yeah no I do have some I do have some stuff I definitely want to talk about um yeah sure so when it comes to how Fedora hand packaging Upstream this is getting to the OBS stuff handles packaging upstreams that don't want to be packaged in whether it's foror flat packs whether it's in fedora's regular RPM system the with with this situation it really did explode just it people were not paying attention it kind of seemed like exploded just out of nowhere yes it certainly felt like that to me um I I knew that
the workstation group was was discussing some of these things but I didn't um there's fos them a bunch of stuff going on you know um it had hadn't uh really gotten to my attention several people did send it to me so thank you several people um but yeah and this is also a problem Fedora as an old project um we've gotten kind of scattered and sometimes it's just not easy to see you know where the missing Treads are as you're walking up the stairs uh and I think that you know um the flat pack Sig
GPO that that got filed against something that no one was really monitoring closely especially not for something so as important as that and we also didn't have any particular signpost saying hey this is not a great place to put this so I I understand why the reporter felt like they were being ignored um even though there was there was ongoing conversation in a different ticket and a whole different you know different git Forge um yeah uh I I do think um you know this all better communication all around would have helped often the case in
easy to say in retrospect right right yeah like it's easy to say well I think there's as you said this is an old project so there's a lot of this disconnected infrastructure if you were to design everything from the ground up I'm sure you could think of ways where okay you could ver like like the way that um GitHub and gitlab work we can like link to a slug and it will send you directly over to that that uh that issue or that PO request if you would to designed the Fedora infrastructure from the ground
up I'm sure you would think of a way where okay if I link to this it automatically sends you over here so you can like easily keep those conversations connected together yeah and hopefully actually so Fedora is moving to forio as our get Forge and hopefully we'll have some opportunities to uh do that I'm hoping we can bring some of the people who scattered out to different parts of the world back into our centralized um get Forge and actually I think you know I I'll probably be out of the um out of the rule out
out of the role of making the policies at this point but um I would like to ask all the different Fedora teams to even if that's not going to be their Central spot like have a page that's up Tod date that says where to go like for this team you know coros most of the stuff is on the GitHub under this thing here go there and I hope that that can be kind of a central place where you can it would be obvious to try and look there and yeah we can hopefully do some of
those you know little automated things that tie things together that would be nice so the the the main the main point I'm I'm sort of wanting to talk about here is how should Fedora handle upstreams that don't want to be packaged like like the OBS case here where they did not want there to be a package in Fedora flat pack or another example is obviously bottles which has made a lot of noise about the packaging in uh the Fedora RPM as well yeah um I think we probably shouldn't do it we should um let it
we should respect people's wishes there um at least when it is a u open source project working in good faith there maybe some other cases where um the software um say theoretically there's somebody who has commercial interests in some thing and they uh only want to release it from their thing even though it's open source we might want to actually like well it's open source um we can provide things we in that case we might end up you having a different name or something um but yeah I can imagine situations where it makes sense to
have it packaged in Fedora still uh but in general especially and when it's a you know friendly successful open source project we should be friendly yeah the name thing is something people forget history like that's happened before with Mozilla with um Firefox and Debbie and where um Mozilla back then was like really picky about people make modifications to the package so they basically said you got to like change the name so that's how we got like ice cat and the rest of their sweet name like that and they were having a real problem at the
time of people taking Firefox and basically putting you know mware into it adwar spyware and then you know this fire box so I understand why they strict about that but it was kind of frustrating um you know we in Fedora have basically the same rules if you want to take Fedor Linux and uh do something out of what make your own thing out of it put your own software on whatever you can do that but we ask you not to call it f which is a fedora remix brand you can use in some cases otherwise
pick your own name it's all open source but you know the name is ours yeah and I that for the Upstream as well it make totally makes sense yeah no the name the name is completely understandable especially if you do have a trademark to already even if you don't like it's it's common courtesy to not name the thing the exact same thing yeah I mean and depending on the legalities like you don't necessarily have to register a trademark to have the trademark kind of protections under things so hopefully lawyers you can stay out of the
whole thing because that always makes the situations a lot more complicated and we can just get along talking like human beings who care about making good software and getting it to users so how do you think things should be handled in the future obviously this is going to be a bit hard to say without things happening but how do you think things should be handled in the future to ensure that it doesn't get to this state cuz obviously the legal threats like that's you know big deal there like that's that's we are going to make
this happen no matter what yeah um I mean it's hard to always predict I the next thing will be something else we can always say like we the repos or whatever um I do think that having a more Central system will help and make it easier to figure out where to go for these kind of things um and I think also we're working maybe working on some policies about you know how to work with upstreams just to make sure that we're consistent I think most people in the project are but want to make sure that
we kind of put out that U if the Upstream doesn't want it packaged like talk to them and see if there's something that can be arranged and the end State might actually be it still ends up packaged but in a different way or some other thing or uh like you said maybe the the whatever problem that was making somebody want separate Fedora package maybe that can get fixed upst stream getting better for everybody I think there's a lot less disagreement here than uh maybe you initially thought like there's that video obviously I got kind of
heed cuz I I am very much in favor of doing as much Upstream as possible and I I do I think people kind of mistake my stance here I do think there's value in Downstream packaging but I think we're we're in this situation where things are changing where the downstream Dro is I guess it's becoming less important it's more of the the core packages like your your glibc's things like that like that's that's where the dro really still shines but a lot of the user facing software a lot of that is moving into other packaging
Solutions like flat packs where essentially flat pack or flathub is a universal Dro that you use on top of your sorry on top of your dis so it doesn't really matter what you're running at your core you're still going to get that same version of the software yeah um I do feel like I mean as a Linux distro person and a fedora representative I think it does matter what you've got running at the core there and we really I mean we put in a lot of work to make it look like it doesn't matter and
everything just works smoothly it you know it didn't used to be that way and that's through a lot of people's hard effort um and I do think people have you know put in that effort into the stuff that wasn't just done that core as well like I said um there are definitely different opinions across the project on this um so I don't know what this maybe for the next project leader some something to figure out what how to bring some Unity there but I do agree that you know things have changed in the world and
that you know the um there's more of a product product mindset in open source in general and you know people doing release engineering and people caring about supply chain security I talked about that a lot in Fedora but you know we don't have a monopoly on that and we're not perfect uh Upstream projects can can and do have really solid supply chain Security in many cases so um actually I also shouldn't say supply chain security that's you know that's the word but um it's the wrong metaphor that but that's a whole different talk um one
last thing I wanted to get to is as always um fonics will take a singular comment and then based an entire article around it there's there was one talk by uh one comment on that thread uh about reordering the um the the the flat pack repos and like uh I think it was by Michael katenzaro who said at some point in the future he wanted to move gnome software to be focused only on flat packs and remove the the RPM component from that and it's just like a one offhand comment but do you have any
any thoughts on on on that happening at some point um I I think that I can definitely say we don't have a unified voice in that's right and a lot of people you know really um like the approach we have now um I personally taking off my phedo project leader hat I think that that is probably the best way to go for the future um even if that does mean you know we're packaging some things up ourselves and maybe we are packaging them up and you know work doing that in flathub or something like that
um because I think that having you know Atomic OS is is the future and FL pack is the best um you know application story on top of that for desktop applications and I do hope um you know developers start using portals and things so we can have it all work nicely and securely but that's kind of a far-off future right now we have a lot of things there and there's um there are still things that don't work as well when they're in the flat pack because of the sandbox model like uh Chrome which has its
own sandboxing um doesn't doesn't work very well Ste has similar issues in that regard as well yeah exactly um yeah so uh I I don't know what the future is but I like that idea of having it um separated like that but again putting my photor project leader hat back on definitely not Universal agreement on that and I would I think that probably um Michael's view on mine is a minority view in a lot of the um Fedora project as a as a whole but I don't know I'm could be surprised I think that is
a kind of important point to hammer home Fedora is a big project and whilst you know things can look as if this is The Stance of the Fedora project often times you're going to have people who are you know relatively big names in the project we've been around for a long time who have fundamental disagreements about some of the directions things are going obviously they agree more often than they don't otherwise they wouldn't be in the project but but not everything is a consensus yeah that definitely true I think um one of the things about
a community really is that you have that shared interest in working on something that is strong enough that you can disagree about things and even disagree with decisions that have been made and are going away that like you wouldn't have wanted to go that way but it is but uh the whole is still important enough to you and you see the value that you know you stay there without that it's not really a community just a you collection of people okay I think we pretty much hit on like most of the stuff that is important
to touch um is there anything else you want to get into before we sign off I think those are the main things just uh the you know there's a there's a long history here and the world's changed um people people all mean well really and communication is hard um and I don't know we don't know what the future will bring I guess those are the things thank you for yeah no absolute pleasure yeah um if you want to come back on when you're in what was what's the new role you're moving to because obviously it's
like I'm going to I'm going to be a manager so we but um I hope to be doing some good good things there with you know the way Red Hat works with communities and um you know making making the future brighter still um yeah for anyone who who forgot about the um the separation this is a totally like fine separation this isn't like I'm leaving the project I hate Fedora now like it's moving on to different things in your life yeah and there definitely some parts that I'll be like well I don't need to do
that anymore that's somebody else's worry and that will be nice for my sleep w i i guess it would be nice not being the uh the face of Fedora uh for once in how many years has it been it's been um almost 11 years right so yeah a bit a time to get a chance I think so um if people want to like get involved in Fedora and all that stuff where can they go so I think the best place is to come to discussion. Fedor project.org um and look at look for the water cooler
section just which is kind of the off-topic fun area uh introduce yourself say hi uh then we do have like a a join Fedora special interest group that can kind of help guide you in but mostly um rather than coming and looking for like what's my first issue to get involved with like just um getting to know people getting involved in the community a little bit and then um you'll find things that are naturally the things you want to do I think that is um the the best way to get involved or if um discussion
forum isn't for you and you like Matrix instead U join you know one of the Matrix rooms foror space um say hi that way um uh we used to have uh virtual release parties during covid times that kind of Fallen apart since then um and that was also a good way to come and see what's going on I don't know we may end up doing some of those kind of things again but I would say the social aspect the first place to start and the technical can follow or non-technical because there's a lot of need
in the project for you know people designers like documentation yeah yeah you know people doing podcasts that kind of thing it's important so uh anything else uh you want to direct people to or is that pretty much everything I think we got it um I don't know how to sign this off because this yeah yeah this is like yeah it's it's not a it's technically the podcast format but like there's a lot shorter form and like very focused on a topic so I think this is going to go on the main Channel I I I
I think that's what we're going to do maybe I'll I'll make it an ad for the podcast go on the main Channel go watch the podcast you can see you can see the last time uh Matt was on here sounds good so um yeah I guess that's how end it oh