okay well I as you say I was born in uh a fairly typical Jewish family we were we attended U reform synagogue and from the time I was probably five years old till 14 years old I attended both Sunday and Saturday school and of course I grew up in Trenton New Jersey which is between Philadelphia and New York so there was a large Jewish population and there was a lot of a lot of information from New York and Philadelphia uh about Jewish activities and I always recognized from the time I was very young I always
noticed that Jewish people didn't use slur words to condemn other people like black people Puerto Ricans uh or other people whereas a lot of the the Christian kids some of whom were my friends commonly use slurs and that gave me a sense that maybe Jews are a little more or a little better than other people also I was born in 1948 so I grew up you know within a decade to 15 years after the Holocaust and every Jewish just about every Jewish Family I knew had family members who had been killed in the Holocaust and
of course in the 1950s anti-Semitism was fairly common in the United States like for example Jews were not allowed to join non-jewish country clubs Jews were not welcome in a lot of places and that's in the Northeast just imagine what it was like in the South uh and the Midwest of the United States so I grew up uh oh and another very important factor for me was when I was in elementary school in public school uh and and let let me point out that school prayer was not considered uh illegal until 1960 and I graduated
from from sixth grade in 1960 so up through sixth grade we had to say the Lord's Prayer most people consider Christian prayer even though it comes from the uh I believe from Psalms in the Tanakh the Old Testament but what I really didn't like was my classes would have celebrations of Easter and Christmas and which of course would not be allowed now but they never had celebrations of Passover or uh any of the other Jewish holidays Hanukah for example which is not really a major Jewish holiday but it coincided with Christians Christmas and so all
that made me kind of maybe get the feeling that my Society didn't really respect Jews very much and so I grew up being very defensive about Jewish people and about later on about Israel and uh after the 1967 six- Day War when Israel defeated Egypt Syria and uh Jordan and took over the West Bank and Golan Heights um I was very proud of what Israel had accomplished but I always knew in fact I didn't just know it I I felt it that there would never be peace in the Middle East between Israel and its neighbors
and I didn't know why but I used to hear that when I would be at synagogue as a kid I used to hear the men talking about that a lot and they would often say well uh the good news is that the Arabs never agree on anything and so the the Arabs are never United then of course gaml Abdul Nasser came along I think 1956 the leader of Egypt and the the charismatic pan pan uh uh pan Arab leader and he became a threat now David benorian who was the Prime Minister of India sorry of
Israel and Israel's first prime minister and the leader of the Jewish Agency for many years before Israel's establishment in 1948 David vorian referred to Nasser as the Hitler of the Middle East and when you when you're a young kid and and you have relatives who who had relatives who were killed in the Holocaust and you have uh relatives or friends of my parents who fought in World War II when you hear that uh Nassar is the Hitler of the Middle East just imagine what kind of images that conjures up in a young person's mind oh
my God the Arabs want to do to the Jews what the Nazis almost did to the Jews and partially did to the Jews so all of that reinforced my attachment to my Jewish identity and then years go by and um I was always defensive when people would con would say something negative about Israel I would get upset and I would deny that what they were saying was true I would say it was Arab or Palestinian propaganda and I had no basis for any of that really then in probably the mid90s my identical twin brother who's
a Orthodox Jew and very very very anti- Palestinian uh and I he Pro my guess is that he's a supporter of itamar Ben gavier and bezel smotrich the two ultra Orthodox um ministers in the Netanyahu cabinet uh my twin brother gave me a book that I didn't had never heard of but it was a bestseller called from time from Time immemorial by Joan Peters and that book allegedly prove that Israel has always been in the right it it basically said there is no such thing as a pal pal inian people Arabs from various parts of
the Middle East moved to Palestine to Israel uh in order to get higher paying jobs from kind Jewish landh holders and uh they're never and you know I can't remember anything it said but it turned out it was all garbage and it was completely debunked first of all by Norman finlin in the United States but it was also debunked completely by Zionist Jewish uh historians in the state of Israel they refer to it as is trash utter propaganda worthless but I believed it all because it was my bi it became my Bible I believed it
because it gave me an argument to refute anything that anyone said that was critical of Israel so in 2006 as some people may remember Hezbollah uh conducted a crossborder raid into Israel and killed three Israeli soldiers and abducted two this was in July 2006 I was very upset about that because 3 weeks earlier Hamas had captured Israeli soldier gilad Shalit on the Israel Gaza border and I saw those two events as proof of a Arab world conspiracy to destroy the Jewish state it became clear to me that the Arab world would not rest until they
threw the Jews into the sea I was convinced about that and the day after his father's raid Israel invaded Lebanon with immense force and I was very upset but I reported The Invasion I thought it was necessary so a couple days go by and um I decided I was going to speak with two of my wisest friends both of whom were not Jewish and both of whom had been somewhat critical of Israel in the past but this time I thought they would realize the the the uh severity of the situation and they would realize that
Israel really was only defending itself against anti-semites so I went to each of them individually and I talked to them and both of them blamed Israel for its disproportionate use of force against the people of Lebanon and neither of them accepted my argument and I was devastated and so I went home and I thought about it and I went over each conversation trying to see did I miss something did I misunderstand something and my conclusion was no I didn't miss anything no I didn't misunderstand anything and only Jews can understand the suffering of our people
maybe my dear friends two of the most compassionate people I've ever met maybe they're anti-semites like all the other non-jews or most of the other non-jews so then a few days later during this Onslaught that Israel is conducting in Lebanon I received a phone call an un a rare phone call from a friend of mine in New Jersey who I grew up with and he rarely calls and I knew he had studied is the subject of Israel in Palestine for many years but he never made a big deal out about it at all he was
very quiet about it and he was fairly quiet by Nature anyway anyway he called to tell me that he was going to be coming out west where I was and I was living in New Mexico at the time and was going to visit me and I said that's great and then by the way the Arab world wants to kill all the Jews and I went into a two-hour di tribe against the Arab world and he let me go he be rarely interrupted me and he listened to me and it was really over two hours occasionally
he would interject a comment like no that's wrong uh you know you know no this is what's happening but he rarely said anything and he didn't argue with me he didn't criticize me at a certain point he said why don't you read books by these two Israeli professors Baro Kimberling and Tanya Reinhardt both of whom were very respected though I had never heard of them and I thought to myself you know what maybe I should read something maybe there's something I don't know the only book I read was Joan Peter's trash and yet I thought
like like most most of my Jewish friends today and most of Israel supporters today I thought I knew all there was to know but because he gave me the space to question myself after we hung up I went online to Amazon and looked up books by Kimberling and Reinhardt and when you do that you see other books on the same subjects and I decided I'll go to my uh library and see if I can find some of these books my stipulation was I only wrote down the names of books and the names of authors who
were Jewish I wasn't going to trust that a non-jewish author could be honest or not anti-semitic this is how um uh radical I was so I went to the library got a few books came home the next day I started reading and maybe about a week after reading fairly uninteresting material that didn't really uh address my concerns that much I started reading Norman finklestein's Beyond hutzpah on the misuse of anti-Semitism and the abuse of History I I had never heard of finlin my friend who had who had directed me to Kimberling and Reinhardt had years
earlier had said that Joan Peter's book was debunked by a Jewish Professor who lived in New York but he couldn't remember the name and he was referring to finlin and I just said oh well that I don't believe that the Jewish Professor must have been confused or maybe he's a self- aing Jew so I started reading finlin book and what happened was every knew immediately that he was a brilliant that he was a brilliant man and his everything he said his criticism was only directed towards Israel there was no criticism of the Palestinian people at
all or the Arab or the Arab side and I was wondering well when's he gonna speak out about the Arabs but I couldn't put the book down because number one I committed myself to really studying the history as objectively as I could and number two I recognized in the first paragraph of the book that he was a brilliant man somehow I recognized that so I kept reading plus he documented all of his claims very meticulously so his sources were organizations like Human Rights Watch Amnesty International bitum the Israeli human rights organization and so I was
reading and reading and reading and as I was reading I would go look online for the doc for the uh sources that he was citing in his book so I go to the to the uh papers that Amnesty International for example that they had written on the subject and I would look for the quotes he had taken from them I was hoping that I would find him taking the quotes out of context or changing a word here or there to misrepresent what the organization was saying unfortunately sort of at least from that prior point of
view he was everything he said was impeccable there was nothing that he everything he was beyond reproach so I continued reading and at a certain point I started be I was so absorbed in what I was reading that I allowed all the emotions that were going through me I didn't resist at all so I was going through shock at what I was reading oh my god I've supported Israel all these years this is what Israel is doing oh my God and then anger at Israel for misguiding me all my life and getting me to support
the the Mal treatment of Palestinians then my anger turned in on itself and I got angry at me for being such a dupe and being so ignorant and never checking anything out and then shame and embarrassment arose and then finally a great sorrow for the Palestinian people for all that they had been through well first of all I want to mention that I agree with Noom Chomsky that uh this propaganda stands on thin ground that's one of the reasons why people become so hysterical when they're confronted with the facts because they know they they actually
don't admit it most people I've met they don't admit that they've never studied the history but deep down they know they haven't studied the history so when you confront them with a revision and and and and a um alteration of what they believe that proves that what they believe was completely wrong they can actually become hysterical it is a threat to their mortal identity so so you mentioned the uh Barack peace proposal uh which which refers to the 2000 Camp David Summit uh at the end of uh Bill Clinton's presidency and yes that is one
of the most egregious uh propaganda uh beliefs that has been um that has infiltrated our society and the collective mind of Jewish culture because they believe that ahod Barack made a generous offer to the Palestinians and the Palestinians rejected it and they rejected it because they always reject peace because they rejected because they've rejected every other peace proposal prior to the year 2000 the Camp David Summit well first of all Israel has rejected or ignored every peace proposal since 1948 since its establishment every single one and the 2000 Camp David is an example so the
head of ahood barack's negotiating team was schlomo Ben Ami and schlomo Ben Ami at the end of the failed Summit said of the concessions offered by is uh the sessions offered by Israel fell far short of even modest Palestinian expectations a couple years after that he said if I were a Palestinian I would have rejected Camp David as well Ned Walker who was a former ambassador to Israel who was part of the Clinton negotiating team said of the ideas discussed the Camp David there is no way the Palestinians could have accepted this thing and um
uh G Halal who was the Egyptian American translator for the American team who had worked for numerous uh presidential administrations said ah the whole point of the summit was for ahood Barack and Yasser Arafat to get together and discuss making a peace agreement but ARA but but ahood Barack locked himself up in his room and refused to meet with Arafat except for one time but for Te only and on the condition that they discuss nothing of such subance and so this is the reality and then when you look further into it Dennis Ross who was
the head of the American negotiated team who was who the Israelis said was more pro-israeli than they were and who I read Bill Clinton had to uh shut him up shut him uh in his room and keep him away for a while because he was so pro-israeli Dennis Ross years later in his book I can't remember the name of the book he said that the Israeli offer was 91% of the West Bank with a 1% land swap but the Israelis did not present a map to the Palestinians but then when you dig deeper into that
91% the 91 Dennis Ross did not subtract out from the 91% the buffer zones that could be 5,000 meters in in width uh Parks um all kinds of Jewish only roads and according to Ron pundak who was the head of the Shimon Paris uh Center who died a number of years ago who was part of the O Israel Oslo team he said that that the that the Barack offer basically uh came down to about an offer of 60% of the West Bank for peace which at that time the Palestinians just could not have accepted and
it did not include a a capital in Jerusalem which would have enraged the entire Arab world so it was impossible for the uh for the Palestinians to accept such a such a worthless proposal I believe Barack was there mainly to con arat into signing an end of conflict agreement and that would absolve Israel of its responsibilities under international law so that's one example do you want me to give you any another historical example of this propaganda yeah maybe like like like one more if you like um okay one more one that is very common also
is the 1947 un partition plan I often hear the Jewish side say well the Jews accepted partition and the and the Palestines rejected it so there what they're saying is the Jews accepted partition therefore it's the Palestinians fought there's never been peace and it's the Palestinians fault they are under occupation what they don't say is that the partition Plan gave 56% of historic Palestine along with 80% of the coast and the most fertile land to the je side 43% to the Palestinian side with Jerusalem and Bethlehem the remaining 1% under the United Nations Administration and
they don't say that within a week Israel violated Partition by moving institutions and the rabet the chief rabet into Jerusalem they don't say that manim bean the head of the eron and future Prime Minister was praying that the Arab side that the Palestinians would reject partition because knew that if they accepted partition it would be much harder for Israel to make the the to make the cause to to to justify its expansion into the whole of Palestine because for at least 10 years before partition it was clear to everybody to the US state department to
the Arab world to all the Jews in Israel that Ben Goran David benorian and the Jewish leadership had no intention whatsoever of honoring partition as K whitesman said one of the most famous of the Jewish leaders the first president of Israel as K Whitman said we would be fools not to accept a state the size of a tablecloth because once we get a piece of land that is legally ours at least according to the United Nations that will serve as a as the stepping stone to to expand into the whole of Palestine which benorian repeatedly
said he promised his political party that the uh that that the partition plan was not uh that was not the end of the issue and also a Jewish State under partition would have had depending on who you read between a 40 and 49% Arab or Palestinian minority and with the higher birth rate eventually within a few years the Arab minority would have become a majority so it's ridiculous to believe uh that Israel would have accepted such a thing and so these people now today who are just who are blaming the Palestinians for not accepting the
the theft of their land just some institution taking away their land because they were badgered and and and blackmailed and um treated badly by the Jewish side to think that the Palestinians made a grievous error by not accepting partition is really ridiculous especially in light of the fact that Israel isn't even satisfied with the 78% of palestin its control since 1949 so why would it be satisfied with only 56% without Jerusalem it's another illogical ridiculous argument that they make but they can't come up with any other with any real arguments because there aren't any there
really aren't any [Music] [Music]