if there's one defining feature of classic Doom it would be that it's simple dead simple from the very first moment you load up the game you'll notice that you can't look up and down there are no rooms over other rooms and most perplexingly there's no jumping but don't be fooled by The Game's limitations Doom 2 is one of the deepest shooter strategically not in spite of its Simplicity but because of it at first glance it might not seem like the game has a very high skill ceiling as the granddaddy of the FPS aiming is surprisingly
absent as a skill the auto aim is also so heavy that if you give the plasma rifle to somebody with only 5 hours in the game they'll have about the same DPS and accuracy as somebody with 5,000 hours so if the depth isn't in aiming then what about the movement Doom has kind of been retroactively lumped into the movement shooter genre because it has a lot of relatives in the family but the class Doom games don't really have a lot of Rich movement Tech compared to games like Quake or Titanfall or Doom Eternal those games
have things like rocket jumping and grappling hooks things that Doom definitely does not have so Doom doesn't really share a lot of skills with other twitch Shooters even though it directly inspired them maybe it shares some depth with some other genres well what first comes to mind when I think of difficult games are souls likes Dark Souls seiro you name it the difficulty in those games is based around being precise in timing your Dodge rolls and parries as well as being able to memorize attack patterns but these skills aren't really present in Doom there's nothing
like a Parry or Dodge roll that requires precise timing and basically only one attack that you need to memorize precision timing and mechanical execution are all skills that difficult games usually demand of the player and while these skills are important in Doom they're not the main focus most of the guns are exceedingly straightforward to use with very few Advanced Techniques there's no things like head shot or weapon combos or anything like that they're not complex enough to have things like status effects either so there's no synergies even the fire extinguisher in deusex has more synergies
with other weapons than any of the weapons in Doom so if this game has none of the things we traditionally consider to be depth where is the Strategic complexity well whenever I die in Doom I usually think to myself man what order should I kill these demons in to consistently win the fight or man how do I ensure these demons consistently in fight if they should at all but I don't think things such as man I really had bad aim in that fight that's just not something I have to really worry about so where the
complexities and Dooms weapons lies is not in the rot mechanical execution but rather in the strategy behind when to use each weapon similarly the skill in movement is not in being able to do perfect bunny hop but rather in deciding where to move what pattern to move in and when to run away every decision matters a lot more when you can't jump in no other game have I stopped at a difficult fight and thought hm maybe I should think about this from a top- down perspective this might sound weird but that's what I actually had
to do when I started playing harder Community mods Doom's minimalist movement enemy and weapon design emphasiz a strategy over twitch gameplay and that allows for mappers to create Rich combat encounters so to start let's take a look at Doom's simple movement to see how it affects dodging WD is basically all you get in this game and it really affects how you dodge and deal with enemies the lack of movement options means that you have to be very attentive to your incoming attacks and so dodging becomes a very active Affair this is why Doom is often
compared to a dance you're constantly improvising a path through a maze of projectiles and doing this is just really satisfying and engaging to do at points it almost feels like you're playing a bullet hell since you're usually dodging things from only two dimensions that's a side effect from not being able to jump and there's actually some Merit to this idea that Doom is similar to a bullet hell since they do share some basic strategies just look at this strategy guide for Doom and compare it to these strategy guides for bullet Hells this this is where
micro dodging comes into play the idea is to begin at one of the edges of this spot and move through to the other side as slowly as possible carefully watch as the high density focused beam of fireballs approaches you and at the very last moment before you take any damage take a step aside and wait here to repeat the process again which is why lesson one is so important you can deal with this by rhythmically tapping in One Direction gradually moving along killing the enemies while their bullets Trail or kind of stream in behind you
now I'm not going to say that Doom is a bullet hell one of the main differences is that you can take many more hits in Doom than in any Dan maku even still the game's damage and health system doesn't really encourage you to take hits most attack damage in this game varies with r that's the DND influence that crept into every 9s PC game and the RNG in the game makes you have to stay on your toes while dodging incoming damage one of the most egregious examples of this is the Revenant projectile and he can
do from about 10 damage to 80 damage at the high end that's really punishing so even though you'll usually get a low to mid damage roll you always have to keep in the back of your mind that it can do a full 80 and you got to calculate that what makes it even worse is when you get hit with a lot of damage your screen just becomes red for for several seconds when I get hit by a cyber Demon's rocket I feel like my ears are ring because of how I'm complely blind another thing that
encourages dodging hits rather than just tanking them is that you only have a limited amount of Health pickups there's no Health after kill so you have to be very conservative with what hits you take when the projectiles are slow and you can really understand how to dodge them and where they come from it makes you more engaged in dodging and combined with the high damage values it stops dodging from being something passive you do with that being said when projectiles are faster and more chaotic the feeling of bobbing and weaving in between them gets lost
and replaced with a kind of manic scrambling where you move just to keep moving rather than paying close attention to where the projectiles come from this only becomes more apparent when you have a Dodge or a dash or any other movement options when you have a dedicated Dodge button especially one with invincibility frames evading attacks is more about getting the right timing and memorizing attack patterns in comparison Doom's dodging feels more analog since you have to physically move your hitbox out of the way of attacks it feels more continuous rather than discreet it's improvisational not
rehearsed it's just visceral seeing your physical margin of error when you Dodge or graze past a cyber demon rocket don't take my word for it here's the game director of Doom maternal talking about it is there anything really specific about Doom 1 and two like anything that like when you when you projectiles feed immediately yeah it was like we've never even quite got this right you know like uh you strafe to aim in 2016 in Eternal for sure but it's mostly just like just keep moving keep moving you know I think in the original Doom
in the opening hours we all remember it it's like you know imps or soldiers firing slow moving project especially the m and they hit hard one on the first level that's like the top CL they hit really hard and if you get hit by one of those you're you're in a lot of trouble so and the trains like it's just a natural you know well yeah you start to slom between them and then that's where the movement comes in so instead of constructing a multi-tiered Arena which is badass to to keep you moving right and
that's what movement means in in the modern Doom games it's like well if we ground it slow down the projectiles make them hit way harder and create patterns in the space and then that's that's the jungle gym you're going to move through is is this Maze of projectiles very much like a threedimensional schmu and it was just like oh yeah you know why didn't we should do this you know they did this 20 30 years ago like it really worked okay so we can see how Doom's lack of jumping affects dodging let's see how it
affects your relationship with space Doom is especially unique and how easily enemies can body block you due to the Primitive Graphics a lot of enemies can be rendered on screen at a time combined with large enemy hitboxes and your lack of vertical mobility it's not hard to see why getting cornered is such a dangerous but common occurrence compare this to in blood where you can easily hop over crowds of zombies in tight spaces this might be the only aspect in which blood is more forgiving than in dun most of the time you don't think of
imps as being very large threats however when they're placed in small areas and a lot of them are placed they can be a legitimately scary threat because of this you have to always be thinking of potential Escape Routes this is because when you inevitably do get cornered you might not always have an easy way out that's why you have to play proactively in this game Doom guy might be able to outrun his own Rockets but that doesn't really matter when you have no room to move around your car might be able to go from 0
to 60 in 3.4 seconds but what good does that do when you're grid locked in traffic so how do you deal with these large crowds especially when you don't have a lot of room well you have to engage in a strategy called Monster hurting if you've ever played COD zombies it's similar to the skill of training basically the enemy AI is so simple in this game that you can effectively lead them around like cattle they'll generally just wander to where you are and this predictability can be exploited to make fights easier let me show you
an example specifically from map 11 of Rush by continuously moving in a horseshoe also known as UST strafing I can congest the enemies into the center so that there's free space at the edges for me to move around it alternatively I can lure all the the demons to one end so that the rest of the area is completely free there's much more Nuance to shepher Demons but this is about the clearest way I can explain it one application of monster hurting is to provoke infighting in this fight I can lead the crowd of imps to
the front so that they block the bullets from the spider Mastermind when an enemy of one species gets hit by an enemy of a different species they get enraged and start fighting this not only clears up the imps but it also distracts the spider Mastermind so that I don't have to worry about her these mechanics are a big part of why you often hear Doom being described as a combat puzzle many fights often seem impossible at first glance but there's always a way to simplify a fight and make it more manageable the first time you
play this fight in haste map 6 you'll usually end up using a lot of BFG ammo because you get ganked by hell Knights revenants and pinkies however there's actually an elegant solution to this Arena that doesn't require using the BFG at all if you look at this map from a top down perspective you can see that there's actually two exits to the hellnight room the normal entrance is to the right where they go out into through the hallway but if you stand near the left they'll start taking the shorter route and go through the gutter
intercepting the Cyber demon this causes them to infight and distracts the Cyber demon and the hell knights from attacking you with just a little thinking the fight has effectively been simplified to just pinkies and revenants something that's pretty easy to deal with additionally because I've just been hanging out in the back of the room the demons are no longer hanging out in the front so I can go there as I please this is an example of how Doom rewards players who take their time to think and strategize rather than winning fights through Brute Force Special
thanks to speedrunner and mapper RD she helped me out with finding examples in this video another thing that limits the player is that their weapons are imperfect the guns given to you are undoubtedly powerful but they all have very large downsides in any given Circumstance the use of Doom's weapons trans towards a more specific and contextual application as opposed to a one- siiz fits-all approach that many modern games take this adds to the game's more strategic and knowledge focused gameplay in many shooters the weapon choice is up to preference as you can win most encounters
by just using your favorite guns if you tried to play Doom in the same way you would do other games you would die very quickly in harder difficulties using the wrong weapon at the wrong time can straight up kill you due to their harsh penalties especially the chainsaw I don't know if it's software intended for this weapon to be so bad but Doom guy seems to smile after picking it up this is called luto narrative dissonance let me use an example to illustrate what I mean in this fight I have access to every weapon except
for the BFG if I use the super shotgun or chain gun at any point in this fight other than near the end I will just die they have very low DPS in this situ situation calls for something that can clear up space very quickly instead of the super shotgun the rocket launcher and the plasma rifle are the main workhorses here they both complement each other perfectly filling in each other's weaknesses the rocket launcher has good ammo supply good range and the second highest DPS in the game with its Splash damage it's hands down the best
weapon at clearing out crowds other than the BFG however using it all the time is very risky since it deals very heavy self damage the plasma gun on the other hand is kind of the opposite of the rocket launcher it fires many small projectiles instead of one big projectile and it has great DPS at close range and reliably hit stuns enemies but the ammo for this weapon is rare and it struggles against crowds of High Health enemies which makes it balanced against the rocket launcher when I'm facing this amount of enemies in such a small
space every second matters I have to make split-second decisions on what weapon is the best to use and commit to it because Doom has a very slow switch speed do I stay on the rocket launcher to thin out the crowd but potentially risk dying if I hit something close or do I switch to the plasma rifle which is safer to use but might cause me to get overrun because of its lack of crowd control whatever is the case I can't just be indecisive about weapon Choice time spent swapping guns is time I could have spent
shooting Rockets or clearing up space that little animation probably added in without a second thought has ended dozens of my runs for fun let's see how this fight would have gone if I were in Doom Eternal even though the weapons are heavily specialized there are still situations where they have overlap in use in this boxed in Fight For example you can totally be successful using either the super shotgun or the rocket launcher but each choice entails a different strategy because of how cramped the space is you might be inclined to use the super shotgun but
this decision might actually end up causing you to take more damage in the long run the strategy with the super shotgun revolves around trying to avoid enemy fire and seeing if you can provoke infighting however if you use Rockets your strategy is slightly different you can kill everything much faster but you have to keep your range more and do heavy monster hurting this is all to avoid taking self damage something that the super shotgun does not have you could also try to use both weapons and get the best of both worlds however the slow swap
speed might actually get in your way there's actually another fight from fractured worlds that hinges on this mechanic in map 32 there's a switch that can only be triggered with bullet weapons it pulls up a wall preventing the arch vals from attacking you but you need to reactivate it every so often since the wall is put on a timer the Crux of this fight is that the rocket launcher is the most efficient at killing kacos but it can't activate the switch if you're too greedy with the rocket launcher the slow weapon swap speed can cause
you to die if you don't use the rocket launcher the kacos can block the switch and you also die moreover the rocket launcher has another weakness which is the fact that it isn't reliable at hit stunning enemies due to how it doesn't fire multiple pellets like the shotguns nor does it fire rapidly like the plasma rifle it can't interrupt enemies who rarely Flinch such as Arch files and cyber demons the pain chance system keeps the chain gun relevant because it can stun lock hard to dodge enemies such as manui or arachnotron however this doesn't mean
that you always use the chain gun against arachnotron or manui using the chain gun only makes sense when you're in a tight room and you have very little space to move around it it makes more sense to use higher damaging weapons such as the super shotgun or the rocket launcher when they're in Open Spaces because you can dodge them easier this is an example of how the interactions between weapons and enemies is not rock paper scissors many games encourage you to change weapons by making enemies resistant or weak to certain guns this is not the
case and do in Doom weapon Choice goes much deeper than just enemy type things such as available ammo range enemies around the area or geometry can override enemy type in consideration for instance whenever you're fighting an arch B you usually want to use either the rocket launcher super shotgun or plasma rifle because they're really effective against them with the rocket launcher and the super shotgun it really encourages a hit and run play style against Arch vies and you can deal a lot of burst damage while peeking around corners which is perfect for its attack with
the plasma rifle its high rate of fire plus the arch V's long windup animation makes it ideal for safely killing them since most of the time you'll Flinch it before it finishes their attack however you would usually not use the chain gun since it doesn't fire fast enough to consistently Flinch them to add on it has really low damage but even with these weaknesses there's still situations where the chain gun is the best choice against them in this fight of map 11 of sunlust an arch vile spawns in surrounded by zombie men because the chain
gun is so good against Hit scanners and you're constantly being fed ammo drops from revived zombie men the chain gun becomes the most viable option this situation demonstrates how nuanced weapon Choice can be in doed the chain gun was mainly good in this scenario because I was lacking ammo in my other weapons compare this to the decision making in Doom maternal when you see a stone imp you use the full auto shotgun there's not much decision making behind it you just use it because he takes more damage from it why does it do more damage
because the full a shotgun was underpowered it's like if there was a green Arch V in Doom 2 which could only be killed with a pistol you may have noticed that I've talked about all of the main weapons of Doom but I haven't really talked about The BFG yet doesn't it kind of break the game's balance because it doesn't have any real weaknesses well yes it does but only if the map makes allows it to The BFG is balanced more around its ammo supply and Rarity rather than through weaknesses like the chain gun and rocket
launcher you only use it in emergencies or large fights because its ammo is so precious but sometimes that's not enough let's say you're a mapper and you put the BFG in a secret in a previous level now you have a very hard situation because you have to balance the game for people who found the secret and people who didn't find the secret and it's really hard to make a fight still difficult for players with the BFG but not too difficult for players who didn't find The BFG this is why people do something called pistol starting
basically at the beginning of every level you voluntarily give up your weapons this play s might sound weird but Doom 1 and two were actually designed with pistol start in mind because they were worried players would forget to save and get stuck after losing their weapons on death today many mappers still design their Maps around a pistol start because it's much easier to balance them when you know exactly how much ammo or what weapons a player has without pistol starts some fights wouldn't be possible without being either the first map or the first map in
an episode it's also a good pacing tool for mappers sometimes fighting with the super shotgun all the time is boring and a single level without it can be good for the pace it's made me appreciate get weapon pickups a lot more rather than being disappointed by them when I find them in Secrets this style of play also bolsters the skill of routing because certain weapons are locked behind alternate Pathways it's up to the player to decide what order to pick up the weapons in and which route leads to the most consistent Victory when playing without
saves one last thing I want to mention in the section is that the inclusion of the bfg9000 also expands the scope of possible level design because it allows Doom guy to take on large crowds say what you will about Slaughter Maps but but without the BFG this genre of mapping would be much more boring and two-dimensional with great weapons there also needs to be great enemies to shoot at and Doom 2 has them in Spades Doom 2 has a very diverse beastiary and that's a big part of why the gamep playay is so Timeless mappers
have been creating fresh encounters with them for over 30 years and it's a testament to how welld designed they are they might be simple on their own but when combined together they can facilitate really complex combat just by combining the first two enemies in the game Doom teaches you how to do Target prioritization do you shoot the zombie Men first or do you shoot the Imp first well since you can dodge the Imp due to his slow projectiles but not the zombie men who fires hit scan you almost always shoot the zombie Men first as
a side note this setup is only possible because Doom has a combination of both hit scan and projectile enemies I think that pit scan kind of gets a bad rap these days but it's not intrinsically a bad mechanic when used well it can add variety and help prevent enemies from blending together anyways if you've been playing Doom for a while you've probably developed the kind of Threat Level hierarchy in your head you know shoot hit scanners first shoot projectile lobbers last but the idea of a Threat Level hierarchy goes beyond just hit scan versus projectile
the pain Elemental for instance doesn't have an attack that directly hurts the player however he's very high on the priority list because he puts time resource and spatial pressure on the player time because the longer they're alive the more lost souls they'll spawn resource because killing the lost souls eats through your ammo and spatial because those lost souls can prevent you from moving when you hear its wakeup call you have to immediately push forward through the crowd to deal with them otherwise you'll get suffocated by skulls this enemy also gives you an interesting dilemma in
regards to weapon Choice do you use the rocket launcher against them because it's the fastest way to take them out or do you use a different weapon because you can easily blow yourself up the answer changes depending on how long they've been alive and how far away they are while these enemies are almost always the first demons you target their threat levels aren't set in stone the enemies are nuanced enough that mappers can create situations that play around with monster priority take this crappy mockup I made in Doom Builder usually you want to shoot the
arch V first as he has both a hit scan attack and he revives enemies but in this example the imps pose a lot more immediate danger to me because of their numbers and proximity while this is just a mockup there's actually a very famous set piece where you do prioritize imps over Arch vs this fight has an easy to grasp concept but becomes increasingly complex after the hell Knight start spawning in now a hell Knight is basically just a big imp but they definitely do not fulfill the same role remember Doom is a game about
controlling space and that little increase in health prevents them from being cleared out in just a single rocket if I don't pull out my BFG in time this is what happens this fight is also a good example of how imps can introduce the player to set pieces here's a clip from the mapper Nirvana creator of fractured worlds if you have like a big gimmicky fight then imp are a great thing to use to kind of establish your gimmick uh like at the beginning you get this nice buildup for the player of okay they've seen the
fight sort of functioning in an easier way with imps and then we can bring hell Knights and rants in sort of towards the end of it Target prioritization is further flipped on its head through infighting instead of just having high priority targets Doom also has enemies that you target last this is where infighting comes in as sometimes you actually want to leave certain demons alive in order to help you in a fight if you want to learn more about the subject of monster priority check out so bad's video he goes a lot more in depth
than I do enemy attacks also change up your movement quite a bit you would never Dodge a manibus the same way you would an arachnotron or a cyber demon one of my favorite enemies to dodge is the Revenant because of his homing projectiles they have a lot of counterplay due to their limited turning speed and you can snag their rockets on walls and enemies due to how slowly they turn additionally if you're good enough at movement you can cause Revenant missiles to enter an orbit around you this is something you can't really do with the
vores from quake since their homing missiles can turn sharp Corners due to their lack of counterplay you often find yourself either backtracking through half the map or standing in one place to deal with them you might be asking if Quake VES are so unfun to fight against since they force you to move behind cover then what about the arch vile their entire gimmick is that you're forced to go behind cover that's a fair point the reason why the archvile is so interesting to fight even though there's very little counterplay to his attack is because it
speeds up the game rather than slowing it down their fast movement speed combined with their hit scan attacks forces you to constantly reposition yourself towards continuously changing safe zones they flush you out so that other monsters have a chance to kill you on the other hand since VES are so stationary they encourage you to stand around the same Corner playing peekaboo rather than an inspiring Dynamic movement Quake mappers actually struggle to use them in conjunction with other monsters because they lead to a hard stop on combat when used overriding all other gameplay rather than adding
to it many in the community actually prefer to make levels for a mod called copper which changes their projectiles to be more like Revenant to add on the Revenant counterplay doesn't completely NE neutralize their threat you can still lose control of their rockets and die if you're sloppy with your movement that is something I respect about the monsters in Doom they're hard to completely neutralize going back to Quake the shambler has the same basic attack as the arch V but he's much less scary than him because you can prevent him from using his attack by
baiting out his melee like with the Vore the copper mod removes this exploit in order to reestablish his intended Threat Level the reason why the arch vile is so scary is because you don't have a consistent way to to avoid its attack there's no weak spot or exploit to disable them they decide the rhythm of the fight they make you play by the rules that's why they're one of the best enemies in Doom lastly a word on Silhouettes and sound design every enemy has a very distinct color palette shape and sound which makes it very
easy to read a room at a glance here I'll show you what is this guy it's a kakad demon what about this guy it's a baron of Hell okay what about this m Le okay now look at this sound what is this demon an archvile what about this a mancubus okay now what is this guy it's a Hellraiser from Doom 2016 do you even remember what this guy does so to conclude every enemy is simple on their own but like Lego they can slide together to create something complex along with the ability to adjust weapon
and ammo availability through pistol starting Doom makes itself a great sandbox for mapping giving designers very fine control over its Rich combat playing doom and creating levels for Doom is simple enough for anybody to pick up but deep enough that one can spend a lifetime practicing these skills Doom 2 is incredibly well-designed and I would encourage anybody who enjoys difficult games to try out custom Doom WS there's simply nothing else quite like them