Good afternoon folks we will get started in just a minute or two we are missing a very key element to our board meeting and that's our American flag so we're going to pause we'll start a moment or two late just to allow that to get here so please be patient for all right the time is 6 PM I call this meeting of The Godly Independent School District order let the record show we Have a quum of board members present the meeting's been duly called and the notice of the meeting's been posted in accordance with the
Texas open meeting act Tex Texas government code chapter 551 um before we get started um just to set the stage with the agenda we do have a workshop that is um in the middle of the uh agenda for this evening we will Target to start that around 7 PM so I may adjust uh the agenda timing on things just a little bit to make sure That we have all of the candidates here uh to allow that participation so please be patient with us if we make adjustments uh next Mr braer would you care to offer
the invocation sir check all right let's pray our most gracious and Holy Father we are so grateful for your love and and your grace and your mercy that you bestow upon us day in and day out and as we proceed through this meeting I ask that you uh bless this board with your Wisdom and uh guide them and direct them as only you're able to do and Lord we're just so grateful for the sacrifice of your son Jesus Christ and of the the Forgiveness of the sins that uh we're able to to receive from that
uh ask that you do forgive us when we fall short it's in Christ's holy and precious name that I pray amen and I believe we have some of our immediate team members that are going to help us with our pledges could you all Come to the podium please we do we have Miss Sophia kadina and Mr Marcus Santos I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all honor the Texas flag I pledge allegiance to
the Texas one State under God indivisible you may be seated thank you media team I app Appreciate that so next we will go into recognition good evening board thanks for letting us come up here and recognize some of our fabulous students uh tonight we have a wonderful group uh that Miss trewick has started this program a couple years ago and last year we had four students that were running the TV media at games and events and this year she has 16 so this program has already grown immensely in just a couple years of M with
leading it but I will Let her come up and talk about the team a little bit and then we'll recognize the ones that were able to make it tonight good evening board thank you for having us we're really excited to be here um like Mr flood said um just last year we had four on a good night uh able to come and this year we have 16 and we literally have so many students this year that we have to do rotations which is a great thing um it's been so much fun these kids honestly they're
all new This year they had to learn kind of on a whim I'm up here but Marty is really a lead ringer Le read what is that somebody help me you got it okay um so he is really super helpful on this um I get to have these students at least once a day in class and then they show up even after school so that says a lot um a lot of these kids work jobs they have to take off work to be here on Friday nights with us they really learned this uh equipment That
we have new this year in our new amazing building on the first game and they just kind of got with it Marty can attest it was amazing it went so smooth they're incred incredible leaders and have just really picked up on this technology but it says a lot for students to be here an hour before kickoff and they're some of the last ones to leave every Friday night for a home game they're setting things up um one night we didn't I don't Think got out of here until 11:00 and so I so thankful for these
students and their dedication I don't think people will realize how much goes into it not only are they running the board if you ever get a chance you should really come tour and see some of the equipment that they're running it's professional equipment it's the same equipment that uh any big NCAA school is running uh one of our guys that came in and helped us said that the Cowboys use some of this Um technology as well so these students are going to be set up when they leave us at Godly high school that this is
something they want to continue as a profession or even just as an internship in college they're going to go in ahead of the rest right so we're setting them up for success and it's just so much fun to be a part of I'm so thankful that I get to lead this team alongside Marty and yeah thank you guys for having us these these kids are Great I I like to say this too that the the most exciting one of the most exciting places to be on a Friday night is in the control room with these
students just watching them manage the Controlled Chaos of live stream production and they're running the video board they're running all the different cameras and the drones and everything and it's very impressive to watch these kids work so just want to say that we really appreciate these guys So we do have some students missing tonight again a lot of these students work jobs um after school and so some of them couldn't be here but we're thankful for the ones that are um they also know that I'm not great with um pronouncing names sometimes but they forgive
me so it's okay uh first we're not first we have Ellie Navaro next we have Angie terzes next we have Sophie Perez next we have Sophia Kadina we have Marcus Santos we have Alexis Morales next we have Valerie Basera we have Wyatt Jones we have Xavier vas and actually I lied uh Xavier was on our team last year so he's the only returning member he's our vet that came back this year to help which really says a lot and then we have Kylie pedon um those that couldn't be here tonight uh we have Ava Jackson
Ben Clark I do think he's actually on his way Kimberly monado Corey agle har col Coulson and brillan not so that's our media team e if we could have all of our principles line up on that side of the uh cafeteria pleas orli please so October is National principales month and I am so pleased to have the opportunity to come before you today in recognition of the amazing principles That we have in our school district um I was a principal in this school district for several years before moving into this position and and I know
that being a principal is not an 8 to5 job it's not a 7 to3 job it's a 247 job you wake up in the middle of the night thinking did I take care of that or how can I Inspire my teachers or how can I encourage my students um and they they truly do care about the entire community and everyone that is involved in making their campus Successful so um today we're going to recognize them with a certificate with um just a appreciation from the board and from the school district as well as a gift
certificate to go to the granberry opera house and they can go to a show or a concert um just take some time to get away and go have a little bit of fun so thank you to Mr Met for making that happen all right let's begin with Dr Melissa Block principal at Pleasant View Elementary Mrs jod Dixon principal at Arby Godly Elementary Mr Tom Frasier principal at Legacy Elementary School Mrs Jamie Ducket our newest principal at The Godly sixth grades campus Miss Stephanie principal at Godly Middle School Miss Michelle swam the principal at links Academy
and Mr Curtis J flood principal at Godly high School thank you all so much for your dedication to our students in our district for all right next we will have superintendent report Dr yes sir we're going to start with um got someone who needs to be another meeting there he is Mr Jeff Roberts is G give usate on refunding some bonds thank you Dr deer president Stevenson of Jeff Robert with Hilltop Securities I'm here tonight to share Some information related to a bond refunding is the same as a refinancing for whatever reason our industry term
refunding but share information then ask that consider adoption of a parameter order that would delegate final authority to make all the preparations and finalize the refunding if we're able to do the district has two so the district has uh two two different issues outstanding that have principal maturities that that are Eligible to be refunded using tax exempt rates uh unlike a mortgage you can't just refinance at any time in order to use tax exempt rates you have to be within 90 days of the call date on the bonds that you're going to refund and so
on the 2015 series The call date is two February 25th February 15th of 25 and then there's maturity from the 2022 series that also has that same February 15th of 25 call date so if we did the refinancing we would just have to make Or settle it after November 17th in order to be able to use those tax exemp rates uh this first page has a lot of numbers on there but a couple that I'll point out if you go over uh two through four columns two through four are the bond principal maturities we'd be
refunding uh columns five six and seven is a hypothetical refunding issuance and then the savings from the refunding issuance which is column seven versus column four is shown there in column 8 And so what we've done is we've structured most of the in the early years because we feel like that'll help our capacity going forward best uh we're not going to extend the term of the debt and we're also not going to take a loss in any single year and right now we're projecting that the savings would be about $1.3 million up there on the
the right kind of in the light blue shaded area and a red number the PB savings is a percentage of refunded principal That's kind of The Benchmark that we use in our industry to kind of determine uh how well a refunding went or how how how much savings refunding had the higher the number the better um if the PB savings is above 3% it's worthy of consideration at this point in time it's about 7% so hopefully it'll remain at that level or increase whenever we decide to do the refinancing um the next page I did
a just a summary um kind of restating some Of the things that I've said just so you have it writing before you and kind of go back and and look at it once again the main thing is right now we're looking at about 1.3 million in savings service won't be increased and we won't extend that term and if for whatever reason interest rates were to spike on us we just wouldn't do the refunding and your current outstanding de service would just just remain the same so there wouldn't be any pocket cost or anything Like that
so the parameter refunding order I think some of you may be familiar with the parameter process but allowable under the Texas government code the board would delegate final pricing Authority in this case to superintendent or CFO the parameters that included are listed under bullet and again if for whatever reason those parameters aren't me the refunding just wouldn't be executed and then the last page the Proposed parameters are listed here again pricing officer superintendent CFO maximum principal amount we won't issue more in refunding bonds than what is being refunded so we W increase that principal amount
that 3% PV savings we've used is is the floor um this isn't something that will just show up on Dr deer's desk and say we're done you know that I would I would let Dr deer know here's looks like right now do we want to pull the trigger and go ahead and do It or do we want to wait so there's a lot of a lot of communication and collaboration going forward before we execute the final material date again we're not extending the debt at all and the delegation expiration is is I know I flew
through that fairly quickly if anybody has any questions I'd be be happy to answer yes sir I do have a question for you this delegation is 365 days if um I understood correctly you have U the time frame that when These notes need to be would need to be called I such a ly delegation if that decision would be made say within the next 90 to 180 days well we do that really for flexibility so if for whatever reason let's say rates moved away from us and we were just unable to to achieve a savings
then the hope would be that that would give us more time for maybe rates to settle back down maybe they do maybe they don't but it's just a just a flexibility Thing that we put in there to try to get as much Flex as possible and I have a similar question related to the 90day window um if we don't call them by December November 17th then we lose the opportunity to do a refunding after February no ma'am it's it's callable anytime on or after February 15 and 25 quick question what what's the lead time when
you start this process closing iume on you know we could probably be ready to price within a couple of weeks Maybe maybe shorter and whenever you do a pricing it typically takes about a month to close so the time between pricing and closing is about a month because everything has to go to the Attorney General's office and be approved by the attorney general and at that time is when we could make sure we close after that November 17th okay so the second part of my question on that front is is what you presented is that
would that be consider the pricing Currently that's using current rates yes sir they're changing every day so I think I ran this as of Friday of last week and sent this on Mr Davis so this was Thursday's rates rates actually went up a little bit today so I mean they're they're going up and down constantly so we just got to kind of take a snapshot when we're ready to price we'll take a snapshot and say this is where we think we would end up is this we want to move forward or we want to Wait
has Godly ISD done this before yes' were you with us when we did it before yes ma'am you remember when we did it before um well I've been with you since 1997 um so we did it in 2015 as a matter of fact the bonds that were refunding is actually a refunding issue so we're refunding some bonds from a 2015 series issuance um we did it again and what the last time 2015 appears to be the last time that we had have done the Thank you yes ma' I had um two questions I believe you
answered my first question that I had before tonight but I just want to clarify so this is not adding to our principle we're not adding to our debt and you also answered that we're not extending the length of time so this is not any additional debt correct okay and then my other question is just on the bond order that I saw in our board book um I noticed the language reads leving Ual ad Borum tax to provide for the security and payment of said bonds I just want to clarify is this an additional tax no
this is your same interest in syncing fund tax rate and you'll actually be levying potentially less for Debt Service as a result of of saving some money in those certain years okay so is that wording just standard I guess then okay yes ma um can you explain um when our bond p are made and how they're Calculated yes so every Bond issuance that you do has principle coming due each year um and each year that principal amount has an interest rate tied to it so your bonds are scheduled to where you make principal payments annually
on February 15th of each year and you make interest payments semiannually on February 15th and August 15th of each year so we just have to calculate you know what what principal amounts associated with which interest Rates combine all of that to come up with your total have we ever missed a bond payment no man no so to go back to my question if you guys have identified that we have an estimated $1.4 million in savings if we refund the bond in the process from start to finish is roughly 30 days what what would we wait
around it could potentially grow is that we we' identifi this do we not execute The deal and to kind of tie back into Craigs point of 365 days on the delegation so forth right so again we have the 365 days for flexibility my hope is that we're able to do it as quickly as possible however if for any reason rates spike in the next week week and a half and all of a sudden it's 1.3 million is 300,000 let's say then you might take the tact of you know what we're willing to wait to hopefully
see if interest rates will settle back down And then uh execute the refinancing but no the hope is that we execute it within two weeks um but it's just there just in case and quite honestly if you want to we can lower that delegation period right now you know you can make a a motion to approve the order with that change but again that's just for flexibility reasons and that's just something that I do with all the the school districts I work with and I would say I don't want maybe 99 times out of a
100 we're able to do it as quickly as possible but there may be that instance you see that Spike and say okay wait we need a little bit more time to hopefully see it go down before we going back to Terry's question if we've ever missed a bond payment and we haven't this might be a Spencer or you Jeff question maybe um where can our community verify that we have not missed a bond payment do we post that on our website I'm sorry for The let me I'll let him answer it in just a second
but so each one each School District bond issue in the state of Texas is covered by the permanent School fund guaranteed Bond guarantee program and that program started in 1984 or five and in its lifetime no District in the state of Texas has ever had to tap in to the psf Guarantee Bond guarantee program making their payment for them has there been a clerical error where maybe the bond Payment got sent A Day Late by somebody I don't know but but no district has ever been in solvent and just flat out can't make their payment
so that the psf had to stay and then one of the things that we did our transparency Stars so our debt obligations uh they can public can go to that website and it has all of our information um above and beyond what statutorily required so there's a lot of information out there that they can look So I've heard recently some rumor that said that Godly ISD was bankrupt and that we owed you know 400 million dollar in bond payments that we hadn't made so would you say that person was uninformed well I I I think
let's try to equate that to our own personal financial situations and May compare it to a mortgage um if if you went and took out a $400,000 mortgage for a new home and I did this exercise recently in a roughly six and a half perc rate which Is actually a little below what the going rate is your total payout on that would be over 900,000 so would you if people asked you what your mortgage was for would you tell them about 900,000 or would you tell them 400,000 so I think there's it's implied that if
you borrow moneyy that you're paying interest but the amount that you borrowed is the amount that you borrowed so the the $400,000 figure Excuse the $400,000 figure is the total principal and interest over the life of your bonds uh just like the 900,000 would be the total principal of interest on a 30-year mortgage at 6 and a half% um so I don't I don't see any reason to believe that Godly is going bankrupt I I've been doing this for for quite a while I work with Mansfield Keller back when they were high growth District back
in the early 2000s and I think similar statements were made um about them being Bankrupt um they're doing okay right now and I I'm working with several other districts similar to Godly that are going through high growth right now and yes the debt burden is high because you're growing and because you're building facilities for kids that are not only here but kids that are going to be here in the future um but again in the 20 it's my 29th year of doing this in my 29 year roughly 29 years doing this I haven't had any
districts that I've worked with go bankrupt as a result of their their bond issuances I don't know if that that kind of ram yeah and I guess to add to that this refunding process that we're doing in refinancing is saving the district over a million dollars if we get to go ahead and go through it yes I mean that that certainly certainly helps yes thank you any other questions thank you thank you appreciate it thank You Jeff appreciate it um now we'll do a construction update I believe S&P is here us a little construction upate
Sor I'm a little bit under the weather today do my best um we are coming to the Final Phase right now um area f a little bit behind we uh have a rough couple of weeks last two weeks make a traction plan um but we're down to about 100 punch list items uh for function and as far as completed scope we have two areas for waiting on some Ceiling grid parts to to button up some glass pieces down in the training room um we had to make some stru modifications late game something noticed in the
field Wasing daming now um and then we have uh we have just a couple of fixtures that we're waiting order delivered missing so we are down to the last push um I am dedicating my personal time here in full time 5:30 in the morning Till as late as possible whatever um to complete all these items and I won't leave this site until we're done so here's my plate on other projects I've been assigned to and dedicated here to really don't have a lot of updates for you other than area turned over and usable to a
point and my hope is that Wednesday this week we have those ceilings and those final areas buttoned up it really essentially be fully open and operational and we'll Just be focusing on punch l b control issues I have two questions um how long do you foree the punch phase of this project to go on and all the so my goal is 30 days or less from now that's that's the goal to get completely out of here there are some issues with some of the door hardware that were ordered to repair um some of The issues
that we had probably about six weeks out so it kind of pushes that out a little bit um I told Mi and team that that six weeks we're waiting on that hardw that should be the last thing we do out here all the hardw was was operating correctly it's just the wrong color we want to do the color swap back to Satin it was a completely new hardware set in just new color assume change the hand so we re so that six weeks Last and the other you mentioned that you had not had as much
traction the last few weeks that you had anticipated or hoped for we haven't really had any weather what what has flowed the the progress down subcontractor performance really um we've we've organized everything and requested the the attendance and hav them been showing up so I've been doing a lot of work last week week and a half in the office trying to pull the owners of each Individual company in hold them accountable Express dis pleasure we have been for the last two and a half months it's really just trying to realign efforts to get out of
here contract okay so um are you prepared to bring in new subcontractors if that's what it Tak we have we've brought in two new subcontractors already and supplemented the original contracts um and I've also freed up financially for us S&P side to perform whatever we need to internal so I've been given that priority to be able bring 15 people on own go through here I had a question specifically for the arena and the sound and the AV there it doesn't seem like it's working properly yeah I think there was a a little bit of a
um design coordination and expectation in this alignment with the scoreboard and how that was going to interact with the audio system they're completely two different systems and in our contract set those systems didn't Talk to each other um I know Marty and team and infinity is working on a solution to adapt that make that all function correctly um but from our side of it and I'm certainly not protecting Infinity here but um they did install Pur contract documents and that integration was not part of it so that was I heard the rumor about the sound
quality being really terrible when it came to producing the audio that was coming off of the screen it's completely Different it seems like that integration would almost be standard though when you said it our contract wasn't didn't include that would it be included in most contracts uh it really depends on on the providers so the screen is a deconic system and in our system through Infinity is a very a very different uh acoustical systems and know that it is not uncommon for the school district to have actronics or or whatever they whatever company that they
Have working on a system that's independent from everything else so I would say it's unfortunate that it happened but that expectation of that functionality wasn't including the drawings and the documents um but it's something we can deal with not resolving um and we we've done this also with the TV studio there was an intention um on your live stream to actually be able to run the TV studio integration that also was not included in in the way the System was designed um our subcontractor because they a lack of performance I convinced the president of the
company to invest in the integration switch and extra cabling that's required to do that at no cost of the district and they're installing that I believe it's already installed or it's getting close to being installed M so of those integration pieces um are unfortunate but uh it does it does happen in addition to that the TV studio And all the equipment and training final training will be done this Thursday so that kind of ear marks the completion of the audio system as a whole we will have two um outstanding issues one is one of the
screens in the arena presentation room still is not functioning the vendor sent out texts from wherever they're from they reped the three screens that were broken one of them need to be reordered that screen is supposed to be here next Friday to be fully replaced um That is one issue and then the other issue is the intercom on the connector uh those speakers um through lonar they were installed and they're the wrong oh speaker so they were submitted on they were installed it's a 4arm speaker it's an eight speaker that's needed so go are AIO
issues question for uh Miss Nicks are we comfortable with the uh process that we have for working down the punch list okay thank you appreciate It any other questions we're much more comfortable now that Caleb is be on S every day until we so we really appreciate that yeah I I person own the last couple of weeks it didn't happen the way we had planned it so I'm taking up own that responsibility we will address it um I also did just upgrade um one um I upgraded all the Landscaping alongside the field all the way
down construction entrance that is All been permanently irrigated at our cost because we did some damage out there it was never irrigated before we were able to tie that into the system so it's Iration and I also paid the additional money to have that all soldered so all that is a gift from S&P we did some damage instead of trying to some Hy seed out there hope it grows sorry thank you sir for uh the additional efforts and the focus uh to Help us get to Clos questions just get one next thank Mr KS and
Mr flood that talk to us just a little bit about Cass they got the opportunity to go down and present at our last Cass training so I wanted them just to bring us up to date on that all right good evening um so the uh Tac um group generally meets twice a year once in the fall and once in the spring um I was honored to get a go with Mr KS um and work with a lot of different districts godle has been a part of this work since its Inception which is seven years now
I believe um so Godly is one of the founding members that works with this group and it's cool to see a lot of the new groups that that join all the way from massive districts like McKenna um down to really small districts um we got to sit with Lidle this year uh and talk with Lidle and see how they do things they've they've been Really strong on the work and they have a new superintendent this year there's have done most of the work and retired and they have a new one that's really picking it up
and leading the charge so it's always fun to get a talk with them um I was honored this year they had a principal panel uh that they were able to ask us questions I was able to talk a little bit about the campus and represent Godly uh on that panel um there was a focus this year to talk a Little bit more strategically about how this work is done on the campus as opposed to just the district level and a lot of these districts have District Personnel that help run these um and so they're really
trying to figure out how to push it down to the campuses and include all groups um I Heard a uh Alamo Mo Heights presentation on how they got Athletics and Fine Arts to have input into their accountability systems how they got um local departments as far as Custodial or food or maintenance to also include their accountability into the system um along with all the academic pieces and everything else that go with it uh so it was a great two days um to hear the stories from others and learn from others and work with them um
and I was honored to get a to get answer a few questions um that they they lobed for us to be able to answer them so well and what he's not going to do is brag on Himself he represented us so well he rocked it like it was so cool like there was just aw and gasps from the from you know peers uh that we're sitting with and the you know so Mr flood talked about how he he talks about benefit in uh in government economics every year he comes in and teaches a class and
talks about um our our community based accountability and benefits and you could see everybody just go oh that's a that's yeah that's a great idea so they Were writing that down in their notebooks and so Mr flood represented us so well and I was honored to be with him we got to spend some time time together and learn together um and just um continue building our relationship and um um so and it was nearby it was uh in iring and car Carolton Farmers Branch area and so um not too far so um but we had
a great trip and it was good to uh uh just hit the refresh button a little bit and visit with some others uh get Gather some ideas I know I came back with an idea for our um cabinet meetings on how to incorporate the pillars and and um those benefits um even better uh we we do it now but always listening and learning from others so it was just a great opportunity and and we were excited that the Cass um that our community report came out hopefully everybody got theirs in the mail um I was
excited to see that and I think it looks really good and Kudos again to all The principls and directors and Jeff met for uh the work that they did put into that so we just want to let youall know that we're working hard on it and keeping it on the front burner and uh representing Godly I well we believe so thank you Mr cars yes ma'am for people who may not be familiar with what Tac is can you tell people what those letters stand for and explain what that is in a little bit more detail
sure so Tac is the Texas public accountability Consortium and this started um yeah I think 2017 and um and then so of course a little bit before Co and then Co hit and really knocked it and and threw us for a loop and then we we uh got things charged back up again um but this is a group of school school districts from across the state that believe in true accountability and believe in more accountability State accountability is a piece and and we own that and we face That and we deal with that but there's
so much more that one letter uh you know a single letter grade can tell about any school I know a very affluent School District that said you know we'll get an A no matter what we did our kids are teacher proof and it's like whoa but then they lamented the fact that it didn't tell everything about their school district it didn't talk about other good things Andor their struggles and so that's where you know we really Latched on to that and what a great idea and to have local control local you know telling the story
here's where we're doing well you here's where we're struggling and what what were the strategies that we're trying to do to to improve and so uh really just focusing on what's happening in Godly ISD um and and finding those local you know data points um stories um you know you'll see a lot of good stories and things of things that are going on and then also Those data points if it's our map test or how we're doing on the SAT or U you know those those types of things and our reading levels and all those
in that uh in that document so um I you remember how many districts there are now 34 I think there's more than that I could get that number for you but yeah that's right there were 34 new districts this year so there's there's I think it's maybe 100 150 districts um but you know a lot of um and a lot of sharing of That work and and what you know learning from each other and we've been proud because we were learning from so many um that now we've turned that and we have people that are
learning from us and the work that we're doing and how uh so and we're going to be coming back to you all in November uh for our quarter 1 signaling uh for the campuses and and how we're doing and what they're um what they're doing well at what uh what they're working on so we'll be Back with that uh signaling chart in November were you able to uh show them copies of uh current presentation yes and that's super exciting and and um we were s there was one group that we were sitting with and they're
like okay and and I only had one copy and they're like okay I want to see more and so I pointed them to the website and where that was and so how how they were able to find that and they you know and because what you'll see you'll see different ways of Of how people will do it from anything from a small flyer and pointing to a website or you know full magazine such as you know there those there are several districts that that do that as well so uh just seeing in what they're putting
in there and like you know we'll times that we'll have something in ours that that they're like oh we want to do that and and vice versa we'll see things like oh we need to include that uh to better tell our story as well Okay thank you all for the opportunity thank you guys for representing us and uh demonstrating first of all and also leading us into community- based accountability again it's to me it is such a key element so again I appreciate you all buying in supporting all the way through so thank you guys
it's good work yes sir thank you I want to Echo that we're so proud of all of our principles and Mr KS for for for stressing our pillar and talking about the benefits And putting kid first kids first and and and really spearheading um Community Based accountability so thank you all really appreciate all your hard work and that is the end of superintendent thank you sir all right next on the agenda is uh public participation so at this time we extend the opportunity uh for public parti of the meeting in compliance with Section 5517 of
the Texas government code I have a number of folks that have signed up public participation provides the general public the opportunity to address the board regarding topics listed on the agenda persons attending the meeting and wishing to participate have already signed up thank you for that uh each individual addressing the board will have three minutes to make their presentation you will see a timer on the screen for that uh personal Attacks on District employees by name or position or students will not be allowed um all participants are expected to speak with respect and Civility and
maintain a calm professional demeanor upon the expiration of the three minutes um I'll call the next person that's signed up to speak uh please note the open meaning act does not require the board to respond uh in any way um so uh we will now get to public participation Uh first on my list is Mr Cooper and I believe he wanted to speak with uh regarding agenda item 5 a and 8 B evening uh excuse me evening board um so we're going to talk about bonds today and um it's great that Godly I is not
going bankrupt and it's great they've never missed a payment but let's put some of the debt in proportion with the rest of Johnson County so Godly ISD with principal and interest and you have to factor an interest they're currently 48 Million in debt Burleson is $44 million in debt that's number two they have 12,000 kids they're also a fast growth fast growth District debt per student that's important because average daily attendance is how you get your funding Godly ISD is in debt per student $145,000 per student the number two Place district is $50,000 per student
behind that you guys receive more money you spend more money and you're in debt more money than any other District in Johnson County and it's not even close now if you had built everything we could have a discussion about that but you just had an 889 million doll Bond fail 1.7 billion with interest and a 365 million 774 million with interest fail so the question is at what point have you taxed and forced enough people Out of their homes to where you're satisfied with the opulence that you've created around you yet your insatiable appetite still
needs more it's a very fair question then you turn to the next page and you can see that the academics have not yielded positive results with this so at what point is leadership questioned about whether or not godly ISD is on the right path most districts Here their debt is so far below Godly isds it's not even in the remote zip code it's not even close there's four fath gross districts in Johnson County you guys aren't the only ones and you're tier three on the lowest level and you receive more money for fast growth districts
so at what point is enough enough thank you next I have Mr Hunley there he is you're up sir yes sir I believe you're going to speak on agenda item number seven the workshop sorry ladies and gentlemen thank you for allowing me to speak I'm Craig Hunter of course I'm in defense of our present CAD board that we it took us five years to get and I'm trying to expand on it and we this is spreading across the state of Texas right now uh we've had 40 Years of no accountability to the taxpayers because of
the mafia type system called Central Appraisal District orad created from the pavito bill and passed by elected in 1979 and enacted in 1982 and was designed to keep our taxpayers in the dark and Confused our elected in the past have rubber stamped the chief appraisers picks to protect the system when we uncovered what was happening and challenge the system it took five years to bust the system and we succeeded we campaigned hard While our opposition never had to show up for support if y'all remember a year ago we were out campaigning none of our opponents
had to show up and they still got votes the only push back was and I hate to say it but the only push back we've had is from the school districts and I haven't figured that one out yet until we came along no one in the public knew there was a governing body elected by the tax and entities and not The public and the first time I showed up to a cad board I walked up in this little dark room up in top of the cad office and the first thing out of their mouth was
what do you want it's supposed to be an open public meeting uh now our meetings are held in large halls with 80 to 100 people in attendance every month being allowed their first amendment rights our new CAD board is now cleaning up the mess left By the past and finding many problems our board has shaved almost a half a million dollar off the cad budget open meetings to the public hired a t officer who represents the tax paays a new website posted agendas in full transparency our elected or working to pass a bill well what
is happening in Austin right now they're working on a bill next next session to make sure that all the cad board is elected by the public last year they gave us three in The new tax bill but hopefully after this session everyone will be elected by the public our movement is growing fast across our state and we will eventually take this thank you next I have have uh Mr spinson and speaking on item number seven Workshop Mr board president and board members I appreciate the opportunity now I didn't bring notes or Handouts that is a
citizen of Johnson County I have been so heartbroke over the increase in taxes I've attended all of these different board meetings and hopes that I would see a change and I want to compliment Mr Dwayne gouy he's right there and next to him is Mr Larry traml I don't if we have any other board members but I mean they have done us right if right is still good in this world and like you said when Mr Hesit presented a budget of 1.25 million they said wait a minute the old board not only approved whatever he
wanted see they had it all backwards they thought they worked for Jim hesi but it's different he works for you and the cabiny and so when they trimmed 440,000 maybe a little bit more off that budget nobody had ever done that before no one I just thought wow who are these people that's why I can name who they are and they're the ones that have Decided that they're going to freeze your taxes and not increase for 3 years how about that they're paying attention to us our needs the needs of the young married people in
this District that are buying their first homes and they're afraid they're going to lose them over high taxation and you all know insurance has gone up 30 some odd per and inflation has gone up 24.31 now how much can you stretch that Rubber band before it breaks where we're at that point so what am I saying I hope you'll support the new nominees that Mr Craig Hunley I didn't know Craig Hunley a few months ago but I know what he stands for he stands for the citizens of Johnson County and I know you here in
Godly Texas want the same for your Community or your citizens that it's been said and I can validate it that over 37% of residents in Texas will either go bankrupt this year or lose their homes and I don't think any one of you as wives mothers of children that you want that to happen I appreciate the time and I just want to say I support the new bad board bad board they're trying to do thank [Applause] you Miss olon you're up next again I believe the item is number seven the workshop we are supposed to
have a Representative government a war was fought in our constitution written with the Express in intent that citizens hold the representatives within government entities accountable we have strayed dangerously far from this tenant and as a result our country is and many government entities are in financial chaos and Corruption abounds we have some individuals who are citizens who welcome Financial Accountability transparency and who are not afraid of criticism a constitutional republic can only function properly if the citizens work to balance strong leadership and robust accountability our country and our freedom depends on it I'll remind you
what was said at the end of the Constitutional Convention those many years ago when asked what kind of government we had a republic or a Monarchy Ben Franklin said a republic does anybody know what he what was said after that if you can keep it that's on us it's on us as Citizens to hold this government to do the things that we want to be done in this country so I ask you humbly to consider these citizens who are trying to be strong leaders who are trying to protect our Republic Dwayne Golding John Wood Amy
Lingo Brandon po and Jim cochrell as the individuals who would take that responsibility most seriously in word and in action thank you next I have Mr cockrel and I guess sir before you come up just a quick thing you are more than welcome to speak now but you'll have your opportunity during the workshop if you care for both you're more than welcome to if you want to defer no all good so we'll we'll certainly Hear from you in a few minutes okay thank you sir again not trying to cheat you out just want to give
you opportunity okay uh next uh Mr Lee Jr I pronounce that right like okay I'm sorry please come up thank you for being able to speak to you tonight and uh I want to say that have said a lot of the things that I've thought about but I've taught in classrooms like this mathematics History also shop I've done shop and have a teaching certificate and have experience with what goes on in this in this building ladies and gentlemen when I was teaching history one of the things that I learned was that when our government was
formed the issue that motivated the Revolution was taxes and representation on taxes now we are faced with a with a Problem of the appraisal district and the representatives that serve on that appraisive District it is imperative that those people represent the people that are paying the bills because you have a mortgage on these houses the state has a mortgage on these homes and that mortgage that c is so powerful that they can evict a person from that home and when we uh when we raise the appraisal when we do that we need to be Sure
that we take that into consideration that we are affecting the life and the liberty of individuals and the way they live and the quality of their life I I applaud of y'all on on listening to to our words and giving thought to these issues and I thank you and I ask you to use good judgment thank you okay that will wrap up the public participation section uh I'm going to Recommend a 5 minute recess and then we will move into Workshop for for e for for for for for for E for all right we will
get started with the workshop so the just to remind folks the purpose of the workshop is learning about the candidates that are uh appointed by the taxing entities to the Johnson County Appraisal District Board of director um a little bit different than our regular board meeting we'll uh so just I'm trying to level set every one Understand um we'll still be respectful of folks we may not follow Robert's Rules of Order to the strictest of detail because we're in a workshop mode so um a little bit different there um the general audience again this is
the intent is focused for the board members here to get to know those candidates so please be respectful of of that as we ask questions in such uh board members again the the idea is for us to get to know these candidates to Understand them um I do intend to ask a couple of questions for them to fill in as a part of their uh their dialogue and then um we'll have opportunity to ask some questions toward the end of that um I will try to keep us moving through so we don't get too stagnant
none of us want to be here till midnight so just again more opportunity to get to know each another um thanks to each of the candidates for being here that are here I'll run down the list in a few Minutes um I know having been on the the school board that um in a position on a board whether it's CAD board School Board that's uh can be an interesting uh position um so first of all thank you each of you for your willingness to uh to serve our communities so thank you for that um let's
see I know uh our appraisal district school districts have a lot in common uh first of all we've got to operate within Whatever the the state rules and guidelines head ly for us that's part of the the game we play um as you you both everyone knows the legislature has contributed less to uh schools over the last couple of years um and uh have created some uh interesting dilemas for districts across the state um so uh I guess first of all uh I think Spencer was going to give us a little bit uh about the
district before we jump In so thank you Craig all right so I just wanted to um give a little bit of information about the district just so that everybody um is aware of kind of the situation that we're in just kind of reset uh where we're at so again we've had multiple de uh de demographer reports so that we can tell where are we going are we being responsible with what we're doing and then how many students we're we're having coming in and so one Of the things that is prudent of that is that that
is related to proactive planning instead of reactionary planning and so by us staying ahead of of the growth and staying ahead of the challenges um it actually helps our students and our and our staff and teachers and so uh one of the things that we look at on the September 2024 demography report is that over the next 10 years there's an average about 5.3% of growth estimated and so this Year we're actually outpacing that already we're at 6. 5% and so what does that mean on a on a student basis well on top of the
191 students that we originally had estimated we have an additional 40 that have come in that we now need to make sure have a safe area um to educate um have room for them have desks for them Etc and so um it's just one of the things as we move forward just keeping in mind that the students are coming it's not um when but it but It's if and so looking at our growth um we've actually experienced about a 38% growth over the last six years as it relates to the fast growth districts um that
was that was brought up earlier we are um one of the fast growth those districts we're actually the 23rd fastest growing District in the state of Texas um and so when you look at that um on a percentage of growth basis um that is kind of why we're in the situation that we're in and so we're projecting Over the next um three to five years that we're going to need you know three to five campuses if we continue um to experience the growth of of this nature and some of the challenges that we're faced with
is that the legisl has not done us any favors um not given us uh any funding it's actually on record in in the Senate uh finance committee meeting that the deal that was on the table last time was the best that it could get and more than likely we're Going to get something a lot less than that this year and so um keeping that in mind yeah inflation has gone up uh over 23% um and so our buying power has been reduced with a on average the entitlement per student it's it's exactly the same and
so we're being asked to do more uh with with less and so over the past two years what we've done uh when I came in in 2023 2024 and then this year we've cut over 20% of the non-payroll budget and so this doesn't Impact any staff it's our goal that we wanted to keep all the positions uh all the staff all the salaries uh for for them and so there's some challenges with that and so um if we have any reduced funding where where is that going to come from um if we want to keep
teachers employed if we want to continue doing step raises potentially doing raises in the future um there's only so much money that goes around under current law and so um those Are some of the challenges that we're that we're faced um one of the things that I wanted to bring up um as it relates to um growth percentage so I was brought up earlier that there are four um uh fast growth districts in the county and that is true um and if you look at the percent of growth by the number of students that they
have over six years as it compared to their overall Ada uh you can see the percent of growth there in the middle um one of The big things and by the way Godly is is yellow um you can see we've grown 821 students uh and that was as of last year that's actually now up over a thousand because we're now over 3200 in enrollment so when you look at the percentages um if you add up all the percentages outside of R Vista which I'll talk about here in a second um that is pretty much what
we are experiencing in growth um as one ISD so the way that fast growths work in the state of Texas Is if you're growing more than 250 students over a certain time frame then you're coded as fast growth now you could be high fast growth low fast growth Etc and it's all based on the number of students that you have coming in so while other districts might have um 10,000 15,000 students they're bringing in more District excuse me they're bringing in more students um and so they're rated higher on a a tier basis but on
a percentage of growth Basis they're actually um if we're looking apples apples the percentage of growth is not the same as what we're experiencing I mentioned uh r v earlier so it says 28% there um but I did a little bit of research and if we go back to 2008 um they were actually at the same level that they're at now so they experienced a large decrease in enrollment and then now are are bringing that back up so um that means uh outside of of Godly ISD all these other Districts have capacity and have room
for the students and so again that's one of the challenges that we're being faced with is we have the significant growth and we don't have the availability of of the room and so um again just wanted to to point out there and then also um a lot of times it's it's brought up okay well what about like size uh districts and so if we want to compare ourselves to other like siiz districts in the state of Texas um that's all fine and Great but we're not the same as anything else and so if you look
at other like siiz districts that are similar Ada to us um you can see out of um all of those listed there four of them are actually declining in growth so while they have a um per debt by enrollment or per debt capita um piece that might be lower than us if we look at the the growth of enrollment um by a percentage of um the debt by enrollment that's that's really what gives us more of a driving Factor We can't just look at you know one thing and say hey we have um an x
amount of debt per enrollment but we need to look at on a percentage basis of growth what does that actually look like and so again just wanted to to bring some of these to light um that way when youall are discussing when we're talking through some of the um things that that we'll talk with the public tonight just wanted everybody to have a good frame of Reference thank you sir all right um let's see so Mr Golding you would uh care to to start us off um I mentioned uh give you a couple of questions
again our perspective is school so uh um as you introduce yourself can you then talk a little bit about how do school funding factor into the the calculus for appraisal um and then what's your thoughts on the uh how the state uh funds not not again part of you Introduce yourself first but then just kind of keep those questions if I need to repeat I'm happy okay uh I'm Dwayne gy thank you for letting me speak tonight uh you have my bio I'll quick summary I am a native of Johnson County grew up here left
and came back when I retired came home uh you can see what my specialties are I've been business executive retired as a business executive Running what we do relatively small companies 1500 employee size companies so I've been a executive in high- techa I started out in math and computer science and uh spent a career in the Information Technology field and wound up running some of those countes we reside here along with our three sons and their wives and most of my grandkids that aren't in college are Here but uh most of them have graduated and
moved on that's my background I've had pretty pretty nice career now I'm a goat Ranger so uh regarding the school funding uh you know the the uh property tax system how you speak to the whole system and not just a component it's a kabuki Dance nobody knows how this thing works I I spent a good deal of time on the phone with uh assistant director of property tax division comp controller's office I find it interesting that the chief appraiser doesn't know all the how things work Downstream she admitted me she doesn't know how things work
with school funding I also had an opportunity to talk to Omar Garcia which is I guess one of the acknowledged experts in school Iing had a lengthy conversation with him and we're going to we're sponsoring a presentation by him and his colleagues coming up here about three weeks or so uh I'm not an expert on school funding but I do know that we have we have to comply with state law and we're complying with state law and trying to serve both the taxing and the taxpayers we're finding that's a real Difficult balance as you can
imagine uh but that's that's our goal to balance the two last year when we started out the big goal was transparency no one knew what was going on the board meetings were effectively closed to the public they were open but nobody knew when they were they held during the day uh so nobody showed up we changed that we changed the website we're very Transparent with the all the informational website somebody mentioned taxpayer liaison officer they're required by law to have the T and they had one it wasn't documented on the website no one knew about
it and that monthly report of the T always said nothing to report we changed that we have a UT the uto their monthly report can show Whe it actually assist the taxpayers they don't advocate for the taxpayers what they do is they assist they sort of advise you need to do this you need to do that so we've got an active T this serving the taxpayer and it's our intent if I'm reappointing it will be my intent to continue with the transparency issues the accountability mentioned about the budgets the expenditures we have uh pushed pretty
Hard the cad has cooperated with us very well and they have made the cuts that they need to make and so we've cut nearly a half million dollars out the budget comeing here for the C and that's money that you guys as individual taxpayers don't have to pay that's money that you can keep it Godly in your ISD budget anything else I can answer any questions well at this point thank you Sir okay um I would like to walk through the rest of the candidates and give them can I mention that uh some of our
candidates have conflicts had a medical emergency Amy lingo had a work emergency Brandon pots had a family function thank thank you for the opportunity to speak to we will have additional questions in a couple of minutes uh but if you don't mind we'll we'll walk through and let the other candidates speak and then we'll come Back with some additional questions very well thank you thank you sir let uh next Mr cooch good evening thank you for the invitation come up here I as I heard Dwayne say I believe we have packets on all of us
but I will just tell you that uh I have uh served a number of Masters I've worn a lot of different hats uh in my day I know I'm mold some people accuse me of having been friends with AB Lincoln but that's not true I'm just telling you uh but I uh I've been a working journalist both broadcast and and Print in fact I love this media presentation that you had tonight my last teaching G public education was setting up the uh broadcast journalism program at Legacy High in Mansville we uh didn't quite have the
funding to do uh to provide them with all the Cool Tools of course those tools Weren't available available back in 2008 when we did that so we got it done by grant funding but uh but I I love seeing kids get involved in programs that that are Innovative like that I uh was a corporate executive as well uh served a lot of time as an administrator of nonprofits I was the uh CEO of the Central mle and multiple listing service in the early 80s that's in Baltimore is the uh largest in-house mls in the country
at the time I've Uh uh I this I I spent 30 years in public education as a teacher coach administrator have my superintendency certificate uh and most of my career my educational career was SP in Mansfield a high growth District uh so I get that that piece uh I will just tell you that my interest uh in serving as one of the cad members is I feel like I have a foot in both camps to be honest with you if if if you see this as one Camp here and one Camp There I I see
it as we're all uh in this situation and we're trying our best to serve everybody uh certainly the uh people who pay the bills pay the taxes uh need advocacy uh as do school districts as well uh I know that you're doing the very best that you can do for the students here in Godly and that's the case for every school district uh in in Johnson County so at the end of the day I hope uh that I can Earn your support whether I do whether I don't uh I want to wish you all the
best in your endeavors and asan said I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have well so the same two questions that I asked uh Mr Golden um I realize you haven't been on the board but give me your thoughts if you have any there on um how does school funding factor into the appraisal and then your thoughts on how the schools are funded by state well it has been my experience Uh having been in the business uh schools are really caught in the middle to be honest with you uh the way theun happens
for schools in the state of Texas uh you are called upon to uh do so much and then but but then there's there's restricted funding there uh there are uh rules regulations things that you've that you that restrict how you can go about the job that you're doing uh So so you've got some serious challenges with just basic State funding uh of public education as it pertains to how it interacts with uh the position that that I hope to serve as the uh C boards uh their their total function is to try to make sure
that property appraisals are fair that's it purely and fair and uh and I I believe transparent helps an awful lot with that I will tell you this there's nobody that I know and I've been Involved I've met in the last year a lot of folks there's nobody that I know that is uh is in any way trying to uh uh be anything but that is trying to undermine our public education in any way but there is there is this area in the middle where there's it's it's hard to mesh things together so I'm hoping that
uh we can keep the lines of communication open and that you are able to meet your responsibilities with our help and at the same time we are able to Advocate both for you and for the taxpayers U I don't know if that answered your question it it does thank you sir okay I appreciate it bet we may have more questions for you in a few minutes thank you for the invitation to be here that thank you I'm going to walk through the next uh number of candidates Mr Diaz I'm not sure if he's here okay
um Miss pate See her and then Mr Gibson don't see them okay they're missing out on an opportunity all right so I know we had several questions um Mr Golden would you mind coming back up and um I I do want to set the ground Ru right up front if Mr Golden feels that we are getting into CAD business we will not cross that line um we have to be careful and uh protect him as well so he's going to have that Latitude we'll ask questions but if we Hit too close to home and get
into to CAD board business then we will stop that I'll do my best to answer your questions thank you sir I appreciate it um so uh Jeff you had a question go ahead sir Hey sir I it would it had been referenced multiple times about a budget cut that you guys were able to cut about half a million dollars from the budget to get a baseline on that budget what those budget cuts were like how I I was trying to read some Information on it and I saw an increase in budget from 2022 uh 2023
budget an increase to 2023 24 an increase percent increase in the 24 to 25 budget but maybe I'm reading it WR so now we what I was referring to the budget that was submitted to the board we cut that roughly 55,000 makes total sense okay now I get it yes sir I have a quick question um it looks like Godly ISD paid the Johnson County Appraisal District um in 2020 $162,000 and then 2025 is projected that we'll pay 287 to the cad board uh that's a 77% increase over the last 5 years and but yet
you know the school district has to cut our budget so I was wondering if how does that budget increase that we're having to pay you guys is that affected by the budget cuts that you're talking about yes you know the budget historically the budget was submitted And approved uh usually with no Cuts I but I understand I've only been there l a year but the budget that was submitted this year in May and by the way we're all new to the board we didn't know we're going to see a budget in may I come from
corporate I've never done budgets in May my budget year started in October November and they show up at a board meeting with a budget it's like why are we doing the Budget do I cause that so yeah save save a couple of dollars U so we didn't understand the budget cycle and once they submitted that budget we started asking a lot of questions and and we've been asking questions about some of the expenditures putting away from budget and probably the most obvious example we asked one of our members tonight that couldn't be here go a
Retired Bank president and she's now in a second career I don't know why you do that anyway uh she and I are asking questions about why are we paying the bank Fe $55,000 like the bank Fe and long story short uh they said well we have a contract I said why don't you go to the bank ask them to wave your fee that's so we have the contract I said ask to wave the fee all that say is No we'll fulfill the contract and we'll find another bank guess what we save the taxpayers $4,900 a
month for the rest of this year next year we won't pay Bank fees we looking for we're going to give that bank and other Banks an opportunity to bid for the business and next year we're will pay F that's $60,000 that's part of the budget so question for you um I know there was this Um probably call it the wrong thing but uh the plan to free rates years um or or Praises not rates Praises let get the word there um so how do you view that with uh the fact that there are areas that
are going to continue to grow in that three period um does that not seem to uh provide some form of penalty um for those areas that do continue to grow well I'd be happy to come over and speak With you in more depth but in a kind of a nutshell if you really read the reappraisal plan we have safety nets in there right if this isn't working we trigger a real appraising okay if Godly gets out of compliance you do real appraisal get you back in compliance so the way the cont controller office explained it
to me Godly won't lose a dime to stay funing and we won't let that happen because we will Trra we understand that we have to fund the schools we have to fund the county we have to fund the cities everybody's got to be funed but what we think is that one of the St a little controversial I guess I can was that appraisal should be raised only with clear and convincing evidence it shouldn't be I think shouldn't be a Kentucky windage it should be based on solid Evidence so that's an example but we we have
the safety nets in there if you have a real appra as public document page 19 in fact if you read page 19 you've got 95% of what you're interested in okay thank you sir no other questions Mr I would just like to applaud you in opening up the cadboard meetings I know the first cadboard meeting I went to um a year ago we were having the public had to stand Out in the hall and we couldn't even hear the cadboard meeting so um I can Tes that it was not very open to the public so
I really applaud you guys in getting a bigger venue um opening that up posting those agendas being transparent for the public I am a huge advocate for open government so I thank yall for doing that with the cad board well that was one of our goals and we we've had as many as 80 people come to our CAD board Meetings so we think you done pretty well that thank you I'm not going to get real close to it um just something that you mentioned when you were um doing your introduction when you got started um
talking about how y'all have saved $400,000 and you had said just that um that's be can stay and help the school so how does that help the school well The the uh CAD is funded by the taxing entities and each taxing entity and I don't know the details how this works but they send funds to the cab and it's based on the size of your budget no your tax base so every taxing entity County the city the school districts they all fund the C that's want I say we when we cut those budgets that's money
you don't have to set C coming in You were referring to some saf that are in the re reappraisal plan um so if it appears if that appears that the school district school district is going to lose money how do we know that you're going to reappraise like I mean it's it's not it's not legally binding I mean you know the old story yeah trust me I know lots of old stories no what if the comp controller comes back and says We're out of compliance regard the board will vote immediately to the current board it
may not be around I don't know the board will immediately uh trigger a real appraisal for The Godly properties I'm not talking about compli I'm talking about loss of funding like if we start seeing less money and we're going to be looking at cutting teachers jobs because of our loss of funding that we have historically Gotten uh how are we to know that you guys will call for a reappraisal the appraisals are done based on market value by State ball technically they have nothing has nothing to do with f Central Appraisal District's mission of state
law is to appraise it Market B we can't technically can't stray off of that to help or hurt any one Person that's that's to answer your question Christa the way that our taxes work is we set the tax rate and that's a calculation that we do based on appraisals so if the appraisals have not gone up then we can raise our tax rate if we need to raise revenue but we don't want to raise our tax rate why I mean you yourself have been like adamant about not raising taxes none of us want to raise
taxes so why would we let their let their pad board ta lower their tax Rates and then us just have to turn around in tax I they're not lowering the tax rate they're they're freezing appraisals unless there's clear and convincing convincing evidence to raes appraisals in my opinion this makes us be more transparent as a taxing entity with what we are asking of our taxpayers because we have to raise our tax rates for the revenue we need and we're not blaming appraisals going up every single Year it doesn't affect our funding it our rate we
can adjust for whatever Revenue we need because it's a balancing act and it's a um it's not fair to the tax taxpayer who has you know I have a $300,000 home and my neighbor has a $400,000 home that's soon to be sold for 500,000 and his value is the same as mine that's not right why should my taxes go up when his value and his property is more valuable why shouldn't they pay more the dollar amount that They're going to pay in taxes is the same based on our budget and based on our tax rate
tax the same for everybody you're you're correct we we have some anecdotal evidence that there's differences in appraisals similar properties we have we're initiating an effort bring in an external consultant to do an assessment of all the processes uh that are followed by the cab and make sure number one they're Compliant with state law they tell me they are I don't know we want a consultant that's with expertise come in tell us they're compliant with state law and we're asking them to look for any inequities that exist and their appraises do we have a training
issue do we have a data issue do we have a system issue we have a bias issue hope to God we don't have a corruption issue so we're going to do that and we're going to get A the goal is my goal is we have the most Innovative most efficient most effective CAD in the state of Texas to the extent we can with the state la which may not be as easy as s is there a mechan will there be a mechanism if um truly property value increases in a year that a triggering mechanism that
will automatically reappraise that or is that something the school district is going to have to talk To the com troller to talk to the C to get that adjusted don't talk to comp talk to those call us call me anytime you want to I am wide open for any issues or problems we'll address it as much we can and the other thing I'd like to say she's partly right about tax rate the appraisal the system if you look at it and it it is very complicated I can't T to understand it but certainly can't Explain
I call it a kabuki dance like I said the one thing it does one thing it does it funds budgets in the end the budget will be funded whether it's about tax rate or appraising or state funding or what it will get funded I don't really have another question but I do want to say I think what you guys done on the catch board is amazing work don't discredit anything You've done um it was all improvements that needed to be made um as a taxpayer I'm very grateful the decisions I make sitting up here when
I'm on this stage I have to forget that I'm a taxpayer I know I answer to taxpayers but I personally cannot think about myself and what is going to be personable rewarding for me have to think about a the children our district is legally bound to serve every one of them that walks in the door we Don't get to pick and choose every one of them that walks in we have to we have to educate them and the teachers that work here we have we have to answer to them as well as well as all
the taxpayers I get that but my number one priority is always the children closely followed by the the teachers and so you have understand where our concern comes from that if we lose any more funding we will be faced with possibly Having to let go of teachers and we aren't going to let that happen um those are jobs they're important to our community they are important to our children we can't teach them without teachers in the class that's right the kids have to come ver you know I know that the cadboard is absolutely in a
very tough position in fact that they have to keep in mind what's good for the taxing entities as well as the tax payer taxpayers and we're in the same boat It's just a different vote in the fact that we have to we have to try to please the taxpayers and take care of our teachers and students so we're actually very much so alike and I I hope that we can all work together to fix the funding issues and the taxing issues all work together yes absolutely there's one more complication that you didn't mention state law
you guys have regulations laws you have to comply with we do too and we got to work together to Figure out how to get the best outcome probably the hardest complication so Mr Golden you and I spoke the other day about the state mandated State directed change within the board expanding from certain number of members to a larger number do you mind walking through that just for first of all this audience and the fact that it's live stream anybody that does have last fall when we came here we we were advocating for a position on
the Board U I thought I was going to be appointed if I got appointed a two-year ter it's only been a year and I'm back turned out it wasn't two years the state legislature changed the law they did a number of things one is they expanded the board so there's three taxpayer elected board members which took seat their seats in July I think it was I'm not sure I think that's right July and the tax assessor collector which is obviously collected became a voting member of the board in July so the board effectively expanded from
five to nine people in July in addition that they're going to stagger fouryear terms so half the board will be reappointed reelected every two years to serve fouryear terms so we're in the midst of that transition that's why you had to put a One up again here A year later and then I talked to our CAD attorney uh when the ballots come out there going to be as I understand it two positions for onee terms three positions for threeyear terms then we'll want that put us in the two-year cycle of uh reappointing re-election to four-year
terms so that's where we are I don't know if that makes any sense At all but that's what I've been told thank you for walking through that again for everybody's benefit appreciate that does anyone have additional questions Mr Gold thank you again thanks I appreciate you being here thanks again thank you again for being here Mr St can I say one thing yes sir uh I've met with some other folks a couple superintendents and so forth one of the things we have to do my opinion is we've got to stop the we They stuff we've
got to start working together as a team the school districts the cities the county the cad we all have to pull together and we that's the what only way we're going to fix the problems that we all face so I invite you to call me if you have concerns if you want I'm retired if you want to meet me for coffee on a Tuesday morning if I'm not wrangling goats I'll come meet you for coffee but we've got to get to a point where we Work together we've got to stop the walls between all these
entities and the cad and the everybody else that's involved thank you for the time appreciate it yes sir thank you thank you again I appreciate everyone's time um I was just gonna say for Mr cockroll specifically just because I kind of resonate with you when you're talking about your history uh in education that's exactly where I come from as well I've got the heart for education and background for it so I appreciate that you're soone to serve in different capacity but I I just want to just second Miss heer's sentiment about how I mean I'm
up here just wanting to tell y'all all everybody like we're all taxpayers up here we're all hurting we're all whatever but just really I'm hoping with your internal knowledge of education system again same thing that's what I want to BR to the table I'm said It from day one I'm not the person that's going to be able to explain all the complicated complicated Finance systems that we have but I can be there as an educator so I'm just asking for you to try and remember those days when you didn't get to advocate for a raise
for yourself you get to take the pay that you're offered right and do what you do and you put in your personal money and I mean there's just so many things that teachers on a day-to-day Basis put in extra for and that's just something that again as she said like we're all here fighting for the students and the teachers and also we're we're in that like you said you did this you know it's like that I said the same thing we're all torn about it so I'm just imploring you if you do get that position
that like everybody else you can keep keep the boards in mind up here that we're just doing what we're working within and I appreciate that mayre I I will say that uh retired my wife and I both retired 30-year Educators in 2011 uh 5 years ago we mov retirement home a place to retire I say and uh not why got recruited by clevand school district and is teaching that she is a she she C her special she needs special education GL and teing I have the impath that that never Goes away just but I I
do want to suggest to that if we we all read the same keywords I think there's there's change head for all of us probably starts in Austin and and we're all going to have to navigate this together and I just reinforce what Mr said this is this is going to requ cooperation we just have to work together in order to to serve all the constituencies you serve we serve we all serve but thank you and I want to I want to agree with You I I really appreciate first of all want to Echo what you
said up here we really appreciate all of your work I mean I I think we all want taxes to be lower and I I really love that what you what you just said we a big part of this conversation does need to happen down in Austin I really hope that I know that we can we can collaborate and we can work together we can cooperate and we can maybe help that happen down in Austin because that's where the real change Needs to be because Mr booing did point out that we're Bound by the system that
they give us and we don't like it either we really don't like it we we're blamed for it a lot we don't like it and we would love to change the system um for the better so thank you you two for coming here we really appreciate it I just wanted to say that thanks again appreciate all Mr President uh Mr sson was raising his hand could we allow him to ask his question during the Workshop well that does go against the uh the outline that we did provide for primarily intended between the the candidates and
for the board um so I I guess if there's a question that want to be written and passed along to a board member I would accept that yes noted thank you I appreciate it thank you all right we're going to move along back into our regular business um with the uh business item number 8A the consent Agenda I'll move to approve the consent agenda as listed I have a couple questions thank for being here my questions um were over the check register so I'm going to a second yes ma'am um I've noticed several entries for
diesel services and um a while back the the district hired a diesel mechanic to work in the bus bar to help alleviate some of us um having to spend money for Outside Services um so uh that diesel mechanic is still ined here correct correct okay and so the services that we're still having to pay outside of our district can you kind of go into a little bit of detail on what services those are sure absolutely so one of the things um with Muse diesel services that's the one that um m is referring to has to
do with the AC um so the air conditioner parts uh of the bus and so um there's some certain expertise that That uh deals with that's not necessarily with um as my understanding the motor side of it and the diesel and so we do have to Outsource some of that um so that we make sure everything's functioning properly and um that it's meeting all the required laws okay and then um there was an entry on the 10th of September for $105,000 plus an extra change for a new or used school bus so this is actually
um since we're The Fiscal Agent for jcssa um this is a jcssa uh bus purchase and so it was approved by their um board but since it's our check register and we're the SSA um then or we're the Fiscal Agent of the SSA okay all right since we're the Fiscal Agent of the SSA it does uh show up on our check registers is it on um and you and I have already kind of discussed this but I have asked that on Our check register for purchases over $10,000 in the future for there to maybe be
just a a small amount more detail so we don't have to have pounds you with questions every month um and then I also had brought up a recommendation that on things that say Campus Student Activity there's a lot of those entries in our check register to maybe indicate which campus so it's a little easier for us to track right absolutely those are those are great points um so one of the Reasons too that we um went to this uh kind of shared commodity piece was that was easier um to digest for the community we push
it out um but I'm definitely more than happy to to give more information as needed and then um on the campus activity funds yes we can make sure moving forward that uh when I code those those are not coded without U the campus on there great great suggestion my last um stat last question and this is more because now that they Are on the website and people can see I want to make sure the people who are looking at the the registers are they're going to see a lot of Amazon purchases and so you know
I asked the question um about Amazon purchases and how that that happens because I know in my own home everyone in my house is has control oh well I pay for it but they can put a they can put an order in and and it comes right to the house and it's super Easy and it sometimes isn't the most economical option um and aramy cudle gave me a great example of how that's working now um so can you explain that just for people who might be watching at home or other people who might also be
looking at to check register and see a lot of Amazon purchases yeah great great point we don't want boxes to show up every single day like uh does of my house um so specifically um one of the things that I Implemented uh this year with Amazon um is that I'm requiring two other quotes um to go along with that purchase and so um that way the uh staff knows that that okay if we're going to purchase from Amazon it's sure it's going to be quick right it's going to come to our door but we want
to make sure that it's the most economical so um I made sure to implement that this year and um they weren't too happy about it at first but I think they understand kind of why now And they've been great um making sure that that it was there and there's actually been some instances where they' realized that oh I could actually get it cheaper somewhere else majority of the time Amazon is is the cheapest but I think it's important that we go through the mechanics of that to uh to make sure we're we're spending the funds
wise on thank you for that by way you're welcome all right just a quick question just for the public can you explain uh The reasoning and also the plan for the deficit of 1.7 million in the general fund and the 82,000 for the interest in thinking fund just um a little bit of background on that absolutely so uh when you as a board uh approved this budget back in uh August for the 2425 year if you remember this is going to be our transition year to the June fiscal year end um and so that would
be the budget if we were on a full 12 month uh plan but um after this month after October Snapshot occurs I'll be bringing next actually next month in November an adjusted uh budget amendment that will show uh true 10 months and so it actually is going to end up turning to be a surplus um in both the general fund and uh The Debt Service fund thank you for explaining that okay I have a motion by Terry sorry one more thing um one moment I have a second by Marissa any further discussion yes sorry I
just wanted to Make sure that Faith made the changes to the meeting minutes from myself and Terry okay thank you that was it any further discussion all those in favor passes unanimously all right and next we have uh 8B the ordering order the authorization of issuance of Godly Independent School District unlimited tax refunding Bond so this was the presentation that Was provided to expens do you care to cover any yeah thank you Craig so this is again just the board action of us requesting the ability to U price uh so that we can save uh
the the money on that refunding and so uh Mr Robert gave a great presentation um I'd be happy to try to answer any other questions that you have but um really the the main piece of this is that uh we're going to be able to to essentially refinance the bond to save uh interest and save Taxpayers money I move to adopt the order authorizing the issuance of Godly ISD unlimited tax refunding bond series 2024 as presented and recommended by Jeff Roberts and I'll second have a motion by Terry and a second by any further questions
or discussion all those in unanimously next we have the second Discussion and possible consideration of the district Improvement go ahead oh okay um good evening yes I am coming to you this evening with our district Improvement plan our second reading um last month I brought to you the goals the three goals that we've set for um the year along with the objectives which are the pillars that were tied to that specifically looking at how we're tying each of the um seven Community- based accountability pillars to our big goals um those goals were to increase or
to show growth 90% of students show growth in um literacy and numeracy across the district um to increase our communication of our Cass goals and pillars um 70% of our communication across the district and then also to implement some procedures and increase the um the use of many of the services and um resources we have available under the safety and Well-being um this month we have I have submitted to you um an almost complete plan there are a few pieces I'm still trying to add on But it includes the strategies that we are tying to
the goals and objectives and so I just wanted to highlight a few of those strategies to show you things that we're doing this year um one of the primary goals when you're writing a district plan is to keep it simple the more things that you pile on the harder it is To achieve them so um the first Big Goal can you go to the next slide I don't know if I have power or not um one of the primary things that we're doing this year one of the biggest moves that we made is to implement
what's called a look ahead protocol across the district um we've had design days built into our campus calendar for three or four years now and we've used those days for a variety of things trying to make sure that we're doing professional Development planning parent conferences um this year everyone in the district every single employee has a small group that they're meeting with um we have a protocol in place where they are looking at the specific standards that they're getting ready to teach they're looking at data um if they're not in a instructional setting they have
a different protocol but they're looking at what projects are coming up they're looking at how they're communicating the Projects they're making a plan so um we are setting aside one half of a day every month to make sure we are going deep and understanding what's coming up in our school district um some of this came from changes in laws regarding lesson planning and a few other things but we really felt like tier one in instruction the very first instruction that students get is the most important thing that we can impact in our school district and
if we're going to see Growth in 90% of our students tier one instruction has to be solid across the district so we are implementing that um we've created a data dashboard where we're capturing data beginning of the year middle of the year end of the year I know this was a question that you all had about how we were going to capture that um we had several great conversations we did get a dash in place and we have captured teacher perception um beginning of the year teacher Perception from all teachers on all students we're done
so beginning of the year data is captured um in addition to our map data eara cbass all the other things that we're doing our cbas um so we're capturing data in several ways but teacher perception data I think is one of the most important ones because that's the whole child the teacher sees all of it so we did get that done um we'll continue to gather information throughout the year and then we'll do Again at the end of the year teacher perception data paired with all the other pieces and we'll make a um determination on
growth for every student and then we'll submit that that to you um over the summer in all likelihood at the beginning of next year so that's goal one um those are our big uh strategies that we're putting in place to achieve that first goal and to meet those first three um objectives any questions about that first one yeah Before you move on from goal one I know we talked a little bit about this the last board meeting um but after pondering on it some more I have a concern that our goal is subjective and not
very measurable um and so my concern is that if I like that we're you know looking at each individual student but I would like to see a measurable goal districtwide whether it be using map data or Star data whatever we choose to use that our growth we have a a goal of Maybe a growth of a certain amount of percentage points that way we have a measurable goal and it's not just subjective in well we saw some growth does that make sense it does but it's a very difficult way it's very difficult to set that
because one point of growth for one student might be significant might be a lot of growth um whereas 10 points of growth for another student might not be much at all it's very difficult to set a single number that's What the state does with the star test saying this is the number that we have to achieve and we're looking at data from several different pieces if we can see a preponderance of evidence that shows a student has made growth from the beginning of the year to the end of the year we feel like that is
the that is what we're trying to achieve I just I don't feel like it's fair for us to for students to set a one single number and say this is what you have to achieve Because sometimes growth is growth if they've made any progress throughout the year that's what we that's what we're looking for and I definitely understand that on an individual level I'm just speaking to the district and us as a board as where judging how our district is doing as a whole I would like to see a measurable goal so districtwide we see
you know like I said whether you want to use map data or Star data whatever data you think better that data um it would Be more measurable to say we want to grow two percentage points or or whatever it is and then we've had 90% of growth that every student um or as a district I just am concerned that this goal is not measurable if that makes sense okay um any other questions about goal one okay our next goal is for us to increase or to have at least 70% of our district communication include the
language of Seabass and I believe we Will be well in advance of this by the time we get to the end of the year um this is catching on like wildfire we have had um several of or we have created hashtags for all of our pillars and so you'll see that in many of our um postings on social media our emails that we send out um as Mr K said he's revamped our meeting agenda so that it's um being laid out our our district meeting agendas they're being laid out with the pillars um emails that
you see Coming out parents Square almost everything I've seen come out in the last few months has the language of the SE Bas pillars in it I think once it's become part of our um just our language and what we're doing it's it's going to be it's everywhere um as you can see that poster that's up there we have one of those hanging in every District administrator's office it has the pillars and the benefits so it's just right there in front of us whenever we Um craft an email or when we have a conversation with
someone so um I really think 70% is going to be easy to accomplish but we will definitely see more people who understand and use that language by the end of the school year and that was our primary goal is just that everyone understands the mission of our district any questions about this goal all right and the last one man this one really surprised me how much stuff We were doing um and this is not as much about us doing more things but more people taking advantage of them um we already had most of these things
in place but people didn't know about them and so I'm very impressed with what our safety and well-being department has set as their goal for this year because they want people to actually engage with all the resources and services that we have available um some of the new things that we've done this year um notes from the School nurse she's been putting out a monthly newsletter telling people about things um Miss Evans has started putting out some videos um about uh the risks of Sentinel overdose and about um what bullying and conflict resolution and she's
putting more and more um pieces out and we are just being very intentional about letting people know what resources are available how to access them and what benefits there are to being um taking advantage of some of These pieces so I just think we're going to see a huge growth in the people engaging with us in our safety and well-being department and so um their goal is truly just to put procedures in place and communicate and so they're doing that already but and I think we're definitely going to see an increase in usage of all
of the the resources that are available any questions about that goal not a question but a comment on it I did notice the the broadcast messaging um regarding naal prevention month over the past few days so uh while the gold may not have been uh accepted in as part of the district Improvement plan I see you guys working so thanks for leading for excellent thank you okay um again this is our second reading we typically do three um there only changes that will'll be going into this from this point forward will be just updating goals
where we are Updating how much money we've spent or how much resources we've used um in different areas um the goals won't change the objectives won't change the strategies won't change we may add to them if we feel like we've already accomplished this one we may add another um but for the most part the plan is set so we can if you want to approve it this month you can if you want to give it another month of read through and come back next month we can Approve it then either way is fine any further
questions from the district Improvement plan thank you Miss CL I'm and then I think the next one is our first iteration on the campus Improvement plan yes and this um again you will notice on all but one of the schools the campus plans are again goals and the objectives they are tied directly to our district goals they've simply gone through and changed it from A a district goal to a campus goal so the growth in literacy in numer across the campus the increase in communication um of the seab bass language across the campus and then
the implementation of the procedures to raise awareness and raise um participation in the health and well-being and then they're all also tied to the same SE bass pillars um the one area and I know this won't come as a surprise to you but Mr flood did add a few additional goals and they were very Intentional for his campus and they were timely they were things that I think um were were great additions he did go in and add a um a goal to increase specifically the Master's level um on the EOC tests to increase by
three percent or three 3% for English one English 2 Algebra 1 biology and history so really working on that end of course to get those Master's level um up additionally he has a goal to increase the attendance rate at the high school To 94.5% they've been doing a lot of hard work at the high school to just raise kids awareness of how important it is to be at school and and what the attendance rate is and how they can help so um they're working on that and then lastly I'm so cold I'm about to my
teeth are about to chatter um the last one is that for the class of 2025 that the students 75% or greater will obtain a college career or military Readiness or That the students will get a college career or military readiness of 75% or greater so again those are specific to the high school I think they're good goals and I think they're things that came out of his needs assessments that will be um very timely so when we present next month each campus will give you the specific strategies that they are going to put in place
to address the goals on their campus and then we'll um go forward once One more again we can look at next month and decide you want to go for a third reading or not um you do have access to that spreadsheet so if you have questions um I think I linked it in the agenda item that you can just add the questions there and I'll address them as they come through and then we'll go from there thank you I have a quick question I'm sorry yes um I noticed in our board book The Seabass pillars
were there um were we going to talk about that at the Next meeting I just had a question on that Cass I believe we're signaling next month on Cass yes okay thank you I'll ask that next month absolutely thank youy I I have a quick question I'm sorry yes the the district goals it looks like they funnel up to I'm sorry the campus goals funnel up to the district goals which TI it in C well if I if I'm seen this correctly each I opened all the PDFs and it looks like each district I'm sorry
Each campus has a tangible measurement of how to measure that growth yes for each campus level which then Feats up to the district level yes so to tie into to a point that was brought up earlier I guess I was able to find a tangible measurement on a camp yes yes ABY yes thank you hey thank you it's been a while since we've seen monthly updates on our ABA it used to Just be part of our meeting in the superintendent reports can we can we have that in our monthly meetings again thank you okay I
believe this covers the first portion of our agenda um time is 8:15 we will uh go to close session um we will discuss um section 551.071 discussing purchase exchange lease of or value of real property uh section 551.074 discussing Personnel or hearing complaints against personnel for for for e for for for e for For e for for for for for for for for for for For for for for for for for for for for e for E for for e for for for for e for for for E for e for for e for for
for for for e E e for for e for for for for for for for For for e for for for for e for for for all right we come out of close session at 8:55 P.m. have no further action so do I hear a motion I have a motion to by Terry in a second by Marissa a j no