foreign [Music] I'm very honored to do this video on a complicated topic the pregnancy denial but in reality I would like to call my presentation differently I would like to give the title how to perceive unperceived pregnancies you'll see why I prefer that terminology I am oguzomei I'm a medical doctor a prenatal psychiatrist in lausanne in Switzerland pregnancy denial as it is called or unperceived pregnancies if you're a professional or if you're just from the lay public you might encounter this phenomenon simply in the journals look at at what time any time you look at
the publications of journals and here's what you can find this is what we try to do at one moment soldier who gave birth in Afghanistan returns to Britain she was combating in Afghanistan nobody knew she was pregnant and she gave birth in Afghanistan mother of 20 gives birth on the toilet after three doctors missed her pregnancy and thought she was constipated instead another one here this cannot be happening again meet the women who found out they were pregnant moments before giving birth unexpectedly not once but twice and to Capital mom who didn't know she was
pregnant delivers a rare set of twins you might just check the internet and find similar news anywhere in the world in the language that you would like let me try to simplify things for you because there are different faces of this phenomenon I think it's very useful to see three different presentations of the phenomenon the situation one I'm just reading the slides here the situation one is a woman may be pregnant yet her pregnancy may not be perceived neither by herself nor the people around her before the 6th 7th or eighth month it's important that
neither by herself nor the people around her she may develop many ordinary signs of pregnancy Within several days after the recognition if she gets to understand that she's pregnant if somebody notices that she's pregnant then she becomes an ordinary pregnant woman so this is situation number one this is not a situation that you will find in the journals of course Situation Number Two is more complicated a woman and the people around her May identify a pregnancy only as the baby is being born that means for example the woman might go to a local hospital with
stomach ache thinking that she has another condition and she might discover that she's delivering a baby if the baby and the mother are well this surprising situation maybe a rapidly forgotten by all as if nothing special happened I can tell you that this occurs rather often I have seen it myself in maternity Wards colleagues just you know joking oh yesterday we had somebody just came in and delivered she didn't know she was pregnant hahaha you know this happens situation number three is more tragic a woman may give birth to a baby and may still not
perceive and identify what is happening especially of course if there's nobody around her to help her move out of that State of Shock if she's at home or somewhere else alone that baby might die from obstetrical reasons just remember that this is not a usual delivery right or there has been no follow-up the baby may die from obstetrical reasons or maybe killed by the woman but the woman is probably unconscious of what's happening and is not aware I should say what's happening and these may be automatic behaviors well that is where it gets all complicated
and very tragic of course so just remember these three situations probably the phenomenon that we that has been called pregnancy denial has been known three through centuries we even have countries who had you know some disposition legal disposition criminal legal disposition uh avoiding severe pains for women who killed their babies this is a complicated you know historical subject to research but if we look at modern Publications we find the first publication in Milton the publication that I have found are probably more gifted researchers but Milton at 1985 identifies nine case reports himself in the literature
at that point and published eight additional cases of total or nearly total denial if we read K in 1990 the initial impression of the clinicians or the professionals was that I'm reading the majority of neonatal neonaticidal oh different different difficult word mothers are unwed poor have denied or concealed the pregnancies conception they frequently give birth alone and dispose of the baby as an abortion that occurs to late now that is a little bit judgmental and I don't know if there were any proof of evidence to think that that was the case but that was the
initial impression on these women the first modern study or publication I should say is a naturalistic study by Christoph brzinka who was basically a practicing obstetrician in in Austria brzinka a wonderful person uh collected 27 cases of women who did not know that they were pregnant until term or during the delivery that was an important naturalistic study and he already observed in a more careful epidemiological way that in this naturalistic 27 women these women were healthy and otherwise normal women and he wrote at that moment that there was no need to place the child with
foster parents just because this denial had occured because these women were capable of taking care of the child if they were if they got sufficient help yes Wessel in Berlin was an obstetrician not from the University he has done a study I think that was for his MD thesis or something he has done a one-year perspective study in the whole Berlin metropolitan area and he has collected in a prospective way 29 462 deliveries nearly 30 000 deliveries and singled out 94 women who gave birth after real you know and realized that they were pregnant after
the 20th week so partial or total denial or total unperception and he confirmed only 62 as being denial of pregnancy there were different situations this study is a very solid epidemiological study that we personally I wanted to replicate many times but couldn't because I'm not as a researcher myself but anyway I think these numbers has not been put into question and what the rodent study tells us is that partial unawareness or partial denial if you like that means between 20 weeks and up to birth a woman realizes that she's pregnant after the 20th a week
and before birth it is 1 in 475 and total unperception is these numbers are complicated let me simplify it so it is partial 1 in 500 and total one in 2500. this is not an exotic rare situation this is very very frequent and what the Berlin study showed us and other studies since then show us is that any woman can present an unperceived pregnancy many studies confirm that 80 of these women are in a stable relationship 50 already have a child any age of fertility high or ordinary socioeconomic status not necessarily adolescent immature cognitively impaired
or psychotic so do you think that we should call this phenomenon pregnancy denial pregnancy denial you know even in in French in my language it sounds worse she has done a pregnancy denial we say in French as if the woman had done something whereas we know we don't know anything about what has happened in this phenomenon we don't have a scientific explanation my and I shouldn't say my and the opinion of a group of colleagues is that we should not call this like that it is judgmental and it is not helpful the we should rename
this phenomenon as unperceived pregnancy which is a neutral and respectful term unperceived pregnancy what is on perceived pregnancy it is I'm reading you the slide it is a woman's lack of awareness of being pregnant after the 20th weeks of gestation if you discover you're pregnant at 18 weeks then that's not an unperceived pregnancy it's just conventional but after the 20th week that's an unpreceded pregnancy it can be partial or total as we said but this unperception should be combined with the lack of awareness of the people around the woman around that woman partner Partners who
make love regularly might not be aware that the woman is pregnant family mothers mothers of the mother colleagues friends professionals including medical doctors who have examined these women another person a passerby even if a passerby said hey aren't you pregnant that would lift the non-perception and we have you know anecdotes of real cases of women who were pregnant up to term sometimes and have not been perceived as being pregnant in prison by prison guards they were in prison by television workers and television audience because you got stars who have done shows and they were pregnant
and we even I think that's a case from brazinka we even have a woman who have who has delivered after being several days before in a nudist camp totally nude unperceived pregnancy is not a concealed pregnancy where the patient knows that she's pregnant but she does not want to show it or say it it is not on the other side it's not it's not a psychotic patient who is unaware of her pregnancy whereas her family or her doctors are aware that she's pregnant this is not an unperceived pregnancy you might call this a psychotic denial
of pregnancy why not in unperceived pregnancy the non-perception is shared how can this be I mean uh but we don't know and this is what we should we should research instead of you know having great theories about it we should research this how can this be you know one characteristic of human beings is that human beings can imagine things that don't exist like States Banks or money like Harari tells us but it's very interesting to see that collectively human beings can ignore to perceive or can fail to perceive things which might exist and this even
changed the huge changes the human biology of the woman well let me just get to the point not lose myself in interesting discussions what are the consequences so if we confirm the the prevalence as being one in 2000 2500 pregnancies a total denial diagnosis per pattern as we should say it is estimated that one in four of these deliveries of total denial or total on perception would be out of the medical context at home or elsewhere consequences will depend on if the mother is alone or not if the mother is not is is not alone
then the environment helps her to realize what's happening and it's not easy but at least it's it is it happens in some way we have clinical cases on this of course but if the mother is alone then the non-perception is not lifted and the patient probably goes into a dissociative state in the traumatic sense with unpredictable Behavior and the death of the newborn might be caused by the neglect or the consequence of unpredictable unpredictable Behavior putting the baby in a garbage or in the Deep Freeze things like that just to give you an idea in
France in 2021 uh we had 740 000 births that gives nearly 300 totally unperceived pregnancies discovered at Birth nearly one every day and of these pregnancies probably 74 occur out of the medical context at home or elsewhere and it is estimated that one one in five of these might cause or might end up by the death of the baby seven natural deaths maybe because baby falls into the toilet and things like that and seven uh you know baby killed or the mother is accused of killing the baby uh as a consequence as a consequence of
her behavior this is the reality in France in you know in any country if you have just you know these are the numbers I will not read them to you in a hundred thousand births you just estimate and we probably have two deaths per 100 000 births in any country this must be checked of course by more systematic research so yes Wessel has said there seems to be no other condition as dangerous to the mother and fetus that is being ignored across the literature uh as pregnancy denial before ending this video I should say that
you know I'm talking to you from Switzerland I don't know where you are there are many different countries in the world Africa United States Canada Japan China turkey the legal framework changes some countries might severely condemn these mothers to Decades of prison other countries may be more uh understanding I had the chance to intervene in several uh uh you know trials we have international colleagues who uh through the Marseille Society or other organizations try to help these mothers you know in perinatal Psychiatry there we have been working for decades so that mothers with depression or
anxiety don't go unnoticed and don't you know live sad lives without any help I think we are kind of successful in doing that but pregnancy denial or unperceived pregnancies especially total and with medical legal consequences is a territory that the whole world and the scientific Community is ignoring and these mothers are victim of a phenomenon of which we don't understand the character and I think we cannot allow science and you know Human Society legal the police and you know rights of women and everything we cannot allow this to happen there are too many tragic situations
they're the only way to get informed is through the journals and you know how how does it call it English you know just you know you know dramatic things in the in the journal whereas we should have a global Observatory to to um to uh to collect all these cases and get the necessary research admit just to end this talk a medical phenomena with the same frequency one in two 1500 like help syndrome on up to date which is a medical website you have 10 000 Publications in up to date you don't even find the
topic pregnancy denial and you have only 50 to 70 Publications on pregnancy denial this is unfair for the women for the babies that we lose and for the whole for whole families and communities we should work to change this thank you for your attention [Music] thank you