[Music] [Music] hi Austin how are you hello excellent facts so today's episode is the origins of Science and this is one of those things that is one of the most important events in history I think you could say the invention of science it's competitive for the most important event in history and people often Bunch it together with the Industrial Revolution But they're actually diff there are different historic events that occurred for different incentives although they're connected and the biggest thing for this video is less so implicitly about science itself more so disproving disproving historic and
cultural narratives we have related to science that make it impossible for normal people to understand what actually happened because there's three or four different psychological narratives that We got really incorrectly and the only way to see the reality is to debunk each of those and what are those psychological narratives so let's go through each of them one at a time the first is that we have no idea how the rest of humanity perceived reality secondly we don't realize that science itself pulls on Ancient and uh ancient and medieval roots that we've forgotten about and thirdly
um actually there's four thirdly That science and religion are not actually at odds and fourthly that what we're practicing now is not science and that we don't actually use science to guide our society anymore and so if you look at each of those four you'll see that the invention of science you need to study those four things and in the process of seeing those you'll be capable of understanding why science developed how it made the modern world where it stemmed from and um what that Means for us today so the first of them is understanding
how the rest of human history perceives the world where for example we forget how much of the thing things that we believe as completely obvious are in fact particulars to certain historic trajectories we have an example of this and this is the simplest thing the idea that physical things exist this is an idea that stems from Aristotle developed the concept That there are physical things and that the spiritual concepts are fundamentally derivations of originally physical things and that sounds OB obvious but in uh Indian platonic and in uh Islamic philosophy the spiritual is first and
then the physical world is a mere is a a pale imitation of the spiritual so in lots of world philosophies things that we view as completely insane are just taken for granted where in Indian philosophy as an example reality is an Illusion spun by the gods called Maya or Gaya and thus in Indian philosophy as an example until the British Empire it was seen as immoral to make the peasants wealthier because if the peasants got wealthier then they would suffer less unless they would need religion less and the purpose of life is to read lead
lead to religion thus bringing the peasants out of poverty is immoral and selfish and materialistic because you're shutting them off from reaching religion So I'm going to let that sink in because that sort of thing is an example of how different a worldview can be and interestingly enough Indian philosophy and history isn't even the furthest removed from the Western tradition because they both originally have an Aran route so with the Indian example it's and the different frames I guess a good way to think of it is they're following the logic of certain conclusions so if
You set something as your highest value then all sorts of weird yes situations can arise out of trying to attain that like like an AI movie where the AI goes crazy because his mission is to protect expers then he goes uh out of his to weird conclusions to do that and I was going to do I was going to bring this up later in the video because we've done that today and it's one of the biggest parts of of the downstream effects of science because I'm going to argue that The the invention of science although
it is inordinately positive there are very key negatives to it and an example of this is that there's a great book called the knowledge Machine by uh the knowledge Machine by straven and it's about um the origin of the scientific method and so this is very important because he talks about the iron rule of Science and the iron rule of science the way the scientific method works is that you Create a uh you create a test where one of two results creates an outcome that you have two hypotheses then you have an in a test
where an empirical result can pick one of one or two hypotheses an example of this is that if you were to say is America a wasp oligarchy let's compare income range by American white ethnicity and when you find that Italian and polish and Jewish Americans are the highest rank of white American Income and then British Americans are below Average you can see that America is no longer a wasp oligarchy like it was a century ago so you have two hypotheses one that America is run by a small Anglo-Saxon Elite another is that we have a
more Diversified white elite and if you look at income ranges that can lead to the H the second hypothesis that we've seen a democratization of power and wealth in America across all white ethnic across multiple white ethnicities and so you could the way science works Is that you have a test and the empirical results for the test dictate uh dict uh which of these hypotheses you pick and this is incredibly good at certain things and the point that the author makes is the thing science does the best is it's an arbitration method where there have
been many examples of this over history where the shift from neonian Einstein physics they had a and this is Another thing the book talks about where they had inconclusive evidence to move from uh Newton to to Einstein's model and then they purposely hedged the evidence to move it towards the Einstein model because the scientist involved had a bias towards internationalism because it was during World War I and the British were fighting the Germans so he thought if we can prove a German philosophic thesis then we can show that war is bad and we Should love
internationalism and physics is one of the fields I've studied the least but as far as I can understand Einstein's model the thing with physics is I meet lots of people who are way smarter than me in this discipline and they uh and they have vastly different opinions on physics and so I don't really know what opinion to say but as far as I could understand Einstein's theories have trounced Newtons or they've created a different field but The thing with the test that there's multiple multiple points I'm trying to illustrate with this the first is that
science is a testing method the problem is that you can't use science to develop a moral code and you can't use science for contextual understandings where we have tried to shove science which is limited by its power where science is so good because it creates an arbitration method and also creates incentives to gather data because what the scientific Method does really well is that it gives an incentive if we establish empirical data to decide between different thesis then that's what we reward and thus the modern world has this huge amount of data that we can
use for different stuff and it's good for it's good for process of elimination but science is really bad for contextual understandings or human life or um things that require uh more complex Motion in more complex fluid systems because Um because it is by its own definition limited and when science was developed there was if you had told the people people at the time that this one thing will become your entire formulation for all of human knowledge they would say that's insane anyone in the development of science if you asked them this will become your in
several hundred years from now your entire society's mental formulation for how you relate to the world with your only form of knowledge They would say yeah that's not going to work and they were right because I guess that's where we get up to Chaos Theory yeah where the overly deterministic scientific view of the world started to run up to its limits in the 70s or 60s this is something that I've I want to make a video about but in every single every single discipline we hit up against a wall that we can't really use science
to predict and then the obvious answer that I'm shocked no one has Reached is that in almost every case the pre-industrial world already had an answer that question so in physics uh physics both Einstein and Newton's theories have been pushed up against their limits and there's too much stuff that we can't predict we've hit a point where every single honest physicist is like I have no clue what's happening um and so physics for genetics we hit this wall of DNA where DNA is so complicated and there's so many Different sub interactions that um that uh
it's impossible to predict same thing with psychology and human nature where you hit up against Freud and Freud can't explain everything then history and politics you hit up against this um the and throw on top of this just blatant lying the blank slates a lie equality is a lie progress is a lie we'll get to that later and so um something we'll talk about later is the shift from actual science to scientism we we're Science isn't even our arbitration method anymore we just make crap up and then try to rationalize it but uh we'll get
there and the um so in each case we've tried to P using purely science to the Limit and the and Houston Smith who's one of my favorite authors he's a uh religious author and he said science is like you know uh there's these broadcast lights where if you've got a show there's these huge lights there's these lights to make huge Beams of singular light that hit uh that you use to like show on the crow or show on sign on the singer he said Sciences like that where it's very good at um it's very good
at basically shining on a certain thing and understanding a given issue but then you have to relate to the entire night sky as a human being and so that's why you you need to have tradition or wisdom or uh religion and art and those things because even art we don't think of it this way art is a way Of thinking because it's a it's figuring it's related to the subconscious which is why for all of us there are pieces of art that are the most important thing in our lives because it spoke to something deep
inside of us and I find a lot of science is the attempt to avoid wisdom because wisdom is uncomfortable because the thing with the first of all wisdom is not fair and it's also heavily hereditary so if you acknowledge wisdom you have to acknowledge some people are Born innately innately vastly more intelligent than others then on top of that wisdom is also gained through studying the past and it's also gained through uh and life experience wisdom comes through both books and beatings and um that's not something we want to acknowledge because one of the great
moral tabos of our society is you can't say there's a positive to suffering in our culture you will never find someone Even indirectly say that suffering is builds character and that you have to suffer to grow strong and how does that relate to wisdom because it's more like trial and error and I guess does it introduce a level of uncertainty where it doesn't um apply to kind of the neurotic focus of of science where you can't demonstrate wisdom um almost every issue I will say with science here is not an issue with science per se
it's an issue with the Society that used science so science is itself it's pretty Unapologetic and it's very good at what it does um the issue is trying to use science for something it's not and people there there's multiple factors going on here and I I I'll jump to the fourth point where we don't practice science anymore we practice scientism and I think the peak for the legitimate application of scientific research on a society was Around World War I um because around because if if you actually study science you find there are lots of very
uncomfortable reality that we can't stomach as an example you can't say that you're a scientific society and then have men and women say that men and women are the same that's there's just no basis for that men and women are physiologically different they're neurologically different they're psychologically different they're values Wise different same thing with biological race has been completely proven scientifically you can ask anyone who study biology and genetics and they'll say that or that um or that there's lots of weird scientific research we haven't integrated so there's we've proven that plants have the ability
to read intentions where you can modulate the blood pressure the the pressure on a plant as you change the things you're thinking about the plant And then the plant can see whether or not you thinking good or bad thoughts we've run this experiment a bunch of times and it's it's pretty consistent and that's one of those things where if we actually studied science we would have to Grapple with that but we haven't and now our real God is equality and then we rationalize scientific we make up and rationalize scientific results to get the end result
of equality and that's Been the case ever since World War I and the book that I've recommended uh before in the previous show was the pass the passion of the Western in Mind by tares and it's the best philosophy book I've read where he said the West today we lost faith in God and then with the world wars we really lost faith in science so now we have no arbit method for our moral code so we just make up and is it a coincidence that we lost science swiftly After God oh they're they're completely connected
because we'll get there but I mean one of things that always shocks me is that the like the current rule in class they pretend that they have any validity and I try to I'll ask them okay so uh how do you rationalize your moral code explain to me why you have validity explain to me why the things you say have any meaning and I don't understand why no one under looks the philosophic underpinnings of our society because This stuff isn't hard like these are relatively simple Concepts and our society's ruling class and our ruling philosophy
uh and it's just stuff I I've read these thinkers they say reality doesn't exist power determines reality humans are infinitely mutable um and that once you gain the government you can control everything I think to myself that's so disastrous if your Elite believes that something very very bad will happen and those are easy Concepts to understand like I grew up in a I grew up in a rural mostly Christian place and among the normies I grew up with they could they were capable of understanding theological Concepts like they would talk about like Concepts in Christianity
that are more advanced than the stuff I just said and there's this huge psychological blockage inside our minds from realizing how silly the things we are the things we believe are and a lot of It was done with the magic trick of just changing the language because most disagreements are definitional so you have an intuitive understanding of of what something is and then people end up defining it a certain way and then you can say you know I don't care what you call it just this thing that we're describing let's define it not use a
word this phenomenon like you describe science as actually you know a simple um useful concept and they've Twisted that To the point where they use empiricism like a cudgel but they're only selectively choosing correlations that enforce either um the oligarchy or some uh ideology of equity so a lot of it I think is just they're manipulating the words and that's manipulated our our mind and they've kind of claimed evidence-based and almost made it a bad word when it it uh doesn't need to be just because the way that they're abusing it as a called to
Authority I Call myself a radical empiricist and what I mean by that is that if it works it works I don't really care why or how it works and the I and I the irony with empiricism is that if you are an empiricist you look back over human history and you'll realize wait every society ever needs religion the societies without religion fail and people people sub people subjectively have religious experiences and that's something you need to keep track of and People subjectively have emotion and uh relationships to the world and communities and that stuff and
what people did is they said if it's not perfectly replicable it doesn't exist but and that works for certain things like my friend Kurt ditt always likes to say that for law that's completely necessary and I agree for legal systems for business contracts for that stuff you have to operate off replicability but most of the Human Condition itself is not replicable and so if you want to operate on that for the entire Human Experience you're just going to end up in a completely numb and meaningless society which is where we are and uh it's it
it's I I believe in subjective empiricism where if if if you feel an emotion or if you have a religious experience it is what it is write down what happened and then you can relate back to it and use it as a tool of analysis and then you can study It for its predictive value where you just look at the experience for what it is you look at how you feel about it and then you subjectively see what the symbolism is and this is what Yung and Freud did and it's the underlying nature of psychoanalysis
but one of the things that the tarnis book talks about is that there's all of these philosophic and also with um radical empiricism it's incredibly easy to unify science Religion and philosophy at once uh because you've integrated the entire Human Experience through a combination of the subjective feelings through empathy and then the empirically what happens and then you test all these things for how accur how how how well they work um and and the thing that Taris book said that's really interesting is he said there's this huge um romantic push over the last 200 years
against the cold impersonality and Materialism of industrial civilization but then what happens is that those people can never systematize so that over the long duray of the Industrial Revolution what happens instead is that the forces of bureaucratic impersonality just gradually grow larger and larger and squeeze out everything else because they have been institutionalized so they don't even need to think they just constantly keep moving forward while Subjective stuff can't be institutionalized on an industrial basis so when you lose your ability for wisdom and objective uh striving for new objectivity then the institutions just run rough
shot yes there's no alternate I see it as like a real estate where uh the big firms like Black Rock they buy up more and more land and if you have a small real estate firm one bad house can screw you over and then what happens is That when you're the scale of Black Rock nothing is bad bad enough to stop you so you just keep growing and then the bad luck of smaller real estate companies adds up and it's Matthews law the Rich get richer and the poor get poorer and so over industrial history
basically standardization had a scale advantage and you would short-term break you had short-term push backs of subjectivism like n or the hippies or uh like I don't know grunge or the Nazis or Romanticism Or any of these things and then each time they push it back a little and then the force of managerial bureaucratic sterility it keeps pushing for word um because there's it's it's it's there's nothing really to fight against because it's a system you can't fight against a system although I try and what is so what changes that Dynamic um is and that's
a product of losing uh the ability to be generally objective in the Culture so this trend can't last for much longer because the underly ing end point of all of this is the collapsing birth rate because the birth rate is the canary and the coal mine that something about modern society is innately intolerable enough that people won't have kids and so I see the the collapsing birth rate as a sort of Silent strike by population saying our lives are uh not fulfilling enough so we refuse to have kids and then the Industrial system can't survive
that because it demands constant growth to maintain itself and so the one thing it can't handle is a declining population and so we will have to go through um we well we're going to have to go through a social renovation process and I an example of this is uh in Japan they're they're trying to in Institute a 4-day work week you know you know the Japanese are Workaholics because they need people to actually like each other and so They're like we'll give you an extra day off if you have kids and so I'm expecting more
of that because also as the population's grown the value of human life has decreased and at the same time um as the value of human life has decreased the power of the system grows but then as the population goes down the value of human life Visa the system will increase yeah I mean it depends how you're conceptualizing value because you Have the general growth like is it like um one person as a percentage of value or the value generation of an individual person combined uh yeah but I like um and then mate formation's an interesting
indicator because you know there's a lot of arguments about inequality you can talk about um parito distribution or when is it too much inequality when everybody's conditions are getting better Etc and the lack of ability Um for mate formation kind of cuts through that as the relevant indicator it's like okay yeah maybe you can have different percentages of inequality and it's not a problem um but if you have mate formation breakdown then there's going to be people looking to change the system I was in the phone with merik today and what I told him is
um the Boomers can cope about anything except the stock market the Boomers can be like oh yeah people aren't having kids oh Yeah people or make less money purchasing power is lower um mental health is worse and then they point at the stock market and they'll be like yes but at least the GDP number goes up and they've been able to default and say that the complete failure of every other institution except GDP go up is fine because it allowed the GDP number to go up the birth rate stopped the G the GDP number from
going up so there's nothing they can cope about and so that will Once the Boomer can no longer cope is the day our age ends yeah um I think I mean I don't know about the exact correlation between with the the GDP and our current population Trends or when the timing of that will hit but I think already politically the stock market has stopped being an end all Beall economic indicator for what makes people politically happy so because everyone knows pumping the the big stocks is not Helping the general economy it's kind of like increasing
real estate you know and stocks is good for people's portfolios or Boomers portfolios but it's not actually helping the economy that's true for us as conservatives because we're not the ones getting the government printed money um but so for the left uh the the line go up as really a scop where I have friends in politics who tell me a huge amount of democrat policy is just doing money printing so they can Shove their buddi money so they're going to print a crap ton of money for quantitative easing and then give it to us Aid
give it to their constituents give it to Democrat cities give it to various corporations built off the payroll so what the the right is moving past this and what I see for the left is they're like oh yeah stock market stock market go up number go up uh here's $10 million uh gay charity fund of Uganda and so they're using line go up as this Uh cover to just shove their buddies money right it's exactly it's a upper middle class welfare system and it also if you for example ban stem cells or make these pharmaceutical
treatments 10 times artificially more expensive that's going to boost the GDP because we spend like 28% of it on medical care but that's not actually improving people's lives it's the same as buying uh tanks and bullets and yeah you get the GDP boost but You're rationing um so these numbers are not yeah good indicators always there's a great book called the growth delusion by David pilling and I read it in high school and it was very uh it was very important for my future mental development because I'm kind I'm an anti-corporate rtist um and what
the the books about how the uh how the the numeric uh how our enslavement to GDP per capita stats is are are weird and it has these bizarre Outgrowths we're an example of this is that Kenya has six times the economic size in reality than on paper because uh third world currencies are not processed at the same level as first world currencies and so an example of this is that if you buy a burger in America it can be like 15 bucks and it would be 10 cents in Kenya um or and so it's counted
a lot less as a transaction that on top of it a lot of the Kenya economy is done through family relations or Village Relations where money is not spent or the black market and so if K if if Africa has six times the economic size of what we think that's a huge detail or it talks about how the US government purposely pushes this enormous really inefficient medical bill spending and an Chang for that because it it grows the number and they can tell voters they made jobs and what they're not saying is how much was
wasted to make those jobs right and on the other hand you if you Did actually go after the oligarchies and open up markets you would see GDP drops of a lot of big corporate stocks and I don't know what the time Gap would be but ultimately you would see GDP continue to go up yes like even faster so GDP can represent it's not good things bad things it's just not a perfect indicator yes so to go through the different points um the the thing with other societies Having completely different value systems you notice it more
so when you see the threads that science did pull from and another great thing the Taris book covers is he talks about the shift in Western philosophy between revering the Ancients and then not reading the agents where almost every every single thing you admire or respect uh in our society was built because someone read the Bible or the ancient Greek Classics and then they were trying to imitate it And so uh American democracy was built off the the Greeks and the Romans um the our entire social structure was built off imitating uh the Bible um
and so many ideas you wouldn't even think about uh do ultimately stem from the classics and when you read the founding fathers and that entire the French Revolution the French Revolution was the invention of leftism and they were trying to model their constitution off these bizarre I Of this like single city state in the aan that they said was a Utopia and you know you know uh utopians always have to default on there was a society the size of a village where this worked and um they would wear the Fran so these are early leftists
people who are basically Communists and their their biggest fashion statement was wearing uh this Fria was this country in western turkey at the time of the ancient Greeks they they weren't even Greeks and it's Crazy that it was a society where the average educated person was literate enough to know specific details of fashion about Fria and the point I'm trying to convey here is that we see science the start of a new age but in reality science was the culmination of a much older tradition that stemmed back into the ancient world and so when you
try to figure out the factors that resulted in the creation of science you're looking at fundamentally the Repackaging of ancient and medieval philosophy and then what happened is that once science worked they translated it into a SC a a more science fiction mental mold and there was a Tipping Point I would say in the 1800s when people thought science has made us so great that we no longer have to read anything our ancestors said and that's what unmowed us from reality and became so dangerous because once you can't cross reference yourself against history You're just
making stuff up and the philosophic schools that science comes from is they were pulling from Aristotle Plato Christianity and hermeticism so for each of those the ancient Greeks and Roman had their own logical tradition that wasn't science and this is something people think people like to imagine that the ancient Greeks and Romans founded science and then there was a dark age and then the Renaissance showed up and then people Started bathing again and then uh theyed reading again and that narrative is completely incorrect the way you should see it better so is that the Greeks
and the Romans are a completely different civilization you should see the Greeks and the Romans more comparably to how you see Islam or China than like an extension of Western Europe where they were these collectivist slave societies that worship pagan gods and they lived in Clans and uh and um so they were a Completely different civilization although we get a lot we have a lot to be grateful from from the Greeks and the Romans and as we said in the previous video their concept of of logic was that they didn't want to apply things to
the physical worlds they didn't have empiricism because you could find logically correct arguments and then from said log Ally correct arguments you could extrapolate to figure things out as an example of this is that Aristotle Said that heavier objects fall faster than lighter objects and uh then in the Renaissance an Italian thinker went onto the Leaning Tower of Pisa and he dropped two objects of different weights and they fell at the same length at the same speed and so in 20 seconds he disproved this thing that had been believed for thousands of years and that's
a great example because it shows the big flaw in the ancient Greco Roman worldview where they had highly Advanced logical systems But they didn't apply them to the real world because that was seen as ungentlemanly where their entire worldview was the aristocracy could think and operate in complex Concepts but then they couldn't T they shouldn't touch the real world so the Greeks and the Romans actually had the steam engine and Computing technology where they had these highly Advanced gear mechanisms that operated as computers and they didn't have an industrial revolution Partly because slave labor was
so cheap but also because they didn't want to have to deal with the physical world and it's important to understand why they believed that because the Greeks were trying to adapt to firstly the invention of geometry where geometry was the most important thing in Greek philosophy and the way mathematics works is that you develop these abstract principles removed from reality and then You use abstract principles to figure out physics equations so they were trying to do that for the entire Human Condition and also we have proof that the Greeks were using psychedelics and this is
what Plato stems from where they would use the Elian rituals or the uh the orphic rituals to go to the spiritual and then they would talk to these abstract spiritual archetypes and so what this means is that the Greek worldview uh viewed all philosophy and All thinking as purely abstract and then the more you sued the abstract with the physical the more uh the more you were uh defiling it but the problem is that this created very this meant that they could never break through the actual science or industrialization or empiricism because these are all
based on touching physical things and they assume the flaws of and inconsistencies of the physical world were actually messing with their logical Models and throwing them off the course rather than correcting them and it's a great example of Incorporated knowledge because I was thinking about the Apple example and uh Tower of Pisa Etc and it's just hard for me to conceptualize that people didn't know that objects fell at the same speed yes because I just figured there'd be so many accidental examples where you could see that but maybe the the differences are are small You
me accurately so theic presupposition takes presid over the poor measuring of empirical reality they actually pulled from a different philosophy that got them to believe that but let me go to the bathroom first excellent um pause hello so what you said leads back to the second philosophy I'll talk about which I think is actually the most important for the development of science which is hermeticism and hermeticism was an Ancient Egyptian philosophy that went back to the Pharaohs where if you look at 3000 BC and the the architecture in the pyramids of the Spinx it's still
hermetic symbolism and when the Greeks conquered Egypt they codified it into a uh into a set moral code that was used that later went into uh into Islam in Western Europe and to simplify hermeticism is alchemy and Alchemy is supposedly about making gold but what they were really trying to do is that Gold was symbolic for the Perfection of the human soul and they were using this coded language they wouldn't be accused of heresy although the church did support hermeticism Herm it's funny that hermeticism or the worship of Hermes was widely accepted in early modern
Europe in a very Christian Society where in the Catholic Church they said hermeticism was like Sena or Plato or Aristotle who were pre Christian Pagan philosophies that were in line with Christianity so The papacy F funded hermeticism every major Court in Europe did and the way the hermetica works is it's the underlying philosophy that you're trying to increase life charge and then through you increase life charge through suffering where all of hum all of the world is a unified Consciousness and the world has the ultimate goal of making Humanity more like God and through the
process of life you learn and then over over time you learn to be more and more Like God and this is one of those things where it's hard to overemphasize how much hermeticism influenced modern science almost every single figure in the development of early science also studied the hertica where Galileo as an example he the idea that there is a sun and then planets revolve around the Sun and there's thousands to millions of planets that's a hermetic idea and so in kernus and Galileo in Bruno Bruno was the first thinker and he was very overtly
a hermetic when they were saying this they weren't saying it because there was scientific evidence there were say not at least at first they were saying it because there was a previous religion that said it and they were trying toti like stick it to the previous they're trying to say that this previous religion is correct or Newton a third of the books he studied was Alchemy and every principle in Newton's Laws of Motion stems to the cabalan and I'm I'm understating this this is true of um this is true of of basically every thinker of
that time period and the concept of evolution itself where the the alchemical transmutation of forms is that you face suffering and through facing suffering you gradually transmute into something better through the gradual process you evolve from one form to another and what happened is that hermeticism Was very popular in the 1500s as was mysticism where every this is thing we've wrote written out as well every single one of the early scientists also studied the occult and they didn't see any barrier between religion and Science and thus they would um thus they would uh like Newton
wrote as much about angels and demons as he did about science same thing with John D and so they saw science as finding the mind of God so Their goal was through science to def find God and this is actually how science started in back in in the medieval period where the goal for science was to reflect the beauty of God's creation you look at the Islamic world the reason the West developed science and the Islamic world didn't is that in the medieval period the Islamic World thought all of God's truth is contained within the
Quran and thus there's no reason to study science Because you can study the Quran and the out the external Earthly world is itself self fallible and then in in Thomas aquinus Thomas aquinus is a very important figure we've forgotten he lived in the 1200s and and um he made the he made a logical system that connected Christianity with with the Greek thinkers and in the process he made the philosophic principle that became dominant in the West that Earth is a reflection of the divine plan and thus by scientifically studying Earth you could uh find the
mind of God and learn to honor God more greatly and you had this debate in Europe in the high medieval period between dun Scotto the dun scotus school that it's basically the the Muslim opinion that you should submit to God and then the Thomas aquinus school and they were both fighting against uh more rigid more rigid pre-established uh Beliefs either just completely worshiping the Greeks or worshiping the previous Bible without critically thinking about it and then the almost every single underlying toolkit in the scientific method was developed in the 1300s by monks um where the
William of aam develop development of the developer of aam's Razer he was a monk an English monk in the 1300s Roger Bacon another English monk in the uh 1300s and so every and this is thing I can't I can't Overstate is that you can't have sence that Christianity because all of the founders of early science were Christians and um and it's predicated upon Christian philosophy where the Breakthrough to from the Greek rationalist tradition to modern science is that the Christian value of humility demands you test things because if you want to apply Christianity to science
it's we don't know what's true because We're humble so let's just test everything to see what works and so that is the the Touchstone you had to combine the Greek rationalist tradition with ch Christian humility to create science and the greatest funer of science into uh the into basically now was the Catholic Church where the Catholic Church act and this is we really got wrong with the narrative the Catholic Church funded and protected and guided science for most of this time period and it was only later That they became a scientific reactionary Force where Galileo
the Touchstone example but Galileo and the pope were friends and the papacy funded his research and um they Galileo got in a bad spot with the church uh due to complex Church politics uh relating to a variety of other things right he was not even purchased because of this supposed um conflict between science and and Christianity which it was completely Church politics So that that's a great cultural myth interesting how pervasive it is um I guess as part of the propaganda um and then you get into um natural law with aquinus right and does that
does that relate to there's kind of a parallel between the study of physics and the study of Sociology where you look at there's certain patterns to human nature yeah and then there's certain patterns to the Universe uh like within physics uh and both of these Concepts are connected to the idea of God's words versus God's works and is that kind of like the problem with Islam is they were stuck in the the words but not the works as in acknowledging the universe that God created has certain rules that can be observed and discovered yes that's
correct uh great point you made there and natural laws such an important thing and our society can't understand the concept of natural law but it's actually a pretty simple Concept it's that the Universe has certain rules and it rewards you for following the rules and that's obviously true um like if you work harder that's generally better men are generally physically stronger than women there are these general principles to the universe and if you follow the principles you get rewarded and our society rejects that although it's obviously true um and natural law there was this concept
that there was a Unified theory of how the world worked and over time we used science to dissolve any concept that reality exists until you hit the 20th century when every I I've read multiple philosophers say the great issue of philosophy is that there's no argument for why reality exists and I thought you idiot of course course reality exists if you need an argument for why reality exists you're a nerd just shut the up and just cut cut the nerd man um and It's the whole thing with postmodernism where they're like oh my God how
do I prove reality exists okay if I kick you in the face you're going to feel pain because I kicked you in the face that is the nature of reality if you don't think reality exists if you don't think reality exists you have not faced enough suffering and or youve faced too much suffering you're coping but um the the church science division is interesting and it's largely an outgrowth of the 30 Years War and that so the religious wars in the mid 1600s they created a very first of all they got rid of mysticism where
uh the connection between mysticism and science um that was a side effect of the ends of the wars of religion because Europe was so deeply ravaged by these religious wars that there was there were several subconscious assumptions the West made that we haven't tackled but are super important the first is that religious Wars became socially tapoo secondly the church the religion got sectioned off in its own little ghetto uh where we are a society where religion is seen as purely subjective or purely uh purely subjective purely personal and purely cultural while science gained complete dominance
on how to understand how the world works and then the public sphere and you also saw the separation of religion and uh the church where they became at odds because they weren't at Odds beforehand and that was structured because so the philosophy books I keep reading they'll say that there's the um Galileo K decart access and that this is the axis that separates the Enchanted medeval and uh early modern world from the current world where Galileo found that the world circles the Sun and this was huge because the previous idea is that you go up
into the heavens towards God and then we found that no um the reality is that it's just space out There and this was important because it made us realign how we physically processed the world because we confused psychic space with physical space because what religious thinkers have constantly said is that heaven is above us and that hell is below us and that's symbolic of The Human Condition we have to go we have to choose between good and evil you can go towards good or towards evil and then we literalized that and the Protestant Reformation made
religion Really literal when it was originally meant to be symbolic and then that killed religion because religion can't exist on this literal frame of reference and Galileo did that and the church could have positioned them the church positioning themselves against Galileo was a huge PR disaster they never were able to recover from then under Kant um Kant argued that what Kant and dayart both argued is that you should ignore the senses and that What mattered is What fits in abstract you should ignore the physical sensations of the world and then what that in turn allowed
was just logical arguments disconnected from reality and the biggest issue with modern philosophy is it's completely disconnected from The Human Experience it has no relation you'll never hear philosophers talk about uh culture or sex or history or politics like I was reading this book about burnout and the book never mentioned people are working More hours they're have worse mental health and that stuff he was just saying philosophically through the substructure of studying Kant this is why people have burnout and I'm like no man people have burnout because they're working too much for too little pay
they have burnout because they're trying to figure everything out without actually addressing reality yeah exactly exhausting yeah and so over the course of the 1600s it feel It looks like it looks as if you have something to say about the thing I was saying earlier like I I yeah the subjective versus objective part I just kind of wanted to nail down into that more because it's almost like the um the deterministic view of science wiped out that integration of objectivity and subjectivity and then all we were left with at the end was subjectivity and power
games and it's it's kind of a hard Needle for people to mentally thread that just because humans are unable to be objective about reality doesn't mean um that object objective truth doesn't exist and you have to be able to operate subjectively to get closer approximations of objective reality and that's just a hard mental place for people to be they kind of drift into subjectivity or objectivity at least in our current cultural Paradigm yes I think equality killed a lot of our Abstract thinking and it's funny that as the complexity of the concept we worked with
got higher the mental ability of the intellectual class decreased where we don't understand the concept of an abstract concept where for natural law as an example the innate polarity of the masculine and The Feminine is the most basil level of reality if you can't understand that men and women are different you're completely crazy and This is how I feel a lot of this stuff where uh we you science was an incredibly useful rationalization tool because it created you could have a test and then said test could claim to be objective and then what happened is
that each part of the political Spectrum has been able to rationalize why they are the objective truth because they study the things they want to see and they refuse to study anything else because if only things that we can scientifically Replicate are true then you can make up a bunch of crazy stuff that's obviously not true and then not study it it's a really easy thing to psychologically hack which is why as I said before every corner of the political Compass has at one point or another said they're scientifically true and the lack of an
ability to understand an abstract concept is for example it's clear that moral goodness exists uh it's like you can attain mortal goodness but because You can't measure mortal goodness then they can say it doesn't exist although it's clear that Gandhi is like Gandhi is a better person than Hitler right it and even if people um stop trusting the institutions it's almost like we've lost our ability to flex this science muscle ourselves yeah um and thinking that way and then if you wanted to just like really quickly Define science versus scientism again just to keep our
models Clear about it um so science is the actual testing method science of self is actually pretty spare it's just an empirical testing method scientism is the culture of being the science and so as of now we're almost purely scientistic and then not scientific where uh the whole Co thing of follow the science is that's an example we'd all know that's so obviously uh rigged because any of like we found consistently that CO's not that Dangerous All Things Considered uh and whether or not how much you want to react to an illness that's not particularly
dangerous is your choice um but then the science the only science we were allowed to say was that Co was dangerous and so there was this apparatus that demanded you follow the science and we've been doing that for we've been doing that for for for a while we're in the 20th century this Allure of the science to became our Entire ruling religion although it was stuff that was the opposite of the truth in all reality and one of the points that our society needs to learn that we haven't is that we are the weird outliers
where there's a bunch of things that every other Society in history except us believes that we don't and it's pretty inexcusable that we forgot the things that everyone else in history believes and then we use science as a way of rationalizing it but the reality Is that we is that through science's incredible abilities we grew so wealthy that we gained delusion and then we rationalized the delusion with science we were stuck in the closed loop where you were D correct by definition and examples of this is that equality isn't real genetics determines reality every other
Society in history is religious they believe in God they believe in the spirit world they believe in natural law they believe In uh the nation ethnicity culture art philosophy as an example culture is pretty culture is pretty clearly important even on a materialist basis where where you can say that a culture is someone's identity it's how a society survives it's the operating system but then we could use a very narrow scientistic understanding of reality to um to basically say if we can't study it it's not real and thus uh we can completely ignore the importance
of Culture yeah and it just seems so simple breaking it down I'm wondering like how do people fall for scientism I mean I know I get it seen it but it's almost like you have to remove thought to go along with with certain things and like you said is the fragility allows you to ignore it and not focus on it because you can build up fragility for a time um we have that luxury but it's like it's been 50 years after the death of this deterministic philosophy with Chaos theory that we're still operating in this
manner it's also consistent with the avoidance of uncertainty like the uncertainty of life we try to eliminate all risks so it fits the the bureaucratic element of our um civilization to the point where you're actually creating more risk Etc so I guess it just uh it's like the apples like people not knowing that things the same um different weights fall at the same speed it's just yeah you it's Amazing what you can miss based on selective focus yes it's because we're the last men writing in 1880 n said that um after a century of nihilism
that the West would become a society that prized comfort and mediocrity and weakness and uh stability he said the Society of the last men would be so decadent they would be incapable of protecting itself or having the will to live and it would be a society where uh it would punish great where great men could not rise but at The same time that uh it would be a society incapable of flourish of allowing even normal healthy human life to develop because it would prioritize emotional stability and comfort and that above all else and I I've
thought about that and I when the more I see the more I realize that n was just completely accurate and that we are before anything else we are the last men wait sorry we are not the last Men We Are The Last men right but when we lose all these Qualities and then it becomes kind of easy to to cut through or just a few people who remember how to think to to make a change yeah um and how does Action relate into this does I feel like action is is tied in somehow to um
science and actually uh advancing trial and error and being attached to certain out outomes and moving and taking risk like is there an science an action element that's Missing from the scientism side that is found in the science side science is innately incredibly masculine in that it is purely evidence focused it removes all uh strippings it removes trappings it removes all trappings it removes all context and it's purely Effectiveness he is at its core masculine is doing feminine is being and so I think a lot of the over feminization of our culture is actually a
reaction to the over masculinization of science um where we Have this very hyper masculine so mental model supposedly in our culture and then we attach feminism to the other side of it for us to psychologically balance I say modernity is a combination of the autistic masculine and the hysterical feminine which is the descendant from Romanticism and the enlightenment where what we're seeing now is the degenerate form of the Enlightenment and the Romantic Movement um and the thing with Action is that science demands constant testing in order to work and it's innately very um it's innately
Progressive and it's also innately uh destructive and so what you end ended up with is a social code where the only thing that's acceptable is the disproving of previous thesis so we took the empirism of the scientific method and then warped it into something uh it's the culture of critique where the reason the culture of critique Worked is because it's the scientific empiricism and the complex thing that do you ever find it ironic that the culture of critique came from the exact same society as so the way postmodernism works is you basically say let's criticize
everything and let's be open to all ideas and then let's immediately jump to the most doctrinaire Marxist worldview possible where you can't criticize anything they make the mental jump everything is open To question criticize everything oh wait we have this incredibly doctrinaire theory that the second you deviate from it we're kicking you out right well you get the institutionalized protection and then you get different legal mechanisms reinforcing those cartels yeah so people can't question um the reputations and so that can lead to a paralysis of of actions but it's kind of like it's I'm trying
to relate it to the words versus works and It's like I consider the works like the action um and like you said they kind of hijacked it so we were doing things and then we just started talking about doing things to the point where that became the whole process and you see this with a lot of organizations where it's originally about like a mission and then it becomes about the bylaws or something like the or with the Pharisees where you have like the law is supposed to serve You versus the other way around and it's
like we stopped doing the actual act um you yeah one of the most things modernity believes is that if you have a good mindset you can do anything like the only thing stopping you from attaining complete success is your bad mindset and so if you're not successful it's because you don't have a good mindset and that is just or also that you can just choose to be happy and you Can choose to have your internal monologue both of which are is completely insane like there's no rational deification for them and they actually end up becoming
quite tyrannical where it's you see it in a lot of the class depression of our society where if you're a workingclass white person barely getting by actively discriminated against by the system the system will just say oh you're you're not wealthy because you Don't have a good mindset and they ignore all of the systemic things that have happened against what working white class PE white people um and the um I feel bad that we just relentlessly on scientism because science has done so much good for the world and it it goes unstated or everything around
us has been influenced positively by science between the uh between the electrical lighting between air conditioning Between food between um uh our ability to live in Texas or uh our everything is scientific and so I I I want to express tremendous gratitude to science but at the same time I think you guys already know that and that's a part of our society's mythology I don't feel the need to emphasize it that much here because it's something that's so that's so obvious and it's also saying we're all told from childhood where we're all told from the
second we wake Up that um the reason our society is great is due to science right and that's true if you take it by its literal definition or its original definition which is why it's so annoying and pervasive how words are manipulated cuz we're having this conversation about feeling bad about uh crapping on science when there was no there was nothing ever wrong with science yes and um we just don't do it and and they stop us from doing trial And error and act they stop us from discovering and flourishing and um all these things
on the altar of some weak correlation maintaining a insane ideology or a cartel so the issue yeah the biggest issue with modern society is that there's no rules for uh there's no rules for discourse where I see this online a lot where lots of online discourse is literally just slander there's no benefit it's not funny it's just people slandering each other and That adds nothing to society it adds a massive negative and if you go out online and say hey you guys need to actually have constructive conversations that's the most morally impermissible thing because it's
like you're having a standard for them and just I Society the worst thing you can do is hold others to standards um and which is why we're the last men um and then that's true in the society where I if uh the left just makes up and then when the right Calls them out in making it up they're like oh my God how can you say that but then there's no factchecking mechanism so people just abuse terms and then they just make stuff up and then they'll just break definitions and then put them back together
um and there's just no qualification against it because the biggest thing with our society is there's no feedback loop to reality we just make stuff up right and appeals to the truth get mocked even by the right Almost because we we're so deeply in this environment but and the and I like to say the truth won't always save you but it really it sure can help to have it on your side yeah because there there's an enormous networks of information and people that constantly work to hide the truth they do a lot of work on
it and there there's a reason they do that effort is because it the reality undermines their conceptions and I think we're starting to get to the Point where we can reclaim the language just by distinguishing through this new term scientism and having people have clear understandings of those definitions um to it's a language battle the the the best thing we have going for us is that leftism is a luxury belief and most people in the west are poor now so they can't they can't afford luxury beliefs anymore um huh so I think we did science
Justice I think we covered the whole Arc of science um anything else Austin um just the the four The Arc was uh you want me to repeat that okay first Arc is that societies around the world have vastly societies across human history have vastly different beliefs that we than we do um and then as an example of this most socities in history don't even have a concept of rationality the Greeks invented the concept of rationality and as an example uh if you tried to explain a natural law to a Babylonian they would have no concept
of That because their entire view of the world was that a god Wills something so you give Marduk or you give Tiamat presence so that they help your fate the idea of an objective universe is an ancient Greek concept the idea that the universe is also rationally explainable is also a Greek concept um so that's the first thing that most people in history do not believe the things we believe and in fact our beliefs are very very rare secondarily that um science stemmed or That science stemmed from ancient and medieval beliefs about the world in
that the science uh was actually formed by the Catholic Church thirdly that um that the Divide between religion and science isn't real and then fourthly our our society doesn't use science anymore we use scientism right and the last example I wanted to talk about was um Gene editing and governance because like you talked about with Gene editing where we thought We were going to be able to do all these things and then we realize pretty much every single Gene we mess with creat a a worse result or like a failure of the bology or basically
death because you don't understand the inner working inner workings of that complex system so it's basically it's almost impossible to make an intervention and get lucky um and it's it's similar with uh governance and Central planning where this is this ideology also emerged around scientism And the idea of uh determinism and human beings are make up complex systems so you try and make interventions to that it leads to problems which leads to to further breakdown um and you can illustrate that through biological examples or other things so I think it's interesting that that's that's I
think that might have been one of like governance might be one of the four things we missed with Gene editing and the other examples you gave earlier in Terms of another field that this philosophy has corrupted it's interesting with uh when I was a teenager I predicted that with genetic engineering we'd hit up against some kind of wall like that that there's some natural principle that would stop us from being a being able to manipulate genetic engineering uh to the level that we believe we would um because for everything there is a cost and so
I Imagine let's say if we do genetic engineering to raise the average IQ of a person 20 points is that it would come at a cost of so many other things in their in their life and you don't even know which Gene leads to an IQ increase it's not necessarily the one you think it is because everything's interrelated in a complex system you know we could solve this by encouraging people with good genetics to breed more yes some sort of natural uh breeding well that's That's what Gene editing has gone into in the plant world
is they're making breeding stock so they're not breeding to the final qualities but they're using very minor interventions to create a breeding stock that then is naturally bred for the final result the people who were doing these genetic surveys probably have very good genetics if they're smart enough to to do this sort of thing and I'm sure they don't have kids there's a there's a degree of uh There's something deeply hilarious about that yeah there's there's a big correction mechanism I mean yeah we talked about the population problem there's a disaster there but um hopefully
if people can act again free free of bureaucratic fussing it'll be cheaper to have kids and they can start doing it early so one of my friends likes to say that a lot of leftism is people with good genetics telling people with bad genetics that genetics doesn't Matter uh the like the biology department at Harvard is people very good genetics and then they're telling like the entire rest of the population oh genetics don't matter don't worry about the uncon about the innate bias the innate Advantage we have it's like a Hollywood actor saying that money
doesn't matter or something yeah um I'm trying to I I have a joke there I'm just forgetting it um so okay um do you have a pick for next Week uh I do not maybe hermeticism uh let's not go down that rabbit hole now I don't want to do an entire history 102 on just on the hermetica just because I don't know as much about that but um let's um let's do the 50s oh fun a little modern that's super relevant that'll be easier to make uh political correlations or modern correlations so facts okay goodbye
all right see you guys