Hello, I'm Professor Amanda Almosara, and in today's class we will continue our study of legislative power in constitutional law. Very well, in today's class we will talk about the constitutional powers granted to the Chamber of Deputies and the Federal Senate. Very well.
The Constitution assigns specific functions to the Chamber of Deputies and specific functions to the Federal Senate. Be careful, because these powers cannot be confused with the powers of Congress. You might say, "Professor, but Congress isn't the Chamber, it's the Senate.
" Exactly. So, there are constitutional powers granted to Congress, which means the Chamber and the Senate. Both must act there, but there are also powers that belong only to the Chamber and only to the Senate.
So, it's different. The powers of Congress are stipulated in articles 48 and 49 of the Constitution. The powers of the Chamber are stipulated in article 51 of the Constitution, and the powers of the Federal Senate are stipulated in article 52 of the Federal Constitution.
Okay, let's talk a little bit about the powers of the Chamber of Deputies. Article 51 of the Constitution establishes that it is the exclusive responsibility of the Chamber of Deputies. We already have the first trick question on the exam.
What is the trick question? Article 51 says that the power is exclusive, not private. So don't confuse the expression, because that could make your exam question incorrect.
Article 49, which discusses the powers of Congress, says it is the exclusive responsibility of the National Congress. Article 51, however, says: "It is the exclusive responsibility of the Chamber of Deputies. " So, don't confuse the exclusive responsibility of Congress with the private responsibility of the Chamber, because that could be confusing during the exam.
Okay. So, the exclusive responsibility of the Chamber, that is, it belongs to this house. What are they?
The first power is the authorization to initiate proceedings against the President of the Republic and the Vice-President of the Republic, as well as the Ministers of State. Okay. So, proceedings against the president and vice-president, as well as ministers of state, can only be initiated if there is authorization from, and this is what's on the exam, 2/3 of the members of the Chamber of Deputies.
This means that to initiate proceedings, there must be authorization from the Chamber. But the authorization must be given by 2/3 of its members. So, on the exam they mention absolute majority, relative majority, 3/5, 1/3.
Be careful with the fraction. 2/3 of the members of the Chamber authorize not the conviction, be careful, but the initiation. So, to initiate proceedings against the president, the vice-president, and the ministers of state, there must be 2/3 of the members of the Chamber authorizing it.
Very well. It is also the responsibility of the Chamber to proceed with the auditing of the president's accounts when they are not presented to the National Congress within the constitutionally established deadline, which is 60 days after the opening of the legislative session. What is the date of the opening of the legislative session?
We'll see that in our next meeting. We'll talk about legislative sessions as well. It's a very straightforward lesson.
And it's a lesson that will help you answer any question your examiner might ask. So, if the President of the Republic does not present his accounts to Congress 60 days after the opening of the legislative session, this accounting of the President will be done by the Chamber of Deputies. And then there are some things that are kind of obvious.
Why is the Chamber's internal regulations drawn up? But please, let's explain, professor? Of course, by the Chamber of Deputies.
So here it's very simple. The Chamber's internal regulations are made by the Chamber. Guess what?
The Senate's internal regulations are made by the Senate. The Congress's internal regulations are made by Congress, that is, the Chamber and the Senate. So, very easy.
The Chamber's internal regulations are the exclusive competence of the Chamber itself. Now, the Constitution says that it is the exclusive competence of the Chamber to determine the organization, functioning, police, creation, transformation, and extinction of its positions, that is, within the Chamber, positions, jobs, functions, services, and even the initiative of law to set the respective remuneration. Of course, observing the constitutional parameters , but it's interesting for you to know that the initiative for the law to increase the remuneration of deputies belongs to them.
Oh, how interesting, right? They themselves have the initiative to propose, through law, an increase in their remuneration and also to elect the members of the Council of the Republic under the terms of article 89, item 7. The Chamber has a choice, and the Senate also has a choice.
This choice, when it is the Chamber's responsibility, is made exclusively by it. Very well. Article 52 establishes the attributions of the Federal Senate.
So, be careful. 51 of the Chamber, 52 of the Senate. I'll give you a tip for the OAB exam.
How are you going to memorize this? You'll memorize it like this: The attributions of article 51, items 1 and 2, are technically only for the Chamber. So, you memorize these two .
Why? Because the others are either responsibilities that the Senate also has, and we'll talk about those later, and those that aren't on this list of two items or the common list, consequently by exclusion, belong to the Senate. How are you going to memorize this better?
Here's a tip for the exam: You have to study at home, you have to really go for it to pass. So, take a sheet of paper, make a column, responsibilities of the Chamber of Deputies, of the Senate, and look at and compare the two to see what the differences are and be able to identify them during the exam. Let's discuss some of them.
Article 52 says: "It is the exclusive responsibility of the Federal Senate. " So, the representatives of the states, of the federative units. So, it is the Senate's responsibility to prosecute and judge.
Then you say: "Ah, I saw that in the Chamber of Deputies. " No, the Chamber of Deputies doesn't prosecute and judge, it authorizes the initiation of proceedings. So, it is the Chamber of Deputies that authorizes the initiation of proceedings.
Now, who will prosecute and judge the President of the Republic, the Vice-President of the Republic for crimes of responsibility, as we will see later ( we will study this), the Ministers of State, and the commanders of the Navy, Army, and Air Force for crimes of the same nature or connected to those? The Federal Senate. So, be careful.
Prosecuting and judging the President and Vice-President of the Republic for crimes of responsibility, as well as Ministers of State, commanders of the Navy, Army, and Air Force for crimes of the same nature, that is, crimes of responsibility, and those connected to crimes of responsibility, is the Federal Senate. The Senate is also responsible for prosecuting and judging the ministers of the Supreme Federal Court (STF), the members of the National Council of Justice (CNJ), the National Council of the Public Prosecutor's Office (CNMP), the Attorney General of the Republic (PGR), and the Attorney General of the Union ( AGU) for crimes of responsibility. So, who will judge?
In cases involving Supreme Court justices, members of the National Council of Justice (CNJ), the Military Council of the Public Prosecutor's Office (CMP), the Attorney General's Office (PGR), and the Attorney General of the Union (AGU) in cases of crimes of responsibility, the Federal Senate is responsible. These are the authorities who have a special prerogative of judgment that is not technically done by the judiciary but by the legislative branch, specifically in this case, the Federal Senate. It is also the Senate's responsibility to approve, by secret ballot after a public hearing, the selection of magistrates.
That's why we talk about the confirmation hearings of Supreme Court and Superior Court of Justice justices. What is that? It's the approval that the Senate makes for the selection of magistrates when the Constitution so establishes, which is the case for the justices of the Supreme Court, for example.
Also, the ministers of the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU), those nominated by the President of the Republic, go through Senate approval; as do governors of territories, when and if there are any, presidents, and directors of the Central Bank. So, both the president of the Central Bank and the directors of the Central Bank are previously approved by the Federal Senate. And also the Attorney General of the Republic (PGR), who is the head of the Public Prosecutor's Office, the head of the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office.
It is also the Senate's responsibility to approve, by secret ballot after questioning in a closed session, the selection of heads of permanent diplomatic missions; to authorize external operations of a financial nature and in the interest of the federative units, the entities of the federation: the Union, States, the Federal District, and Municipalities. It is also the Senate's responsibility to set, upon proposal of the President, the overall limits for the amount of consolidated debt of the federative entities: the Union, States, the Federal District, and Municipalities. It establishes overall limits and conditions for external and internal credit operations of all entities, including autonomous agencies and any entities controlled by the public power .
It also establishes limits and conditions for the granting of guarantees by the Union and external and internal credit operations. It further establishes overall limits and conditions for the amount of marketable debt of the states, the Federal District, and the municipalities. It is also the Senate's responsibility, and this is very important, to suspend the execution, in whole or in part, of a law declared unconstitutional by a final decision of the Supreme Federal Court (STF).
(I'll make a parenthesis here. We will study this point better in the class on constitutional review, but it already makes an important asterisk in Article 52, item 10 of the Constitution. ) It is also the Senate's responsibility to approve, by absolute majority, the dismissal of the Attorney General before the end of their term.
And then, all the powers that the Constitution establishes are the same powers that the Chamber of Deputies also established: its own internal regulations, taking care of its own organization, its functioning, its internal police—police in the sense of administrative security—the issue of creating and abolishing positions, jobs, functions, and even the limit of its remuneration. It is also similar to the Chamber of Deputies that the election of the members of the Council of the Republic is the responsibility of the Federal Senate. The only remaining distinction we have is the periodic evaluation of the functionality of the national tax system and the performance of tax administrations at all levels of the federation.
This is a responsibility that belongs exclusively to the Senate, OK? So you'll have to do the following: you'll have to read articles 48, 49, 51 , and 52 of the Constitution. You might say, "Oh, professor, but this is so boring, I won't be able to memorize it.
" It's not about memorizing, it's about studying with discernment. Try to identify the common points, the distinguishing points, and what is most fundamental. Knowing what falls under the Chamber's jurisdiction and what doesn't, by exclusion, falls under the Senate's jurisdiction.
And, in Congress , knowing that article 48 establishes the responsibilities of the Legislative branch, along with the Executive's sanction or veto, and article 49 establishes the exclusive competence of the National Congress. To conclude our lesson, here's a golden tip. Remember that we saw in Article 49 that, since it is the exclusive competence of Congress, there is no sanction or veto; all matters foreseen there will be approved by means of a legislative decree.
Very good. Be careful. The powers that technically belong to only one of the houses, the Chamber or the Senate, are powers that will be regulated by means of a decree, legislative decree, or law.
So, what? Resolutions. Don't confuse them.
The powers of the Chamber and the powers of the Senate are deliberated by means of resolutions. So, the topics of Article 51 and the topics of Article 52 are approved by means of resolutions. The topics of Article 49 by means of a legislative decree, and the topics of Article 48 by means of a law.
This will be important because later on, when we study the legislative process, you will already know the difference between law , legislative decree, and resolutions, okay? If you liked this lesson, share it, and I want to see you here at our next meeting to talk about deliberations within the legislative sphere and the constitutionally established sessions. Thank you for your attention, and see you later.
Oh.