what I want to do is actually show you how to file a copyright application if you used AI in the process he goes well I took my song and I created through soono and then I took it and redid it a bunch of times and I did all this additional stuff is that going to be enough please review what you're putting in these boxes very very carefully Ai and copyright ability is real murky land I do AI law I'm a copyright attorney and I did a deep dive looking at the copyright office's newest report which
is not short and what I want to do today are two things one I want to synthesize where we're at today as far as Ai and if you use AI in the creation of your creative stuff what does that mean for you and what do you need to know and then secondly what I want to do is actually show you how to file a copyright application for your creative thing if you used AI in the process I'll be sure to time code this video so you can jump to whatever section you want to go to
but it's very important that before you even move forward with trying to file a copyright application you need to understand how this works so that you do not get into trouble with the copyright office and then I'm going to give you some Pro tips as far as navigating using AI with your creative process if you're excited give this video a big thumbs up and let's jump into it all right so the US copyright office releases this report on copyright ability if you use AI in your creative thing now in our last video we did look
at internationally where different countries are sitting with this and across the board everyone generally requires that in order to get copyright your creative thing has to be human made if something is purely made with AI meaning you just gave it a couple of prompts AI did all the work spit out the final thing you don't have copyright protection and you certainly are not going to get any copyright registrations which is important because at least here in the US a copyright registration as I like to say blossoms your rights and gives you more rights that you
wouldn't otherwise have without actually getting the piece of paper from the federal government now either way this report has major implications for creators because your registrations can be challenged or cancelled if you fail to do this the right way with the application process including to disclose how you used AI in your creation process so the general rule is that when a human an author takes an idea and fixes it so meaning to put it in to something like a piece of paper an MP3 so fixes it to a tangible Medium as the fancy language of
the Copyright Act States you as a Creator get automatic copyright protection but we do know that registering gets you these additional benefits like being able to file a lawsuit seek reimbursement of your attorney's fees seek statutory damages so the report essentially went through and it took feedback from all kinds of Industry players from the music companies to different filmmaker guils build s we even heard from Adobe and essentially being like look us as the copyright office we're trying to figure out how to allow the integration of AI because you know what quite frankly creators are
just using Ai and the feedback that was received was kind of all over the place you know we heard from Universal Universal kind of made me laugh they were like using AI is the equivalent of someone going and asking their musician friend to go make me a nice song about love or something like that and then claiming that that person is a joint author because they made the request right so AKA like how someone onso might just input some general directions and then get something brand new created by the AI and in the report the
copyright office went through and gave us some really interesting examples for example it looked at when the camera you know became a thing and just being like well if the rule is that in order to have copyright it has to be human made meaning not made purely by a machine and the copyright officer was like well we really struggled with the camera because if you just click a button the picture that is created is wholly made by a machine the copyright office basically goes well we struggled with that we struggled with computers when they became
a thing and obviously we found our way through and so did even the Supreme Court to find that there is human contribution in let's say a picture because you decide where you put the camera how you stage the model how you do your set design how you do your lighting and then we were given examples like this and be like well you know someone can give really complicated prompts right doesn't this make you an author if you're like hey I need a professional photo with like this super duper cat in a robe on a Sunday
reading a newspaper and smoking I wanted 70 millim cinematic highly detailed basically the copyright office looking at the final output and being like well there's so much Randomness in the final output because you didn't specify well what breed of cats right what's the what's the size if ultimately the analysis is we need to be able to identify what was the human contribution in the final output like I can't stress this enough when it comes to copyright the final thing and who created that final thing is so important even for human collaborators because you have disputes
all the time where someone's like I was a joint author because you know what I hired you to write my screenplay for example and I gave you the general idea that it should be a screenplay about two people who fall in love and someone breaks the other person's heart well in that example the person who then goes and actually writes the script is for sure the copyright owner right because that person took their ideas and put put it down and the original person hiring the writer may not actually be a joint author if all they
did is just to give a very very generic idea but equally that's why these cases really are reviewed on a case-by Case basis anyway I thought this example was really interesting so basically copyright office goes in says we could talk about it all day on well you gave it prompts and then you refined and you did it like a hundred times on you continuing to refine refine refine is that enough for you to be like I was the author of this AI made thing and the copyright office says no but the copyright office as relates
to this example goes well this is interesting this is what's called an expressive input where you make a human-made thing okay and then you ask AI to expand on what you did okay so the prompt was a young cyborg woman with roses flowers coming out of her head photo realistic cinematic lighting akk hyper detailed so this was the human-made drawing and then what the AI expanded on then is this and so the copyright office goes well the final work where we see like the realistic three-dimension representation of the nose lips rose buds as well as
the application like all the AI attributions aren't actually copyrightable so this is one thing I want to make sure you guys are clear on in this instance this picture was allowed to proceed to registration but it was only because the applicant disclaimed meaning told the copyright office hey the Basse drawing is mine this is human made and then disclaimed the aspects that were created by AI so it means that the AI is still not copyrighted but as a whole the work can be registered does that make sense another example might be like a cover song
so you can register a cover song for copyright protection but you have to tell the copyright office what portion of the cover song You Don't Own you don't own the composition meaning the other person's words and lyrics but you own all the stuff you did around that such as your original production your original performance if you were the singer so you own your cover but there is a portion inside that cover meaning the composition that actually belongs to someone else so you disclaim yet tell the copyright office now one of our big takeaways from the
last video was just to say that if you do not disclaim your registration it can get challenged it can get canceled and that can be devastating for you if you happen to be in the middle of a lawsuit and this kind of technicality comes up I'm a litigator so I can tell you it's a real big deal so one of the big takeaways from this video is just going to be make sure you tell the copyright office any aspect of AI that was contributed or contributed to your creative work and then two other examples that
we looked at from the report one had to do with a comic book that was allowed to proceed to registration by the copyright office and the comic book images had all been created with AI but human author comes in takes those images rearranges it right puts it into a proprietary you know order a new creative thing and so still the AI images themselves are not copyright protected but as included within the comic book the comic book itself can proceed to registration and then another one had to do with a producer who had used AI as
a tool to help with a voice recording on a sound recording so the song So meaning the song was able to actually proceed to registration even though AI had been used because it had been used as a tool all right so in summary purely AI generated Works they're not copyrightable period and that's not just here in the US that's in a whole lot of other countries which we discussed in the last video two human authorship must be perceptible in the final work so meaning like with the drawing and the Roses coming out of the lady's
head the human authorship element of that is that the Baseline drawing is perceptible in what we see in the final work so meaning AKA that helps in whether your AI created thing can be registered so although prompting AI alone doesn't get you there and even prompting Ai and revising AI in most instances doesn't get you there if you can use an expressive input meaning if you can put something that is your original creation into as part of the AI that should be able to get you there selecting AI generated outputs so this was authorship by
adoption so meaning like if you get the AI to give you 10 different examples and then you just pick one so you're like I adopted it so that's me being like an author nope that's not going to get you there either if you significantly modify the AI in some kind of way like with the comic book example in some instances that will be enough and I saw someone comment on the last video right and he goes well I took my song and I created through suo and then I modified it right and then I took
it and redid it a bunch of times and I remastered it and I did all this additional stuff on top of it is that going to be enough and even in that example I go I'm not sure you got there the analysis is what are the human-made elements that essentially like transforms your AI creative thing into human author so so the point being in the copyright office said this we are going to look at these on a case-by casee basis but also that's why we did the Deep dive so you can check that out when
you're done watching this video all right so now Pro tips all right we talk about copyright protection and the additional rights you get by actually getting a federal government registration we also mentioned the fraudulent websites out there if anyone's like hey I can help you get copyright protection for your stuff by using my service and uploading it to my special proprietary cloud and I'll get you a certificate and this and that please run the other way the website I'm going to show you the process I'm going to take you through is the real way of
getting a copyright registration but you know some of the comments that I saw which were you guys are very very insightful and I so very appreciate that you are here on this channel I love nerding out and I appreciate that there are those of you out in the world that are like me all right so if you for example have something that is purely Ai and you're like well what do I do though from a legal standpoint here's some creative lawyering on this there are other claims that you could potentially seek against someone even if
you could not proceed with copyright infringement so meaning there's a legal Theory called unjust enrichment so if someone comes and they just like steal your let's say poster idea that you made using AI if someone makes money off of your thing you created you can at least assert a number of claims right you can seek potentially on Justin Richmond if someone came and interfered with a deal that you did because here's the thing pursuant to platforms like suo they say you own what you created through their platform so if that's the case then you have
a legal claim that you own this thing this digital asset even if you don't have copyright you still have other rights right that's what I would argue so in any case there's theories like interference with contract interference with business opportunity so someone comes and usurps your business opportunity by stealing what you had created or I've had someone sell a music catalog and within that music catalog there were AI created music videos so that's something that was absolutely disclosed but you know for example if you have a contract you could have a bad faith claim so
I want you to know that there are creative lawyer ways to handle situations where someone has come and taken it advantage of you and if you have such a case feel free to reach out to Delgato entertainment law I love this complicated nuanced stuff all right so as promised I'm going to show you as far as filing through the copyright office how to do this some things to keep in mind let's go so you want to go to copy copyright.gov if someone has a website and they're saying they're going to help you and register your
copyright and it's not this website beware okay so you scroll down right here it's register your works and then you want to use this right here log into our e registration system and then you'll put in your secret sauce credentials or just set up an account so here on the left side it shows the different types of applications that you can file just to try to simplify this if you do a group of unpublished work you can do up to 10 if you have not actually released your creative thing but there is a cap of
10 okay and then the filing fee is going to be I think it's 65 bucks as of now and then $85 if it's unpublished so you know strategically might save a little bit of money waiting until your work or works are published meaning released but it's so important that when your stuff gets released you need to make sure to register right away this impacts your statutory damages and all kinds of things so very important most of the time we are doing either a standard application you technically can do like an album so you do a
bunch of filings if it's the same collection of works if that makes sense or they actually have an application for that which is register a certain group of unpublished works so in this scenario I'm just going to do a standard application so let's pretend you used Ai and you have a song you have a picture Maybe cover art you have a poster maybe you have a script all right so through this process we are going to provide all the needed information pay the the fee and we need to give the copyright office an actual copy
of our creative thing all right in the type of work so in this little list if you're registering a song it's a sound recording if it's written work it's literary work if it's a movie or a music video you're going to do motion picture so let's pretend we're doing a song so we'll just select sound recording always read all the good stuff in detail and then click I accept yes you may have my firstborn continue all right so I'm doing this I'm going to select new and for this I guess I'll just do one of
my last songs I released so this is the title of work being registered so the song is say to me I've already done my copyright filing but let's do it again so say to me now we're going to save continue has this work been published so at this point let's pretend I had just published the song so we'll say yes it was published so the year of completion first date of publication I'm pretty manic about stuff like I'll go and register my stuff the day my music comes out I don't want to forget because there's
so many steps when you release your music from the promotion to registering with the pro and Sound Exchange and song trust and so I have like an administrative checklist that I'm going to go through and I just want to hit it ASAP so let's pretend today was the day United States for the nation of first publication okay continue okay the next two sections we have authors and claimants sometimes these are different people are company often times they're going to be especially for like independent songwriters it's going to be the same person or persons so meaning
you know you can have an author let's say if you are Jane and you work for a music business okay so Jane was the author she's the one who actually created the thing but then is transferring the ownership to the entertainment company I don't want to over complicate this so I'm just going to pretend we're doing this as it was just me on say to me actually I'm a thirds EAS with that Orco and then my prior guitar player but anyway just just for pretend today so let me give you a pro tip on this
I'm adding just me as Crystal Delgado but if I was registering this let's say under my record label it would be Dukes up records really really really really important if you register something as a company your LLC your corporation it's really important that you say that this is a work Made For Hire the copyright office will just they just refuse they I don't even think they will let you go on to the next page unless you select yes on this and even if it does let you it will create problems for you later on so
click work Made For Hire but that's not what we're doing here citizenship and domicile savey save so we're going to select sound recording let me just give you a little Pro tip here if you go well what about my lyrics what about the composition right that's embodied in the sound recording which is like as Chance the Rapper likes to put it the idea of the song right your chords and you know your lyrics and stuff those elements are contained within the final fin recording so meaning if someone comes and steals your lyrics When you have
the registration for the song we can still take that piece of paper to go and sue someone and saying you stole the lyrics because the lyrics the composition the instrumental everything is contained in that sound recording so we're saying I'm going to claim the entire thing okay so it added me as the sole author continue all right so now the claimant this is in fact going to be the same but it may be different this is just subject to whatever agreement you have if there was anyone else involved I'll plug in my address and such
and move on to the next thing all right so we'll we'll have pretend Street which is located in the city of moon in Arizona all right so the added benefit of you going through this is that you're learning literally how to file your own copyright applications through the copyright office yay but I'm showing you the nuances of how to do this if you are disclaiming AI so we're at the applicable page which is limitation of claim so this is one ex example so we go here the instructions are if you need to exclude for example
pre-existing material from your creative thing or identify something new that is being registered so remember I said as far as like cover songs you would say well the sound recording right the new version that I created is my own however here maybe the lyrics and composition is not yours so you would disclaim it for that reason now in this case we are doing some something that includes AI so for example we go well the material that we are excluding and saying we don't own it so AKA this is the stuff that was made with AI
here we would say well the had we had AI lyrics and Melody but what is new what is being registered is the actual sound recording now if you were just doing this for your song in general and it's 100% human made you wouldn't need to add anything into this limitation of claim it's very specific to these situations that I'm speaking to right now so then conversely let's say you made your song entirely right or almost entirely made your entire instrumental bed using AI so then you would go in what's excluded you go the AI thing
is let's say well no and that's you know I guess if it's the instrumental you could say the AI instrumental and you could go what is new here would be the lyrics Melody performance right so you just kind of write out all the things that are new on top of your AI instrumental but in this example what we're going to be doing is just saying we used AI to help us with the lyrics and Melody but we own the entire song so that's where we're going to put all right this is also an optional page
right so it gets a little easier with filing these applications if you are 100% owner of your human-made creative thing but for the rights and permissions this is what is going to be listed publicly if you think someone may ever want to get into touch with you in regards to licensing your creative work right purchasing your creative work from you this is what's is going to be publicly listed I always put my contact information on this I should say my company's contact information we'll pretend for this I don't care so I'm not going to put
anything in for now but otherwise I don't know I normally do and would recommend you do it as well all right correspondents who does the copyright office need to speak with if there is a problem guys if you put in the wrong email address and the copyright office emails you and you don't respond to the email because you had a typo in your address that is literally your fault pursuant to the compendium of the copyright office meaning The Rules book they go even if it really was like an innocent mistake if you don't get our
email and you don't respond timely then we're going to close your case you lose your fee and I've had this happen where someone did not know that the copyright office was trying to get into contact with them they had had a typo in the address unfortunately and it was a huge deal because you need to have the registration before someone violates your copyright in order to seek things like statutory damages up to $150,000 per willful infringement AKA please review what you're putting in these boxes very very carefully okay so I'm just going to plug in
this information we have pretend streets right all right where do you want us to mail the certificate to so put in the address for that do you have any special handling instructions we had a situation where the client has a copyright infringement issue and didn't have the registrations and we need the certificates before we can file the lawsuit so we're Expediting all of his copyright registrations there is a very very Hefty fee uh if I remember correctly it's like 800 bucks to do this on an expedited basis so again all the more reason to just
file as you are releasing your creative stuff all right we don't have any special handling instructions this is where you would put the expedite request and then you certify this is the truth and nothing but the truth and then you're going to review your submission so it'll give you a nice summary capturing everything you look at it you approve it you then submit pay your fee and then you go to a final page where you actually give a copy of your creative thing to the copyright office cuz guys remember the copyright office is a glorified
filee keeping system so meaning if you ever have to actually Sue they need to know what was the state of your book what was the state of your song and you use that in court as evidence of your ownership all right so circling back to the conversation about copyrightability of AI and human-made stuff mushed together someone left a comment saying okay this makes no sense whatsoever to me if I write the lyrics choose a style structure the song and then useo to generate the music and then when sunno gives me a decent sounding song but
mispronounces words sings the instrumental sections and does weird stuff like try to repeat the bridge only to run out of time if I then take time to go back and edit the song fix the broken sections remaster it that's not deserving of a copyright claim or at least not for the entire song but if someone takes a picture or a video on their phone that shows a murder suspect in the background they own that entire photo or video video and can sell it to the news agencies without issue I read that initially I'm like a
murder suspect what I understand what you're saying so that's why I wanted to draw out in the beginning of this video talking about how there are different ways to protect your creative thing even if copyright technically won't extend to protecting the AI separately if you found this video helpful don't forget to subscribe I'll see you on the next one I'm top music attorney