have you been funded and established by any uh by the CIA or three any threel agencies I think it'll be out by this by the end of this month oh okay cool yes there's some early stage offer that's by the way I think that's the first that's the first time it's been mentioned so congrats to coin Bureau for I mean could you share any moments where your analysts were absolutely flawed by what they discovered like you know just I picture them screaming like come quick you're not going to believe this what we found hello everyone
and welcome to another another interview here on coin Bureau and today I have got Miguel moral he is the CEO of Arkham intelligence which is of course the preeminent blockchain analytics firm um and he's a returning guest on the coin Bureau so Miguel welcome back and we're looking I'm looking forward to our discussion today thank you very much thank you for having me no worries man um so we've got a lot of stuff to talk about um and we don't have that much time and I want to take a deep dive obviously into the alpha
of blockchain tracking um but I think it's always good to start at the basics um so quite quickly I just want to obviously Arkham is a lot of things and I'm sure everyone in crypto has come across it in some form be it on a news article or be it on Twitter uh but very briefly can you explain for our viewers what Arkham is and what your broader goals and goals are absolutely so Arkham as a whole is essentially a way for people to try to understand more about who the market players uh Within crypto
are um whenever there's major activity in the cryptocurrency space everyone's always wondering what what causes it um and the reality that there's always some person some institution that is the one buying and selling uh a particular kind of asset and that is what causes these uh you know price fluctuations um and so with Arkham what we've intended to do is to build a platform where anybody can go on and search for who the major players within the space are and what it is that that they're doing within the market in a way that could you
know produce market moving activity for example okay great so obviously you've got the platform that allows people to track um dresses and everything and it utilizes Ai and there's many components to it and um you know obviously it's focused on blockchain which is um crypto component but last year you've also introduced The Exchange the intelligence exchange Right Where You launched a token and all this kind of stuff and um I think just to lay into context obviously there was a little bit of fud around that in terms of people like this concept of docs to
earn snitches a service stuff and obviously you guys I've watched subsequent interviews and you addressed it very well so I think do you feel that this has now subsided this potential fud that was created around the deanonymization of of addresses and the pain in terms of incentivizing people to do it yeah absolutely I mean I think anyone who has followed Arkham over the past year would know that we've been completely Vindicated on you know essentially everything that people claimed our our product was going to be um you know there were many people who were kind
of uh sort of very upset that they believed um that our platform would essentially go around uh and you know releasing information about um you know everyday sort of sort of people and that this is going to be plastered all over the front of of our platform and and protocol or or whatever and then what it actually turned into um was a way for people to track down those committing scams a way for people to look at proof of reserves uh within large uh large exchanges and uh and services ways for people to find uh
information about what governments are up to with uh with Bitcoin um and there really wasn't any to be honest of this sort of malicious uh address information seeking um it doesn't exist I haven't even seen requests for it um and in the very beginning I think many people uh especially those who are more cynical um felt as if what we had created would cause this sort of mass deanonymization of you know a bunch of sort of uh you know normal Traders and stuff in the space um that did not happen U but in fact I
think our vision uh was realized of wanting everybody to know you know at least the major sort of players and Bad actors um and and and bringing more transparency to that side of the of the space yeah it's fair I mean um but I'm curious then just to Circle back to this in terms of like the question of De anonymizing you know Wales certainly potentially also want anonymity to some degree um and obviously um you know reading your white paper one of the quotes is De deanonymization is Destiny and and I'm just curious because I
know you're an early bitcoiner as well and I'm you know obviously there's the point around the broad the whales which and there's obviously everyone who's doing scams running scam should be de anonymized right and this blockchain intelligence stuff is important but do you how do you B and thread the needle between like the idea of we people who got involved with cryptocurrency and Bitcoin they wanted the anonymity component but now also we want to De anonymize the entire blockchain for people I think that you know as a whole our vision uh or at least prediction
that deanonymization is is Destiny is more of a a political statement um than a literal one I think in the long run in order for cryptocurrency to you know reach the sort of level of adoption that everyone is one expecting because for for for those of us who believe that you know Bitcoin will be a million dollars or you know whatever uh you know those of us with moon targets for for this um I don't believe that we can attain that kind of that kind of scale and that kind of market cap as an industry
uh in pseudonymous form I think that as the industry continues to grow and get bigger the dollars are going to have to come from somewhere and when people sell the dollars are going to have to go somewhere and those are all coming from the traditional Financial World more dollars are moving from the traditional Financial world into crypto and as that happens and as more and more of this money uh enters the space um it will not be in pseudonymous form right it won't be from like mining it won't be from people doing Anonymous billion dollar
TC deals or something like this um kyc and and and and sort of compliance with uh you know anti-secrecy laws and Bank secrecy laws and anti-money laundering and things like this uh exist in every kind of financial industry including crypto uh it's just that within crypto and blockchain it hasn't been brought to the same scale as exists in for example equities um and so my view is that DN ization uh for for public blockchains is is Destiny um because in order for for public blockchains to reach that 1020 billion sorry 10 20 trillion dollar market
cap as a whole um there will need to be significantly more uh you know kind of compliance uh from the government's uh perspective or else they won't allow it to reach that scale um and so that's why you know that's why I have that that perspective yeah it's very good point I think it's more broadly like this institutionalization of crypto so some people you know the cipher punks would have an issue with it in the sense that you know Bitcoin was created to be outside of the traditional Financial system um and now it's been increasingly
becoming part of the traditional Financial system but you know that's good because obviously it means adoption but you have to have some trade-offs and one of those trade-offs is transparency with what's going on which you guys yes help to do quite well so moving moving away from the philosophical point where and more to back to I mean obviously guys um you know it's amazing how how you manage to do some of the tracking and some of the things you're able to pick up on and as quickly as you do so can you give me a
quick idea of the process um how are these whales ident verified and identified and picked up so um with Arkham all of the information that we use is publicly available the overwhelming amount is found on blockchains themselves um so a big component of our business is actually just um taking information from the Bitcoin blockchain from the ethereum blockchain Tron Etc and actually analyzing that information from a machine learning perspective uh in order to find clusters of addresses that likely belong to the same entity that being like an individual or or an institution such as the
government or a hedge fund once we have that we use whatever sort of um you know kind of metadata uh we have found or or is available from for example you know court filings things people have posted publicly on their websites um Etc in order to then match the portfolio of uh of that entity to the cluster of wallets that we have found and based on the similarities in activity in time stamps in amounts in coins Etc uh we essentially make predictions um about what entities uh or or sorry what cluster of wallets are likely
to belong to which entities that's sort of the highlevel process for how it works so is it probabilistic um in the sense that so you can never say for so you can like when it comes to verifine and I bring this back we'll we'll talk about the ETF wallets as well but it's like um you know uh the certainty with which you can say a wallet is X belongs to X entity you can you so you can't say it's 100% because you know this don't trust verify kind of thing so it's kind of like using
a probabilistic model to you know present as facts absolutely Arkham is a at the end of the day is a tool in a toolbox which you should be using as part of a more let's say holistic uh analytical approach right I think anything in in in science as a whole and this is typically my response to people um who maybe are like skeptical of our methodology or skeptical of the fact that we say we can't you know prove things 100% it's that the overwhelming majority of the time in science and in experimentation it is is
probabilistic it is not a 100% you know uh uh Silver Bullet right so if if if I'm running a pharmaceutical company uh and I create a a cure or a solution for some kind of problem in this case the problem is people you know not having transparency uh within the crypto space like yes there is auditability in the sense that anybody could look at a block Explorer but the reality is that information isn't as useful as what you see on Arkham it's a lot more useful to actually see the name of an entity um it
is to see the address um and so for me it's it's kind of like I'm I'm I'm finding the cure to a particular problem and we're saying that in let's say 95% of cases the information is is likely to be correct um and yes there's some margin of error in the same way that you know there's margin of error for for any kind of cure um but we we take a very scientific um approach to it in the sense that you know it it should be the case that it is probabilistic uh you should be
very skeptical of anyone who says you know we know this with 100% certainty um for just about anything that you know is not owned by them or being created by them yeah makes sense um you currently just in terms of uh what blockchains you track uh is this Bitcoin ethereum and Bitcoin ethereum Tron base um arbitrum optimism yeah we have a lot of them okay is there a minimum like requirement in terms of what blockchains because obviously you need the data a lot of data not just from the component of the transactional data but a
wallet just Court fence for the for the machine learning component right so is there a minimum requirement in terms of no I would say there's no minimum but we try to add the we try to add the blockchains that have the most activity um so we're constantly looking for okay which blockchains are getting a lot more hype uh which blockchains are actually you know being used the most um which are the ones with all the interesting you know activity uh and once we once we have that in place then we can begin uh you know
building what we need to build in order to offer support for it um but otherwise uh we we tend to sit and wait um to verify that you know we've got actually you know good healthy activity in an ecosystem before we attempt to offer support okay and have you got any little insight into which other kind of blockchains you guys are at least looking at on boarding or you know is that still the next one will be salana salana that a big one which does not current yes that's going to be a big one does
not currently have a really amazing uh Explorer um we get many many complaints um about people who who want to be able to use salana and uh and they're not able to so uh I am very very excited to to to add it for sure yeah that would be a really is there any sort of I know you don't want to commit to any hard timelines but just a rough idea because I'm sure the crypto industry would love that I think it'll be out by this by the end of this month oh okay cool there's
some early stage offer that's by the way I think that's the first that's the first time it's been mentioned so congrats to C coin Bureau for for the information and the the right you got to ask the right questions man yes that's what everyone's wunning for because obviously that's um where a lot of meme coin degeneracy is taking place and I'm sure that um you know there's lots of people who would like B more transparency on that side um which is people who wouldn't which makes prodct controversial you guys are going to become fed again
you're going to get fed by the entire um salana mem coin Community now but it is what it is um so I want to just come back to some you know ex cases like case studies in terms of what you've currently been tracking and it's fascinating more on the institutional side in terms of the ETF data um and you know I noticed this because I think about two weeks ago I ched to your team there and I was like you guys we're doing some research on the there was the questions around Black Rock coinbase settlement
right in terms of uh yeah is coinbase holding all all that fud created onchain addresses and things like that and you guys were one of the few that were able to actually you know have the Black Rock identified black rocks but you know ETF addresses um and I watch on presentations in Istanbul I mean do you want to explain exactly the significance of why um how how it's important for this in this case where you've got a ETF that has fully transparent settlement mechanisms and what abely Financial World absolutely so um I think as a
whole the financial the traditional financial industry is behind uh in the sense that people are constantly making filings you know they're constantly needing to uh have some centralized process um by which people can uh or or Sorry by which corporations can make filings about their Holdings um and can kind of give people insight into what's actually going on inside of the company um but then that ends up requiring you know third-party auditing and consulting firms let's say such as deoe in order to actually verify that the information is true prior to it being filed with
the regulator um and then exposed to the public and the issue with this is is multifaceted one it's an incredibly centralized process uh two it requires the trust of the institutions involved who are actually verifying the information uh and then three the timelines for it are very long because auditing people takes a long time filing things with the government takes a long time and uploading those things to the internet then also adds a bit of a delay and so the overwhelming majority of the time this ends up happening quarterly or in the case of something
like an ETF potentially even daily um with Arkham when you have all of that information um about which uh is is actually being um created uh in terms of the addresses which addresses are actually being created in order to to to hold the Bitcoin uh for a particular ETF you can actually see the settlement happening in real time you don't have to wait for the end of day release or report or whatever um before being able to have the information about how the ETF is is performing on a given day and so that's actually one
of the most interesting things about Arkham is that we're one of the only places if not the only place right now I I don't look at you know what other people have done but um you know historically I know we've been the first on on several of these identif ations um where in real time you're actually able to see the information of what's going on with an ETF and what are the current balances and what are the withdrawals and what are the deposits um and that gives you an indication of how the market is doing
in real time rather than needing to wait to do the research later yeah um and um I think it's also because obviously everyone's tracking and looking at um you know the ETF f l in terms of how much inflow or outflow came a day before right and um with this basically it's like they can get that information real time so have you seen um funds of any description or that you know of that utilize your uh ETF you know your your tracking data in terms of the ETF set settlement there are many yeah there are
there are hundreds of uh hundreds of hedge funds who who use who use Arkham at least on a monthly basis uh in order to get information perhaps not specifically about ETFs but um certainly a combination of TFS looking at what other head funds are doing Etc okay yeah and is it only I know I at Black Rock do you have the other what other hedge f um ETF funds have you managed to identify addresses or managed to locate goodness and identify I think Fidelity van e those are two two other you know big ones um
I don't know them all off the top of my head I think they're like 12 or something um and we've managed to we've managed to get just about all of them okay cool and have you um I guess it's like the settlement that's the public filin that come out all these block all these normal tracking websites you know Far Side investors all these other ones have you m tried to match up and is it generally fully fully accurate then you let you guys know okay this is definitely the address because we see the settlement on
chain and afterwards when the actual filings come out yes exactly yes so that using essentially back testing on this information um we are able to confirm that you know it is actually you know it's actually the case right because we get to see from the very beginning of the history of the ETF uh what they're publicly filing in terms of uh in terms of how much Bitcoin has come in and out of the particular cluster of wallets that black rock owns um and then after we make the publication about which you know addresses We Believe
belong to Black Rock um we can then continuously update our model of those addresses um and the probability that we are correct given that every single day it should be that our cluster of addresses matches the same balance that black rock reports um and so we we can from this thirdparty perspective understand uh more about what's actually what's actually happening and whether or not we're correct right it's a it's it's a way of independently you know verifying what what what we've said training the machine obviously training the machine learning algorithms the ACT correct come um
correct okay so obviously um ETFs are the most uh preminent example here but you obviously uh talked also about um Bitcoin Miners And I find this very interesting because it's one of those ways in which you can try and get Alpha on what a Bitcoin miners earnings could be like based on what's reported in terms of tracking on Arkham able to track in terms of minor wallets you maybe just explain that a bit more yes absolutely so the basic sort of concept in theory there um is that there are plenty of of publicly traded companies
within the cryptocurrency space maybe they're not all exchanges like coinbase um but there are publicly traded companies such as mining firms who are constantly reporting their their earnings on on this quarterly basis and analysts are trying to make predictions um about how much money they have made in order to see if they will beat um or or or fail at uh at earnings um and so I think as a as a whole um what we have manage to to to do is if you actually do the identification of the wallets that are actually owned by
these miners um you can see the amount of the Bitcoin um that is being essentially generated by them and therefore you have the the ability to look at all of the uh uh information of the coins that they are receiving the price at which they are receiving it and how it is um that that they are selling it right you can see if they're depositing onto exchanges if they're sending it to OTC firms Etc you see the amount of Bitcoin um and then at the end of the day you can calculate the the amount of
money um that is actually being created from this from this value um that they are sending to these OTC deaths and and to these uh exchanges and then from there um you're able to then calculate theoretically you're able to then calculate the amount of Revenue that they're making against what their costs are um and then you have an estimate of uh of pro profitability and therefore what their share price um should theoretically be worth right and so this is a much kind of more direct way of being able to to understand um you know the
performance of a of a mining company without necessarily needing to wait for them to to report their earnings or do you know some other kind of weird observations or data Gathering to try to understand how much money they make because at the end of the day they make money from mining Bitcoin and that information is all publicly available so theoretically it should be perfect efficient yeah I mean it's fascinating because that's like it's one of the few industry I think probably the only industry where you can use like uh this information and glean like earnings
from it um and so I'm curious then um be moving beyond these two most PR the biggest examples you guys have got and talked about um if the kind of if it was ever a particular example where it really caught you ey the most I mean could you share any moments where your analysts were absolutely flawed by what they discovered like you know just I picture them screaming like come quick you're not going to believe this what we found that's an interesting that's an interesting question I mean we always have um you know different kinds
of different kinds of findings um very rare for us to really be surprised um at at any uh particular particular thing I think some of the most interesting stuff has been government related um as a whole I think that has also been some of the stuff that has gone the most viral for Arkham right finding the wallets of the of the German government for example um or of the kingdom of Bhutan you know those are things where those pieces of information prior to Arkham did not exist publicly nobody knew um who owned um those wallets
or if these governments um had this money or where what they were going to do with it and and and you know this is very important kinds of information for people which is why this news ends up going so viral um so as a whole um I think the most kind of shocking discoveries we've made have probably been the ones that are government related because they're the most sort of um interesting and also the ones where there has been the least publicly available information um about them um we also found the Tesla and SpaceX uh
Bitcoin Holdings that was pretty cool right because beforehand you would need to for the the the announcements from SpaceX or from Tesla mostly Tesla because that's the one that's actually public you would need to wait for them um to to actually tell you that that they are buying or selling their Bitcoin in their in their quarterly statements but now you don't have to do that you can just look at Arkham yeah and the bhan case that was also I mean that stage you guys if I recall you um you identified they were Mining and they
were they were using mining pools and stuff is and how did you inclusively like I me obviously we say it was all probabilistic but I mean you know they disclosed it so were there any particular points of information any ones that you can point as like yeah this was this conclusively proved this was linked to Bhutan or is it more there was a lot of there was a lot of publicly available information uh about the mining projects that were going on in in in Bhutan and their size and their scale and so forth um the
dates which you know they went operational um you know these are kinds of very interesting pieces of information there was a lot of indepth uh investigative journalism being done by Forbes um as well they did a really great job bringing together all these different pieces of the puzzle um and so using all of those kind of crumbs let's say we were able to piece together a story uh of what was actually going on in bhuton uh with their Bitcoin yeah it's fascinating man um all to thanks to the blockchain um so I just want to
quickly like obviously you know AR SC it's like a massive range of tools but I'm curious in terms of where do you see room for improvement in your current offering and is there anything in particular you're trying to take to the next level when it comes to your product offering your sweet your tools and features and functionality that's an interesting question um absolutely I want to add salana you know that is one kind of major Gap in terms of activity in the cryptocurrency space um that we do not currently uh analyze um additionally I think
it could be really interesting to add way more uh you know Market related tools so branching Beyond I mean onchain information is obviously our bread and butter and will always be our kind of core Focus but given that the our audience is made up of of investors and of and of Traders um I want to add more Market related information that could be offchain in order to help people use Arkham as kind of like a full tool Suite rather than needing to use other sorts of products uh in order to kind of supplement the information
that they find on Arkham about what's going on on chain um so maybe sort of verticalized more of those uh types of analytics from not just on chain info but also the the achain uh information I think could be could be very interesting okay go Ahad um so I want to fin I want to quickly finish off with one of the most pressing questions of all now this is obviously kind of going back to the F I've seen some questions online and um and um have you been funded and St and in established by any
uh by the CIA or three any threel agencies no absolutely not unequivocally no completely private um yeah we don't have any relationship uh with any of those kinds of agencies so um just a bunch of crypto guys wanting to build really great uh analytics tools for the for the space though I could see because we've built such amazing technology why people would believe that it's government back um but the hilarious thing is that my personal opinion of this um is that the fact we've built such amazing technology uh is actually evidence that it was not
built by the government because the government could never build something as good as Arkham uh is basically my my to be fair you guys have identified lots of government wallets so um you know you've docked the governments and yes many people many people think that Bitcoin was a lab some people think Bitcoin was a lab leak from a intelligence agency itself so you know um the end of the day if it's transparency for the space and we help identify the Bad actors and the tools help um people to you know spot addresses and make money
in the space as well it's a benefit for all um absolutely Miguel this has been a very it's been unfortunately short interview um because we have to run but you know it's been great and very insightful so far and I'd love to have you on again but thanks for coming on to the coin Bureau and now hopefully absolutely where can where can our fans follow you obviously on Twitter is there anything else any other links and stuff that want you want to highlight here well I would I would definitely recommend people actually go onto the
Arkham platform itself and and and look at all the wonderful analytics information that exists on there um you can sign up for for our platform and then we'll add you to to our marketing chain so that you receive new updates about the product and then otherwise Twitter is the best place to to look at our uh new updates and uh exciting information great yeah so guys we link to below and we'll definitely get migal back on when he releases when they release their salana functionality and he can tell us where all the mem coin whales
are sitting absolutely come on thanks a lot thank you very much for having me yes