[Music] you're listening to the sspx podcast and welcome to episode 15 in our sacrament series and our second episode on matrimony father luke is back to see how a simple change in the understanding of the ends or purpose of marriage can have extraordinarily far-reaching and disastrous effects for couples families and even whole nations what happens when you switch the order of two of the Purposes of marriage we'll see why this shift happened what the reaction was and how it actually caused pope paul vi to never want to write another encyclical but first we'll start with
the consequences and then work our way backwards can this simple change explain the degradation of the modern family we'll try next if you like these series and want to help us continue to make them you can help by leaving a small monthly or One-time donation on sspxpodcast.com or by subscribing to this channel on youtube or by subscribing and leaving a rating for the podcast on apple podcasts spotify or wherever you're listening and thank you for doing that for helping us with this apostolate to reach as many people as possible with the beauty and the truth
of what it means to be a traditional catholic now let's join father luke for episode Number 15 of the sacrament series right now well father luke thank you for joining us again on this topic of matrimony how has your week been it's been very good thank you very much and yours good good uh very good actually we were just talking before we started recording it's always nice when a day actually is productive it's so rare probably for you as well as the principal of a school you get hit With 30 things before you go get
anything accomplished probably that's often very true it's kind of one of the joys having kidlets you know that happens exactly well father um we we talked about the traditional uh form of marriage we talked about the traditional reason for marriage in our last episode today we're going to start talking about The new the new right where would you like to begin father that's a good question and i think perhaps in order to give a little bit of context to what we're going to discuss a very brief look at let's say the situation of marriage in
the church at least here in the u.s might be of some help because i think that will in a way give a living background To precisely the principles that we're going to see and indeed it's it's a very large question that touches i would say on a lot of people's lives so to begin that i'd like to reference a few statistics that are provided by georgetown actually by a service they run Called cara c-a-r-a which is designed precisely to gather statistics that in some way or another indicate the the health of the church what's going
on in the church so they'll do things like how many people are getting ordained what's their background et cetera et cetera et cetera and they have a very very helpful section called their faqs Things that they most often are asked about and some of those are i think very eye-opening so maybe in the first place we can look at the catholic population here in the united states so they've been more or less keeping track of this since uh 1970 is where they begin and what they note is that in 1917 there was If you look
at the question of parish registers you know who's actually part of the parish roughly 48 million people in the u.s at that time were catholic um now if you go to people who identify themselves as catholic it rises slightly to 54 million you know there's about six million gap you know who think of themselves as catholic but weren't on the registers Now if you fast forward to 2020 that's which is the last year that they have statistics for they show that now in the united states they have just under 68 million catholics that are on
the registers so official catholics uh baptized members of a parish or whatever and if you look at the self-identified those who claim to be catholic without necessarily having that affiliation it Rises to about 72 million people which would be roughly about a fifth of the country's population in fact just a little bit over that right so that's i think kind of a beginning starting point so what we see in the church in the u.s is at least numerically a growth now right unfortunately that's uh that growth is very superficial and one may be observation is
that uh there's been a drop A fairly significant drop in those who identify as catholics so the height was in 2010 where you had 81 million people identify as catholic meaning roughly in the last 10 years that's dropped by about 10 million almost just those who identifying themselves although oddly enough the the number of registered catholics has continued to grow so anyways so really what you're seeing is People who weren't really practicing just no longer say they're not practicing right now what you might expect as a result of that is to see the sacramental life
to grow accordingly since you have um about a 20 or almost a 50 increase in the number of catholics or thereabouts um you would kind of expect that but if you dig into the statistics That's not what you see and we begin perhaps given our our topic of marriage by looking at sacramental marriages here in 1970 again the first year that they have the records on their website what they show is that in that year they had 430 000 marriages for catholics it's not bad Right so it's about um two percent of the catholic population
at the time was getting married that year um and at the same year and we'll kind of maybe do these together they had about just over one million baptisms throughout the whole of the united states it's pretty nice okay it's a lot a lot of children being born and that's not even that's not even the Time of the uh you know the uh the baby boom right after world war ii it's still pretty pretty intense but now if you flash or fast forward to uh 2020 again last year they have statistics for if you look
at marriages so again we've had uh the catholic population is now about 20 million more roughly than it was um 50 years ago And what we see in the marriage is if we go from in 1970 430 000 to 2 years ago roughly 130 000 so it's a drop by about um 75 roughly wow just the very number of marriages and then if you look at the question of baptisms the you go from just over a million baptisms to two years ago 550 000 you know it's almost you half the number of new babies being
baptized together with that it might be of some interest to to look at the statistics for annulments now again annulments were something where it's the church for one reason another declaring that a marriage of actually of supposed marriage never in fact existed it was a very rare thing you know in You know prior to the second vatican council you might have a few hundred for the whole world a year now they didn't actually keep statistics for this in 1970 or up until 1990 or 1985 is the first year that i see statistics on georgetown's website
okay but in 1985 um in that year you had 61 000 enrollments declared in the us alone which is by far in a way unfortunately The worst of all the western countries um now that number has continued to drop more or less as a yearly total until in 2020 two years ago you only had you only had 20 000 annulments declared now it's a little hard to measure this directly with the marriages but that's one-sixth of the number of marriages that were entered into that year And again in the previous five ten years you had
had roughly similar amounts of marriages each of those years which indicates that it's a fairly large percentage even if it's dropped numerically of marriages that are ending in annulments right which indicates there is some go ahead i was just going to say it's not as high as divorce rates but it's still it's It's a lot a six correct it is yeah it's a lot and um [Music] in one way or the other it indicates there's something profoundly at odds or off-kilter uh even amongst catholics as far as marriage the fact that there are so few
getting or are not ordained getting married Um and of those a fairly large number saying oh wow something went wrong you know now another statistic that's of some interest in again providing a little bit of background for what we're going to see as far as the changed attitude towards marriage that manifests itself initially at vatican ii and then as you know works its way into the catholic life afterwards is a question of contraception Um and this was something that i'm pretty sure that father mcfarland discussed way back when and the introductory podcast to the crisis
in the church right and um this one in a way is pretty disheartening and what i'm going to reference here is a survey it's done by the an organization Uh called the gutmacher institute which was done in 2011. so this is about 10 years ago it's a fairly famous study which was a little bit misrepresented in the press at the time because it's you get a very famous statistic this was well maybe the background this is performed more or less right at the time that you had obamacare being passed And together with that the requirement
that businesses provide free contraceptives to their employees our female employees and you had a very famous supreme court case that was brought by a group called the little sisters of the poor basically the sister saying we in conscience cannot provide you know let's say those people who are working for us um whatever that capacity may be with this thing that was against our religion And there was this institute survey was quoted quite frequently and saying ah you claim this but if you look at the numbers in fact upwards of 98 of catholic women have used
contraception and there is a little bit of pushback on that and so um the same institute the good mocker institute published a study a little bit later which clarified dug a little bit more Deeply into the numbers because that 98 of catholic women basically uh was counting anyone who'd ever used anything um even if they weren't necessarily using it on a regular basis so you might have a young lady who makes a mistake or something like that but it's not really deeply saying it's fine so they're like okay fine we'll dig into this a little
bit and so we'll ask a little bit a further Question which is how many of catholic women are currently using it on a regular basis contraceptives and when they clarified that what the numbers that they got in their survey was 87 of catholic women were regularly are at that time of the survey still making use of contraceptives and then they took one step further and Said okay uh if we look at something a higher a more effective manner of contraception for example an iud sterilization some of these terrible techniques that modern science modern medicine has
made available unfortunately what they found there is that 68 of catholics currently using one of these more highly effective methods of contraception indicating that A very sizable majority of catholic women in the u.s regularly or maybe not regularly but at least as a somewhat steady basis make use of those methods which if the church traditionally has taught that's something which is intrinsically forbidden indicates there is some kind of disconnect at a very deep level and maybe one last thing to give just Very briefly on again this this context of the situation in the church as
a whole and here expanding a little bit beyond the borders of the u.s if you look at what sociologists call a total fertility rate by which they mean the number of children a woman can be expected to have over the course of her childbearing years in any given country What you see is that there's a pretty dire problem in catholic countries with what uh what they say what statisticians say is that for a country even to stay at the same population level you have to roughly have um a total fertility rate of 2.1 which means
that the average woman has On average 2.1 children which reminds him of gary larson a cartoon where you have this guy entering in a in a a person's house and the parents like we'd like to introduce you to our 1.5 children you have like two kids next to each other at least one half of a kitten but anyways i was thinking of that exact same comic strip when you said that father so yeah that's a very light way of looking at this but right um Anyways if if you break this down the top 100 countries
as far as is concerned are basically uh and i exaggerate a little bit but not by much in africa and the middle east the the top country in the world is niger with uh where the average woman over the course of her uh childbearing years can expect to have seven children so that's the average Right it's pretty impressive now if you start looking towards traditionally catholic countries or a long-standing catholic countries as say in europe the top country we can say is france which is 105th in the world and it has a total fertility rate
of 2.06 meaning it's below replacement level but they're having kids right of course if you dig into that a Little bit it gets a little bit more problematic because who's having kids and friends well probably traditional as catholics and muslims so but you take a long time to get to the next catholic country let's say belgium so now we're down to 151 and there they're at 1.77 kids per woman Whoops that's unfortunate and then if we get to spain and italy these you know traditionally bastions of catholic culture spain is at 1.51 and italy is
at 1.47 those are disastrous numbers for any civilization and just maybe to help our listeners to understand what that means let's say you have a population of 200 People in the country just for simplicity's sake and it's broken down evenly 100 men 100 women they're all married to each other it's a hunky door world if you have a replacement rate of 1.47 that means those 100 women will have 147 children so the next generation you go from a population 200 to 147 if that continues and let's say that 147 is split evenly You have 74
boys 74 girls you have in the next generation 100 and basically 15 kids so in almost two generations the population of the country drops by half again that's just of course it works in a perfect mathematical basis right but and maybe just illustrate that i had a good family friend who went traveling in italy and they had eight kids at the Time no at the time they had seven kids you know and so they're just going to various different places and they're going through italy and they recall very distinctly like going through venice at one
point and uh basically all the italian older talents are like bambini bambini like you have kids this is awesome you know it's great to see kids around Right but it's just because there's so few uh amongst young people my wife and i were touring italy a few years ago and we were at parks they were empty and this is you know before kovit like you know people were supposed to be at the parks right there were no kids at the parks uh it was i remember actually telling my wife oh look there's some kids it
was so weird to see kids Yeah it's it's striking yeah and again it's in our context right here and now um you know this is i think the background picture of how to understand the real world effects of what we're going to see as far as the changed perspective on what marriage is in fact meant to be that's again began at the second vatican Council and which has unfortunately continued to make itself very present in the life of many many catholics and again a lot of people in let's say our circles and other society circles
or maybe even i would add uh traditional circles and even conservative nova scotia parishes they're a little bit cut off from that wider reality what's going on in the church unfortunately Right now of course the question arises where does this come from where do all these statistics that are not very encouraging if you just look on them on the surface humanly speaking what's the origin of that and i would say that to begin what leads to this confusion was a a confusion about the very purpose and Ends of marriage and a reversal of those ends
which really was not didn't originate a vatican too but which found its let's say highest initial expression there in which informed a lot of the reforms that came after the council and perhaps by way of introducing that aspect i'd like to quote a common to pope francis which arose in one of his infamous Interviews after one of the papal trips this time as he was coming back from the philippines in january 2015. and as one of the journalists i as i understand it asked a question about precisely uh artificial contraception in the waking you know
in the philippines is one of the few catholic countries left that has A high birth rate and the population is very growing a lot you know still growing quite enormously and so the implication being well they're going to run into all these overpopulation problems and therefore you know shouldn't something be done about that now apparently to his credit he didn't let's say say oh no it's fine you use artificial hunt Chefs and great but right in speak out and here i'll just quote from an article that comes from the bbc the british broadcasting corps from
that time and the author there from the bbc says that speaking to journalists while heading back to rome from the philippines on monday pope francis was asked what he would say to families who had more children than they could afford because the church forbids artificial Contraception he replied with an unexpected turn of phrase you know some people think that excuse my expression here that in order to be good catholics we have to be like rabbits no parenthood is about being responsible this is clear i remember at the time you know a lot of families were
you know open arms about This because you know basically on the face of it it's very insulting and i would say that on the one hand it's completely out of line with reality the problem with most catholic families is not that they're breeding like rabbits it's the fact they're having too few children but even otherwise the the very mentality there is the sense that they're not really and fundamentally there to bring new life into the world You know that's just animalistic there's nothing noble about that fundamentally and the mindset he's expressing there i think can
be traced back to the council [Music] and interestingly enough there was a very intense and heated debate during the third session of the council so here we're talking about the fall of 1964. when the documents the conciliar documents uh gaudium and spez which is where marriage is discussed was debated okay and there was a very well i might say infamous exchange precisely where a number of liberal cardinals and bishops pushed strongly To explicitly reverse the the ends of marriage to give the primacy of place ultimately to the question of conjugal love marital love between husband
and wife or at the very least to completely eliminate the idea of primary and secondary ends which by its very nature gives the primacy to the traditional understanding of procreation and education of the Children this let's say group was really animated by a belgian cardinal called leocardinal swannins who will figure a lot in this this podcast now um let's say to begin there was uh over a course of days it was on the floor of the council so they had Kind of like a parliament kind of like an open debate where different bishops and cardinals
could speak and over the on this open floor you had four speakers you had cardinal leger from montreal canada cardinal swennans a eastern right catholic and then A spanish for latin american catholic monsignor mendez arcelor all of whom got up and basically argued in favor of reversing the church's traditional base of the presentation and here i'd just like perhaps to cite some of these um the speeches or at least portions of them to begin i'll quote from in fact a book by xavier wren who i mentioned before The reason i like to quote him is
he's a liberal he's like and his take on their interventions like this is awesome like this is the way we need to go so firstly with cardinal dejo so he gets up to speak and he says the following it should clearly present human conjugal love and by the it he's referring to the schema which will become gauri mezfez As a true end of marriage as something good in itself with its own characteristic and its own laws what he means by this is that it's completely independent from the question of procreation and that'll be important he
goes on the schema is too hesitant on this point there's no point in the schemas avoidance of the term secondary end for conjugal love if it does not present Love as being at the service of procreation so in other words if the schemas ignores primary and secondary ends but still says that conjugal love is ordered towards bringing new life in the world and it's problematic because it means it's subordinated even there towards procreation and it goes on in marriage the spouses should consider each other not as mere procreators As rabbits but as persons love for
their own sakes and then he ends by stating [Applause] it must also be stated that the intimate union of the spouses also finds a purpose in love and this end is truly the end of the act itself the marital act lawful in itself even when it is not ordained to procreation now that is a critical point Because he's saying something more than what the church has always acknowledged so the church is always admitted let's say that when you have either a case where a couple gets married and finds out that for one reason or another
they're sterile they cannot have children and simply there's something wrong for either the man or the woman that just doesn't allow it they can Still they're still legitimately married and can make use of the marriage right completely and legitimately same thing for a couple after the child bearing years of the woman they can still legitimately make use of their right even though because the deficiency of nature is certain that there's not going to be a new conception that's not new what he's saying is that effectively Even if it's not ordained to procreation meaning that if
they put a positive obstacle to the possibility of a new conception the fact that there is true conjugal love means that it's fine okay it's a that's a huge shift of perspective and something that goes completely against what the church has always taught about the nature of what the right that the husband and the wife Give to each other it's the same principle if uh two two people of older age get married there's no possibility for procreation but correct it's it's still but that's the the end of marriage is still the procreation it that doesn't
change the entire end of marriage right correct you know they still again the idea is they make use of marriage in such a way that it would be possible For nature to take its course and lead to new life if nature hadn't been weak at that point right so again nobody questioned that nobody questioned that up until this time so for to make that statement necessarily means one's going beyond that and conversely interestingly enough what else does that make possible That principle uh contraception certainly but even we can go a step beyond that homosexual marriage
oh sure okay now of course cardinal legere would not have admitted that but the principle that he's enunciating leads in that direction now if we turn to cardinal sweden's he's in a way i would say the the heart Of this movement [Music] and he's pretty strong so if we look at him um he in a very long speech and very a speech that garnered an intense reaction from the conservatives and we'll see them in a moment he says um the following it's great These these liberals are very good so he says it's up for us
ourselves for the commission and i'll mention that commission later to study whether up to now we have been given sufficient emphasis to all the aspects of the teaching of the church on marriage to be sure it is not a question of modifying or of casting doubt on the truly traditional teaching of the church it's A very very common thing we're not throwing any doubt on this but okay let's go on [Music] so he continues this established it is important to examine whether we have maintained the perfect balance in perfect balance all aspects of the teaching
of the church on marriage it may be that we have accentuated the gospel text increase and multiply To such a point that we have obscured another text that they will be two and one flesh the two in one is a mystery of interpersonal communion gratified and sanctified by the sacrament of marriage now what he means by that is in other words this is an independent purpose of marriage that there be this inter-communion interpersonal communion Between the man and the wife that's a goal for its own sake regardless of the question of procreation that's what we
have to understand there and it's also for this commission to tell us whether we've excessively stressed the first in procreation at the expense of another equally important end that is growth in control unity in the same way It is up to this commission to deal with the immense problem arising from the population explosion and overpopulation in many areas of the world for the first time we must proceed with such a study in the light of the faith it is difficult but in the world whether consciously or not awaits the church to express her thoughts and
be a light for the nations and what we'll see in a moment is that For cardinal sweden's that meant allowing artificial contraception he's very clear on that and he ends that long speech by saying i beg of you my brother bishops let us avoid a new quote-unquote galileo affair one is enough for the church and he says we must follow the progress of science You know it's in a way you can hear cardinal sweden's being a foreshadowing of all that we've been hearing these last let's say a few years follow the science this trust the
science and that's really what he's saying it's like all these new modern medical developments that allow us to prevent conception we should use them we have to trust the science Like i said he's making these statements on the the floor of the council in open debate all passovers there's other ones i mentioned because they don't really add anything intrinsically to what's already been said but the conservatives really strongly react we have a very famous intervention by cardinal lataviani and we've seen before the prefect at the time of the holy office And who gave a very
personal comment in defense the traditional doctrine he said look i'm the 11th of 12 children that were born i was and who all were born to a poor family but we have this great confidence in providence and trust in the goodness of god and then you also have cardinal brown who is a dominican who is a personal friend of archbishop lefevre And he in a way gave a little bit more systematic defense the traditional doctrine [Applause] and he comments in the following way he says i thought that the council of discussion would throw light on
the text but i find now that i must bear witness to the traditional doctrine on marriage which has been called into doubt the primary end of marriage is Procreation and the education of children the secondary end is on the one hand the mutual aid of the spouses and on the other remedy of concupiscence this is basic marriage you know instruction and he's like uh this is the most basic point about what marriage is and i'm having to remind all of my fellow bishops about this when he goes on what about love you may Say love
forms are part of marriage but we must distinguish between the love of friendship which desires the welfare of another and the love of concupiscence which seeks what is good for oneself the kind of love required for the stability of marriage is the conjugal love of friendship there is an element of sensual pleasure in the miracle act which often causes the love of concupiscence to predominate And we must be careful therefore in vindicating the right to that conjugal love it is good when the spouses act with due regard for the ends of marriage in other words
when it is open to life which is precisely that act of friendship i'm willing to give myself to you to such an extent that i'm open to there being another you and that's really what the marriage act is all about And so he says the begetting and education of children fidelity and rendering the debt and the sacrament which renders married life holy [Applause] there is a lot of other interventions there but that i think will surprise for the moment like i said it was a very strong um in debate so much so and basically the
progressives were so intense that paul Vi himself the very the pope sent a number of amendments to the floor that they had to consider and which made very clear the traditional teaching actually that artificial contraception was not permitted not lawful now the liberals so we have these bishops on the floor of the vatican council basically trying to upend Marriage the entire teaching and i i guess i shouldn't be shocked father after going through the entire crisis in the church series but for some reason that really surprises me uh like you when you were talking about
what cardinal brown was saying this is basic marriage class 101 and yeah we're just reversing it correct exactly we're just reversing it and again What we can say in a way is uh at a very deep level perhaps we'll come back to this close to the end today is we're dealing with a loss of faith yeah a loss of a supernatural perspective i mean that's what cardinal taviano was saying it's like look yeah it can be rough but there's this sense of being united with our lord on the cross as we saw last time marriage
is About that union of christ with his church on the cross and the fruitfulness that comes from that and there is a sense of trusting providence not unintelligently not being you know um foolish and just not taking uh the means for for example for a father to provide for his family or whatever but still trust in providence now coming back to this these amendments that Pious or sorry no pious but paul the sixth sentence um i'll just read a few sections here from of father vilken's book the rhine flows in the tiger again a very
good reference he says that the first of these amendments called for the insertion of two words artificial contraceptives among the quote deformations detracting from the dignity of conjugal love and family life by polygamy divorce and free Love at the same time the pope called for a precise footnote reference to the two pages in popeye's eleventh sensical encyclical caste kanubi where the use of artificial contraceptives was condemned so paul vi actually is pretty clear okay look these are against the purpose of marriage and therefore cannot be used now the commission that received these amendments excused itself
from introducing Artificial contraceptions and used instead illicit practices against human generation and omitted the references to cascanubi so basically they received this uh amendment that the pope wanted inserted into the text i think okay that's very nice we're going to get rid of the heart of it and also it says the third of these amendments again quoting vilken The third called for the substitution of the words it is not lawful for the words should not in the prohibition to quote sons of the church to use methods of regulating procreation which had been or may be
found blameworthy by the teaching authority of the church a footnote was to be added here calling attention both to cassidy kenubi and pius xii allocation to midwives Which reiterated the teaching of that encyclical stating that the prescription against artificial contraceptions was derived from natural and divine law so something that's from god now the difference between it is not lawful and should not is that when we speak of it's not being lawful it's forbidden but should not is a recommendation right okay this really would recommend That you not do that it's better but you know if
you have to okay okay that's really the sense the difference that small little phrase there but once again the joint commission that's responsible for bringing these amendments effectively completely changes it it doesn't quote either pope paul pius 11th or 12th and it quotes a speech that paul vi gave About let's say a commission that had been formed and which we'll look at in detail to question to study the question of artificial contraception in which he said okay look we can't change things yet but we're looking at it which raises the problem so basically they're like
yeah it's not from the natural divine law we're looking at it we may change it wow So it's a big thing now what the conclusion of that is in the eyes of liberals such as cardinal swennans carnal legion ultimately parents could legitimately and deliberately limit the number of children they had and to do so again and we'll back this up presently is make use of contraceptions to Frustrate the marital act provided that they did so in order to quote foster conjugal love you know cardinal suenance himself really wanted to see cassie knew be revised again
in the light of this idea that we're no longer is marriage primarily about bringing new life into the world and educating the children that are a gift of god rather it's is that simply a Independent and co-equal in sometimes with this question of marital intimacy merit or conjugal love okay so again we have to understand that for them they wouldn't say that there should never be children and they certainly wouldn't go so far as by any stretch the imagination to admit of uh let's say the modern argument in favor of homosexual unions or anything like
that But they're bringing the principle that does make that legitimate right now the fruit of all these debates is rather uh ambiguous so uh just to quote real quickly xavier renegade and his conclusion on the section [Music] He says very approvingly so after the challenge is thrown down in the debate on thursday by what he means is the conservatives one paratus a frequent spokesman for the new theology of marriage summed up his impressions in the following words quote it was the death of cassidy kenobi in quote so he sees that as awesome you know this
is progress and xavier Wren again he's he he's fully on board with that [Music] now like i said the the final text of gaudium spez on marriage is ambiguous meaning that it tends to announce a traditional doctrine in a number of places on the primacy appropriation well nonetheless insisting on equality of the conjugal love is a purpose so it's kind of an uneasy balance okay and that's partly as a result of The the pushback of people like cardinal lataviani and cardinal brown nevertheless um father wilkin could still say uh in his kind of summary on
this whole section that um this new version of the text could still be interpreted as leaving it to the spouses to decide whether or not To use artificial contraceptives to limit the size of their families provided their ultimate aim was the fostering of conjugal love and father wilkin is not a conservative really he's not as full bore liberal and progressive as xavier wren but he's still commenting okay it leaves it open it seems okay and it was in order to kind of close that gap that paul vi sent those amendments i was just quoting or
Discussing and which were basically gutted and to quote uh roberto de mette in his book the second vatican council an unwritten story he says at the very end of his view of this section that unfortunately the family morality formulated in the chapter the quote dignity of matrimony And of the family in gauri menspez would incorporate the suggestions of the innovators rather than those that offenders of traditional morality and it resulted in the unfortunate synthesis of contrary tendencies meaning that you're you have both viewpoints clashing with each other and so i think it might be good
just to quote a few of those sections from guardiansfest to kind of get that that's that clash Okay so paragraph 48 of gaudi mesfez it stated that by their very nature the institution of matrimony itself and conjugal love are ordained for the procreation and education of children and finding them their ultimate crown which in many respects is basically just a restatement of the traditional doctrine by its very nature they're directed towards that a little few two paragraphs later in Paragraph 15 we read hence while not making the other purposes of matrimony of less account the
true practice of conjugal love and the whole meaning of the family life which results from it from it have the same that the cup will be ready with stout hearts to cooperate with the love of the creator and the savior who through them will enlarge enriches Enrich his own family day by day so again this aim of family life the whole meaning of family life is that the cup will be ready to work with god the creator in other words to bring new life into the world but it's interesting they make a point of saying
while not making other purpose of matrimony of less account okay okay And then a little bit later in that same paragraph we read marriage to be sure is not instituted solely for procreation rather its very nature as an unbreakable compact between persons and welfare of children both demand that the mutual love of the spouses be embodied in a rightly ordered manner let it grow and ripen so again it's not solely for procreation again the language is tending towards This equality of love marital love and procreation and then finally in that to just quote the section
that specifically deals with what uh father ralph wilkin was saying that it seems that could be potentially open to artificial contraception the document says that thus they the the spouses will fulfill their task of procreation with human and christian Responsibility and with docile reverence toward god will make decisions by common counsel and effort [Music] let them thoughtfully take into account both their own welfare and that of their children those already born and those which the future may bring for this accounting they need to reckon with both material and the spiritual conditions of the times as
well as their State in life finally they should consult the interests the family group of temporal society and of the church herself the parents themselves and no one else should ultimately make the judgment in the side of god the judgment they're talking about is whether to have another child okay um and again it's not simply as though that Uh cannot be understood properly but at the same time given the language it's and given the fact that there's not an explicit rejection of artificial contraception it leaves open that door which was the intention of the authors
now before coming back to that question of artificial contraception because there is really where you find this new conception of marriage um incarnated i would say I think it's important under uh to look at how uh this vision of the new status of the ends of marriage has been translated into the life of the church um the this language and vision that is to say the equal status of marital love and procreation has really been enshrined in the mindset of the modern church you know that's where things um how it's viewed Um and maybe just
uh as a little anecdote i remember talking with somebody uh a young person that i knew that was uh soon to be married and was getting classes through the diocese where they where this person lived and the the priest was giving the instructions at the following the guidance of the Diocese basically told the person and there's prospective spouse that basically as soon as you get into the marriage you can use natural family planning in other words you can deliberately make use of the marriage in the way that's most likely not to have children right that's
perfectly fine then again the mindset there is okay look you know You're free not to choose not to have kids right away because you love each other and that's fine you know unfortunately this person was very generous and didn't go along with that they and their spouse now have several children but again that mindset is it's only possible with that revision of what the Ends of marriage are because if you can't get married if you're not ready to have kids basically right you and the difference there with the traditional teaching the church is sometimes given
very specific circumstances beyond one's own control and which would make it unjust in one way or another to bring in a new life then one might make use of those that the marital act in a way that's you know going to render less likely A new conception right but still open to life okay but never impossible yeah never ruling it out so anyways there's a few things which i think kind of help this out so firstly if we look at canon law so in the new canon law the 1983 code of canon law in canon
1055 we read that the matrimonial covenant by which a man and a woman established Between themselves a partnership of the whole of life and which is ordered by its nature to the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring has been raised by christ to the dignity of a sacrament between the baptized anyways there's no discussion of primary secondary ends and what appears first is The good of the spouses themselves if we look at the catechism the catholic church published in the 1990s in paragraph 1601 there we read the matrimonial covenant by
which a man and a woman established between themselves a partnership of the whole of life is by its nature order to the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring And this covenant between baptized persons has been raised by christ the lord to the dignitary of the sacrament so [Music] yes it's it's again this idea that there is an equality and it's you know if one doesn't have that history in the background what the church has indeed always taught you know one might be like okay that's fine But the difficulty quickly becomes
that well again this is the mindset very deeply behind that breakdown of catholic family that we've seen over the last 50 and 60 years sorry were you gonna ask a question there or no i was just i was just thinking it's it's not um again that that 1601 in the catechism it doesn't it's nothing wrong in there but they are But they're switching the order of things yep i mean they're saying that one is more important than the other the other but that's the problem yeah exactly it's precisely the problem and we can even now
if we look then at the new right of marriage okay itself it's intriguing you know one author points out that Effectively um the new right more or less is completely drawn up from whole cloth and it emits of a huge amount of possible varieties they they did some quick analysis and they come up with a number something along the lines of uh 20 million possible Ways of doing the marriage right as opposed to the one and only one way of doing it in the traditional right but we can say a couple of things about the
right in and of itself so firstly um firstly that it doesn't it downplays a great deal in the right itself the question of Marriage you know so he points out that the traditional marriage states two times that god established marriage for the continuation of the human race and every traditional marriage reference to children is asking god for the blessing of children confirming that children are a blessing of god and indeed i can add to that that the nuptial blessings that we discussed a little bit last time as we saw Make very clear that um we
ask the church asks for the couple that they see their children and their children's children under the third and fourth generation it's very much in the presence of the mind of the church in giving this right now the author points out in contrast the novus order of marriage right teaches that marriage provides man the constant help of a woman so that woman And man should no longer be two but one flesh and the references to children are more sparse in fact it's in a way stated almost as a wish in fact the novel sort of
right inquires whether the couple will accept children lovingly and then in the words the author sells the idea by praying may your children bring you happiness [Applause] so i mean we could say that it's understood that the couple are going to say yes we will accept children lovingly but it still is presented as a question [Music] and it doesn't speak of it as a duty or as a blessing but rather as a hope that it becomes a source of happiness and it's interesting because if you look At the notion of blessing then over sort of
writes does still keep the longer blessing that we looked at in a little detail last time but with some very intriguing uh differences okay um so just real quickly to speak of the first of the traditional blessings it says Listen with favor o lord to our prayers and graciously up graciously uphold the institution of marriage established by you for the continuation of the human race so that they who have been joined together by your authority may remain faithful together with your help now that same prayer is basically rendered in this way and then over sort
of right my dear friends let us turn to the lord And pray that he will bless with his grace this woman now married in christ and this man and that he will unite and love the couple he has joined in this holy bond so there's no reference any longer to the continuation of the human race and then in that longer blessing which can be multiple parts can be just ignored or left out so as in the words the rubrics uh that they'd be not too long or that They so as to shorten the blessing one
of the things that can be left out an option is that words can be said or they may be omitted is this bless them with children and help them to be good parents and may they live to see their children's children that's an option uh in the blessing you know so in other words you could go through it and say no no we don't actually wish for you that Blessing and the author you know being a little bit harsh says that with a few changes or with a few uh options that are available there it's
entirely possible that this right could be used for homosexual marriage as you can with all those different possibilities available You could choose bible readings omit those references to children and there you go again obviously it's not probably in the uh the first intention but unfortunately is itself open to that and then lastly again just looking at how this new mindset is discussed this this leveling Of the two we can look at humane vitae which uh maybe discuss in a moment um it's the encyclical published by pious sorry paul vi in 1968 which reiterated the church's
forbidding of the use of artificial contraception but even here so in paragraph 8 the pope says marriage then is far from Being the effect of chance or the result of the blind evolution of natural forces it is in reality the wise and provident institution of god the creator whose purpose was to affect and man his loving design as a consequence husband and wife through that mutual gift of themselves which is specific and exclusive to them alone develop that union of two persons in which they perfect one another Cooperating with god in the generation and the
rearing of new lives and then in paragraph nine finally this conjugal love is fikand fruitful is not confined holy to the loving interchange of husband and wife it also contrives to go beyond this to bring new life into being so even when he's defending and forbidding artificial contraception the way he talks about marriage is that firstly it's about this mutual gift for Themselves in which they as he says in paragraph 8 in which they perfect one another and that love is firstly directed towards each other but it's not limited to it it seems to go
beyond that by bringing a new life into the world in union with god's creative action so even here it's completely different perspective which is unfortunate because it's part Of the reason why there's going to be such an intense reaction against that encyclical and um maybe just the last quote to show this this mindset just being everywhere in the church you can look at um amoris leticia pope francis and the final relation of the synod of bishops that prepared it so in the final relation this is the Document published by the bishops to give to pope
francis to lead him to publish his exhortation so there we read that the second radical council defined marriage as a community of life and love putting love at the center of the family [Music] it's interesting because maurice leticia in the final relation will become very important for other reasons what we'll see perhaps a little bit later not today But when we look at marriage from the point of view of humanism it's very interesting right but again love is marriage is all about love and love of husband and wife right yeah yeah and then when that
goes away or if something happens to destroy that i mean i mean that this is the whole domino effect or the avalanche whatever Metaphor you want to use if you get rid of that principle part of the procreate and i'm reiterating what you've already said sorry but i'm just making a question um but if you get rid of that first point then what is left love great love should be there but if then if you get rid of if love goes away then you can get divorced and you can get remarried then you can have
same-sex Marriage then you can have i mean doors open all these things yep yeah again it's that'd be far beyond what say uh cardinal swennen's or cardinalization would have intended and they would have argued against certainly homosexual marriage he would have argued against divorce um but they're arguing part of the principle and once you get rid of the principle it's all open yep Yep they've shot themselves in the foot in a in a way in a way right um so lastly just to quote well actually this is a little bit up elsewhere what i think
might be good now [Applause] might be to look at that in cycle i mentioned my vt a little bit more in detail because as i said it's really kind of where this the Effect where these liberals are driving becomes incarnate and more easily visible in humane vitae pope paul vi is going to definitively reiterate and the traditional teaching of the church on artificial contraception saying that it is not permitted you cannot frustrate that natural part of that marital act it's Simply not uh in constant with the divine or the natural law now this document was
published uh in july 25th 1968. it's a middle of a miserable summer uh there's a lot of revolutions a lot of student protests all this and just a lot of charming nature now maybe just a little bit of context of this encyclical beyond what we've already seen is that Basically all the protestant denominations by this point have admitted contraception beginning with the anglicans at their what's called their lambeth conference as a group meeting of all their uh dignitaries as it were um in 1930 where they permitted anglican couples to use birth control under certain circumstances
they didn't say it's all Fine whenever you want but they said in principle at times it can be legitimate now that was the same year that cassie kenubi was published by pius x he published that at the very end of the year and of course so everybody's talking about the anglicans you know which are not the modern anglicans um are episcopalians who believe in nothing But anyways so this you know it's still a very big social institution in england and therefore for much of the world england was a very great world power at the time
so everyone's talking about this and obviously the pope has to address it and so he speaks about this question in the following terms through our mouth proclaims anew any use whatsoever of matrimony Exercised in such a way that the act is deliberately frustrated in his natural power to generate life his offense against god i'm sorry against the law of god and of nature and those who indulge in such a are branded with the guilt of a grave sin so it's part of the divine law and the natural law anything that would frustrate the natural act
So again that's and that's what's going to be reiterated though not in such strong language by paul the sixth now also at the same time frame you have a famous supreme court case here in the united states uh in 1965 so about three years earlier called griswold versus connecticut um basically griswold was a representative of planned parenthood the great joy of planned parenthood in that case declared Unconstitutional a state law of connecticut which for bad married couples from using contraception under the guise of their right to privacy in fact this will be the case that
sets the precedent that leads to roe versus wade and then so just in a to read a kind of a short summary of the case from a harvard law site in a seven to two ruling the supreme Court concluded that connecticut's state law against contraceptives and counseling counseling violated quote a zone of privacy that is inherent in the constitution even though the constitution does not explicitly protect a general rights privacy there are various degrees within the bill of rights that connect penumbras or zones and establish a right to privacy [Applause] It's various penumbras so penumbra
means a shadow it's like you have a shadow on the right so whatever anyways and this isn't this isn't a law podcast or a supreme court podcast but it's that word is fascinating in supreme court language yeah because that is anything can be can be put into a number oh yeah of course yeah anything yeah which of course is how they'll find out oh yeah by the way you know there's this right to you know kill the babies in your Mother's womb i mean of course this is what the founders had in mind they were
clearly they just couldn't quite articulate it yet it's an idiot anyway sorry it's not very quiet um so and the last thing as far as the context and this perhaps most relevant is that there had been a commission that i've kind of referenced a few times before established under john the 23rd in 1963 Right before he died in fact it was meant to study some of these more modern techniques for example the pill which had been developed in 1960 that commission was continued by paul vi to study the question more in depth it came to
include in the end about 60 experts a lot of whom were belgians which is important and at the same time pope paul vi also added to that a commission specifically of 16 Bishops of whom one was cardinal swens it'll be interesting uh now a majority of the members of both of those commissions the one of 60 experts and the one of 16 bishops made recommendations to allow artificial contraception in the case of the bishops nine of them said that there's nothing intrinsically wrong with artificial contraception out of the 16 3 only said no And four
of them were like i [Music] don't know okay and this the experts the majority of that commission also recommended it which is interesting because it shows a certain moral fortitude on the part of paul vi to go against it because he he went against all the uh the majority of those bishops and those experts As well as emote but there's a great quote this is from the notes of cardinal swennens once the encyclical was published he writes and this is actually a bit of a summary of the notes but the encyclical has shocked so many
people because it went even before beyond what anyone foresaw in conservating in conservatism And as a reaffirmation the doctrine announced 30 years ago by pius xi the pope has taken his again a decision against the commission of 60 experts against the cardinal and episcopal commission of 15 members or 16 members against the uh world congress of laity held in 1967 against the great mass of theologians and against a good number of households again that's cardinal swenis And for him he's like everybody is saying this is fine and the pope now is saying it's not you
know so he was pretty upset this is probably a very strange thing to say on an sspx podcast but i have a great amount of respect for paul vi for doing that no no i mean it was that's getting yeah and i mean like i said it shows a moral Fortitude and a devotion to the traditional doctrine i mean it's there's there was a document i read in preparing this is put together by a belgian leader cleric who was involved in some of these uh deliberations but he uh commented there was a back and forth
of letters between the pope and carlos sweden and so you could see the fact the pope was personally wounded by the fact That they were gone against him but he stood firm it's like i have to my conscience commands me to do this yeah good so um but obviously what that entitles is there's a lot of uh opposition and it might be good to look juiced at the reaction to belgian episcopal under the guidance of uh cardinal swennes because That kind of set the tone for a lot of countries we may say now they published
their reaction on the 30th of august of the same year it was primarily written by monsignor phillips uh who was a um a theologian who had been instrumental in riding Lumen gensium at the council so he's not just nobody and it's interesting the spirit we may say of the the bishops not all of whom are on the same page um is described by cardinal swenos in this way this meeting of the bishops which leads to the document opened with two tendencies the one which i could resume in this way roma lucuta s causa finita est
so romer Spoken the cause is finished in other words we can't we can't defend this the other ten says this is really good the other tendency which i would resume by this other adage which he actually takes from aristotle a friend to plato but more a friend to truth in other words we're going to be loyal we love plato we love And plato here is popolo 6. we love paul vi but we love the truth more in other words the pope got it wrong and the thing is like i said this reaction is going to
really be the heart of the document that the belgian bishops eventually published because cardinal sweden's drives things and that's going to shape basically a lot of reactions by a lot of bishops a lot of priests in handling this question Okay look there's the formal statement of artificial contraception but we're going to go in the direction of the fact that there is this love you know that's an independent end of marriage which the pope himself even speaks like that so he just doesn't draw the consequences that a lot of other people draw from it now just
very briefly this document has a basic structure of three parts firstly we must admit to the pope even In non-infallible judgments conclusion we must submit to the pope middle part yeah there's some leeway it's great it's very well done right so for example in with a central part of it which is where they get to the heart of it they're stated okay so after all this we have to submit to the pope we have to you know Lay down our judgment at the authority in the church if nevertheless someone competent in the matter incapable of
forming for themselves a well-established personal judgment which of course supposes a necessary information comes after certain points of a serious examination before god To different conclusions they are within their rights to follow them within the domain of their conviction provided that they were you know remain disposed to continue loyally and they're searched for the truth so basically if somebody in studying this question that the pope has just issued a judgment on the fact that there cannot be use of Artificial contraception and they come to the conclusion oh actually no i think i can well they
can do it it's great as then they continue on even in this case they have to preserve sincerely their adhesion to christ into his church and to recognize respectfully the importance of the supreme magisterium as the constitution lumen ginsum prescribes which i wrote Again monster phillips they are also to watch not to compromise the common good and the salvation of their brethren by an unhealthy agitation or my even more strong news my putting into question the principle of authority in other words they can continue to do what they have but they have to be Respectful
they can't come out and say the pope has no idea what he's talking about and we should all go against him but i judge that he's wrong yeah i mean they have a few other areas where they um kind of elaborate that point but the basic points been made not to belabor this point uh but it is Striking here this this document or this conclusion basically outlines when a according to uh according to sweden's right um well he was yeah all the bishop was published under all the bishop's name this is this is kind of
a guideline for in their mind as to when you are allowed to dissipate oh right the problem here and and people would say Why is it that on an sspx podcast why is it father loop you are you are mocking a a cardinal or or saying hey he's saying disobedience but you are disobedient here's the here's the distinction though magisterium the or the the teaching tradition is on the side of of everything that the sspx is saying there is nowhere in tradition or in the magisterium the teaching power of the church that says this is
ever okay and They're still saying go ahead and disobey the pope on it yeah it's moreover and moreover what we're dealing with here is a pope who's issuing a judgment where he's reiterating what his predecessors have taught again and again effectively um multiple obviously the question of artificial birth control is not something that let's say for example i don't know saint pius fifth would have Been really engaged you know it's not impossible because there would have been something that people could do but it wasn't as pressing an issue um so obviously only a few more
recent popes had talked about but they based themselves on various solid principles namely the first and primary purpose of marriage being precisely to give life And it's something that they had founded on the divine law saying this is part of the divine law as we saw from pius 11th and paul vi is simply saying that's it i i in my conscience must go against this and uphold what the church my predecessors have always taught and now what we see in these men is like oh okay you can say that but effectively my own personal conscience
well-informed conscience which uh allows me to go against it but how Are they forming their conscience right if not by the teachings of the church conscience is not the root of morality no it's not anything there's one catechism too right i mean it's the same this same level of argumentation is the same thing we see with john f kennedy and i think when we were talking about the americanism where he says okay look you know i will basically not be guided in my public life as a Catholic but rather by my private conscience which raises
the question what's forming your private conscience if not the moral teachings of the church so again um so again they finished the thing um uh well maybe just one last quote from the document before concluding they they say uh the bishops say it's necessary to recognize according to the traditional Doctrine the last or ultimate practical rule is dictated by a conscience duly um enlightened according to the collection of criteria exposed in gauri mespas and that the judgment on the opportunity of a new transmission of life belongs in the last resort to the spouses themselves who
ought to decide before god but again from their point of view That conscience is not being formed by the teaching authority of the church but from somewhere else and from their perspective ultimately from medicine and modern science is what it would come down to [Music] now wow just to kind of wrap everything together that we've seen today and it's kind of present because this is Only one of the aspects in which marriage has been deformed um since vatican ii right um but this what we're seeing this shift of perspective on what marriage is and is
for but equalizing of the ends and in a way making practically speaking the end of the common good of the spouses Of primary over children is deeply intertwined with those statistics we were seeing earlier um it's it's um if conjugal love is that primary end of marriage and something fundamentally independent of procreation as you yourself said it becomes very difficult to justify forcing a couple to stay married right if they cease to have This love for another you know and again we're going to see that a little bit more in detail with the question of
amoris leticia which we'll see more in detail when we look at the marriage and so far as it's been reinterpreted in light of ecumenism and there'll be several aspects there as well as the fact that you've had especially in catholic countries an absolute cratering of child rearing It's not merely catholic countries but you know there are ones where it's strikingly notable right um now just to conclude damitay and his uh he has a section uh of the after council and he talks about himanovite and he noticed that paul vi was so wounded by that widespread
and vocal opposition on both the part of laity and clerics To humanity that he did not publish another encyclical for the entirety of the rest of his pontificate so that was published in 1968 he dies in 1978 so last he'd published like six or seven in the first five years nothing in the last ten and practically i think that's maybe a good either microcosm or image of kind of what's happened in the leaders of the church They've in a way done the same thing in this question the ancient marriage they speak often times in such
ways to confuse the faithful and effectively allow them to practice the means that they even the leaders will denounce when they speak about it as being contrary law of god i mean there's no way that let's say 60 70 percent of catholic women in the us are regularly using highly effective means Of contraception in other words oh practically denying them procreation is the reason they got married right if the leadership in the church is not making a point of giving them that formation you know in one way or another and it's the real issue that
we see in the church is not the questions pope francis said that you know catholics being made you know spoken of reading Like rabbits but rather that they've been led to have a truly impoverished and incomplete love or knowledge or understanding i should say of what catholic marital love is the fact that it is in fact the ability to share with god to communicate life and that according to the traditional teaching the church it's always the occasion whenever they Have that joy with their spouse to be open to that life even if you know god
or nature doesn't you know bless it at that moment um and only you know in very exceptional circumstances that are independent of their will you know to make use of marriage even in such a way that it'll make it less likely that they'd have a new life um It's precisely giving back that spirit of sacrifice that willingness that openness to life that will see a return to this healing of those disastrous statistics that we're seeing so in other words it's kind of depressing to see what's going on in the church in the wider scale but
we have the answer it's what we saw in last episode which is a beautiful answer it's Crucifying it is but nevertheless the source of true joy of the joy that god has in his eternal let's say um generation of the sun so um father that was um it was a great reminder and thank you for putting that All together for us that was um you know these things or as as catholics we know these things or we should know these things in any case uh but to see it all in that timeline that was excellent
thank you very much um yeah it's been my pleasure and thank you for having me thank you [Music] you