i have my laptop here i've got a blank notepad and a timer for one hour i'm going to show you how to come up with a research topic in less than one hour let's go the first step i'm going to recommend is that you just start listing your not even research topics right now just things that you're interested in remember in my previous video on how to define the best questions for economics research i wanted you to make a contribution and i wanted to do something that you're interested in so let's go ahead and figure
out interests that we have before we start going into what the contributions are gonna be contributions come way way later let's list interest first [Music] so it just took a few minutes to write down some topics that i have and the way i was focusing my interests were on the things that i would like to know more about something that i would like to become an expert in so the first at my list was youtube because you know here we are on youtube i'm trying to get better at making youtube videos and understanding youtube and
i really don't think that there are people who are investigating the economics behind youtube i think that might be an area where i could make a contribution but you know again most of this right now is what are you interested in so youtube was a natural fit given that we're talking on youtube right now one of the other things i started thinking about is developing countries and haiti haiti is where my research is in economics as a professor and so of course i want to develop that a little bit more i also put down cell
phones cell phones i kind of see as like working with all of those with you know people are consuming youtube on their cell phones you know how have cell phones affected developing countries or specifically in haiti i'm trying to think of that's the technology i think is interesting again i also have some other research that deals with cell phones and their effects on society so i decided to just throw that in there in case there were some research ideas that i wanted to pursue then i started putting some things i thought like they're just starting
to get bigger and maybe i want to make sure that i understand those things so that way if i have opportunities to work in those spaces that i'm there so i put video game economics just because i think with fortnite uh you know maybe fall guys i haven't seen much economics on there but with what's coming in video games it feels like that space is going to get bigger much quicker and so i thought maybe i want to be head on that same with crypto and video games i've seen some companies that are involved in
crypto currencies and blockchain and how that's going to affect video games i don't think there's that much work there and it's something i'm kind of interested in so i might want to pursue that and then i put pokemon not quite as a joke but um i just feel like you know my kids love pokemon it comes up all the time at home i just thought like oh are there any like research questions about pokemon that i put in there so you can see that i don't have like specific research topics yet right now it's just
what are the things that i'm interested in what are the things that i'd be willing to go and put some time into to try and learn and to try and contribute now i want to go ahead and go under each of these and just start thinking of some questions that i have in there what are some research topics that come to mind as i start listing out these topics and i'm just gonna you know give a couple of minutes now let me just see what comes as i am looking at this and thinking about the
questions so now i have about 20 different questions that are related to these topics that i'm interested in and the way that i came up with them were just like just questions that came to my mind um i think the funnest one was down at the pokemon topic i i played the pokemon card games with my son and i'm always thinking like what's the game theory involved here and like what are the best cards which cards would you never use in an actual game like which cards are just completely worthless because you only have a
limited number of cards that you can put in your deck why you know which ones are you just gonna completely get rid of it seems like you could pretty easily create like a production possibilities curve for the pokemon cards and figure out which one should be ruled out so maybe i want to create that production possibilities curve um so so that was just something that as i was thinking about this topic of pokemon and what are some research topics that i would get into while i did it i remembered that experience playing with him something
that's interesting is that one of the interests i had listed earlier was just developing countries really broadly and that was just way too broad when i looked at that i just didn't know even what to ask but when i asked about haiti when i started diving into that i was able to get a couple of questions that were on my mind with haiti and finally there was youtube where these are just things that i think about with my channel things i would like to understand here you know how do views evolve how do content creators
choose topics that was actually one that came from a conversation i had a couple of weeks ago with someone talking about how people stream video games how do people decide whether they're going to stream fortnite or fall guys or league of legends like if somebody moves over to that space you know what are the effects on that creator and there's a whole lot of strategy that goes into those decisions and i was interested in you know is there a way i could look at that and i thought well okay that i'll put that down on
the list some of these questions i don't know how i'm going to research but that's not what i'm worried about right now i'm worried about just creating questions and then i worry about it later you should not be thinking can i actually do this right now right now you should just be thinking about the things that you're interested in and then the questions you would like answered on that topic now that you've filled out a page of questions that you're interested in you want to start trimming it down you want to say which of the
questions that i asked are going to be the most likely to produce something pretty soon and here are some ways that you might want to trim that down first you want to know what your goal is in terms of the contribution okay remember we're trying to move towards a contribution we've started with interest we've been focusing on that solely now we're moving towards contribution what are the things that i want to create what are the things that i want to learn which topics do i have the most likely chance of actually telling us something new
but if your goals contribution you also need to think about what is going to be that final product is it going to be something that you're going to publish in a peer-reviewed journal an academic journal that top economists are interested in getting into or is this something that you just want to put up on your website and say hey i did this kind of thing and here's proof that i learned something and you're going to try and get some attention to it either by sharing it on reddit or maybe you share it on twitter some
some way like that if you understand what your goal is that's going to help you understand which topics that you can go pursue so for me the topic that i want to pursue isn't going to be something that ends up in a peer-reviewed journal it's not going to be held up to the highest academic standards just because i'm trying to demonstrate research processes for you and so the end goal of this is going to be something that i want the most amount of people to do so the goal my goal with this project is to
write an essay by the end of the time i do all these videos and that essay is going to describe what i found related to this topic so now that i understand that goal i think actually i'm going to rule out most of my haiti questions the haiti questions they're going to be really involved they're going to be require like a lot of work for me to make the contribution that would be worth that work and so right now i'm not going to pursue these maybe these are things that i want to pursue later i
can put them in notebook i can put them in some sort of document that i can search online but for now i don't think i'm going to pursue any of these haiti ideas funny enough like one of the pokemon ideas might be worth pursuing like that production possibilities curve i i think i might end up doing that one day and that would be something that i wouldn't send to a journal but would have fun writing on my website now i'm looking over the youtube policies and i'm seeing some things that i think might work out
again this is going to get to the data that i want to collect like how am i going to do this and what is my end goal like i do want to understand youtube better and so it's going to be i think you're gonna have this feeling too where you start thinking about questions and you wonder if you can actually do anything on that and you need to push through that you need to say right now i'm not worried about it there's so many times where i thought like oh there's no way i would be
able to do this and then i see friends who had like even more ridiculous ideas they just had these these huge ideas and i said like this is so silly that you're thinking about that there's no way you're gonna get done but because they had those ideas and they pursued them they ended up making huge contributions whereas i was always confined by what i thought was possible which then confined me even more to just doing something really small so it's good to think really big right now because there's no constraints just just try and think
as big as you can so i've narrowed it down to three questions now what i want to do is start thinking about what i would be able to demonstrate through doing this research because again i'm i'm guessing that you're the kind of person that wants to demonstrate some skills or develop some skills as you're working on this project you're not so interested in getting a peer-reviewed publication right like that we're not worried about that process right now you want to demonstrate some sort of understanding and so i'm just going to list under each of these
questions what i expect to be able to talk about or to think about as i try to answer these questions so now i've got my three questions and i've got the topics that i think are going to come up so how to video views evolve what i'm thinking about here is talking about competition and how competition on youtube or on the creator space differs from like competition and maybe movies or television um i think that could be a really interesting angle to go with this um with content creators responding to youtube policies i'm thinking about
incentives what kind of incentives are we creating for creators and this actually could be a really important question to answer with what's going on with the future of the economy right like more people are getting online that participating in the creator economy how do the policies shape the content that we get how careful do we have to be about what we're creating and then on the pokemon card production possibilities frontier you know curve whatever i put data collection that's not really a skill like i have to do that for the other two and then i
also put strategy so i don't think this is going to be one that really shows off what i want to show off right now so already i'm leaning away from the pokemon card topic i also think i might lean away from video views right now and i think i'm going to land on how do content creators respond to youtube policies so i'm less than 30 minutes into this process i've already narrowed down my research topic pretty significantly and i'm starting to get at like a vision of what this could become but i still i'm not
there yet we need to get a little bit more specific on this otherwise it's just a pretty broad thing now i happen to know some of the policy changes that have happened recently just in my time the things that have come up are coppa and ad role changes so kappa is child online privacy protection act i think is what the full thing is and this was this concern that you know youtube was able to suggest videos to children and it was a big kerfuffle and last year in 2019 there were some issues about whether your
channel was going to be affected by policy changes youtube was making another change just happened recently and that's when they started putting mid-roll ads on videos that were eight minutes long so you used to have to make a video 10 minutes or longer if you wanted mid-roll ads that is the ads that pop up in the middle of your video now they've changed it so that way if your video is eight minutes long you can still qualify for those ads so it'd be really interesting to see how people respond like are you seeing a lot
of people right there that 10 minute mark uh after before the change and then they actually shift down they go to eight minutes that'll be a really interesting behavioral change that actually as i'm describing it i want i can see that that's gonna be like a really precise question that i could ask okay so my question right now is how did youtube creators respond to the change in mid-roll ads policy so i'm seeing it evolve but i think i'm not quite there yet because what i would like to do is narrow it down a little
bit more to make sure that when i go research it i can find it and one of the questions that's popping up in my mind is how in the world am i going to measure this like there are just millions and millions of hours of content uploaded like daily and might even be in the billions i forget what the exact numbers are but how am i going to go and track this down who who's in my sample i guess is what i'm thinking about and so i would like to have people who are maybe more
sensitive to this so you definitely need people who are qualified for ads so i'm not going to look at just random videos i want to look at people who have a track record as well so i want established creators um i'm thinking out loud right now so so maybe people who already have a hundred thousand subscribers their silver play button or maybe a million their gold play button um maybe i look at the top creators maybe i'm looking at like the top 100 creators um maybe i'd have to find a list let's go ahead and
just pull up a list and see if i've got something right here so i've pulled up this wikipedia page on the most subscribed channels and i'm getting kind of like a mixed view from this on the one hand i'm seeing like really popular creators like pewdiepie mr beast but then i also see a ton of musicians and um just entertainment channels people that i don't even think are going to be sensitive to this so like taylor swift is on here taylor swift does not care about youtube ads when she's creating her music videos so that's
not going to be a good person to target for this i probably don't want them in my sample so who do i get in there you know mr beast on the other hand he might be somewhat sensitive to this so i do want him the sample i just realized that i covered up my timer as i've been working on this we still got plenty of time so what i'm going to try and do is find like a list of youtube channels that have more than a million subscribers like or maybe like in this range of
1 million to 5 million i don't know i'm going to try and narrow the range i don't know exactly yet but i've got an idea that that's what i need to do and then i'm going to look at their video link so really what i want to know is how did video length change in response to the mid role ads policy for creators with 1 million to 5 million uh subscribers so that's a really specific question it's something i can definitely pursue and i think that's gonna be interesting i think if i write about that
if i talk about it here that's gonna be something that people are really interested in and there's lots of economics involved in this question because you're responding to incentives i really like this one i think i may go with this and this is great like this is not something that i thought of right like hey i've still got a whole like 23 minutes to spare and i've got a research topic a really specific research question just by going through this pretty simple process if you do this let me know in the comments below so that
way i can steal your research ideas totally getting right there i just want to know if this is working out for you and maybe we can give each other feedback in the comments as i continue the series you'll see more of these videos right here we'll see you around