we want to start off by saying that today we are of course in amsterdam and it's the capital of the netherlands and the netherlands was the first country in the world who legalized gay marriage actually in 2001 and so we wanted to start off with a with a kind of a straightforward question to you are you in favor of gay marriage of legalizing that by law well i'm in favor of marriage and i'm in favor of the continuity of marriage and i think it's a reasonable social experiment to extend that the way it has been
extended so i mean i mean homosexuality has been around forever it looks like particularly on the male end of the distribution that has a fairly powerful biological component it seems like a reasonable experiment i mean it leaves open questions because we we have no idea what the long-term viability of such relationships might be compared to heterosexual relationships that's a completely open question and we also don't know to what degree it's optimal for the development of children to have both a male and female role model close by but my suspicions are those things can be dealt
with in an effective manner and i suspect that it's better for children to have two parents than one now i think the conservatives who objected to the legalization of gay marriage had their point because they believed that the institution of marriage had had been under sustained assault for a substantial amount of time which is something i also happen to believe and so they had the reasons for resisting further change but i think you can make a strong conservative argument for the utility of of gay marriage as well as a libertarian or liberal argument so we'll
see and we've also developed a consensus around that that's pretty much universal across the west and so that's how we decide things we develop a consensus and it doesn't look like it's ushered in the apocalypse so so far so good well the reason we ask is because please don't well we actually have a quote of you about your opinion on gay marriage uh and regarding gay marriage in australia and you've said quote i would be against it if it was backed by cultural marxists because it isn't clear to me whether it will satisfy the ever-increasing
demand for an assault on traditional modes of being um but don't you think that opposing gay marriage just because it was also it's also in the agenda as you say of cultural marxists is is problematic and it's kind of against your principles as a principally liberal person i said if right so if you read the quote again that's what it started with i mean it's complicated when when you're trying to determine what stance to take on a particular issue because it's very complicated to determine just exactly what the issue is so for example with this
notorious bill c-16 or perhaps my notorious response to it my uh those who regard themselves as my enemies chose to focus on the element of the legislation that that was relevant to at least in principle relevant to the well-being of transgender people now i'm not so sure it was relevant to the well-being of transgender people but because i looked at the methodology that was used to uh do the public surveys for example prior to the to the introduction of the legislation and they were handled in an absolutely incompetent manner and and i think but the
the issue was with bill c-16 well was it about the rights of transgender people or was it about the desire of a certain uh ideological group to write a social constructionist view of gender into canadian law or was it about compelled speech it's like it's not obvious you have to be a careful diagnostician to make such judgments i believed that it was fundamentally an issue of compelled speech and the desire to write a social constructionist view of gender into canadian law and so i opposed it on those grounds and i think i was correct now
people could say well you know isn't it rather reprehensible of you to object to the extension of rights to transgender individuals it's like well depends on your level of analysis so these are complicated things it's maybe good that you brought up bill c-16 because there's also been two recent hot topics uh i don't know if you know but in the netherlands three weeks ago the first official non-gender passport was given to a dutch citizen at the same time in the u.s of course the new trump bill which considers to narrowly define gender as something that's
immutable and that's totally cons totally based on genitalia at birth is is now a potential law so if you had to choose between these two laws which one would you pick well if you're transgendered is it immutable i don't know right neither does anyone else and so there's tremendous incoherencies in the theory so at the moment for example it's perfectly reasonable to formulate the proposition and and this is this is very characteristic of of let's say the ideological types who drove bill c-16 to say you can be ma a man born in a woman's body
which is a biologically determinist argument and to say that gender is socially constructed and to say that it's a personal choice it's like sorry all three of those things cannot simultaneously be true so there's going to be a variety of legislative responses to that but mostly it's just incoherent and i also think that it's driven by something deeper it's driven at least in part by the desire to destabilize uh traditional perceptual and cognitive categories and i see that as part of an assault on the idea of categorization itself that's been undertaken with a fair bit
of success in the university since the 1970s and so generally speaking i'm opposed to such things i don't believe that introducing confusion about gender identity into the lives of young people at an early age is going to have a net positive consequence we'll see but i doubt it but wouldn't you be also against the trump bill because like as you said it is also a way in which the law compels a certain identity upon you which is the reason you opposed bill 16. so how would you go about what is your position on this well
i opposed bill c-16 because it compelled my speech in a particular manner yeah it wasn't that it compelled an identity upon me it was very specific in that in the entire history of english common law there has never been legislation that required people to to utter particular phrases now you could be there were limitations on what you could say that's a whole different thing and you know i'm no fan in general of limitations on what you can say but there are certain legal limitations that are reasonable you can't incite to crime for example and that
seems appropriate but it was a matter of of compelled expression and it's also the case that in 1942 the americans decided at the supreme court level that such requirements were unconstitutional and the fact that it's unprecedented in english common law history and unconstitutional by american standards indicated to me that it was a very bad piece of legislation which it most certainly was especially the gender provision so here's the argument biological sex gender identity gender expression and sexual preference are independent okay they're not the definition of dependent is that there's a strong statistical relationship between them
could be correlational could be causal it is in fact causal it's also correlational but it's an unbelievably tight linkage so that the overwhelming majority of people who are uh a particular biological sex identify with that sex it's 99.97 percent okay the overwhelming majority of people who are of a given biological sex and an isomorphic gender identity express their gender in accordance with those two uh fundamental uh elements of their identity and that would be more perhaps something in the range of 95 assuming that one in 20 is playing with fashion and self-presentation in a gender-bending
manner which is not uncommon that's been going on for a very long time and then of this of the people who are of a given biological sex the the isomorphic gender identity and who present themselves that way the overwhelming majority are heterosexual that is not independent it's the very opposite of independent even though that's not now the law and then the other element is there is a strong element of biological proclivity along all of those dimensions now it's not it's not complete obviously anyone with any sense understands that people are quite mutable in their self
and cultural presentation i mean we are people we are creatures with long developmental histories and we can learn but the idea that biology doesn't play a strong role in influencing phenomena at every every one of those levels of analysis is absolutely preposterous and so and that's pushed very hard by the social constructionists and i think that's reprehensible it flies in the face of of it flies in the face of anything reasonably defined as fact and it does no one any favors well not least because you can't say well you're a man born in a woman's
body it's like well is that a biologically deterministic argument yes or no so what are we saying you can be a man born in a woman's body and that's biological but if you're a woman born in a woman's body that's socially constructed it's like really that's supposed to be an argument that's it's it's beyond preposterous so