MOOC perinatal mental health in the first 1000 days A project by Module 1: Mental health and perinatal mental disorders Personality disorders in the perinatal period Dr Anthony Bègue, Child psychiatrist, Hospital practitioner (Erasme Centre, Antony) Hello, I am Anthony Bègue, child psychiatrist and hospital doctor at the Erasme facility. Together with Dr Valérie Garez, head of the PPUMMA team, we have chosen to talk to you about personality disorders in the perinatal period. Why this particular period?
Pregnancy does induce psychiatric changes, which will be expanded on by other speakers, but it is above all a maturational crisis for a pregnant woman, allowing the formation of a new identity for this mother-to-be. And it's also a moment of investment for this unborn child. It is also a state of great psychiatric vulnerability with, firstly, the possibility of also being in a state of asking for help, a relational state that allows the mothers-to-be to ask for help from the people who are present for them at that moment.
This is also a special moment, since there is a resurgence of the past, with the reactivation of older emotions, related to childhood. Thus, in the context of personality disorders, it is a special moment that poses the risk of mental decompensation for these mothers. It is therefore a particular state where the work in child and perinatal psychiatry allows work on the question of mother-baby interactions.
And as Delzenne said: "The finest and earliest marker of the mother's intrapsychic difficulties is above all the disharmony of interactions. " We chose to preferably focus on borderline personality disorder because it is an important disorder in the general population, from 1 to 6%, and it is particularly represented in clinical populations, since it is estimated to be 15 to 20%. Two thirds of these patients are women.
In the presentation, we chose to be able to talk primarily about mothers, but it is also about fathers. So, we will continue with the presentation of the mothers for a while, but you can extend it to the question of the family and the parents. The prevalence of postnatal depression is estimated to be 10-18% of the general population.
It was found that borderline personality disorder and postnatal depression are often comorbid. This is a particular disorder that causes a lot of discontinuity. One of the possible etiologies in this interaction disorder is borderline personality disorder, as it shows a lot of discontinuity in this framework.
This is the prototype of interactive discontinuities with a permanent confrontation with the unpredictability of maternal functioning which is sometimes satisfactory, sometimes inadequate, with a mother who can be overwhelmed by her fantasies and internal concerns. Within the baby's framework, it is subject to great insecurity as a result of this unpredictability and the impossible nature of anticipating maternal emotions. We will compare the framework of maternal symptoms with what the baby can express, show, feel in the context of its interactions with a mother who has a borderline personality disorder.
Mothers show frantic efforts to avoid abandonment that is real or imagined. Thus, the baby is constantly abandoned and taken back in turn. It abandons and resumes relationships.
Interpersonal relationships are unstable and intense and they veer, for the mother, between extreme idealisation and devaluation. The baby reflects and receives its parental projections. The mother sometimes experiences a disturbance of identity, which is marked by instability and inconsistency of the self-image and self-concept.
Therefore, the baby can have a mirrored parental representation that is quite fragile, that is difficult to unify. Maternal impulsivity which can be in one or two areas can be experienced in a complex way by the baby within the intense emotional and affective reactions. The mother's repeated behaviours, gestures, or threats of suicide or self-harm potentiates these emotional movements.
Affective instability due to a marked mood reactivity makes the baby react, once again, to these emotional variations. Intense and inappropriate tantrums with difficulty in controlling anger can have an impact on the baby who may be inappropriately stimulated which in turn may activate negative emotional reactions. Regarding chronic feelings of emptiness, the baby reactivates or fills this emptiness.
When stressful situations occur, certain persecutory ideations or severe dissociative symptoms may also occur in the mother, and the baby can potentially be included in this delusional discourse. We will describe some of the research data, linking it a little bit to parenthood with borderline personality disorder. First, the question of the impact on the pregnancy with physical consequences or associations, in relation to the pregnancy, with an increase in gestational diabetes, premature rupture of membranes, risk of chorioamniotitis, but also prematurity.
In the psychopathological context, there is also an increase in vulnerability signals and signs, especially with the issue of substance abuse, follow-ups that can be erratic and chaotic, and unstable or precarious living conditions. We would also like to present a qualitative research, published in 2019. This study is based on interviews with six mothers who are hospitalised in the context of a mother-baby hospitalisation unit who have been diagnosed with a borderline personality disorder.
They were interviewed to understand how they felt when their baby was crying. The results of this study show different themes in relation to these mothers' experiences of their baby's cry. One of the first themes is actually the question of their own beginnings as children, including the question of intergenerational trauma.
That is, the history of violence, traumas, losses that these mothers may have experienced in their own childhood. They also refer to their own attachment difficulties they may have had with their parents or attachment figures they may have had during their childhood. The cry of these babies also affects their psyche.
That is, it can be a cry that awakens rather intense negative emotions. They may say, "The cry of this baby that's waiting for me. " They can also be put in a quite intense emotional and physiological state, which is exactly what we can see with patients with borderline personality disorder, with intense variations, the roller coaster, in the context of that particularly stressful moment that can be the cry of a baby.
They also experience the occurrence of negative beliefs and thoughts that tend to be automatic. Also the feeling of being alone, sometimes with feelings of dissociation. That is, to have: "The good mother in me that wants to go, but at the same time, this other woman who can't.
" There may be what is described as a mental shutdown, a cessation of thought, as part of that particular cry that a baby may have when in distress. There is also the activation of survival mode with a hesitation that is difficult to reconcile, of wanting to leave or of wanting to act. And this acting out can also take the baby into account with the possible apparition of violent thoughts This provides a link with the care provided for the prevention of shaken babies.
At such times, there may also be the occurrence of particularly intense suicidal thoughts. The domino effect, which is described as being the fifth theme, also refers to the perception that these women may have of others' opinions. That is, "How will my relatives, or strangers in the street, for example, look at me when this baby shows signs of discomfort?
" Other quantitative studies may also use the research conditions used in attachment research. Whether it's the still face with newborns or babies, or the strange situation, when the babies start to walk. The still face is a time when these mothers are placed facing their babies.
There are three times, with a time of meeting and playing. A time of breaking off, where the mother is asked to keep a neutral face and to be in her thoughts, and a reunion. The breaking off moment is particularly interesting, as it allows one to see the baby's emotional reactions which can usually be moments of distress, of despair, but also of detachment.
With borderline mothers, at 3-month-old, it is observed that these babies cry more and relate differently to their mothers, compared to babies with mothers who do not have borderline personality disorder. They have more difficulty interpreting facial emotions of their babies. At 12-months-old, when attachment can be measured through the strange situation, a higher percentage of disorganised attachment is observed in babies.
This points to the fact that these babies are not able to develop a strategy to cope with the stress of separation. In the long term, longitudinal studies show a transgenerational transmission of maternal difficulties towards their baby. This can be observed in childhood through internalised disorders, such as mood disorders, externalised disorders, such as conduct or behavioural disorders.
These children will have a higher percentage of psychological disorders in adulthood and, in particular, a higher risk of borderline personality disorder. In conclusion, the importance of these situations determines an early intervention with an identification, if possible, within the maternity hospital, i. e.
from the prenatal stage. It allows for the implementation of adequate measures, the initiation of a follow-up and the collaboration with all the partners. This follow-up also allows for postnatal evaluation of parent-child interactions, being able to limit or even prevent relational distortions, supporting the child's psychoaffective development, refering the mother, the father and the triad - the dyad to mental health care.
This also makes it possible to refer the family to early childhood partners, such as maternal and child protection or the creche, for postnatal care of their child. If possible, involving other family members, if they are supportive, allows one to offer different interaction models to children. Lastly, it is also important to consider applying for Child Protection, if the situation requires it.
Thank you for your attention.