Good morning good morning everybody come on in grab a seat and if you are suffering like many of us are from anxiety don't worry the countdown music is over uh I want to welcome everybody to this session it's going to be a doozy uh in this session we are exploring how to maximize resource value while balancing economic and social impacts uh we're going to hear from pioneering Entrepreneurs who are revolutionary uh revolutionizing circular business model models and material governance here in Europe our panel will be delving into the complexities of critical raw materials from geostrategic
issues to societal choices and we'll be discussing Sustainable Solutions that enhance competitiveness across industrial value chains and again if you're just coming in come on in grab a seat and uh you know next time shoot to be early to the Panel like we asked you yesterday um we get ready uh those of you here and those of you arriving to challenge ideas and discover Which business models best promote uh circularity but before we start the panel I'd like to begin with a poll uh and it's a very simple poll question uh you know you do
it do it on the app and if you haven't downloaded the app I I I don't know what what what you're doing wrong with your life um but get on the app and let us know where You're from I mentioned this morning that we had folks from a hundred different countries uh in the building and I'd like to know how many of them are represented here so if you could pull out the app and answer the very simple question where are you from uh and if it's a a difficult question we we'll see what the
answers they're coming in now so only one person has answered from the country of Arrow a lot of Belgium so far though I think that's Just because it's the first couple that in Belgium and Finland that's there we go the the uh the two great uh great nations of Belgian and Finland in the house and I have a feeling they're just the only ones that can operate the thing Canary Island's well done Malta Belgium's still bigger than everybody else and uh Netherlands joins the frey right next to its best friend uh Germany they love each
other don't let don't let them fool you Dominican Republic really Taking up so much space and then little it tucked in there Netherlands now overwhelming Belgium and Finland as a Netherlands resident I'm really proud of the uh of these numbers coming in Taiwan Malta and Germany looks like one long German world word for a moment there now they don't Bosnian and herzo so boy Belgium Belgium shoulders out Netherlands I think that's a bigger font right now right now we it's it's we sort of see the big four we got a big four Right now now
it's a kind of a big-ish four it's a big-ish four really Belgium now it's now we're back to a big it's kind of a big three and a half now and I'm uh I'm honestly not certain how long I was going to say how long my narrating this will remain interesting but I I think we're we're well past the end of that so I'm just going to say welcome to everybody no matter where you're from uh welcome and uh and if you haven't Answered yet you're you're really not good at this uh though so so
but but congrat we've got a oh Bangladesh joining the FR I'm glad we waited for Bangladesh and uh and there were two uks one with a lowercase k and one with an uppercase K get your act together UK K and then you'll have bigger letters um I've got another question and uh and and the other question is what do you expect from this session I think there'll be less matching on that one less matching But what do you expect from the session I'm going to keep that poll going while the next speaker is uh talking
so answer quickly and then and then pay attention to the speaker because it be a fantastic and brief talk you don't be wasting the whole time you know trying to say what you expect out of the session so get that answer and quickly we'll look at the poll results after this first speaker but I do want to introduce our first speaker and start things off right Uh he is an eesc member a trade unionist and heavily involved in sustainability please welcome to the stage floran Marin P group two thank you so much for for being
here today thank you so much for uh for your interest in circularity my name is Marin Florian as the previous speaker mentioned and I'm coming from the European economic and social committee um well I'm actually proud to be here I'm proud because in 2015 my committee European economic and social committee proposed to have a platform a hub a One-Stop shop between stakeholders main stakeholders and public authorities it was in 2015 in our in one of our opinion one of my colleagues kilan was was the rapporter and today we have European circular economy stakeholder platform from
my perspective and from the committee's perspective this is a result in which Civil Society among also with uh with Public institution can cooperate can create synergies in order to boost circularity in the EU but also in the world but what is the role of the Civil Society in in cular raw material in promoting secularity well I see at least four directions first of all first of all uh in the decision- making process they are part of the consultation process and they are being involved Civil Society is really involved in amending amending regulations and Debating D
proposal of directives and regulations but also things like that the second from my perspective it's education because the Civil Society is part of the decision making process and it is involved at the grassroot level yesterday it was mentioned that uh uh that um uh local authorities are crucial for boosting circularity at the local level green deal will be implemented taking into account the involvement of The local authorities without member states without Civil Society without a partnership between all those the circular cular economy will be much difficult to implement so we are part of and we
have a responsibility in order to educate consumers but also our members I'm coming from the from the trade unionist uh movement and I have a responsibility for my members uh then the third one well Civil Society could be a watchdog Could be a Watch Dog for preventing green washing because it could be uh a situation like this but also in uh in uh tackling uh fake news we are seeing that in some member states in some part of Europe some products which are circular product which are har not harming the environment well are being used
in different uh in different uh propaganda issues uh electric vehicle for example I'm coming from Romania more exactly and I'm seeing this quite often uh then the Last one could be uh sharing best practice and the platform is doing this very well uh in order to to to share best practices and approaches in order to boost circularity it's obvious that we need Innovation and we need uh more knowledge in uh promoting better and implementing U circular economy but the problem is also access to Innovation because the Innovation should be well spreaded among the member States
among uh the states which don't have perhaps The possibility to access that uh technology access to waste is also a problem in some part of Europe but not only in Europe because waste is becoming more and more perceived as being a resource which is a resource and access to waste is is getting more and more difficult but what I'm seeing is that for all this we need dialogue and we need cooperation what I'm seeing is that market is not enough because Market cannot alone boost uh circular economy We we need regulation and we need other
kind of dialogue from my perspective I think that we need social dialogue because we are discussing about about e business models we need social dialogue and we need solidarity Europe has been built through solidarity everything which is lasting in this world every hour or all our achieve our achievement have been built through solidarity so we need it is imperative it is crucial to rebuild or and also to protect the European solidarity in order of course to boost circularity I have saw yesterday uh a lot of referrals to uh to uh uh to access to critical
raw materials competences and things like that well without skills without the proper involvement of the workers and without the right competences will be extremely difficult to implement uh circular economy and to have critical raw materials which are circular we need This kind of approach in order to share responsibility among workers and businesses in order to boost circularity but it's not an easy task we need to be sure that we are doing on the right thing also the consumers if they want to be involved and they will be involved in this process they have to understand
that they sacrifice they purchasing is really contributing to the circular economy so we have to also to build trust in order to boost circular economy And to discuss about the right business models in in in the circular economy of the future so European economic and social committee is working closely with all in all the legislative proposal we are quite involved in in how we will deal in the future with circular economy and with the critical raw material and we are open of course to debate and to to make Partnerships uh for uh for for boosting
this thank you so much I hope that we'll Have some concrete answers some very technical answers um from our panelist and I wish you a fruitful debate thank you so much thank you on uh let's uh before I bring up the next uh speaker uh let's let's take a look at the uh the word cloud and see what folks are hoping to get out of the session and uh as you can see it's it's it's very difficult to read uh but but you all have uh God so my here's my Favorite is right here is
uh is sustainable and Equitable Golds and sustainable Supply I mean Equitable Supply chains I mean it's it's it's tough when the word cloud doesn't let you have any spaces right like it's it just makes it difficult for you a lot of folks want to Innovation a lot of folks want to see Solutions uh and inspiration and insights as well as uh if you glued the Practical insights together with the insights I think uh I think insights Might just win out but uh but then then we've got the many worded answers it's it's difficult a lot
of uh complex uh and uh and some common desires for this session we're going to see if we can satisfy them as as we move on because I'm going to bring out the uh the chief sustainability officer from uffer please welcome Carl Franken Carl [Applause] thank you P for the introduction and uh thank you uh for having me to give this Introduction here um so the um title is yeah is circularity the cure for criticality it's a question I've put it as a statement and it's always good to start a bit again from the definitions
what are we talking about and what does these all really mean I I think we need to realize that criticality goes together with the Technologies of the future the things we need and it has been said already before it's very much linked to the energy Transition but we need to realize that there's also other things that we need the whole digital transition will also rely on this uh vast amount of of material so here you see a graph from one of the basic studies from the European jrc The Joint Research Center which laid the basis
for the European definition of the critical raw materials list so it looks set a variety of materials that we need for the sustainability transition so not only The energy transition and it looks where we need which material and you see that there's a lot of dots in that graph so we need a lot of material for all these very complex things to work and to be um to be organized or to be developed the second thing then is if we need all these materials where do they come from and this is the view for Europe
it is a European perspective if we need all these materials where can we Source them and it's uh very apparent From here that you we rely a lot on the rest of the world on Russia on China democ Democratic Republic of Congo South Africa so the materials need to come from um from other places in the world Europe does not have its own materials available and that brings us to this criticality uh definition so it is a combination of economic importance and Supply risk and I think that's important also to to realize it has nothing
to do basically with environmental impact or With the amount of material that is available in the soil so it is an economic and strategic principle this criticality and that also means that it has a very Regional aspect if Europe defines a list of critical raw materials it's probably different from the material list from the United States or for a country in the South so um I think that's important to realize this if we talk about these critical raw materials it's a regional list it's an economic And strategic perspective and also it's not only rare earth
metals often we think ah yeah we talk about these critical materials that's the neodymium that we're talking about no the list is much broader there's other things on that like phosphate Rock like graphite and that means that if we develop a strategy it's not a rare Earth element metal strategy that needs to be developed we need to develop strategies that go through a lot of material value Chains and product value chains and so in Europe we have developed the critical raw materials act uh and there there are specific strategies now in specific targets for extraction
for processing for recycling and for the diversification of of supply and so you see that recycling is part of the solution there so that's where uh the circularity topic comes in but of course circularity is much broader than recycling alone I think it's important To consider and that's also the topic of this discussion it's about business models for circularity and for critical raw materials so we don't we we need to think beyond the closing of material flow go beyond the recycling recy recycling will surely not solve the issue of criticality also I think circularity alone
will not solve it but it's important if we discuss circularity that we also think about different business models it's about slowing Material flows making sure that the objects we make the products we make have a much longer lifetime that they stay in the stock of of the society and that the functionality is maintained and it's about narrowing flows making sure that we can do deliver the same service with less material it has been mentioned yesterday also in the discussion about the global resources Outlook we need to reconsider the product system the production in consumption system
and Think about sustainability inherent in that system so if we think circularity don't only think recycling there's a need also to look at extending the lifetime of materials and making sure that similar functionality is reached with less material and that also applies for these critical materials if you want to solve the criticality issue we need to look for Solutions where we need less of those materials and once we have them we use them for a longer Time so it means that we need a different system it's not just a material flow that needs to be
solved we need a different syst system and I always like this picture of the mobile phones and these are the mobile phones of the past the problem with many of those materials of the critical materials is that they're very disperse they're distributed around the world in very small quantities and that Makes it very difficult to bring them to recycling if we consider recycling it is not the recycling technology as such that is the problem once you have those mobile phones or electronic circuits in the smelter the recovery percentage is very high of the metals that
you need the problem is to get them to the smelter because they they are in drawers they are very much everywhere and it's very difficult to collect so so there's a whole logistic system behind that and That's also where those business models the alternative business models can come in how do we make sure that people use their devices longer and that they bring them back by leasing the materials uh that may be a Sol solution leing materials out products out gives an incentive for people to also bring them back and you know where the materials
go if you stay the owner of of your product so I think that's what those circular Concepts also bring about it forces the Producers to think about refurbishing remanufacturing and how to stay the owner of the product that they put on the market so those are aspects I think we need to bring into the debate we need to name them specifically and because I hear also in the discussion that that we've been having we often still think a yeah circularity that's the recycling part and it's about how how we um bring the metal back into
the circle so those are a few key issues There yeah we need to think about criticality as an economic and strategic principle it's not only the metals and circularity can be part of the solution if we think about it as a broader system and from that perspective I think it's very important if we look also at the policy agendas and also the European policy agenda which might change with the new elections that it's very important that circuit economy stays high on the political agenda and that It's not replaced by criticality thinking or by um a
policy which is only based on reming and on uh setting up strategic alliances with mining countries circular economy needs to stay in the center of the policym it needs to stay there so we need to keep those elements of the green deal and not just replace them by the criticality debate those two things should join forces criticality and circularity they need to stay together that was my main message Thank you fantastic for Carl before you go I've got a question for you now you're you're you're talking about folks changing their business models but you're from
Waste Management should waste man also be changing their business model I think waste management companies have a very important role in all this um the business model of waste is very much still relying on uh that people are paid by the Tipping fee by the volume of waste that they can treat And process I think Waste Management business should change also their business model more and more to to product to a product sales model where they are financed by the product that they bring on the market the recycled material or the products that they manage
FR ladies and gentlemen all righty we've laid down some groundwork now it's time to get to the nitty-gritty and by that I mean the panel discussion itself I'm going to Invite the panel to join me up on stage uh please welcome to the stage the director KU Loa Institute for sustainable metals and minerals Tom Jones consultant for circular Electronics suzan F bham senior techn technical adviser European Recycling Industries Confederation Ricard AR bount and the director of policy and research at thecovery Center Claire Downey welcome folks welcome grab a seat Grab a seat picked at random
but by coincidence under your picture I'm putting the clicker here folks click it will click it will we're having an impromptu conversation for which they brought slides so um Tom I want to begin with you if I may um and uh before I do what I what I want to do is give you a chance just a two minutes tops a minutes better to respond to what you just heard Carl say yeah basically don't disagree with What has been said it's clear that uh circularity is only a small part of the solution for Europe's um
critical raw materials conundrum as you all know we are extremely dependent on the critical metals that we need to meet the Paris climate Target agreement uh so Clarity will be part of the solution but it will only be a small part of the solution in my in my view in our Institute at kyen circularity is a big part of of our research agenda so in the next things I Want to say I want to point it out I just want to focus on the physical laws of thermodynamics on the circular economy agenda because I think
there's a lot of poor understanding of the physical laws that we are subjected to I think a lot of things are being wrongly told about the possibilities of recycling of and the circular economy so I think it's vital we we debunk some myths and stop speaking in simplistic terms about Circular economies so if you allow me I've only brought two slides I don't want to give a presentation here but I just want to first show this diagram and this is how policy makers well now wait a second Tom I just just to be clear just
so we pretend it's interview um let's pretend I'm asking you this question say the circular economy can provide only part of the necessary materials but still needs full attention to keep the topic high in the political Agenda and not be replaced by a CRM policy that largely based on reming Europe what's your take on that and have you brought two slides to demonstrate well I I fully agree that we need circular economy next to critical raw materials acts uh and of course there is a clear link because the critical raw materials act puts recycling targets
firmly on the agenda and of course that is only part of the circular economy strategy but it's it's a major part and We don't have to be um stupid about that so what I want to say here I don't have much time but what I want to say here is that the circular economy figures that you see in all the text books and all of you know about these figures is like you show a circular diagram we saw it in the previous slides of of Carl um okay he wants to slow it and he wants
to make some modifications to it but it's still like a Perpetual mobile and the second law of Thermodynamics the law of entropy Clearly states that it's impossible to have a Perpetual mobile so basically in every single step of the recycling process from collection to pre-processing to metallurgical processing you have losses so if you have 50% collection efficiency 70% pre-processing efficiency and and 90% metallurgical processing efficiency your total efficiency is around 30% so you're losing Metals left right and Center so the idea that you can have a perpetu m In that you can keep the metals
in this eternal cycle is ludicrous it's really not based on physical law so we need to understand we have losses at any stage so that's the first myth I wanted to debunk the second myth is related to again the fact that you can keep them into this eternal Loop because in reality it's so much more complex as you can see from this figure here which I've taken from um Simon Mish of gtk from Finland um and I can speak for hours About this figure but I just want to draw your attention to some key facts
here so first of all the recycling stream that is available today for recycling to make new products is much smaller than what we need to make the new products because we're in a growing Market we're in a market where we need to drastically um boost the produ ction volumes of lithium iron batteries wind turbines electric buses electric bikes electric cars so we need loads and loads And loads of metals to do that even in a post capitalist world that would be the case the point is you can't recycle what is not in the cycle yet
so the lithium ion batteries end of life will become available around 2035 before that they areti negligable so they will not be able to meet the new needs for lithium nickel manganese Cobalt and all the other critical Metals we need for the batteries secondly there is also a very Important Dynamics in a technology that we are using the things that we put into our systems 10 or 15 years ago are not what we need today ex exactly so to give you one example 15 years ago we had fluorescent lumps these were lumps that were energy
saving lumps they replaced the incandescent lumps they were a great invention at the time they use rare Earths europium turum and itum we set up recycling processes for those but by the time those recycling processes were Efficient and were commercially available we didn't need these Metals anymore because the fluorescent lamps were replaced by LED lamps so suddenly europium turum ium were not needed in those quanties anymore so you see there is a change in dynamics of technology which makes that this cycle that you see in all these circular econ e omy textbooks is ludicrous it's
way more complex than that fourth myth I want to debunk is the economics um we know we Can recycle a lot of the critical Metals we have developed numerous flow sheets to do so for example rare earth magnets the end of life magnets in electric cars or in wind turbines we have the capability technically to recycle them the problem is today that the operational costs to do so are much larger than the price you need to pay to buy virgin Rare Earth from China at this moment so you see there is a mismatch there in
yes we want to recycle but the Cost is often too high compared to the cost to buy virgin material so as long as you don't have policy mechanisms that stop the use of primary rare Earths in your new products then it's not going to work and this is one example but we have a lot of similar examples examp Les in the recycling of complex products containing critical raw materials and the final one I want to debunk is that a lot of people who are working in the field of circular economy have the Simplistic belief that
by definition recycling is clean and Mining is is dirty but sorry I have to debunk that reality as well because it's not the case in practice if you look at the recycling of lithium ion batteries that is a dirty business it is a very complex thing to recycle a lithium ion battery with the graphite with the electrod the electrolytes you have and Carl is well placed because he was been working on this for Belgium for many years on the Pasas problem so the Eternal chemical problem with fluorinated compounds lithium ion batteries are full of fluorinated
compounds so if you do it wrongly your recycling process of your batteries you will either not this destroy the existing pasas in the system or you will create new ones during your thermal treatment at 500Β° to pre-press before your pre-process before your hydrometallurgical treatment so just to say that the reality is that recycling Can sometimes also be a very dirty business and it's not necessarily cleaner than a mining process so again I'm not saying that we should not uh pretend that should not go for recycling process and not not go for circular economy principles it's
a core part of our gur work actually but I just want to debunk all these myths and all these simplistic beliefs um often policy makers have in this uh very important field thank you very much than we're [Applause] done myths myths myths have been busted uh suzan let me uh let me give you two minutes or less to respond and then I'll have a a spontaneous question for you after that thank you thank you um yes so uh I completely agree with uh pet Tom um uh uh the circular economy is a great principle however
it's too simplistic we have all these nice pictures that show an internal Circle but that's not the case there are losses in every step of The uh of the uh recycling process when you for example when you look at the uh recycling of uh lithium ion batteries there is a great loss already in only the first step in the pre-treatment step uh a lot of the cathode active materials that we all focus on in lithium ion battery recycling is already lost over there and indeed uh battery uh recycling is a very dirty job so um
I completely agree with that uh with uh that yes but I do think that there are many many uh Possibilities to approach a circular economy would you say that you think that circular economy is is 100% circular economy is actually possible no no definitely not uh definitely not on the short term really the harsh to panel yeah yeah yeah yeah well there's should I push the green button green one I think so yeah yeah okay great thanks uh so no there will NE never be a full circular um uh economy be there are so many
hurdles it will not def definitely Not be the case on the short term so if we look look first instance at the current business models for product use it only focuses on the product use so people buy a product they use it and they discard it it doesn't allow for other our strategies than recycling such as refurbishment or repair so I do don't think that uh that uh the current business models are in place for a circular economy and then also if you look at the use of materials it has Become much more complex um
if you look at uh plastics for example there are plastic Blends but there are many Plastics that contain inorganic uh additives but also organic additives such as uh persistent organic pollutants um it's very hard to uh recycle both of these components so that will definitely not be the case and also if you look at the high-tech uh apparatus there are many multi-layers are used of metals thin layers that is Fair very tough to uh to focus on in recycling processes so also if you look at e-w for example there are so many valuable uh materials
but as Mr Franken said uh they are dispersed over millions of products so it's very tough to concentrate all these materials but if you look at the current recycling uh process um products are collected they are sorted maybe dismantled to a certain extent for example hard dis Drives are removed from laptops and then the product goes into a shredder and then uh the materials are sorted by their magnetic properties or density for example but that means that if a metal that is present in a uh product and it resembles the properties of iron or aluminum
or copper it ends up with iron aluminum or copper so it's lost in the probably in the pom metallurgical uh meth uh treatments so I think there are some Opportunities to uh optimize the end of Life Technologies uh if you look at the Sorting schemes we must learn more about uh how does a product uh uh how does how is how is it composed uh what kind of components are high on uh CRM uh um um materials for example in that way we can concentrate the materials by components by products in order to concentrate the
critical raw materials but also if you look at uh lithium I battery recycling for Example um there is much to gain because a lithium battery always contains a battery management system a casing that should be dismantled however that's very labor intensive so if we develop automated uh dismantling then there's ALS there are also many material materials that can be saved before the battery goes into a shredder and then finally if it all M all materials will end up in a recycling process but in order to do that more sustainably I Think we should uh support
really the innovation of improved and economically viable processes and that can be done by minimizing the waste by circular use of materials but also um uh uh Electrify where uh where possible so we are still quite far from the circular economy in my opinion but there are some opportunities to approach the circular economy in one word we won't get to a 100 but what percent is well let's start at 70% 70% that's a Great floor that's a great Flor uh Ricardo can you respond uh to suzan in uh one or two minutes and then I'll
have a question for you yes uh so first and foremost I would like to say thank you very much and I'm very happy to be here to discuss uh such an important topic uh also thank you very much for your presentation I would like to focus a little bit on chemical legislation and indeed that in some Plastics uh in Plastics basically especially in Technical Plastics we have substance of very high concern and persistent organic pollutants so basically here I would like to say maybe we have to reevaluate the way that uh reconsider the way that
we evaluate the substances before even placing them on the market because at the end of the day when these substances are you know are being used by manufacturers they are perfectly legal but when they reach the end of life we as recycling facilities we are the ones That uh have to deal with those substances and of course manufacturers will come up with new substances to replace the old ones and again eventually these substances will again get restricted possibly and again recyclers we have to deal with those in terms of of the mining industry I I
also believe that um uh we as European recyclers we cannot provide 100% of the materials needed so indeed the mining industry considered that is being done In in a responsible way um will will still be important for uh Europe's economy but also for the global economy as well U fantastic well my here's my question uh what in your opinion is required to further close the loop of crms at an EU level and deliver the Union's ambition so thank you very much I will I only have three slides if I manage to go to the slides
okay so today I would like to convey only four messages uh that basically that are very Important for us um is first and foremost is Echo design because uh you know products that are being placed on the market they have to be manufactured in such a way that first and foremost we allow them to stay in the market for as long as possible because consumers will be able to repair them but by themselves or by professional repairers or and also when they reach the end of life recyclers have to be able to dismantle and recycle
this this different products In an easy and fast way um now this obviously as I said will speed up the recycling process but also it will increase the the quality of the of our output material and uh some components that for example today are very difficult to extract from especially for from electronic products are batteries and pcbs when it comes to batteries of course it's it's most of the batteries that we see today in products are built in batteries so it's Extremely difficult to take them out when they reach end of life um but also
it's a very sensitive topic for us because they are also especially lithium batteries are very prone to Catching Fire uh so what we experience today in our recycling facilities is that uh we have thermal events almost on a daily basis and these thermal events can can can be from Sparks till explosions and the cost after a thermal event can be from a couple of thousand EUR to several Millions and if I'm not mistaken recently we had even in France a recycling facility that was completely destroyed um so that's why of course there is a battery
regulation on batteries and waste batteries that foresees the removability and replaceability of batteries but of course it has to be seen also what uh what will happen about the derogations that we see under this regulation the second message and again this is Very important for us is recycle content targets because we need pool measures uh of for for the recycl M materials um for the recycled materials and specially critical raw materials that we produce so basically of course we do not ask from uh going from zero to here overnight so we don't we don't say
that we want 100% recycled content targets um but what we from discussions that we've had with some of our recycling facilities we see that in Certain cases they recover some critical raw materials and they they of course because the quantity was very low they didn't find the market I know that I'm running out of time so two more things that I would like to say is basically reporting obligations we need more information from producers for the critical raw materials they use in their products so we can report them back to the member states and the
member states back to the commission And last but not least increase the collection of products rich in critical raw materials I think this is extremely important especially if we want to have ambitious recycled content targets and yeah to to to close the loop as much as possible Ricardo you still do have a minute or two if you'd like I okay I thought I was running out of time I very much appreciate that and my instinct is to not give you back the time but here we are so in in this last slide Basically I would
like to focus on the number that you see basically these numbers come directly from the European commission H and the the the point on increase collection uh is extremely important because for example you can see uh 700 million mobile phones are stored in households if I'm not mistaken that was mentioned also before in in a previous presentation and obviously all these mobile phones have critical law materials so if there are no mechanisms In place to allow consumers to return uh this these mobile phones to recycling facilities so that we can recycle the and put back
into the market the critical raw materials I think uh yes the the whole crma and circular economy action plan cannot really work um in terms of the collection targets if you have a look at the wi directive of course there are two different collection targets and I have to say that if if you have a look at the Collection Targets in the different member states of the EU there are only a few that basically they they reach this targets so and it all comes down also to how the what is the calculation methodology because for
example some of these memb states uh yeah the calculation methodology to not go into the Integrity of this discussion basically has also to be reconsidered uh I would like to conclude that we also as yqu support the Recommendations put forward by the European commission again I would like to reiterate collection of critical raw materials and product it in crms are EXT is extremely important and yeah I stop here thanks very much Ricardo thanks a lot uh if you I'd like to move over to CLA but if you could just slide that clicker this way the
golden of course clicker and uh Claire just just like everybody else if you could take a minute or two and respond to what Ricardo said and then I'll have a off the cuff question for you perfect thank you um first of all thank you to the ecsp and reuse Network Europe for having us on the panel and deepest apologies from my colleague um Dr s Miller who was due to talk uh today in my place so I wanted to pick up on the recommendation that was the very last recommendation on the last slide uh that
member states should introduce reuse and preparation for reuse targets it's something we've Been pushing for for a long time as has the ReUse Network Europe uh the European environment agency just recently published a paper called accelerating the circular economy and that also recommended shifting our circular policies much more towards target-based approaches so it's good to see that coming through and I'm really excited to share as some of you may already know that Ireland uh last uh month introduced our first national reuse Target it is a Statutory Target and also set the groundwork for a future
National repair Target which is really exciting and we were part of the research that helped underpin that with other partners we created a methodology for measuring reuse but also measured the Baseline where are we today in terms of reuse and that found that currently in Ireland we're reusing 6 kilos per person and the national Target that was just set is for 20 kilos per person by 2030 so we have To Triple our current levels of reuse to reach that Target I think that represents really good ambition and I think we need to see this level
of ambition in our circular targets um not just realistic but what we have to achieve that's fantastic this this question just occurring to me uh what can cities and regions do to support business models to cater for CRM well it's funny you should ask that because I have a few uh that is Lu brilliant um so first of all I think cities need to really look at radically reducing consumption down to the level of sufficiency and this idea of sufficiency came up a lot yesterday in the context of the global resources Outlook um how do
we meet human needs and prioritize well-being while staying in the limits of our planet or how do we make sure there's enough for everyone everywhere dealt out in a just uh way cities are really well placed to Understand the needs of their citizens they're connected to their citizens but it also needs a systems approach so when we're thinking about you know where critical raw materials are used we think about data systems and energy systems and what are we using all this data for as we make the digital transition is it really necessary to digitalize everything
certainly it's good to move away from paper um but we're creating another problem here and you know for Every click every kit video that we watch every um website that we visit every word cloud we create we're creating data and data needs data storage and it needs data transmission and it needs interfaces so everyone has to have a device to click a QR code and all of that contains critical raw materials so we need to think about how much of this is actually necessary um and how we can reduce demand and move maybe in a
more mindful way um through This digital transition so cities need to think about that look at the systems build that into their plans and then support the models that actually bring consumption down and not support the models that increase consumption as was said yesterday so some examples of that well first of all education it's not a business model but it's critical for future innovators and also for I suppose communicating that sustainability message cities can support sharing Libraries um bikes for example bike libraries bicycle frames actually contain up to eight critical raw materials um so bike
libraries toy libraries tool libraries repair systems as well cities are doing fantastic work around supporting repair vouches um repair cafes that also engage consumers and help them understand the value of our products all of that keeping critical raw materials in circulation for longer But all of this then needs citizen engagement we need people to buy into these models to support them not just to create the the models and the services but actually have the people use them it's really important for the model so we need cities to engage their citizens and again cities and regions
are really well placed to do that because they have their networks they're at that level the neighborhood level um we've been doing some Market Research into circular Economy is a term and behaviors and attitudes towards that and we've found that while the familiarity with the term circular economy is growing the understanding of what it actually means is still really low you know we heard some people think it means money going around in circles you know so I think these Concepts they're just not that clear um we've also been doing some work with the ecsp on
a leadership group on citizen engagement talking to lots of Experts in this area and one real strong message that we've had we've created a few podcasts around this is that we're using language that's too complex and terms that are too complex and certainly critical Ro materials is a good example of that so if we're trying to engage people we need to talk about bike frames and we need to talk about well not bike FR spikes and we need to talk about digital devices and data and so on so that's the citizen engagement piece and Then
finally we need to also make it easier for people to do these things and one way to do that is for cities and regions to support social Enterprises we heard yesterday again that social and environmental have to go hand in hand in the circular transition um social Enterprises do even more I suppose than the social impact they've been driving circular business models for decades they're practitioners they make repair accessible and affordable through all The models I've already described um they're also innovators uh they're trying out new models before they're mainstream before they're commercially viable some
great examples from the ReUse Network Europe are EnV which has launched a new reuse and recycling facility for solar panels testing solar panels testing components for reuse before sending the remainer for recycling with a new uh label quality label for secondhand um electrical Goods With resource in Belgium another network of um social Enterprises in Ireland we've just launched our first ebike Library which is very exciting um with the community-led initiative supported by social Enterprise um social Enterprises also of course support skills building and work with marginalized communities for that social impact these are the communities
that are going to be most affected by climate change and most likely to be left behind If the transition isn't just so they're also supporting that I guess none of these are very I suppose glamorous uh solutions for investors we're not going to get big processing facilities out of them but they're whole of society approaches to what I think is a whole of society problem well thanks Claire it's funny I live in Amsterdam where we already have a pretty unique uh circular economy for bicycles where you buy it and then it's And then it's stolen
and then you buy it from the thief and then it's stolen again it's it's fantastic beautiful um I didn't know we were we were saving crms which I I feel really good about myself now um I've got one more question and I'd love it if all four of you could answer and we'll start with Claire and go down the line the question is this uh if you had a magic wand or a final wish what would that wish be what would you do with the wand and I knowe best is if You could answer in
a minute I know we've got a clock but that that that also includes the the five minute speech that comes after us Claire very quickly then if we're talking about business models we need to make um the circular business models more viable and we need to internalize the externalities if you like the cost of production of Virgin raw materials the cost of production of products and rebalance that economic system because at the moment it's just Not viable for a lot of repair and reuse and prevention uh solutions to work so we need to find a
way to rebalance the economy cool Tom what do you do with your magic wand I think we first need to understand the reality I think a lot of the talk we are doing here again is about mobile phones I see this coming back in several uh interventions but we have to look at the the volumes of critical metals that we actually need the real volumes are Going to go into wind turbines and into electric buses and electric cars and that that's where the high volumes of critical materials are really in and where we need to
think about the strategy how we're going to produce our lithium for example how are we going to refine it how are we going to recycle it and just a wakeup call here for everyone in the audience in Europe at this moment we have zero operational lithium mines we have zero operation Lithium refineries and we have zero commercial scale lithium iron battery recycling plants at this moment so we are at z0 Z so it's all nice to talk about about bikes and recycling bikes I'm a cyclist myself I do that all the time I have cargo
bikes all over the place in our garage we do everything by bike but let's not be U telling ourselves things which are not true the crms contained in bikes are peripheral they're marginal compared to the volumes Of critical methods we will need to drive the energy Mobility housing transition in our world so let's look at the facts and realities first before we go into the the details of circular economy models clear clear and fair Ricardo magic wand so from my side I think uh it comes down because legislation is a powerful tool so basically and
we have crma if you ask me if it can be improved sure but it's a good starting point I think so from my Side it's really to align uh well the crma with a different piece of legislation because you have also an Neco design for sustainable products regulation and indeed we will need in the future especially when it comes to coer and electrification of the of the EU industry and the global industry we will need large amounts of critical raw materials but without aligning properly the different piece of legislation in my opinion it's we will
we will we will Start from one step behind so if I had a magic want if the policy makers can can align perfectly no more silos in the legislation because that's the biggest problem for the crma today exactly suzan final wish um if I look at it from a recycling perspective um there's we we know all the the materials are there in in e-w in the urban mine but uh for uh many Wast streams we don't know specifically what is in these waist streams so I think uh Un unlimited data access unlimited data um uh
Gathering that would be my final wish in order to uh improve the recycling to know where we can find these materials fantastic uh I'd like to keep this conversation going unfortunately we are out of time but how about a round of applause for our panel thank you all very much suzan Ricardo Tom and Claire fantastic you know y'all can stay or for because John's going to come over And talk I think fun if he has an onstage audience y'all just stay comfortable if you want um or you can go but let's face it it'll be
awkward now if you do uh our final words come from the adviser of environment policy and Cabinet of the Belgian Federal minister of environment John vont I'm I'm G to turn my chair to see you okay thank you um so what I've heard here is um is quite a uh a complicated message because we need critical raw Materials but we see that the solution is it's not as simple as we uh at first s would think uh recycling will not be enough we've learned so we will need an approach that is is uh consisting of
different uh of different angles so we we need mining we have learned uh and we are not good at that uh we Europe is is lagging behind in in the world context of course we need Recycling and and there is a lot of uh a lot of opportunities to to to to increase to Step up recycling by better data management better collection systems better recycling Technologies but we also have to move further it's not only about recycling it's also about reuse it's it's about changing business models it's about changing product design make sure that products
are are easily reusable that they have a long lifespan that they do not uh have any toxic substance in it so that they toxify the cycle afterwards so that are very Important things to to work on and and finally we also so need to think about not only the product design but also about the the design of the needs in which these products have a a role to play do we actually need all those products to fulfill our needs and that is a a very important question that is not even addressed at this moment in
in in European policy so when I look at the complexity of of this um um of of this topic I I see that there is a real need For a resource policy and and at this stage I think in Europe there is no real resource policy we have pits and pieces bits and pieces we have a a mining strategy or starting to have a mining strategy with critical raw materials act we have a recycling policy we have an Eco design regulation but there is no real resource policy there is no real um uh Target how
many um resources do we actually need to feed our economy how many resources can we consume in in our European economy given the fact that we are not the only European um that we're not the only continent in the world there are another s and a half billion people in this world that also want to have Mobility that also want to have housing and all that so at this stage we don't know in Europe how many uh resources we actually need and that should be the starting point really start to think about what is the
real uh demand for for for materials uh that we That we will require for for an economy that is working for everybody in Europe and that is also in balance with the needs of the rest of the world we can't just uh uh claim all the resources that are that are available just for the European citizens and that exercise is something which we really need to to do and that is also one of the topics during the Belgian presidency that we would like to give the message to the European commission please work on on a
Real strategy think about how how many resources we actually need and then you you you can guide policies towards that specific targets we have a clear climate Target one and a half degrees Celsius and that is guiding our our our our efforts but we don't have a resource uh Target and that is actually we should need and then secondly demand s is is is really a gap in in in European policy uh we have recycling um uh policy we have now uh the critical raw material act uh Which is uh the basis of a new
mining strategy but on the demand side there is there is uh really nothing that that is appearing we only touching the product design but we are not really talking about how many cars do we need how do we want to organize our Mobility systems how do we want to organize uh the the the housing and how many uh materials do they require so we also actually need to work on that on on a real a demand side policy and that can only be realized When we of course know how many materials can we actually used
to be uh sustainable so I think this is uh my main uh thoughts when I uh I've heard the panelists in that case how about a round of applause for John and uh I want to thank you all for being part of this session uh thanks of course to the panel uh thanks to to floron and Carl there you are and uh and I believe it's time for lunch uh last one there is last in line uh we'll see You after lunch [Applause]