have to thank Fred white for uh uh letting me know the proper pronunciation of the names here and I will do my best not to uh even though I speak no Russian to make sure that I pronounce them as well interestingly uh it's vavilov vavilov and Lenka are the uh the pronun I've heard a a number of different pronunciations but those are the uh those are the correct Russian pronunciations uh what I'm going to be talking about today is I think one of the uh actually not just one but a series of of stories and
and events that come together in what turns out to be both one of the most tragic as well as one of the most heroic episodes in the history of Science and uh it's unfortunately uh an episode that not many people are aware of where where Science History politics uh education a number of things come together and uh uh to to illustrate what uh the the devotion and the passion that some scientists have for their for their professions as well as the the tragedy that comes from uh political interference when a political ideology comes into play
uh the two key players in this presentation will be Nikolai uh vavilov and uh and trophy uh Lena and uh one uh vavilov who was uh one of the most prominent geneticists in the history of the science and then uh uh uh lenko who was then probably the most notorious uh case of of a pseudo geneticist in in the history of the science and their uh and then the contention that they uh that they had when uh when they came together uh to understand this we need to have a little bit of a background and
we'll go back as far as uh Jean Baptist Lamar who was a uh a French naturalist who was actually one of the pioneering figures in developing the theory of evolution he's usually badmouthed by uh by scientists because the idea that he came up with or the one he's remembered most for is uh one that is called the U uh the lamaris or the inheritance of acquired characteristics and the basic idea there that he that he put forward which made sense at the time was that uh that organisms could evolve but the way they evolved was
that the environment somehow influenced their physical makeup and then their physical makeup can then be transmitted through generations and over a period of gener erations they could gradually change under the influence of the environment it's actually not all that different from natural selection except that in natural selection we don't look at the environment as directing the selection but rather the uh mutations and variability being there and then the environment serves as as in a sense The Selective agent that uh that favors or disfavors certain organisms for their survival and ultimately reproduction so that they then
pass on the inherited character istics that they have and that's really the major difference that we see here uh but Lamar certainly had a profound influence on the development of evolutionary theory and and and also the development of of an understanding of inheritance and I think it's unfair to uh uh to look at him as in a sense a bad figure in the history of genetics and evolution and in fact Charles Darwin had uh read Lamar had quite a great deal of admiration for him and if you read Origin of Species there really is a
surprising amount of lism in it uh Darwin did not have a good grasp of inheritance because he was completely unaware of the work that mendal had done and uh uh some science historians have speculated that if Darwin and mle had come together in this great meeting of the minds that uh our understanding of evolution would have been uh greatly enhanced at a much earlier period as it turned out the the Darwinism and mentalism really didn't come together as I'll show in a few moments and until the 1930s that's when we have a period called the
modern synthesis uh another key player in this in the historical context is Gregor mle who conducted a series of experiments on uh peas and beans in the uh 1850s late 1850s right up into the early uh 1860s and from those experiments he discovered the what are the fun FAL patterns of inheritance that apply not just to the plants he was studying but to multicellular organisms in general and in fact the the basic principles of inheritance that applied to pea plants that he discovered uh are also the same that we see in humans as well as
most other organisms and uh uh mendle unfortunately during his lifetime was not recognized for his scientific work there were a few people who were aware of what he had done uh several Publications during the late 1800s that cited his work but no one recognized it for the power that it had and the fundamental principles of of inheritance that it established uh mle died in 1884 uh before his work was known and then in um in 1900 uh three botanists uh in essence rediscovered his work what they were doing was they were conducting experiments with plants
they independent ly discovered the same principles that mendle had without being aware of what he had done and then uh and then each of them it appears that Carl Corin was the first uh found mle's paper and realized that mendle had done this work uh uh essentially 35 years earlier and uh and had published it and from 1900 on mendle then became known as the founder of the science of genetics and uh some people claimed that shermock was is not one of the rediscovers that he really didn't grasp mentalism I've read his paper I'm convinced
that uh that he really should be included among the uh the three rediscovers now someone who is also often included as a ReDiscover who really wasn't but became mle's greatest proponent was William Bateson uh Bateson was a British naturalist he had been studying inheritance and there's this great story about him being on a train and reading mle's page paper and almost being almost undergoing a a kind of Quasi religious conversion to mentalism he uh according to his own account he was on the train on the way to give a lecture and he completely changed his
lecture after reading the paper and gave this lecture on mendelism and from that point he became mle's greatest proponent now interestingly some of the greatest scientific ideas become established out of controversy and that was certainly the case with mentalism uh there were some scientists known as the biometricians who really developed their ideas right around the same time right around 1900 the the leaders being Carl Pearson and wfr Welden who uh who felt that Evolution proceeded in a very gradual way uh Bateson saw uh inheritance of discreet characteristics as being the predominant mechanism and those two
seem to be in Conflict now now interestingly later they uh and in fact even within the decade they came together uh where scientists showed that melan inheritance could certainly explain the gradual distribution of of characteristics we see such as height in humans which is not tall or short but rather uh a wide range of of characteristics uh but because of that controversy baton and a number of his followers conducted a whole series of experiments that strongly established mentalism as a as a clearcut uh mechanism for inheritance and they showed that it worked in a wide
range of organisms plants and animals and uh and their work was very foundational then in in in establishing the science of genetics and Bateson comes into play as a very key uh person in this uh vov uh Lena contention uh because vov was one of Bon's students he left Russia to study or the Soviet Union at the time to study under baton and Bateson was his uh his principal mentor and so filo became uh a very prominent melon during this time of uh of the establishment of of of mandalis now interestingly if we look at
the uh Darwin's and mandal's ideas on how the environment influences inheritance we see a very strong contrast here Darwin wrote in Origin of Species it seems pretty clear that the organic beings must be exposed during the several generations to the new conditions of life to cause any appreciable amount of variation and that when the organization has once begun to vary It generally continues to vary for many generations now what we see in here is kind of a quasi lamarian point of view Darwin is saying that you'll notice he uses the word cause and uh that
that uh that the conditions of Life which we presume is the environment here uh cause variation and then after several Generations that variation can appear now interestingly um uh here's where my personal involvement comes into this I had the great opportunity to uh to study mle's copy of Darwin's Origin of Species where mle had made uh marginal notes and interestingly no one had Lish that and so we had the opportunity to publish those notes uh Bryce ridding who is in the department of music and I were able to do that and U mendle marked this
passage it it clearly was of interest to him and we can see that interest emerging in his classic paper where he in in essence counters this very passage uh and the following if the changing conditions of Life were the sole cause of variability one would expect that those cultivated plants that have been grown through centuries under almost identical conditions should have regained stability this is known not to be the case for it is precisely among them that we not only uh that not only the most different but also the most variable forms are found mendal
is arguing in essence against this point of darwins and against the neol lamaran point of view here uh that uh the environment is is really not the the the cause of of variability and that those two contrasting ideas really form much of the heart of the V love Lea contention that comes into play later which is why we're going through them now another key historical event that took place concurrent with the uh with the events in the Soviet Union was what we now call the modern synthesis and the modern synthesis was the bringing the the
the full bringing together of mendelism and Darwinism where Mendel's Laws essentially explain Darwin's theory of natural selection that's the that's the basic Point here and uh there were a number of scientists that brought that about four of them uh four of the of the most important players are Illustrated here JBS halane who is certainly worth a an entire seminar or book alone given the uh his his photograph I think illustrates very well his his personality uh he ended up uh he ended up by the way uh uh immigrating to India and wearing uh uh Indian
clothing uh uh and then also we have Sul Wright who is an American geneticist uh Ronald fiser down in the the lower left corner who was a British statistician one of the founders of the science of Statistics also a very prominent genetic IST and then also another key person theodocious djansi who was Russian and who immigrated to the United States and in largely because of the way uh of of what Lena was doing in the Soviet Union refused to return to his home country and ended up becoming a naturalized American citizen and one of the
most prominent geneticist evolutionary biologists in the history of the United States and uh the four of them along with others were key in bringing this synthesis of Darwinism and mentalism together so if we look at the early melians there were really two major groups one European one American and uh the unquestioned leaders of those groups during this this time period were William Bateson and Thomas Hunt Morgan and their names come into play a little bit later in the presentation as well uh I've listed some of the geneticist certainly not all of them who uh who
worked uh worked in these groups and interestingly you'll notice I've listed at the top uh this was a time in science when uh women didn't play a prominent role genetics is a big exception to that one because Bateson was teaching at a women's college uh he was at the John inis Center in England but was also teaching at a women's college and recruited quite a number of women geneticists and so we have people like uh uh like Muriel wheldale and Edith Saunders who who become uh important geneticist during that time Reginald pet after whom the
pet square is named French geneticist Lucien quo Carl Corin Eric Von shermock who were two of mle's rediscovers interestingly uh uh Dev became a a a sort of a non- melan very shortly after he had rediscovered mle's work Ronald fiser in in Britain and then I've highlighted in uh italic some of the people who come into play a little bit later here Theodosia stansky Nikolai vov and uh then also uh you on the American side Lillian Von Samson was one of Morgan's students who contributed much to what we understand about fruit flies and ended up
marrying him and uh which is why Morgan is listed as her fourth name there and then Barbara mclin talk who worked with r em Emerson but also had very strong contacts with Morgan Emerson being a Cornell professor who who established corn as one of the key uh uh organisms in uh in establishing mandelian genetics Calvin Bridges who worked under Morgan and I've highlighted his name in italics because Bridges was a comp communist sympathizer as were a number of others including um uh Herman Mueller uh and in fact U Morgan's most prominent students were uh uh
were were Bridges Mueller and Alfred Sturdivant and of those three two of them were very strong communist sympathizers and very interested in what was going on in in the Soviet Union and then also Su Wright William castle and Kurt Stern listed in here and by the way Dwayne Jeffrey is with us and he knew some of these people personally and uh and has some great stories to tell the uh now let's uh go to vov and uh and a bit of the chronology now on the chronologies that I've listed here I'll give one for him
and also for Lenka but the uh uh the chronologies even though they end here right around 1940 the reason I've ended them there is that that's really in the 1930s and the 40s where the two of them come together and where the the contention itself begins and so these chronologies do not go through the ends of their lives although vov is really pretty close uh at this at this point he died in 1943 uh anyway he was born in uh in Moscow 1887 in 1910 graduated from the Moscow agricultural Institute as a plant uh as
a botanist and he studied he then went to England 1913 to 1914 studied with baton and that's really where he became a strong mandelian is that baton had a powerful influence on him and in fact uh Bateson and uh and vov uh maintained correspondence and visited each other uh uh later in uh in vavilov's career uh he then became a professor at The Saratov agricultural Institute and public studies on the origin of cultivated plants which was one of the key Publications that he uh that he made uh by the 1920s he was the leading geneticist
and certainly uh leading botanist uh one of the leading scientists in the Soviet Union uh had great support from lenon and uh and which uh after uh let's see lenon died in 24 was it yeah 1924 was when Lennon's death was and then in 19 1926 AEV received the uh Lenin prize 1937 he had uh uh the the world was going to gather the world of geneticist was going to gather in Moscow for the international Congress of genetics as we'll see Stalin cancelled that but uh vov was really at the height of his career in
the 1920s going into the N early 1930s very well respected in the Soviet Union as well as throughout the world as a as a leading geneticist and uh one of his greatest contributions was during the period 1916 to 1940 when he made Expeditions throughout the world to collect seeds as well as tubers of uh different types of plants and he brought those back to the Soviet Union as a way of collecting the world's genetic diversity for cultivated plants and uh there's a very good reason for that here are some uh photographs of vavilov in in
his uh in his many Expeditions throughout the world where he was uh collecting these seeds and bringing them back and the reason for this is he came up with an idea that is still very valid and very important for plant geneticist plant breeders and really for the entire world because our entire food supply depends on this on this concept and it's uh an idea that we now call genetic erosion and uh the perhaps one of the best illustrations of it that I've chosen to use here is the potato the potato originated in andyan South America
largely in the in the high Andes of Bolivia and Peru and if you go there even today the different types of potatoes that you see will look very much like uh this lower photograph right here incredible genetic variety of potatoes when the Spaniards arrived and and what had happened then is that the ancient civilizations of that part of the world had domesticated the potato from Wild ancestors and they had this tremendous diversity there so that there were little VAR varieties that were adapted to the various microclimates of this highly varied region in the mountains and
uh so incredible diversity for potatoes when the Spaniards arrived they took potatoes back to Europe not all of them grew well there they only took a subset back and so the genetic diversity in Europe for potatoes was substantially less than it was in uh in Peru and then potatoes became an tremendously important crop interestingly the the Soviet Union and had was and is one of the major uh potato producers in the world and then potatoes made their way throughout Europe up into Ireland and then from there uh to the United States of course we have
the great Irish Potato Famine that uh has a great influence on uh immigrants coming to the United States and uh then and then uh American breeders took the potatoes that they had coming in there and developed using modern plant breeding techniques based on mle's principles as well as Darwin's developed modern varieties that were much more productive than the native varieties that we see in uh the Andes where the real danger of genetic erosion comes then is when these highly productive varieties that have very little genetic diversity go back back to their region of origin and
begin to displace that diversity because that diversity is the foundation for the future of plant breeding those genes that are contained within the area where a crop originated are so critical for plant breeders to use that the loss of those genes through genetic erosion is a huge loss to humanity and vaval or VAV was the one who recognized that and because of that he recognized that erosion was going on and not only did he recognize it and publish it but he took the action to collect that diversity and preserve it and he brought those seeds
tubers all these other things back uh as well as cuting from fruit trees back to the the Soviet Union and there he established uh uh we'll get to that in a moment uh one of the theoretical things that came out of this and well theoretical and practical is that vov recognized that it was not throughout all the world that plants were domesticated but rather there were certain centers inly and not coincidentally these were the centers of major CI ancient civilizations where people where Advanced civilizations had developed they were dependent on cultivated Agriculture and that is
where domesticated plants and likewise animals these same centers apply to domesticated animals that's where they uh uh that's where they appeared and Vil recognized that those also are the centers where the diversity is going to be his basic concept was that the greatest genetic diversity for a species typically is in the region where it originated where it evolved and for domesticated plants then that would be the pl the places where ancient civilizations domesticated those those species and so he identified eight centers and we won't take the time to go through them but you can see
that they uh anyone who's familiar with ancient civilizations recognizes that each of those places had a very important ancient civilization where the domestication uh took place interestingly though what I will mention is that some of the foods that we now think of as being inherent to a particular area are not truly inherent to that area for instance what would Italian food be without tomatoes and yet Tomatoes originated in Mexico and potatoes of course are an important worldwide food but they originated in South America uh most of the grains that we have uh wheat oats barley
uh originated in uh in the Middle East rice of course in Southeast Asia as we might expect uh corn in Mexico and to a lesser extent in South America and uh now uh they uh vavilov as I mentioned earlier was very well known as a geneticist here's an example of Bateson visiting him uh later on when he was at the height of his career in uh in the Soviet Union he established this great Center that uh where they kept and and stored like a museum the diversity that he had collected had quite a number of
scientists uh working with him had plenty of funding from the government it was uh essentially an ideal situation and then Along Comes Lenka he was born in 1898 and uh was fairly obscure and one of the things that brought him to uh prominence was in 19 27 a uh uh a Soviet reporter in prda wrote an article about him that praised what he was doing and I'll quote from that in the next slide he then um came up with a hypothesis of vernalization that was pretty much a lamaran type of hypothesis uh it turned out
that uh vavilov and I hope I pronounced this correctly uh Constantin OV uh close enough uh who was one of of A's students uh they went through a Ser because at this time uh lenko was getting a fair amount of attention for his hypothesis they conducted a series of really fine experiments done on a large scale with good statistical analysis and it essentially disproved entirely the uh what lenko was doing uh and yet Lenka gain Stalin's favor was named president of the Academy of agricultural Sciences and received the Stalin prize in 1944 now uh here
is this article that helped bring him to prominence and in fact if it weren't for a coincidence of a number of events Lena probably would have faded in never even been mentioned in the pages of History uh but he ended up having a profound uh negative not just negative but tragic effect as we'll see here's the quotation from the story It's a Wonderful quotation Lenka gives one the feeling of a toothache God give him Health he has the uh he has a dejected mean stingy of words and ins significant of faces he all one remembers
is his Sullen look creeping along the Earth as if at very least he were ready to do someone in but then a little later in the article this is the same article the the reporter turns the uh turns the table and says the Barefoot Professor Lenka has now followers pupils and EXP experimental Fields he is visited in the winter by agronomic luminaries who stand before the green fields of the experiment station gratefully shaking his hand and uh the what really brings like Lenka to power is that Stalin sees in lenka's ideas something that is truly
Soviet that contradicts the Western tradition of vandalism and he then promotes Lenka and this Photograph here I think is yeah this is one of those cases where you hear of a a picture telling a thousand words this one really does it uh you see Lenka down here giving his speech and then look at stalling up in the corner uh looking at him uh the in one of the speeches that uh and this Photograph by the way is from 1935 I don't know that it is the very speech that we're looking at here but it certainly
depicts what what we see during this speech Lenka said that Soviet geneticists and he was targeting vov in particular uh are kulac Wreckers and sabur who instead of helping Collective Farmers they do their destructive business both in the scientific world and out of it and after that just stinging speech of Stalin arose uh the way the account of it goes that he stood up and I think that's great in this photo you see him standing there uh in power and he says Bravo comrad Leno Bravo uh it's clear that he has this uh tremendous support
from uh uh from the powerful dictator now one of the key uh one of the key uh uh Concepts that uh Lena put forth was the idea of of vernalization and what he claimed is that uh to understand what he was talking about there were there are two types of wheat what we call Spring wheat which Farmers plant in the spring yet then grows up into the late summer and uh and produces a crop or winter wheat which they plant in the fall and then it must undergo a process that we do call vernalization where
the growing plants have to be cold enough be frozen enough that uh it triggers them then in the spring to grow and produce a wheat crop and the wheat crop comes much earlier and for that reason uh winter wheat can be grown without uh uh often without irrigation because it produces nerer crop having germinated in the fall and uh what Lenka contended is that by freezing giving cold treatment to the seeds of winter wheat that they could be vernalized and become spring wheat and uh the experiments that filov and his students did showed very conclusively
that we s a was wrong that the environment did not change the genetics and convert winter wheat into spring wheat and uh and yet uh Leno's response to it which is given in the second paragraph on this slide is uh scanton of must give thought to the fact that when such erroneous data were swept away from the field of scientific activity those who failed to understand the implications of such data and insisted on retaining them were also swept away which in a way is almost a uh prophecy of what's about to come and that is
this uh geneticists were among the most affected of The Purge that Stalin made of intellectuals during the late 1930s and uh and the fact that uh vov and his students are now contradicting lyso openly means that they are some of the primary targets and he's in essence here warning them what uh what is going to happen uh Lena and then another uh a philosopher named prisant I'm not sure if I'm pronouncing that correctly but uh got together and launched a campaign against favila uh which was supported by Stalin and a number of the events are
here and I'm going to read some quotations that illustrate some of the uh some of the points during this time lka becomes even more uh lamaran during this period here's a quote that illustrates I think very clearly what he is trying to promote as the doctrine of genetics of this time heredity is inherent not only in the chromosomes but in every particle of the living body and you need but change the type of metabolism in a living body to bring about a change in heredity and then in 1937 he publicly names vov as an enemy
of the people in 1937 Stalin cancels the international Congress of genetics which was organized by Vila scheduled to be held in Moscow and then he ramps up his Purge of intellectuals who are sent to prison or executed among them a dozens of geneticists and who refuse to accept uh Lena and then uh 1939 here's a nice quotation that well illustrates what is going on at this time our native geneticists those attempting to defend the truths of men of mendelism Moranis notice he brings Thomas Hunt Morgan the American into this should take pause over the significant
fact that the philosophical foundations of the theory they defend had already found a place in the history of pseudoscience the struggle against the remnants of bis opinions in science the impliable struggle against pseudoscience and the idealistic and metaphysical distortions in the business of every scientist and every scientific institution in the land you know these are powerful words they sound very much uh you you can sense the the the stalinist uh doctrine that uh that comes through in these and can see why Stalin was uh was so supportive of it and uh 1938 Leni is appointed
as president of the Academy of agricultural Sciences two of the most prominent geneticists in the world have ties to the Soviet Union seeing what's going on Herman Mueller who was an American who actually was fired from the University of Texas for his communist views he went to the Soviet Union and had planned to stay there uh recognizing what was going on he left ended up going and uh and assisting with the Spanish Civil War uh in the uh those who were fighting against Franco and ended up up in the back in the United States never
returning again to the Soviet Union Theodosia stansky who was a Soviet citizen himself uh refused to return to his homeland and and stayed in the United States as I mentioned earlier becoming one of the most prominent geneticists and evolutionary biologists and uh Dr Jeffrey you knew do jansy didn't you or met him yes we we hosted him over at BYU yeah uh and just a remarkable scientist who who was one of the most prolific geneticists in history and it's it it's something to think what he would have done for Russia had he returned to his
homeland but this entire uh this entire contention then uh led him to uh was one of the major factors that led him to the United States and and caused him to stay there uh vov on the other hand was a very strong strong Patriot to the Soviet Union and uh and also very uh uh very committed to promoting uh science and particular his own science of genetics and in a speech he gave in 1939 attacking lka comes one of the greatest quotes I think ever uttered in the history of Science and in a way a
uh likewise a uh uh prophecy a prophecy of what was to come he said we shall go to the P we shall burn but we shall not Retreat from our convictions and he and uh the other geneticists who were there uh were true to their word they stood staunchly against uh Lenka uh in the full knowledge that they were likely to be imprisoned and possibly executed or kill or die in prison as a consequence and yet remain uh uh remain devout to the uh the science with vov being the leader and uh tragically and not
surprisingly uh not long after that 1940 uh vov is arrested and uh this is an example of his mugshot at the time of his arrest he's taken to the uh to prison in Leningrad where interestingly he continued to teach and to write uh about genetics and um and then in 1941 uh this is during World War II and we have uh one of the uh one of the most tragic events in the history of the war which is this 900 day Siege of Leningrad when Hitler's Army cuts off the city entirely in anticipation of that
uh prisoners were moved from prisons in Leningrad out of fear that they might be released uh vov was one one of them he was moved to sarov prison uh where he died of U of malnourishment and starvation in 1943 let's now return to the siege of Leningrad because an important story uh connected with Vil love and to a lesser extent with Lena comes out of this and uh during the siege of Leningrad it was most severe during the winter of 41 to 42 there were over 200,000 people who died of starvation during that time uh
the Nazi army had uh completely cut the city off from its uh supplies there uh these are some photographs that uh depict how and there are literally hundreds of photographs like these that uh that depict the great tragedy of this Siege uh this Photograph I think is uh this is sort of a uh uh uh a Russian version of Anne Fran uh a young girl who recorded in her her diary the dates at which each of a number of her relatives died of starvation in Leningrad uh because of this great Siege uh The Siege took
place over a period of 900 days water electricity fuel supplies were cut off uh during January of 42 when it was at its worst food was rationed to 125 gram of bread that's less than a slice of bread per day per person also included sawest that they B yeah it's you know uh uh just unimaginable uh how how awful this was for the uh civilians when by the time the siege had ended more than 641 th000 civilians had died and uh at least 200,000 during the winter of 41 to 42 now uh you'll recall that
the Institute that vavilov had established was in Leningrad and what what did it contain seeds seeds it contained food collected seeds that had the genetic diversity of the world represented there to protect the world against genetic erosion and the seeds were not enough to make any kind of an impact on the uh the population if they were you know if they took the seeds out and distributed them to the people uh they'd probably all be eaten within a day and and have have very little impact but certainly for the workers who were there this could
be a source that could keep them from starving they could they could have eaten those seeds the uh I but what they did is they made a pact among themselves they all gathered and said they promised one another that they would not eat the seeds and in order to enforce it in fact they they made an agreement among themselves that no one would ever be alone they would always be at least in groups of two so that they would be watching out for each other to make sure that the that the Heritage the genetic Heritage
that vov had collected would be preserved and there are some wonderful quotes that come out of this Vadim uh Lovich who was one of the scientists at The Institute who survived uh uh said this he said it was hard to walk it was unbearably hard to get up every morning to move your hands and feet but it was not in the least difficult to refrain from eating up the collection for it was impossible to think of eating it up for what was involved was the cause of your life the cause of your comrades lives they
were devoted enough to that that they refused to eat the food and the uh tragedy as well as heroism that came out of this is that nine of them died at starvation died of starvation uh some of them at their post surrounded by food the uh there's a nice passage that comes from a recently released book called where our food comes from that comes from interviews of the of the survivors who were there at The Institute he said among this group Alexander stuken died at his writing table holding in his hand a packet of his
most prized peanuts that he had hoped to send off for a grow out the custodian of if voves many collections Lilia rodina died of starvation as did Dimitri Ivanov who as his own life failed stowed away thousands of packets of rice that he held so dear there were others as well stenov kovaleski uh lanvi Malina corun some who who perished by starving some riddled by sickness others by shrapnel Wolf the herbarium curator was hit by a missile shell fragment and bled to death gber the archist of of A's field notes died in the midst of
those papers rather than leave his post now once the war had ended U the senka by then was had pretty much eliminated most of his enemies the students of the geneticists who had uh uh who had been imprisoned many of whom had died by now uh uh tended to to keep quiet and um and then a number of scientists in an attempt to please Lenka actually published false papers and so we have this quote from jores medev who who wrote an expose on on Lenka uh where he said in nearly every issue of the journal
AGR Biologia articles appeared in which there were seriously reported transformations of wheed into Ry and vice Versa barley into oats peaches into vet vet into lentils cabbage into sweds Furs into Pines hazelnuts into hornbeams Alders into Birches sunflowers into strangle weed all of these communications were utterly without proof methodologically illiterate and thoroughly unreliable the authors had one leading thought to pleas Lea and then uh it was not unknown outside of the Soviet Union what was going on Ronald fiser as I mentioned one of the uh uh one of the founders of U uh one of
the founders of of statistics and a geneticist said after examining lenka's arguments I have no doubt that we cannot as many have been inclined to do describe him simply as a scientific crank or simply as a wrong-headed Yokel his mind does not seem to work in either of these ways no I cannot believe that the reward of Lena's triumphant career is the advance of scientific knowledge nor that it is is the prosperity of poor peasants the reward he so eagerly is grasping is power power for himself power to threaten power to torture power to kill
and uh one of the great tragedies of this is that it was not confined to the Soviet Union that uh that lysenkoism uh went into China ma adopted it uh mandated that it be used in in Chinese Agriculture and the ultimate result of that was famine during the late 50s and early 60s in China not only did people die at the hand of the executioners many died of starvation because of false science being promoted now one of the great heroes in this story too is jores medev who was a Soviet scientist and activist and a
great risk to his own personal life in the 60s he wrote exposes one of which was an expose of Len which he sent in Russian got it smuggled out of the Soviet Union translated into English and published as a book called the uh rise and fall of TD Lena which is a book well worth reading and uh then Lena fell from power at about the time that cruff did cruff supported him but uh at that point Soviet not biologists but physicists began to speak out against him among them was Andre sakarov who said uh he
is responsible for the shameful backwardness of Soviet biology and genetics in particular for the dissemination of pseudoscientific views for adventurism for the degradation of learning and for defamation firing arrest even death of many genuine scientists uh there are two really fine books out one of them is Med's book on the rise and fall of Linka and then another one recently released called the murder murder of Nikolai vov uh by Peter Pringle a British author that came out just a few years ago I've read both of them they are both excellent books well worth getting and
reading now I've intentionally lysen by this point was uh uh essentially banished uh he had had fallen into disrepute and so I put in very small print here he dies in 1976 now to end though I have as a little bit of an epilogue I have to share a personal story uh the first time that I went to uh visit uh mle's Garden which is the uh the pilgrimage that every geneticus should make uh I uh it was four years after the fall of Communism his garden is located in what's now the Czech Republic in
the city of berno and uh as I was there the director of the mendal museum uh they had just put up a display of the Soviet scientists who had been uh uh who had died under lysenkoism and um the uh and she told me a personal story of how now that people were free to travel that many of the students of these scientists then made their own pilgrimage to M mle's Garden collected a bit of soil from the garden and then took it back and Scattered it on the graves of their mentors and hearing this
story I thought I can't resist and so I went out and collected some soil myself uh I have to apologize I I have it in a vial up in my desk I was was going to bring it and show it to you and I forgot to do it uh but I have a little vial on my desk of of mle soil uh remembering the as a as a way of honoring and remembering those Soviet scientists who died uh as a result of this okay uh thanks for your attention and any questions you have you have
question Dan can you give some examples of how the cnism LED to famine uh in the case of china the idea was that uh the the main thing that happened there is that they mandated that the people that if seeds could grow close to one another if you get a lot of plants in there they were supposed to influence their own genetics and change and so Mao mandated that they plant far too many seeds that they put them in just extremely uh uh compacted uh plantings and and what it did of course is it meant
that the that the plants would compete with one another and they produced a much lower Harvest and uh what actually happened is that some of the PE peasants knew that this was wrong but when Ma would come to look at the gardens they would actually go ahead of him and they would take rice plants transplant them in there to put them in uh in a very high density so that it looked like these productive plants were doing well and then after he had passed they would go in and pull them out so that the plants
would still grow well uh but that was one of the main things that happened in China that resulted in in famine is that they were uh they were following uh misguided practices that substantially reduce the yields yeah so I I'm not I'm not I come from the humanities and political s so excuse me if I it's a silly question um so if I understood well lenko through the process of vernalization what he was the the the principle that he was relying on was Lamar's principle of um of the fact that the if I understood this
well the only cause for genetic change within a species is the environment so you us saying well let's modify the environment and that way we now way you modify the genetics you see and if you look at it in terms of uh well go uh uh go ahead and ask your question sorry no that that was that was the question am I am I thinking about the mark properly is yes yes absolutely does that compare with like the current Mandan yeah the idea now is that uh that what happens is that mutations occur in DNA
and the environment May introduce them but it doesn't Target specific genes in other words the the environment does not direct the the course of of mutation in other words it does not shape the genetic material the genetic material can change and but it does so not not necessarily in response to a particular environmental effect to make it that in other words what lenko is proposing is that you could take winter wheat and genetically convert it to Spring wheat simply by making it cold which does noten happen you do that and it still remains winter wheat
and uh and mentalism is is very different than that and in fact interestingly if you look at it uh what vff did is that he collected diversity for this very reason that environment does not change it if lism worked you wouldn't need to collect diversity because you could just take whatever you have put it there and the diversity would arise on its own in response to the environment and uh the diversity that we need to collect then is is unessential but of course that's not the case just just just follow up just to make sure
that clarified this well enough um so for example with the forest here in Utah there's certain like plants that come up only when there's a forest fire right it's something that hatches them up but when that fire happens or the same way the same way that the spring weight happens the environment does not actually change the the the the genetic does not change the genetic material no gen material is just responding to the environment but it's not reallying change it's just reacting yeah right yeah and in fact a way to think of Lamar is is
that if you if you go and weight lift your muscles get larger but you don't pass that on to your children children don't grow up with larger muscles because you've been weightlifting that's a good way to think of it okay I think our time is probably gone one more question I might share just one little story about J to death U I was at Berkeley doing graduate work at the time that he smuggled that manuscript out to Michael burner yeah and you notice there was the translat learner is the transl learner was Russian born but
he was a geneticist also at Berkeley at that time and when learner translated that he he he sent word back in again smuggling to like to to medf and said we will publish this anonymously or your life is gone medf got word back and said it must have my name or no one will ever believe it and learner said this has got to be the bravest act I have ever witness now medf ultimately managed to get out to to gri this you know and and and uh finished his life there but the comment from learner
this has got to be the bravest guy I've ever known because he insisted it had to have his name even though he would likely to be killed you know and and to me he is also one of the heroes in this of the many heroes in this in this whole period abut uh the uh certainly uh the story in fact if you look at the subtitle that I I put on this talk it was very intentional it's the tragedy heroism and passion for science all three of them come through uh I think like we have
never seen in the history of Science in this in this whole episode thanks yeah and I think it's uh quite an honor here to have someone who was uh who actually witnessed this and knew many of the characters in Liv than