[Music] Dr BF Skinner professor of psychology at Harvard University has authored such important scientific books as the behavior of organisms verbal Behavior the technology of teaching and contingencies of reinforcement in addition he has written two books of general interest which have been both widely received and highly controversial the novel Walden 2 and Beyond freedom and dignity included in the many scientific Awards bestowed upon him are the distinguished scientific Award of the American Psychological Association membership in the National Academy of Sciences and the president's metal of Science in this film Dr Skinner addresses himself to some
of the most important issues facing education today with Dr Skinner is Dr John M Whitley of Washington University St Louis the issues of freedom and control are among the most misunderstood of your work I would like to provide the learning behaviors of two children by way of example one child's learning behavior is characterized by excessive dependence on the teacher at every stage of doing an assignment the other child's learning behavior is characterized by an independence an apparent love of learning on its own a self- starting which child is the more free and which child is
the more controlled you see you have you phrased the question by referring to one child as dependent on the teacher and the other child is independent he is independent of the teacher but he's not independent of the natural world he has already come under the control of the physical environment which interests him rouso raised this question 200 years ago rouso didn't like personal dependence he thought people harmed natural goodness so he wanted everyone to be dependent on things but that's the point that you are dependent on the physical environment just as much as you are
dependent on people I think we would agree I believe that the child who is exploring the real world around him is is farther advance in the child who has to run to the teacher for approval and the teacher if if he's any good will make sure that child shifts his his dependency to the world of things otherwise the teacher would remain essential and that you don't want every teacher has to wean uh the student just as every therapist has to wean his client you have to get you have to break up these dependencies however if
a child is really not getting much reinforcement out of life then a little parental or or instructional approval will be enough to get the child going but that should be withdrawn you should you should break down the control exercise by another person and play up the control exercised by the the environment but there's no Freedom involved in either case the child will will feel free in both cases in one case he's free to go and ask the teacher if this is good and the teacher says yes in other case he's free to try something new
and something interesting happens but uh and he feels free but actually he in one case he is still under the control of personal approval in the other case he has come under the control of all of the interesting things that happen in the World At Large when you when you begin to explore it you've written that our educational environments are defective How would teachers within this environment go about helping the child modify his learning Behavior well you have to do it first of all by constructing the kind of environment that will will bring the child
under some kind of control if you go into a disrupted classroom where the kids are late in arriving and they run around the room and so on the teacher may be completely out of control there what you have to do is to set up some very conspicuous rewarding or reinfor forcing contingencies and you can do it with with by tokens or with credit points or with personal approval or something of that kind make sure that the child is reinforced for coming to school for sitting down getting to work and learning something now you may have
to make it very explicit to begin with something as conspicuous as a a token that he can pocket and exchange for something at lunch or something like that but you don't want that to go on forever you don't want uh kids to live their lives just to collect tokens any more than we want people to live their lives just collecting money it's something else again but you can then change from a token system to a credit system from a credit system just to a bit of approval a pat on the back but then you want
to get rid of that also and have the the trial come under the control of the instructional materials he's working with now I don't think you're going to do that by finding things that are naturally interesting to the child there are naturally interesting things but the child is there to learn behaviors which will pay off naturally only much later in his life for example beginning reading is not very re rewarding uh you can put four color pictures on every page of the of the of your reader and that kind of thing but there are ways
in which you can work out contingency so the child is successful very quickly in in it may be quite arbitrary you may get some feedback that this is the correct name for that object and so on and but with these Furious contingencies call them anything you like you can begin to build up fluent reading behavior and then the child will begin to get reinforced as we all are from Reading enjoyable things but you can't move to the enjoyable things immediately because they they aren't enjoyable he hasn't acquired enough Behavior to read enjoyably so you set
up artificial contingencies which might be just approval but could be much better than that to build the behaviors which then come under the control of of the natural contingencies built into books we read books for the rewarding things that happen when we read and you can't start there but that's where you want the child to move as fast as possible what are the range of positive reinforcers open to a school seems to me schools are operating in a very different way than the one you just described yes that when you ask yourself as a teacher
as I have at the college level what have I got that my students want uh sometimes a pretty discouraging question but you can uh discover things which will be reinforcing to students at any level and that has been done a great deal of progress has been made there are things in an ordinary even say a ghetto classroom lower grades or high school that can be used as reinforcers um you can have special Foods at lunchtime access to play Space privileges to associate with with other kids of your choice more and more of these things have
been brought into play as as the kinds of contrived reinforcers that can be used temporarily to get the kinds of behavior which will then eventually have their own natural consequences which will be reinforcing that that can be done fortunately for us all the human organism is reinforced just for being successful with something and that has had survival value and it can be used if you design instructional materials properly and I would say that programmed instruction is an example then mere progress is is is reinforcing what do you mean that programmed instructions designed properly well I
mean good programs in which the response you make U demand something from you it's not too easy but it's still a almost always right and as a result of having made that you were then able to go on and do something else that you couldn't do before a good instructional program has some buil-in reinforces if you just Leaf through toward the back of the book and see what you don't know and it's always obvious you don't know it and then you look back and see what you've covered and you do know that that's obviously something
is happening you're making progress and before you know it you know the whole whole the whole program and fortunately for us all the human organism is reinforced by by successful accomplishment so on a stage to to Stage basis through this program text you're rewarded as you go on it would seem to me however that our educational environments are designed very differently typically for example you're punished if you don't do well the school rewards uh it's best rewards for those people who accomplish the most but almost by definition within it there can only be a few
at the top and children aren't rewarded on it on a day-to-day basis for accomplishing as much as they can well there are all sorts of things wrong with the contingencies which now Prevail and I want to get away from them just as much as say the free school people do but I think they're going the wrong way they're not going to be able to get away from these they always fall back on them eventually no you're quite right all the way up through even through graduate school the Aver student studies to avoid the consequences of
not studying quences which can