welcome to this edition of the Rana report I had the really really fun opportunity many many months ago talking to a series of church leaders pastors I know and basically I was trying to get to the bottom of this question what are some of the characteristics of some of the most highly effective pastors now the first thing I have to admit on this is that when you begin to look at how the effective pastors there is a lot of subjectivity in that phrase highly effective you know what what does that mean that means they're leaving
their churches for a tremendous evangelistic growth does it mean that they have a great discipleship ministry where people are growing day by day in the Lord does it mean that there is a great fellowship and there's there's a lot of unity that takes place does it simply mean that the pastors are largely liked by their congregation and as a result they are willing to follow the leadership of the pastor well the answer is using the infamous words of Jonathan Hal and Tom Rayner it depends but I did come back with some subjective ideas about highly
effective pastors and here's the confirmation in this as it was done we were able to talk to other people and I was able to ask the question do you think this person is a highly effective pastor and almost unanimously if they knew this pastor they would say oh absolutely and they may not have precise metrics they may not have precise reasons for this effectiveness as we articulated here but they all agreed that there were different things how the pastor was leading in growth how the pastor related to other people how the pastor led in discipleship
really the aggregation of all of those things these people with whom I spoke said yes that person is a highly effective pastor okay we admit that it's subjective so we pause for just a moment we say okay there is some subjectivity there now that we've admitted that and then said you cannot get a precise measure of what effectiveness is now that we've done that then go to the next step we have identified these effective or highly effective pastors now that we've identified them what are some of the characteristics of them so we could come up
with probably 11 or 12 but if you distill this down even more and maybe combine some that are obvious combinations when it was all said and done we came up with seven characteristics of highly effective pastors once again if you are a numbers nerd you may have a bit of discomfort with the subjectivity of all of this but it is a reality that these are the things that we heard repeated again and again about these pastors now I'm going to put these really in the order in which we heard them that does not necessarily say
that means that this is the order of importance but it's the order in which we heard them in other words frequency so these may not be in terms of what is the most what are the most important things but as people talked about these highly effective pastors these are the things that were mentioned most frequently in order of the most frequent okay a lot of introductory thing three-and-a-half minutes to get to the introduction now let's go through each of the seven number one they have genuine enthusiasm they have genuine enthusiasm not rah-rah cheerleader not some
type of fake enthusiasm but they have genuine enthusiasm the word enthusiasm comes from two Greek words in a US which means in God so they were truly excited about their call they were truly excited about their ministry they were truly excited about what God was doing in their lives and it showed people will follow enthusiasm if it's genuine if it is something that reflects a heart for people they will follow enthusiasm they don't follow people do not follow lackluster and boring dull people but they follow those who have a genuine heart a genuine sense of
excitement about what God is doing in their lives we heard this again and again and again now to be clear on this some of these who are genuinely enthusiastic we're extroverts but some of them were introverts as well it is not a personality characteristic as much as it is an overflow of how God is working in the lives of this pay these pastors number two they are great listeners they are great listeners we all have a tendency to want to hear ourselves and as someone else is talking or speaking to us instead of listening we're
often thinking about how we're going to respond so we can be heard one thing we heard about these pastors is they are great listeners a corollary to this is when I spoke to this pastor I felt like I was the only person in the room I felt like that pastor was so focused upon me that there was a sense that wow there is really concerned caring empathy that is taking place now just as some kind of a reminder even though these are characteristics just be reminded that these are characteristics that none are necessarily well let's
just put it this way they can be learned they can be learned so if you're not a great listener you can focus on listening how do you do that as a person is speaking you're genuinely trying to take in the words he or she is saying instead of thinking about how you're going to respond I've heard many people if someone's talking they're kind of not in the hair's and say yeah yeah you can almost hear them I watch their body language because they're all they're doing is they're prepared to go to what they want to
say they're great listeners number three their identity is not in their vocation now that hear hear me well their identity is in Christ in Christ call upon their lives but they don't wake up each morning and say I am Who I am because I am a pastor they wake up each morning and say I am Who I am because I am a child of God because I am in Christ their identity is not in their vocation if your identities in your vocation you hang on to your vocation you're never willing to step down and retire
from your Voki you you won't have titles in your vocation you want to be an emeritus you just you want to hold on to things because that is your identity their identity was not in their vocation number four they were intentional about personal witnessing they were intentional about personal witnessing that doesn't that mean we can have a debate on whether evangelism is an office or a gift and I'm not going to go into that but that does not mean that they have the gift of evangelism or have a natural propensity toward evangelism but they were
intentional about it the most effective pastors had a a pattern where they were intentional and often accountable for evangelism so one they have genuine enthusiasm two they're great listeners three their identity is not in their vocation for they are intentional about personal witnessing number five they have unconditional love of their critics tough one I know you pastors know you leaders know if you're not being criticized you probably are not leading man when criticism happens there's a visceral reaction to want to fight back and to defend yourself these pastors had an unconditional love of the critics
in fact many of them they told us they prayed for their critics and this would be related as well number six they have a gentle spirit they just have a gentle spirit does that mean they're not intense it does that mean they're not competitive but there's something about them that's just a gentleness and you you have a genuine comfort around them because they're not all about themselves they have a spirit that desires the best in others so number six is they have a gentle spirit finally number seven they persevere the most effective pastors sometimes just
get up the next morning and still do what they're supposed to do and then the next morning and the next morning they persevere they hang in there they stick to the task that God has called them until they are certain beyond any doubt God's call in their lives are there to move to something else they persevere perseverance is not always easy because of the critics because of the ups and downs of pastoral ministry but cause of the great emotional swings that are often present and endemic to the role of being a pastor they were consistent
they just kept on keeping on to get to get it counter cliche seven characteristics of highly effective pastors genuine enthusiasm great listeners identity is not in their vocation intentional about personal witnessing unconditional love of their critics have a gentle spirit and they persevere it was really fine to have these discussions about effective pastors and I hope that for those of you who are pastors or just in roles of leadership that this could be of some benefit to you let me say thank you as always to Tim songster and just thank him in Cusco for their
work for their role at church and you can go you can look up Cusco at Church design.com find out about that design build firm recommend them all over the place they're doing a great job and thank you those who are viewing this for being a part of the reina report come back in a couple of weeks and we'll have another edition ready for you I'll see you then