Sonoma an Akuma and welcome to contemporary Islamic law so no and I need chrome season alaikum Salaam so we're talking about contemporary Islamic legal issues right and that's basically the theme of our show what specific topic are gonna be addressing in today's episode all the villainous shaytan al rajim bismillah ar-rahman ar-rahim the books of felt begin with the section dedicated to h2 heart and took lead and i think that's the perfect way to begin discussing and understanding and studying fit because fit is derived out of the Quran the hadith edge map which is the consensus
among scholars or Muslims and what is the intellect which is intellect so how do we derive those laws that's a discussion of itself the process of each t hat is a discussion in itself the history of its Ahad is a discussion in itself I wanted to start with and a question that is often Lee asked and that is can a woman become a much debt can you follow a woman that is a merchant and you know this topic can be discussed in a variety of ways but I want to make sure that our audience our
respected audience know that we're not discussing the ammama of a woman here whether she is going to be the the representative of the 12th Imam in that sense of having Malaya to the people upon the people because that's in itself at a completely different topic there are men issues relating to woman in fact for example can womanly prayers can women do the witnessing you know is it to witnesses is it one all those things but we want to discuss the following one can a woman is it possible for her to become a funny how much
dad or is it that something stops her from becoming a much dead number two if she becomes a much to hit can she then follow her own self her own defense was or does she still have to follow another man and number three if then she's a much dead and she follows her own each to heart can either follow her can others follow her and I think that's a very important topic because I find a lot of woman living in the West or probably even in Muslim countries that have given up on it Sahad have
given up on going to the seminary studying becoming Foca ha because I feel they're not encouraged enough and they feel that you know this is a dead end for them and what we want to do is we want to basically let people know that's this is very important in the introduction of this episode I want to say we've had many woman which two hits an hour the history of of the method above I had a debate which two heads the powerful much dance that happened to be a woman so let's discuss this I believe one
from a historical perspective if you look at the books of a Satan more table for example who died in the year 436 specifically his most important book the dairy aisle a soulish area I'll order for Shahab who died in the year 463 and Muhammad Ali who died in the Year 676 Edgeley and ma ba de la Sol for a llama Holly died in the year 725 those are our most important scholars that I believe have impacted Shia Islam the most when discussing the criteria of a merger the criteria of a know where it is stated
by them that it has to be a men so that in itself is something you know yeah and then we come to the Year 1281 Headley I would say the the Godfather of the Maharaja and Hauser and the AHA and the master of them all shackle ansari shackle ansari specifically says that there is no evidence that a fatty and a metal jerk or much de head has to be a man we lack evidence in that however I must also add the today our contemporary my idea the popular opinion amongst them I cannot say there is
a consensus there is no consensus there are folk AHA in the holy city of Palm that I am aware of that I have read their books that are staunch supporters of the fact that woman can become which dance woman can become Foca and they can even become rajim but the popular opinion amongst the scholars is that they may become which the heads however in regards to take lead in regards to becoming Mirage or there is a glitch there's an issue that's what we're going to be discussing associated now I have a question here at this
point isn't a measure basically an expert right from my understanding so according to their opinion what's stopping a woman from becoming an expert exactly the scholars that are opposing the fact that much the heads and melodia can only be men one of the things that they say is look at the history of humanity and specifically now and look at look at them all around the world if a woman for example has a PhD and a man has a PhD they look at both of them at the same level of being equal expertise you know you
know if you want to go to a dentist if you want to go to a physician if you catch a cold and they tell you this person is a really good doctor you're not gonna say well is that a man or a woman you know I highly doubt anybody would say that or for example I mean as far as their expertise is concerned yes so that's one thing you know woman can become experts on the topic you know she can read the Quran and she can read the hadith look at the opinion of scholars at
Jamaa octal use her intellect and derive a lot and once she derives this law then you know much the head cannot follow another which that of course in fact it is haram for a much to had to follow another which that and if you look at the jaws ovitch to HOD that's given by senior scholars to their students one of the indicators that they say this person is now on which to hit is that they say why automatically Darley it is haram for this person to do technique meaning he's on which they had himself so
let's just make this point clear that you either have to be a much dead yourself or you have to do tuck lead or you have to do it yet basically you look at all the opinions of scholars and you take the most difficult one because that is to be on the safe side yeah that's gonna put you on the safe side so now that she's how much debt and it's how long for her to follow another much dead can others follow her if they find her to be an expert on the topic that's where the
disagreement I believe lies some scholars say absolutely yes because Allah in the Quran says Aloha hello Vic and contemplate Solomon just ask the experts once you don't know it doesn't specify it or a hello Vic you know obviously are the Imams are the muscle mean and inheritors of their knowledge who is the inheritor of the knowledge is the the person who can derive the correct opinion what the Imam really wants form the hadith because you know when you look at the books how do you know that this really the Imam really said this how you
know he didn't say it in a state of tukya you know although this is the job of woman saying so once this person can do that then what would be the problem in taking their opinion and their expertise on the topic thank you very much Seidman thank you to our viewers and listeners for being with us this has been contemporary Islamic law of course don't forget to share your questions and suggestions with us in the comment and we will get to them in the further episodes until then wa salaam aleikum