philosophers dramatists theologians have grappled with this question for centuries what makes people go wrong interestingly I asked this question when I was a little kid when I was a kid growing up in the South Bronx in a city ghetto in New York I was surrounded by evil as all kids are who grow up in an inner city and I had friends who were really good kids who lived out the dr. Jekyll mr. Hyde scenario of Robert Louis Stevenson that is they took drugs got in trouble went to jail some got killed and some did it
without drug assistance so when I read Robert Louis Stevenson that was in fiction the only question is what was in the juice and more importantly that line between good and evil which privileged people like to think is fixed and impermeable with them on the good side and the others on the bad side I knew that line was immovable and it was permeable good people could be seduced across that line and on the good sand some rare circumstances bad kids could recover with help with reform with rehabilitation so I want to begin with it's wonderful it's
wonderful illusion by Swiss artist MC Escher if you look at it and focus on the white what you see is a world full of angels but let's look more deeply and as we do what appears is the demons the devil's in the world and that tells us several things one the world is was will always be filled with good and evil because good and evil is the yin and yang of the human condition tells me something else if you remember God's favorite angel was Lucifer apparently Luther means the light it also means the morning star
in some scripture and apparently he disobeyed God and that's not all timid disobedience to Authority and when he did Michael the Archangel was sent to kick him out of heaven along with the other fallen angels and so Lucifer descends into hell it becomes Satan becomes the devil the force of evil in the universe begins paradoxically it was God who created hell as a place to store evil he didn't do a good job of keeping it there though so this arc of the cosmic transformation of God's favorite angel into the devil for me sets the context
or under human beings who are transformed from good ordinary people into perpetrators of evil so the Luther effect although it focuses on the negatives the negatives that people can become not the negatives that people are leads me to a psychological definition evil is the exercise of power and that's the key it's about power to intentionally harm people psychologically to hurt people physically to destroy people mortally or ideas and to commit crimes against humanity if you google evil a word that should truly have with it by now you come up with a hundred and thirty six
million hits and a third of a second a few years ago I'm sure all of you was shocked as I was with the revelation of American soldiers abusing prisoners in a strange place in a controversial war I would grave and in Iraq and these were men and women who were putting prisons through an unbelievable humiliation I was shocked but I wasn't surprised because I had seen those same visual parallels when I was the prison superintendent of the Stanford Prison study immediately the Bush administration military said what what all administration's say when there's a scandal don't
blame us it's not the system it's the few bad apples a few rogue soldiers my hypothesis is American soldiers are good usually maybe it was the panel that was bad but how am I gonna how am I gonna deal with that hypothesis I became an expert witness for one of the guards sergeant chip Frederick and in that position I had access to the dozen investigative reports I had access to him I could study him have him come to my home get to know him do psychological analysis to see was he a good apple or bad
Apple and thirdly I had access to all of the thousand pictures that these soldiers took these pictures are a violent or sexual nature all of them come from the cameras of American soldiers because everybody has the digital cameras cell phone camera they took pictures of everything more than a thousand what I've done is I organized them into various categories but these are by United States Military Police Army reservists there are not soldiers prepared for this mission at all and it all happened in single place Toa on the night shift why tRNA was the Center for
military intelligence it was the interrogation hold CIA was there interrogators from Titan corporation all there and they're getting no information about the insurgency so they're gonna put pressure on these soldiers military pleased across the line give them permission to break it with the will of the enemy to prepare them for interrogation to soften them up to take the gloves off those are the euphemisms and this is how it was interpreted let's go down to that dungeon so pretty horrific that's what that's one of the one of the visual illustration of evil and it should not
have escaped you that the reason I paired that the prisoner with his arms out with Leonardo da Vinci's ode to the humanity is that that prison that was mentally ill that prison had covered himself with [ __ ] every day and they used to have to roll him in dirt so he wouldn't stink but but the guards ended up calling him [ __ ] boy what was he doing in that prison rather than in some mental institution in any event here's former Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld he comes down and says I want to know who
was responsible who are the beds who the bad apples well that's a bad question you have to reframe it and ask what is responsible because what could be the who of people but it could also be the what of the situation and obviously that's where I'm headed so how does psychologists go about understanding such transformations of human character if you believe that they were good soldiers before they went down to the dungeons there are three ways the main way is what's called dispositional we look at what's inside of the person the bad apples this is
the foundation of all of social sciences foundation a religion the foundation of law social psychologists like me come along saying yeah people are the actors on the stage but you'll have to be aware of what the situation is who are the cast of characters what's the costume is there a sage director and so we're interested in what are the external factors around the individual the bad barrel and social scientists stop there and they missed the big point that I discovered when I was became an experienced tribal grab the power is in the system the system
creates the situation that corrupts the individuals the system is the legal political economic cultural background and this is where the power is of the bad barrel makers so you want to change the person you got to change the situation one change the situation you got to know where the power is in the system so the loser effect involves understanding human character transformations with these three factors and it's a dynamic interplay what did the people bring into the situation what is the situation bring out of them and what is the system if that creates and maintains
that situation so my book the loser in fact recently published is about how do you understand how good people turn evil and has great a lot of detail about I'm gonna talk about today so dr. Z's loser effect although focuses on evil really is a celebration of the human mind infinite capacity to make any of us kind or cruel caring or indifferent creative or destructive and it makes some of us villains and the good news story that I'm going to hopefully come to at the end is that make some of us heroes this is a
wonderful cartoon in The New Yorker which you really summarized my whole talk I'm neither a good cop nor bad cop to Rome like yourself I'm a complex amalgam with positive and negative personality traits that emerge or not depending on the circumstances this is a study some of you think you know about but very few people have ever read the story you watch that you watch the movie this is a sandy Milgram little Jewish kid from the Bronx and he asked the question could the holocaust happen here nah you say no that's not see Germany that's
Hitler you know that's 1939 said yeah but suppose Hitler asked you would you electrocute a stranger no way not me I'm a good person so why don't we put you in a situation and give you a chance to see what you would do and so what he did was he tested a thousand ordinary people 500 New Haven Connecticut 504 and the ad said psychologists want to understand memory we want to improve people's memory because memory is a key to success okay we're going to give you five bucks four dollars for your time is we don't
want to college students we want men between 20 and 50 and latest studies there in women ordinary people the barbers clerks white-collar people so you go down and one of you is going to be a learn and one of you is going to be teacher to learn it's a genial middle-aged guy he gets tied up to the shock apparatus in another room the learner could be the middle age could be as young as 20 and one of you is told by the authority the guy in the lab coat your job as teacher is to give
this guy material to learn gets the right reward and gets it wrong you press a button on the shock box first button is 15 volts he doesn't even feel it that's the key all evil starts with 15 volts and then the next step there's another 15 volts the problem is at the end of the line is 450 volts and as you go along the height is screaming I got a heart condition I know madam you're a good person you complain sir who's gonna be responsible something happens him experiment says don't worry I will be responsible
go continue teacher and the question is who would go all the way to 450 volts you should know to see it when it gets up to 375 is as dangerous severe shock when it gets up to here this xxx the pornography of power so Milgram has 40 psychiatrists how meant what percent of American citizen who go to the end they said only 1% because that sadistic behavior and we know psychiatry knows only 1% of Americans are sadistic ok here's the data they could not be more wrong 2/3 go all the way to 450 volts this
was just one study Milgram did more than 16 studies and look at this in study 16 where you see somebody like you go all the way 90 percent go all the way and study five if you see people rebelled 90 percent rebelled what about women study 13 no different than men so Milgram is quantifying evil as to the willingness of people to blindly obey Authority to go all the way to 450 volts and it's like a dial on human nature a dial in sense that you can make almost everybody totally obedient down to the majority
down to none so what are the external parallels all research is artificial what's the validity in real world 912 American citizens committed suicide or murdered by family and friends in Guyana jungle in 1978 because they were blindly obedient to the sky a pastor not the priest a pastor Reverend Jim Jones he persuaded them to commit mass suicide and so he's the modern loose effect a man of God who becomes the angel of death Milgram study is all about individual authority to control people most of the time we are in institutions so the Stanford Prison study
is a study of the power of institutions to influence individual behavior interestingly Stanley Milgram and I were in the same high school class in James Monroe in the Bronx 1954 so this study which I did with my graduate students especially Craig Haney we also began work with an ad we didn't have money so we had cheap little head but we wanted college students for a study of prison life seventy-five people volunteered to personality test we did interviews pick two dozen most normal most healthy randomly assign them to be president guard so on day one we
knew we had good apples I'm gonna put them in a bad situation and secondly we know there's no difference between the boys are going to be guards the boys are gonna be prisons the kids are gonna be friends I said wait at home in the dormitories with the study will begin Sunday we didn't tell them that the city police were going to come and do realistic arrests police car pulls up in front and a cop comes to the front door knocks and says he's looking for me so they right there that you know they took
me out the door they put my hands against the car there's a real cop car it was a real policeman and there were real neighbors in the street who didn't know that I was this was a experiment and there was cameras all around the neighbors all of it they put me in the car then they drove me around Palo Alto they took me to the to the police station the basement of the police station then they put me in the cell I was the first one to be picked up so they put me in a
cell which is just like a room with a door with bars on it you could tell it wasn't a real jail they locked me in there in this degrading little outfit they were taking this experiment too seriously here are the prisoners who are going to be dehumanized they're going to become numbers here the guards with the symbols of power and anonymity guards get prisons to clean the toilet bowls out their bare hands to do all the humiliating tasks they stripped them naked they sexually taunt them they begin to do degrading activities like having them simulate
sodomy you saw simulating fellatio in soldiers novigrad my guards did it in five days the express reaction was so extreme that normal kids we've picked because they're healthy had breakdowns within 36 hours the study ended after six days because it had was out of control five kids had emotional breakdowns does it make a difference if warriors go to battle changing their appearance or not does it make a difference if they're anonymous and how they treat their victims we know in some cultures they go to war they don't change appearance in other cultures they paint themselves
like Lord of the Flies and something they wear masks and many they wear soldiers are anonymous and uniformed so with this psycho anthropologist John Watson found 23 cultures that had two bits of data do they change their appearance 15 do they kill torching milli 13 if they don't change their appearance only one of eight kills torture mutilate the key is in the redzone if they change their appearance 12 of 13 that's 90% kill torture mutilation and that's the power of anonymity so what are the seven social processes that grease the slippery slope of evil mindlessly
taking the first small step dehumanization of others deindividuation of self diffusion of personal responsibility blind obedience to Authority uncritical conformity to group norms passive tolerance of evil through inaction or indifference and it happens when you're in a new or unfamiliar situation your habitual response patterns don't work your personality and morality are disengaged nothing is easier than to denounce the evil doer nothing more difficult than understanding him Dostoyevsky tells us understanding is not excusing psychology is not excuse e ology so social psychological research reveals how ordinary good people can be transformed without the drugs you don't
need it you just need the social psychological processes real-world parallels compare this with this James Schlesinger I'm gonna have to end with this says psychologists have attempted to understand how and why individuals and groups who usually act humanely can sometimes act otherwise in certain circumstances that's the loser effect and he goes on to say the landmark stanford study provides a cautionary tale for all military operations if you give people power without oversight it's a prescription for abuse they knew that and let that happen so another another report investigative report by General fade says the system
is guilty and in this report he says it was the environment created Abu Ghraib by leadership failures that contributes to the occurrence of such abuse and the fact that it remained undiscovered by higher authorities for a long period time those abuses went on for three months who was watching the store the answer is nobody I think nobody on purpose he gave the guards permission to do those things and then whom nobody was ever going to come down to that dungeon so you need a paradigm shift in all these areas the shift is away from the
medical model that focused only on the individual and the shift is toward a public health model that recognizes situational and systemic vectors of disease bullying is a disease prejudices ease violence is disease and since the Inquisition we've been dealing with problems at the individual level and you know what it doesn't work Alexander Solzhenitsyn says a line between good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being that means that line is not out there that's a decision that you have to make that's a personal thing so I want to end very quickly on a
positive note heroism as the antidote to evil by promoting the heroic imagination especially in our kids in an educational system we want kids to think I'm a hero and waiting waiting for the right situation to come along and I will act heroically my whole life is now going to focus away from evil I've been in since I was a kid to understanding heroes banality of heroism is odd it's ordinary people who do heroic deeds it's the counterpoint to Haaretz a banality of evil our traditional societal heroes are wrong because they are the exceptions they organize
the whole life around this that's why we know the names and our kids heroes are also wrong models for them because they have supernatural talents we want our kids to realize most heroes and everyday people and the heroic act is unusual this is Joe Darby he was the one that stopped those abuses who saw because what he saw those images he turned them over to see an investigating officer he was a low-level private and that stopped it was a hero no they had put him in hiding because people wanted to kill him and then his
mother and his wife for three years they were in hiding this is the woman who stopped this type of prison said and I said it got out of control I was a prison superintendent I didn't notice out of control I was totally indifferent she came down so that had house and said you know what it's terrible what you're doing to those boys not prisoners the nut cards there boys and you are responsible and I ended the study the next day the good news is I married for the next year [Applause] I just came to my
senses obviously so so situations have the power to do through the sink but it's the point this is the same situation that can instant that can inflame the hostile imagination some of us that makes us perpetrators of evil can inspire the heroic imagination in others it's the same situation and you're on one side of the other most people are guilty of the evil of inaction because your mother says don't get involved mind your own business and you say mama Humanity is my business so it's at college of heroines immense we're gonna end in a moment
how do we encourage children and new hero courses that I'm working with Matt Langdon he has a hero workshop to develop this heroic imagination is self labeling I am a hero in waiting and teach them skills to be a hero you have to learn to be a deviant because you're always going against the conformity of the group heroes are ordinary people whose social actions extraordinary who act the key to heroes have two things you had act when other people have passive be you have that socio centrically not egocentric Lee and I want to end with
the story that some of you know about Wesley Autrey New York subway hero 50 year old african-american construction worker he's standing on a subway in New York a white guy falls on the tracks the subway train is coming there's 75 people do you know what they freeze he's got a reason not to get involved he's black the guy's white and he's got two little kids instead he gives his kids to strange it jumps on the tracks puts the guy between the tracks lays on him but somebody goes over him wesleyan the guy 20 and a
half inches height the Train clearance is 21 inches a half an inch would have taken his head off and he said I did what anyone could do no big deal to jump on the tracks and the moral imperative is I did what everyone should do and so one day you will be in a new situation take paths one you're gonna be a perpetrator of evil evil meaning gonna be Arthur Andersen you're gonna cheat for you're gonna have to allow bullying that's who you become guilty of the evil a passive inaction that's where you become a
hero the point is are we ready to take the path to celebrating ordinary heroes waiting for the right situation to come along to put heroic imagination into action because it may only happen once in your life when you pass it by you'll always know I could have been a hero and let it pass me by so the point is thinking it and then do so I'm going to thank you thank you thank you let's oppose the power of evil systems at home and abroad and let's focus on the positive advocate for respected personal dignity for
justice and peace which sadly our administration has not been doing thanks so much [Music] [Applause]