hey guys it's Bella welcome back to my channnel happy Monday hope you're all having a great start to the week if you're new here welcome we do a series on my channel called mystery Mondays where basically on Mondays we get together and we talk about True Crime so if that's something you're into then come join us make sure to subscribe so you don't miss a video today we're going to be talking about a case that is actually a pretty tough one to talk about this case is a hard one to swallow it's about the murder
of a 15-year-old boy which happened back in 1961 and this case actually took 41 years to solve and throughout that entire 41 years there wasn't a moment in time where his parents gave up it's actually really really heartbreaking the whole situation around that so you guys will see as you know we get more into the case and talk more about it but today we're going to be talking about the case of John mccab he was born on the 13th of March in 1954 in Middle sex County Massachusetts his dad bill was an engineer and his
mother Evelyn worked at the school library and he was the second of their three children so he had two sisters a younger sister named Roberta and an older sister named Debbie and they were a really really close family there was just a lot of love there between all of them they all said that John was really full of life and that he was a little bit of a prankster Debbie said she remembered one time when she opened her closet and it was full of grasshoppers courtesy of her little brother Roberta said that he just loved
being outside like his hands were always dirty with you know dirt and then oil grease animals he was always picking up animals like frogs one time they said that he even came home with like a full Goose by 1969 John was 15 years old his youngest sister Roberto was 6 and his oldest sister Debbie was 17 and the family was living in tuxbury which is also in Massachusetts and John had a school dance on the 26th of September at the Nights of Columbus Hall he asked his parents if he could go and he was just
so excited so of course they said yes and he went he got all ready he had a shower he did his hair he used his dad's arm to shave even though you know he was a 15-year-old boy he didn't shave yet he spent all afternoon getting ready for this dance he head out that night and the dance was meant to finish at 11:00 p.m. so he was expected home by at least or by latest midnight by about 11:00 p.m. his mother Evelyn is checking out the window for him waiting for him to come home but
by midnight he still wasn't there so she left she jumped in her car she drove to the school and she was driving around the school calling Jon's name but there was no sign of him so she ended up driving through all of the streets surrounding the school just yelling out her window calling for John and and there was nothing there was no sign of John anywhere and she just had this gut feeling that something wasn't right that something had gone wrong and she just started to pray she spent that night just praying that he was
okay the next day on the 27th of September three young kids were cutting through a vacant dirt lot on Maple Street in the nearby town of LOL which is only like a 30-minute drive from tuxbury as they were cutting through this dirt lot they came across the body of 15-year-old John mccab with which on top of everything else on top of how horrific it is that a 15-year-old boy has been murdered I cannot imagine how traumatizing it would be for these young children to stumble across a dead body and not only that but JN had
been bound and gagged as well so it was just really a horrific traumatizing scene after the discovery and after the police went out there and identified the body they went to the house of Bill and Evelyn mccab to let them know and it was such a horrific way in which his body was found that they didn't want to tell evely in the detail so they took Bill down to the basement and told him that they had found his 15-year-old son's body there was tape over his mouth and his eyes his ankles had been tied together
with rope and his wrist had also been tied together separately and then another piece of rope had been used to tie his ankles to his neck as they were telling Bill all of this information Evelyn of course she she had mother's intuition she knew that the police she knew that something was wrong with her son she knew there was a reason that he hadn't come home that night you know of course he was a prankster but he would never play a prank on his parents where he wouldn't come home that night you know what I
mean like he would never make his parents worry like that so she just knew something wasn't right now the police have shown up at her house the next day and so there was actually this vent in her bathroom where she could hear everything that was being said in the basement so she got on the floor of the bathroom and she put her ear up to this vent and she heard every single detail and she just laid on the bathroom floor sobbing Bill had to go and identify his 15-year-old son's body which I can't even like
the strength of these people I'm watching their interviews watching Bill and Evelyn's interviews it's a really really tough watch because their pain is so so palpable and Evelyn says in these interviews she says at one point you know I let him go I let him go out the door I shouldn't have and she also says what kind of mother was I I should have been there for him and it's heartbreaking because she was just making her son happy like he was so excited to go to this school dance it's a school dance you know she
was just letting him go and do this thing that was meant to be fun and meant to be exciting doing something to make her child happy never in a million years would you expect your 15-year-old son to go to a school dance and be murdered there a huge investigation was launched by the tuxbury L and Massachusetts State Police they went and they combed that vacant lot where his body was found and they collected the Rope the tape that was used to bind him and gag him they collected his clothes and his shoes and then they
also were able to recover a fingerprint from something in the area you know whether I don't know where the fingerprint came from but they collected a fingerprint but it was 1969 so DNA evidence isn't really a thing and all of those things that they collected they couldn't really do anything with them like they didn't produce any leads none of it could be tied to anybody they did have a couple of witnesses that they found there was one witness who said that on this vacant lot on that night of the murder that they had seen a
maroon 1965 Chevy and paror another witness also said that on the night of the dance on the night of the murder that they had seen John hitch hiking and he had been picked up by these two kids who also went to the same school as him and these two kids were 16-year-old Michael Ferrera and his friend a girl named Nancy Williams obviously police went and spoke to Mike and Nancy and Mike said that he didn't really know John you know he'd seen him around school a couple times but that was really all he knew of
him he didn't have any other information Nancy was also the same you know she didn't really know John had just seen him around school but they weren't even the same age I don't know if they were in the same grade or what but they obviously did not run in the same Circle so they didn't know him but they had seen him hitchhiking putting his thumb out so they picked him up drove him gave him a ride to the dance and dropped him off there and that was that once the dance started Michael and Nancy also
you know split up went their separate ways Michael went and met up with his friend a 17-year-old kid named Walter and he and Walter went in Walter's car to LOL to just drive around and get some beers and drink some beers Walter Shell's car right was actually a 1965 maroon Chevy andala Mighty coincidence so of course police go and they search the car there's nothing in the car right there's no signs of anything in the car no evidence that can point them towards him having any thing to do with Jon's murder or John being in
his car nothing of course they still bring him in for questioning they make can do five polygraph tests and in these polygraph tests he has found to be lying in all vital areas but that's it polygraphs are known to be really reliable there was no evidence against him nothing to suggest he was involved nothing in his car so it just turned out to be another Dead lead and the next year in 1970 both Michael Ferrera and Walter Shelly went and joined the Armed Forces police did try to look into a bunch of other suspects they
looked into drug dealers in the area pedophiles in the area other teenagers other kids who went to John's school but they didn't really find a lot there was one other guy that they looked into a 25-year-old named Robert moley and Robert moley knew both Michael Ferrera and Walter shell he was reportedly suffering from some type of mental illness which they didn't name in any of the reports that I read he was named a suspect but he was named a suspect kind of in relation to Michael Ferrera so when that lead died out I guess the
lead of Robert moley also died out years later like there really wasn't a lot of evidence in this case so it was a very very very slow case there just wasn't a lot like there wasn't a lot of leads that popped up evidence there was no evidence in the case right so there just wasn't anything so it wasn't until 1974 that another suspect was identified a guy named Richard Santos he was flagged in 1974 as a suspect by the tuxbury police because he committed a very similar crime to Jon's murder so he abducted a girl
a young girl on Route 38 he bound her feet tied her hands behind her back bags he duct taped both her mouth and her eyes but again this lead just fizzled out they couldn't tie him to Jon's murder in any type of way and honestly after this the case went cold pretty quickly the case was cold between 1969 and 1974 but then after that it was like just nothing there wasn't another development in the case for another 26 years and that was 26 years of torture for the M familyes I'm sure you can imagine they
continued to set a place for John at the table at dinner I tried to angle myself just to visualize what it felt like I wondered did he call for me what kind of a mother was I I wasn't there for him I I don't think I've had a whole night's sleep since it's happened John Z Bill also wrote a story about John's life his entire you know short 15 years that he had on this Earth his life and his death because he wanted to have a record of John and have a record of his life
he wanted to hold on to him and he wanted to hold on to his memory I think we ever right to be proud of him yeah I always visualized him as being a big shot somewhere John Joseph mcab my son JJ you know but I never got to see any of those things Evelyn actually throughout this whole time throughout this entire 26 years and Beyond like throughout her entire life she held on to some of John's money that he had as a memory of him I almost put it in the casket with him and then
I thought no I'll just keep it with me and when I see him again I'll give it to him Bill and Evelyn prayed every single day that they would get Justice for their son and they never gave up hope they never gave up trying they never gave up trying to get this Justice for their son bill was always on the phone to the police he was always calling the police trying to make sure that they remember John that they continued to look into his case he you know was just always trying to keep his case
and his memory alive and he was tireless in his efforts over all of these years you know 26 years with no development and they never gave up eventually in November of 2000 there was actually a development in the case and this development came from one of John's childhood friends that he went to school with a guy named Jack ward he had promised bill when he was younger that he would tell Bill if he found out any or heard any information about J's murder because obviously Jack knows people that knew Jon knows he probably know somebody
that knows what happened to JN right so he was always he promised he would always keep an ear out for anything and that's exactly what he did when in November of 2000 he went to a cookout with a bunch of people people that they had gone to school with and one of those people in particular was Michael Ferrera everyone at this cookout is you know they're sitting down they're eating drinking chatting and then all of a sudden Michael Bloods out I know who killed John mccab of course Jack is like hold on a minute you
can't just say that and not say who like who is it so Michael says that it was Walter shell and that he killed him because he was jealous he killed him over a girl this girl was a girl named Mara she was 13 years old at the time of the murder and she was dating Walter Shell at the time of the murder they ended up actually going on to get married for a brief time they they're divorced at the time of the cookout but you know after the murder after I guess she got a bit
older she was 13 I think he was like 17 at the time they went on to get married for a bit and yeah so they were dating at the time of John's murder and apparently Mara may have had a little crush on JN at the time which made Walter very angry very jealous and so he killed JN he was known to be a very jealous guy but that is like extreme Jack of course you know after hearing this goes and tells Bill and Bill writes these names down and he called the police and told them
and the police really didn't take it seriously at first it took another 3 years and many many many more calls for bill for the police to actually go and question Walter shell and Michael Ferrera about this it wasn't until 2003 that they went and question Michael they showed up at his house he was living in Salem in New Hampshire which is about 25 km or 16 mi from tuxbury he was a forklift operator and he was living there with his now wife Nancy Williams so the girl who he'd been with in 1969 when they picked
John up on the of the dance now Michael had a very different version of how the cookout conversation went he said that on that night Jack had had a few ter many drinks and he was going around saying Shel did it Shelly did it Shelly did it about Jon's murder and Michael reckons just to shut him up he said yeah he did or yeah he probably did he claims that he never said anything about Mara shell or Walter being jealous apparently that was just Jack's Theory and of course there's really no evidence in this case
there's nothing to dispute what Michael is saying there's nothing to confirm what Jack is saying is true it's just a he said she said kind of situation and so once again the case goes cold another 4 years later in 2007 there's another kind of new development in the case when a new district attorney for Middle sex county is sworn in his name is Jerry Leone and the L County Police Department came to him with John's case and said can you please look into it investigators had gone through all of the files again and they had
actually seen a new name pop up in their most recent interviews with Michael from 2003 I guess they didn't notice that this new name popped up all of a sudden in their interviews from 4 years ago or what the deal was but this name had never been mentioned before until their most recent interview with Michael so how it came up is in that interview he gives them you know the same story about the night of the murder says John was hitchhiking he and Nancy picked him up dropped him off at the dance Nancy and him
go separate ways and he goes and meets up with his friend Walter Shelly to go and get some beers and drive around low County except this time in this most recent interview all of a sudden he throws another name in the mix and he says that it wasn't just Walter Shelly he was with he was also with this other guy named Edward Allan Brown at the time of the murder back in 1969 Ed was 17 and he lived not far from the mccab family Michael and Walter of course are names that have been consistently popping
up throughout the entire investigation so they're Persons of Interest and so by association Edward is now because he was with them on the night of the murder investigators haven't gotten anything from Michael or Al so far so now they're going to focus on Ed and try and get some information out of Ed he has since moved away to New Hampshire he's retired from the Air Force at this point in 2007 police tracked him down they go to his house they speak to him and this guy reckons he knows nothing about the matter he's never even
heard of John mccab which I mean there's no way you know someone from Tisbury to claim that they have never heard of John mccab is ridiculous in and of itself but also this guy who lives right down the road from the maves he obviously runs in the same Circle as kids who went to John's school so it's safe to assume especially if he lived in the same area as John that he went to the same school as well everyone else who he knows has heard of this murder like it's just ridiculous basically for him to
claim that he has never even heard of John M cave it's a massive red flag but there's nothing investigators can do about it right if he wants to lie to them what are they going to do shortly after they left this interview with Edward they're pretty deflated because they're like well you know he's hiding something but not much we can do shortly after they leave that interview they get a call from his wife Carolyn and she says I think my husband's lying to you because about 20 25 years ago he actually told me that he
had been involved in the murder of a young boy obviously that is crazy in and of itself but can I also just sidebar I don't know if you guys have noticed this but the amount of cases lately that I've been covering where women have been told by these men like yeah I murdered somebody and then the women are like oh okay let's get married and I'm not going to tell anybody that you murdered somebody and let's also have kids even though I know you're a murderer there has just been a lot of that going around
lately and it just baffles me because who is doing all that who is like going and marrying a guy who told you they murdered somebody and you're like not going to cry you're not going to tell anybody Let's Get Married let's have kids even though I know you're a murderer like it's just crazy how much of that there has been and how many cases there are where that happens and these cases could be solved so much earlier if these women first of all decided not to marry someone that they know was a murderer but also
told somebody anybody about the murder that their husband confessed to anyway again despite you know Carolyn calling them and telling them this there's nothing they can do Edward is lying to them there's no evidence to prove that he's lying there's nothing they can do about the fact that he's lying and so once again the case hits another dead end and it goes cold and I can't even imagine how frustrating this is for Jon's family that it's like they kind of keep getting these little glimmers of hope here and there and then the case just goes
dead and nothing comes of it again and again and again over all of these years and even after all of these years they are still fighting for justice for their son Fighting For answers they are taking all of these minor leads and these little bits of hope that are given to them by these minor leads and it just must be so so exhausting finally in 2011 a new detective is assigned to this case who feels the same way as the mccab family she wants Justice for John and she is going to do whatever she can
to get it her name is detective Linda Coughlin and even after all of these years she managed to give the mccab family hope again and she put her everything into this case and so the case really took off once she got involved she zeroed back in on Ed and went out to New Hampshire to interview him she interrogated him twice she gave him a polygraph which he failed and then when he failed this polygraph he just totally comes clean he admits that he was there when Michael Ferrera and Walter Shelly killed John McCabe and thanks
to confession on the 15th of April in 2011 so nearly 42 years after the murder of 15-year-old John mccab Edward was indicted for man's order Walter Shelly and Michael Ferrera were indicted for first-degree murder of course Bill and Evelyn are notified right away and they were just in complete shock like Bill just killed over the table and started crying because for 42 years he had been fighting for this day he never gave up over 42 years and now finally you know all of his efforts have paid off there have finally been arrest in his son's
murder he's finally going to get Justice for his son one officer said quote Mr mccab held our feet to the fire he never let us forget John McCabe's murder and what's more as well is that these guys Michael Ferrera Walter Shelly the guys who had been arrested their names were actually in John's book of mners so they had gone to Jon's wake and his funeral it took another 2 years for their trials to start they were tried separately Michael and Walter and Ed actually never went to trial in the end because he took a deal
where he wouldn't get any jail time and in exchange he would testify against both Michael and Walter because of course you know there wasn't really a lot of evidence in this case they never would have sold it if Ed didn't confess so he was their star witness Michael ferrera's trial began in January of 2013 Ed testified against him on the 18th of January and this was the first time the details of Jon's murder had ever been shared publicly so he claimed that on the night of the murder on the night of the dance he was
at home watching TV when at around 10:30 Michael Ferrera and Walter Shelly showed up at his house and they needed his help with he didn't even know what until he got in the car with him they just said we need your help he's like sweet let's go gets in the car in Walter's car the 1965 maroon Chevy andala and they start driving towards the Nights of Columbus Hall where the dance is being held and as they're driving towards the dance that's when they tell Ed what they need help with what their plan is they basically
want to go and find this kid who had been messing around with Walter's girlfriend Mala and they wanted to teach him a lesson for doing that at some point on their Drive Michael spots JN with his thumb out trying to Hitch hike and he says that's there he is so they pull up next to him Michael gets out of the car from the front passenger seat he grabs John and he shoves him into the back seat of the car with Ed and then he goes back around and gets back into the front passenger seat of
the car he's facing back towards the back seat and he's trying to like slap and smack Jon up from the front and John has his arms in front of his face you know trying to prevent this from happening they're driving towards that abandoned lot on Maple Road in L and that's where they pull up at this point Edward pushes Jon out of the car and he's just like thinks he's helping Michael and Walter sort of rough this kid up he thinks they're just going to slap him around a little bit Michael and Walter then trip
Jon up and they get him on the ground while Ed and Walter hold Jon down while Michael tied him up Edward said in his testimony quote Michael tied his ankles then went around and tied his wrist together then he took another piece of rope around his ankles and attached it to his neck they had put tape on his mouth John squirming wiggling trying to get out he's lying on his belly with his legs up in the air and his head turned sideways then they said this will teach you to mess with Mara anymore Ed claims
after this point they got back in the car and they left John there tied up taped up and they just left they went and they drove around drinking beers until eventually Ed said to them you know we should go back and we should let him go So eventually they do go back and Michael and Walter get out of the car they go over to John they're there for all of 30 to 45 seconds before they very quickly get back into the car drive away and they turn around and tell Ed that he wasn't breathing anymore
and that's because John had died of strangulation after this they drove Ed back home and Ed can't he said he couldn't really remember what he did after they dropped him off he thinks he just went up to his bed and cried and he said that he kept this a secret for the last 41 years because he was scared of Michael because Michael apparently had threatened to kill him if he ever told anybody in response to this whole story that Edward has testified to Michael says Brown's a freaking liar and I mean they know that according
to the prosecutor he's been to Iraq in Afghanistan five tours maybe he's got something wrong in his head and even by that even by the way in which he said that like his tone in which he said that like you guys he is insane now over the next 2 days Ed was cross-examined by Michael's defensive attorney and to say that it didn't go well is probably an understatement because he really cracked at the slightest bit of pressure he admitted to lying under oath let me just read you guys a little bit of how this testimony
went cuz it was it was really bad so the defense says Mr Brown you've lied under oath when you're scared right yes you've lied under oath when you're nervous right yes you've lied under the oath when you're frightened right correct you still can't get your F straight can you no you you were fed information it was a dirt lot right yes you were fed information that it was near a railroad tower right yes and you're being told that Shel was jealous over Mara Shina right yes then after that dumpster fire of a cross-examination the defense
calls Mara Shina to the witness stand and she claims in her testimony that John never flirted with her never hit on her they never went to the dance together he never conveyed any interest in her at all then she throws even more of a curveball and she says that at the time of the murder her and Walter weren't actually even dating they started dating after the murder took place but she also said that they started dating in September so it must have been very soon after the murder because the murder took place in on the
26th of September and what's also weird is that according to police when they they obviously went and interviewed her earlier and when they interviewed her she told them that her and Walter were dating at the time of the murder she also said that they had been dating since she was 12 years old and at the time of the murder in 1969 26 of September she was 13 years old so obviously they questioned her on this and she says you know I don't know I just I can't imagine that I did say that to them and
I'm going to read you a quote of what one of John's sisters said about this because I agree wholeheartedly she said why lie about dating someone unless it was because of her that JN was murdered which I get that you know she probably just didn't want to feel responsible for this matter I can't think of any other reason why she would lie and she was clearly lying you know under testimony because the way in which she said oh I don't know I I can't imagine that I did say that like it was very just obvious
that she had just kind of been caught in a lie and she's like oh I don't know I don't know about that which is also strange because even so even if it was kind of over the jealousy of her it still wouldn't be her fault you know it's not her fault that Walter is a complete psycho she did go on to marry Walter but she said that they got divorced because he was a very violent man and when she was asked on the stand if he was a jealous man she responded absolutely and can I
also just say even if they started dating after the matter clearly they were like kind of seeing each other before that so it's still could have been over the jealousy of you know their sort of talking and the talking stages and she's maybe talking to JN at the same time and Walter didn't want any competition and so he still killed Jon out of jealousy like whether they were dating or not jealousy is still a motive during the trial the defense also called detective Linda coflin to the stand and they accused her of having tunnel vision
and overlooking investigative reports that may have pointed to other suspects and they also named these other potential suspects Richard Santos who I mentioned earlier and then also Robert moley who I also named earlier he was labeled in a police report at one time as a strong suspect but Linda Coughlin in her testimony said yes he was but in that same report Michael Ferrera was labeled the prime suspect John stad Bill also took the stand he was 85 at the time and it took every ounce of strength left in him to get to the witness stand
and even to just make it to this trial that he had waited 43 years for good morning Mr mcab do you remember September 27th 1969 yes sir how old was John at that day he was 15 years 6 months and 2 weeks at the end of the trial the jury deliberated for 5 hours and when the verdict was read bill actually had to leave the courtroom and go into another room because he really just wasn't in a good way from The Trial from all the stress of everything and he just didn't think that his heart
could handle hearing a not guilty verdict and that's exactly what the verdict was Michael Ferrera was found not guilty Evelyn had to go and break the new to her husband and she said that she was actually terrified to tell him because she knew that he wasn't doing well and she just didn't think that he could handle it you know all he wanted was Justice for his son and this whole thing had been so stressful for him you know the last 43 years of his life without his son had been so stressful for him because he
had spent all of that time fighting for justice for his son and she was worried that when she told him that the verdict was not guilty that he would die from the stress of it when she told him he just broke down and 4 days later he did pass away his heart gave out his family believes that this was actually a result of stress from The Trial his heart just couldn't take anymore and he was laid to rest right next to John before he did pass Evelyn told him she made a promise to him that
she would take over for him now and she would do everything that she could to get Justice for their son those weding bells are I still don't believe Bill is gone I can still hear him snore in the night and then I I feel the bed is not there Walter Shell's trial began 7 months later on the 3rd of September in 2013 he was now 61 at the time of his trial he was remarried and he had actually been living just a few miles from the maves ever since his trial was pretty much the same
as Michael's same evidence same Witnesses pretty much everything was the same except this time after 2 days of deliberation the jury found Walter Shelly guilty of first-degree murder Evelyn actually wasn't in the courtroom when this verdict was read because she had to leave the courtroom this time because she was so afraid of also hearing another not guilty verdict you know everything was the same the entire trial was exactly the same and she just couldn't handle another verdict of not guilty but it wasn't he was found guilty of first-degree murder and he was sentenced to life
in prison when John's sister Roberta heard the verdict read out she was in court and she said my father would be proud We got one of them but unfortunately Bill never got to see that he never got to see this killer go to prison for the murder of his son he only got to see one of the killers walk free he never got the ending to the story that he wrote about his son's life hey John guess what we got him please take great care of them until I get there please and then I will
in March of 2016 Walter Shell's verdict was actually reduced by a judge to Second deegree murder because the judge said the heft of the evidence falls more squarely on second deegree matter so he will be eligible for parole after 15 years after serving 15 years so he'll be eligible in 2028 John's sister said that they and all the other family members will oppose any of Walter Shell's bids for parole a few months later on the 12th of August in 2016 Evelyn actually passed away as well and you know this comes for just a few months
after his verdict was reduced he's going to be released in I mean four years from now which is crazy I just hope that Evelyn and Bill are now at peace with their son but that's everything for this case let me know your thoughts and your feelings I know this one was a particularly tough case it was a really hard one to talk about and to research as well my heart was just in pieces for John's family and the fact that bill passed away just 4 days after hearing that not guilty verdict and he didn't live
to see Walter Shelly found guilty I was in tears and also not just his family but John himself like what he had to go through in the last moments of his life for no reason because some guy was jealous that maybe he had a crush on a girl maybe they both liked the same girl or maybe a girl that he liked liked JN as well it's just he was 15 years old you know what I mean like it was so senseless and ridiculous and what Jon had to go through is heartbreaking on a night that
he was so excited for he'd spent all afternoon getting ready getting spruced up doing his hair putting on his in stads After Shave and he was just so excited for that night you know and also the fact that Michael Ferrero was found not guilty on the same evidence that Walter was found guilty of like it was the same trial same Witnesses same evidence same everything it was the exact same trial so the fact that Walter Shelly was found guilty on the evidence Michael wasn't and he can't be retried despite that sucks and if you go
and look at interviews of Michael Ferrera his attitude sucks like that guy is a dick and he just seems so cocky about the whole thing he really just seems so cocky and it pisses me off to be honest with you but I digress that's everything he wasn't found guilty but that's everything for this case so let me know what you guys think that's all for me today I hope that you have a great rest of your day and hopefully I'll see you in my next video bye guys