Physical metaphors are best remembered. And a good way to do this, and this is one we often do in groups, is to act this whole process out. And we have a volunteer who's gonna help us.
Come on up. (lady chuckles) What's your name? Doe.
Hi, Doe. So, do you know anything about anxiety? Oh yeah.
Okay, me too. I'm glad I'm not the only one. Well, I'm your anxiety.
I'm your anxiety at it's worst. I'm the anxiety monster, okay? And you're in a situation, here just grab this rope, where anxiety showed up, and you wanna back up just a little bit, and in between you and this anxiety monster is a large bottomless pit.
Uh-oh. You see it right there? Oh yeah.
If you get into that bottomless pit, you will just fall and fall and fall to your death. So it's really important that you not. So I'm gonna pull you in.
I mean, if you don't resist me, (laughs) I'm pulling you right in. Your life is over. So you better start, I'm gonna pull you in.
I am your worst nightmare. I am your biggest fears. (laughs) Oh, by the way, there's things to do over there.
There's like people to love. There's children to hug. There's spouses to, there's things to do, there's a.
. . I am going to pull you right into the.
. . Come on, walk around.
What should she do? (laughs) What can you do? You can't go over there because you gotta do this work first.
If you don't do. . .
You better watch out. You're not strong enough. You need to pull harder.
I'm pulling you pretty hard. Look at that big gigantic. .
. (laughs) What should she do? What could she do?
Can I let go? I don't know. You tell me.
Okay, (laughs) Is that the answer? What could you do? Oh!
Here, grab the rope. (laughs) So, I am gonna pull you and pull you. You can't go over there.
Over there is life, but you've got this work to do. What should she do? Let go, let go.
What should she do? [Lady In Audience] Let go. Let go?
Here, grab the rope. (laughs) No! Here, grab the rope.
Here, grab the rope. Oh good, I got her again. (audience laughs) Here, grab the rope.
Can you do that? Can I do what? Oh no, I got her again.
(everybody laughing) Here, grab the rope. Oh, I've got a stubborn one. (laughs) Do you mind me?
No. Can you do that? You could do that, right?
Yeah. Our clients could do that too. Thank you for being a.
. . (audience laughs) (audience applauds) You know the authority of a workshop leader is not too different than the authority of the dictator within.
I mean, when your dictator gets going, it's saying, no really, you have to, you have to. I mean, there's no space in there. I was being a little kinder.
You know what I'm talking about? And so it seems like, aside from our clients, for us, it's not even within the world of possibility that we can respectfully decline the invitation to be hooked, to grab on, to struggle, to fight, as a means to do something so that you can do other things. And the posture you were in when you let go of the rope, if love, connection, community, contribution is over there, you have the freedom to go there.
In the posture you were in here, you don't have the freedom to go there. Our clients have put their lives on hold. That's the pain of absence.
And meanwhile, artificially building this enormous pain of presence, of this domination of an emotional life, emotional dysregulation, et cetera, that seems overwhelming, not realizing that your posture with regard to the emotions have created that situation. Drp the rope. If you do this exercise in groups, or you can even do it with an individual in therapy, and the person has this kind of realization, again, the physical metaphors can be used almost like a hook to put anything on.
Be a little careful, don't overuse the hook. And especially, don't browbeat your clients with it. Why don't you just drop the rope?
Do it yourself, therapist. (chuckles) You're getting hooked right in that moment. So, a little well-timed and moderate use of these kinds of things.
You've opened a door. Don't browbeat your clients with it, but do remind them of the variations possible in situations where the mind says there's no variations possible. One place you wanna put the acceptance work is in deliberately creating situations that are emotionally difficult.
You put it into exposure work. And the first article ever written on an ACT in a thorough way, in 1987, written in the late Neil Jacobson's book on innovations in cognitive behavior therapy, when it was still being called comprehensive distancing, I said ACT is an exposure-based method. But what exposure is moves from what we have thought about it historically, which turns out to be wrong, which is a kind of extinction and inhibition process that involves decreases in emotions so that you can behave more flexibly.
The more recent work shows pretty clearly that the process of exposure has to do with taking these previously repertoire-narrowing events and behaving more flexibly in their presence. And so what we're gonna try to do in exposure from an ACT point of view, when you're deliberately seeking out situations, or in imagination, things you have physically in actual in vivo exposure, or in imagination, what we're gonna do is we're gonna change our relationship to the thoughts, feelings, and memories that show up that would normally narrow our repertoire. We're gonna change that relationship very much like we were doing with some of these physical exercises, and then put in additional behaviors as part of it.
In order to do that, you really have to let go of the previous agenda. There's a little flip of the switch that's required. And so I don't like doing exposure where the core of what I'm gonna do, which is acceptance and values work in the middle of contact with something that's repertoire-narrowing, if I'm gonna do it inside a conditional yes, I don't want a conditional yes, I want a yes.
So you can limit willingness, but only by two things that I know of, time and situation. You could say I'm willing here, and I'm not willing there. Might have a cost to not being willing there.
I don't know. I'm not saying you get a free pass. I'm just saying you can do that.
You can say I'm willing for this long, but not for that long. Okay. But here's what's not safe.
I'm willing this much, but not that much. (makes wrong answer buzzer noise) Uh, you're mind's listening. If this were a secret and Mr Mind's not listening, okay, maybe you get away with that, but that's not what's happening.
The metaphor in the classic ACT work, it's like if you had a tantrumming kid that you took to the grocery store who always wanted candy and was willing to fall to the floor and scream, "Give me candy! "Give me candy! " and make a big scene.
And (sighs) you know you're supposed to get a candy, but you can't stand the big scene, and so you have a thought like, if this little bratty kid tantrums for more than a minute, I know I shouldn't, but I'm giving the freaking candy. And the kid could hear it? Guess how long your tantrum's gonna last?
One minute. One minute plus one second, absolutely guaranteed. Well the same thing, if you say, well I'll go to the mall as long as it doesn't go to a number 10 panic attack, if I have a nine it's okay, but not a 10.
Your mind's listening. You go to the mall, you're at 7, oh my gosh, it's almost, you're now at eight, it's really getting, you're now at nine, (whimpers) (imitates electrical short) You've plugged yourself into that artificial amplifying loop of anxiety is something to be anxious about. And you're setting a limit is tantamount to inviting the tantrumming kid to call your bluff.
So, I wanna negotiate this before I do it. And a metaphor that I like using is that we can, what we need to do is we need to practice putting ourself in the situation where we are no longer in control in the normal sense. And it's something like jumping.
You know if I were to. . .
This is not a very thick thing. This is probably just 1/1000 of an inch or so, right? But it has a certain thickness.
I'm now a little higher than I was, right? Okay, I'm gonna, jump. I jumped 1/1000 of an inch.
Yeah, but I jumped. And for the moment that I was up in space, when I hit is not up to me, it's up to the gravity, right? And the mass of the Earth.
I could do the same exact thing here that I did there, except then it's going to take a little longer to hit, right? I could do the same thing, probably, I'm an old man, it's probably not safe, from here. I used to do it, but I'm not gonna climb up there and jump from here, although I am tempted to.
(audience laughs) Should I? [Lady In Audience] No. I shouldn't.
(audience laughs) No, don't do it. What do you think? I think I can do it.
All right. (grunting) Do you have insurance? (audience nervously laughs) [Lady In Audience] Oh that chair is too-- Oh man, this is uh, woo woo woo woo.
Woo-hoo! Ta-dah! (audience cheers) The actual muscles involved in that jump are a little different 'cause of the wiggly-ness, were identical to this one.
True? Agree? Context different, time and situation, we can play with context.
Now I'm not gonna jump from the roof of this building without, be life-threatening, I probably wouldn't survive it. Put a parachute on me, I might do it. Take me up in an airplane, if I'm jumping out with a parachute on, probably the same muscles, with me on this?
If I'm gonna practice jumping, I can start my practice here, or there, or there. What I can't do is this. I am not completely comfortable jumping.
I'm just gonna step down, okay? So I did it, right? No you didn't.
I mean you were in control at every point, right? You never did jump. You never were putting yourself in the situation where gravity decided when you landed.
You decided. Well that's fine here. It's even fine there.
I can't do it from there. It's impossible, never mind the top of this building. I got an email from somebody who'd done an ACT workshop with me.
And he said, "After I went home, about a day later, "I got a call that my dad had died unexpectedly, "boom, of a heart attack. "And what I normally would have done "is say I'm not going to the funeral. "I can't stand the pain.
"I'm not doing it. "Instead, what I did is, "I went to the funeral. "And it was excruciating.
"And it was wonderful. "I saw my sister and my brother. "And I saw my relatives.
"And we cried. "And we laughed. "And we hugged ourselves.
"And we told funny stories. "And we wept some more. " Then he said something like, "Thanks for the jumping.
" You don't know if life is gonna ask you to jump from a building tomorrow. You don't know. But you can practice for that moment by your willingness to do the small things.
And so, you're learning something. There's a tape of me working with Kirk Strosahl, with a person who is diagnosed as borderline personality disorder who had just had a relationship breakup, a long marriage breakup, and who was on welfare and incapacitated, and who said, "If I were to touch my aloneness, I will die. " And she meant it.
If you have worked with people with that diagnosis, you know how emotions can feel so overwhelming that it literally is life-threatening. And there was an ottoman in between us. Kirk And I were sitting with her, and that was back in the day when I would do training on ACT by just getting in with therapists and doing training, and people would watch behind the mirror.
A lot of the early trainings were done that way. And I asked her to take the ottoman to be aloneness, and to reach out, and to feel aloneness. And she recoiled from that ottoman like it was a snake.
And I said, "Well look, how about if we do this "just for 30 seconds. "We're just gonna feel this. "Just like imagine this ottoman, "and what it feels like "is like you deliberately, by choice, "opening up to your own sense of aloneness.
"Just 30 seconds. " She said, "No. " I said, "10.
" She said, "No. " I said, "One. " "Okay, but for one second, just one second.
" I said, "Okay, one second. " And the video shows her (mumbles) like that. Another letter, but this one long later, it was something like 10 years later, where she writes to Kirk, who was her primary therapist, I just did one session with her, and she's become an allied health professional, I won't mention it, but I just might, confidentiality, has a life, is married, and, "Thanks for the ottoman," is on the note.
Who knows where in a one second is a jump that's only 1/1000 of an inch? But it's okay if what you're doing is the quality of showing up without artificially controlling. So, I think we start where we can start.
We're not here to fix our clients. We're here to liberate our clients and then let their lives unfold from there.