modern has always been a format that's had a lot of problems in fact I kind of think that that's been one of the selling points at least to me is that modern is a format where players can come to feel very hot and cold there are Decks that players really really love certain cards certain play Styles certain matchups that are just so unique from everything else when it comes to Magic the Gathering and games in general and then there's also Decks that you just kind of love to hate crazy big Mana decks weird combos way
too efficient interactive cards like you could really feel all of the extremes of what it's like to be very enfranchised and Enchanted by a game but lately and really since the release of modern Horizon's 3 it's been a lot more lukewarm unfortunately for the last 6 months that modern Horizon 3 has been legal the format has been dominated by unbalanced cards from that set we had a very unpleasant Nadu summer the card and the deck built around it dominated the pro tour was the most competitive deck in the format for a long period of time
and wizards took way too long to ban the damn thing those months leading up to the NAU band were a very difficult time to be a modern player modern Horizon 3 was I think the most anticipated hyped up set of all time I think you could make a very good argument that it that was the case we had a lot of players who did play Modern already every day who were super excited that was me we had a lot of players trying the format for the first time we had a lot of players coming back
back for the first time in a long time it was really exciting but when it was clear that Nadu was uh just dominating the format much better than everything else completely unbalanced there was like a big sense of like anxiousness from these players who want to wanted to play with the new cards and wanted to play the format but the format was just kind of unplayable and we had to wait months for the scheduled BNR announcement to get to play with the D cards and when that announcement came out I made a longer video talking
about how the schedule be are really bad for the health of the format I'm going to link that video down below I think there's a lot relevant there that I'm not going to get to today that is still relevant today but I did want to play a clip from that video which I I feel is super important for today's discussion and that pressure comes from the fact that if Wizards doesn't perfectly fix a format with a scheduled BNR announcement the next chance they have to fix it is months and months away I think the next
scheduled BNR they've said is now in December and that means that if the one ring or Ruby storm or ugan Labyrinth X or whatever ends up being super duper prominent dominant and modern and things are unfun then we have months before Wizards is going to do anything about it and here we are three months later the format has been pretty bad this entire time it's kind of just devolved into a Bor Synergy versus combo meta game it's been like this for a while and we have had to wait months for anything to happen so it's
time to get into the weeds a little bit talk about what is the modern meta game like what are the problems and what are the solutions and of course I really really want modern to get back on track I want it to be fun and exciting again it is still my favorite format to play I love to dive in deep I love to get really weird with it there's just nothing like it it's such a unique and special format to me and I have high hopes that we can fix the damn thing but before I
get into the specifics of what I'd like to see ban what I might like to see unbanned I want yall to hear this I think the most important thing that Wizards of the Coast can do during the December 16th scheduled BNR announcement is to get rid of scheduled BNR announcements to just simply fix formats where they need to be fixed and leave them alone when they can be left alone I understand that there are positives to the scheduled announcements but in my opinion modern is just too volatile a format to have these scheduled announcements and
keep an active and excited player base because things were relatively stable in the modern format from like strict Saven to Outlaws of Thunder Junction with a few ctions like of the bean stock and uh grief Fury scam uh I think people kind of have forgotten that a big part of this format's history is just a new broken card being released like literally every set I think from like War of the spark to C time there was either a card that got another card banned a card that got a rule changed or a card that outright
got banned itself and bands are bad it stinks when stuff gets broken in modern but modern is also an incredibly deep deep and complex and weird format and unfortunately stuff is just going to break sometimes which again is why I think you just need to have a more proactive approach to the band list but I'll try not to harp on that point too much as we dive into the specifics so let's talk about the elephant in the room the one ring is problematic in modern it's a very powerful colorless card draw spell uh it can
go in every deck and boy does it go in a lot of decks now if you remember around the time natu was legal there was a lot of conversation about banning the one ring and I said you know it's possible that you could need to ban the one ring but the problem I had with it was that the one ring decks were very good against boros Synergy it was a pretty common thing where you could just play your rings for a couple turns go over the top of the boros energy decks now since that was
the metagame dynamic boros energy has just started playing the ring themselves they do this so that they can beat those control Decks that were playing the ring against them and so that they can just beat the mirror and they're going to side them out against a lot of the combo decks but the card quality of boros is so high that they can just afford to play the card and I think for me as soon as this became the metag metagame dynamic you remember at the pro tour when naughty was legal boros did not play the
ring ring decks very good against boros they've since adopted it for me this was the threshold where I felt that the ring needed to be banned and I think we have a clear picture also that that the one ring is just a more powerful card in the modern format than it was before modern Horizons 3 came out I don't really see a lot of people talk about this but I think ugan Labyrinth flag both make the One Ring much stronger than it used to be and the fact that orcish bow Master is just not nearly
as common as it used to be have just made ring stocks go way way up ugan Labyrinth especially in combination with talsman let lets you just cast the one ring on turn two pretty dang often INF flag is just such a perfect powerful resilient uh life gain win condition that you can play in your ring control decks and you can play in your ring midrange decks energy and orish bow Master used to be a a four of in two tier one decks yog mooth and Rus scam two Decks that have since kind of evaporated from
the metag game these things combined the one ring is just a really different animal than it used to be I think to a lesser extent too when they banned violent Outburst kind of the Premier force of negation decks rhinos and living in started to evaporate a little bit from the metag game and so less force of negations means your non-creature for Mana spells get better also so we've talked about the elephant in the room it's time to talk about the elk in the room I do think a lot of modern players aren't really ready to
have this conversation but Gigan of the Wellspring is a very broken card um it is the third most commonly played card in the modern format and it also got a really weird and kind of quiet buff in Arena of Glory your eight Mana 55 has now been ered to be an eight Mana 55 with haste and that is a really really big deal on the card now of course jantha is not broken in the way that luris was broken or yoron was broken uh because those are really powerful card Advantage spells that you get for
free if you jump through your deck building requirement jagan is broken because there is no deck building requirement a lot of the time I do a lot of brewing in the modern format and every single time I make a new deck I just do a gigantic check did the deck I build have any double Mana symbols and it's about 20 30% of the time they just don't and I get a free five5 um I I think that this pill is pretty easy to swallow that companions are pretty broken giving players an extra card is very
silly it breaks the game in a big way luris and yoron were really really awful now and a lot of times when I have this conversation people say oh okay let's just ban all companions I think that this is kind of missing the point at the very least the ones that are still legal besides giganta luch umori guda Zera they're not they're just kind of unplayable and they do have pretty strict deck building restrictions and I wouldn't ban them I would ban gantha gantha is broken because it does not really have a deck building restriction
decks like Bor Synergy domain Etc just get to play the card for free it should go it is it is very very bad to uh win the game with a Gigan or lose the game to Giga which I have done probably over a hundred times at this point since the card has been legal I it is it is time for the card to go in my opinion I I usually get a lot of push back when I say this but uh I feel very confidently that it is time for the Elk to retire so with
these things in mind I think that Wizards of the Coast this is Wizards of the Coast here have two paths that they could take path one you could ban janta wait path one ban one ring and Giga obviously Banning Jaga is not as important as Banning the one ring but I think both should go in my mind these are the two cards that would really improve gameplay and overall quality if they if they left the format now Wizards could do this and they could also say we are also getting rid of all scheduled Bandon restricted
announcements going forward we think that this has been not a good way to manage the format and going forward we are going to be keeping a close eye on Bora Synergy we're going to be monitoring the deck closely and there's a chance that we will ban something uh from the that deck in the coming weeks I also think it would be a really good idea to unban some cool classic iconic cards too now you don't have to unban these three cards specifically or even three cards in general but I would like to see Splinter twin
umasa J and birthing pod unbanned I think that all all three of these cards are very exciting I think that there these all of these cards speak to different style of players creature combo players players who really like uh creature combat and like combo control players I also think all three of these cards would be Fringe playable at best which I know might be a dynamic and polarizing thing to say I feel very confidently in this Splinter twin is a card that not only is there so much insane premium interaction for it that was not
legal when this when Splinter twin was around in the format fatal push Solitude besade you force of vigor force of negation the list really goes on and on and on not only is that the case the forat has just gotten a lot faster and more efficient in general and I think Splinter twin would be just a relatively clunky combo in the modern format in 2024 UMO jite does one thing really well in a format that does not care about that thing um J is a card that uh makes creature combat really one sign but I
also think that the format has gotten much more powerful much more efficient and um's J would not see any play in boros Synergy this is something this is an argument that I get a lot wouldn't umal J make energy better I think no I think it would be suboptimal to play any number of umoa is jite over any number of goblin bombardment in boros Synergy I think that jite would be a one of in stone Forge Mystic bruise and I think making Stone Forge Mystic bruise better is fun and exciting exting I think that those
are Decks that people really gravitate to and they like I think it's good for those decks to kind of feel kind of classic and iconic you get to get jite get to get cauld I think I think it's just kind of cool I'll also say that these kinds of cards like jite when they've kind of had poor play patterns in the fast I think twin is another example of this uh poor play patterns in the past people are worried about unbeing them for fun reasons I think you could have made the same argument though for
blood braid out for Jace the Mind Sculptor for stone Forge Mystic itself for Ancestral Visions for bitter blossom but in my opinion when cards get kind of power leveled out of the format like twin jit and pod then they become fun like cards that are not powerful enough to dominate a format do not create uh unpleasant play patterns in my opinion and um I think birthing pod would be a suboptimal way to build the yog moth deck which would be the best deck for birthing pod in general I think birthing pod is worse than birthing
ritual I think that it is a very life intensive card gets hit by artifact hate I I I I actually play tested both twin and pod against Caleb D like two or three years ago at this point and the card performed quite poorly I think I think pod is another one of these cool classic iconic cards that would be safe to unban but also I think when you unban cards you should do so with a purpose and for me the purpose of unbanning these cards would to be get people excited about the format these are
cards that people love people would be excited to try them out and play I think it would be a good way to get some some life and excitement back into modern okay so that's path one Wizards could take ban the One Ring ban gantha get rid of the scheduled bnrs unban some cool iconic cards I feel like this would be what I would like to see happen and this was what I would do if I was in charge now I do think that there is another path if there if the CEO of Wizards of the
Coast or some executive or even the play design team themselves have just decided to keep these schedule bnrs if they are just here to stay and they're not willing to change them you do have to take different action here you need to ban the One Ring you need to ban jantha I think that I think this is something you should do no matter what but you also need to ban something from boros Synergy it is just too risky to have a three-month Nadu period format is unplayable three month of boros vers verse combo format is
very bad into is is the format still just going to be boros versus combo decks it definitely could be which is why getting rid of the scheduled BNR lets you keep an eye on it but three more months I don't know I don't I don't know if I can do it so if you were going to ban something from boros I think you could kind of just pick any two cards from a Johnny static prison fled amp Raptor and guide of souls uh I wouldn't pick ocot Pride I think these five cards are about the
same in power level I think you can make a really good argument for uh any two of them most people want to ban guide of souls I kind of think amp Raptor would be the first one I'd ban and then maybe guide behind it maybe uh my friend young dingo who plays a lot of deck thinks of Johnny would be the one to go I think there's a lot of great Arguments for static prison it's just like the most efficient removal spell ever just one Mana Exile anything I think fle being so resilient especially compared
with Arena of Glory has a pretty good argument too but I would ban two of them I would just be very very safe very much Nerf the deck so and I would also say that unbanning cards proactively like this is also a lot more difficult if you have these scheduled bnrs I don't think it would be a mistake to unban any of these but you just have to play it very very safe with your unbans if you have scheduled announcements so I probably wouldn't unban anything if I was uh if I was going to take
this route here so these are the two things the two routes that I think would make a lot of sense for wizards to do now Wizards of the Coast does not always do things that make sense as Andrea maguchi once wisely said Wizards of the Coast mostly does things at random in fact I kind of feel very likely that Wizards will not take one of these two paths I think that there's a good chance that something else happens it's possible that there's some big executive pressure for them to not ban the One Ring because it's
such a iconic card it's uh it's possible that they won't want to ban two things from Modern Horizons 3 because this is such an anticipated set I don't think that those arguments make any sense and I think that they're like weird corporate arguments that I I don't like to make them for wizards if there if Wizards is going to do weird corporate things I'm not going to try to do mental gymnastics to justify it I'm just going to talk about what I think would make sense to happen this is what I think would make sense
to happen this is what I hope happens if Wizards messes it up I will probably continue playing standard for a while um let me know what you think obviously very divisive very polarizing people have a lot of opinions on this I feel like I did the best presenting my arguments as best as I can um we'll see what happens next Monday thank you for watching goodbye