the very first verse in the Quran describes Allah as being the most merciful being in existence and today's topic is how in chapter 22:1 15 of the Quran the most merciful god gets angry and tells disbelievers to commit suicide this video is going to be looking into this verse is it a 100% literal or is it more a figure of speech we'll be looking into the context from a kranis perspective and we'll be looking into how this kind of contradicts some other verses obviously the one I've just shown you so firstly what does the verse
actually say whoever should think that Allah will not support him in this world and the Hereafter let him extend a robe to the ceiling then cut off his breath as I'm sure you've noticed the translation I'm using have added in the name Prophet Muhammad to describe who the verse is talking about the reason the translators assume this is because the Quran was revealed through Muhammad and as a result that is most likely who the hym in this case would be if you're a Muslim watching this and you have your own theory on who the hym
could be unfortunately I won't be discussing it in this video because I'm going to center it around Prophet Muhammad but let me know in the comments and I'll hopefully have a conversation with you but yeah assuming this does mean Prophet Muhammad then what this verse is saying with a literal meaning is that anybody who doesn't believe Muhammad himself had Allah on his side in other words Muhammad was an actual true Prophet who knew the true God of the universe if you don't believe that you should go kill yourself fairly harsh language no doubt so obviously
there is two you know directions we could go here firstly it would be a literal meaning and secondly it would be a figure of speech will tackle the problem if it's a literal meaning real quick firstly not only if Allah is telling people to go kill themselves for being disbelievers well it certainly seems to contradict any verse describing him as merciful as we know suicide is a big important discussion in the world especially on topics about mental health to have the god of your book telling people to go do this I think a lot of
people would say that is not merciful by any means and when you compare this to the fact that the Quran has verses telling Muslims themselves not to commit suicide such as chapter 4: 29 where Allah tells those who believe do not kill yourselves and one another when you understand that he's in one case telling Muslims to stay alive and in another case telling non-muslims to go kill themselves it just makes Allah look evil to be completely honest with you so I want to remind you guys that this is a video on quranist Islam these are
hadif rejectors so hadif rejectors aren't able to go into the Sunni hadiths for example in pull out uh hadiths where Muhammad says don't kill yourself obviously a sun could use that to say that this Quran verse isn't fully literal because we also have evidences that contradict what Allah is saying here so it would push the narrative that it's a figure of speech obviously a quranist could claim the same thing they just don't really have evidence to back it up so yeah if this is literal it certainly makes Allah seem very evil and certainly not a
merciful god okay now I want to go with the Viewpoint that I'm going to assume is the majority I'm going to assume most people believe that this is just a figure of speech Allah doesn't really want all disbelievers to go and hang themselves although it's good that the command isn't literal no doubt about that it makes Allah look very bad almost as if he has human emotions and in a complete fit of rage has lashed out against non-muslims in a very derogatory way I would again use this comparatively with the Quran verses about Allah being
merciful and say that seems a little contradictory it doesn't seem as if the guy is very merciful here like could you imagine you have mental health problems maybe and you're reading a book in the God is like telling vast majority of the world to go and kill themselves I mean it's completely outrageous to be completely honest I don't know how to word it very well just something I would never expect in a religious text regard to ever behave in such a way and use his language so carelessly remember the Quran is supposed to be perfected
it's a detailed book every word that's in there is intentionally put there by Allah and we're seeing things like this I mean very very bad really and there's one last counterargument that you may expect to see and the reason I've put it last is because I'm going to go over the context of this verse from a kuranes perspective and the excuse would be that this verse only applied to a specific group of disbelievers in the time of Muhammad so I've scrolled all the way back about 10 verses and we're going to read the full context
leading up to that verse and then I'm going to respond to the counterargument I previously mentioned Allah discusses people who are in doubt about Islam specifically the resurrection and Allah reminds them that he is the one who created Humanity so of course he can pull off the resurrection at the end of times where he brings everybody back to life to judge if they go to heaven or hell or not Allah credits himself of bringing reality to existence and giving life to the dead Etc he reminds people that the hour is coming that's the last hour
as previously talking about the day of Resurrection the end of time he mentions people who are in dispute about Allah who are basically arguing about Islam and Allah even though they apparently don't have any knowledge any guidance or an enlightening book this could be the Quran or any other previously revealed scripture Allah describes how these people as a result end up misleading people from the way of Allah and for him the world is disgrace and on the day of Resurrection such a person would go into the burning fire and that is because Allah is never
unjust to his servants he's always completely just apparently Allah describes certain people who are kind of on the edge when good things happen in their life they are reassured by it they believe Islam even more but when they're struck by trial when things go wrong all of a they start losing faith in God or Allah specifically such a person has lost this world and the Hereafter he invokes instead of Allah that which neither harms nor benefits him he invokes one whose harm is closer than his benefit how wretched the protector and how wretched the associate
indeed Allah will admit those who believe and do righteous Deeds to Gardens beneath which rivers flow in other words good people good true Muslims who believe and do righteous deeds will go to heaven and then finally we get the verse about whoever should think that Allah will not support him Prophet Muhammad tie a robe to the ceiling and kill himself so that is the context building up to this verse this certainly isn't Allah discussing very extremely evil people like murderers and rapists Etc is basically disbelievers who are doubting Islam expressing their doubt leaving for various
reasons building up to this verse about tying a robe to the ceiling and it's especially important from a quranist perspective because such a person would deny the Hadi and would have pretty much no idea what the context of anything in the Quran is anyways so so naturally you can't really use arguments about oh it was this specific group of people in the time when you don't even know who that specific group of people is according to your own quranist hadif rejecting perspective so yes this verse is not describing an extremely specific type of people sure
there is criteria listed such as people who are doubting certain events people who are arguing over Islam Etc but I mean I would say all those criteria apply to me myself and I'm reading verses of Allah telling me to go commit suicide so yeah I completely reject this third counter argument so that is all from me goodbye