i'm christine grady i'm from the department of bioethics here at the nih clinical center and we're going to spend the next hour talking about ethical principles in clinical research to start of course these are mostly my views and don't necessarily represent those of the government and i have no conflicts of interest that i need to describe all right how many of you have studied ethics you those of you in the room so a bunch of you have so this may be very familiar territory um hopefully you can have some good questions or additions to the
commentary so i wanted to start with just a couple of examples uh fairly randomly selected from the new england journal of medicine this is a study uh double double blind placebo-controlled randomized study of people with traumatic brain injury seen in the emergency room given progesterone to see if it made a difference in their symptoms and recovery and this was a study that was done without informed consent it was done in an emergency room here's another example of a study of looking at children with vesiculo i can't say the word reflux and again it was a
double blind randomized controlled study to see if antimicrobials made a difference in terms of reflux there's another study where the participants were pregnant women and they were randomized to two different time points in terms of thyroid screening and if they screened positive on the on the tests that were done they were given levothy thyroxin the outcome the primary outcome of the study was cognitive ability or iq actually in their children at the age of three so all recently done studies excuse me all published in the was in the new england journal of medicine so i
think the interesting question to ask ourselves is are these studies ethical and if the if you think so or if you think if you're not sure question is how do you make that decision so just for the people in the room what do you think makes studies of the nature that i just showed you ethical or not ethical any ideas informed consent okay so we had tbi patients who couldn't give informed consent children who legally can't give informed consent um so does that mean two of the three were not ethical not necessarily right okay risk
versus benefit and we didn't go into the details of those but we'll we'll talk about that a little bit anything else no actual harm okay so that kind of falls into the rubric of risk versus benefit okay i think it's really uh interesting to think about what does make research ethical and so that's what we're going to talk about i want to point out a couple of things before we go there though um what i often think of as the inherent moral tension or the ethical tension in research is pretty much captured by this slide
and that is that the goal of research the goal of clinical research is to generate knowledge useful knowledge about human health or illness ways to prevent diagnose or treat diseases and the goal is not to benefit the individuals who participate in the trial although sometimes they do benefit so that sets up this interesting problem ethically and that is that the people who are asked to participate are are actually the means to developing a useful information and therefore they are at risk of exploitation and that's really what a lot of the ethics of clinical research is
sort of aimed at attending to we know that sometimes people think of clinical research like this you know that people who participate in research are human guinea pigs that they are susceptible to exploitation and sometimes are exploited the lay perception of research often is this understanding um but i think it's interesting to think about how we reconcile this so what i like to say is that the ethics of clinical research really requires recognizing that there are two parts to this puzzle that generating useful knowledge is an ethical responsibility and that knowledge can promote benefits to
society and to future patients and that that effort of generating useful knowledge for for future patients and for society has to be constrained by or balanced by if you prefer the analogy um protecting and respecting the rights and welfare of the people who are participating the participants and so there's this constant tension between these two and that's how we think about the ethics of clinical research you