what did you mind so I was thinking the last old river in turning telling your world upside down we're gonna die as a patoot you know thoughts himself to turn O'Brien upside down v aggregates and and you were saying in order to do that you cannot deny just turning turning the self and the aggregates round it's not about denying mmm it's not about just I'm not acting out a bit not denying but allowing it to endure and recognizing it and and you say I think you sort of suggested that kind of if that's the most
difficult thing for a patina to do but there are you know certain characteristics of that sense of self are the most difficulties to see to see a sense of self yet to seem to pick up on okay that's what yourself see there's a phenomenon of think didn't use my sense of self is such a sensual even if you can't define it that is its its characteristic yeah you cannot be defined but it's really such as an undefinable ambiguous thing because if there is absolutely no sense of whatsoever you talk about yeah so yes yeah so
you can I just say if petitioner learns how to see the sense of self he can then eventually see the right order of the aggregates through that sense of self not in response to not as a as a as a means of dealing with the self but literally just through the sense of self you see the basis upon which that sense of self defense and that basis is not in your control so seeing the basis is impermanent seeing the basis suffering means the experiences that not my self and alternatively I suppose learning how to see
two simultaneous things means you can know the other so learning what the knowledge is yeah it's also a way in the same direction yeah because when we talk about two simultaneous things I bet many people would think like also I have to think of two things at the same time you know let balance the extent of them know as literally now what we are speaking the body is enduring oh but I didn't think about it exactly but you know it so rediscovering Reedus earning that which already know that it's they're enduring simultaneously with other things
you're attending to that's that's how you create the basis for discerning that sense of self the characteristics of the sense of self are something you can attend to on the basis of an enduring sense of self yeah but if you have absolutely no no grasp of such a phonological principle there's nothing good to see cuz all you see is what you can put in front of here yeah and that's where people struggle like understanding the sense of self because for them understanding means being able to put my finger on it yeah that's all I understanding
yeah that's you attending to it that's you informing yourself collecting data yeah but none of that is on the level of understanding which is always better for all to it so understanding is being something that you're not you cut you're not pretending that you're not yeah it's a definition of an insight as well well like say wouldn't like fully understanding something when you well you know they committed any problem you try to understand problem yeah you're attending to the to the components yeah things that constitute your problem you collect the information about it yeah but
that's not understanding and you know that that's not understanding and you can have a lot of information and you can even make sense out of it to some extent but still you know it's not understood cuz the problem is still there now I imagine while you're making that effort to figure out all this information about the problem and then you get it you wouldn't get it if you haven't been attending to these things there's a problem as something that needs to be understood but you certainly did not get it simply by attending to these things
mechanically you got it cuz you understood it so that's I mean it's all wrong so you can't do you can't do understanding directly but if you attend to the right things rightly and know what you're supposed to understand that's how you you're closer to getting understand but you you know you understand that when you don't need to do anything about of course once it's understood it's understood you can question that understanding you can try and sort of put it to test so to speak like revisit it maybe see if it really holds the water in
every regard but yeah to some degree you understood that so am i free of suffering when I kind of my understanding well I'm not sure well maybe I haven't understood enough having calculated what I did understand having because that's the measure it's not like that you think you understood it's when you can't suffer anymore you want to contribute understanding it because of your understanding your freedom so for as long as that's not developed you have to keep pushing that same understanding same as we started a sense of self you're not understanding the ambiguity of the
center self and you will not understand them we go to the sensor for as long as you think that understanding is on the level of clarifying information about the ambiguity it's not only to some extent you need to know what you're supposed to understand but for most people understanding as I said it's more like when you can define things have it on your own terms put your finger on it then it's regarded as if it's understood because look it's so clear I've broken down I systematized systematize all this information about sense itself in all these
charts and stuff assets so now I just need to get it and I got it all laid out I memorized it and it's understood no and the more you think that that's understanding the less likely you'll be able to actually understand them because you're going in the opposite direction of understanding you collect the information about it but do you think it's worth like considering what the various kind of characteristics in the sense of cellphone in itself it's meaningless doing that if you know why you're doing it mmm cuz you want to get understanding then yes
oh yeah so tell me in the view behind the motivation behind determines it whether it's helpful or not not oh just do this blindly and it will be helpful for you yeah the only thing you can do blindly they will be helpful for you is keep the pset yeah just do that but everything else it depends while you're doing it and to what extent so sometimes people will be ok so I'll just attend to the characteristic of this and stuff because they're trying to get rid of the discomfort yeah you know you're understanding you're just
using it to acting out of same type of craving so you won't understand the nature of it what is the nature is whether said the nature the self is that it's not yours it's not yourself so that's what needs to be the stood on the basis of that sense of self you have to stop denying the sense of self because how can you understand it if you're trying to give a little bit if you're begin ordering it if you're indulging arey if you are basically engaging with it so first you have to develop distraint recognize
that there is a sense of self that is a problem because of which you suffer so now within that sense of self you want to see how that is not yours mmm that's the understanding you pursue so yes if you're doing it for those reasons then you would be investigating characteristics the signs and tokens is the word I would say because they're coming now against with like against the background of the right context is mmm investigation like is that no never like is that the means which you can develop an understanding but you also have
to understand that's not completely understanding yeah that's the closer to something that you can do in order to develop understanding but if you if you want to do rightly your investigation must not lose the sight of itself and by that I mean you should already but I wanted to investigate you should begin investigating why do you want to investigate not like all the investigation I found these random things that the suitors talk what's all investigated I'll ponder about it in these like psychological terms now I found these things I want to investigate okay stop why
why do I want to investigate what is the problem there must be a problem in my experience as a whole that I'm trying to overcome by practicing the Dhamma by investigating by doing what this were to say what is that problem so investigation basically because starts and it never really leaves the basis of clarifying what the actual problem is being very understanding what the problem is will then get you to understand what the solution is yeah dukkha but again okay so what buddies do content do I know I understood it for you just any kind
of genetic notion that I sort of have concept of art okay okay what is dukkha for me so understand that and there you go through your investigation look like investing in your own motives you got to investigate now the nature of the suffering and that's certainly much closer to enabling you to understand the nature of suffering which is the first noble truth this is suffering okay so you realize then that people are not free from suffering now because they haven't done things rightly know they simply don't understand even what suffering is amidst of them suffering
they still don't understand what suffering is but often people would assume we kind of already simply by suffering you know what suffering is and now is just a question of performing a set of prescribed rules and observances and techniques and methods emotions and you will then travel out of the of the world of suffering know that that travel begins by first actually understanding that you don't know what suffering is because the moment you understand what suffering is you understand what they were they escape from it is you understand what the cause of it is you
won't be acting out of it well you understand Four Noble Truths the only reason you're acting out of it because you're affected by and you're affected by it because you don't understand so that's another thing like you could you arrived at oh so I want to present my because suffering is the problem okay so what would be the characteristics of that suffering so you can take that in various directions but for example now as how we start to this you can answer can you suffer without a sense of self without any self awareness can you
experience dukkha if self awareness is not there if there is no self awareness awareness of this body and experience yeah awareness of yourself recall any suffering that you had mm-hmm did for you would be the closest representative of what you think Duke is is there a perception of yourself there can you be unaware of yourself while you're suffering you would be aware of yourself if there was suffering yes so can you have something without self-awareness can you have feeling without self-awareness so it's always a sense of self so you feeling can be experienced but you
cannot have feel like would you think like assuming feeling like feeling is that toned the mood of your experiences I mean of the experience is still there but you do not assume that experience of feel well then the feeling is not there if you're not assuming it you can't have two perspectives at once you're speaking on is if you're both go to jail and had another hunt and that doesn't work you're either one end or the other so you can't save your feeling but you're not assuming the feeling for you the only feeling you know
is the feeling that's being assumed don't the aggregates continue to persist well how would you know that how can you see that for itself the only way to see how can I gets possessed is to become an adult which means your current aggregates will not possess because your cotton aggregates at top to bottom affected by your piranha that's what it would say matter would cease feeling everything all the greed would cease when you become enlightened because when he speaks to petitioner from this point of view yes everything that he is assumed will cease to be
so but sure if you be step back from both and assume the situation theoretically yes aggregates persist but how to what extent you can either continue thinking it theoretically or recognize that that situation does not apply to you thus it's not accurate so for you feeling perception and you agree that you know is already assumed that's the whole problem but to say that there is no more accurate there is no more aggregate put that I mean we cannot be denied okay Mike well there's no more for the brothers still no sense sure it's a it's
a denial but you denial is determined by your motivation not by actually saying there are no aggregates death is not to deny up for another hunt cessation is not a denial it's why you're doing the cessation so if you're saying there are no more aggregates there are no more regulate could you basically just trying to manage the pressure that current assume aggregates are putting onto you so you're just dismissing the problem yeah then yeah that's a denial but it's not the denial because of the dismissal is now because of your intention behind it I think
it's why I may have read often that there's the our hunt he's awakened and he's developed the full extent of knowledge but any there's remainder there's still remainder left yeah and that remainder left is the aggregates yeah so see you got the idea about it now and you have two options you can either leave that idea as it is and think it that it represents what our hunt is oh you can then start questioning that idea and say well if you really understood another hunt you would be at least a sort of honor so are
you sort of honor if the answer is no to that means your idea of what ahadees is not an accurate idea nobody denies that there is an idea there but you mustn't leave it for what it is because okay it makes sense yeah but are you so depend on account of that sense no means it's not an accurate idea that's I mean you have a degree of understanding but it's because you don't push the understanding that's why you don't get freedom from suffering as a result of the understanding it's not because you haven't you know
found all the right understandings and so on or you haven't been doing it long enough so you got the idea about another hand but it cannot accurately represent it because you're still go to dinner you cannot accurately represent this so make more evident understand what kind of what is the residue in the case of an element and then if that understanding frees you from suffering you know you're on the right track I suppose my understanding of the aggregates I mean that would be insufficient would you mean Mike Ike if there's a conscious party the aggregates
must be there like that's let's see that sort of you if there is a conscious body aggregates must be there like experience so how over experience so again saying if there is a conscious body occurrence must be there implies that on account of your conscious body you know the aggregates but conscious body it's already where the aggregates are there being a while so having a conscious body means within that notion of conscious body that you can relate to that's where you decide the grades you don't infer the aggregates on account of having a conscious body
thus the aggregates must be there now having a conscious body means the aggregates are there as that conscious body so within the basis within the context of conscious body you can then discern more of an aspect of material or emotional over ever within the basis of conscious body not kind of in response to but if they're but again why would you want to descend if I like it yes because we're mentioning before I mean my understanding isn't complete but there was the idea that an hour hunt has no more aggregates hmm fully enlightened being doesn't
experience aggregates anymore so but for me currently I can't understand how one can be alive or have a living body and not experience it and that's why you're still not another finding out how is that possible we'll make it least sort of fun but see thinking that there is a thread that unites you with a state of another hand that you can think accurately is why you're not understanding what another one is because that thread stands in place of what you think understanding of another hand state is and that's often people struggle with thinking that
oh I know I'm not so the pan-arab dujana but my practice is helping me which means I am somehow in some manner to some extent on some level getting closer to our country you don't have a clue only sotapanna can know okay no now I know exactly by the way is and I can either pursue it or not but he knows so unless there is a right view you should not trust any understanding that you have doesn't mean you should mystify to pretend no it's just you know it's not about understand it is about understanding
but it's about sufficient understanding sufficient being at least the understanding of the right of you but see for as long as you think now did your idea of other hand segregates is accurate you're not gonna make effort to understand how can I got under not heavy could you think you figure it out and now you're just about you know felling watering doing this doing that and somehow you get closer to that that that state so yes from petitioners point of view other hand has no aggregates there's no being bhava he sees he does not exist
it was the cessation of assuming sure yes theoretically it is a cessation of assuming but for you as we discussed video that everything is true that assuming so you can't think accurately how would things be without assuming because you're thinking that with your assuming I thought that there would be aggregates and no assuming that would be empowered there would be a joints again theoretically extrapolated from your experience it doesn't apply to you so that's not an accurate thought because now any notion of aggregates you have even arahants aggregates free from assuming are your aggregates affected
by assuming so you can't have the accurate thought of arahants aggregates while you still go to dinner it's just impossible because your thoughts are affected by you're assuming thus anything within those thoughts is equally affected by assuming on your own a cessation of feeling which is understood by someone who sees the dummer yeah so the cessation of feeling is the cessation of that's not good sure sure waves decision of wall exactly yeah but just just that I'm just like if you haven't got if you've got this idea of the like yes advocates continue for the
what does that mean sensation feeling Wow well he's alive you know that's just dumb just doesn't flag the hair that's okay something no understood oh yeah but the reason why people ignore the flags is because it's quite frightening yeah to now recognize that even the most accurate ideas that you have about Dhamma and instead of an are handed everything you're still fully enclosed within that sort of sinking ship of your ignorance but if you actually are able to accept that idea that's how you can find a way out if you don't that will be the
reason why you want find a way out doesn't matter how much other effort you put in your practice you see understanding is so enticing because you know basically things make sense yeah and that's exactly how it should be think make sense but then you question that extent of that sense you made yeah hmm so okay so this makes sense but am I free from suffering is the last diminishing in me a version desire for distraction are all these things dissipating as a result of understanding well then you should not trust your understanding so said just
trusting about the fact that things make sense yeah you have to okay that makes sense let me see if I can make more sense out of it and more sense and more sense and more sense and all of it converges on that Vayner even this whole thing before you know trying to understand the aggregates get the idea of what outside gates are then you know try and approximate it whatever why because you don't want to suffer which means you feel right here right now your non freedom in regard to suffering you are still liable to
it so then if you stay within that context your thinking will cease to be theoretical because you still within the okay so this is the measure this is the container within which whatever I'm trying to do or understand on account of the Dhamma should be understood within me being liable to so liability to suffering what are the characteristics how does that feel how would then understanding of the aggregates free me from this suffering but often people start with yes of course I want to be free from suffering then aggregates need to be understood and then
you go there and completely forget and abandon the context of why you're doing it in the first place and that's how you become you start thinking about the amount to early abstract terms and then people kind of understand oh well this is just too abstract this doesn't really pertain to suffering but then they will go too far the other way oh just stop thinking stop reading the suitor stop just sit and meditate and your chitta will open up and whatever else because they kind of understood that this is abstract it doesn't work but they haven't
understood that you can also learn how to think not abstractly you can think on the basis on the within the container of your feeling and that motivation to be free from suffering but that's a skill that needs to be discerned right in the middle there so it's usually either you overthink it and becomes just abstract and you divorce yourself which is the definition of abstraction you divorce yourself from that basis of feeling oh then you just completely dismiss domain of thinking which is ironically another thought on account of which you just start to mystify the
present here now judgment-free mind embodiment and whatnot and then refused to think refused to make the effort to understand either way you failed to understand what needs to be understood because you overshot the mark then you under showed it that may bring us back to the sense of self bringing bringing the feeling like you know well I think actually that's probably even more accurate for something what petitioner should do is never lose the context of feeling present enduring feeling within that you wouldn't discern the signs of your mind within that you will discern the signs
of yourself yeah off you sent yourself off your sense of I am of your sense of master controller within the feeling you're subjected to so then if you wanna choose a contemplation so to speak in terms of the suitors what needs to be understood you choose the ones they will least likely result in you distract being distracted from what you're feeling right there right there so don't think about the third jhana and relationship to the base of nothingness cuz you're still a potted unit doesn't even know them doesn't even have a Monday in the right
view and yet here you I want to understand all this it John is make again understand in other words you're just acting out of craving to have things laid out figured out in a sense that you want them to be you know putting your finger on to it it's basically always rooted in craving even on the mental level so why do I won't understand five and a half Janice oh because I want practice but why do I wanna practice Buddhist teaching cuz I'm worried from suffering with suffering and suffering right now no but I am
liable to suffer oh so it's right here right now my ability to suffering it's always present I'm always within it it's always my reality and on account of that I'll forget about it and they're not going to figure these random things Rd then I read a lot of failures it doesn't work it's just thinking so when I can't do want you to be free from suffering I will abandon that awareness of that liability in order to dismiss the thinking and then mystified my present moment either way he basically concealed the problem although you started with
the problem with the recognition of it so that's what me the idea you have of the father five aggregates of another hunt habitant you think about it and also allow your liability to suffering to be there discerned so is your idea freeing you from that liability means it's not if you're doubtful about it it's not freeing you from it it's not clear thus it cannot be magically freeing you from it unless you know it so then take that development idea further until it fully binds in connects goes right through the center of that liability to
suffering so their liability to suffering is that mmm it's wanting a feeling it's tell you what I wanted no no no just well Jesus felt being within fuel you can try and define it all you want they will all be secondary to the fact that it's felt and how is it felt and that's the definition of dukkha which really means this is so crazy Duke Lee's opportunities and that's the thing so you know you don't need to suffer right here right now in terms of something really affecting you a mere recognition that you are liable
to suffer and you cannot even fathom how could you defend yourself from it you have no access to that exposure to suffering you just recognize it that is so that's Duke and then that Duke is the chief of all the Duke all other suffering experience has to come within the basis of that liability to suffering that liability of feeling it's like like how that once with this says like even in pleasant feeling it's named for seeing it as painful yeah exactly a handful yeah yeah you you're liable you're liable to suffer advanced means any any
feeling any change in the feeling can be that suffering which means any feeling is that suffering could you liable to feel it can you be liable to suffering if you don't feel anything impossible so liability to suffering for you means liability to feeling so that's why if you cherish entertain welcome delighting act out of feeling that you want makes you equally than liable to feelings that you don't want because you can't just have half of the feelings and not the other half impossible the only way to free yourself from liability suffering is to free yourself
from liability to feeling and you free yourself from liability feeling by you know being restrained not acting out of the feelings and then understanding the nature and arisen feeling whatever that feeling is and once you see that that involves the fact that old feelings come before any sense of self yeah yeah you don't even have to think about sense of self in this particularly God if you just recognize the liability of feeling enduring oh I feel okay now but I'm not saying it thus I will not have saying when there changes and you will have
to change one way or the other and what if you change for words exactly what if you change for better exactly you've no control either way you were subjected to it so how can you free yourself from something you've no control over firstly by understanding what why is it I provide why there is a problem with it there is a problem with it sometimes people tell well ok it's just so the feeling is just on the other hand can say that but we don't start as our hands we started petunias thus your feeling is just
so means my feeling is just so and it's a problem for being you just so-so you don't know mystified but you certainly don't abstract yourself from it either so not being in control of your feelings why is it a problem I can I'm affected I could be affected at any time and even when I have a pleasant feeling arise it's lonely glass a certain period of time I walk more of it and I can't get more of it well then I suffer on account of that so because of the problem is the problem of not
being control feeling is because you'll be affected why is that a problem while being affected by feeling is a problem being affected is it's painful yes I can't I can't so use that sound okay so that's even more accurate being affected it's painful wise pain it's a problem why is pain it is a problem of why why is the problems sometimes I mean I guess I'm thinking of degrees of pain but that's not the same yeah we don't know the pain no matter what agree why is paying a problem being affected by it and that's
why I can them I'm yeah I'm exposed I'm vulnerable I'm susceptible to it that's all that is a problem because it's painful being exposed vulnerable susceptible what they all have in common is that they are uncomfortable discomfort means pain so we're back on to wise pain the problem and the pain is a problem always and only for one reason it's because you want to get rid of it so the pain is not a problem problem is not in the pain problem is in you always automatically not wanting get so that's what the problem is your
attitude so can you be susceptible to something without that being painful would you would being susceptible to something be a problem if it's not painful no and then would something be painful if you're not trying to get rid of it if you're not craving against it no so then the problem is your craving not the pain not the lack of control not being susceptible not being liable none of these things are a problem the problem is your craving of not wanting it so when non control is a problem it's only so because you still crave
control and that's why they would like the mindfulness recollectionist of death is like a direct the quickest the sharpest way as well towards a Timeship literally have a thought of dying the next moment next in-breath are you affected by if you are it's not because of death or anything that can befall you it's because you resisting to accept it resisting craving against it and that's why again the first noble truth understanding what suffering is this is what's up that's that's this is that understanding you really suffering is not in the pain pain is not suffering
but for petitioner for another light in mind there is no pain without suffering because there is no pain without craving against the pain but the suffering is in the craving why because if suffering were in the pain the removal of pain would mean removal of suffering but it's not but if suffering is in the craving if you remove the craving yeah you have pain in because you don't always suffer when you experience pain by the way if I tell you oh if you endure some matter no physical discomfort for ten minutes and then you'll be
rewarded by sixty billion dollars and in a life of luxury and and you never have to work a day in your life that pain will be joyful for you because you know what's at the end of it all is the Buddha would say if you practice you the pain of restrain you'll be rewarded with the can and the rivers life's of luxury and any enjoy then that pain but if the pain is always suffering you would suffer you would not accept that deal because pain is always suffering but it isn't and every time you go
to work we have to hold you do to you that's so painful that's so uncomfortable but you don't resist it because you have a bigger picture in your mind that this contributes towards that bigger picture which is picture of pleasure even being even wanting the freedom from suffering is the picture of pleasure and that's just a natural principle that's how it works so suffering is not in the pain because if it were so there would be no self awareness of it whenever there is pain there suffering I'm stupid absence of suffering absence of liability to
suffer as well and you would not have a recognition of it but the fact is that suffering is in your craving towards pain see if I tell you if you do this pain for 10 minutes and then you have a exponential reward you won't claim against the pain you will want that pain cuz you want the reward and you won't suffer in regard to the pain although you would suffer if I tell you I just tricked you I'm not giving you the reward and without inflicting any physical pain on you and you would suffer on
account of it more than you suffer on physical pain being inflicted upon you why because you're craving determines the suffering first you were not craving against it you are not claiming against the pain but you were very much Crapo the great reward so craving is present in regards to the reward I tell you there is no reward your cravings there you suffer because of a craving you want to protect your reward because of your craving you want to defend it you will cry on account of it if you lose it because of the craving so
pain is the problem because of your craving with us pain is not a problem your craving is a problem but saying that now for somebody who is not free from craving saying ok so pain is not a problem well that's an idea but if that idea is not freeing you from suffering as in not freeing you from craving means pain is the problem for you because you don't know how not to cream in regard to the pain so that's I mean sometimes people get a hint that Oh suffering is not in the pain but then
overly accept any feeling that comes their way ok so this is just so there is no problem in this just accept it just let it go can you let go of you or your idea of letting go can you really let go of that can see I'm letting go of all of this it still allows me to have at least some sense of control I'm just practicing letting go a sense of control is sense of craving so you letting go of your cravings with your craving and usually those people get very upset if if that
view is challenged they might not get upset on account of things they're letting go but if the view of that letting go is challenged they get upset they defend it because they have using their control and on account of it they suffer so it's not an accurate application of your effort in other words you want to apply your effort whereby what you are letting go is resulting in freedom from suffering in every regard now just in this particular little corner it works but if anything else changes if if somebody challenges it I'll be affected I'll
be emotionally disturbed on account of it so how would you not create for pain that's what my ability to pain is that's well ability the suffering is its inability to not crave just think of a stock answer yeah craving yeah so craving is not a matter of choice but at the same time is something you're responsible for as long as a non are hard I'm responsible for craving yeah and when it arises well on it you've never freed from craving because you always feel something which means you always crave something and you got the feeling
that's why craving is not in regard to only regard to pain it's in regard to the domain of whatever's felt so if you feel Pleasant you will automatically crave towards it if you feel unpleasant you will automatically crave away from it if you feel neither well you will automatically create towards distracting yourself from it so how can you stop that automatic craving because you are responsible for it craving is not part of the aggregate it's not part of the things that arise for you it's your attitude towards it stopping refusing did stopping the denial of
feeling and stopping the giving into it but why would you want to stop the denial of feeling what would be your motivation behind that no longer be effective the craving to denied you want to stop the denial you wanted to stop the noun is rooted in denying the craving because how are you affected by craving as I said claiming doesn't arise in the same sense feelings arise for you so what is there to stop do you ever notice well your your understand your attitude towards it so I was thinking towards what to look towards the
order is what I was thinking God so let's let's stick with the feeling and craving that's what I mean so so you can't attend you to craving claiming is not an object of your mind oh I see my craving but for as long as you think that you can convey me is peripheral in regard to whatever's presently felt yeah for as long as you keep the understanding that you can affect the feeling you can change it you you have a right to know want this feeling to be there right yeah good cuz it's two different
things by the way you can't change your feeling I mean sensuality has effect yeah it will has effect yeah oh my god it's completely has nothing to do with anything it works yeah it's the only way that petitioner knows of working yeah but the thing you refer to is like you have a right to do so that's a different thing and that's already do the level of the view yeah I have a right to interfere with this feeling which means I have a right to claim against the feeling for the feeling and for as long
as you don't abandon the view that you have a right to do so you will be automatically doing it so so only through going against the grain of that view that I have a right you will stop doing it and that's how you stop that automatic response of craving by ceasing to provide maintenance for it and this view that you have a right to do so is how you maintain the attitude of claiming of doing so so abandon the view that you have a right towards pleasurable feeling towards unpleasant feeling towards the into feeling you
don't have a right which ever feeling is there you subjected to it you have no rights over it you within it yo the other self wanna say you what kind of subordinate and that cannot change any change that you can inflict so to speak is within it with its engine which fully contains you that you have to do so stop giving in to the means of changing feeling on account of what's felt that's how you will stop perpetuating craving understand and that's not something off here is a recipe just stick to these rules and these
methods because different literally different whenever you become recollect of the present moment there is a feeling and during their which means they're going to be an attitude towards it and that's the attitude you need to be dealing with not the theory of the attitude that I must do so what are you feeling right here right now neutral what is are you are you aware of it are you losing the sight of that neutral are you being distracted towards other things that's your work then I feel unpleasant is there an implicit attitude that I should not
feel this I have a right to not feel this I'm entitled to not feel this I can't wait for it to go away all these thoughts are exemplification of the attitude that I am first and this just here temporarily amongst even I will endure it for the rest of my life why oh because I don't want it to be here it's that so what you do not count of it it's whether you feel exactly why why are you doing it which will reveal whether you feel entitled and you will for as long as you're not
aware of it so you can act it on a counterfeit but disappearance between acting on account of it with the thought that under the impression that I am in control of it and under the impression that I'm not in control like I did I it's not my right well to me it bends what what acting on economy means and it's skillfully not like it it's not against the precepts not against the training right yeah well that's the thing if it's if it's not against the precept if it's nothing straining you're not really acting out of
it anything a lead means acting for the purpose of either getting more of this feeling or getting rid of this feeling but that only applies on the life of the body and that's not what the feeling is rooted so you have to start by not acting out of it as in not going against the presets but then see it's not against the precepts to go alone and sit be alone in you could sit quietly so it's not on the level of unwholesomeness of breaking the presets but you might be one doing it for very unwholesome
reasons so you can't just say oh it's just a question of not acting out of it not acting out of it first to contain yourself well then it's a question of understanding whatever current feeling whatever Cardon feeling is and whatever your attitude towards it is so you might be on paper wholesome cause you're always secluded in your couch and so on but the true reason for there might because you hate everybody else you can't stand other people everything is a disturbance so you just want to find the environment that's in your control my cooter if
somebody comes and tells you get out of there Cody would you remain indifferent and economist or would you be disturbed so what you need to do is know the motivation in regard to present hindering feeling and not lose the sight of it because that's what acting out truly is you know in ignoring that degree of that motivation behind cuz I said oh I will not act out of my feeling y ou cuz I want to get rid of it so now for me getting rid of the feeling is abstaining from getting rid of the feeling
and you can never okay always look at your motivation that's your methods yeah I suppose you can say that but why do I want to do that exactly so why am i doing that which means always has to be discerned on the on the on the basis of a recollected present experience as a whole because that's where the motivation is that's what the feeling is induced that's where the moods are so now while you're trying to figure out what I'm saying why ask yourself okay so why is this important to be understood and that's how
you'll understand what I'm saying to be free from suffering to be free from yes so why do you want to be free from suffering now is it because they thought it implies you're not free not free so how does that implication manifest in your experience do you not free from suffering how's that because feeling is felt yes so how is that it I'm not free from suffering is that a concern for you he's concerned unpleasant yes is this pleasure the problem is pain a problem so through going through this basically almost like drills of reflection
you keep happening in the context that pain Volunteers of feeling valid induced it's not a problem but there is no problem without the feeling and that's how you get to then discern the attitude peripherally to the problem of the field and they're so good Ahmet Hooper done is not in the final days but there is no Padano without the family it's being there but usually people think about holding an attachment what everyone has translated it just becomes another thing another thing I can attend to focus on say no to choose it no you can do
that with things that aggregates present you but you put on is not in them nobody nothing nothing between nothing responds nothing yet without aggregates there is no putana but if you look at the aggregates you're not gonna see you putana it's completely peripheral from you look off the aggregates same with the feeling there's something that you can't see you're craving you can't say no to your craving because that's not craving you claiming that craving is peripheral to present enduring feeling so discern recollect present enduring feeling as I said oh well suffering is not being control
is a problem I will cause cause I'm liable to it it implies I can suffer Oh how's that although that's felt as a concern what is a concern a concern is unpleasant feeling didn't yours so I'm craving against it I wouldn't have a problem with concern if by some whatever reason it's not felt unpleasantly any problem you have in the world any problem you had you would have you will have it's only problem for one reason it's felt unpleasantly and not not crave against it so concerned is not a problem anxiety is not a problem
none of these things that are problem hey is the problem because you cannot you don't know how not to create for it know is just symptoms those are just further results and then we reverse the pain is on the problem either it's my craving that's the problem that's why I suffer that's what I said presence of clearly means presence of suffering absolutely absence of suffering and that's simultaneous so whenever there is a suffering present in me means craving is present in me to the extent the very suffering whenever there is no suffering present in me
then there is no craving present in me are usually people regarded in the linear sense of craving is a matter of choice you just say no - it's a note it and somehow down the line your feelings will wither away and then and then you'll be free from everything no could you claim for that because you're not aware of your motivation in regard to why you're doing it in the first place like when I asked you the other day in the talk are you liable to suffering yeah why is that a problem how does that
feel right here right now so if you don't feel suffering on account of right here right now liability to suffering would you then suffering kind of anything that can comes in there liability impossible because you approach to the feeling the recognition of my suffering but the only reason this is a problem is because I don't know this caper of suffering which is another way of saying I don't know how to stop claiming that's when the Four Noble Truths is once you understand what the true problem is which is not the pain it's the claiming in
the God are that's where the problem is you don't understand that absence of that means absence of the problem regardless even if the people come and you know start shopping your lives in a and everything else you will not suffer because suffering was never in those things suffering is not in the aggregate in the same sense super than is not in the aggregate it can even ask you sir why is that why is the why is the pain of interrogation unpleasant cuz you came against the pain of it because you crave against the pain of
it so it's suffering because you crave against it well because in itself it's suffering I guess then there's what's the motivation of knowing that it's painful but the pleasure derived I guess no you have to stop like that that's what we lament the what was it can see these the cravings to be banned with means of craving conceived by the means of conceit so you crave now to be free from craving as a result of that craving you will hopefully do the right let's understand the right things make the right effort they will result in
cancelling that very crazy and what is that what I'm describing so because you want to be free from suffering you start to question the nature of the feeling and then you get to realize that suffering is not in the feeling it's in the attitude in regard to that feeling and then you get to realize the data it should is not a matter of your choice but more like a matter of your secondary choices the result in feeding their attitude choices towards pleasure choices to is no pain acting out of it so you stop doing that
and you stop feeling the suffering feed in the craving sorry and that's how you destroy the craving on account of the very creamy filling the craving is reading the sufferer yeah of course that's very synonymous craving enduring presence of craving peripherally as the attitude of your mind is felt as suffering it's the same thing now if I got there screaming and they did it suffering there's one thing edge to the craving that's felt suffering so removing that you're craving cannot anymore result in feeling suffering but the reason see it's so hard well it's so easy
because the attitude is invisible as I said you can't attend to your craving you can't see oh this is my craving you only feel suffering and then when you look all you sees things in front of you I see this I see that thus natural response response with the grain of death deception is I suffer because he said that I suffer because I lost this there is losing of this and suffering simultaneously present but it's a mistake of the like fundamental proportion to assume that because they're simultaneous present that's why this is suffering and that's
the nature of ignorance that's why when a region cannot be in the aggregates cannot be in things you perceive or feel or intend it's in regard but it cannot be found anywhere else except for those things up because how can you mistake your suffering for something you perceived or even for the feeling you felt if feeling and perception were not there is nothing to be mistaken with