[Music] [Music] [Music] I'm going to tell you a story story about a little boy named Brooke Hopkins who grew up to be a college professor then he moved to Utah where he fell in love and so did I his field was um English literature especially the uh Romantic Poets Wordsworth colid ke Keats Shelly and my field was bioethics the study of philosophy and issues about end of life in particular so pulling the plug euthanasia suicide physician assisted dying choices about dying we talked about these things a lot as we traveled we had a nice life
together we treed we relaxed in cafes all over the world and as we did that we talked about romantic poetry about end of life issues and of course about a great many other things right what we didn't know though as we talked although we both knew that we would die someday we didn't know what a contemporary book death Brooke would die it wasn't going to be one of those old-fashioned deaths the kind in which death courts you follows you at every moment when deaths are primarily deaths of infectious and parasitic diseases deaths at any moment
in the lifespan deaths that are unpredictable in uh their General outlines uh and when they occur and deaths in which the physician can't do very much at all to Stave them off except to comfort deaths of plague deaths of infection this is George Washington who in December of 1799 went out inspecting his properties on Horseback caught a cold was rainy cold December and was dead in two days of infection in the Contemporary world we live in in the developed World deaths like this almost never happen where there's access to adequate Medical Care in just a
little over a century we have moved since about the 1850s from deaths that were primarily deaths from infectious and parasitic diseases um which were most of them comparatively rapid unpredictable and could occur at any time in the lifespan to Deaths which are predictable more or less Long sustained right and which the doctor can do a great deal to shape and postpone that's in what epidemiologists call the age of delayed degenerative diseases they occur late in life and have shapes like this the top one is cancer not all cancer deaths look quite like this but this
is the general pattern of deaths with which are typically diagnosed months even years in advance um and in which there is a relatively good quality of life until a comparatively steep tail off or deaths from organ heart and other organ failure in which there's a pattern of exacerbation and remission trending downwards that ends in death also typically over an extended period of time or deaths from the various dementias including Alzheimer's in which there is typically a much lower level of function but that extends over a period of time sometimes as long as a decade these
are the deaths that we die now there are slow deaths right acute deaths from unexpected causes are a minority of deaths in our uh developed world and while there's a little uptick in infectious disease that's modest compared to the frequency of deaths like this this is what awaits us now there are a lot of ways we can um try to understand this but one thing that Brook and I we talked about it so often um recognized was that this new pattern of dying didn't mesh very well with the religious cultural uh and political assumptions that
came from an much earlier period claims like dying is in God's hands or it's your time or quer Sarah or death should be natural we shouldn't do anything to interfere with natural dying or you'll know when your time is up right those phrases don't mesh with the way we actually respond to these new slower deaths what do we do well we issue DNR orders do not resuscitate orders we withhold or withdraw treatment we use heavy doses of opioids and other kinds of pain medication understanding though not intending that this may hasten death this is legally
recognized in this country we withhold artificial nutrition and hydration right when it seems that death is imminent right more recently there's some I think you might call it Vogue for um stopping eating and drinking on the part of the patient we sometimes resort to terminal sedation this goes by a number of names extended paliative sedation um and many other euphemisms but they all describe a practice of sedating into um unconsciousness or close to it or even into comparative coma a patient whose symptoms are otherwise intractable and who is nearing death these are the ways that
we now deal with the extended deaths that we die and in some places in the world world it is even now legally permitted for Physicians to Aid dying patients in dying right in this country physician aided dying called physician assisted suicide by its detractors and physician uh aided Dying by its proponents right is legally possible now in four states in this country Oregon Washington Vermont and Montana uh and in a number of European countries as well the Netherlands Belgium Luxembourg Switzerland and there's controversial picture in Germany you'll see on the right hand slide that um
that depicts the spread of right to die societies around the world and one thing you notice is that these are primarily in the developed countries right this is a problem of our luxurious health care and um General economic situation this is the way we in the privileged parts of the world die then something happened Brooke went for his usual bike ride one crisp lovely November afternoon I often went with him but this day he went uh by himself and as he was coming downhill on his bicycle uphill was coming a bike racer doing sprints and
they collided around a blind curve the other guy wasn't hurt he was just tossed off his bike but Brooke broke his neck and just by chance there was jogging down the hill behind him a fully trained flight nurse specializing in respiratory therapy who saved his life later when we met her in the hospital she said I've always wondered if I did the right thing since after all she knew that he would be paralyzed for life and that he would almost certainly be on a ventilator for life I always wondered if I did the right thing
she said well he thanked her profusely from his hospital bed even though though those things were proving to be true right and indeed although he required support for every bodily function from the neck down right just the same he prized his life he was glad to be alive we had fun sometimes after we came home friends came to play in our backyard they played music we laughed right we were able to go trail riding in the quite beautiful Utah Foothills right and he was even able he was a college professor right able to continue teaching
courses he taught courses at home of works with enormous intellectual impact content The Iliad The Odyssey the anad the divine comedy Shakespeare and of course the Romantic Poets that he'd always loved even more important in a way for both of us is that although we couldn't do any of the other activities we'd always done together we learned to write together my hands you can see are on the keyboard there uh and we talk together as we compos osed an account of what it was like to be in this situation and to always keep in mind
that this is only a tragedy if you make it that way our relationship and the intimacies in it moved from doing things together and of course sex to a much deeper more profound intimacy so close that it is I think impossible to describe he flourished in spite of pain limitation utter dependency he flourished and so did everyone around him who was close to him but then things became more difficult he had repeated infections he had repeated pneumonias he had plural affusions he had many other medical complications and he knew that it was time to die
to die to die he had loved life he was so glad he'd been rescued in spite of the unimaginable limitations under which he lived but he knew that things were downhill he was powerless to stop them so were all the rest of us and so he formed over quite a long period of time the conviction that it was time to die he knew what he want wanted right he wanted to be able to die when he was ready he wanted to be able to die with the help of a physic he wanted to be able
to die without pain without air hunger he wanted to be able to die with his friends and his family around him he wanted to die in peace he knew exactly what he didn't want he didn't want to die in a hospital in that sterile sometimes impersonal and always protocol governed environment he absolutely did not want that he knew what you needed was a physician who would listen to you who would understand you who would serve who would be your ally your helpmate your friend in how to die he knew he was lucky and he knew
he was lucky because by this time he had five medical technologies that contributed to keeping him alive he had a cardiac Pacer he had a diaphragm Pacer he had a feeding tube in the stomach he had supplemental oxygen that was necessary much of the time he had a ventilator and he knew that he could have anyone or all of these discontinued even though he had accepted them initially he knew the very fine line because we had talked about this so often in all those years we' spent traveling trekking sitting in cafes he knew the very
fine line between allowing to die and causing to die that's at the center of the right to die debates he knew that his choice as it became increasingly clearly and firmly his considered Choice he knew it would be difficult for his family his friends for me I was the main foot dragger this was unbelievably difficult to see someone someone you love so much form reflect on consider make and formally request this step but on the other hand when it's someone you love so much you have to respect what they want and we all knew that
his choice would be easier for him than any of the alternative deaths he might die in the situation he was in and he knew and kept reminding us and we had to acknowledge that he had both the legal and moral right to make this Choice even though we lived in a state where a sisted dying in a state in a country in most of which assisted dying was not legal he was asking for a death that one would think of as contemporary a death not like those old medieval deaths where you're annihilated by some disease
without much a warning also not like our current deaths deaths with long downhill slopes in which one is essentially obliged to continue down much of that downhill slope he wanted to be able to die given the extraordinarily difficult nature of his situation to die on his own terms which he did this is the expression on his face snapped at the very moment the hospice physician said I will help you discontinue the ventilator and so he did and I lay in bed beside him and I listened as they began to dial down the ventilator administering drugs
to control air hunger pain anxiety as they dialed it down from 18 breaths a minute to 16 and then 16 breaths a minute to 14 and then 14 breaths a minute to 12 and then to 10 and I could hear the heart become irregular or slower and I could hear the spacing between breaths slow and slow until there were long intervals in between and I knew that one of them would be the last and so ended A Love Affair that began almost 40 years ago thank you [Applause] [Music]