[Music] thank you for joining us for this second episode of our series on the sacraments on the sspx podcast today we'll have father paul robinson back to look at some of the common errors some of the heresies that have arisen over the centuries about the sacraments we'll also take a look at the way two distinct groups understand the sacraments namely protestants and modernists as you'll start to see in this episode and as it will become clearer throughout the series both groups have an outsized role in how the understanding of the sacraments shifted in the church
in the last 50 years as we move forward in this series we're looking for help if you like these series and want to have more of them you can help us by leaving a review or a rating wherever you're listening on this podcast and please share it with someone who you think would like it or appreciate it or maybe they just need it that's the best way to help because you're helping us with this apostolate to reach as many people as possible with the beauty and the truth of what it means to be a traditional
catholic now let's join father robinson for episode two of the sacrament series right now welcome to the sspx podcast our second episode on the sacraments welcoming father robinson from saint is the doors in denver hi father how are you hello andrew doing fine good good well last episode we talked about what a sacrament is we talked about what is necessary for the validity of a sacrament and as we will be doing throughout this whole series we'll be looking at one episode on the sacrament itself on baptism for instance and then looking at the new right
um we're going to do the same sort of thing on this introductory section and that is looking at errors on the sacraments in general so where do we start by looking at errors in the sacraments father yeah well andrew when i was when i was preparing the notes i was thinking what is the most straightforward way to explain the heresies that have existed throughout the entire history of the church on the sacraments and i thought the the best way is for us to just go back to that definition of the sacrament that that we've all
memorized um and and look at it from that perspective that we know that the catechism definition includes three elements for a sacrament it's an outward sign instituted by christ to give grace and when when we look at those three elements of the sacraments we're going to say a heretic is going to deny one or more of those elements and generally speaking in the history of the church the heretics have not denied the first aspect of the sacraments that a sacrament is an outward sign they don't have a problem with that generally speaking what they have
had a problem with historically is the question of the sacraments being instituted by christ and the belief that the sacraments give grace so i would like to look at those two uh the denial of those two things and how there's generally two sets of people uh denying them uh mainly the protestants and the modernists but we'll also see some other flavors of heretics as well and that's okay all right sounds good so looking at the institution of christ um by of the sacraments and being instituted by christ how do the protestants see that father so
the protestants generally speaking have uh the idea that man is so depraved by original sin that it's impossible for god to sanctify him and so when they speak of something like grace they hold that that grace is not something that changes man on on the inside to make him pleasing to god that god basically cannot do it that that our sins are so heinous that our our nature is so wrecked by sin that god cannot elevate us to the supernatural level and make us pleasing to him so what what god does is that he sort
of covers our our sins he just like did you got this stinking pile of sinfulness and he takes a blanket and he puts it over it and he hides our sinfulness and that's how we become pleasing to him or he just basically hands us a card and it says get into heaven card and you just hold on to that and you present it to saint peter when after you die and he let you into probably even though you are still your sinful self you haven't been right sanctified so because of of this they don't believe
that we can be sanctified by by god they also don't believe that our lord instituted seven signs to sanctify us i mean why why would our lord institute things to sanctify us when it can't happen right so in their in their mind the only thing that sanctifies us quote unquote i mean it's really an external sanctification the only thing is faith it's faith alone it's not the sacraments it's not through the ministration the priesthood it's just faith you just make this act of faith you say i boo i accept although jesus christ my personal savior
and you get the card or you know you get the blanket on top of you and and then you're good you're good to go um but it's there's nothing else that you can do really in the spiritual life to to be holy okay so so they basically see the sacraments as as magic or as nothing that's that's kind of how they would see the sacraments that it's it has no effect yeah yeah right right they're just they're just signs of faith and then they they they would look at us catholics and how much ceremony we
surround the sacraments with how much reverence we give to the sacraments and because they don't believe they do anything they tend to mock the sacraments they they call the sacraments or they came up with the term hocus pocus in order to describe the sacraments and i don't know if they came up with those those magic shows either you know where we got just like um what in other words i don't know if they designed if the way we do magic shows today was kind of based off of that protestant mockery that you just walk up
to a door and you say abracadabra you know open says me and there's like a form that's that's used you uses magic words and then something happens or you you you you wave a wand and you say abracadabra over a hat and you pull a rabbit out um so they they look at like a priest bending over the altar and saying over the host or s corpus mayhem as just superstition and it does nothing or the the pouring the pouring of the water over the baby they they see it as as just like a magic
show where the effects of the sacrament are so out of proportion to what is being done um so we know that when you when you go to the magic show and you see the the magician wave his wand over his top hat and he pulls a rabbit out you know after he showed it to you empty you're just like wow that's amazing but you know that waving a wand is not going to create a rabbit ex nicola it's just not it's not as efficient cause to do that so so too um a man pouring some
water on a baby and saying some words is not sufficient to produce a supernatural effect and so they they just mock the sacraments and say this is this is just uh magic that the people in the magic show would know it's just slight of hand really the effect is not really happening so too the process would say the effect is not really happening um and we would say to them well look you know it's true that these words in the pouring of water is not sufficient to create grace in the soul of a baby that's
true and and me as a human being bending over a piece of bread and pronouncing those words is not sufficient to make christ present of course not right but but if god is involved whenever you get god involved then you do have enough cause out causal power to make that effect and god can use anything to create the effects that he wants um so he can use a a a a lowly man like myself and some lowly bread as means to cause the effect of the presence of christ being there if he wants to because
he has omnipotent power and so this is this is what we believe we say with god in in there the the causality is proportional to the effect and it's not it's not magic so right um they're just they just lack faith they like they like the faith that this is what god is doing this is what god wants to do that god is acting in these in these seven sons and so shortly after the the protestant reformation defamation that the church really solidified what the sacraments are i mean they were they obviously already existed beforehand
but trent really put in stone uh in order to combat this this heresy what the sacraments are yes so because the the protestants were attacking the the sacraments so vehemently they were denying the sacraments they were denying that institution by christ saying christ did not institute sacraments trent had the very healthy reaction of clarifying the teaching of the church and saying for everybody that no christ did institute the sacraments and if you don't believe that you're going to hell um so trent was very good at in making cannons that to say that i'll just read
a few of them uh for you one of the things trent says is that any if anyone says that the sacraments of the new law were not all instituted by jesus christ our lord or that there are more or fewer than seven or that any one of these seven is not truly and properly a sacrament let him be anathema and then there was associated with the council of trent a profession of faith and we sometimes make this profession of faith that was issued by trent because the the council didn't just want to make these cannons
but she also wanted to make sure that catholics were adhering to these things and so she the council trent issued this very elaborate and long professional faith but one of the things that it says is i profess that there are truly and properly seven sacraments of the of the new law instituted by jesus christ our lord and necessary for the salvation of mankind although not all are necessary for each individual so these are just very very clear definitions from trent to say the seven sacraments are instituted by jesus christ and this is part of our
catholic teaching you have to believe it stay fit okay okay so that's trent's reaction this is what the protestants believe um the modernists are also going to be attacking what the sacraments are but in a more subtle way is that right that's correct that's correct i think actually andrea this is probably uh i think one of the things we discussed when we had our two podcasts on modernism and the crisis in the church series but this this perception of the modernist that when we look back in history and we say where'd religion come from effectively
they're going to say it didn't come from god it never came from god and the catholic church is not an exception that really the origin of religion is some sort of need in man that that man has some sort of need for validation of his subconscious that he has this feeling of god and he needs to validate that by an act of faith that he believes in that god is working in him in the feelings that he's having and then man goes from there after he's created this faith of the god of his subjective feelings
after that he wants to go and associate with other men and incarnate that belief in some sort of ritual and that this is how the sacraments were born that the apostles got together and they started sharing their faith in christ that they had invented and they said hey let's let's find some rituals let's do some rituals in order to express that faith in christ like yeah this is a great idea what do you think oh maybe we should come up with a ritual to indicate that christ is going into a soul for the first time
yeah how about we just pour some water over somebody's forehead you know sort of like what john the baptist was doing and you know it just sort of goes on like that that that the christian community invented the seven sacraments in order to show their faith to manifest their internal faith about christ it's that it's coming from that naturalism i think right that that man is creating things worship is is his own idea god doesn't play a part um yeah it's just because we have some sort of psychological need that we need to fulfill and
that's why we invent these sacraments but this was condemned pretty squarely uh shortly after this kind of came into vogue right yeah so you know that saint pius intent he was he was not a man to leave any stone unturned when it came to the condemnation of heresy and because he speaks about that in paschindi that the the modernists believe that sacraments are just the invention of human beings they didn't come from christ he systematically goes through all the sacraments to condemn the belief of the modernist that they were instituted by human beings so lavantavali
was a document that accompanied pashindi so pashindi was this encyclical on modernism ramen tavi lee was a list of propositions that he drew up from modernist teaching and he wanted to say that these propositions are condemned these these are heretical so i'll just give you some of these propositions that are found in laminitability uh proposition number 39 says and again this is this is a statement of the modernist position and saint paul's sentence is saying this statement is condemned okay the statement says the opinions about the origin of the sacraments with which the fathers of
trent were imbued and which certainly had an influence on their dogmatic cannons are far different from those those which now rightly obtain among historical investigators of christianity so basically they're saying the fathers of the council of trent were wrong about sacraments that's condemned number 40 the sacraments had their origin in this that the apostles and their successors swayed and moved by circumstances in advance interpreted some ideas and intentions of christ so it was the apostles and their successors who invented the sacraments 42 the christian community has introduced the necessity of baptism adopting it as a
necessary right and adding it to the obligation of professing professing christianity so it just baptism was invented by the first christians number 44 there is no proof that the rite of the sacrament of confirmation was practiced by the apostles but the formal distinction between the two sacraments namely baptism and confirmation by no means goes back to the history of primitive christianity so confirmation again is is not something instituted by christ it doesn't go back to the beginning and as they say he just goes through every single one of the sacraments and gives these errors that
the modernists have when they're saying that the sacraments were not instituted by christ but they were instituted by the apostles or by later christians okay so protestants still have uh an an idea of the sacraments um if if sacraments don't give grace according to the protestants what do they say is the is the point like what's what's the point of having a sacrament if it doesn't do anything yeah that's that's the question so what if if um it's faith alone that saves you and these these signs are not able to sanctify you then what why
do them and it's it's quite simply so that you can foster your faith you the only reason why you do these rituals is to strengthen your own faith to support your your own belief and that's both the protestants and the modernists have this idea that the reason why we should do these rituals is not because they give us grace not because they sanctify us but only because they strengthen our faith so according to luther the the sacraments can be said to save but they save through the faith of the one who receives them so if
you have faith in the sacrament it's not the sacrament so much that it saves you as your faith in the sacrament and for calvin they're just a way for us to show our devotion to god but they don't they don't cause any sanctifying grace to come to us and that this is another one of those things that the council of trent condemned the reduction of the sacraments to merely a manifestation of faith trent says if anyone says that the sacraments are instituted solely to foster the faith let them be anathema so the the modernists as
well as they said they they believe that the sacraments are just invented by us in order to satisfy the need of expressing that internal faith that we have so one of the things that pius 10 said in paschindi is the following he says for the modernists sacraments are bare symbols or signs though not devoid of a certain efficacy and efficacy they tell us like that of certain phrases vulnerably described as having caught the popular ear inasmuch as they have the power of putting certain leading ideas into circulation and of making a marked impression upon the
mind so doing the rituals just helps strengthen your ideas in your mind they they help get the ideas out there the the faith of the of the community is strengthened by performing these rituals that's that's pretty much it okay so so modernist and protestants kind of have the same sort of idea they they would say well sacraments are just there to to help you with your faith they don't really produce an effective grace yeah so if we if we were to make up our own protestant or modernist catechism andrew and this is not probably not
a project we should we should launch out on but uh we would we would say the sacraments are outward signs not instituted by christ but instituted by us to strengthen our faith howard signs instituted by us to strengthen faith that's that's what we would say and they're very nice and they're so nice i mean they make me feel good um does the the new code of canon law talks a lot about the sacraments um does this does this new code does it kind of dive into this modernist tendency of of getting away from uh getting
away from the sacraments giving grace yeah unfortunately it does to some degree so the the new code of kenneth law um often strikes a middle ground between modernism and catholicism and the same is true in some cases in the catechism of the of the catholic church that was issued i think in 1992 so so the the new code came out in in 1983 and it has a cannon talking about the sacraments and and what it does instead of like what the old code does is it just says very clearly um the the sacraments are instituted
by our lord and their means for your sanctification and salvation so it lines up perfectly with that definition of of the sacraments instituted by christ to give grace that's it so do the sacraments nourish our faith of course they nourish our faith sure but we're not going we're not going to emphasize that because that's not the main thing the main thing why our lord instituted them is or in order to give us grace they also have the effect of of nourishing our faith but especially since we know that protestants and modernists reduce the sacraments to
simply a stimulation of faith then we're not going to mention that and we're definitely not going to emphasize that that was the spirit of the old code but the new code does precisely that it does mention that the the sacraments sanctify us but only says that after it talks about the the sacraments as a means to stimulate our faith so it includes both and it seems to put the more important effect to be the stimulation of our faith and i mean this this sort of thing can can cause problems it can cause problems if you
don't put things in the right order so canon 840 of the new code says the following the sacraments of the new testament were instituted by christ our lord very good and entrusted to the church as actions of christ and of the church there are signs in means by which faith is expressed and strengthened worship is offered to god and our sanctification is brought about thus they contribute in the most effective manner to establishing strengthening and manifesting ecclesiastical communion now if if you're not aware of these disputes you might think that the strengthening of your faith
in the sacraments is what sanctifies you that the one comes from the other that it's not the sacraments themselves that the saints if you put the faith first it's like where does the sanctification cut does it mention later where does that come from does it come from the fact that my faith is strengthened or does it come from the sacraments themselves so there's a you know you introduce an ambiguity you can introduce confusion and you make a text that is acceptable to modernist and it can rewrite in a catholic sense but it's also can be
read in a modern sense right and and as we've seen so much these these modernist texts they're subtle and if you don't know what you're looking for you miss it and it sure sounds good but it's it's there yeah there's some danger there's some poison lying there and unless you're in the know you won't be able to pick it out right so those are the errors on the on the the faith i guess part of of the sacraments um there have been errors in terms of the validity of the sacraments uh in the past as
well and we're just talking generally here about about all the sacraments uh but throughout the history of the church there have been these errors on whether or not a sacrament is valid can we walk through a few of those father yeah sure sure you know it's it's just interesting that um our lord instituted sacraments but he didn't institute a theology he really left for us to work out as far as we can the the explanation of the sacrament so the things that we discussed in the first podcast they're really a result of a lot of
theological reflection explaining the mechanics of the sacraments how the sacraments work what is necessary to build the sign what makes for the validity of the sacraments and you know we shouldn't be scandalizing that that the fact that we took the church centuries to really work out um how god had designed the sacraments she she took from the beginning this institution by christ and we you know there's a performance of the sacraments and the sacraments were working but but to explain them and understand their their nature and how they work took time and uh because of
that there was there was disputes there were disputes in the history of the church that are quite interesting so the there were various the disputes initially arose about that question of whether you have to be holy in order to administer the sacrament or whether you have to have faith the faith of the church in order to administer the sacrament properly so as a dispute arose in the third and the fourth centuries with regards to people who had defected from the faith and were administering the sacraments are there are their sacraments valid or people who had
defected from the faith and returned to the faith uh did their defection does that mean that that their sacraments are invalid as well because they they apostatize for a while it was especially in northern africa that um the the bishops started to believe that the baptism conferred by heretics was not valid and there was in fact two different saints who who had a dispute on this in the third century on the one hand you had saint cyprian in carthage who was having a synod in which the bishops the 71 bishops who were assembled said that
that those who were baptized by heretics needed to be re-baptized that by the fact that these heretics did not share the faith of the church they had to be re-baptist so that defect in faith meant a defect in the sacrament and it was the pope of the time pope saint stephen so you know it's interesting because you have two saints on the side of this dispute and they're having different opinions it reminds you of the great western system when you have like saint catherine siena voting for the right pope his name vincent faire voting for
the wrong pope you know right so but but they're both in good faith they're they're they both have good will it's it's it's when the church actually defines something that there's no room for for bad for for good faith or bad faith anymore i mean you just have to accept it um and if you deny it you're in bad faith so pope saying stephen he said no you don't have to re-baptize them um because we've never done that you know why would we start doing it now 250 years into the into the church when we've
never done that in the past we've accepted people from heretical faiths and accepted their their baptism but he didn't make a definition at the time and there was there was no solemnity given and so that left the possibility of the dispute rising again and it did rise again um like in the next century with the donatists the donuts is uh were a particular type of of heretics who believe that only the just are members of the church so so sinners those who have fallen away from grace are no longer members of the church it's sort
of the idea that once you fall into the mortal sin um you're basically excommunicated in the church and so they they said um those bishops who were called traditores who when diocletian was persecuting the church and he was asking the hand over the sacred books and they they went and they handed them over to diocletian he burned all the sacred books the the catholic books that those bishops when they did that they fell from the church they were no longer bishops and as a result their sacraments were no longer valid well unfortunately for the donatists
there was a great genius bishop at the time by the name of seeing augustine that they had to face off against and well um seeing augustine he he made an important a clarification that was very important later on for reflection on the sacraments when when people like st thomas aquinas gave a very clear sacramental theology in the middle ages and he said well you know if you have a situation where one heretic is baptizing another heretic an adult i'm not an infant and so both of them have the wrong faith that that it is a
valid baptism but the heretic who receives the sacrament does not receive grace he receives the character of the sacrament but he doesn't receive the grace of the sacrament um so when we were talking about the validity of the sacraments we weren't talking about the recipient we we didn't talk about the recipient um but so he's talking about you got a heretic on both sides both the minister and the recipient he's saying it's possible that the the sacrament is valid um but the grace is not given so you can have a valid sacrament where the grace
is not given and then there was this uh there was another bishop at the time saint obtatus um who who made some important clarifications the same clarifications that that we made in that first podcast namely that it's not the holiness of the minister that determines the efficacy of the sacraments the sacraments do not have their efficacy from the holiness of the minister or the faith of the master they have their efficacy from the church and from our lord jesus christ that's where they divide derive their principle power and efficacy and in the church and in
our lord cannot um and therefore if the min the minister is sinful um if he's dirty he can still cleanse as it were you know okay if the if the minister is dirty with sin yet he can cause the cleansing of another soul because really it's our lord working through the minister who's doing the cleansing so it's not like uh the unclean is cleaning it's really the clean who are cleaning the uh lord who's clean is cleaning he's you he's he's doing working to a dirty minister but he is still the primary agent okay that's
very interesting i was actually going to ask that a little bit earlier when we were talking about um the protestants saying that the faith of the bleepers uh was necessary and that brought up a kind of a hypothetical you've taught catechism i've taught catechism you and i probably both hate hypotheticals well father what if um but but yes but that sorry but forgive me i'll ask one anyway let's say i got married when i got married and i didn't believe in the efficacy of the sacrament of matrimony and i was just going along with it
because my fiance wanted to and i didn't care about it by saint augustine's definition i would receive the character of matrimony but until i accepted the fact that matrimony was a sacrament and all that then i would receive the grace of the sacrament is that what you're saying um so there is no character with matrimony so there's three sacraments that that give a character um baptism confirmation holy orders so we we would say you would you would receive the sacrament the sacrament would be valid um so you would in other words you would have contracted
a sacramental marriage however there would be like a block to the channel of grace so you you the the channel of grace would be would now be available for you to re you receive the the graces of marriage but there there's an obstacle there and that is your state of sin and your lack of belief and that you know if you confess that if you went to confession and you said bless me father five sin you know um i got married and and i you know explicitly disbelieved in the sacrament of marriage um and you
get absolved then that block would be removed and the graces of your marriage would come to you at that point so the marriage would be valid you would be a married man your wife would be a married woman she would be receiving graces you would not be receiving graces okay so it's it's similar it's exactly what what saint augustine was was saying with regards to reception of baptism by a heritage okay thanks that that helps um so then we get into the middle ages and that's when the church really starts to clarify you know all
of these all of these questions a little bit more formally yes yeah and you know it's um it just takes a lot of refraction reflection in in the the usually what happens is there's a certain terminology that is developed and the the terminology of ex oprah operator xobare oberantes um so we we say that the sacraments work ex oprah operato it's by doing the thing but just by doing the action that's what makes it work whereas by exoplanets means it's it's really the one doing it who makes it work it's not the it's not the
action itself that makes it work it's the one doing it it relies really on the one doing it so when we say with the sacramentals they work exoplay on operontes we're saying it works on the faith of the one who's conferring the sacramental and when we say that the sacraments works work exoplanet operato we're saying they work just by the action being performed not by the one the uh doing the the the sacrament so um that distinction was introduced by a theologian of the middle ages in 13th century peter poitier and um the the uh
basically what what the church did in the middle ages is she took the position of saint augustine and finally elevated it to the level of dogma she said this is the right perspective on the sacraments that position of saint augustine the position of saint optatus that firstly well effectively that the sacraments derive their validity from christ and from the church not from the holiness or the faith of the minister at that time there were there were three opinions on uh the efficacy of sacraments one thought that sacraments that were administered by excommunicated ministers were invalid
others held the position of seeing augustine which we've already considered they're valid but they don't produce grace and then the third opinion held that they produced grace they were valid and they produced grace but somehow the grace is not sanctified the grace is there but it doesn't have a sanctifying effect on you and there there were various heresies uh floating around the the albigensians and the waldensians were teaching that the you had to have a holy minister for the sacraments to be valid and what the church did was institute professions of faith for them for
people who were coming over from those from those heresies they had to make a profession in faith and effectively profess the the faith of of saint augustine the position of saint augustine on the sacraments that when you have an excommunicated minister the sacrament is valid but the grace is not given the grace is blocked by the heresy of the person receiving the sacrament so um you know that's that that was i think the the major sacramental controversy um in the history of the church those those sacramental controversies um that existed before the protestants and the
modernists that was the main thing on the question the validity and then after after them after the middle ages uh the protestants introduced this lack of faith in the sacraments uh at all so so the the the problem of the donatists and the problem of the albigensians and the waldensians they were thinking that that's too much relied upon the minister um they were they were sort of lacking faith in the efficacy of the sacraments in themselves and and placing their faith in the in the holiness of the minister for the validity of the sacraments and
then after those heresies were conquered in the middle ages um and the protestants the modernists came along again they they failed to believe that the soccer machine is instituted by christ or that they gave grace very interesting well father that's been a great look at at the um introducing us to the sacraments in these last two episodes thank you so much for taking the time um we'll be looking we'll be starting our our look at the sacraments themselves next time um we're starting with baptism obviously and i think we'll have you back for uh holy
eucharist yes uh god willing i don't know i i'm looking forward to that all right very good father thank you so much have a wonderful week thank you andrew [Music] you