by now I'm sure you've seen the absolute meme that is Boycott Weyland which has a couple of reasonable points here and there but a lot of it is just blatantly wrong and completely out of date and even complains that some X configuration tools don't work on Wayland like what would you expect now on the other side there are plenty of Articles out there arguing for the technical Merit to Weyland for example this recent one by Oro and I've made plenty of videos on the topic myself but what I had never really stopped to consider is
that none of this really matters anymore so a bunch of people have been sending me this article by Chris sieberman the technical Merit to Weyland are mostly irrelevant when I first read that title I wasn't really sure where it was going to go but some really interesting arguments do get made I don't particularly disagree with weyland's General technical Merit and improvements but at this point I think they are mostly irrelevant as such I don't think that talking about them will do much to shift more people to Weyland I say that the technical merits are irrelevant
because I don't believe that they're a major factor anymore in most people moving or not moving to Weyland at this point in time and from my vantage point there are roughly four groups of people still in the x-camp from my experience from my comment section I will always run to these people that no matter what you say about Whelan no matter how much of a better experience it is going to be for the regular person they just have no interest in using Weyland they have their experience on X and it doesn't matter what you say
that's the experience they're going to be using so people on Unix environments that don't have wheel and support they have to use X or not have a graphical experience suggesting that these people change to a Linux environment with Wayland support is a non-starter they are presumably using their current environment for good reasons a great example of this is the bsds now FreeBSD does have wheel and support but if you're a net BSD user or currently an open BSD user that is being worked on but right now those only support X or say you have a
Unix server like IBM AIX HP ux Oracle Solaris which are still things that do exist in the world and are still being sold you're going to be using X or so you have this box it has one function it sits in a closet somewhere or controls some random machinery and was last updated 20 years ago that probably doesn't support Weyland either all of these are situations where no matter what you say about Weyland being great it doesn't matter if you're using a system like this you have a good reason to be doing so but these
aren't the only people there are people using mainstream desktop environments that already support Weyland primarily genome and KDE in relatively stock ways now there are other examples and things are being worked on like budgie it very shortly is going to be Wayland default or Weyland only but the list is still very very short switch to new Weyland is generally transparent for these people and happens when their Linux distribution decides to change the default for their Hardware if Dylan's distribution has not switched to default there is often good reason for it most of these people switch
over time as the distribution changes defaults and they're unlikely to switch before then these are the sorts of people that aren't using Linux as a hobby Linux is a tool for them they don't care about Linux gaming or racing Linux they need a Linux environment to get some work done and that's pretty much it they don't care about destroy politics oh you're using Arts you're using Manjaro it doesn't matter all they need is a system that does the job I know a Game Dev like this hinstalls Godot he installs any of the other tools he
needs and that's pretty much as far as it goes but there are other people in this Camp as well people who are just first starting to get into Linux they don't really know anything about the tech stack yet they know that there is this distribution this distribution this distribution they do slightly different things but why they do different things and how that happens that's not something they're really concerned with yet there are also people using desktop environment or custom X setups that don't currently support Weyland switching to Weyland is extremely non-transparent for these people because
they will have to change their desktop environment so far to gnome or KDE or reconstruct a Weyland version of it back in 2021 this included xfc and cinnamon and bass on Modest internet searches I believe it still does from my understanding it still does I know ecstasy is working on it and cinnamon most of their components do support Wayland minus the window manager part the kind of most important part yes ecstasy and cinnamon are popular but most desktop environment users are using a gnome and then less so KDE when we talk about the window manager
space this is where it gets even worse I3 is a massive window manager but if you're using pretty much anything else you're not gonna have an experience on Weyland without changing to a completely different environment yes there are things like river which is inspired by bspwm yes there is dwl which calls itself dwm for Wayland and yes there are things like lab WC which are inspired by open box but all of these are different environments from just hey I'm on KDE on X I am on Katie on Weyland yeah there are some things that are
going to be a bit different but you don't have to go and install anything new you have to go and change any config files learn a new config format it's just switch to toggle and you're pretty much good to go here you are rewriting your entire configs in the window manager space there are certainly exceptions you have sway on Weyland which is a superset of A3 obviously some of the X tools you're using will have to change but all of the I3 features are supported in sway NG of Q tile which has a Weyland and
an X11 version but these are few and far between most of these either Wayland or X and if you want to switch there's going to be a time commitment and if you're not that attached to the environment maybe give it a shot but if you've been using the exact same Window Manager for three years and you've been using X for 10 plus years and have an environment that is perfectly crafted to do exactly what you need it to do I can see why you don't want to move one can hope that some of these Destin
environments will get whale and support over time I have a lot less hope for the window managers usually there's like one or two core developers and most of the major ones have had open issues about Weyland for multiple years and nobody really wants to work on it I can understand why it would be a massive undertaking but if these environments did do so it would move people using them up into the previous category and probably moving them to Weyland juices however the primary bottleneck for this is probably time and attention from developers who by now
probably have heard Lots about why people think they should add support for Weyland and its technical merits I can't even imagine how many people have said hey guys add Whalum here is why listing the exact same reasons now as for some of the well-known desktop environments xse does have a road map from my understanding things are supposed to be properly implemented by 4.20 I don't know if that's going to happen but that's certainly what's being talked about Clem in regards to Cinnamon has said hey uh our tools work on it but like there's not really
any specific plans yet I've not found any road maps so they're just sort of coasting along doing what they do now over on the Ubuntu mate page it says this Modern Display server support Weyland is set to become the de facto Next Generation display server while EXO has some years of usefulness remaining now is the time to start planning for how mate desktop in there for Ubuntu mate Implement support for Weyland so they want to do it but like there's not any specific plans yet budgie on the other hand has this giant page called Weyland
and at least for now budgie 11 is aiming to be Wayland first but we might see Weyland support sometime during the life cycle of budgie 10. and then there's lxqt which I don't know how many people are still using but they just have Waylon Supply support already and are improving it every single update now the final major group are people who can theoretically switch to Weyland and who might gain benefits from doing so but who have found good reasons often related to Hardware support that X worked better for them the best example being Nvidia gpus
you can use an Nvidia GPU on Weyland but there are pretty good reasons why you might not want to do so and certain accessibility workflows don't function the way you would expect on Weyland and in some cases simply don't function especially if you're operating outside of one of the major desktop environments there is just more tooling available for doing accessibility on the X side you may not have been in one of those groups but that wasn't an exhaustive list there are smaller groups not included here such as people who have critical lines on X features
not well supported in Weyland and I feel like I'm kind of in one of those groups so I rely on video capture Now pythwire video capture does exist on Weyland and for the most part it's fine but it's not as good as X so I was previously using the hyperlan desktop and there was some portal issues happening that were completely locking up my desktop forcing me to hard reset my system now I don't know if that was a portal issue or a hyperland issue what I know is was certainly an issue now if I went
to use sway instead none of that happened but I couldn't capture individual windows I could only capture my entire desktop so I simply couldn't do the podcast on sway then there are things like OBS browser docs which simply do not work on Wayland and the only way to get them to work is run OBS through X Weyland which breaks a couple of different extensions video production is incredibly Niche video production on Linux is a niche of a niche video production on Linux on Weyland I don't know there might be like 10 people doing it there
are people out there like Georgia stavrock is doing incredible work in this space but it's certainly not a major focus of most projects and I totally get it like focus on the things that most normal people are doing and then eventually we can get around to the more Niche problems or I can help out with those projects and things like that but it makes sense why it's still rough with only a slight amount of generalization none of these people be moved by whalen's technical merits the energetic people who could be persuaded by technical merits to
go through switching desktop environments or in some cases replacing Hardware or accepting limited features have mostly moved to Weyland already the people who remain on X are there either because they don't want to rebuild their desktop environment they don't want to do without features and performance they currently have or their Linux distribution doesn't think the desktop should switch to Weyland yet I think all of that is true but I think there is a very important Point don't take anybody else's word about the state of Weyland if you've not used Weyland ever in your life or
you've not used Weyland in like you know three or five years give it a try now see what it's like maybe it's good enough for you now maybe there are still some rough edges in which case keep using X but don't just read a forum post from a couple of years ago saying whale and bad and think oh weyland's still bad today there has been some massive work being done over the past couple of years and things are in such a better State for the regular person they were back then and whilst people still using
X might be really loud about it I don't think there are many of them left by now and if they're out there they're hard to reach since the Weyland people have been banging this drum for quite a while now there is a very good reason why on the boycott whale and thread I was called YouTube's top Wayland propagandist look I'll wear that title with absolute Pride yes I am a whale and propagandist and you should be too PS the other sense that weyland's technical merits are mostly irrelevant is that everyone agrees that Whalen is the
future of Unix graphics and development of the X server is dead unless and until new people shop to revive ex-server development Weyland is the only game in town and when you have a monopoly your technical merits don't really matter this is certainly the case for anybody who's actually paying attention turns out there is a lot of people that aren't paying attention though so let me know thoughts in the comment section down below do you use Whelan do you use x if you are still using X why like what about X is still keeping you in
that system do you just not really care or do you have a really good reason for it I would love to know so if you liked the video go like the video and if you really like the video and if you want to become one of these amazing people over here just go to patreon Scrubs deliver pay Link in the description down below that's gonna be it for me and Weyland is the future but maybe not the present for some people [Music] holding chocolate [Music]