[Music] Hello everyone. On behalf of the organizing committee, it's my honor to welcome everyone to the third and last day of Enthopi. My name is Alex Jidu. I am a professor at the State University of Arana and I will provide a brief audio description. I am a white man with a short black hair and I'm wearing a blue shirt. Behind me, there's a white wall and a white flower To my right side. On the third day of the event, I am the moderator of the round table called acknowledging life stories in research which is the
last activity of the event. It's my honor to invite two distinguished re researchers to share this screen with me. Please join me in welcoming Dr. Saul Consuli at the State University of Edinburgh and Dr. Fabricio from the Federal University of Matros Du. When members of the organizing committee decided the theme of this edition, we immediately thought about inviting both of you, Fabricio and Saul. For those that are watching us, both researchers have something in common. They recognize the humanity and uniqueness of people involved in research in the field of applied linguists. The ways they research,
they write, and they live deserve to be recognized at This event. That's why we thought about both of you. Even though they share a sensitive methodological approach, they come from unique professional different trajectories. Dr. Saul Consley is a lecture research in language education at the Institute for Language Education at the Mory House School of Education and Sport at the University of Edinburgh. His research focuses on the psychology of language Learning and teaching with a specific emphasis on student learning motivation and learner engagement as well as language teacher well-being. Also he has an active interest in
research ethics and reflexivity in applied linguistics and education more broadly. Dr. Fabricio owner is a professor at the language teacher education undergraduate program and at the language program at the federal university of mto du. He's an active researcher at technology and his current research interests are epistemologies and ontologies, literacies, decoloniality and authography. Again, I want to express my deepest gratitude for both of you for accepting our invitation. So I'll give you some seconds for both of you just to say um some initial words for those that are watching us and then we start with the
Presentations. So so please feel free to share your thoughts with us and once again thank you so much for accepting our invitation. Well, um, thank you, Alex, and thank you everyone on the organizing committee for this event, for thinking of me and for inviting me to be part of this event at a distance. Um, I already have a developing um relationship with Brazil Over uh several ideas and projects. So I it's a shame for me not to be there um um face to face to be able to enjoy the environment and the company but um
it's um a joy nonetheless to be part of this. So thank you so much. Um Alex, would you like me to move on to the the presentation? Do you want me to let Fab British say some words first? Uh, not sure if I'm okay to start the presentation because I don't know if you Can see my slides. Uh, can you see my slides? Okay. So, I'll I'll make a start. Is that okay? >> Yes. Yes, we can see your >> Okay. I'm so sorry. Thanks for checking. Okay, so um one of my um areas of
interest is um thinking of how to advance research methods in uh language education Research. And in the last five six years, one of the core um concepts that I've been um working on in this area is the notion of life capital. And life capital here is intended as a lens to um revisit research methodology in language education research. Particularly in this short um intervention, I'd like to talk about um um restoring the concept of humanity in language education research. And to do so, I'd like to refer to my work on life Capital. So um here
we we'll briefly start by um talking about the concept of humanity and what it means to me in this particular context and what is life capital why do we need this new concept how has it been used so far and how it could be used in future. So the early ideas of this theoretical concept are in this paper in Tissel quarterly where I introduce the premises um of the concept and how it could be adapted to initially Tissel research but then more widely language education research. What do I mean by humanity? This is a very
sensitive topic. I think um for everyone in this world at the minute, wherever country they live in, there is something happening that has challenged for me in in in one way or another the the state of being, the state of living causing discomfort. There are so many um world events happening as we speak that are causing lots of discomfort and they get Me thinking about the notions of social justice that we often hear about in research or in um various academic activities. And here I connect to the concept of humanity by thinking of the term
that Emanuel Kant used in German va that is normally translated into English as dignity and that's where I connect the notion of humanity um in this case where is the dignity of the people that um are part and parcel of our research where is our own dignity as human Researchers when we engage in research. So that's where um my um idea of humanity goes. The premises of the concept of life capital therefore uh come from the um French philosopher Pierre Bio who talked about capital in his theory called the social theory where his idea was
to um understand society particularly the concept of social classes in society um but I if you like employ Bulier's um terminology technology to kind of take this concept A little further to extend it to something slightly different. Um Bio talked about social classes and the notions of capital in terms of um acred resources like economic resources, cultural resources. I think of life capital as a um lens that we can use for our research methodologies to allow us to implement more holistic approaches in research methods that would do greater justice to the complexities and the multi-layered
understandings that we Offer with our research pod um's work I should today has been cultivated um simultaneously by multiple colleagues who have developed different relationships with this work and we have been inspired by it extended it and made empirical correctives to it. We have also used it as a springboard to open new visitors and ask new questions. And that's exactly what I'm doing here with or what I've done I should say with the concept of life capital. In Bodio's work there is a um the notion of habitus. Habitus is this idea that the individual um
is seen as having this agency embodiment um that connects with the social world where we live. Um some have thought of the concept of habitus as this connection between the individual and the social world as it the metaphor if you like of the onion. The onion has many layers to its structure. So if you think about how many layers the onion Has well then we could think of abitus as the adult developed onion with its multi-layered structures stemming from a process of growth facilitated and impacted by external forces such as the sun, the rain, the
soil and so on so forth. So basically we have the onion that develops. So the habitus of an individual develops um in relationship to the environment where the individual is situated. Um this therefore suggests that there is Um there are as you say social structures within which one is um raised and this will affect the development of their own subjectivity. Each of us has their own subjectivity which develops as a result of um an internalization of life experiences. So this is all very complex um theory that I'm summarizing here in a very reductive manner for
interest of time. But the idea according to Bulier's theory of capitals is that society is understood through an Individual's accumulation of resources or accumulated history. And as I said earlier, he talked about economic capital, social capital, cultural capital and symbolic capital. Now in the field of language education research, the work of BU has already been used um in the areas for example of learner agency inequality um or specific aspects of teachers emotions and so on so forth. But in this book where I uh present um the notion of Life capital within a particular empirical study
that looked at students motivation, I present uh a new perspective on capital. I decided to position the concept of habitus within the same realm of the construct of identity. And I argue that uh these are both habiters and identity. They're both concerned with the experiences that shape one's sense of self and dispositions to the world. And I also think that habitus and identity are Inevitably impacted by one's life story which evolves from the moment that we are born and throughout our life affairs. Now I see life capital as a fresh perspective for research. I think
that this could be a methodological approach that emphasizes the importance of our individual life stories uh particular type of holistic research lens that um looks at the individual and the social practices in context. Um, in the research field, traditionally, we've often heard of concepts like L1 interference or lack of proficiency or lack of engagement, lack of motivation, and so on so forth. But these are all very clear-cut um, labels and categorizations of very complex phenomena. And so I think we need to look at the complexity of the phenomena of um language education research that we
investigate. We have had the good work of colleagues who um have advanced complex and dynamic systems theory which offers complex and holistic perspectives on um dualisms. But um what happens with complex dynamic systems theory is that usually although they make a very good effort to theorize the unpredictability of complex phenomena like identity and motivation anxiety I think that complex system theory really remains at a very highly um Abstract theoretical level which kind forgets about that humanity of the very people that the very people who form parts of our investigations. Um, another approach could be ecological
perspectives. Ecological perspectives or approaches um have followed a similar philosophy to CDST, complex dynamic system theory. Um, and indeed they provide clear illustrations of language teaching and learning phenomena within that complexity. But these ecological Perspectives tend to limit their scope to discussions around context, space, environment. I think with a life capital perspective, we are able to open our eyes to the actual humans life stories in our research with a holistic view of these stories. This focus basically helps us understand more clearly the rich and unique complexities that characterize the lives of the people involved in
our research. So I define life capital as Embracing our participants life stories as part of our epistem or episteem means that we recognize the idiosyncratic memories, emotions, dispositions, needs and desires to name but a few factors that constitute the complex essence of a human being. Um, I should recognize that this work took inspiration uh from Emo Shioda's person in context theory that views people in this case learners as real people not theoretical abstractions. So Reminding ourselves that every individual person is a thinking feeling human being with an identity, a personality, unique history and a background.
a person with goals, motives and intentions. So um if I said that habitus close to the notion of identity is shaped by um and constantly reshaped by one's life story then we need to remind ourselves that everyone's life story is very much Unique and idiosyncratic in the realm of the world and there is a symbiotic relationship between um the experiences that we face and go through in life and the way we develop our habits. So if we move away from Bio sociological project about social classes and we look at human beings more holistically then that's
where life capital um emerges. Life capital um emerges as a wealth which every one of us has possesses which can be understood Through the richness of our own life experiences including um memories, desires, emotions, attitudes and so on so forth. Now very briefly looking at one highly successful paper in the journal TES quarterly that looked at motivation practices. I want to show you how we could reframe our methodology by asking life capital inspired questions. Now, this is something that was written in this paper. Uh the researcher wrote, "This class was chosen because the instruction covered
diverse language aspects. The group involved students of different ages, genders, and language backgrounds, and the instructor was more expressive in her non-verbal moves than the other teachers observed. So, as you can see here, one way or another, the researcher is um passing a judgment on the teachers, saying that the teacher that she chose to observe is more expressive and other Teachers are less expressive. Okay, I'm sure that the researcher had all the right intentions when she wrote this. However, from a life capital perspective or from a life capital methodology, I should say, I want to
ask these questions. What do we know about this teacher? What makes her more expressive than other teachers? And how is this resource embedded within the teacher's life story? Could it be that this trait has always been part of the teacher's um Behavior even outside the classroom? or is it part of or result of a specific type of teacher training or professional experience? We don't know this and this understanding this would help us understand the phenomenon that the researcher is talking about. Um something else that the researcher wrote was the students confusion in this observation could
have been resolved if the teacher had attended to his gesture. And I would like to ask the questions, But um is the teacher here being portrayed as not doing the right thing? Could there be a specific reason or previous experience that may explain why the teacher chose to behave in such a way? And also without data from the student we are unable to say whether the source of the confusion in this obser observed class might have roots in domains other than may appear just through an observation. So a lot of the data that we can
just look at through Observation there's there's a lot um complexity that we are missing out and I think asking these life capital questions might be one way of doing it. In a recent uh publication also in diesel quarterly um this time um authored with my post-doal um student Azar Tajabadi we looked at um understanding motivational experiences um through the dual lens of activity theory which is a very wellestablished analytical approach um to data analysis And also a life capital perspective and this is what happens. If you see here to the right hand side, these are
the normal sorry the usual um elements of activity theory. We got the subject which is the participant, the object which is the learning of English. Then there's the outcome. Then there's the divisional labor which is the activities the the actions the processes the community where the participant is um situated the rules of the context of The structures and then on the left hand side is all the unique details that we were able to gather through a life capital lens. All of this which you see on the left hand side would have been left out completely
through an activity theory approach. So this is just an example of how much more richness a life capital lens may add to um a wellestablished analytical analytical perspective on research in language education. Okay. Uh I think I might have run out of time. So I I just want to say thank you for following me and happy to take any questions or very happy for people to get in touch if they so wish. Thank you. So thank you so very much. Um a disclaimer for everyone. I have read all Saul's publication on the concept of live
capital and I always love to hear you explaining it and always learning more with you. >> You read even the last one I just talked about even that one. >> Yes. Yes. >> Thank you so much. We are going to um look at some questions and some comments later. Um, so now I would like to invite Dr. Fabricio Ono to share this screen with me. Um, and now I would like to turn the floor over to you, professor. And once again, thank you so much for joining us and accepting our invitation. >> Uh, I'd like
to say thank you, Alex, for Alex, for uh, hosting us this afternoon here in Brazil by the end of the afternoon. And I would like to uh say thanks to the organizing committee for inviting me to to dialogue and talk with you in this very important event for uh language teachers in Brazil. So I try to organize my my my talk this afternoon in order to to to fit with the uh the event theme. But uh Um I lost my I lost I here. Okay. Uh so my outline is I have I'm going to say
some some general things like my general perspective about life stores or um subjectivities and then I'm going through a ethnography. I think uh people expect more me to speak about athography. Well, so this is the this imagery represents what I thought about research when I started like my graduate course long ago observing just reflecting what People were doing or things like that not not bringing my life story or other people's life stories uh to to to the table I mean to to discussion um so nowadays this is a very different perspective I have from doing
research search. So I think things may not be as the the past this this this picture here that I asked uh chat to create. Okay. And then I would like you to observe this picture now and if you could write like what do you see in this picture? Well, if you look at this picture like from this perspective, we're going to see like a lot of beautings, a a green area, a like this touristic point here. This picture I took in S. Paulo. But if you go further, you're going to see that this picture has
many other elements which were not captured uh by the camera shuttle. If we go further, we can see that there are a lot of people who live here. And I I'm going to show the picture again. This is the Prestigious University of S. Paulo surrounded by this community. Why do I bring this here? Um I bring this here because I really agree with Adella's July when she says about the power of the camera shutter. shutter. I mean the camera shutter in terms of unlearning imperialism, observing things or trying to bring to our reality things histories
which were not um registered or didn't have the opportunity to be told. Um if you if you allow me I'm going to read this just this part from her when she says people and artifacts have become objects of observation and study conversion and care charge and control by two seemingly unrelated sets of disciplines institution and their scholars and experts. In truth, however, neither the movement nor their separation are unrelated. With a certain endlessly recurring brevity, similar to that the operation of a camera shutter, The un unending instant instantiation of their separation is reiterated. Uh they
are continually produced as disconnected as if it were the nature of artifacts to exist outside of their communities to come into being as museum objects to be out of reach of those who felt at home in their mid midst. uh as if it were the nature of certain people to exist, bereft of the worldly objects among which their inherited knowledge and rights, protective social Fabric and safety, bliss and happiness, sorrow and death are inscribed as if these objects were not a source of worldliness and a fountain of loveliness of for the communities from which they
were taken. So what I try to do here is to match the picture and what uh Azouai says just to start this conversation about life stories in research. Uh I also would like to to to say that I'm I based I'm based on I anchor what I say to this afternoon or this night in doser And is slaughter. I I'm gonna I'm gonna recall them later. But I would like to start with I would like to ask a couple questions. Why do life stories matter in research? Do they matter because we want to romanticize things,
victimize, overcome or not? I don't think so. I think life stories matter because we are telling history and histories that we're not told. Maybe we are keeping memory. We are uh expanding our cultural Perspectives. We are understand that we have different bias. We are trying to unlearn as well. We are question what is worth and what is valid. We're questioning imperial and colonial epistemologies when we bring life stories to research. So uh I would like also I I would like to add as well that machines do not have life stories. Why do I say that?
I say that because of this platformization of education that are happening a lot of States here in Brazil. So I think life stories are powerful tools against platformization of education. But what kind of life stories do we want or we need to tell? That's another important question when we think about life stories. I would like uh I would like I didn't I didn't I didn't translate this I dare translate this from Karolina Maria Jesus when she said that she writes about the miserable life of the people who live in Shanty towns because she was a
rebel and she didn't believe in nobody. She hated politicians and um boss the her bosses just because her dream was to write and poor people wouldn't write because it was a a noble thing. Uh but she wrote the reality. I think when I recall this, what kind of life stories do we want to tell or do we need to tell when we think about research and um I also worry about like what kind of life stories we are going say an uh I I Would like to make this analogy like life portrayed on social media
for example that's really different from life real life. So uh I think we have to be really careful when we uh think about life stories in research not to represent just a part of it that what is convenient for that moment because it would be a trap for researchers. uh so recalling dosier the author I mentioned in in the beginning he argues that narrative also functions as a site For the reconfiguration of the subject through biography autobiography and life stories narrative allows us to grasp how individuals and collectives constructs meaning and time he sees narrative
as a relational act and encounter between the narrator and the narrated that resist the impersonal structuralist models dominant in mid-century histography and is laudery. Human beings are spherical creators who live in symbolic envelopes, cultural, linguistic and Narrative space that give form to existence. Storytelling is one of the ways we inflate these spheres. It produces imaginative main brands within which communities orient themselves. So I do believe that bringing uh life stories that really matter but remembering that we're not romanticizing, victimizing or trying to give uh some pieces of advice of overcoming advices like coaches do a
lot on social media for example. But we are Retelling or counting histories that are were not told. We are keeping memories. We are expanding cultural perspectives. We have to go back understand that we have different bias. We have to unlearn and question all the time and and life stories may help us to do this. Um but what I what I I thought in 2017 and I rewrote about it this year like considering foreign language teacher education or language teacher education. I think that bringing this to the Autoethnographic field I could I would like to to
say that autoethnography it's an exercise when we bring our life stories to the re to to researches to research I mean why do I think that because it's an opportunity for self-practice and self-acceptance uh I think we have to review and we or think or reflect upon drives of the teacher educator It's an opportunity as well to redesign ourselves and we also have to be Available for the unknown and I would add today tonight the acknowledge the unknown. Maybe our perspectives our angles are so um establishing in one direction for example we have to be
and being sensitive and accept that we are vulnerable. Um and so thinking about autoethnography, this is the part two of course of my presentation. I think I I agree with Gail and W when they say it Is not enough to talk about the work that is done by bodies that are simply human. So we can ask some questions when we think about it. What we can what can a body do? What work does a particular performance or act do? So what analogy uh thinking about life stories, what can a life story do? What work does
a particular life story do? So I would add these questions when we think about life stories in research and I bring a piece of magal here when She says um What she means? She means that an autoethnographic emotional autoethnographic research is also a dive into our own history but is also a flight a panoramic flight that allows us to visualize um happenings what happened in our social context with the different perspectives broader and deeper. But before going to the end of my presentation, I would like to say that Why do we research? I would like
to make a few questions. Why do we research? What are our goals as researchers? Why do we intend to m do we intend to maintain tradition paradigms? Why do we have to acknowledge life stories? What is the purpose? fat, fashion, principles, ideals, what convenience, no liberal demands. I think these questions are really important when we we are talking about bringing life stories to research. Not uh not to Not to to to be in I mean not to to to get not to not to be gotten by the trap of neol liberal productivism or neol liberal
demands. And I think that bringing life stories we are going to build different movements but these movements uh have to be collective. They are not individual. We have to to when we bring life stories to re research we have to also change our perspectives what to do research is what to do Research mean research means and I think that's all people thank you for listening to me this afternoon thank you the organizing committee again. >> Thank you so much, Professor Fabricio. Once again, um I want to invite now professor Saul to join us on this
screen. Professor Professor Sal. Yes, thank you so much. Right. >> Um, so one comment that I realized that I would like to make at the very Beginning is we did not plan that but Saul ended talking about life capital and how it somehow guides the way um we understand and do research and Fabric started with the picture and how the way we take pictures also guide the way we describe them. So I think it connected a lot. So thank you so much both of you. Um, we have one question that I would like to direct
for both of you. Professor Juliana Brocei, she asks, um, let me get this one. How can we Researchers with all the papers and researches we must do in our daily lives use these lenses of life capital in such a sensitive and ethical work? with many participants in a study. >> That's a very good question. Um I should start by saying that um I I see life capital as a lens because like a lens that we use to see better. um you would apply that lens onto any methodology that you're wishing to use. Okay. So the
idea is not for researchers To change their approach to research or change their methodological preferences. It's to add to that. And that just simply means adding small acts of awareness of um respect for that dignity. Just simply reminding ourselves as researchers that we are dealing with people. So if I'm for example um if I'm writing if I'm designing a questionnaire for uh I don't know to understand multilingualism in a Secondary school in China. Okay. Um, I'm going to be pay attention to the way I phrase and word the items on the questionnaire to show respect
for the languages that I represent in that questionnaire, for the people involved in that school and so on so forth. And this takes me back to for example the way we use language as researchers in terms of are we just doing theory or are we working with, for, in, and through society. So imagine if we're talking About language education and we want to say that a stu students lack proficiency in a certain competence in a certain skill. Are we going to phrase that as researchers with this tone of deficiency that in a way disrespects perhaps
the stories of these people that we don't even know. So sometimes it's not necessarily about learning everything about everyone's life story because that's practically impossible and not everyone will be inclined to that of Course but I think it's about not rushing to judgments conclusions that could even be crude and you know not quite representative of the reality that we're looking at. So it's not always practically possible to look into people's life stories. I think it's important to assume that what we are observing or the people we're working with have life stories. Therefore, we need to
resist the urge to jump to lovely findings and conclusions just to Sound clever and um attractive to an academic audience. I don't know if that actually answered my the the question, but that's some thoughts. We can talk more about this. Janna, I'm more than happy to have a nice chat with you over coffee. >> Thank you, would you like to to comment as well? >> Yeah. Um, I think I I do agree with S about uh his point of view. Um I think We have a lot of life stories that are not that are not
told and maybe I recall what I I said before we have to be available to the unknown. We have to be sensitive all the time. Uh I know that academia like being in that academic world like sometimes we go on the flow. We go with the flow and we have to stop and think what am I doing? Do I am I listening to people? I'm observing people. I'm sh am I sharing experiences like deeply or just like I I I I just turn it on the automatic pilot. So I think we have a lot of
questions and we are researchers. We teach people to be educate people to be teachers in the future and also teachers who are already uh working as teachers ongoing education. I mean uh and I think that I have a life story in the academic world that changed the my perspective and I'm I'm I'm glad for the people who I I had the opportunity to meet and to dialogue. I think we need More moments and with calm to to share experiences. uh our our world's like really fast is running really fast. I think we h we want
to go with the flow but we don't need to go with the flow. We need to to breathe and have more uh time to to observe who we are, what we want and who we we live with and we educ and who we educate. So I think this is a way to to >> Yeah. And um but by listening to to both Of you sometimes as researchers we might be open to ask questions um to participants but as it is a relation participants might not feel comfortable for example right to share their life stories. So
it's not just about being open to listen but also by realizing that sometimes the person that you are asking the question to still see you the researcher in the asymmetrical relation right so um the interpersonal connection seems to be Like the necessary bridge in order to access the life stories and learn from them. Um and uh what both of you commented um professor Rossi she also mentioned fabric and saw it's very hard to bring these concepts to a study within our academ academia that is so conservative and traditional right so um I think we all
agree here on the event and on this round table because we connect through this idea of a more humane approach to research arch but we Know that academia is so larger than our small group right so >> but I think it's also about um finding a way to play the game that you have to play to be able to live in whatever society you find yourself we all have to you know keep our jobs and keep our careers going so there's no denying that that we have to do this right it's a role that we
have to play Um but at the same time I I can only speak from my own experience. Obviously, everyone has Different uh life experiences, so it's impossible to generalize here. But I guess in our own spaces we can find ways to translate you know uh for example you know I'm I'm very happy to say for example that um the the the paper that I wrote in 2022 about life capital was purely theoretical you know and over the last three four years there's been so many applications of that to empirical practical scenarios. So You know um
we can't always uh well I don't think we any of us can really um solve the real world problems of the world but with a little small contribution we can make a small change which you know with the help of a community or even sharing like we are doing this now very calmly as Fris just said calm calmness does help I'm sure do a better job um I think there is impact you know people talk about impact in academia But impact is not just writing a paper in a great journal or with a great publisher.
It's also having this moments of sharing right now as we are because I know that there will be more discussions and more events and more action happening. So I think with small small contributions even within the constraints of academia there is plenty of space for impact real impact to the social world. Yeah. >> Yeah. Okay. Thanks for your question, Juliana. I we have a lot of things to to to to to I have a lot of things to say about your question because there are many elements that should be considered. Uh I do agree with
Saul. Sometimes we think big and sometimes we have to think in our community people who are around us not like for the world like and I think these actions they start locally to go further and I also think that we Have some problems here in Brazil the ethics committees like they think they they have a position that's different for humanity sometimes. So this is something that we put on the table to discuss about how do ethics committees like uh in different institutions see things sometimes >> uh I would like to go back to what you
said Alex uh about as well about that stories that we we ourselves don't want to say some stories of our lives so this Is we have the moment to say them so this is also like something we have to to think about with ethics all the time. But as I think you mentioned this, we have to be on the trail and out of the trail as Valky War says a lot like we have to keep on the track and out of the track sometimes when it's possible. But what what I've been thinking and saying that
we miss power without being a collective. M >> some actions are really like individual or from certain groups and we don't get together. We don't hold our hands all together in a bigger movement. I think this is one way to be uh to to to break with some paradigms or some research tradition. Mhm. >> Oh, and also uh I would like to add that we uh we there is an author I don't remember the name now but he says about the unforgotten uh the the purpose um I mean sorry I wrote here intentional Forgetfulness of
some stories. So that's why I mean like sometimes we need more time to bring these stories to to say this to tell these stories and it all depends on the circumstances. >> Yeah. And I think this idea of collectiveness um helps us a lot because professor Valeria she wrote this um to both professors in our academic and institutional realities. Not every single story gets to be told. Some Voices are amplified while others are marginalized or erased by structural inequalities. And then she continues, "So the question I'd like to pose is how can we as researchers
and educators deal with the social, political, and institutional inequalities that define those stories that are heard sorry uh that define whose stories are heard and whose are silenced. A very simple question, right? Thank you, Valeria. I think we need more than just uh a cup of coffee to develop that the answer to that question. In fact, I don't ever think I don't think that even if we have more time, we can come up with an actual solution to that question. Uh because every context will be different. You know, I I'm sure that in the UK
or where I was before in China, I experienced different challenges from the ones that you might experience in Brazil or other places. Um I still think that um whilst Respecting that concept well however people want to relate to that concept of um you know dignity as I put it in the beginning of my talk. I think whilst remaining as faithful as possible to that as individuals, I repeat, we play the game to stay in our role to stay within the professional communities that we are part of keeping that dignity as intact as possible. And then
we find ways to get the voices that we think are less Heard, you know, to take some um stage space. Um and I do think I don't want to do any promotion work here, but for example, the one project that you and I, Alex, have been working on, I think is an example that comes to mind. Um, we took the opportunity of some funding from a national body in the UK to turn that narrative into something small which I think meant something to some small community in a certain area Of Brazil. And it wasn't anything
big. It was a matter of arranging some face-toface exchanges, some activities based on some ideas. But in a way, people's lives changed for a few days, for a few hours for the better. I experienced some my own changes in in that. And it's something small but I think again small contributions can make impactful differences and change. And in That way people who as you know better than me might have never had the opportunity to even leave the confines of a specific region in the country. have the opportunity to open up to realities and ideas that
might have been alien or far away from them physically and ideologically. And therefore I think that in a way their voices were heard. They might not be published in a research paper. They might not be um on a podcast somewhere, but they have been Heard and they have they I think they took pride in being heard, even if my Portuguese is very rusty, >> as well as it is my English. So, >> your English is far better than my Portuguese. I can assure you. Sorry. Carry on. would you like to to comment? >> I think
uh Valera I think the the scenario has been changing slowly. It changed a little bit in the last 20 years. I think Here in Brazil uh I do agree that we need to amplify more voices and I would like to I I I would suggest to start with Hansier the master in the ginarand. I would suggest people to read this before. Uh so I think it's a good start to a good way to start this discussion about amplifying other voices and also reread Freddy's uh masterpiece in order and and ask that question. Why do we
do research? I'm going to ask your question with Another question. Why we do research? So uh we have this awareness that we do research not only for ourselves. That's that's for the whole thing. Uh I think we could like um reduce more a little bit more the inequalities and bring amplify voice voices which which don't have the opportunity to be heard all the time. >> Yeah, thank you. Um I I want to move a little bit our discussion now from research to classroom um experiences Because professor Danielle Fhas he asks how can educators really listen
to the many life stories of his or her or their students and to quote Shimamanda's 15 million views um the YouTube how can we avoid the danger of a single story. And just to add a little bit on Daniel's question, how comfortable do you think we as educators, we are to share our own stories in the classroom with these students? Because if we are going to ask Them about their life stories, are we comfortable enough to share ours? >> That's a fair point. I mean as I said for example already in my early um musings
about life capital all of this has to be done with respect you know um not everyone wants to share their life story um nor would it be appropriate or relevant anyway so I think it's about understanding the boundaries of that um but for me more importantly as I said earlier the awareness that everyone has A story so before we jump to interpretive conclusions just to make some research questions or findings sound more appealing. I think we need to remain mindful of that. Um I forgot the first part of the question. Uh oh yes, how can
we single out one story as opposed to others? I think I liked very much what Fabricio said towards the end of his talk actually that sometimes the story or the stories come up or come forward because they Might we as researchers fall into the trap of crafting something that sounds wow and therefore is going to be good, you know, and and I guess that sometimes we might do that unintentionally. you know, we we might have very good intentions at heart and then what happens is that we cherrypick the things that um would, you know, we
we suspect would look sound very, you know, juicy and attractive to an audience of some kind. So, I guess I like for Bruce's um Reminder to be uh even more aware of that uh because I think we do that even when we don't want to. And from my perspective, one thing that can help not stop that from happening because because I think it's part of a human nature, but one practice that can help mitigate the impact of doing that is being reflexive, is doing reflexivity, is being aware of who we are as individuals and remaining
asking um ourselves Questions about what we're doing and why we're doing it at each stage. stage of the process and and thinking about how what we're doing is impacting ourselves ourselves and other people and the work that we wish to achieve. I really do think that reflexivity can mitigate not resolve these issues. That's my view at the minute. >> That's a very hard question from Danielle. But I I I am privileged educator. I work with a few students. Uh I mean his question was specifically for these students, wasn't it, Alex? >> Yeah. As educators. Yes.
>> Uh yeah, I'm I'm really privileged with my because I have just a few students every semester. I mean few students 70 or 50, but I I have the opportunity to to be with them for more than one year. So I can listen as more as I I can like of life stories if they want to tell me. So that's that's one point. Uh so but when we think about uh PE uh teachers Who work in basic education they they don't have time. They have 600 students like so it's not possible. What we what would
we I think I would recall what I said before like we have to be available to the unknown. We have to be sensitive but we are not God if God exists but we have to to develop our what we can do our uh we have to to to to our role as educators but we are not we don't we are not octopuses or things like that. So we don't have to to to Charge ourselves that much as well. But we have to be aware that there are more stories on more things that we need to
know but not to be like oh we have to know everything. >> Yeah. And um Saul mentioned this project that we worked together and I think you will recall Saul that one of the activities we did with um pre-ervice language teachers and I'm going to mention this example because after the activity I realized That sometimes we as educators we ask for things that if students deliver were we ready for what they delivered. Yes, >> one of the activities of the project, we asked preserves language teachers just to bring one object that represents their stories and
to share the story. >> And I thought they would bring like a book or a family photograph, something like This, like some superficial stories, let's say. But that meeting was the most emotional one. All of them cried because all of them felt comfortable enough to share really um individual and impactful stories like from happy moments to very sad ones. Um and at the very end of the meeting everyone was involved but as Fabricio mentioned I knew those students for two Years already so they felt comfortable enough to share those life stories right so it's not
just in the first day of class that you will ask your students and then they will open their hearts for us as educators so it it it requires a lot of um interpersonal connectedness before that um we have one more comment from professor Barbara Sabot. She says, "Dear professors, thanks for the presentations Today. We have been using autoethnography in our group and it was a valuable addition to what we already knew. To what extent would you agree life capital register in research uh work as a transgression act as a means to create cracks ruptures to
the hegemonic structures that regulate society? >> Um so I have to say I missed the first part of that question. Something happened to the connection. I'm so Sorry. I only I only got the very last part. Maybe that's the most important. >> Oh sure. The question was to what extent would you agree life stories registered in research work as a is a as transgression act as a means to create fractures ruptures to the hegemonic structures that regulate society. >> Oh okay. Okay. Um well I confess that when I personally um started becoming involved with you
know quite passionate about the idea of advancing Life stories in research. I wasn't thinking necessarily about this, you know. I was thinking more about let's be a little bit more mindful and aware of what we are observing and why. You know, kind of getting more into the why of what we see rather than just concluding certain explanations or um theories of reality. Um, so I was more concerned with understanding the fact that reality is so complex that um, we need to do a little more than just observing and Coming up with some variables and theories.
But I do think that there is plenty of potential for disrupting um, macro structures that don't work or serve the people that we work with or the people who are agents of our work. I think there is plenty of potential for that. Again, like this has been said several times already today, we we are not divinities. We are not necessarily powerful in those macro Structures. There's only so much we can do. But I think rather than being frustrated with the fact that we can't really change the macro structures, I think we want to look at
the very small um contributions or small acts of life that we can experience or gift to others. that might be very very small and look so tiny compared to a whole country but they will mean something to someone like the story just mentioned from our Project. Um I think that's enough. you know there's I didn't I I personally didn't think that we can expend or rather I I didn't see the point in expending more energy being frustrated and and then obviously ending up disappointed because we cannot change what we can't change because we don't have
that power but instead turning that energy into ways that can mean something even if it's small scale that's that's the way I See Uh thank you Barbara for your question and I would say that your the question is what happens before or beyond the register. I think the transgression and cracking ruptures start before the register of of it of them. They are on our intentions and our uh awareness of the world. I mean uh that's why I I I repeat uh we have not to be complicent or we just not uh or Just do something
just to fulfill an academic requirement on no liberal trends. What are our intentions before it? I think this is transgression. I mean in terms of um research when we think that the future cannot be so damaged as it's going to be and we can uh historically understand the potential of other his story histories I mean stories of other stories. I think we have this I think these questions come before the Register. For me, this is the the real transgression. The the register is just a consequence. >> Yeah. And um just to to comment a little
bit on that on what you mentioned Fabricio, some of my students when I invite them to write autoethnographies or even ethnographies, some of them immediately ask, "But who will be on my viva? Can I actually do that and be approved?" So it's not it's not a matter of do they want to write or to create those cracks but I would say they're they are just afraid of being accepted in academia once they do that right so people do have potential it's just a matter of them realizing the space in which um they're supposed to to
survive right and to live Um, so I just want to to finish this moment of ours with Professor Juliana Bros's comment that she left for us. Um, she Says, "In my opinion, putting the heart into the research, um, being reflexive and recognizing we don't know everything and won't understand everything may bring us closer to other stories. Um, I must confess that I have been thinking a lot about giving up being a researcher. I am less inclined to it after hearing you tonight. So, we both of you were just mentioning that we might impact life stories
and we don't know it. So, Just left you a testimony. I think I think we need to hurry that coffee that I mentioned earlier with Juliana just to make sure that no nothing disastrous happens after tonight. Um so let's um arrange that. Um I I I I'd just like to say um not just once again thank you for inviting me to be part of this but it's been most exciting for me to actually um listen to in this case Fabricio but also hearing other people's ideas that are so close To home in a way. So
that's that's the most exciting thing that we didn't even know each other. we are in very far away um communities and yet I felt that we were talking about like we were using the same language and that's um very exciting. So thank you for that. Briad I can say that >> all I can say >> I would I would like to say thank you for everybody for the committee and to meet the opportunity to meet all this Afternoon this night. I mean in yeah thank you for for the opportunity to listen to you. Thank you
for all the questions uh for all the colleagues who are here watching us this afternoon. I saw a lot of comments on YouTube and thank you very much. >> Thank you once again Saul and Fabricio. Um we loved hearing from you and from your stories and again as both of you mentioned from different life perspectives. We all connected. >> So thank you so very much for joining us. Um President, Valeria, Good evening everyone. Professor methodolog. Compass exams. Campus exams. Campus exams. Ed methodolog states. Yeah. organized. Fore! Foreign! Foreign! for say no. Amen. Fore! Foreign! Foreign!
[Music] Yes. Uh we uh thank you for the Opportunity and for your support. Wow. We thank you. That's so nice being you with us. Yes. Fore! Foreign! Foreign! Fore! Foreign! Foreign! This is conferenc. for [Music] platform. Fore! Foreign! Foreign! Online. Surprise. Yes. Fore! Foreign! Foreign! St. Alex Julie Edchech. [Music] [Music] participate as live. Happy Alex. is participants. Jerida, Michelle, Chow chow. [Music] We are in love.