MOOC perinatal mental health in the first 1000 days A project by Module 1: Mental health and perinatal mental disorders Risk factors, perinatal traumatic experiences Pr Philippe Deruelle, Professor of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Ms. Anne Evrard Co-president of CIANE Hello, I am Philippe Deruelle, obstetrician-gynaecologist at Strasbourg university hospital and I will talk to you about the risk factors related to medical and/or obstetrical history, but also to perinatal traumatic experiences and their consequences on mental disorders. We know from the latest confidential national survey on maternal deaths that the suicide rate is 13% for pregnant women or women who have just given birth.
And it's all the more important that screening, detection, knowledge and treatment of these mental disorders are largely insufficient in our country. There are two objectives to this two-part course. I'll introduce the first one which is to know the risk factors for postpartum depression, and then I'll let Anne Evrard speak, who will give us a better understanding of the women's own expectations on this issue.
Six risk factors for postpartum depression are described in literature: economic risk factors, social risk factors, very important, the history of mental disorders, but also lifestyle, biological elements, such as the drop in progesterone, but also the interaction of obstetrical factors. It has been very well-demonstrated that complications during pregnancy are associated with postpartum depression, even if, to put a bit of a damper on it, the strengths of these combinations remain relatively weak. We can mention pre-eclampsia, caesarean section, gestational diabetes, premature birth, anaemia, vitamin D deficiency and postpartum anaemia.
There is a very important role of violence, whether it's physical, sexual or psychological violence. They triple the risk of postpartum depression and increase the risk of post-traumatic stress disorder. When we talk about violence, we are of course talking about intrafamilial or domestic violence, but there is also this recent notion, although it has existed for 15 years, of the role of obstetric violence.
In reality, these factors are intertwined: a woman who comes from a low socio-economic background, smokes, and has a complication during her pregnancy with pre-eclampsia, a transfer to an intensive care unit and difficulty in finding support, will obviously be more likely to suffer from depression than a woman whose pregnancy went well. There is a real limit to the risk factors. The risk is to only target women who have a risk factor, when in fact many women who will develop a mental disorder and a depression around pregnancy don't have any particular difficulties.
That's what's very difficult to identify. And apart from depression, there are also other mental disorders: post-traumatic stress disorder, fear of childbirth or of having longer-term gynaecological care, the idea of having a negative body image or a feeling of dehumanisation. Therefore, it is very important to offer systematic screening for these situations and mainly to train perinatal care workers in a broad way, in order to meet women and women's expectations.
And now Ms. Anne Evrard, co-president of the CIANE, will continue on this theme. Hello, I am Anne Evrard, co-president of the inter-associative collective around birth, the CIANE, I am representing the women's and couples' associations, and I'll continue what Professor Deruelle said, on the specific issue of obstetrical violence.
My goal is to give you a synthetic description, to tell you about the consequences and especially the issue of traumatic experiences. The violence in obstetrics and gynaecology is very rarely the subject of a very specific moment during care that would otherwise be satisfactory. It should really be taken as a disruption of the care relationship as a whole.
And the first thing that often fails is that communication and information are lacking, women complaining about a lack of contact or an unsatisfactory contact with the caregiver or caregivers who are present, either for the pregnancy follow-up, or for the management of the delivery or the postpartum period. This will result in a lack of information, a lack of seeking consent from the woman or by a lack of respect for her choices and the couple's choices. One can encounter verbal abuse, i.
e. mockery, denigration, remarks that can be infantilising, sexist, and it can go as far as intimidation or threats. In the women's stories, there are very often important points about the denial of the pain they express or a poor support or treatment of this pain with a denial of the level of pain they feel, which can go as far as instrumentations, caesarean sections without anaesthesia as a result of not dealing with the pain.
We also find in the women's stories a deficit in the support or in kindness, in the respect of intimacy, modesty and sometimes gestures that are perceived as brutal, aggressive or behaviours that are really considered disrespectful and disturbing. One should not forget that we also have inappropriate medical procedures, that is, they don't correspond to the best standards in obstetrics. Of course, the women are affected by these situations, but one should not forget that they can also affect the couple, and thus the partner, who may be suffering at the same level as his spouse from the situation in question.
The first thing that will be impacted, is the personal image that will be debased, based on a feeling of being ridiculed or mocked. As a result, a disruption in dialogue and exchange with the caregiver, a loss of trust and a feeling of loneliness and neglect. At the same time, because of this lack of contact, the woman feels that she is losing her place of interlocutor and decision-maker, and therefore understands the situation less and that she is worried or even afraid by the fact that things are happening around her, on her, for her, but without her being involved.
This lack of understanding and feeling of insecurity will often increase, to a feeling of endangerment, either of the mother or the baby. There are also near-death experiences, a feeling that one is really in major danger and that one won't be able to escape from it. It is very common to find a feeling of being assaulted, similar to sexual or physical assaults, feelings of rape, particularly about acts that have been carried out without the woman's consent.
If, following childbirth, the woman tries to explain her experience, to express what she has been through, it is very important that the staff does not try to normalise what has happened, because this aggravates the trauma and it is really experienced as a double punishment, with a great deal of additional violence. The situation has an impact on the overall health of the woman and, of course, on her mental health, but also on her physical experience. That is, the primary disturbance, is post-traumatic stress, and this post-traumatic stress will have an impact on the daily psychological and mental experience, which will affect the physical experience.
These are often women who express feelings of diffuse pain, of intense perineal pain, even when there's no perineal injury, with a tear, an episiotomy. And, of course, there are all the known manifestations of post-traumatic stress, namely: reminiscences, loss of sleep, nightmares, the feeling of reliving the same events over and over again, accompanied by major anxieties. The degraded personal image often creates a difficulty in the relationship with loved ones, especially in the relationship with the child.
And a great loss of trust in caregivers in general, not only those in the gynaecological and obstetrical sphere, but women can lose trust in their general practitioner, specialists that they may have been following up until then, or even dentists, for example, and abandon personal medical care and, sometimes, go off on a medical hiatus. On the other hand, it is rare for the child's follow-up to be impacted, but it can happen. In addition to this, there may be depression, the impossibility of returning to work with necessary long-term sick leave, sometimes a deterioration of the condition when returning to work, when the woman realises that she is obsessed with the aftermath of the events and that this results in both physical and mental exhaustion, making it difficult for her to carry out her daily activities, both at work and at home.
Sexuality is always affected, often severely. Marital crisis is almost always present, especially if the spouse also experiences the same consequences of these situations. In terms of treatment, it is often long and complex.
If EMDR and hypnosis therapies are advocated, the cost of these therapies, which is not always covered by the government, is a limitation to care. They may need to be combined with talking therapies, more traditional psychotherapies and be accompanied by physical care as well, because of this feeling of physical exhaustion and diffuse pain. As a result of all this, many women don't seek treatment or don't even dare to start it, for fear of not being able to continue it.
I thought it was important to read out to you some quotes from these women expressing their distress, so that you have in mind the level at which this is happening. The first one says: "I feel that I am good-for-nothing, that I have been considered as something other than a person, that I have been betrayed in the trust I had given. " Another lady says: "I have a bad self-image.
Feeling bad about being assaulted in my privacy for no medical reason, and that a moment of vulnerability was taken advantage of. " Or: "I feel guilty that I didn't resist, that I didn't know how to react, that this is how my baby was born, I blame my husband for not defending me. " Or this woman who says: "I am in extreme distress.
I have to suppress my thoughts about the birth and the stay in the hospital to try to see the baby for what he is. I have to imagine that I have adopted him, that he is not really mine to look after him properly. I feel that I have brought all the abuse from the hospital home with me, when I brought him home, because he is the proof of what happened.
" Lastly: "I don't feel I have any legitimacy over this baby, I don't feel I'm his mother, I don't feel concerned by decisions relating to him, I look after him well but only in a technical way. I doubt his identity because I could not see him when he was born or when he passed in front of me wrapped in a blanket. I have nightmares, I think my baby might have died, that this one is not my baby.
If someone picks him up, I leave the room, because it confirms to me that I can't do anything for him. " I would like to briefly mention the specificity of women or couples who were previously victims of violence. Of course, these women and couples are not more predetermined by a specific personality to experience violence or traumas than others.
Previous traumas, however, are easily triggered by situations of violence in care and aggravate the overall experience and health of the people concerned. This is true both for the woman and for her spouse, if he has previously been a victim of violence himself. Given the frequency with which people are victims of violence, and the difficulty of a systematic detection - it is still not widespread and, sometimes, emergency situations do not allow the issue of previous experiences of violence to be addressed -, caregivers should keep this risk in mind for all their patients and adopt an appropriate behaviour, which will be beneficial to all of them anyway Lastly, I think it is important to insist on one point for the prevention of these situations.
It is only through an alliance between the caregiver and the woman - with respect for her voice, respect for what she expresses, for her experience and her wishes - that these situations of violence in care can be effectively prevented, by having a better understanding of the needs of women and couples, in order to make an alliance with these couples to ensure their overall safety. This includes pregnancy, childbirth and postnatal care as well. Professor Deruelle and I would like to thank you for your attention and hope that this presentation has been of interest to you.