the Final Fantasy 13 Trilogy is either one of the most beloved or most hated trilogies in all of RPGs depending on who you ask of course and usually there's nothing in between personally I love the trilogy and I think it's one of the best RPG trilogies of all time but one of the main questions proposed when you look at the trilogy is which one in the trilogy is the best and also which one's the worst so let's find out the worst of the trilogy for me Lightning Returns is the worst in the trilogy by far
but I think it's still a good game so let me explain Lightning Returns is the last game in the Trilogy and it completely switches up the formula for better and for worse but why does it switch everything up there was already a very well established battle system in the prior two games that the first game introduced and the second game interated on and improved upon the third title could have been a further development of this formula but here the game play the world the motivating force and the story is so far removed from the prior
two titles that it really doesn't even feel like it's a part of the Final Fantasy 13 Trilogy only by the characters does this game really properly tied back to the prior two titles and again why the combat is definitely good in Lightning Return and it makes it more interactive compared to the prior titles but the combat system of Final Fantasy 13 and 132 were so good that I think a third iteration on this formula would have been magnificent to see and personally that's where I wanted Lightning Returns to go the world of Lightning Returns is
also very different and almost borders on the realm of unbelievability not saying that the prior two games were particularly grounded by any means but there was at least consistency between them Final Fantasy 13 was definitely the most grounded experience of the trilogy and Final Fantasy 13 2 gets pretty wild with its World lore in terms of the other Realms of existence the time traveling and the magical powers but if you stretch the realm of disbelief Final Fantasy 13 2's world does actually fit quite nicely into the Final Fantasy 13 universe and it leaves a pretty
great Cliffhanger for the third injury to pick up from but Lightning Returns really doesn't do that it is so far removed from the world in the lore of the prior two games that even a professional gymnast couldn't stretch the realm of disbelief in order enough to be engrossed with the story and believe that it does actually truly fit with the Final Fantasy 13 Universe frictionlessly I mean you literally fight god with the power that God gave to lightning you kill him you create a new realm of existence and you travel through space and time and
create Earth and then you live happily Forever After on Earth with all the dead loved ones that now come back to life in this new realm Distortion or creation or whatever it is this of course isn't exactly what happens but I mean it's pretty close but it is pretty epic in a fun ride so I mean you have that and finally let's talk about the clock you're either a player that really likes limiting time systems where the game has you complete certain objectives in a certain amount of time or otherwise the game's over or you
lose something significant or something to that extent or you really don't like this mechanic I really don't like this mechanic especially with this game primarily because the game encourages you to explore and complete side quest in order to level up but you have to do all of this quickly so you don't run out of time and restart your playthrough so the time restraint discourages exploration due to how much time exploration naturally just consumes but it's also encouraged because these quests are the only thing that level up lightning and speaking of the leveling system I don't
particularly like that either because defeating enemies doesn't level up lightning only completing Quest does you do get significant drops from Battle which somewhat incentivizes battle but for the leveling you could just skip right past enemies so naturally what I did when I was playing the game I essentially thoroughly planned out my path by looking up guides and finding the most efficient routes in order to execute the quote unquote best playthrough which definitely didn't go flawlessly at all and I have to admit that planing is somewhat neat in itself and kind of fun but I did
feel very limited when I was playing the game and I was extremely careful of how I tackled things and the pressure of the clock kind of made it not as fun as it should have been in my opinion also I didn't know that this game is somewhat intended for you to play through it multiple times in order to beat it and that's because there's nothing in particular that lets you know that if you don't complete it the first time you can carry your progress to the playr and this is definitely important information because the final
section is very difficult and the postgame content is even harder so if you take the approach of well if I don't beat it this time I'll just beat it next time around the experience may be better but to play through this 20 to 30 hour game again to beat the final section is pretty dramatic however most things in this game are pretty good and I definitely do like it but to me everything is subpar when you compare it to the prior two games and that's why it's the worst in the trilogy for me and overall
I'd give it a C+ the middle child I'm ranking the trilogy based Bas off a bit of bias of course but I also want to use a bit of objectivity and for me objectively Final Fantasy 13 is worse than Final Fantasy 132 Final Fantasy 13 is still a really really good game but it has a lot of issues holding it back first and foremost is the pacing it takes way too long for this game's pacing to pick up it takes about 20 hours for the game to really kind of start making traction and that's that's
just too much it's still fun in these 20 hours because the story is still intriguing and the characters are very interesting and the world's gorgeous to journey through as well the battle system is very Bare Bones in the beginning it's kind of a sloth until you hit about the 10- hour mark again the characters story and lore and the world as a whole are all very interesting which makes it much easier to push through but even these aspects pick up significantly when you get towards the latter half of the game and once it does I
think it's great once it begins to pick up you start to realize that the world and the characters that are built within this universe are arguably some of the most interesting characters in the world is also one of the most interesting worlds in a Final Fantasy game ever and really RPGs as a whole and there's just so much to Bo when the battle System picks up you realize that the system is really something more than what it initially seems to be and unfortunately something that we don't really get nowadays it's much more active than it
initially lets on and actually requires a lot of planning and organizing team building and then strategizing especially as you face later battles that are really tough and of course Paradigm shifting becomes the name of the game and you really have to be on top of it in the later battles just to make it through super fun and unique battle system that I wish we had more of another problem with this game is of course the linearity along with emptiness the game's pretty much completely linear with the exception of one major section which is of course
chapter 11 and there's a lot of really cool activities and side quest to do especially for end game but again chapter 11 is the 11th chapter out of 13 chapters in total so it takes quite a while just to get there and as far as linearity goes I don't necessarily think it's the linearity that's the big issue but it's the linearity mixed with the emptiness there's a lot of games that are completely linear that are absolutely great but their worlds are teaming with things to do NPCs to interact with and just interesting as a whole
this game's world is definitely interesting but it's extremely empty most of the time you essentially go from one long quor with enemies in it to another long Corridor with more enemies in it and it absolutely gets repetitive and can get a little bit boring but again the the world is gorgeous it's very interesting so for me the linearity is not bad but the emptiness the lack of towns and the pacing as a whole all combined with the linearity does kind of make it more of a negative aspect for this game however triple again the world
is very stunning and it's extremely interesting journey through and the music as you really do everything in this game is without a doubt one of the most upper echelon soundtracks of all time and even early on the story is at least intriguing and it evolves to be super interesting later on so although the pacing is terrible and the world for the most part is empty it is still a joy to journey through and once the pacing picks up and game's absolutely blast and totally worth it also real quick some things to mention the main antagonist
is pretty weak the idolan which are the summons critically underutilized and underpowered for the most part with the exception of specific situations and in-game sections the upgrading system for the weapons and accessories is super complicated and poorly explain the lore in the story can be a bit confusing as well and snow as a main character kind of sex but the rest of the characters are really great even iconic and the game as a whole is pretty brilliant I'd objectively give Final Fantasy 13 a B+ the best Final Fantasy 132 is almost a direct answer to
all the criticism of Final Fantasy 13 and fixes nearly all the issues that Final Fantasy 13 had the pacing in Final Fantasy 13 2 is great it has open level design there's plenty of towns and NPCs to interact with the story is more understandable still a little bit complicated but more understandable than the Priti the main villain's great the upgrading system is much more simplified for better and for worse and the battle system is in full swing from the beginning the way that the battle system started off in Final Fantasy 132 is the way that
it really should have started off in Final Fantasy 13 objectively almost everything is better in this game but some things are a bit different as well the main thing about Final Fantasy 132 differentiates it from Final Fantasy 13 is of course a third party member which is actually a monster that you capture again I think this game as a whole requires you to stretch the realm of disbelief in the sense of the story and the lore but I also think that this monster capturing mechanic really doesn't fit well into the pre-established Final Fantasy 13 Universe
thematically at least that being said this monster capturing and battling with the monsters is really cool and they did it super well this game so I'm glad that they had it and in fact I think lowkey this might be one of the best if not the best monster capturing battling game that there is but this mechanic is not the only thing that differentiates Final Fantasy 13 2 from Final Fantasy 13 honestly the most notable thing about Final Fantasy 132 as a sequel to Final Fantasy 13 is of course the main character of Final Fantasy 13
Lightning is not the main character of Final Fantasy 13 to and really she's not even in the game for the most part and all other main characters from Final Fantasy 13 are not really in the game either in the sense of them being in your party this is a pretty bold choice and even to this day lightning is one of the most recognized characters in in all of Final Fantasy history and RPG history as well to not have lightning in the follow-up game to where she was the main character was very risky but I think
it paid off very well Sarah and N are phenomenal main characters and they play off each other very very well and limiting the main protagonist number down from 6 to 2 allows for a more intimate story to be told which is refreshing and really the right direction to take this game especially if you playing a pivot away from lightning being the main character and have her be the McGuffin of the story Sarah is also an absolutely excellent representation of femininity which again is very refreshing in the stra overall this was really a great experience through
and through and it's honestly one of the best games that I think I've ever played there is one section that is kind of super annoying in this game that's where you have to go back to different levels and find specific items that are very obscure and as a whole it's pretty tedious but otherwise I think it's a wonderful game I'd objectively give Final Fantasy 13 to a solid a subjectively so there's a reason why I kept referring to certain scores or things that I liked or disliked as being objective I think it's important to look
at games with an objective point of view and be able to assess if something in a game is objectively bad or simply underperforms of course there's no such thing as objectivity when given a ranking or review score any type of game but you can most certainly try to limit your own bias and objectively I think this is my ranking of the Final Fantasy 13 Trilogy with lightning returns Final Fantasy 13 being in last place Final Fantasy 13 being in the middle Final Fantasy 13 to being the best but let's make this fun and throw some
bias in here subjectively I would still keep Lightning Returns in last place and I'd still keep it at of C+ however I would move Final Fantasy 132 to second place with an A minus and move Final Fantasy 13 to first place with a solid a let me explain in almost all aspects Final Fantasy 132 is a better game than Final Fantasy 13 but when I play a Final Fantasy game I want that Final Fantasy feeling I want an epic 40 hour plus jrpg story with great combat multiple party members huge character development a super interesting
World lore and universe bigger than life enemies and stakes and a complete story in an all-in-one package Final Fantasy 132 did have a great story it did have bigger than life Stakes it also did have really good character development but there's just something about it where you can tell it's just not like a main title Final Fantasy game and to be fair it's really not trying to be and it's still an absolutely wonderful game but I think I love the mainline titles more than anything else that they could produce unless of course they were really
bad but I don't think any are to this state I haven't played Final Fantasy 2 so don't don't hold me to that the world in the lore Final Fantasy 13 is so much more interesting than anything else that came after it that I really just want more of this original World Final Fantasy 13 2 Strays away from Final Fantasy 13's a world and lore and kind of has its own world and lore that plays off of some of the things that Final Fantasy 13 had very lightly and Lightning Returns does the same thing again to
Final Fantasy 13 2's World lore so now with Lightning Returns you have two layers of separation from the original Final Fantasy 13 World lore so when you go through the trilogy you end up so far removed from the original World and setting that it almost feels like these aren't Final Fantasy games anymore Final Fantasy 13 is absolutely a traditional Final Fantasy game and honestly it may be one of the last and again for Final Fantasy games I want that traditional Final Fantasy experience not necessarily the combat style but the experience overall and out of the
trilogy Final Fantasy 13 is the only game that truly gives you that experience once the pising got on track and the story developed and I did some digging through the data logs I became fully engrossed with it and I was extremely excited to keep going the battle system at this point had also become one of the best turn-based battle system that I ever experienced it was extremely unique the story quickly became one of my favorites I loved how wrapped up in the end to me the ending was perfect and it certainly wasn't designed to have
a sequel and again a point to go against Final Fantasy 132 was how Final Fantasy 132 handled the reconning of the original Final Fantasy 13 ending which I significantly disliked also Final Fantasy 13's OST is my favorite soundtrack of all time really and not to say that Final Fantasy 13 2 soundtrack is not good because it very much is but to me Final Fantasy 13 is damn near perfect also I found a lot of the places that you went to in Final Fantasy 13 to be significantly more interesting than really any other place throughout the
trilogy so all these things put together just for me makes the original Final Fantasy 13 experience more important Final Fantasy 132 is definitely a better game in respect to the pacing combat system and the level design which are all extremely important aspects of a game but Final Fantasy 13 is that more traditional Final Fantasy experience with a bigger story more interesting world and lore and a diverse range of main characters all of which really Define what a Mainline Final Fantasy title is and with the latter one-third of the game after the pacing hits an appropriate
Tempo I think that Final Fantasy 13 becomes a superior experience and that's why it's my personal favorite of the trilogy if you like the video hit the like button hit the Subscribe button and hit the Bell notification that way you don't miss out on any future videos and leave a comment and tell me what you thought about the video or what you would like to see me do next also if you want a more detailed version of what I think about each of these games in the Final Fantasy 13 Trilogy check out my other videos
on my Channel or click the links in the description again thank you all for the support I appreciate each and every one of you I love seeing what you think about the video or your opinions on the game/ games now in the comments also if you want to help support the channel further consider becoming a member and get some extra loyalty badges emojis for comments and a shout out in my next video it's your support that keeps this channel alive and if you don't have the means or the desire to further support the channel that's
totally fine I truly just appreciate the fact that you watched the video up until this point I hope that you found it to be worth your time but until the next video I wish you all the very best and again I hope you enjoyed [Music] bye-bye